eVersion 1.0 - click for scan notes

VASTER THAN EMPIRES AND MORE
SLOW
Ursula K. Le Guin
    It was only during the earliest decades of the League that the Earth sent ships out on the enormously
long voyages, beyond the pale, over the stars and far away. They were seeking for worlds which had not
been seeded or settled by the Founders on Hain, truly alien worlds. All the Known Worlds went back to
the Hainish Origin, and the Terrans, having been not only founded but salvaged by the Hainish, resented
this. They wanted to get away from the family. They wanted to find somebody new. The Hainish, like
tiresomely understanding parents, supported their explorations, and contributed ships and volunteers, as
did several other worlds of the League.
   All these volunteers to the Extreme Survey crews shared one peculiarity: they were of unsound mind.
    What sane person, after all, would go out to collect information that would not be received for five or
ten centuries? Cosmic mass interference had not yet been eliminated from the operation of the ansible,
and so instantaneous communication was reliable only within a range of 120 lightyears. The explorers
would be quite isolated. And of course they had no idea what they might come back to, if they came
back. No normal human being who had experienced time-slippage of even a few decades between
League worlds would volunteer for a round trip of centuries. The Surveyors were escapists, misfits. They
were nuts.
    Ten of them climbed aboard the ferry at Smeming Port, and made varyingly inept attempts to get to
know one another during the three days the ferry took getting to their ship, Gum. Gum is a Cetian
nickname, on the order of Baby or Pet. There were two Cetians on the team, two Hainishmen, one
Beldene, and five Terrans; the Cetian-built ship was chartered by the Government of Earth. Her motley
crew came aboard wriggling through the coupling tube one by one like apprehensive spermatozoa trying
to fertilize the universe. The ferry left, and the navigator put Gum underway. She flitted for some hours
on the edge of space a few hundred million miles from Smeming Port, and then abruptly vanished.
    When, after 10 hours 29 minutes, or 256 years, Gum reappeared in normal space, she was
supposed to be in the vicinity of Star KG-E-96651. Sure enough, there was the gold pinhead of the star.
Somewhere within a four-hundred-million-kilometer sphere there was also a greenish planet, World
4470, as charted by a Cetian mapmaker. The ship now had to find the planet. This was not quite so easy
as it might sound, given a four-hundred-million-kilometer haystack. And Gum couldn't bat about in
planetary space at near lightspeed; if she did, she and Star KG-E-96651 and World 4470 might all end
up going bang. She had to creep, using rocket propulsion, at a few hundred thousand miles an hour. The
Mathematician/Navigator, Asnanifoil, knew pretty well where the planet ought to be, and thought they
might raise it within ten E-days. Meanwhile the members of the Survey team got to know one another still
better.
    "I can't stand him," said Porlock, the Hard Scientist (chemistry, plus physics, astronomy, geology,
etc.), and little blobs of spittle appeared on his mustache. "The man is insane. I can't imagine why he was
passed as fit to join a Survey team, unless this is a deliberate experiment in non-compatibility, planned by
the Authority, with us as guinea pigs."
   "We generally use hamsters and Hainish gholes," said Mannon, the Soft Scientist (psychology, plus
psychiatry, anthropology, ecology, etc.), politely; he was one of the Hainishmen. "Instead of guinea pigs.
Well, you know, Mr. Osden is really a very rare case. In fact, he's the first fully cured case of Render's
Syndrome—a variety of infantile autism which was thought to be incurable. The great Terran analyst
Hammergeld reasoned that the cause of the autistic condition in this case is a supernormal empathic
capacity, and developed an appropriate treatment Mr. Osden is the first patient to undergo that
treatment, in fact he lived with Dr. Hammergeld until he was eighteen. The therapy was completely
successful."
   "Successful?"
   "Why, yes. He certainly is not autistic."
   "No, he's intolerable!"
    "Well, you see," said Mannon, gazing mildly at the saliva-flecks on Porlock's mustache, "the normal
defensive-aggressive reaction between strangers meeting—let's say you and Mr. Osden just for
example—is something you're scarcely aware of; habit, manners, inattention get you past it; you've
learned to ignore it, to the point where you might even deny it exists. However, Mr. Osden, being an
empath, feels it. Feels his feelings, and yours, and is hard put to say which is which. Let's say that there's
a normal element of hostility towards any stranger in your emotional reaction to him when you meet him,
plus a spontaneous dislike of his looks, or clothes, or handshake—it doesn't matter what. He feels that
dislike. As his autistic defense has been unlearned, he resorts to an aggressive-defense mechanism, a
response in kind to the aggression which you have unwittingly projected onto him." Mannon went on for
quite a long time.
   "Nothing gives a man the right to be such a bastard," Porlock said.
   "He can't tune us out?" asked Harfex, the Biologist, another Hainishman.
    "It's like hearing," said Olleroo, Assistant Hard Scientist, stopping over to paint her toenails with
fluorescent lacquer. "No eyelids on your ears. No Off switch on empathy. He hears our feelings whether
he wants to or not"
    "Does he know what we're thinking?" asked Eskwana, the Engineer, looking round at the others in
real dread.
   "No," Porlock snapped. "Empathy's not telepathy! Nobody's got telepathy."
    "Yet," said Mannon, with his little smile. "Just before I left Hain there was a most interesting report in
from one of the recently discovered worlds, a hilfer named Rocannon reporting what appears to be a
teachable telepathic technique existent among a mutated hominid race; I only saw a synopsis in the HILF
Bulletin, but—" He went on. The others had learned that they could talk while Mannon went on talking
he did not seem to mind, nor even to miss much of what they said.
   "Then why does he hate us?" Eskwana said.
   "Nobody hates you, Ander honey," said Olleroo, daubing Eskwana's left thumbnail with fluorescent
pink. The engineer flushed and smiled vaguely.
   "He acts as if he hated us," said Haito, the Coordinator. She was a delicate-looking woman of pure
Asian descent, with a surprising voice, husky, deep, and soft, like a young bullfrog "Why, if he suffers
from our hostility, does he increase it by constant attacks and insults? I can't say I think much of Dr.
Hammergeld's cure, really, Mannon; autism might be preferable … "
   She stopped. Osden had come into the main cabin.
    He looked flayed. His skin was unnaturally white and thin, showing the channels of his blood like a
faded road map in red and blue. His Adam's apple, the muscles that circled his mouth, the bones and
ligaments of his wrists and hands, all stood out distinctly as if displayed for an anatomy lesson. His hair
was pale rust, like long-dried blood. He had eyebrows and lashes, but they were visible only in certain
lights; what one saw was the bones of the eye sockets, the veining of the lids, and the colorless eyes.
They were not red eyes, for he was not really an albino, but they were not blue or grey; colors had
canceled out in Osden's eyes, leaving a cold water-like clarity, infinitely penetrable. He never looked
directly at one. His face lacked expression, like an anatomical drawing or a skinned face.
    "I agree," he said in a high, harsh tenor, "that even autistic withdrawal might be preferable to the smog
of cheap secondhand emotions with which you people surround me. What are you sweating hate for
now, Porlock? Can't stand the sight of me? Go practice some auto-eroticism the way you were doing
last night, it improves your vibes. Who the devil moved my tapes, here? Don't touch my things, any of
you. I won't have it"
   "Osden," said Asnanifoil in his large slow voice, "why are you such a bastard?"
   Ander Eskwana cowered and put his hands in front of his face. Contention frightened him. Olleroo
looked up with a vacant yet eager expression, the eternal spectator.
    "Why shouldn't I be?" said Osden. He was not looking at Asnanifoil, and was keeping physically as
far away from all of them as he could in the crowded cabin. "None of you constitute, in yourselves, any
reason for my changing my behavior."
   Harfex, a reserved and patient man, said, "The reason is that we shall be spending several years
together. Life will be better for all of us if—"
    "Can't you understand that I don't give a damn for all of you?" Osden said, took up his microtapes,
and went out. Eskwana had suddenly gone to sleep. Asnanifoil was drawing slipstreams in the air with his
finger and muttering the Ritual Primes. "You cannot explain his presence on the team except as a plot on
the part of the Terran Authority. I saw this almost at once. This mission is meant to fail," Harfex
whispered to the Coordinator, glancing over his shoulder. Porlock was fumbling with his fly-button; there
were tears in his eyes. I did tell you they were all crazy, but you thought I was exaggerating.
    All the same, they were not unjustified. Extreme Surveyors expected to find their fellow team
members intelligent, well-trained, unstable, and personally sympathetic. They had to work together in
close quarters and nasty places, and could expect one another's paranoias, depressions, manias, phobias
and compulsions to be mild enough to admit of good personal relationships, at least most of the time.
Osden might be intelligent, but his training was sketchy and his personality was disastrous. He had been
sent only on account of his singular gift, the power of empathy: properly speaking, of wide-range
bioempathic receptivity. His talent wasn't species-specific; he could pick up emotion or sentience from
anything that felt He could share lust with a white rat, pain with a squashed cockroach, and phototropy
with a moth. On an alien world, the Authority had decided, it would be useful to know if anything nearby
is sentient, and if so, what its feelings towards you are. Osden's title was a new one: he was the team's
Sensor.
   "What is emotion, Osden?" Haito Tomiko asked him one day in the main cabin, trying to make some
rapport with him for once. "What is it, exactly, that you pick up with your empathic sensitivity?"
   "Muck," the man answered in his high, exasperated voice. "The psychic excreta of the animal
kingdom. I wade through your feces."
   "I was trying," she said, "to learn some facts." She thought her tone was admirably calm.
   "You weren't after facts. You were trying to get at me. With some fear, some curiosity, and a great
deal of distaste. The way you might poke a dead dog to see the maggots crawl. Will you understand
once and for all that I don't want to be got at, that I want to be left alone?" His skin was mottled with red
and violet, his voice had risen. "Go roll in your own dung you yellow bitch!" he shouted at her silence.
   "Calm down," she said, still quietly, but she left him at once and went to her cabin. Of course he had
been right about her motives; her question had been largely a pretext, a mere effort to interest him. But
what harm in that? Did not that effort imply respect for the other? At the moment of asking the question
she had felt at most a slight distrust of him; she had mostly felt sorry for him, the poor arrogant venomous
bastard, Mr. No-Skin as Olleroo called him. What did he expect, the way he acted? Love?
    "I guess he can't stand anybody feeling sorry for him," said Olleroo, lying on the lower bunk, gilding
her nipples.
    "Then he can't form any human relationship. All his Dr. Hammergeld did was turn an autism inside
out … "
   "Poor frot," said Olleroo. "Tomiko, you don't mind if Harfex comes in for a while tonight, do you?"
   "Can't you go to his cabin? I'm sick of always having to sit in Main with that damned peeled turnip."
   "You do hate him, don't you? I guess he feels that. But I slept with Harfex last night too, and
Asnanifoil might get jealous, since they share the cabin. It would be nicer here."
    "Service them both," Tomiko said with the coarseness of offended modesty. Her Terran subculture,
the East Asian, was a puritanical one; she had been brought up chaste.
    "I only like one a night," Olleroo replied with innocent serenity. Beldene, the Garden Planet, had never
discovered chastity, or the wheel.
    "Try Osden, then," Tomiko said. Her personal instability was seldom so plain as now: a profound
self-distrust manifesting itself as destructivism. She had volunteered for this job because there was, in all
probability, no use in doing it.
   The little Beldene looked up, paintbrush in hand, eyes wide. "Tomiko, that was a dirty thing to say."
   "Why?"
   "It would be vile! I'm not attracted to Osden!"
    "I didn't know it mattered to you," Tomiko said indifferently, though she did know. She got some
papers together and left the cabin, remarking "I hope you and Harfex or whoever it is finish by last bell;
I'm tired."
    Olleroo was crying tears dripping on her little gilded nipples. She wept easily. Tomiko had not wept
since she was ten years old.
    It was not a happy ship; but it took a turn for the better when Asnanifoil and his computers raised
World 4470. There it lay, a dark-green jewel, like truth at the bottom of a gravity well. As they watched
the jade disc grow, a sense of mutuality grew among them. Osden's selfishness, his accurate cruelty,
served now to draw the others together. "Perhaps," Mannon said, "he was sent as a beating-gron. What
Terrans call a scapegoat Perhaps his influence will be good after all." And no one, so careful were they to
be kind to one another, disagreed.
  They came into orbit. There were no lights on nightside, on the continents none of the lines and clots
made by animals who build.
   "No men," Harfex murmured.
    "Of course not," snapped Osden, who had a viewscreen to himself, and his head inside a polythene
bag. He claimed that the plastic cut down on the empathic noise he received from the others. "We're two
light centuries past the limit of the Hainish Expansion, and outside that there are no men. Anywhere. You
don't think Creation would have made the same hideous mistake twice?"
   No one was paying him much heed; they were looking with affection at that jade immensity below
them, where there was life, but not human life. They were misfits among men, and what they saw there
was not desolation, but peace. Even Osden did not look quite so expressionless as usual; he was
frowning.
    Descent in fire on the sea; air reconnaissance; landing. A plain of something like grass, thick, green,
bowing stalks, surrounded the ship, brushed against extended view cameras, smeared the lenses with a
fine pollen.
   "It looks like a pure phytosphere," Harfex said. "Osden, do you pick up anything sentient?"
   They all turned to the Sensor. He had left the screen and was pouring himself a cup of tea. He did not
answer. He seldom answered spoken questions.
    The chitinous rigidity of military discipline was quite inapplicable to these teams of mad scientists; their
chain of command lay somewhere between parliamentary procedure and peck-order, and would have
driven a regular service officer out of his mind. By the inscrutable decision of the Authority, however, Dr.
Haito Tomiko had been given the title of Coordinator, and she now exercised her prerogative for the first
time. "Mr. Sensor Osden," she said, "please answer Mr. Harfex."
   "How could I 'pick up' anything from outside," Osden said without turning, "with the emotions of nine
neurotic hominids pulsating around me like worms in a can? When I have anything to tell you, I’ll tell you.
I'm aware of my responsibility as Sensor. If you presume to give me an order again, however,
Coordinator Haito, I’ll consider my responsibility void."
   "Very well, Mr. Sensor. I trust no orders will be needed henceforth." Tomiko's bullfrog voice was
calm, but Osden seemed to flinch slightly as he stood with his back to her, as if the surge of her
suppressed rancor had struck him with physical force.
    The biologist's hunch proved correct. When they began field analyses they found no animals even
among the microbiota. Nobody here ate anybody else. All life-forms were photosynthesizing or
saprophagous, living offlight or death, not off life. Plants: infinite plants, not one species known to the
visitors from the house of Man. Infinite shades and intensities of green, violet, purple, brown, red. Infinite
silences. Only the wind moved, swaying leaves and fronds, a warm soughing wind laden with spores and
pollens, blowing the sweet pale-green dust over prairies of great grasses, heaths that bore no heather,
flowerless forests where no foot had ever walked, no eye had ever looked. A warm, sad world, sad and
serene, the Surveyors wandering like picknickers over sunny plains of violet filicaliformes, spoke softly to
each other. They knew their voices broke a silence of a thousand million years, the silence of wind and
leaves, leaves and wind, blowing and ceasing and blowing again. They talked softly; but being human,
they talked.
  "Poor old Osden," said Jenny Chong Bio and Tech, as she piloted a helijet on the North Polar
Quadrating run. "All that fancy hi-fi stuff in his brain and nothing to receive. What a bust."
   "He told me he hates plants," Olleroo said with a giggle.
   "You'd think he'd like them, since they don't bother him like we do."
    "Can't say I much like these plants myself," said Porlock, looking down at the purple undulations of
the North Circumpolar Forest "All the same. No mind. No change. A man alone in it would go right off
his head."
   "But it's all alive," Jenny Chong said. "And if it lives, Osden hates it."
   "He's not really so bad," Olleroo said, magnanimous.
    Porlock looked at her sidelong and asked, "You ever slept with him, Olleroo?" Olleroo burst into
tears and cried, "You Terrans are obscene!"
   "No she hasn't," Jenny Chong said, prompt to defend. "Have you, Porlock?"
   The chemist laughed uneasily: ha, ha, ha. Flecks of spittle appeared on his mustache.
   "Osden can't bear to be touched," Olleroo said shakily. "I just brushed against him once by accident
and he knocked me off like I was some sort of dirty … thing. We're all just things, to him,"
    "He's evil," Porlock said in a strained voice, startling the two women. "Hell end up shattering this
team, sabotaging it, one way or another. Mark my words. He's not fit to live with other people!" They
landed on the North Pole. A midnight sun smoldered over low hills. Short, dry, greenish-pink bryoform
grasses stretched away in every direction, which was all one direction, south. Subdued by the incredible
silence, the three Surveyors set up their instruments and set to work, three viruses twitching minutely on
the hide of an unmoving giant
    Nobody asked Osden along on runs as pilot or photographer or recorder, and he never volunteered,
so he seldom left base camp. He ran Harfex's botanical taxonomic data through the onship computers,
and served as assistant to Eskwana, whose job here was mainly repair and maintenance. Eskwana had
begun to sleep a great deal, twenty-five hours or more out of the thirty-two-hour day, dropping off in the
middle of repairing a radio or checking the guidance circuits of a helijet. The Coordinator stayed at base
one day to observe. No one else was home except Poswet To, who was subject to epileptic fits;
Mannon had plugged her into a therapy-circuit today in a state of preventive catatonia. Tomiko spoke
reports into the storage banks, and kept an eye on Osden and Eskwana. Two hours passed.
   "You might want to use the 860 microwaldoes in sealing that connection," Eskwana said in his soft,
hesitant voice.
   "Obviously!"
   "Sorry. I just saw you had the 840's there—"
   "And will replace them when I take the 860's out. When I don't know how to proceed, Engineer, I’ll
ask your advice."
    After a minute Tomiko looked round. Sure enough, there was Eskwana sound asleep, head on the
table, thumb in his mouth. "Osden."
   The white face did not turn, he did not speak, but conveyed impatiently that he was listening.
   "You can't be unaware of Eskwana's vulnerability."
   "I am not responsible for his psychopathic reactions."
   "But you are responsible for your own. Eskwana is essential to our work here, and you're not. If you
can't control your hostility, you must avoid him altogether."
   Osden put down his tools and stood up. "With pleasure!" he said in his vindictive, scraping voice.
"You could not possibly imagine what it's like to experience Eskwana's irrational terrors. To have to
share his horrible cowardice, to have to cringe with him at everything!"
   "Are you trying to justify your cruelty towards him? I thought you had more self-respect." Tomiko
found herself shaking with spite. "If your empathic power really makes you share Ander's misery, why
does it never induce the least compassion in you?"
   "Compassion," Osden said. "Compassion. What do you know about compassion?"
   She stared at him, but he would not look at her.
   "Would you like me to verbalize your present emotional affect regarding myself?" he said. "I can do
more precisely than you can. I'm trained to analyze such responses as I receive them. And I do receive
them."
   "But how can you expect me to feel kindly towards you when you behave as you do?"
    "What does it matter how I behave, you stupid sow, do you think it makes any difference? Do you
think the average human is a well of loving-kindness? My choice is to be hated or to be despised. Not
being a woman or a coward, I prefer to be hated."
   "That's rot. Self-pity. Every man has—"
   "But I am not a man," Osden said. "There are all of you. And there is myself. I am one."
   Awed by that glimpse of abysmal solipsism, she kept silent a while; finally she said with neither spite
nor pity, clinically, "You could kill yourself, Osden."
   "That's your way, Haito," he jeered. "I'm not depressive, and seppuku isn't my bit. What do you want
me to do here?"
    "Leave. Spare yourself and us. Take the aircar and a data-feeder and go do a species count. In the
forest; Harfex hasn't even started the forests yet. Take a hundred-square-meter forested area, anywhere
inside radio range. But outside empathy range. Report in at 8 and 24 o'clock daily."
   Osden went, and nothing was heard from him for five days but laconic all-well signals twice daily. The
mood at base camp changed like a stage-set Eskwana stayed awake up to eighteen hours a day. Poswet
To got her stellar lute and chanted the celestial harmonies (music had driven Osden into a frenzy).
Mannon, Harfex, Jenny Chong and Tomiko all went off tranquilizers. Porlock distilled something in his
laboratory and drank it all by himself. He had a hangover. Asnanifoil and Poswet To held an all-night
Numerical Epiphany, that mystical orgy of higher mathematics which is the chief pleasure of the religious
Cetian soul. Olleroo slept with everybody. Work went well.
   The Hard Scientist came towards base at a run, laboring through the high, fleshy stalks of the
graminiformes. "Something—in the forest—" His eyes bulged, he panted, his mustache and fingers
trembled. "Something big. Moving behind me. I was putting in a benchmark, bending down. It came at
me. As if it was swinging down out of the trees. Behind me." He stared at the others with the opaque
eyes of terror or exhaustion.
   "Sit down, Porlock. Take it easy. Now wait, go through this again. You saw something—"
  "Not clearly. Just the movement Purposive. A—an—I don't know what it could have been.
Something self-moving. In the trees, the arboriformes, whatever you call 'em. At the edge of the woods."
   Harfex looked grim. "There is nothing here that could attack you, Porlock There are not even
microzoa. There could not be a large animal."
   "Could you possible have seen an epiphyte drop suddenly, a vine come loose behind you?"
    "No," Porlock said. "It was coming down at me, through the branches. When I turned it took off
again, away and upward. It made a noise, a sort of crashing. If it wasn't an animal, God knows what it
could have been! It was big— as big as a man, at least. Maybe a reddish color. I couldn't see, I'm not
sure."
   "It was Osden," said Jenny Chong "doing a Tarzan act." She giggled nervously, and Tomiko
repressed a wild feckless laugh. But Harfex was not smiling
    "One gets uneasy under the arboriformes," he said in his polite, repressed voice. "I've noticed that.
Indeed that may be why I've put off working in the forests. There's a hypnotic quality in the colors and
spacing of the stems and branches, especially the helically-arranged ones; and the spore-throwers grow
so regularly spaced that it seems unnatural. I find it quite disagreeable, subjectively speaking I wonder if a
stronger effect of that sort mightn't have produced a hallucination … ?"
   Porlock shook his head. He wet his lips. "It was there," he said. "Something Moving with purpose.
Trying to attack me from behind."
   When Osden called in, punctual as always, at 24 o'clock that night, Harfex told him Porlock's report
"Have you come on anything at all, Mr. Osden, that could substantiate Mr. Porlock's impression of a
motile, sentient life-form, in the forest?"
   Ssss, the radio said sardonically. "No. Bullshit," said Osden's unpleasant voice.
    "You've been actually inside the forest longer than any of us," Harfex said with unmitigable politeness.
"Do you agree with my impression that the forest ambiance has a rather troubling and possibly
hallucinogenic effect on the perceptions?"
  Ssss. "I'll agree that Porlock's perceptions are easily troubled. Keep him in his lab, he'll do less harm.
Anything else?"
   "Not at present," Harfex said, and Osden cut off.
    Nobody could credit Porlock's story, and nobody could discredit it He was positive that something
something big had tried to attack him by surprise. It was hard to deny this, for they were on an alien
world, and everyone who had entered the forest had felt a certain chill and foreboding under the "trees."
("Call them trees, certainly," Harfex had said. "They really are the same thing only, of course, altogether
different") They agreed that they had felt uneasy, or had had the sense that something was watching them
from behind.
    "We've got to clear this up," Porlock said, and he asked to be sent as a temporary Biologist's Aide,
like Osden, into the forest to explore and observe. Olleroo and Jenny Chong volunteered if they could go
as a pair. Harfex sent them all off into the forest near which they were encamped, a vast tract covering
four-fifths of Continent D. He forbade side-arms. They were not to go outside a fifty-mile half-circle,
which included Osden's current site. They all reported in twice daily, for three days. Porlock reported a
glimpse of what seemed to be a large semi-erect shape moving through the trees across the river; Olleroo
was sure she had heard something moving near the tent, the second night
   "There are no animals on this planet," Harfex said.
   Then Osden missed his morning call.
   Tomiko waited less than an hour, then flew with Harfex to the area where Osden had reported
himself the night before. But as the helijet hovered over the sea of purplish leaves, illimitable,
impenetrable, she felt a panic despair. "How can we find him in this?"
    "He reported landing on the riverbank. Find the aircar; he'll be camped near it, and he can't have gone
far from his camp. Species-counting is slow work. There's the river."
   "There's his car," Tomiko said, catching the bright foreign glint among the vegetable colors and
shadows. "Here goes, then."
   She put the ship in hover and pitched out the ladder. She and Harfex descended. The sea of life
closed over their heads.
    As her feet touched the forest floor, she unsnapped the flap of her holster; then glancing at Harfex,
who was unarmed, she left the gun untouched. But her hand kept coming back to it. There was no sound
at all, as soon as they were a few meters away from the slow, brown river, and the light was dim. Great
boles stood well apart, almost regularly, almost alike; they were soft-skinned, some appearing smooth
and others spongy, grey or greenish-brown or brown, twined with cable-like creepers and festooned
with epiphytes, extending rigid, entangled armfuls of big saucer-shaped, dark leaves that formed a
roof-layer twenty to thirty meters thick. The ground underfoot was springy as a mattress, every inch of it
knotted with roots and peppered with small, fleshy-leafed growths.
    "Here's his tent," Tomiko said, cowed at the sound of her voice in that huge community of the
voiceless. In the tent was Osden's sleeping bag, a couple of books, a box of rations. We should be
calling, shouting for him, she thought, but did not even suggest it; nor did Harfex. They circled out from
the tent, careful to keep each other in sight through the thick-standing presences, the crowding gloom.
She stumbled over Osden's body, not thirty meters from the tent, led to it by the whitish gleam of a
dropped notebook. He lay face down between two huge-rooted trees. His head and hands were
covered with blood, some dried, some still oozing red.
   Harfex appeared beside her, his pale Hainish complexion quite green in the dusk. "Dead?"
   "No. He's been struck. Beaten. From behind." Tomiko's fingers felt over the bloody skull and temples
and nape. "A weapon or a tool … I don't find a fracture."
    As she turned Osden's body over so they could lift him, his eyes opened. She was holding him,
bending close to his face. His pale lips writhed. A deathly fear came into her. She screamed aloud two or
three times and tried to run away, shambling and stumbling into the terrible dusk. Harfex caught her, and
at his touch and the sound of his voice, her panic decreased. "What is it? What is it?" he was saying
    "I don't know," she sobbed. Her heartbeat still shook her, and she could not see clearly. "The
fear—the … I panicked. When I saw his eyes."
   "We're both nervous. I don't understand this—"
   "I'm all right now, come on, we've got to get him under care."
    Both working with senseless haste, they lugged Osden to the riverside and hauled him up on a rope
under his armpits; he dangled like a sack, twisting a little, over the glutinous dark sea of leaves. They
pulled him into the helijet and took off. Within a minute they were over open prairie. Tomiko locked onto
the homing beam. She drew a deep breath, and her eyes met Harfex's. "I was so terrified I almost
fainted. I have never done that."
   "I was … unreasonably frightened also," said the Hain-ishman, and indeed he looked aged and
shaken. "Not so badly as you. But as unreasonably."
   "It was when I was in contact with him, holding him. He seemed to be conscious for a moment."
   "Empathy? … I hope he can tell us what attacked him."
    Osden, like a broken dummy covered with blood and mud, half lay as they had bundled him into the
rear seats in their frantic urgency to get out of the forest.
   More panic met their arrival at base. The ineffective brutality of the assault was sinister and
bewildering. Since Harfex stubbornly denied any possibility of animal life they began speculating about
sentient plants, vegetable monsters, psychic projections. Jenny Chong's latent phobia reasserted itself and
she could talk about nothing except the Dark Egos which followed people around behind their backs.
She and Olleroo and Porlock had been summoned back to base; and nobody was much inclined to go
outside.
   Osden had lost a good deal of blood during the three or four hours he had lain alone, and concussion
and severe contusions had put him in shock and semi-coma. As he came out of this and began running a
low fever he called several times for "Doctor," in a plaintive voice: "Doctor Hammergeld … " When he
regained full consciousness, two of those long days later, Tomiko called Harfex into his cubicle.
   "Osden: can you tell us what attacked you?"
   The pale eyes flickered past Harfex's face.
    "You were attacked," Tomiko said gently. The shifty gaze was hatefully familiar, but she was a
physician, protective of the hurt. "You may not remember it yet. Something attacked you. You were in
the forest—"
   "Ah!" he cried out, his eyes growing bright and his features contorting. "The forest—in the forest—"
   "What's in the forest?"
   He grasped for breath. A look of clearer consciousness came into his face. After a while he said, "I
don't know."
   "Did you see what attacked you?" Harfex asked.
   "I don't know."
   "You remember it now."
   "I don't know."
   "All our lives may depend on this. You must tell us what you saw!"
    "I don't know," Osden said, sobbing with weakness. He was too weak to hide the fact that he was
hiding the answer, yet he would not say it. Porlock, nearby, was chewing his pepper-colored mustache
as he tried to hear what was going on in the cubicle. Harfex leaned over Osden and said, "You will tell
us—" Tomiko had to interfere bodily.
   Harfex controlled himself with an effort that was painful to see. He went off silently to his cubicle,
where no doubt he took a double or triple dose of tranquilizers. The other men and women scattered
about the big frail building a long main hall and ten sleeping-cubicles, said nothing, but looked depressed
and edgy. Osden, as always, even now, had them all at his mercy. Tomiko looked down at him with a
rush of hatred that burned in her throat like bile. This monstrous egotism that fed itself on others'
emotions, this absolute selfishness, was worse than any hideous deformity of the flesh. Like a congenital
monster, he should not have lived. Should not be alive. Should have died. Why had his head not been
split open?
    As he lay flat and white, his hands helpless at his sides, his colorless eyes were wide open, and there
were tears running from the corners. He tried to flinch away. "Don't," he said in a weak hoarse voice, and
tried to raise his hands to protect his head. "Don't!"
   She sat down on the folding-stool beside the cot, and after a while put her hand on his. He tried to
pull away, but lacked the strength.
   A long silence fell between them.
     "Osden," she murmured, "I'm sorry. I'm very sorry. I will you well. Let me will you well, Osden. I
don't want to hurt you. Listen, I do see now. It was one of us. That's right, isn't it. No, don't answer, only
tell me if I'm wrong; but I'm not … Of course there are animals on this planet. Ten of them. I don't care
who it was. It doesn't matter, does it. It could have been me, just now. I realize that I didn't understand
how it is, Osden. You can't see how difficult it is for us to understand … But listen. If it were love,
instead of hate and fear … It is never love?"
   "No."
   "Why not? Why should it never be? Are human beings all so weak? That is terrible. Never mind,
never mind, don't worry. Keep still. At least right now it isn't hate, is it? Sympathy at least, concern,
well-wishing, you do feel that, Osden? Is it what you feel?"
   "Among … other things," he said, almost inaudibly.
   "Noise from my subconscious, I suppose. And everybody else in the room … Listen, when we found
you there in the forest, when I tried to turn you over, you partly wakened, and I felt a horror of you. I
was insane with fear for a minute. Was that your fear of me I felt?"
   "No."
   Her hand was still on his, and he was quite relaxed, sinking towards sleep, like a man in pain who has
been given relief from pain. "The forest," he muttered; she could barely understand him. "Afraid."
    She pressed him no further, but kept her hand on his and watched him go to sleep. She knew what
she felt, and what therefore he must feel. She was confident of it there is only one emotion, or state of
being that can thus wholly reverse itself, polarize, within one moment. In Great Hainish indeed there is
one word, onto, for love and for hate. She was not in love with Osden, of course, that was another kettle
of fish. What she felt for him was onto, polarized hate. She held his hand and the current flowed between
them, the tremendous electricity of touch, which he had always dreaded. As he slept the ring of
anatomy-chart muscles around his mouth relaxed, and Tomiko saw on his face what none of them had
ever seen, very faint, a smile. It faded. He slept on.
   He was tough; next day he was sitting up, and hungry. Harfex wished to interrogate him, but Tomiko
put him off. She hung a sheet of polythene over the cubicle door, as Osden himself had often done.
"Does it actually cut down your empathic reception?" she asked, and he replied, in the dry, cautious tone
they were now using to each other, "No."
   "Just a warning then."
   "Partly. More faith-healing. Dr. Hammergeld thought it worked … Maybe it does, a little."
   There had been love, once. A terrified child, suffocating in the tidal rush and battering of the
huge-emotions of adults, a drowning child, saved by one man. Taught to breathe, to live, by one man.
Given everything, all protection and love, by one man. Father/Mother/God: no other. "Is he still alive?"
Tomiko asked, thinking of Osden's incredible loneliness, and the strange cruelty of the great doctors. She
was shocked when she heard his forced, tinny laugh. "He died at least two and a half centuries ago,"
Osden said. "Do you forget where we are, Coordinator? We've all left our little families behind … "
    Outside the polythene curtain the eight other human beings on World 4470 moved vaguely. Their
voices were low and strained. Eskwana slept; Poswet To was in therapy; Jenny Chong was trying to rig
lights in her cubicle so that she wouldn't cast a shadow.
    "They're all scared," Tomiko said, scared. "They've all got these ideas about what attacked you. A
sort of ape-potato, a giant fanged spinach, I don't know … Even Harfex. You may be right not to force
them to see. That would be worse, to lose confidence in one another. But why are we all so shaky,
unable to face the fact, going to pieces so easily? Are we really all insane?"
   "Well soon be more so."
   "Why?"
   "There is something." He closed his mouth, the muscles of his lips stood out rigid.
   "Something sentient?"
   "A sentience."
   "In the forest?" He nodded.
   "What is it, then—?"
   "The fear." He began to look strained again, and moved restlessly. "When I fell, there, you know, I
didn't lose consciousness at once. Or I kept regaining it I don't know. It was more like being paralyzed."
   "You were."
    "I was on the ground. I couldn't get up. My face was in the dirt, in that soft leaf mold. It was in my
nostrils and eyes. I couldn't move. Couldn't see. As if I was in the ground. Sunk into it part of it I knew I
was between two trees even though I never saw them. I suppose I could feel the roots. Below me in the
ground, down under the ground. My hands were bloody, I could feel that and the blood made the dirt
around my face sticky. I felt the fear. It kept growing. As if they'd finally known I was there, lying on
them there, under them, among them, the thing they feared, and yet part of their fear itself. I couldn't stop
sending the fear back, and it kept growing and I couldn't move, I couldn't get away. I would pass out I
think, and then the fear would bring me to again, and I still couldn't move. Any more than they can."
   Tomiko felt the cold stirring of her hair, the readying of the apparatus of terror. "They: who are they,
Osden?"
   "They, it—I don't know. The fear."
   "What is he talking about?" Harfex demanded when Tomiko reported this conversation. She would
not let Harfex question Osden yet, feeling that she must protect Osden from the onslaught of the
Hainishman's powerful, over-repressed emotions. Unfortunately this fueled the slow fire of paranoid
anxiety that burned in poor Harfex, and he thought she and Osden were in league, hiding some fact of
great importance or peril from the rest of the team.
   "It's like the blind man trying to describe the elephant Osden hasn't seen or heard the … the
sentience, any more than we have."
     "But he's felt it, my dear Haito," Harfex said with just-suppressed rage. "Not empathically. On his
skull. It came and knocked him down and beat him with a blunt instrument. Did he not catch one glimpse
of it?"
    "What would he have seen, Harfex?" Tomiko said, but he would not hear her meaningful tone; even
he had blocked out that comprehension. What one fears is alien. The murderer is an outsider, a foreigner,
not one of us. The evil is not in me!
    "The first blow knocked him pretty well out," Tomiko said a little wearily, "he didn't see anything. But
when he came to again, alone in the forest, he felt a great fear. Not his own fear; an empathic effect. He
is certain of that. And certain it was nothing picked up from any of us. So that evidently the native
life-forms are not all insentient"
    Harfex looked at her a moment, grim. "You're trying to frighten me, Haito. I do not understand your
motives." He got up and went off to his laboratory table, walking slowly and stiffly, like a man of eighty
not of forty.
    She looked around at the others. She felt some desperation. Her new, fragile, and profound
interdependence with Osden gave her, she was well aware, some added strength. But if even Harfex
could not keep his head, who of the others would? Porlock and Eskwana were shut in their cubicles, the
others were all working or busy with something. There was something queer about their positions. For a
while the Coordinator could not tell what it was, then she saw that they were all sitting facing the nearby
forest. Playing chess with Asnanifoil, Olleroo had edged her chair around until it was almost beside his.
    She went to Mannon, who was dissecting a tangle of spidery brown roots, and told him to look for
the pattern-puzzle. He saw it at once, and said with unusual brevity, "Keeping an eye on the enemy."
   "What enemy? What do you feel, Mannon?" She had a sudden hope in him as a psychologist, on this
obscure ground of hints and empathies where biologists went astray.
    "I feel a strong anxiety with a specific spatial orientation. But I am not an empath. Therefore the
anxiety is explicable in terms of the particular stress-situation, that is, the attack on a team member in the
forest, and also in terms of the total stress-situation, that is, my presence in a totally alien environment for
which the archetypical connotations of the word 'forest' provide an inevitable metaphor."
   Hours later Tomiko woke to hear Osden screaming in nightmare; Mannon was calming him, and she
sank back into her own dark-branching pathless dreams. In the morning Eskwana did not wake. He
could not be roused with stimulant drugs. He clung to his sleep, slipping farther and farther back,
mumbling softly now and then until, wholly regressed, he lay curled on his side, thumb at his lips, gone.
   "Two days; two down. Ten little Indians, nine little Indians … " That was Porlock.
   "And you're the next little Indian," Jenny Chong snapped. "Go analyze your urine, Porlock!"
   "He is driving us all insane," Porlock said, getting up and waving his left arm. "Can't you feel it? For
God's sake, are you all deaf and blind? Can't you feel what he's doing the emanations? It all comes from
him—from his room there—from his mind. He is driving us all insane with fear!"
   "Who is?" said Asnanifoil, looming precipitous and hairy over the little Terran.
    "Do I have to say his name? Osden, then. Osden! Osden! Why do you think I tried to kill him? In
self-defense! To save all of us! Because you won't see what he's doing to us. He's sabotaged the mission
by making us quarrel, and now he's going to drive us all insane by projecting fear at us so that we can't
sleep or think, like a huge radio that doesn't make any sound, but it broadcasts all the time, and you can't
sleep, and you can't think. Haito and Harfex are already under his control but the rest of you can be
saved. I had to do it!"
    "You didn't do it very well," Osden said, standing half-naked, all rib and bandage, at the door of his
cubicle. "I could have hit myself harder. Hell, it isn't me that's scaring you blind, Porlock, it's out
there—there, in the woods!"
   Porlock made an ineffectual attempt to assault Osden; Asnanifoil held him back, and continued to
hold him effortlessly while Mannon gave him a sedative shot. He was put away shouting about giant
radios. In a minute the sedative took effect, and he joined a peaceful silence to Eskwana's.
   "All right," said Harfex. "Now, Osden, you'll tell us what you know and all you know."
   Osden said, "I don't know anything."
   He looked battered and faint. Tomiko made him sit down before he talked.
   "After I'd been three days in the forest, I thought I was occasionally receiving some kind of affect."
   "Why didn't you report it?"
   "Thought I was going spla, like the rest of you."
   "That, equally, should have been reported."
   "You'd have called me back to base. I couldn't take it. You realize that my inclusion in the mission
was a bad mistake. I'm not able to coexist with nine other neurotic personalities at close quarters. I was
wrong to volunteer for Extreme Survey, and the Authority was wrong to accept me."
    No one spoke; but Tomiko saw, with certainty this time, the flinch in Osden's shoulders and the
tightening of his facial muscles, as he registered their bitter agreement.
    "Anyhow, I didn't want to come back to base because I was curious. Even going psycho, how could
I pick up empathic effects when there was no creature to emit them? They weren't bad, then. Very
vague. Queer. Like a draft in a closed room, a flicker in the corner of your eye. Nothing really."
    For a moment he had been borne up on their listening: they heard, so he spoke. He was wholly at
their mercy. If they disliked him he had to be hateful; if they mocked him he became grotesque; if they
listened to him he was the storyteller. He was helplessly obedient to the demands of their emotions,
reactions, moods. And there were seven of them, too many to cope with, so that he must be constantly
knocked about from one to another's whim. He could not find coherence. Even as he spoke and held
them, somebody's attention would wander. Olleroo perhaps was thinking that he wasn't unattractive,
Harfex was seeking the ulterior motive of his words, Asnanifoil's's mind, which could not be long held by
the concrete, was roaming off towards the eternal peace of number, and Tomiko was distracted by pity,
by fear. Osden's voice faltered. He lost the thread. "I … I thought it must be the trees," he said, and
stopped.
   "It's not the trees," Harfex said. "They have no more nervous system than do plants of the Hainish
Descent on Earth. None."
    "You're not seeing the forest for the trees, as they say on Earth," Mannon put in, smiling elfinly; Harfex
stared at him. "What about those root-nodes we've been puzzling about for twenty days—eh?"
   "What about them?"
   "They are, indubitably, connections. Connections among the trees. Right? Now let's just suppose,
most improbably, that you knew nothing of animal brain-structure. And you were given one axon, or one
detached glial cell, to examine. Would you be likely to discover what it was? Would you see that the cell
was capable of sentience?"
   "No. Because it isn't. A single cell is capable of mechanical response to stimulus. No more. Are you
hypothesizing that individual arboriformes are 'cells' in a kind of brain, Mannon?"
    "Not exactly. I'm merely pointing out that they are all interconnected, both by the root-node linkage
and by your green epiphytes in the branches. A linkage of incredible complexity and physical extent.
Why, even the prairie grass-forms have those root-connectors, don't they? I know that sentience or
intelligence isn't a thing, you can't find it in, or analyze it out from, the cells of a brain. It's a function of the
connected cells. It is, in a sense, the connection: the connectedness. It doesn't exist. I'm not trying to say
it exists. I'm only guessing that Osden might be able to describe it."
    And Osden took him up, speaking as if in trance. "Sentience without senses. Blind, deaf, nerveless,
moveless. Some irritability, response to touch. Response to sun, to light, to water, and chemicals in the
earth around the roots. Nothing comprehensible to an animal mind. Presence without mind. Awareness of
being, without object or subject. Nirvana."
   "Then why do you receive fear?" Tomiko asked in a low voice.
    "I don't know. I can't see how awareness of objects, of others, could arise: an unperceiving
response … But there was an uneasiness, for days. And then when I lay between the two trees and my
blood was on their roots—" Osden's face glittered with sweat. "It became fear," he said shrilly, "only
fear."
   "If such a function existed," Harfex said, "it would not be capable of conceiving of a self-moving,
material entity, or responding to one. It could no more become aware of us than we can 'become aware'
of Infinity."
   "'The silence of those infinite expanses terrifies me,'" muttered Tomiko. "Pascal was aware of Infinity.
By way of fear."
    "To a forest," Mannon said, "we might appear as forest fires. Hurricanes. Dangers. What moves
quickly is dangerous, to a plant. The rootless would be alien, terrible. And if it is mind, it seems only too
probable that it might become aware of Osden, whose own mind is open to connection with all others so
long as he's conscious, and who was lying in pain and afraid within it, actually inside it. No wonder it was
afraid—"
   "Not 'it,'" Harfex said. "There is no being, no huge creature, no person! There could at most be only a
function—"
   "There is only a fear," Osden said.
   They were all still a while, and heard the stillness outside.
   "Is that what I feel all the time coming up behind me?" Jenny Chong asked, subdued.
   Osden nodded. "You all feel it, deaf as you are. Eskwana's the worst off, because he actually has
some empathic capacity. He could send if he learned how, but he's too weak, never will be anything but
a medium."
    "Listen, Osden," Tomiko said, "you can send. Then send to it—the forest, the fear out there—tell it
that we won't hurt it. Since it has, or is, some sort of affect that translates into what we feel as emotion,
can't you translate back? Send out a message, We are harmless, we are friendly."
    "You must know that nobody can emit a false empathic message, Haito. You can't send something
that doesn't exist."
   "But we don't intend harm, we are friendly."
   "Are we? In the forest, when you picked me up, did you feel friendly?"
   "No. Terrified. But that's—it, the forest, the plants, not my own fear, isn't it?"
    "What's the difference? It's all you felt. Can't you see," and Osden's voice rose in exasperation, "why
I dislike you and you dislike me, all of you? Can't you see that I retransmit every negative or aggressive
affect you've felt towards me since we first met? I return your hostility, with thanks. I do it in self-defense.
Like Porlock. It is self-defense, though; it's the only technique I developed to replace my original defense
of total withdrawal from others. Unfortunately it creates a closed circuit, self-sustaining and
self-reinforcing. Your initial reaction to me was the instinctive antipathy to a cripple; by now of course it's
hatred. Can you fail to see my point? The forest mind out there transmits only terror, now, and the only
message I can send it is terror, because when exposed to it I can feel nothing except terror!"
    "What must we do, then?" said Tomiko, and Mannon replied promptly, "Move camp. To another
continent If there are plant-minds there, they'll be slow to notice us, as this one was; maybe they won't
notice us at all."
    "It would be a considerable relief," Osden observed stiffly. The others had been watching him with a
new curiosity. He had revealed himself, they had seen him as he was, a helpless man in a trap. Perhaps,
like Tomiko, they had seen that the trap itself, his crass and cruel egotism, was their own construction,
not his. They had built the cage and locked him in it, and like a caged ape he threw filth out through the
bars. If, meeting him, they had offered trust, if they had been strong enough to offer him love, how might
he have appeared to them?
   None of them could have done so, and it was too late now. Given time, given solitude, Tomiko might
have built up with him a slow resonance of feeling a consonance of trust, a harmony; but there was no
time, their job must be done. There was not room enough for the cultivation of so great a thing, and they
must make do with sympathy, with pity, the small change of love. Even that much had given her strength,
but it was nowhere near enough for him. She could see in his flayed face now his savage resentment of
their curiosity, even of her pity.
   "Go lie down, that gash is bleeding again," she said, and he obeyed her.
    Next morning they packed up, melted down the spray-form hangar and living quarters, lifted Gum on
mechanical drive and took her halfway round World 4470, over the red and green lands, the many warm
green seas. They had picked out a likely spot on continent G: a prairie, twenty thousand square kilos of
windswept graminiformes. No forest was within a hundred kilos of the site, and there were no lone trees
or groves on the plain. The plant-forms occurred only in large species-colonies, never intermingled,
except for certain tiny ubiquitous saprophytes and spore-bearers. The team sprayed holomeld over
structure forms, and by evening of the thirty-two-hour day were settled in to the new camp. Eskwana
was still asleep and Porlock still sedated, but everyone else was cheerful. "You can breathe here!" they
kept saying.
    Osden got on his feet and went shakily to the doorway; leaning there he looked through twilight over
the dim reaches of the swaying grass that was not grass. There was a faint, sweet odor of pollen on the
wind; no sound but the soft, vast sibilance of wind. His bandaged head cocked a little, the empath stood
motionless for a long time. Darkness came, and the stars, lights in the windows of the distant house of
Man. The wind had ceased, there was no sound. He listened.
    In the long night Haito Tomiko listened. She lay still and heard the blood in her arteries, the breathing
of sleepers, the wind blowing, the dark veins running the dreams advancing the vast static of stars
increasing as the universe died slowly, the sound of death walking. She struggled out of her bed, fled the
tiny solitude of her cubicle. Eskwana alone slept. Porlock lay straitjacketed, raving softly in his obscure
native tongue. Olleroo and Jenny Chong were playing cards, grim-faced. Poswet To was in the therapy
niche, plugged in. Asnanifoil was drawing a mandala, the Third Pattern of the Primes. Mannon and
Harfex were sitting up with Osden.
     She changed the bandages on Osden's head. His lank, reddish hair, where she had not had to shave
it, looked strange. It was salted with white, now. Her hands shook as she worked. Nobody had yet said
anything.
   "How can the fear be here too?" she said, and her voice rang flat and false in the terrific silence.
   "It's not just the trees; the grasses … "
   "But we're twelve thousand kilos from where we were this morning we left it on the other side of the
planet."
    "It's all one," Osden said. "One big green thought. How long does it take a thought to get from one
side of your brain to the other?"
    "It doesn't think. It isn't thinking," Harfex said, lifelessly. "It's merely a network of processes. The
branches, the epiphytic growths, the roots with those nodal junctures between individuals: they must all
be capable of transmitting electrochemical impulses. There are no individual plants, then, properly
speaking. Even the pollen is part of the linkage, no doubt, a sort of windbome sentience, connecting
overseas. But it is not conceivable. That all the biosphere of a planet should be one network of
communications, sensitive, irrational, immortal, isolated … "
   "Isolated," said Osden. "That's it! That's the fear. It isn't that we're motile, or destructive. It's just that
we are. We are other. There has never been any other."
   "You're right," Mannon said, almost whispering "It has no peers. No enemies. No relationship with
anything but itself. One alone forever."
   "Then what's the function of its intelligence in species-survival?"
   "None, maybe," Osden said. "Why are you getting teleological, Harfex? Aren't you a Hainishman?
Isn't the measure of complexity the measure of the eternal joy?"
   Harfex did not take the bait. He looked ill. "We should leave this world," he said.
    "Now you know why I always want to get out, get away from you," Osden said with a kind of
morbid geniality. "It isn't pleasant, is it—the other's fear … ? If only it were an animal intelligence. I can
get through to animals. I get along with cobras and tigers; superior intelligence gives one the advantage. I
should have been used in a zoo, not on a human team … If I could get through to the damned stupid
potato! If it wasn't so overwhelming … I still pick up more than the fear, you know. And before it
panicked it had a—there was a serenity. I couldn't take it in, then, I didn't realize how big it was. To
know the whole daylight, after all, and the whole night. All the winds and lulls together. The winter stars
and the summer stars at the same time. To have roots, and no enemies. To be entire. Do you see? No
invasion. No others. To be whole … "
   He had never spoken before, Tomiko thought.
   "You are defenseless against it, Osden," she said. "Your personality has changed already. You're
vulnerable to it. We may not all go mad, but you will, if we don't leave."
   He hesitated, then he looked up at Tomiko, the first time he had ever met her eyes, a long still look,
clear as water.
   "What's sanity ever done for me?" he said, mocking "But you have a point, Haito. You have
something there."
   "We should get away," Harfex muttered.
   "If I gave in to it," Osden mused, "could I communicate?"
   "By 'give in,'" Mannon said in a rapid, nervous voice, "I assume that you mean, stop sending back the
empathic information which you receive from the plant-entity: stop rejecting the fear, and absorb it. That
will either kill you at once, or drive you back into total psychological withdrawal, autism."
   "Why?" said Osden. "Its message is rejection. But my salvation is rejection. It's not intelligent. But I
am."
   "The scale is wrong. What can a single human brain achieve against something so vast?"
    "A single human brain can perceive pattern on the scale of stars and galaxies," Tomiko said, "and
interpret it as Love."
   Mannon looked from one to the other of them; Harfex was silent.
   "It'd be easier in the forest," Osden said. "Which of you will fly me over?"
   "When?"
   "Now. Before you all crack up or go violent."
   "I will," Tomiko said.
   "None of us will," Harfex said.
   "I can't," Mannon said. "I … I am too frightened. I'd crash the jet."
   "Bring Eskwana along. If I can pull this off, he might serve as a medium."
   "Are you accepting the Sensor's plan, Coordinator?" Harfex asked formally.
   "Yes."
   "I disapprove. I will come with you, however."
    "I think we're compelled, Harfex," Tomiko said, looking at Osden's face, the ugly white mask
transfigured, eager as a lover's face.
   Olleroo and Jenny Chong playing cards to keep their thoughts from their haunted beds, their mounting
dread, chattered like scared children. "This thing it's in the forest, it'll get you—"
   "Scared of the dark?" Osden jeered.
   "But look at Eskwana, and Porlock, and even Asnanifoil—"
    "It can't hurt you. It's an impulse passing through synapses, a wind passing through branches. It is only
a nightmare."
    They took off in a helijet, Eskwana curled up still sound asleep in the rear compartment, Tomiko
piloting Harfex and Osden silent, watching ahead for the dark line of the forest across the vague grey
miles of starlit plain. They neared the black line, crossed it; now under them was darkness.
    She sought a landing place, flying low, though she had to fight her frantic wish to fly high, to get out,
get away. The huge vitality of the plant-world was far stronger here in the forest and its panic beat in
immense dark waves. There was a pale patch ahead, a bare knoll-top a little higher than the tallest of the
black shapes around it; the not-trees; the rooted; the parts of the whole. She set the helijet down in the
glade, a bad landing. Her hands on the stick were slippery, as if she had rubbed them with cold soap.
   About them now stood the forest, black in darkness.
   Tomiko cowered and shut her eyes. Eskwana moaned in his sleep. Harfex's breath came short and
loud, and he sat rigid, even when Osden reached across him and slid the door open.
   Osden stood up; his back and bandaged head were just visible in the dim glow of the control panel as
he paused stooping in the doorway.
  Tomiko was shaking. She could not raise her head. "No, no, no, no, no, no, no," she said in a
whisper. "No. No. No."
   Osden moved suddenly and quietly, swinging out of the doorway, down into the dark. He was gone.
   I am coming! said a great voice that made no sound.
   Tomiko screamed. Harfex coughed; he seemed to be trying to stand up, but did not do so.
   Tomiko drew in upon herself, all centered in the blind eye in her belly, in the center of her being; and
outside that there was nothing but the fear.
   It ceased.
   She raised her head; slowly unclenched her hands. She sat up straight The night was dark, and stars
shone over the forest There was nothing else.
   "Osden," she said, but her voice would not come. She spoke again, louder, a lone bullfrog croak.
There was no reply.
    She began to realize that something had gone wrong with Harfex. She was trying to find his head in
the darkness, for he had slipped down from the seat, when all at once, in the dead quiet, in the dark rear
compartment of the craft, a voice spoke. "Good," it said. It was Eskwana's voice. She snapped on the
interior lights and saw the engineer lying curled up asleep, his hand half over his mouth.
   The mouth opened and spoke. "All well," it said.
   "Osden—"
   "All well," said the voice from Eskwana's mouth.
   "Where are you?"
   Silence.
   "Comeback."
   A wind was rising. "I'll stay here," the soft voice said.
   "You can't stay—"
   Silence.
   "You'd be alone, Osden!"
   "Listen." The voice was fainter, slurred, as if lost in the sound of wind. "Listen. I will you well."
   She called his name after that, but there was no answer. Eskwana lay still. Harfex lay stiller.
    "Osden!" she cried, leaning out the doorway into the dark, wind-shaken silence of the forest of being.
"I will come back. I must get Harfex to the base. I will come back, Osden!"
   Silence and wind in leaves.
    They finished the prescribed survey of World 4470, the eight of them; it took them forty-one days
more. Asnanifoil and one or another of the women went into the forest daily at first, searching for Osden
in the region around the bare knoll, though Tomiko was not in her heart sure which bare knoll they had
landed on that night in the very heart and vortex of terror. They left piles of supplies for Osden, food
enough for fifty years, clothing tents, tools. They did not go on searching there was no way to find a man
alone, hiding if he wanted to hide, in those unending labyrinths and dim corridors vine-entangled,
root-floored. They might have passed within arm's reach of him and never seen him.
    But he was there; for there was no fear any more. Rational, and valuing reason more highly after an
intolerable experience of the immortal mindless, Tomiko tried to understand rationally what Osden had
done. But the words escaped her control. He had taken the fear into himself, and, accepting had
transcended it He had given up his self to the alien, an unreserved surrender, that left no place for evil. He
had learned the love of the Other, and thereby had been given his whole self.—But this is not the
vocabulary of reason.
   The people of the Survey team walked under the trees, through the vast colonies of life, surrounded
by a dreaming silence, a brooding calm that was half aware of them and wholly indifferent to them. There
were no hours. Distance was no matter. Had we but world enough and time … The planet turned
between the sunlight and the great dark; winds of winter and summer blew fine, pale pollen across the
quiet seas.
    Gum returned after many surveys, years, and lightyears, to what had several centuries ago been
Smeming Port. There were still men there, to receive (incredulously) the team's reports, and to record its
losses: Biologist Harfex, dead of fear, and Sensor Osden, left as a colonist.


Scan Notes:
"Vaster Than Empires and More Slow" ©1971 by Ursula K. Le Guin; first appeared in New
Directions 1 , edited by Robert Silverberg.
[13 feb 2007—From Buffalo Gals and Other Animal Presences]
[30 jan 2008—proofed by ECS (Escaped Chicken Spirits]