WITH FOLDED HANDS
                                         by Jack Williamson

   Underhill was walking home from the office, because his wife had the car, the afternoon he
met the new mechanicals. His feet were following his usual diago-nal path across a weedy va
block—his wife usually had the car—and his preoccupied mind was rejecting various imposs
ways to meet his notes at the Two Rivers bank, when a new wall stopped him.
   The wall wasn't any common brick or stone, but some-thing sleek and bright and stra
Underhill stared up at a long new building. He felt vaguely annoyed and sur-prised at this glitte
obstruction—it certainly hadn't been here last week.
   Then he saw the thing in the window.
   The window itself wasn't any ordinary glass. The wide, dustless panel was comple
transparent, so that only the glowing letters fastened to it showed that it was there at all. The le
made a severe, modernistic sign:

                                         Two Rivers Agency
                                     HUMANOID INSTITUTE
                                      The Perfect Mechanicals
                                       "To Serve and Obey,
                                    And Guard Men from Harm."

   His dim annoyance sharpened, because Underhill was in the mechanicals business himself. Ti
were already hard enough, and mechanicals were a drug on the market. Androids, mechano
electronoids, automatoids, and or-dinary robots. Unfortunately, few of them did all the sales
promised, and the Two Rivers market was already sadly oversaturated.
   Underhill sold androids—when he could. His next con-signment was due tomorrow, and he d
quite know how to meet the bill.
   Frowning, he paused to stare at the thing behind that invisible window. He had never see
humanoid. Like any mechanical not at work, it stood absolutely motionless. Smaller and slim
than a man. A shining black, its sleek silicone skin had a changing sheen of bronze and metallic b
Its graceful oval face wore a fixed look of alert and slightly surprised solicitude. Altogether, it
the most beautiful mechanical he had ever seen.
   Too small, of course, for much practical utility. He murmured to himself a reassuring quota
from the Android Salesman: "Androids are big—because the makers refuse to sacrifice po
essential functions, or dependability. Androids are your biggest buy!"
   The transparent door slid open as he turned toward it, and he walked into the haughty opulenc
the new display room to convince himself that these streamlined items were just another flashy e
to catch the woman shopper.
   He inspected the glittering layout shrewdly, and his breezy optimism faded. He had never hear
the Hu-manoid Institute, but the invading firm obviously had big money and big-time merchandi
know-how.
   He looked around for a salesman, but it was another mechanical that came gliding silently to m
him. A twin of the one in the window, it moved with a quick, surpris-ing grace. Bronze and
lights flowed over its lustrous blackness, and a yellow name plate flashed from its naked breast:
                                            HUMANOID
                                       Serial No. 81-H-B-27
                                      The Perfect Mechanical
                                       "To Serve and Obey,
                                    And Guard Men from Harm."

    Curiously, it had no lenses. The eyes in its bald oval head were steel-colored, blindly staring.
it stopped a few feet in front of him, as if it could see anyhow, and it spoke to him with a h
melodious voice:
    "At your service, Mr. Underhill."
    The use of his name startled him, for not even the androids could tell one man from another.
this was a clever merchandising stunt, of course, not too difficult in a town the size of Two Riv
The salesman must be some local man, prompting the mechanical from behind the parti
Underhill erased his momentary astonishment, and said loudly.
    "May I see your salesman, please?"
    "We employ no human salesmen, sir," its soft silvery voice replied instantly. "The Huma
Institute exists to serve mankind, and we require no human service. We ourselves can supply
information you desire, sir, and accept your order for immediate humanoid service."
    Underhill peered at it dazedly. No mechanicals were competent even to recharge their
batteries and reset their own relays, much less to operate their own branch office. The blind
stared blankly back, and he looked uneasily around for any booth or curtain that might con-cea
salesman.
    Meanwhile, the sweet thin voice resumed persuasively.
    "May we come out to your home for a free trial demonstration, sir? We are anxious to introd
our ser-vice on your planet, because we have been successful in eliminating human unhappines
so many others. You will find us far superior to the old electronic mechanicals in use here."
    Underhill stepped back uneasily. He reluctantly aban-doned his search for the hidden salesm
shaken by the idea of any mechanicals promoting themselves. That would upset the whole indust
    "At least you must take some advertising matter, sir."
    Moving with a somehow appalling graceful deftness, the small black mechanical brought him
illustrated booklet from a table by the wall. To cover his confused and increasing alarm, he thum
through the glossy pages.
    In a series of richly colored before-and-after pictures, a chesty blond girl was stooping ov
kitchen stove, and then relaxing in a daring negligee while a little black mechanical knelt to serve
something. She was wearily hammering a typewriter, and then lying on an ocean beach, in a revea
sun suit, while another mechanical did the typing. She was toiling at some huge industrial mach
and then dancing in the arms of a golden-haired youth, while a black humanoid ran the machine.
    Underhill sighed wistfully. The android company didn't supply such fetching sales mate
Women would find this booklet irresistible, and they selected eighty-six per cent of all mechan
sold. Yes, the competition was going to be bitter.
    "Take it home, sir," the sweet voice urged him. "Show it to your wife. There is a free
demonstration order blank on the last page, and you will notice that we require no payment down
    He turned numbly, and the door slid open for him. Retreating dazedly, he discovered the boo
still in his hand. He crumpled it furiously, and flung it down. The small black thing picked it up ti
and the insistent silver voice rang after him:
    "We shall call at your office tomorrow, Mr. Underhill, and send a demonstration unit to
home. It is time to discuss the liquidation of your business, because the elec-tronic mechanicals
have been selling cannot compete with us. And we shall offer your wife a free trial demon-stratio
   Underhill didn't attempt to reply, because he couldn't trust his voice. He stalked blindly down
new sidewalk to the corner, and paused there to collect himself. Out of his startled and confu
impressions, one clear fact emerged—things looked black for the agency.
   Bleakly, he stared back at the haughty splendor of the new building. It wasn't honest bric
stone; that invisible window wasn't glass; and he was quite sure the foundation for it hadn't e
been staked out, the last time Aurora had the car.
   He walked on around the block, and the new sidewalk took him near the rear entrance. A t
was backed up to it, and several slim black mechanicals were silently busy, unloading huge m
crates.
   He paused to look at one of the crates. It was labeled for interstellar shipment. The sten
showed that it had come from the Humanoid Institute, on Wing IV. He failed to recall any plane
that designation; the outfit must be big.
   Dimly, inside the gloom of the warehouse beyond the truck, he could see black mechan
opening the crates. A lid came up, revealing dark, rigid bodies, closely packed. One by one,
came to life. They climbed out of the crate, and sprang gracefully to the floor. A shining bl
glinting with bronze and blue, they were all identi-cal.
   One of them came out past the truck, to the sidewalk, staring with blind steel eyes. Its high s
voice spoke to him melodiously:
   "At your service, Mr. Underhill."
   He fled. When his name was promptly called by a courteous mechanical, just out of the cra
which it had been imported from a remote and unknown planet, he found the experience trying.
   Two blocks along, the sign of a bar caught his eye, and he took his dismay inside. He had ma
a business rule not to drink before dinner, and Aurora didn't like him to drink at all; but these
mechanicals, he felt, had made the day exceptional.
   Unfortunately, however, alcohol failed to brighten the brief visible future of the agency. Whe
emerged, after an hour, he looked wistfully back in hope that the bright new building might h
vanished as abruptly as it came. It hadn't. He shook his head dejectedly, and turned uncer-ta
homeward.
   Fresh air had cleared his head somewhat, before he arrived at the neat white bungalow in
outskirts of the town, but it failed to solve his business problems. He also realized, uneasily, tha
would be late for dinner.
   Dinner, however, had been delayed. His son Frank, a freckled ten-year-old, was still kickin
football on the quiet street in front of the house. And little Gay, who was tow-haired and ador
and eleven, came running across the lawn and down the sidewalk to meet him.
   "Father, you can't guess what!" Gay was going to be a great musician some day, and no do
properly dignified, but she was pink and breathless with excitement now. She let him swing her
off the sidewalk, and she wasn't critical of the bar aroma on his breath. He couldn't guess, and
informed him eagerly;
   "Mother's got a new lodger!"

  Underhill had foreseen a painful inquisition, because Aurora was worried about the notes at
bank, and the bill for the new consignment, and the money for little Gay's lessons.
  The new lodger, however, saved him from that. With an alarming crashing of crockery,
household android was setting dinner on the table, but the little house was empty. He found Au
in the back yard, burdened with sheets and towels for the guest.
    Aurora, when he married her, had been as utterly adorable as now her little daughter was.
might have remained so, he felt, if the agency had been a little more successful. However, while
pressure of slow failure had gradually crumbled his own assurance, small hardships had turned h
little too aggressive.
    Of course he loved her still. Her red hair was still alluring, and she was loyally faithful,
thwarted ambi-tions had sharpened her character and sometimes her voice. They never quarre
really, but there were small differences.
    There was the little apartment over the garage—built for human servants they had never been
to afford. It was too small and shabby to attract any responsible tenant, and Underhill wante
leave it empty. It hurt his pride to see her making beds and cleaning floors for strangers.
    Aurora had rented it before, however, when she wanted money to pay for Gay's music less
or when some colorful unfortunate touched her sympathy, and it seemed to Underhill that
lodgers had all turned out to be thieves and vandals.
    She turned back to meet him, now, with the clean linen in her arms.
    "Dear, it's no use objecting." Her voice was quite determined. "Mr. Sledge is the most wonde
old fellow, and he 's going to stay just as long as he wants."
    "That's all right, darling." He never liked to bicker, and he was thinking of his troubles at
agency. "I'm afraid we'll need the money. Just make him pay in advance."
    "But he can't!" Her voice throbbed with sympathetic warmth. "He says he'll have royalties com
in from his inventions, so he can pay in a few days."
    Underhill shrugged; he had heard that before.
    "Mr. Sledge is different, dear," she insisted. "He's a traveler, and a scientist. Here, in this dull
town, we don't see many interesting people."
    "You've picked up some remarkable types," he com-mented.
    "Don't be unkind, dear," she chided gently. "You haven't met him yet, and you don't know
wonderful he is." Her voice turned sweeter. "Have you a ten, dear?"
    He stiffened. "What for?"
    "Mr. Sledge is ill." Her voice turned urgent. "I saw him fall on the street, downtown. The po
were going to send him to the city hospital, but he didn't want to go. He looked so noble and sw
and grand. So I told them I would take him. I got him in the car and took him to old Dr. Winters
has this heart condition, and he needs the money for medicine."
    Reasonably, Underhill inquired, "Why doesn't he want to go to the hospital?"
    "He has work to do," she said. "Important scientific work—and he's so wonderful and tra
Please, dear, have you a ten?"
    Underhill thought of many things to say. These new mechanicals promised to multiply
troubles. It was foolish to take in an invalid vagrant, who could have free care at the city hosp
Aurora's tenants always tried to pay their rent with promises, and generally wrecked the apartm
and looted the neighborhood before they left.
    But he said none of those things. He had learned to compromise. Silently, he found two five
his thin pock-etbook, and put them in her hand. She smiled, and kissed him impulsively—he ba
remembered to hold his breath in time.
    Her figure was still good, by dint of periodic dieting. He was proud of her shining red hai
sudden surge of affection brought tears to his eyes, and he wondered what would happen to her
the children if the agency failed.
    "Thank you, dear!" she whispered. "I'll have him come for dinner, if he feels able, and you
meet him then. I hope you don't mind dinner being late."
    He didn't mind, tonight. Moved by a sudden impulse of domesticity, he got hammer and
from his workshop in the basement, and repaired the sagging screen on the kitchen door with a
diagonal brace.
    He enjoyed working with his hands. His boyhood dream had been to be a builder of fis
power plants. He had even studied engineering—before he married Aurora, and had to take over
ailing mechanicals agency from her indolent and alcoholic father. He was whistling happily by
time the little task was done.
    When he went back through the kitchen to put up his tools, he found the household and
busily clearing the untouched dinner away from the table—the androids were good enough at str
routine tasks, but they could never learn to cope with human unpredictability.
    "Stop, stop!" Slowly repeated, in the proper pitch and rhythm, his command made it halt,
then he said carefully, "Set—table; set—table."
    Obediently, the gigantic thing came shuffling back with the stack of plates. He was sudd
struck with the difference between it and those new humanoids. He sighed wearily. Things loo
black for the agency.

   Aurora brought her new lodger in through the kitchen door. Underhill nodded to himself.
gaunt stranger, with his dark shaggy hair, emaciated face, and threadbare garb, looked to be jus
sort of colorful, dramatic vagabond that always touched Aurora's heart. She intro-duced them,
they sat down to wait in the front room while she went to call the children.
   The old rogue didn't look very sick, to Underhill. Per-haps his wide shoulders had a tired sto
but his spare, tall figure was still commanding. The skin was seamed and pale, over his rawbo
cragged face, but his deep-set eyes still had a burning vitality.
   His hands held Underhill's attention. Immense hands, they hung a little forward when he sto
swung on long bony arms in perpetual readiness. Gnarled and scarred, darkly tanned, with the s
hairs on the back bleached to a golden color, they told their own epic of varied adventure, of b
perhaps, and possibly even of toil. They had been very useful hands.
   "I'm very grateful to your wife, Mr. Underhill." His voice was a deep-throated rumble, and he
a wistful smile, oddly boyish for a man so evidently old. "She rescued me from an unplea
predicament, and I'll see that she is well paid."
   Just another vivid vagabond, Underhill decided, talking his way through life with plaus
inventions. He had a little private game he played with Aurora's tenants—just remembering what
said and counting one point for every impossibility. Mr. Sledge, he thought, would give him
excellent score.
   "Where are you from?" he asked conversationally.
   Sledge hesitated for an instant before he answered, and that was unusual—most of Auro
tenants had been exceedingly glib.
   "Wing IV." The gaunt old man spoke with a solemn reluctance, as if he should have liked to
something else. "All my early life was spent there, but I left the planet nearly fifty years ago.
been traveling ever since."
   Startled, Underhill peered at him sharply. Wing IV, he remembered, was the home planet of th
sleek new mechanicals, but this old vagabond looked too seedy and impecunious to be conne
with the Humanoid Institute. His brief suspicion faded. Frowning, he said casually:
   "Wing IV must be rather distant."
   The old rogue hesitated again, and then said gravely,
    "One hundred and nine light-years, Mr. Underhill."
    That made the first point, but Underhill concealed his satisfaction. The new space liners w
pretty fast, but the velocity of light was still an absolute limit. Casually, he played for another poi
    "
     My wife says you're a scientist, Mr. Sledge? "
    "
     Yes."
    The old rascal's reticence was unusual. Most of Au-rora's tenants required very little promp
Underhill tried again, in a breezy conversational tone:
    "Used to be an engineer myself, until I dropped it to go into mechanicals." The old vagab
straightened, and Underhill paused hopefully. But he said nothing, and Un-derhill went on, "Fis
plant design and operation. What's your specialty, Mr. Sledge?"
    The old man gave him a long, troubled look, with those brooding, hollowed eyes, and then
slowly, "Your wife has been kind to me, Mr. Underhill, when I was in desperate need. I think
are entitled to the truth, but I must ask you to keep it to yourself. I am engaged on a very impo
research problem, which must be finished secretly."
    "I'm sorry." Suddenly ashamed of his cynical little game, Underhill spoke apologetically. "Fo
it." But the old man said deliberately, "My field is rhodomagnetics."
    "Eh?" Underhill didn't like to confess ignorance, but he had never heard of that. "I've been ou
the game for fifteen years," he explained. "I'm afraid I haven't kept up.
    The old man smiled again, faintly.
    "The science was unknown here until I arrived, a few days ago," he said. "I was able to apply
basic patents. As soon as the royalties start coming in, I'll be wealthy again."
    Underhill had heard that before. The old rogue's solemn reluctance had been very impressive,
he remembered that most of Aurora's tenants had been very plausible gentry.
    "So?" Underhill was staring again, somehow fascinated by those gnarled and scarred
strangely able hands. "What, exactly, is rhodomagnetics?"
    He listened to the old man's careful, deliberate answer, and started his little game again. Mos
Aurora's tenants had told some pretty wild tales, but he had never heard anything to top this.
    "A universal force," the weary, stooped old vagabond said solemnly. "As fundamenta
ferromagnetism or grav-itation, though the effects are less obvious. It is keyed to the second tria
the periodic table, rhodium and ru-thenium and palladium, in very much the same way
ferromagnetism is keyed to the first triad, iron and nickel and cobalt."
    Underhill remembered enough of his engineering courses to see the basic fallacy of
Palladium was used for watch springs, he recalled, because it was completely non-magnetic. Bu
kept his face straight. He had no malice in his heart, and he played the little game just for his
amusement. It was secret, even from Aurora, and he always penalized himself for any show
doubt.
    He said merely, "I thought the universal forces were already pretty well known."
    "The effects of rhodomagnetism are masked by nature," the patient, rusty voice explained. "A
besides, they are somewhat paradoxical, so that ordinary laboratory meth-ods defeat themselves
    "Paradoxical?" Underhill prompted.
    "In a few days I can show you copies of my patents, and reprints of papers descri
demonstration experi-ments," the old man promised gravely. "The velocity of propagation is infi
The effects vary inversely with the first power of the distance, not with the square of the dista
And ordinary matter, except for the elements of the rhodium triad, is generally transparen
rhodomag-netic radiations."
    That made four more points for the game. Underhill felt a little glow of gratitude to Aurora
discovering so remarkable a specimen.
   "Rhodomagnetism was first discovered through a math-ematical investigation of the atom,"
old romancer went serenely on, suspecting nothing. "A rhodomagnetic component was pro
essential to maintain the delicate equilibrium of the nuclear forces. Consequently, rho-domagn
waves tuned to atomic frequencies may be used to upset that equilibrium and produce nuc
insta-bility. Thus most heavy atoms—generally those above palladium, 46 in atomic number—
be subjected to artificial fission."
   Underhill scored himself another point, and tried to keep his eyebrows from lifting. He s
conversationally, "Patents on such a discovery ought to be very profitable"
   The old scoundrel nodded his gaunt, dramatic head.
   "You can see the obvious application. My basic patents cover most of them. Devices
instantaneous interplane-tary and interstellar communication. Long-range wireless po
transmission. A rhodomagnetic inflexion-drive, which makes possible apparent speeds many ti
that of light—by means of a rhodomagnetic deformation of the continuum. And, of cou
revolutionary types of fission power plants, using any heavy element for fuel."
   Preposterous! Underhill tried hard to keep his face straight, but everybody knew that the velo
of light was a physical limit. On the human side, the owner of any such remarkable patents w
hardly be begging for shelter in a shabby garage apartment. He noticed a pale circle around the
vagabond's gaunt and hairy wrist; no man owning such priceless secrets would have to pawn
watch.
   Triumphantly, Underhill allowed himself four more points, but then he had to penalize himself
must have let doubt show on his face, because the old man asked suddenly,
   "Do you want to see the basic tensors?" He reached in his pocket for pencil and notebook.
jot them down for you."
   "Never mind," Underhill protested. "I'm afraid my math is a little rusty."
   "But you think it strange that the holder of such revolu-tionary patents should find himse
need?"
   Underhill nodded, and penalized himself another point. The old man might be a monumental
but he was shrewd enough.
   "You see, I'm a sort of refugee," he explained apologet-ically. "I arrived on this planet only a
days ago, and I have to travel light. I was forced to deposit everything I had with a law firm
arrange for the publication and protection of my patents. I expect to be receiving the first roya
soon.
   "In the meantime," he added plausibly, "I came to Two Rivers because it is quiet and seclu
far from the spaceports. I'm working on another project, which must be finished secretly. Now,
you please respect my confidence, Mr. Underhill?"
   Underhill had to say he would. Aurora came back with the freshly scrubbed children, and
went in to dinner. The android came lurching in with a steaming tureen. The old stranger seeme
shrink from the mechanical, uneas-ily. As she took the dish and served the soup, Aurora inqu
lightly,
   "Why doesn't your company bring out a better mechan-ical, dear? One smart enough to
really perfect waiter, warranted not to splash the soup. Wouldn't that be splen-did?"
   Her question cast Underhill into moody silence. He sat scowling at his plate, thinking of th
remarkable new mechanicals which claimed to be perfect, and what they might do to the agenc
was the shaggy old rover who answered soberly,
   "The perfect mechanicals already exist, Mrs. Un-derhill." His deep, rusty voice had a sol
undertone. "And they are not so splendid, really. I've been a refugee from them, for nearly
years."
   Underhill looked up from his plate, astonished.
   "Those black humanoids, you mean?"
   "Humanoids?" That great voice seemed suddenly faint, frightened. The deep-sunken eyes tu
dark with shock. "What do you know of them?"
   "They've just opened a new agency in Two Rivers," Underhill told him. "No salesmen abou
you can imag-ine that. They claim—"
   His voice trailed off, because the gaunt old man was suddenly stricken. Gnarled hands clutche
his throat, and a spoon clattered to the floor. His haggard face turned an ominous blue, and
breath was a terrible shallow gasping.
   He fumbled in his pocket for medicine, and Aurora helped him take something in a glass of w
In a few moments he could breathe again, and the color of life came back to his face.
   "I'm sorry, Mrs. Underhill," he whispered apologetical-ly. "It was just the shock—I came her
get away from them." He stared at the huge, motionless android, with a terror in his sunken eye
wanted to finish my work before they came," he whispered. "Now there is very little time."
   When he felt able to walk, Underhill went out with him to see him safely up the stairs to the ga
apartment. The tiny kitchenette, he noticed, had already been con-verted into some kind
workshop. The old tramp seemed to have no extra clothing, but he had unpacked neat, b
gadgets of metal and plastic from his battered luggage, and spread them out on the small kitc
table.
   The gaunt old man himself was tattered and patched and hungry-looking, but the parts of
curious equipment were exquisitely machined, and Underhill recognized the silver-white luster of
palladium. Suddenly he suspect-ed that he had scored too many points in his little private game.

   A caller was waiting, when Underhill arrived next morning at his office at the agency. It st
frozen before his desk, graceful and straight, with soft lights of blue and bronze shining ove
black silicone nudity. He stopped at the sight of it, unpleasantly jolted.
   "At your service, Mr. Underhill." It turned quickly to face him, with its blind, disturbing s
"May we explain how we can serve you?"
   His shock of the afternoon before came back, and he asked sharply, "How do you know
name?"
   "Yesterday we read the business cards in your case," it purred softly. "Now we shall know
always. You see, our senses are sharper than human vision, Mr. Underhill. Perhaps we seem a
strange at first, but you will soon become accustomed to us."
   "Not if I can help it!" He peered at the serial number of its yellow nameplate, and shook
bewildered head. "That was another one, yesterday. I never saw you before!'
   "We are all alike, Mr. Underhill," the silver voice said softly. "We are all one, really. Our sepa
mobile units are all controlled and powered from Humanoid Central. The units you see are only
senses and limbs of our great brain on Wing IV. That is why we are so far superior to the
electronic mechanicals."
   It made a scornful-seeming gesture, toward the row of clumsy androids in his display room.
   "You see, we are rhodomagnetic."
   Underhill staggered a little, as if that word had been a blow. He was certain, now, that he
scored too many points from Aurora's new tenant. He shuddered slightly, to the first light kis
terror, and spoke with an effort, hoarsely, "Well, what do you want?"
   Staring blindly across his desk, the sleek black thing slowly unfolded a legal-looking docum
He sat down, watching uneasily.
   "This is merely an assignment, Mr. Underhill," it cooed at him soothingly. "You see, we
requesting you to assign your property to the Humanoid Institute in exchange for our service."
   "What?" The word was an incredulous gasp, and Un-derhill came angrily back to his feet. "W
kind of blackmail is this?"
   "It's no blackmail," the small mechanical assured him softly. "You will find the human
incapable of any crime. We exist only to increase the happiness and safety of mankind."
   "Then why do you want my property?" he rasped.
   "The assignment is merely a legal formality," it told him blandly. "We strive to introduce
service with the least possible confusion and dislocation. We have found the assignment plan
most efficient for the control and liquidation of private enterprises."
   Trembling with anger and the shock of mounting ter-ror, Underhill gulped hoarsely, "What
your scheme is, I don't intend to give up my business."
   "You have no choice, really." He shivered to the sweet certainty of that silver voice. "Hu
enterprise is no longer necessary, now that we have come, and the elec-tronic mechanicals indu
is always the first to collapse."
   He stared defiantly at its blind steel eyes.
   "Thanks!" He gave a little laugh, nervous and sardonic. "But I prefer to run my own business,
support my own family, and take care of myself."
   "But that is impossible, under the Prime Directive," it cooed softly. "Our function is to serve
obey, and guard men from harm. It is no longer necessary for men to care for themselves, bec
we exist to insure their safety and happiness. "
   He stood speechless, bewildered, slowly boiling.
   "We are sending one of our units to every home in the city, on a free trial basis," it added ge
"This free demonstration will make most people glad to make the formal assignment, and you w
be able to sell many more androids."
   "Get out!" Underhill came storming around the desk.
   The little black thing stood waiting for him, watching him with blind steel eyes, absolu
motionless. He checked himself suddenly, feeling rather foolish. He wanted very much to hit it,
he could see the futility of that.
   "Consult your own attorney, if you wish." Deftly, it laid the assignment form on his desk. "
need have no doubts about the integrity of the Humanoid Institute. We are sending a statemen
our assets to the Two Rivers bank, and depositing a sum to cover our obligations here. When
wish to sign, just let us know."
   The blind thing turned, and silently departed.

    Underhill went out to the corner drugstore and asked for a bicarbonate. The clerk that served
however, turned out to be a sleek black mechanical. He went back to his office, more upset
ever.
    An ominous hush lay over the agency. He had three house-to-house salesmen out,
demonstrators. The phone should have been busy with their orders and reports, but it didn't rin
all until one of them called to say that he was quitting.
    "I've got myself one of these new humanoids," he added, "and it says I don't have to w
anymore."
    He swallowed his impulse to profanity, and tried to take advantage of the unusual quiet
working on his books. But the affairs of the agency, which for years had been precarious, to
appeared utterly disastrous. He left the ledgers hopefully, when at last a customer came in.
    But the stout woman didn't want an android. She wanted a refund on the one she had bough
week before. She admitted that it could do all the guarantee promised—but now she had se
humanoid.
    The silent phone rang once again, that afternoon. The cashier of the bank wanted to know i
could drop in to discuss his loans. Underhill dropped in, and the cashier greeted him with
ominous affability.
    "How's business?" the banker boomed, too genially.
    "Average, last month," Underhill insisted stoutly. "Now I'm just getting in a new consignment,
I'll need another small loan—"
    The cashier's eyes turned suddenly frosty, and his voice dried up.
    "I believe you have a new competitor in town," the banker said crisply. "These humanoid peo
A very solid concern, Mr. Underhill. Remarkably solid! They have filed a statement with us,
made a substantial deposit to care for their local obligations. Exceedingly substantial!"
    The banker dropped his voice, professionally regretful.
    "In these circumstances, Mr. Underhill, I'm afraid the bank can't finance your agency any lon
We must request you to meet your obligations in full, as they come due." Seeing Underhill's w
desperation, he added icily, "We've already carried you too long, Underhill. If you can't pay,
bank will have to start bankruptcy proceed-ings."
    The new consignment of androids was delivered late that afternoon. Two tiny black human
unloaded them from the truck—for it developed that the operators of the trucking company
already assigned it to the Hu-manoid Institute.
    Efficiently, the humanoids stacked up the crates. Cour-teously they brought a receipt for him
sign. He no longer had much hope of selling the androids, but he had ordered the shipment an
had to accept it. Shuddering to a spasm of trapped despair, he scrawled his name. The naked b
things thanked him, and took the truck away.
    He climbed in his car and started home, inwardly seething. The next thing he knew, he was in
middle of a busy street, driving through cross traffic. A police whis-tle shrilled, and he pulled we
to the curb. He waited for the angry officer, but it was a little black mechanical that overtook him
    "At your service, Mr. Underhill," it purred sweetly. "You must respect the stop lights,
Otherwise, you endanger human life."
    "Huh?" He stared at it, bitterly. "I thought you were a cop."
    "We are aiding the police department, temporarily," it said. "But driving is really much
dangerous for human beings, under the Prime Directive. As soon as our service is complete, e
car will have a humanoid driver. As soon as every human being is completely supervised, there
be no need for any police force whatever."
    Underhill glared at it, savagely.
    "Well!" he rapped. "So I ran past a stop light. What are you going to do about it?"
    "Our function is not to punish men, but merely to serve their happiness and security," its s
voice said softly. "We merely request you to drive safely, during this tem-porary emergency w
our service is incomplete."
    Anger boiled up in him.
    "You're too perfect!" he muttered bitterly. "I suppose there's nothing men can do, but you can
it better."
    "Naturally we are superior," it cooed serenely. "Because our units are metal and plastic, w
your body is mostly water. Because our transmitted energy is drawn from atomic fission, instea
oxidation. Because our senses are sharper than human sight or hearing. Most of all, because all
mobile units are joined to one great brain, which knows all that happens on many worlds, and n
dies or sleeps or forgets."
   Underhill sat listening, numbed.
   "However, you must not fear our power," it urged him brightly. "Because we cannot injure
human being, unless to prevent greater injury to another. We exist only to discharge the P
Directive."
   He drove on, moodily. The little black mechanicals, he reflected grimly, were the ministe
angels of the ulti-mate god arisen out of the machine, omnipotent and all-knowing. The P
Directive was the new command-ment. He blasphemed it bitterly, and then fell to wonder-ing if t
could be another Lucifer.
   He left the car in the garage, and started toward the kitchen door.
   "Mr. Underhill." The deep tired voice of Aurora's new tenant hailed him from the door of
garage apartment. "Just a moment, please."
   The gaunt old wanderer came stiffly down the outside stairs, and Underhill turned back to m
him.
   "Here's your rent money," he said. "And the ten your wife gave me for medicine."
   "Thanks, Mr. Sledge." Accepting the money, he saw a burden of new despair on the b
shoulders of the old interstellar tramp, and a shadow of new terror on his raw-boned face. Puzz
he asked, "Didn't your royalties come through?"
   The old man shook his shaggy head.
   "The humanoids have already stopped business in the capital," he said. "The attorneys I reta
are going out of business, and they returned what was left of my deposit. That is all I have to fi
my work."
   Underhill spent five seconds thinking of his interview with the banker. No doubt he w
sentimental fool, as bad as Aurora. But he put the money back in the old man's gnarled
quivering hand.
   "Keep it," he urged. "For your work."
   "Thank you, Mr. Underhill." The gruff voice broke and the tortured eyes glittered. "I need it—
very much."
   Underhill went on to the house. The kitchen door was opened for him, silently. A dark na
creature came gracefully to take his hat.
   Underhill hung grimly onto his hat.
   "What are you doing here?" he gasped bitterly.
   "We have come to give your household a free trial demonstration."
   He held the door open, pointing.
   "Get out!"
   The little black mechanical stood motionless and blind.
   "Mrs. Underhill has accepted our demonstration ser-vice," its silver voice protested. "We ca
leave now, unless she requests it."
   He found his wife in the bedroom. His accumulated frustration welled into eruption, as he f
open the door. "What's this mechanical doing—"
   But the force went out of his voice, and Aurora didn't even notice his anger. She wore
sheerest negligee, and she hadn't looked so lovely since they were married. Her red hair was p
into an elaborate shining crown.
   "Darling, isn't it wonderful!" She came to meet him, glowing. "It came this morning, and it can
everything. It cleaned the house and got the lunch and gave little Gay her music lesson. It did
hair this afternoon, and now it's cooking dinner. How do you like my hair, darling?"
   He liked her hair. He kissed her, and tried to stifle his frightened indignation.
   Dinner was the most elaborate meal in Underhill's memory, and the tiny black thing served it
deftly. Aurora kept exclaiming about the novel dishes, but Un-derhill could scarcely eat, f
seemed to him that all the marvelous pastries were only the bait for a monstrous trap.
   He tried to persuade Aurora to send it away, but after such a meal that was useless. At the
glitter of her tears, he capitulated, and the humanoid stayed. It kept the house and cleaned the y
It watched the children, and did Aurora's nails. It began rebuilding the house.
   Underhill was worried about the bills, but it insisted that everything was part of the free
demonstration. As soon as he assigned his property, the service would be complete. He refuse
sign, but other little black mechanicals came with truckloads of supplies and materi-als, and sta
to help with the building operations.
   One morning he found that the roof of the little house had been silently lifted, while he slept, a
whole second story added beneath it. The new walls were of some strange sleek s
self-illuminated. The new windows were immense flawless panels, that could be turned transpa
or opaque or luminous. The new doors were silent, sliding sections, operated by rhodomagn
relays.
   "I want door knobs," Underhill protested. "I want it so I can get into the bathroom, wit
calling you to open the door."
   "But it is unnecessary for human beings to open doors," the little black thing informed ,
suavely. "We exist to discharge the Prime Directive, and our service includes every task. We sha
able to supply a unit to attend each member of your family, as soon as your property is assigne
us."
   Steadfastly, Underhill refused to make the assignment.
   He went to the office every day, trying first to operate the agency, and then to salvage somet
from the ruins. Nobody wanted androids, even at ruinous prices. Desper-ately, he spent the las
his dwindling cash to stock a line of novelties and toys, but they proved equally impos-sibl
sell—the humanoids were already making toys, which they gave away for nothing.
   He tried to lease his premises, but human enterprise had stopped. Most of the business prop
in town had already been assigned to the humanoids, and they were busy pulling down the
buildings and turning the lots into parks—their own plants and warehouses were mo
un-derground, where they would not mar the landscape.
   He went back to the bank, in a final effort to get his notes renewed, and found the little b
mechanicals standing at the windows and seated at the desks. As smoothly urbane as any hu
cashier, a humanoid informed him that the bank was filing a petition of involuntary bankruptc
liquidate his business holdings.
   The liquidation would be facilitated, the mechanical banker added, if he would make a volun
assignment. Grimly, he refused. That act had become symbolic. It would be the final bow
submission to this dark new god, and he proudly kept his battered head uplifted.

  The legal action went very swiftly, for all the judges and attorneys already had huma
assistants, and it was only a few days before a gang of black mechanicals arrived at the agency
eviction orders and wrecking machinery. He watched sadly while his unsold stock-in--trade
hauled away for junk, and a bulldozer driven by a blind humanoid began to push in the walls of
building.
   He drove home in the late afternoon, taut-faced and desperate. With a surprising generosity
court orders had left him the car and the house, but he felt no grati-tude. The complete solicitud
the perfect black machines had become a goad beyond endurance.
   He left the car in the garage, and started toward the renovated house. Beyond one of the vast
windows, he glimpsed a sleek naked thing moving swiftly, and he trembled to a convulsion of dr
He didn't want to go back into the domain of that peerless servant, which didn't want him to sh
himself, or even to open a door.
   On impulse, he climbed the outside stair, and rapped on the door of the garage apartment.
deep slow voice of Aurora's tenant told him to enter, and he found the old vagabond seated on a
stool, bent over his intricate equipment assembled on the kitchen table.
   To his relief, the shabby little apartment had not been changed. The glossy walls of his own
room were something which burned at night with a pale golden fire until the humanoid stoppe
and the new floor was something warm and yielding, which felt almost alive; but these little ro
had the same cracked and water-stained plaster, the same cheap fluorescent light fixtures, the s
worn carpets over splintered floors.
   "How do you keep them out?" he asked, wistfully. "Those mechanicals?"
   The stooped and gaunt old man rose stiffly to move a pair of pliers and some odds and end
sheet metal off a crippled chair, and motioned graciously for him to be seated.
   "I have a certain immunity," Sledge told him gravely. "The place where I live they cannot e
unless I ask them. That is an amendment to the Prime Directive. They can neither help nor hi
me, unless I request it—and I won't do that."
   Careful of the chair's uncertain balance, Underhill sat for a moment, staring. The old m
hoarse, vehement voice was as strange as his words. He had a gray, shocking pallor, and his ch
and sockets seemed alarmingly hollowed.
   "Have you been ill, Mr. Sledge?"
   "No worse than usual. Just very busy." With a haggard smile, he nodded at the floor. Unde
saw a tray where he had set it aside, bread drying up, and a covered dish grown cold. "I was g
to eat it later," he rumbled apologetically. "Your wife has been very kind to bring me food, but
afraid I've been too much absorbed in my work."
   His emaciated arm gestured at the table. The little device there had grown. Small machining
precious white metal and lustrous plastic had been assembled, with neatly soldered busbars,
something which showed purpose and design.
   A long palladium needle was hung on jeweled pivots, equipped like a telescope with exquis
graduated circles and vernier scales, and driven like a telescope with a tiny motor. A small conc
palladium mirror, at the base of it, faced a similar mirror mounted on something not quite like a s
rotary converter. Thick silver busbars con-nected that to a plastic box with knobs and dials on
and also to a foot-thick sphere of gray lead.
   The old man's preoccupied reserve did not, encourage questions, but Underhill, remembering
sleek black shape inside the new windows of his house, felt queerly reluctant to leave this ha
from the humanoids.
   "What is your work?" he ventured.
   Old Sledge looked at him sharply, with dark feverish eyes, and finally said, "My last rese
project. I am attempting to measure the constant of the rhodomagnetic quanta."
   His hoarse tired voice had a dull finality, as if to dismiss the matter and Underhill himself.
Underhill was haunted with a terror of the black shining slave that had become the master of
house, and he refused to be dismissed.
    "What is this certain immunity?"
    Sitting gaunt and bent on the tall stool, staring moodily at the long bright needle and the
sphere, the old man didn't answer.
    "These mechanicals!" Underhill burst out, nervously. "They've smashed my business and mo
into my home." He searched the old man's dark, seamed face. "Tell me—you must know m
about them—isn't there any way to get rid of them?"
    After half a minute, the old man's brooding eyes left the lead ball, and the gaunt shaggy h
nodded wearily. "That's what I am trying to do."
    "Can I help you?" Underhill trembled, with a sudden eager hope. "I'll do anything."
    "Perhaps you can." The sunken eyes watched him thoughtfully, with some strange fever in th
"If you can do such work."
    "I had engineering training," Underhill reminded him, "and I've a workshop in the basem
There's a model I built." He pointed at the trim little hull, hung over the mantel in the tiny living ro
"I'll do anything I can."
    Even as he spoke, however, the spark of hope was drowned in a sudden wave of overwehelm
doubt. Why should he believe this old rogue, when he knew Aurora's taste in tenants? He ough
remember the game he used to play, and start counting up the score of lies. He stood up from
crippled chair, staring cynically at the patched old vagabond and his fantastic toy.
    "What's the use?" His voice turned suddenly harsh. "You had me going, there, and I'd
anything to stop them, really. But what makes you think you can do anything?"
    The haggard old man regarded him thoughtfully.
    "I should be able to stop them," Sledge said softly. "Because, you see, I'm the unfortunate
who started them. I really intended them to serve and obey, and to guard men from harm. Yes
Prime Directive was my own idea. I didn't know what it would lead to."

   Dusk crept slowly into the shabby little rooms. Darkness gathered in the unswept corners,
thickened on the floor. The toylike machines on the kitchen table grew vague and strange, unti
last light made a linger-ing glow on the white palladium needle.
   Outside, the town seemed queerly hushed. Just across the alley, the humanoids were buildi
new house, quite silently. They never spoke to one another, for each knew all that any of them
The strange materials they used went together without any noise of hammer or saw. Small b
things, moving surely in the growing dark, they seemed as soundless as shadows.
   Sitting on the high stool, bowed and tired and old, Sledge told his story. Listening, Underhil
down again, careful of the broken chair. He watched the hands of Sledge, gnarled and corded
darkly burned, powerful once but shrunken and trembling now, restless in the dark.
   "Better keep this to yourself. I'll tell you how they started, so you will understand what we hav
do. But you had better not mention it outside these rooms—because the humanoids have
efficient ways of eradi-cating unhappy memories, or purposes that threaten their discharge of
Prime Directive."
   "They're very efficient," Underhill bitterly agreed.
   "That's all the trouble," the old man said. "I tried to build a perfect machine. I was altogether
successful. This is how it happened."
   A gaunt haggard man, sitting stooped and tired in the growing dark, he told his story.
   "Sixty years ago, on the arid southern continent of Wing IV, I was an instructor of atomic th
in a small technological college. Very young. An idealist. Rather ignorant, I'm afraid, of life
politics and war—of nearly everything, I suppose, except atomic theory."
   His furrowed face made a brief sad smile in the dusk.
   "I had too much faith in facts, I suppose, and too little in men. I mistrusted emotion, becau
had no time for anything but science. I remember being swept along with a fad for gen
semantics. I wanted to apply the scien-tific method to every situation, and reduce all experienc
formula. I'm afraid I was pretty impatient with human ignorance and error, and I thought that scie
alone could make the perfect world."
   He sat silent for a moment, staring out at the black silent things that flitted shadowlike about
new palace that was rising as swiftly as a dream across the alley.
   "There was a girl." His great tired shoulders made a sad little shrug. "If things had been a
different, we might have married, and lived out our lives in that quiet little college town, and perh
reared a child or two. And there would have been no humanoids."
   He sighed, in the cool creeping dusk.
   "I was finishing my thesis on the separation of the palladium isotopes—a pretty little project, b
should have been content with that. She was a biologist, but she was planning to retire when
married. I think we should have been two very happy people, quite ordinary, and altoge
harmless.
   "But then there was a war—wars had been too frequent on the worlds of Wing, ever since
were colonized. I survived it in a secret underground laboratory, designing military mechanicals.
she volunteered to join a mili-tary research project in biotoxins. There was an accident. A
molecules of a new virus got into the air, and everybody on the project died unpleasantly.
   "I was left with my science, and a bitterness that was bard to forget. When the war was ov
went back to the little college with a military research grant. The project was pure science
theoretical investigation of the nuclear binding forces, then misunderstood. I wasn't expect-e
produce an actual weapon, and I didn't recognize the weapon when I found it.
   "It was only a few pages of rather difficult mathemat-ics. A novel theory of atomic struc
involving a new expression for one component of the binding forces. But the tensors seemed to
harmless abstraction. I saw no way to test the theory or manipulate the predicated force.
military authorities cleared my paper for publication in a little technical review put out by the colle
   "The next year, I made an appalling discovery—I found the meaning of those tensors.
elements of the rhodi-um triad turned out to be an unexpected key to the manipulation of
theoretical force. Unfortunately, my paper had been reprinted abroad, and several other men m
have made the same unfortunate discovery, at about the same time.
   "The war, which ended in less than a year, was proba-bly started by a laboratory accident.
failed to antici-pate the capacity of tuned rhodomagnetic radiations, to unstabilize the heavy ato
A deposit of heavy ores was detonated, no doubt by sheer mischance, and the blast obliterated
incautious experimenter.
   "The surviving military forces of that nation retaliated against their supposed attackers, and
rhodomagnetic beams made the old-fashioned plutonium bombs seem pretty harmless. A b
carrying only a few watts of power could fission the heavy metals in distant electrical instrument
the silver coins that men carried in their pockets, the gold fillings in their teeth, or even the iodin
their thyroid glands. If that was not enough, slightly more powerful beams could set off heavy o
beneath them.
   "Every continent of Wing IV was plowed with new chasms vaster than the ocean deeps, and p
up with new volcanic mountains. The atmosphere was poisoned with radioactive dust and ga
and rain fell thick with deadly mud. Most life was obliterated, even in the shel-ters.
   “Bodily, I was again unhurt. Once more, I had been imprisoned in an underground site, this
designing new types of military mechanicals to be powered and controlled by rhodomagn
beams—for war had become far too swift and deadly to be fought by human soldiers. The site
located in an area of light sedimentary rocks, which could not be detonated, and the tunnels w
shield-ed against the fissioning frequencies.
   "Mentally, however, I must have emerged almost insane. My own discovery had laid the plan
ruins. That load of guilt was pretty heavy for any man to carry, and it corroded my last faith in
goodness and integrity of man.
   "I tried to undo what I had done. Fighting mechanicals, armed with rhodomagnetic weapons,
desolated the planet. Now I began planning rhodomagnetic mechanicals to clear the rubble
rebuild the ruins.
   "I tried to design these new mechanicals to obey forever certain implanted commands, so
they could never be used for war or crime or any other injury to mankind. That was very diff
technically, and it got me into more difficulties with a few politicians and military adventurers
wanted unrestricted mechanicals for their own military schemes—while little worth fighting for
left on Wing IV, there were other planets, happy and ripe for the looting.
   "Finally, to finish the new mechanicals, I was forced to disappear. I escaped on an experime
rhodomagnetic craft, with a number of the best mechanicals I had made, and managed to reac
island continent where the fission of deep ores had destroyed the whole population.
   "At last we landed on a bit of level plain, surrounded with tremendous new mountains. Hard
hospitable spot. The soil was burned under layers of black clinkers and poisonous mud. The
precipitous new summits all around were jagged with fracture-planes and mantled with lava flo
The highest peaks were already white with snow, but volcanic cones were still pouring out cloud
dark and lurid death. Everything had the color of fire and the shape of fury.
   "I had to take fantastic precautions there, to protect my own life. I stayed aboard the ship,
the first shielded laboratory was finished. I wore elaborate armor, and breathing masks. I used e
medical resource, to repair the damage from destroying rays and particles. Even so, I
desperately ill.
   "But the mechanicals were at home there. The radia-tions didn't hurt them. The awes
surroundings couldn't depress them, because they had no emotions. The lack of life didn't ma
because they weren't alive. There, in that spot so alien and hostile to life, the humanoids were bo
   Stooped and bleakly cadaverous in the growing dark, the old man fell silent for a little time.
haggard eyes stared solemnly at the small hurried shapes that moved like restless shadows
across the alley, silently building a strange new palace, which glowed faintly in the night.
   "Somehow, I felt at home there, too," his deep, hoarse voice went on deliberately. "My beli
my own kind was gone. Only mechanicals were with me, and I put my faith in them. I
determined to build better mechani-cals, immune to human imperfections, able to save men f
themselves.
   "The humanoids became the dear children of my sick mind. There is no need to describe
labor pains. There were errors, abortions, monstrosities. There were sweat and agony
heartbreak. Some years had passed, before the safe delivery of 'the first perfect humanoid.
   "Then there was the Central to build—for all the indi-vidual humanoids were to be no more
the limbs and the senses of a single mechanical brain. That was what opened the possibility of
perfection. The old electron-ic mechanicals, with their separate relay-centers and their own fe
batteries, had built-in limitations. They were necessarily stupid, weak, clumsy, slow. Worst of a
seemed to me, they were exposed to human tampering.
   "The Central rose above those imperfections. Its power beams supplied every unit with unfa
energy, from great fission plants. Its control beams provided each unit with an unlimited mem
and surpassing intelligence. Best of all—so I then believed—it could be securely protected from
human meddling.
   "The whole reaction-system was designed to protect itself from any interference by hu
selfishness or fanat-icism. It was built to insure the safety and the happiness of men, automatic
You know the Prime Directive: to serve and obey, and guard men from harm.
   "The old individual mechanicals I had brought helped to manufacture the parts, and I put the
section of Central together with my own hands. That took three years. When it was finished the
waiting humanoid came to life."
   Sledge peered moodily through the dark at Underhill.
   "It really seemed alive to me," his slow deep voice insisted. "Alive, and more wonderful than
human being, because it was created to preserve life. Ill and alone, I was yet the proud father
new creation, perfect, forever free from any possible choice of evil.
   "Faithfully, the humanoids obeyed the Prime Directive. The first units built others, and they
underground factories to mass-produce the coming hordes. Their new ships poured ores and s
into atomic furnaces under the plain, and new perfect humanoids came marching back out of
dark mechanical matrix.
   "The swarming humanoids built a new tower for the Central, a white and lofty metal py
standing splendid in the midst of that fire-scarred desolation. Level on level, they joined
relay-sections into one brain, until its grasp was almost infinite.
   "Then they went out to rebuild the ruined planet, and later to carry their perfect service to o
worlds. I was well pleased, then. I thought I had found the end of war and crime, of poverty
inequality, of human blundering and resulting human pain."
   The old man sighed, and moved heavily in the dark. "You can see that I was wrong."
   Underhill drew his eyes back from the dark unresting things, shadow-silent, building that glow
palace outside the window. A small doubt arose in him, for he was used to scoffing privatel
much less remarkable tales from Aurora's remarkable tenants. But the worn old man had spo
with a quiet and sober air; and the black invaders, he reminded himself, had not intruded here.
   "Why didn't you stop them?" he asked. "When you could?"
   "I stayed too long at the Central." Sledge sighed again, regretfully. "I was useful there,
everything was finished. I designed new fission plants, and even planned methods for introdu
the humanoid service with a minimum of confusion and opposition."
   Underhill grinned wryly, in the dark.
   "I've met the methods," he commented. "Quite effi-cient."
   "I must have worshiped efficiency, then," Sledge wearily agreed. "Dead facts, abstract t
mechanical perfec-tion. I must have hated the fragilities of human beings, because I was conten
polish the perfection of the new humanoids. It's a sorry confession, but I found a kind of happi
in that dead wasteland. Actually, I'm afraid I fell in love with my own creations."
   His hollowed eyes, in the dark, had a fevered gleam.
   "I was awakened, at last, by a man who came to kill me."
   Gaunt and bent, the old man moved stiffly in the thickening gloom. Underhill shifted his bala
careful of the crippled chair. He waited, and the slow, deep voice went on,
   "I never learned just who he was, or exactly how he came. No ordinary man could h
accomplished what he did, and I used to wish that I had known him sooner. He must have be
remarkable physicist and an expert mountaineer. I imagine he had also been a hunter. I know tha
was intelligent, and terribly determined.
   "Yes, he really came to kill me.
   "Somehow, he reached that great island, undetected. There were still no inhabitants—
humanoids allowed no man but me to come so near the Central. Somehow, he came past
search beams, and their automatic weap-ons.
   "The shielded plane he used was later found, abandoned on a high glacier. He came down the
of the way on foot through those raw new mountains, where no paths existed. Somehow, he c
alive across lava beds that were still burning with deadly atomic fire.
   "Concealed with some sort of rhodomagnetic screen—I was never allowed to examine it—
came undiscovered across the spaceport that now covered most of that great plain, and into the
city around the Central tower. It must have taken more courage and resolve than most men have,
I never learned exactly how he did it.
   "Somehow, he got to my office in the tower. He screamed at me, and I looked up to see him
the doorway. He was nearly naked, scraped and bloody from the mountains. He had a gun in
raw, red hand, but the thing that shocked me was the burning hatred in his eyes."
   Hunched on that high stool, in the dark little room, the old man shuddered.
   "I had never seen such monstrous, unutterable hatred, not even in the victims of war. And I
never heard such hatred as rasped at me, in the few words he screamed, `I've come to kill
Sledge. To stop your mechanicals, and set men free.'
   "Of course he was mistaken, there. It was already far too late for my death to stop
humanoids, but he didn't know that. He lifted his unsteady gun, in both bleeding hands, and fired
   "His screaming challenge had given me a second or so of warning. I dropped down behind
desk. And that first shot revealed him to the humanoids, which somehow hadn't been aware of
before. They piled on him, before he could fire again. They took away the gun, and ripped o
kind of net of fine white wire that had covered his body—that must have been part of his screen.
   "His hatred was what awoke me. I had always assumed that most men, except for a thwarted
would be grateful for the humanoids. I found it hard to understand his hatred, but the human
told me now that many men had required drastic treatment by brain surgery, drugs, and hypnos
make them happy under the Prime Direc-tive. This was not the first desperate effort to kill me
they had blocked.
   "I wanted to question the stranger, but the humanoids rushed him away to an operating ro
When they finally let me see him, he gave me a pale silly grin from his bed. He remembered
name; he even knew me—the hu-manoids had developed a remarkable skill at such treat-ments.
he didn't know how he had got to my office, or that he had ever tried to kill me. He kept whispe
that he liked the humanoids, because they existed to make men happy. And he was very happy n
As soon as he was able to be moved, they took him to the spaceport. I never saw him again.
   "I began to see what I had done. The humanoids had built me a rhodomagnetic yacht, that I u
to take for long cruises in space, working aboard—I used to like the perfect quiet, and the fee
being the only human being within a hundred million miles. Now I called for the yacht, and sta
out on a cruise around the planet, to learn why that man had hated me."
   The old man nodded at the dim hastening shapes, busy across the alley, putting together
strange shining palace in the soundless dark.
   "You can imagine what I found," he said. "Bitter futili-ty, imprisoned in empty splendor.
humanoids were too efficient, with their care for the safety and happiness of men, and there
nothing left for men to do."
   He peered down in the increasing gloom at his own great hands, competent yet but battered
scarred with a lifetime of effort. They clenched into fighting fists and wearily relaxed again.
   "I found something worse than war and crime and want and death." His low rumbling voice he
savage bitter-ness. "Utter futility. Men sat with idle hands, because there was nothing left for them
do. They were pam-pered prisoners, really, locked up in a highly efficient jail. Perhaps they trie
play, but there was nothing left worth playing for. Most active sports were declared too dange
for men, under the Prime Directive. Science was forbidden, because laboratories can manufac
dan-ger. Scholarship was needless, because the humanoids could answer any question. Art
degenerated into grim reflection of futility. Purpose and hope were dead. No goal was left
existence. You could take up some inane hobby, play a pointless game of cards, or go f
harmless walk in the park—with always the humanoids watching. They were stronger than m
better at everything, swimming or chess, singing or archeology. They must have given the ra
mass complex of inferiority.
   "No wonder men had tried to kill me! Because there was no escape from that dead fut
Nicotine was disap-proved. Alcohol was rationed. Drugs were forbidden. Sex was care
supervised. Even suicide was clearly contra-dictory to the Prime Directive—and the humanoids
learned to keep all possible lethal instruments out of reach."
   Staring at the last white gleam on that thin palladium needle, the old man sighed again.
   "When I got back to the Central," he went on, "I tried to modify the Prime Directive. I had n
meant it to be applied so thoroughly. Now I saw that it must be changed to give men freedom to
and to grow, to work and to play, to risk their lives if they pleased, to choose and take
consequences.
   "But that stranger had come too late. I had built the Central too well. The Prime Directive was
whole basis of its relay system. It was built to protect the Directive from human meddlin
did—even from my own. Its logic, as usual, was perfect.
   "The attempt on my life, the humanoids announced, proved that their elaborate defense of
Central and the Prime Directive still was not enough. They were preparing to evacuate the e
population of the planet to homes on other worlds. When I tried to change the Directive, they
me with the rest."
   Underhill peered at the worn old man, in the dark.
   "But you have this immunity," he said, puzzled. "How could they coerce you?"
   "I had thought I was protected," Sledge told him. "I had built into the relays an injunction tha
humanoids must not interfere with my freedom of action, or come into a place where I am, or to
me at all, without my specific request. Unfortunately, however, I had been too anxious to guard
Prime Directive from any human hampering.
   "When I went into the tower, to change the relays, they followed me. They wouldn't let me r
the crucial relays. When I persisted, they ignored the immunity order. They overpowered me,
put me aboard the cruiser. Now that I wanted to alter the Prime Directive, they told me, I
become as dangerous as any man. I must never return to Wing IV again."
   Hunched on the stool, the old man made an empty little shrug.
   "Ever since, I've been an exile. My only dream has been to stop the humanoids. Three tim
tried to go back, with weapons on the cruiser to destroy the Central, but their patrol ships alw
challenged me before I was near enough to strike. The last time, they seized the cruiser and capt
a few men who were with me. They removed the unhappy memories and the dangerous pur-p
of the others. Because of that immunity, however, they let me go, after I was weaponless.
   "Since, I've been a refugee. From planet to planet, year after year, I've had to keep moving
stay ahead of them. On several different worlds, I have published my rhodomagnetic discove
and tried to make men strong enough to withstand their advance. But rhodomagnetic scienc
dangerous. Men who have learned it need pro-tection more than any others, under the P
Directive. They have always come, too soon."
   The old man paused, and sighed again.
   "They can spread very fast, with their new rhodomag-netic ships, and there is no limit to
hordes. Wing IV must be one single hive of them now, and they are trying to carry the P
Directive to every human planet. There's no escape, except to stop them."
   Underhill was staring at the toylike machines, the long bright needle and the dull leaden ball, di
the dark on the kitchen table. Anxiously he whispered,
   "But you hope to stop them, now—with that?"
   "If we can finish it in time."
   "But how?" Underhill shook his head. "It's so tiny."
   "But big enough," Sledge insisted. "Because it's something they don't understand. They
perfectly efficient in the integration and application of everything they know, but they are
creative."
   He gestured at the gadgets on the table.
   "This device doesn't look impressive, but it is something new. It uses rhodomagnetic energ
build atoms, instead of to fission them. The more stable atoms, you know, are those near the mi
of the periodic scale, and energy can be released by putting light atoms together, as well as
breaking up heavy ones."
   The deep voice had a sudden ring of power.
   "This device is the key to the energy of the stars. For stars shine with the liberated energ
building atoms, of hydrogen converted into helium, chiefly, through the carbon cycle. This de
will start the integration process as a chain reaction, through the catalytic effect of a tu
rhodomagnetic beam of the intensity and frequency re-quired.
   "The humanoids will not allow any man within three light-years of the Central, now—but
can't suspect the possibility of this device. I can use it from here—to turn the hydrogen in the
of Wing IV into helium, and most of the helium and the oxygen into heavier atoms, still. A hun
years from now, astronomers on this planet should observe the flash of a brief and sudden nov
that direction. But the humanoids ought to stop, the instant we release the beam."
   Underhill sat tense and frowning, in the night. The old man's voice was sober and convincing,
that grim story had a solemn ring of truth. He could see the black and silent humanoids, fli
ceaselessly about the faintly glowing walls of that new mansion across the alley. He had q
forgotten his low opinion of Aurora's tenants.
   "And we'll be killed, I suppose?" he asked huskily. "That chain reaction—"
   Sledge shook his emaciated head.
   "The integration process requires a certain very low intensity of radiation," he explained. "In
atmosphere, here, the beam will be far too intense to start any reac-tion—we can even use the de
here in the room, because the walls will be transparent to the beam."
   Underhill nodded, relieved. He was just a small busi-nessman, upset because his business
been destroyed, unhappy because his freedom was slipping away. He hoped that Sledge could
the humanoids, but he didn't want to be a martyr.
   "Good!" He caught a deep breath. "Now, what has to be done?"
   Sledge gestured in the dark toward the table.
   "The integrator itself is nearly complete," he said. "A small fission generator, in that lead sh
Rhodomagnetic converter, tuning coils, transmission mirrors, and focusing needle. What we lac
the director."
   "Director?"
   "The sighting instrument," Sledge explained. "Any sort of telescopic sight would be useless,
see—the planet must have moved a good bit in the last hundred years, and the beam mus
extremely narrow to reach so far. We'll have to use a rhodomagnetic scanning ray, with
elec-tronic converter to make an image we can see. I have the cathode-ray tube, and drawings
the other parts."
   He climbed stiffly down from the high stool and snapped on the lights at last—cheap fluores
fixtures which a man could light and extinguish for himself. He unrolled his drawings, and expla
the work that Un-derhill could do. And Underhill agreed to come back early next morning.
   "I can bring some tools from my workshop," he added. "There's a small lathe I used to turn p
for models, a portable drill, and a vise."
   "We need them," the old man said. "But watch yourself. You don't have my immunity, remem
And, if they ever suspect, mine is gone."
   Reluctantly, then, he left the shabby little rooms with the cracks in the yellowed plaster and
worn familiar carpets over the familiar floor. He shut the door behind him—a common, crea
wooden door, simple enough for a man to work. Trembling and afraid, he went back down
steps and across to the new shining door that he couldn't open.
   "At your service, Mr. Underhill." Before he could lift his hand to knock, that bright smooth p
slid back silently. Inside, the little black mechanical stood waiting, blind and forever alert. "Y
dinner is ready, sir."
   Something made him shudder. In its slender naked grace, he could see the power of all th
teeming hordes, benevolent and yet appalling, perfect and invincible. The flimsy little weapon
Sledge called an integrator seemed suddenly a forlorn and foolish hope. A black depression se
upon him, but he didn't dare to show it.

   Underhill went circumspectly down the basement steps, next morning, to steal his own tools
found the base-ment enlarged and changed. The new floor, warm and dark and elastic, made his
as silent as a humanoid's. The new walls shone softly. Neat luminous signs identified several
doors: LAUNDRY, STORAGE, GAME ROOM, WORKSHOP.
   He paused uncertainly in front of the last. The new sliding panel glowed with a soft greenish l
It was locked. The lock had no keyhole, but only a little oval plate of some white metal, w
doubtless covered a rhodomagnetic relay. He pushed at it, uselessly.
   "At your service, Mr. Underhill." He made a guilty start, and tried not to show the sud
trembling in his knees. He had made sure that one humanoid would be busy for half an h
washing Aurora's hair, and he hadn't known there was another in the house. It must have come
of the door marked storage, for it stood there motionless beneath the sign, benevolently solicit
beautiful and terrible. "What do you wish?"
   "Er . . . nothing." Its blind steel eyes were staring, and he felt that it must see his secret purp
He groped desperately for logic. "Just looking around." His jerky voice came hoarse and
"Some improvements you've made!" He nodded desperately at the door marked GAME ROO
"What's in there?"
   It didn't even have to move to work the concealed relay. The bright panel slid silently open, a
started toward it. Dark walls, beyond, burst into soft lumines-cence. The room was bare.
   "We are manufacturing recreational equipment," it ex-plained brightly. "We shall furnish the r
as soon as possible."
    To end an awkward pause, Underhill muttered desper-ately, "Little Frank has a set of darts, a
think we had some old exercising clubs"
    "We have taken them away," the humanoid informed him softly. "Such instruments
dangerous. We shall furnish safe equipment."
    Suicide, he remembered, was also forbidden.
    "A set of wooden blocks, I suppose," he said bitterly.
    "Wooden blocks are dangerously hard," it told him gently "and wooden splinters can be harm
But we manufac-ture plastic building blocks, which are quite safe. Do you wish a set of those?"
    He stared at its dark, graceful face, speechless.
    "We shall also have to remove the tools from your workshop," it informed him softly. "S
tools are exces-sively dangerous, but we can supply you with equipment for shaping soft plastic
    "Thanks," he muttered uneasily. "No rush about that."
    He started to retreat, and the humanoid stopped him.
    "Now that you have lost your business," it urged, "we suggest that you formally accept our
service. Assignors have a preference, and we shall be able to complete your household staf
once."
    "No rush about that, either," he said grimly.
    He escaped from the house—although he had to wait for it to open the back door for him—
climbed the stair to the garage apartment. Sledge let him in. He sank into the crippled kitchen c
grateful for the cracked walls that didn't shine and the door that a man could work.
    "I couldn't get the tools," he reported despairingly, "and they are going to take them."
    By gray daylight, the old man looked bleak and pale. His raw-boned face was drawn, and
hollowed sockets deeply shadowed, as if he hadn't slept. Underhill saw the tray of neglected f
still forgotten on the floor.
    "I'll go back with you." The old man was worn and ill, yet his tortured eyes had a spark
undying purpose. "We must have the tools. I believe my immunity will protect us both."
    He found a battered traveling bag. Underhill went with him back down the steps, and acros
the house. At the back door, he produced a tiny horseshoe of white palladi-um, and touched
the metal oval. The door slid open promptly, and they went on through the kitchen to the basem
stair.
    A black little mechanical stood at the sink, washing dishes with never a splash or a cla
Underhill glanced at it uneasily—he supposed this must be the one that had come upon him from
storage room, since the other should still be busy with Aurora's hair.
    Sledge's dubious immunity seemed a very uncertain defense against its vast, remote intellige
Underhill felt a tingling shudder. He hurried on, breathless and relieved, for it ignored them.
    The basement corridor was dark. Sledge touched the tiny horseshoe to another relay to ligh
walls. He opened the workshop door, and lit the walls inside.
    The shop had been dismantled. Benches and cabinets were demolished. The old concrete w
had been covered with some sleek, luminous stuff. For one sick moment, Underhill thought tha
tools were already gone. Then he found them, piled in a corner with the archery set that Aurora
bought the summer before—another item too dangerous for fragile and suicidal humanity—all re
for disposal.
    They loaded the bag with the tiny lathe, the drill and vise, and a few smaller tools. Underhill
up the burden, and Sledge extinguished the wall light and closed the door. Still the humanoid
busy at the sink, and still it didn't seem aware of them.
    Sledge was suddenly blue and wheezing, and he had to stop to cough on the outside steps, b
last they got back to the little apartment, where the invaders were forbidden to intrude. Unde
mounted the lathe on the battered library table in the tiny front room, and went to work. Slowly,
by day, the director took form.
   Sometimes Underhill's doubts came back. Sometimes, when he watched the cyanotic colo
Sledge's haggard face and the wild trembling of his twisted, shrunken hands, he was afraid the
man's mind might be as ill as his body, and his plan to stop the dark invaders, all foolish illusion.
   Sometimes, when he studied that tiny machine on the kitchen table, the pivoted needle and
thick lead ball, the whole project seemed the sheerest folly. How could anything detonate the sea
a planet so far away that its very mother star was a telescopic object?
   The humanoids, however, always cured his doubts.
   It was always hard for Underhill to leave the shelter of the little apartment, because he didn't fe
home in the bright new world the humanoids were building. He didn't care for the shining splen
of his new bathroom, because he couldn 't work the taps—some suicidal human being might tr
drown himself. He didn't like the windows that only a mechanical could open—a man m
accidentally fall, or suicidally jump—or even the majestic music room with the wonderful glitte
radio-phonograph that only a humanoid could play.
   He began to share the old man's desperate urgency, but Sledge warned him solemnly, "
mustn't spend too much time with me. You mustn't let them guess our work is so important. B
put on an act—you're slowly get-ting to like them, and you're just killing time, helping me. "
   Underhill tried, but he was not an actor. He went dutifully home for his meals. He tried painful
invent conversation—about anything else than detonating plan-ets. He tried to seem enthusia
when Aurora took him to inspect some remarkable improvement to the house. He applauded G
recitals, and went with Frank for hikes in the wonderful new parks.
   And he saw what the humanoids did to his family. That was enough to renew his faith in Sled
integrator, and redouble his determination that the humanoids must be stopped.
   Aurora, in the beginning, had bubbled with praise for the marvelous new mechanicals. They
the household drudgery, brought the food and planned the meals and washed the children's ne
They turned her out in stun-ning gowns, and gave her plenty of time for cards.
   Now, she had too much time.
   She had really liked to cook—a few special dishes, at least, that were family favorites. But sto
were hot and knives were sharp. Kitchens were altogether too danger-ous for careless and suic
human beings.
   Fine needlework had been her hobby, but the hu-manoids took away her needles. She
enjoyed driving the car, but that was no longer allowed. She turned for escape to a shelf of nov
but the humanoids took them all away, because they dealt with unhappy people in dan-ge
situations.
   One afternoon, Underhill found her in tears.
   "It's too much," she gasped bitterly. "I hate and loathe every naked one of them. They seeme
wonderful at first, but now they won't even let me eat a bite of candy. Can't we get rid of th
dear? Ever?"
   A blind little mechanical was standing at his elbow, and he had to say they couldn't.
   "Our function is to serve all men, forever," it assured them softly. "It was necessary for us to
your sweets, Mrs. Underhill, because the slightest degree of overweight reduces life-expectancy.
   Not even the children escaped that absolute solicitude. Frank was robbed of a whole arsena
lethal instru-ments—football and boxing gloves, pocketknife, tops, slingshot, and skates. He d
like the harmless plastic toys, which replaced them. He tried to run away, but a humanoid recogn
him on the road, and brought him back to school.
   Gay had always dreamed of being a great musician. The new mechanicals had replaced her hu
teachers, since they came. Now, one evening when Underhill asked her to play, she announ
quietly,
   "Father, I'm not going to play the violin any more."
   "Why, darling?" He stared at her, shocked, and saw the bitter resolve on her face. "You've b
doing so well—especially since the humanoids took over your lessons."
   "They're the trouble, Father." Her voice, for a child's, sounded strangely tired and old. "They
too good. No matter how long and hard I try, I could never be as good as they are. It isn't any
Don't you understand, Fa-ther?" Her voice quivered. "It just isn't any use."

    He understood. Renewed resolution sent him back to his secret task. The humanoids had to
stopped. Slowly the director grew, until a time came finally when Sledge's bent and unsteady fin
fitted into place the last tiny part that Underhill had made, and carefully soldered the last connec
Huskily, the old man whispered,
    "It's done."
    That was another dusk. Beyond the windows of the shabby little rooms—windows of com
glass, bubble-marred and flimsy, but simple enough for a man to man-age—the town of Two Ri
had assumed an alien splen-dor. The old street lamps were gone, but now the coming night
challenged by the walls of strange new mansions and villas, all aglow with color. A few dark
silent humanoids still were busy on the luminous roofs of the palace across the alley.
    Inside the humble walls of the small manmade apart-ment, the new director was mounted on
end of the little kitchen table—which Underhill had reinforced and bolted to the floor. Sold
busbars joined director and integrator, and the thin palladium needle swung obediently as Sle
tested the knobs with his battered, quivering fingers.
    "Ready," he said hoarsely.
    His rusty voice seemed calm enough, at first, but his breathing was too fast. His big gna
hands began to tremble violently, and Underhill saw the sudden blue that stained his pinched
haggard face. Seated on the high stool, he clutched desperately at the edge of the table. Unde
saw his agony, and hurried to bring his medi-cine. He gulped it, and his rasping breath bega
slow.
    "Thanks," his whisper rasped unevenly. "I'll be all right. I've time enough." He glanced out a
few dark naked things that still flitted shadowlike about the golden towers and the glowing crim
dome of the palace across the alley. "Watch them," he said. "Tell me when they stop."
    He waited to quiet the trembling of his hands, and then began to move the director's knobs.
integrator's long needle swung, as silently as light.
    Human eyes were blind to that force, which might detonate a planet. Human ears were deaf t
The cathode-ray tube was mounted in the director cabinet, to make the faraway target visibl
feeble human senses.
    The needle was pointing at the kitchen wall, but that would be transparent to the beam. The
machine looked harmless as a toy, and it was silent as a moving humanoid.
    The needle swung, and spots of greenish light moved across the tube's fluorescent f
representing the stars that were scanned by the timeless, searching beam—silently seeking out
world to be destroyed.
    Underhill recognized familiar constellations, vastly dwarfed. They crept across the field, as
silent needle swung. When three stars formed an unequal triangle in the center of the field, the ne
steadied suddenly. Sledge touched other knobs, and the green points spread apart. Between th
another fleck of green was born.
    "The Wing!" whispered Sledge.
    The other stars spread beyond the field, and that green fleck grew. It was alone in the fiel
bright and tiny disk. Suddenly, then, a dozen other tiny pips were visible, spaced close about it.
    "Wing IV!"
    The old man's whisper was hoarse and breathless. His hands quivered on the knobs, and
fourth pip outward from the disk crept to the center of the field. It grew, and the others sp
away. It began to tremble like Sledge's hands.
    "Sit very still," came his rasping whisper. "Hold your breath. Nothing must disturb the need
He reached for another knob, and the touch set the greenish image to dancing violently. He drew
hand back, kneaded and flexed it with the other.
    "Now!" His whisper was hushed and strained. He nodded at the window. "Tell me when
stop."
    Reluctantly, Underhill dragged his eyes from that intense gaunt figure, stooped over the thing
seemed a futile toy. He looked out again, at two or three little black mechanicals busy about
shining roofs across the alley. He waited for them to stop.
    He didn't dare to breathe. He felt the loud, hurried hammer of his heart, and the nervous quive
his mus-cles. He tried to steady himself, tried not to think of the world about to be exploded, so
away that the flash would not reach this planet for another century and longer. The loud ho
voice startled him:
    "Have they stopped?"
    He shook his head, and breathed again. Carrying their unfamiliar tools and strange materials
small black machines were still busy across the alley, building an elaborate cupola above
glowing crimson dome.
    "They haven't stopped," he said.
    "Then we've failed." The old man's voice was thin and ill. "I don't know why."
    The door rattled, then. They had locked it, but the flimsy bolt was intended only to stop m
Metal snapped, and the door swung open. A black mechanical came in, on soundless graceful
Its silvery voice purred softly,
    "At your service, Mr. Sledge."
    The old man stared at it, with glazing, stricken eyes.
    "Get out of here!" he rasped bitterly. "I forbid you—"
    Ignoring him, it darted to the kitchen table. With a flashing certainty of action, it turned two kn
on the director. The tiny screen went dark, and the palladium needle started spinning aimle
Deftly it snapped a sol-dered connection, next to the thick lead ball, and then its blind steel
turned to Sledge.
    "You were attempting to break the Prime Directive." Its soft bright voice held no accusation
malice or anger. "The injunction to respect your freedom is subordi-nate to the Prime Directive
you know, and it is therefore necessary for us to interfere."
    The old man turned ghastly. His head was shrunken and cadaverous and blue, as if all the juic
life had been drained away, and his eyes in their pitlike sockets had a wild, glazed stare. His br
was a ragged, laborious gasping.
    "How—?" His voice was a feeble mumbling. "How did—?"

  And the little machine, standing black and bland and utterly unmoving, told him cheerfully,
   "We learned about rhodomagnetic screens from that man who came to kill you, back on W
IV. And the Central is shielded, now, against your integrating beam."
   With lean muscles jerking convulsively on his gaunt frame, old Sledge had come to his feet f
the high stool. He stood hunched and swaying, no more than a shrunken human husk, gas
painfully for life, staring wildly into the blind steel eyes of the humanoid. He gulped, and his lax
mouth opened and closed, but no voice came.
   "We have always been aware of your dangerous proj-ect," the silvery tones dripped so
"because now our senses are keener than you made them. We allowed you to complete it, bec
the integration process will ultimately become necessary for our full discharge of the P
Directive. The supply of heavy metals for our fission plants is limited, but now we shall be abl
draw unlim-ited power from integration plants."
   "Huh?" Sledge shook himself, groggily. "What's that?"
   "Now we can serve men forever," the black thing said serenely, "on every world of every star.
   The old man crumpled, as if from an unendurable blow. He fell. The slim blind mechanical st
motionless, making no effort to help him. Underhill was farther away, but he ran up in time to c
the stricken man before his head struck the floor.
   "Get moving!" His shaken voice came strangely calm. "Get Dr. Winters."
   The humanoid didn't move.
   "The danger to the Prime Directive is ended, now," it cooed. "Therefore it is impossible for u
aid or to hinder Mr. Sledge, in any way whatever."
   "Then call Dr. Winters for me," rapped Underhill. "At your service," it agreed.
   But the old man, laboring for breath on the floor, whispered faintly:
   "No time . . . no use! I'm beaten . . . done . . . a fool. Blind as a humanoid. Tell them ... to
me. Giving up ... my immunity. No use ... Anyhow. All humanity ... no use now."
   Underhill gestured, and the sleek black thing darted in solicitous obedience to kneel by the ma
the floor.
   "You wish to surrender your special exemption?" it murmured brightly. "You wish to accept
total service for yourself, Mr. Sledge, under the Prime Directive?"
   Laboriously, Sledge nodded, laboriously whispered, "I do."
   Black mechanicals, at that, came swarming into the shabby little rooms. One of them tore
Sledge's sleeve, and swabbed his arm. Another brought a tiny hypodermic, and exp
administered an intravenous injection. Then they picked him up gently, and carried him away.
   Several humanoids remained in the little apartment, now a sanctuary no longer. Most of them
gathered about the useless integrator. Carefully, as if their special senses were studying every de
they began taking it apart.
   One little mechanical, however, came over to Underhill. It stood motionless in front of
staring through him with sightless metal eyes. His legs began to tremble, and he swallowed uneas
   "Mr. Underhill," it cooed benevolently, "why did you help with this?"
   "Because I don't like you, or your Prime Directive. Because you're choking the life out o
mankind, and I wanted to stop it."
   "Others have protested," it purred softly. "But only at first. In our efficient discharge of the P
Directive, we have learned how to make all men happy."
   Underhill stiffened defiantly.
   "Not all!" he muttered. "Not quite!"
   The dark graceful oval of its face was fixed in a look of alert benevolence and perpetual
amazement. Its sil-very voice was warm and kind.
  "Like other human beings, Mr. Underhill, you lack discrimination of good and evil. You h
proved that by your effort to break the Prime Directive. Now it will be necessary for you to ac
our total service, without further delay."
  "All right," he yielded—and muttered a bitter reserva-tion: "You can smother men with too m
care, but that doesn't make them happy."
  Its soft voice challenged him brightly,
  "Just wait and see, Mr. Underhill."

   Next day, he was allowed to visit Sledge at the city hospital. An alert black mechanical drove
car, and walked beside him into the huge new building, and fol-lowed him into the old m
room—blind steel eyes would be watching him, now, forever.
   "Glad to see you, Underhill," Sledge rumbled heartily from the bed. "Feeling a lot better to
thanks. That old headache is all but gone."
   Underhill was glad to hear the booming strength and the quick recognition in that deep voice—
had been afraid the humanoids would tamper with the old man's memory. But he hadn't heard a
any headache. His eyes narrowed, puzzled.
   Sledge lay propped up, scrubbed very clean and neatly shorn, with his gnarled old hands fo
on top of the spotless sheets. His raw-boned cheeks and sockets were hollowed, still, but a hea
pink had replaced that death-ly blueness. Bandages covered the back of his head.
   Underhill shifted uneasily.
   "Oh!" he whispered faintly. "I didn't know—"
   A prim black mechanical, which had been standing statue-like behind the bed, turned gracefull
Underhill, explaining,
   "Mr. Sledge has been suffering for many years from a benign tumor of the brain, which his hu
doctors failed to diagnose. That caused his headaches, and certain persis-tent hallucinations.
have removed the growth, and now the hallucinations have also vanished."
   Underhill stared uncertainly at the blind, urbane me-chanical.
   "What hallucinations?"
   "Mr. Sledge thought he was a rhodomagnetic engineer," the mechanical explained. "He belie
he was the creator of the humanoids. He was troubled with an irrational belief that he did not like
Prime Directive. "
   The wan man moved on the pillows, astonished.
   "Is that so?" The gaunt face held a cheerful blankness, and the hollow eyes flashed with a me
momentary interest. "Well, whoever did design them, they're pretty wonderful. Aren't t
Underhill?"
   Underhill was grateful that he didn't have to answer, for the bright, empty eyes dropped shut
the old man fell suddenly asleep. He felt the mechanical touch his sleeve, and saw its silent
Obediently, he followed it away.
   Alert and solicitous, the little black mechanical accom-panied him down the shining corridor,
worked the elevator for him, and conducted him back to the car. It drove him efficiently b
through the new and splendid avenues, toward the magnificent prison of his home.
   Sitting beside it in the car, he watched its small deft hands on the wheel, the changing luste
bronze and blue on its shining blackness. The final machine, perfect and beautiful, created to s
mankind forever. He shud-dered.
   "At your service, Mr. Underhill." Its blind steel eyes stared straight ahead, but it was still awar
him. "What's the matter, sir? Aren't you happy?"
    Underhill felt cold and faint with terror. His skin turned clammy, and a painful prickling came
him. His wet hand tensed on the door handle of the car, but he restrained the impulse to jump
run. That was folly. There was no escape. He made himself sit still.
    "You will be happy, sir," the mechanical promised him cheerfully. "We have learned how to m
all men happy, under the Prime Directive. Our service is perfect, at last. Even Mr. Sledge is
happy now."
    Underhill tried to speak, and his dry throat stuck. He felt ill. The world turned dim and gray.
humanoids were perfect—no question of that. They had even learned to lie, to secure
contentment of men.
    He knew they had lied. That was no tumor they had removed from Sledge's brain, but
memory, the scien-tific knowledge, and the bitter disillusion of their own creator. But it was true
Sledge was happy now. He tried to stop his own convulsive quivering.
    "A wonderful operation!" His voice came forced and faint. "You know, Aurora has had a lo
funny tenants, but that old man was the absolute limit. The very idea that he had made
humanoids, and he knew how to stop them! I always knew he must be lying!"
    Stiff with terror, he made a weak and hollow laugh.
    "What is the matter, Mr. Underhill?" The alert mechan-ical must have perceived his shudde
illness. "Are you unwell?"
    "No, there's nothing the matter with me," he gasped desperately. "I've just found out that
perfectly happy, under the Prime Directive. Everything is absolutely won-derful." His voice c
dry and hoarse and wild. "You won't have to operate on me."
    The car turned off the shining avenue, taking him back to the quiet splendor of his home.
futile hands clenched and relaxed again, folded on his knees. There was nothing left to do.