Chrestomanci - Charmed Life  by Diana Wynne Jones


There are thousands of worlds, all different from ours. Chrestomanci's world is 
the one next door to us, and the difference here is that magic is as common as 
music is with us. It is full of people working magic—warlocks, witches, 
thaumaturges, sorcerers, fakirs, conjurors, hexers, magicians, mages, shamans, 
diviners and many more—from the lowest Certified witch right up to the most 
powerful of enchanters. Enchanters are strange as well as powerful. Their magic 
is different and stronger and many of them have more than one life. Now, if 
someone did not control all these busy magic-users, ordinary people would have a 
horrible time and probably end up as slaves. So the government appoints the very 
strongest enchanter there is to make sure no one misuses magic. This enchanter 
has nine lives and is known as "the Chrestomanci. " You pronounce it 
KREST-OH-MAN-SEE. He has to have a strong personality as well as strong magic. 
Diana Wynne Jones



Charmed Life



1
Cat Chant admired his elder sister Gwendolen. She was a witch. He admired her 
and he clung to her. Great changes came about in their lives and left him no one 
else to cling to. 
The first great change came about when their parents took them out for a day 
trip down the river in a paddle steamer. They set out in great style, Gwendolen 
and her mother in white dresses with ribbons, Cat and his father in prickly 
blue-serge Sunday suits. It was a hot day. The steamer was crammed with other 
people in holiday clothes, talking, laughing, eating whelks with thin slices of 
white bread and butter, while the paddleboat steam organ wheezed out popular 
tunes so that no one could hear themselves talk. 
In fact the steamer was too crowded and too old. Something went wrong with the 
steering. The whole laughing, whelk-eating, Sunday-dressed crowd was swept away 
in the current from the dam. They hit one of the posts which were supposed to 
stop people being swept away, and the paddle steamer, being old, simply broke 
into pieces. Cat remembered the organ playing and the paddles beating the blue 
sky. Clouds of steam screamed from broken pipes and drowned the screams from the 
crowd, as every single person aboard was swept away through the dam. It was a 
terrible accident. The papers called it the Saucy Nancy Disaster. The ladies in 
their clinging skirts were quite unable to swim. The men in tight blue serge 
were very little better off. But Gwendolen was a witch, so she could not drown. 
And Cat, who flung his arms around Gwendolen when the boat hit the post, 
survived too. There were very few other survivors. 
The whole country was shocked by it. The paddleboat company and the town of 
Wolvercote between them paid for the funerals. Gwendolen and Cat were given 
heavy black clothes at public expense, and rode behind the procession of hearses 
in a carriage pulled by black horses with black plumes on their heads. The other 
survivors rode with them. Cat looked at them and wondered if they were witches 
and warlocks, but he never found out. The Mayor of Wolvercote had set up a Fund 
for the survivors. Money poured in from all over the country. All the other 
survivors took their share and went away to start new lives elsewhere. Only Cat 
and Gwendolen were left and, since nobody could discover any of their relations, 
they stayed in Wolvercote. 
They became celebrities for a time. Everyone was very kind. Everyone said what 
beautiful little orphans they were. It was true. They were both fair and pale, 
with blue eyes, and looked good in black. Gwendolen was very pretty, and tall 
for her age. Cat was small for his age. Gwendolen was very motherly to Cat, and 
people were touched. Cat did not mind. It made up a little for the empty, lost 
way he was feeling. Ladies gave him cake and toys. Town Councillors came and 
asked how he was getting on; and the Mayor called and patted him on the head. 
The Mayor explained that the money from the Fund was being put into a Trust for 
them until they were grown up. Meanwhile, the town would pay for their education 
and upbringing. 
"And where would you little people like to live?" he asked kindly. 
Gwendolen at once said that old Mrs. Sharp downstairs had offered to take them 
in. "She's been ever so kind to us," she explained. "We'd love to live with 
her." 
Mrs. Sharp had been very kind. She was a witch too—the printed sign in her 
parlor window said Certified Witch—and interested in Gwendolen. The Mayor was a 
little dubious. Like all people who had no talent for witchcraft, he did not 
approve of those who had. He asked Cat how he felt about Gwendolen's plan. Cat 
did not mind. He preferred living in the house he was used to, even if it was 
downstairs. Since the Mayor felt that the two orphans ought to be made as happy 
as possible, he agreed. Gwendolen and Cat moved in with Mrs. Sharp. 
Looking back on it, Cat supposed that it was from this time on that he was 
certain Gwendolen was a witch. He had not been sure before. When he had asked 
his parents, they had shaken their heads, sighed, and looked unhappy. Cat had 
been puzzled, because he remembered the terrible trouble there had been when 
Gwendolen gave him cramps. He could not see how his parents could blame 
Gwendolen for it unless she truly was a witch. But all that was changed now. 
Mrs. Sharp made no secret of it. 
"You've a real talent for magic, dearie," she said, beaming at Gwendolen, "and I 
wouldn't be doing my duty by you if I let it go to waste. We must see about a 
teacher for you right away. You could do worse than go to Mr. Nostrum next door 
for a start. He may be the worst necromancer in town, but he knows how to teach. 
He'll give you a good grounding, my love." 
Mr. Nostrum's charges for teaching magic turned out to be £1 an hour for the 
Elementary Grades, and a guinea an hour for the Advanced Grades beyond. Rather 
expensive, as Mrs. Sharp said. She put on her best hat with black beads and ran 
around to the Town Hall to see if the Fund would pay for Gwendolen's lessons. 
To her annoyance, the Mayor refused. He told Mrs. Sharp that witchcraft was not 
part of an ordinary education. Mrs. Sharp came back rattling the beads on her 
hat with irritation, and carrying a flat cardboard box the Mayor had given her, 
full of the odds and ends the kind ladies had cleared out of Gwendolen's 
parents' bedroom. 
"Blind prejudice!" Mrs. Sharp said, dumping the box on the kitchen table. "If a 
person has a gift, they have a right to have it developed—and so I told him! But 
don't worry, dearie," she said, seeing that Gwendolen was looking decidedly 
stormy. "There's a way around everything. Mr. Nostrum would teach you for 
nothing, if we found the right thing to tempt him with. Let's have a look in 
this box. Your poor ma and pa may have left something that might be just the 
thing." 
Accordingly, Mrs. Sharp turned the box out onto the table. It was a queer 
collection of things— letters and lace and souvenirs. Cat did not remember 
having seen half of them before. There was a marriage certificate, saying that 
Francis John Chant had married Caroline Mary Chant twelve years ago at St. 
Margaret's Church, Wolvercote, and a withered nosegay his mother must have 
carried at the wedding. Underneath that, he found some glittery earrings he had 
never seen his mother wear. 
Mrs. Sharp's hat rattled as she bent swiftly over these. "Those are diamond 
earrings!" she said. "Your ma must have had money! Now, if I took those to Mr. 
Nostrum—But we'd get more for them if I took them around to Mr. Larkins." Mr. 
Larkins kept the junk shop on the corner of the street—except that it was not 
always exactly junk. Among the brass fenders and chipped crockery you could find 
quite valuable things, and also a discreet notice saying Exotic Supplies—which 
meant that Mr. Larkins also stocked bats' wings, dried newts, and other 
ingredients of magic. There was no question that Mr. Larkins would be very 
interested in a pair of diamond earrings. Mrs. Sharp's eyes pouched up, greedy 
and beady, as she put out her hand to pick up the earrings. 
Gwendolen put out her hand for them at the same moment. She did not say 
anything. Neither did Mrs. Sharp. Both their hands stood still in the air. There 
was a feeling of fierce invisible struggle. Then Mrs. Sharp took her hand away. 
"Thank you," Gwendolen said coldly, and put the earrings away in the pocket of 
her black dress. 
"You see what I mean?" Mrs. Sharp said, making the best of it. "You have real 
talent, dearie!" She went back to sorting the other things in the box. She 
turned over an old pipe, ribbons, a spray of white heather, menus, concert 
tickets, and picked up a bundle of old letters. She ran her thumb down the edge 
of it. "Love letters," she said. "His to her." She put the bundle down without 
looking at it and picked up another. "Hers to him. No use." Cat, watching Mrs. 
Sharp's broad mauve thumb whirring down a third bundle of letters, thought that 
being a witch must save a great deal of time. "Business letters," said Mrs. 
Sharp. Her thumb paused, and went slowly back up the pile again. "Now what have 
we here?" she said. She untied the pink tape from around the bundle and 
carefully took out three letters. She unfolded them. 
"Chrestomanci!" she exclaimed. And, as soon as she said it, she clapped one hand 
over her mouth and mumbled behind it. Her face was red. Cat could see she was 
surprised, frightened, and greedy, all at the same time. "Now what was he doing 
writing to your pa?" she said, as soon as she had recovered. 
"Let's see," said Gwendolen. 
Mrs. Sharp spread the three letters out on the kitchen table, and Gwendolen and 
Cat bent over them. The first thing that struck Cat was the energy of the 
signature on all three: 
 
The next thing he saw was that two of the letters were written in the same 
energetic writing as the signature. The first was dated twelve years ago, soon 
after his parents had been married. It said: 
Dear Frank, 
Now don't get on your high horse. I only offered because I thought it might 
help. I still will help, in any way I can, if you let me know what I can do. I 
feel you have a claim on me. 
Yrs ever, Chrestomanci 
The second letter was shorter: 
Dear Chant, 
The same to you. Go to blazes. 
Chrestomanci 
The third letter was dated six years ago, and it was written by someone else. 
Chrestomanci had only signed it. 
Sir, 
You were warned six years ago that something like what you relate might come to 
pass, and you made it quite clear that you wished for no help from this quarter. 
We are not interested in your troubles. Nor is this a charitable institution. 
Chrestomanci 
"What did your pa say to him?" Mrs. Sharp wondered, curious and awestruck. 
"Well—what do you think, dearie?" 
Gwendolen held her hands spread out above the letters, rather as if she was 
warming them at a fire. Both her little fingers twitched. "I don't know. They 
feel important—especially the first one and the last one—awfully important." 
"Who's Chrestomanci?" Cat asked. It was a hard name to say. He said it in 
pieces, trying to remember the way Mrs. Sharp had said it: KREST—OH—MAN—SEE. "Is 
that the right way?" 
"Yes, that's right—and never you mind who he is, my love," said Mrs. Sharp. "And 
important's a weak word for it, dearie. I wish I knew what your pa had said. 
Something not many people'd dare say, by the sound of it. And look what he got 
in return! Three genuine signatures! Mr. Nostrum would give his eyes for those, 
dearie. Oh, you're in luck! He'll teach you for those all right! So would any 
necromancer in the country." 
Gleefully, Mrs. Sharp began packing the things away in the box again. "What have 
we here?" A little red book of matches had fallen out of the bundle of business 
letters. Mrs. Sharp took it up carefully and, quite as carefully, opened it. It 
was less than half full of flimsy cardboard matches. But three of the matches 
had been burned, without being torn out of the book first. The third one along 
was so very burned that Cat supposed it must have set light to the other two. 
"Hm," said Mrs. Sharp. "I think you'd better keep this, dearie." She passed the 
little red book to Gwendolen, who put it in the pocket of her dress along with 
the earrings. "And what about you having this, my love?" Mrs. Sharp said to Cat, 
remembering that he had a claim too. She gave him the spray of white heather. 
Cat wore it in his buttonhole until it fell to pieces.



Living with Mrs. Sharp, Gwendolen seemed to expand. Her hair seemed brighter 
gold, her eyes deeper blue, and her whole manner was glad and confident. Perhaps 
Cat contracted a little to make room for her—he did not know. Not that he was 
unhappy. Mrs. Sharp was quite as kind to him as she was to Gwendolen. Town 
Councillors and their wives called several times a week and patted him on the 
head in the parlor. They sent him and Gwendolen to the best school in 
Wolvercote. Cat was happy there. The only drawback was that Cat was left-handed, 
and schoolmasters always punished him if they caught him writing with his left 
hand. But they did that at all the schools Cat had been to, and he was used to 
it. He had dozens of friends. All the same, at the heart of everything, he felt 
lost and lonely. So he clung to Gwendolen, because she was the only family he 
had. 
Gwendolen was often rather impatient with him, though usually she was too busy 
and happy to be downright cross. "Just leave me alone, Cat," she would say. "Or 
else." Then she would pack exercise books into a music case and hasten next door 
for a lesson with Mr. Nostrum. 
Mr. Nostrum was delighted to teach Gwendolen for the letters. Mrs. Sharp gave 
him one every term for a year, starting with the last. "Not all at once, in case 
he gets greedy," she said. "And we'll give him the best last." 
Gwendolen made excellent progress. Such a promising witch was she, indeed, that 
she skipped the First Grade Magic exam and went straight on to the Second. She 
took the Third and Fourth grades together just after Christmas and, by the 
following summer, she was starting on Advanced Magic. Mr. Nostrum regarded her 
as his favorite pupil—he told Mrs. Sharp so over the wall—and Gwendolen always 
came back from her lessons with him pleased and golden and glowing. She went to 
Mr. Nostrum two evenings a week, with her magic case under her arm, just as many 
people might go to music lessons. In fact, music lessons were what Mrs. Sharp 
put Gwendolen down as having, on the accounts she kept for the Town Council. 
Since Mr. Nostrum never got paid, except by the letters, Cat thought this was 
rather dishonest of Mrs. Sharp. 
"I have to put something by for my old age," Mrs. Sharp told him crossly. "I 
don't get much for myself out of keeping you, do I? And I can't trust your 
sister to remember me when she's grown-up and famous. Oh dear me no—I've no 
illusions about that!" 
Cat knew Mrs. Sharp was probably right. He was a little sorry for her, for she 
had certainly been kind, and he knew by now that she was not a very good witch 
herself. The Certified Witch which the notice in Mrs. Sharp's parlor window 
claimed her to be was, in fact, the very lowest qualification. People only came 
to Mrs. Sharp for charms when they could not afford the three Accredited Witches 
farther down the street. Mrs. Sharp eked out her earnings by acting as an agent 
for Mr. Larkins at the junk shop. She got him Exotic Supplies—that is to say, 
the stranger ingredients needed for spells— from as far away as London. She was 
very proud of her contacts in London. "Oh yes," she often said to Gwendolen, 
"I've got the contacts, I have. I know those that can get me a pound of dragons' 
blood any time I ask, for all it's illegal. While you have me, you'll never be 
in need." 
Perhaps, in spite of having no illusions about Gwendolen, Mrs. Sharp was really 
hoping to become Gwendolen's manager when Gwendolen grew up. Cat suspected she 
was, anyway. And he was sorry for Mrs. Sharp. He was sure that Gwendolen would 
cast her off like an old coat when she became famous—like Mrs. Sharp, Cat had no 
doubt that Gwendolen would be famous. So he said, "There's me to look after you, 
though." He did not fancy the idea, but he felt he ought to say it. 
Mrs. Sharp was warmly grateful. As a reward, she arranged for Cat to have real 
music lessons. "Then that Mayor will have nothing to complain of," she said. She 
believed in killing two birds with one stone. 
Cat started to learn the violin. He thought he was making good progress. He 
practiced diligently. He never could understand why the new people living 
upstairs always banged on the floor when he started to play. Mrs. Sharp, being 
tone-deaf herself, nodded and smiled while he played, and encouraged him 
greatly. 
He was practicing away one evening when Gwendolen stormed in and shrieked a 
spell in his face. Cat found, to his dismay, that he was holding a large striped 
cat by the tail. He had its head tucked under his chin, and he was sawing at its 
back with the violin bow. He dropped it hurriedly. Even so, it bit him under the 
chin and scratched him painfully. 
"What did you do that for?" he said. The cat stood in an arch, glaring at him. 
"Because that's just what it sounded like!" said Gwendolen. "I couldn't stand it 
a moment longer. Here, pussy, pussy!" The cat did not like Gwendolen either. It 
scratched the hand she held out to it. Gwendolen smacked it. It ran away, with 
Cat in hot pursuit, shouting, "Stop it! That's my fiddle! Stop it!" But the cat 
escaped, and that was the end of the violin lessons. 
Mrs. Sharp was very impressed with this display of talent from Gwendolen. She 
climbed on a chair in the yard and told Mr. Nostrum about it over the wall. From 
there, the story spread to every witch and necromancer in the neighborhood. 
That neighborhood was full of witches. People in the same trade like to cluster 
together. If Cat came out of Mrs. Sharp's front door and turned right down Coven 
Street, he passed, besides the three Accredited Witches, two Necromancy 
Offereds, a Soothsayer, a Diviner, and a Willing Warlock. If he turned left, he 
passed Mr. Henry Nostrum A.R.C.M. Tuition in Necromancy, a Fortune-Teller, a 
Sorcery For All Occasions, a Clairvoyant, and lastly Mr. Larkins' shop. The air 
in the street, and for several streets around, was heavy with the scent of magic 
being done. 
All these people took a great and friendly interest in Gwendolen. The story of 
the cat impressed them enormously. They made a great pet of the 
creature—naturally, it was called Fiddle. Though it remained bad-tempered, 
captious, and unfriendly, it never went short of food. They made an even greater 
pet of Gwendolen. Mr. Larkins gave her presents. The Willing Warlock, who was a 
muscular young man always in need of a shave, popped out of his house whenever 
he saw Gwendolen passing and presented her with a bull's-eye. The various 
witches were always looking out simple spells for her. 
Gwendolen was very scornful of these spells. "Do they think I'm a baby or 
something? I'm miles beyond this stuff!" she would say, casting the latest spell 
aside. 
Mrs. Sharp, who was glad of any aid to witchcraft, usually gathered the spell up 
carefully and hid it. But once or twice, Cat found the odd spell lying about. 
Then he could not resist trying it. He would have liked to have had just a 
little of Gwendolen's talent. He always hoped that he was a late developer and 
that, someday, a spell would work for him. But they never did—not even the one 
for turning brass buttons to gold, which Cat particularly fancied. 
The various fortune-tellers gave Gwendolen presents too. She got an old crystal 
ball from the Diviner and a pack of cards from the Soothsayer. The 
Fortune-Teller told her fortune for her. Gwendolen came in golden and exultant 
from that. 
"I'm going to be famous! He said I could rule the world if I go the right way 
about it!" she told Cat. 
Though Cat had no doubt that Gwendolen would be famous, he could not see how she 
could rule the world, and he said so. "You'd only rule one country, even if you 
married the King," he objected. "And the Prince of Wales got married last year." 

"There are more ways of ruling than that, stupid!" Gwendolen retorted? "Mr. 
Nostrum has lots of ideas for me, for a start. Mind you, there are some snags. 
There's a change for the worse that I have to surmount, and a dominant Dark 
Stranger. But when he told me I'd rule the world my fingers all twitched, so I 
know it's true!" There seemed no limit to Gwendolen's glowing confidence. 
The next day, Miss Larkins the Clairvoyant called Cat into her house and offered 
to tell his fortune too. 



2
Cat was alarmed by Miss Larkins. She was the daughter of Mr. Larkins at the junk 
shop. She was young and pretty and fiercely red-headed. She wore the red hair 
piled into a bun on top of her head, from which red tendrils of hair escaped and 
tangled becomingly with earrings like hoops for parrots to sit on. She was a 
very talented clairvoyant and, until the story of the cat became known, Miss 
Larkins had been the pet of the neighborhood. Cat remembered that even his 
mother had given Miss Larkins presents. 
Cat knew Miss Larkins was offering to tell his fortune out of jealousy of 
Gwendolen. "No. No, thank you very much," he said, backing away from Miss 
Larkins' little table spread with objects of divination. "It's quite all right. 
I don't want to know." 
But Miss Larkins advanced on him and seized him by his shoulders. Cat squirmed. 
Miss Larkins used a scent that shrieked VIOLETS! at him, her earrings swung like 
manacles, and her corsets creaked when she was close to. "Silly boy!" Miss 
Larkins said, in her rich, melodious voice. "I'm not going to hurt you. I just 
want to know." 
"But—but I don't," Cat said, twisting this way and that. 
"Hold still," said Miss Larkins, and tried to stare deep into Cat's eyes. 
Cat shut his eyes hastily. He squirmed harder than ever. He might have got 
loose, had not Miss Larkins abruptly gone off into some kind of trance. Cat 
found himself being gripped with a strength that would have surprised him even 
in the Willing Warlock. He opened his eyes to find Miss Larkins staring blankly 
at him. Her body shook, creaking her corsets like old doors swinging in the 
wind. "Oh, please let go!" Cat said. But Miss Larkins did not appear to hear. 
Cat took hold of the fingers gripping his shoulders, and tried to prise them 
loose. He could not move them. After that, he could only stare helplessly at 
Miss Larkins' blank face. 
Miss Larkins opened her mouth, and quite a different voice came out. It was a 
man's voice, brisk and kindly. "You've taken a weight off my mind, lad," it 
said. It sounded pleased. "There'll be a big change coming up for you now. But 
you've been awfully careless—four gone already, and only five left. You must 
take more care. You're in danger from at least two directions, did you know?" 
The voice stopped. By this time, Cat was so frightened that he dared not move. 
He could only wait until Miss Larkins came to herself, yawned, and let go of him 
in order to cover her mouth elegantly with one hand. 
"There," she said, in her usual voice. "That was it. What did I say?" 
Finding Miss Larkins had no idea what she had said brought Cat out in goose 
pimples. All he wanted to do was to run away. He dashed for the door. 
Miss Larkins pursued him, seized his arms again, and shook him. "Tell me! Tell 
me! What did I say?" With the violence of her shaking, her red hair came down in 
sheets. Her corsets sounded like bending planks. She was terrifying. "What voice 
did I use?" she demanded. 
"A—a man's voice," Cat faltered. "Sort of nice, and no nonsense about it." 
Miss Larkins seemed dumbfounded. "A man? Not Bobby or Doddo—not a child's voice, 
I mean?" 
"No," said Cat. 
"How peculiar!" said Miss Larkins. "I never use a man. What did he say?" 
Cat repeated what the voice had said. He thought he would never forget it if he 
lived to ninety. 
It was some consolation to find that Miss Larkins was quite as puzzled by it as 
he was. "Well, I suppose it was a warning," she said dubiously. She also seemed 
disappointed. "And nothing else? Nothing about your sister?" 
"No, nothing," said Cat. 
"Oh well, can't be helped," Miss Larkins said discontentedly, and she let go of 
Cat in order to put her hair up again. 
As soon as both her hands were safely occupied in pinning her bun, Cat ran. He 
shot out into the street, feeling very shaken. 
And he was caught by two more people almost at once. 
"Ah. Here is young Eric Chant now," said Mr. Nostrum, advancing down the 
pavement. "You are acquainted with my brother, William, are you, Young Chant?" 
Cat was once more caught by an arm. He tried to smile. It was not that he 
disliked Mr. Nostrum. It was just that Mr. Nostrum always talked in this jocular 
way and called him Young Chant every few words, which made it very difficult to 
talk to Mr. Nostrum in return. Mr. Nostrum was small and plumpish, with two 
wings of grizzled hair. He had a cast in his left eye too, which always stared 
out sideways. Cat found that added to the difficulty of talking to Mr. Nostrum. 
Was he looking and listening? Or was his mind elsewhere with that wandering eye? 

"Yes—yes, I've met your brother," Cat reminded Mr. Nostrum. Mr. William Nostrum 
came to visit his brother regularly. Cat saw him almost once a month. He was 
quite a well-to-do wizard, with a practice in Eastbourne. Mrs. Sharp claimed 
that Mr. Henry Nostrum sponged on his wealthier brother, both for money and for 
spells that worked. Whatever the truth of that, Cat found Mr. William Nostrum 
even harder to talk to than his brother. He was half as large again as Mr. Henry 
and always wore morning dress with a huge silver watch-chain across his tubby 
waistcoat. Otherwise, he was the image of Mr. Henry Nostrum, except that both 
his eyes were out of true. Cat always wondered how Mr. William saw anything. 
"How do you do, sir," he said to him politely. 
"Very well," said Mr. William in a deep, gloomy voice, as if the opposite was 
true. 
Mr. Henry Nostrum glanced up at him apologetically. "The fact is, Young Chant," 
he explained, "we have met with a little setback. My brother is upset." He 
lowered his voice, and his wandering eye wandered all around Cat's right side. 
"It's about those letters from-—You Know Who. We can find out nothing. It seems 
Gwendolen knows nothing. Do you, Young Chant, perchance know why your esteemed 
and lamented father should be acquainted with—with, let us call him, the August 
Personage who signed them?" 
"I haven't the faintest idea, I'm afraid," said Cat. 
"Could he have been some relation?" suggested Mr. Henry Nostrum. "Chant is a 
Good Name." 
"I think it must be a bad name too," Cat answered. "We haven't any relations." 
"But what of your dear mother?" persisted Mr. Nostrum, his odd eye traveling 
away, while his brother managed to stare gloomily at the pavement and the 
rooftops at once. 
"You can see the poor boy knows nothing, Henry," Mr. William said. "I doubt if 
he would be able to tell us his dear mother's maiden name." 
"Oh, I do know that," said Cat. "It's on their marriage lines. She was called 
Chant too." 
"Odd," said Mr. Nostrum, swirling an eye at his brother. 
"Odd, and peculiarly unhelpful," Mr. William agreed. 
Cat wanted to get away. He felt he had taken enough strange questions to last 
till Christmas. "Well, if you want to know that badly," he said, "why don't you 
write and ask Mr.—er—Mr. Chres—" 
"Hush!" said Mr. Henry Nostrum violently. 
"Hum!" said his brother, almost equally violently. 
"August Personage, I mean," Cat said, looking at Mr. William in alarm. Mr. 
William's eyes had gone right to the sides of his face. Cat was afraid he might 
be going off into a trance, like Miss Larkins. 
"It will serve, Henry, it will serve!" Mr. William cried out. And, with great 
triumph, he lifted the silver watch-chain off his middle and shook it. "Then for 
silver!" he cried. 
"I'm so glad," Cat said politely. "I have to be going now." He ran off down the 
street as fast as he could. When he went out that afternoon, he took care to 
turn right and go out of Coven Street past the Willing Warlock's house. It was 
rather a nuisance, since that was the long way around to where most of his 
friends lived, but anything was better than meeting Miss Larkins or the Nostrums 
again. It was almost enough to make Cat wish that school had started. 
When Cat came home that evening, Gwendolen was just back from her lesson with 
Mr. Nostrum. She had her usual glowing, exulting look, but she was looking 
secretive and important too. 
"That was a good idea of yours of writing to Chrestomanci," she said to Cat. "I 
can't think why I didn't think of it. Anyway, I just have." 
"Why did you do it? Couldn't Mr. Nostrum?" Cat asked. 
"It came more naturally from me," said Gwendolen. "And I suppose it doesn't 
matter if he gets my signature. Mr. Nostrum told me what to write." 
"Why does he want to know anyway?" Cat said. 
"Wouldn't you like to know!" Gwendolen said exultingly. 
"No," said Cat. "I wouldn't." Since this had brought what happened that morning 
into his mind, which still made him almost wish the Autumn term had started, he 
said, "I wish the horse chestnuts were ripe." 
"Horse chestnuts!" Gwendolen said, in the greatest disgust. "What a low mind you 
have! They won't be ready for a good six weeks." 
"I know," said Cat, and for the next two days he carefully turned right every 
time he left the house. 
They were the lovely golden days that happen when August is passing into 
September. Cat and his friends went out along the river. On the second day, they 
found a wall and climbed it. There was an orchard beyond, and here they were 
lucky enough to discover a tree loaded with sweet white apples— the kind that 
ripen early. They filled their pockets and then their hats. Then a furious 
gardener chased them with a rake. They ran. Cat was very happy as he carried his 
full, knobby hat home. Mrs. Sharp loved apples. He just hoped she would not 
reward him by making gingerbread men. As a rule, gingerbread men were fun. They 
leaped up off the plate and ran when you tried to eat them, so that when you 
finally caught them you felt quite justified in eating them. It was a fair 
fight, and some got away. But Mrs. Sharp's gingerbread men never did that. They 
simply lay, feebly waving their arms, and Cat never had the heart to eat them. 
Cat was so busy thinking of all this that, though he noticed a four-wheel cab 
standing in the road as he turned the corner by the Willing Warlock's house, he 
paid no attention to it. He went to the side door and burst into the kitchen 
with his hatful of apples, shouting, "I say! Look what I've got, Mrs. Sharp!" 
Mrs. Sharp was not there. Instead, standing in the middle of the kitchen, was a 
tall and quite extraordinarily well-dressed man. 
Cat stared at him in some dismay. He was clearly a rich new Town Councillor. 
Nobody but those kind of people wore trousers with such pearly stripes, or coats 
of such beautiful velvet, or carried : tall hats as shiny as their boots. The 
man's hair was dark. It was smooth as his hat. Cat had no doubt that this was 
Gwendolen's Dark Stranger, come to help her start ruling the world. And he 
should not have been in the kitchen at all. Visitors were always taken straight 
to the parlor. 
"Oh, how do you do, sir. Will you come this way, sir?" he gasped. 
The Dark Stranger gave him a wondering look. And well he might, Cat thought, 
looking around distractedly. The kitchen was in its usual mess. The range was 
all ash. On the table, Cat saw, to his further dismay, Mrs. Sharp had been 
making gingerbread men. The ingredients for the spell lay on one end of the 
table—all grubby newspaper packets and seedy little jars—and the gingerbread 
itself was strewn over the middle of the table. At the far end, the flies were 
gathering around the meat for lunch, which looked nearly as messy as the spell. 
"Who are you?" said the Dark Stranger. "I have a feeling I should know you. What 
have you got in your hat?" 
Cat was too busy staring around to attend properly, but he caught the last 
question. His pleasure returned. "Apples," he said, showing the Stranger. 
"Lovely sweet ones. I've been scrumping." 
The Stranger looked grave. "Scrumping," he said, "is a form of stealing." 
Cat knew that as well as he did. He thought it was very joyless, even for a Town 
Councillor, to point it out. "I know. But I bet you did it when you were my 
age." 
The Stranger coughed slightly and changed the subject. "You haven't said yet who 
you are." 
"Sorry. Didn't I?" said Cat. "I'm Eric Chant—only they always call me Cat." 
"Then is Gwendolen Chant your sister?" the Stranger asked. He was looking more 
and more austere and pitying. Cat suspected that he thought Mrs. Sharp's kitchen 
was a den of vice. 
"That's right. Won't you come this way?" Cat said, hoping to get the Stranger 
out of it. "It's neater through here." 
"I had a letter from your sister," the Stranger said, standing where he was. 
"She gave me the impression you had drowned with your parents." 
"You must have made a mistake," Cat said distractedly. "I didn't drown because I 
was holding on to Gwendolen, and she's a witch. It's cleaner through here." 
"I see," said the Stranger. "I'm called Chrestomanci, by the way." 
"Oh!" said Cat. This was a real crisis. He put his hat of apples down in the 
middle of the spell, which he very much hoped would ruin it. "Then you've got to 
come in the parlor at once." 
"Why?" said Chrestomanci, sounding rather bewildered. 
"Because," said Cat, thoroughly exasperated, "you're far too important to stay 
here." 
"What makes you think I'm important?" Chrestomanci asked, still bewildered. 
Cat was beginning to want to shake him. "You must be. You're wearing important 
clothes. And Mrs. Sharp said you were. She said Mr. Nostrum would give his eyes 
just for your three letters." 
"Has Mr. Nostrum given his eyes for my letters?" asked Chrestomanci. "It hardly 
seems worth it." 
"No. He just gave Gwendolen lessons for them," said Cat. 
"What? For his eyes? How uncomfortable!" said Chrestomanci. 
Fortunately, there were thumping footsteps just then, and Gwendolen burst in 
through the kitchen door, panting, golden and jubilant. "Mr. Chrestomanci?" 
"Just Chrestomanci," said the Stranger. "Yes. Would you be Gwendolen?" 
"Yes. Mr. Nostrum told me there was a cab here," gasped Gwendolen. 
She was followed by Mrs. Sharp, nearly as breathless. The two of them took over 
the conversation, and Cat was thankful for it. Chrestomanci at last consented to 
be taken to the parlor, where Mrs. Sharp deferentially offered him a cup of tea 
and a plate of her weakly waving gingerbread men. Chrestomanci, Cat was 
interested to see, did not seem to have the heart to eat them either. He drank a 
cup of tea—austerely, without milk or sugar— and asked questions about how 
Gwendolen and Cat came to be living with Mrs. Sharp. Mrs. Sharp tried to give 
the impression that she looked after them for nothing, out of the goodness of 
her heart. She hoped Chrestomanci might be induced to pay her for their keep, as 
well as the Town Council. 
But Gwendolen had decided to be radiantly honest. "The town pays," she said, 
"because everyone's so sorry about the accident." Cat was glad she had 
explained, even though he suspected that Gwendolen might already be casting Mrs. 
Sharp off like an old coat. 
"Then I must go and speak to the Mayor," Chrestomanci said, and he stood up, 
dusting his splendid hat on his elegant sleeve. Mrs. Sharp sighed and sagged. 
She knew what Gwendolen was doing too. "Don't be anxious, Mrs. Sharp," said 
Chrestomanci. "No one wishes you to be out of pocket." Then he shook hands with 
Gwendolen and Cat and said, "I should have come to see you before, of course. 
Forgive me. Your father was so infernally rude to me, you see. I'll see you 
again, I hope." Then he went away in his cab, leaving Mrs. Sharp very sour, 
Gwendolen jubilant, and Cat nervous. 
"Why are you so happy?" Cat asked Gwendolen. 
"Because he was touched at our orphaned state," said Gwendolen. "He's going to 
adopt us. My fortune is made!" 
"Don't talk such nonsense!" snapped Mrs. Sharp. "Your fortune is the same as it 
ever was. He may have come here in all his finery, but he said nothing and he 
promised nothing." 
Gwendolen smiled confidently. "You didn't see the heart-wringing letter I 
wrote." 
"Maybe. But he's not got a heart to wring," Mrs. Sharp retorted. Cat rather 
agreed with Mrs. Sharp—particularly as he had an uneasy feeling that, before 
Gwendolen and Mrs. Sharp arrived, he had somehow managed to offend Chrestomanci 
as badly as his father once did. He hoped Gwendolen would not realize that. He 
knew she would be furious with him. 
But, to his astonishment, Gwendolen proved to be right. The Mayor called that 
afternoon and told them that Chrestomanci had arranged for Cat and Gwendolen to 
come and live with him as part of his own family. "And I see I needn't tell you 
what lucky little people you are," he said, as Gwendolen uttered a shriek of joy 
and hugged the dour Mrs. Sharp. 
Cat felt more nervous than ever. He tugged the Mayor's sleeve. "If you please, 
sir, I don't understand who Chrestomanci is." 
The Mayor patted him kindly on the head. "A very eminent gentleman," he said. 
"You'll be hobnobbing with all the crowned heads of Europe before long, my boy. 
What do you think of that, eh?" 
Cat did not know what to think. This had told him precisely nothing, and made 
him more nervous than ever. He supposed Gwendolen must have written a very 
touching letter indeed. 
So the second great change came about in Cat's life, and very dismal he feared 
it would be. All that next week, while they were hurrying about being bought new 
clothes by Councillors' wives, and while Gwendolen grew more and more excited 
and triumphant, Cat found he was missing Mrs. Sharp, and everyone else, even 
Miss Larkins, as if he had already left them. When the time came for them to get 
on the train, the town gave them a splendid send-off, with flags and a brass 
band. It upset Cat. He sat tensely on the edge of his seat, fearing he was in 
for a time of strangeness and maybe even misery. 
Gwendolen, however, spread out her smart new dress and arranged her nice new hat 
becomingly, and sank elegantly back in her seat. "I did it!" she said joyously. 
"Cat, isn't it marvelous!" 
"No," Cat said miserably. "I'm homesick already. What have you done? Why do you 
keep being so happy?" 
"You wouldn't understand," said Gwendolen. "But I'll tell you part of it. I've 
got out of dead-and-alive Wolvercote at last—stupid Councillors and piffling 
necromancers! And Chrestomanci was bowled over by me. You saw that, didn't you?" 

"I didn't notice specially," said Cat. "I mean, I saw you were being nice to 
him—" 
"Oh, shut up, or I'll give you worse than cramps!" said Gwendolen. And, as the 
train at last chuffed and began to draw out of the station, Gwendolen waved her 
gloved hand to the brass band, up and down, just like Royalty. Cat realized she 
was setting out to rule the world. 



3
The train journey lasted about an hour, before the train puffed into Bowbridge, 
where they were to get out. 
"It's frightfully small," Gwendolen said critically. 
"Bowbridge!" shouted a porter, running along the platform. "Bowbridge. The young 
Chants alight here, please." 
"Young Chants!" Gwendolen said disdainfully. "Can't they treat me with more 
respect?" All the same, the attention pleased her. Cat could see that, as she 
drew on her ladylike gloves, she was shaking with excitement. He cowered behind 
her as they got out and watched their trunks being tossed out onto the windy 
platform. Gwendolen marched up to the shouting porter. "We are the young 
Chants," she told him magnificently. 
It fell a little flat. The porter simply beckoned and scurried away to the 
entrance lobby, which was windier even than the platform. Gwendolen had to hold 
her hat on. Here, a young man strode towards them in a billow of flapping coat. 
"We are the young Chants," Gwendolen told him. 
"Gwendolen and Eric? Pleased to meet you," said the young man. "I'm Michael 
Saunders. I'll be tutoring you with the other children." 
"Other children?" Gwendolen asked him haughtily. But Mr. Saunders was evidently 
one of those people who are not good at standing still. He had already darted 
off to see about their trunks. Gwendolen was a trifle annoyed. But when Mr. 
Saunders came back and led them outside into the station yard, they found a 
motor car waiting—long, black, and sleek. Gwendolen forgot her annoyance. She 
felt this was entirely fitting. 
Cat wished it had been a carriage. The car jerked and thrummed and smelled of 
petrol. He felt sick almost at once. He felt sicker still when they left 
Bowbridge and thrummed along a winding country road. The only advantage he could 
see was that the car went very quickly. After only ten minutes, Mr. Saunders 
said, "Look—there's Chrestomanci Castle now. You get the best view from here." 
Cat turned his sick face and Gwendolen her fresh one the way he pointed. The 
Castle was gray and turreted, on the opposite hill. As the road turned, they saw 
it had a new part, with a spread of big windows, and a flag flying above. They 
could see grand trees—dark, layered cedars and big elms—and glimpse lawns and 
flowers. 
"It looks marvelous," Cat said sickly, rather surprised that Gwendolen had said 
nothing. He hoped the road did not wind too much in getting to the Castle. 
It did not. The car flashed around a village green and between big gates. Then 
there was a long tree-lined avenue, with the great door of the old part of the 
Castle at the end of it. The car scrunched around on the gravel sweep in front 
of it. Gwendolen leaned forward eagerly, ready to be first one out. It was clear 
there would be a butler, and perhaps footmen too. She could hardly wait to make 
her grand entry. 
But the car went on, past the gray, knobbly walls of the old Castle, and stopped 
at an obscure door where the new part began. It was almost a secretive door. 
There was a mass of rhododendron trees hiding it from both parts of the Castle. 
"I'm taking you in this way," Mr. Saunders explained cheerfully, "because it's 
the door you'll be using mostly, and I thought it would help you find your way 
about if you start as you mean to go on." 
Cat did not mind. He thought this door looked more homely. But Gwendolen, 
cheated of her grand entry, threw Mr. Saunders a seething look and wondered 
whether to say a most unpleasant spell at him. She decided against it. She was 
still wanting to give a good impression. They got out of the car and followed 
Mr. Saunders—whose coat had a way of billowing even when there was no wind-—into 
a square polished passageway indoors. A most imposing lady was waiting there to 
meet them. She was wearing a tight purple dress and her hair was in a very tall 
jet-black pile. Cat thought she must be Mrs. Chrestomanci. 
"This is Miss Bessemer, the housekeeper," said Mr. Saunders. "Eric and 
Gwendolen, Miss Bessemer. Eric's a bit carsick, I'm afraid." 
Cat had not realized his trouble was so obvious. He was embarrassed. Gwendolen, 
who was very annoyed to be met by a mere housekeeper, held her hand out coldly 
to Miss Bessemer. 
Miss Bessemer shook hands like an Empress. Cat was just thinking she was the 
most awe-inspiring lady he had ever met when she turned to him with a very kind 
smile. "Poor Eric," she said. "Riding in a car bothers me ever so too. You'll be 
all right now you're out of the thing—but if you're not, I'll give you something 
for it. Come and get washed, and have a look-see at your rooms." 
They followed the narrow purple triangle of her dress up some stairs, along 
corridors, and up more stairs. Cat had never seen anywhere so luxurious. There 
was carpet the whole way—a soft green carpet, like grass in the dewy morning—and 
the floor at the sides was polished so that it reflected the carpet and the 
clean white walls and the pictures hung on the walls. Everywhere was very quiet. 
They heard nothing the whole way, except their own feet and Miss Bessemer's 
purple rustle. 
Miss Bessemer opened a door onto a blaze of afternoon sun. "This is your room, 
Gwendolen. Your bathroom opens off it." 
"Thank you," said Gwendolen, and she sailed magnificently in to take possession 
of it. Cat peeped past Miss Bessemer and saw the room was very big, with a rich, 
soft Turkey carpet covering most of the floor. 
Miss. Bessemer said, "The Family dines early when there are no visitors so that 
they can eat with the children. But I expect you'd like some tea all the same. 
Whose room shall I have it sent to?" 
"Mine, please," Gwendolen said at once. 
There was a short pause before Miss Bessemer said, "Well, that's settled then, 
isn't it? Your room is up here, Eric." 
The way was up a twisting staircase. Cat was pleased. It looked as if his room 
was going to be part of the old castle. And he was right. When Miss Bessemer 
opened the door, the room beyond was round, and the three windows showed that 
the wall was nearly three feet thick. Cat could not resist racing across the 
glowing carpet to scramble on one of the deep window seats and look out. He 
found he could see across the flat tops of the cedars to a great lawn like a 
sheet of green velvet, with flower gardens going down the hillside in steps 
beyond it. Then he looked around the room itself. The curved walls were 
whitewashed, and so was the thick fireplace. The bed had a patchwork quilt on 
it. There was a table, a chest-of-drawers, and a bookcase with 
interesting-looking books in it. 
"Oh, I like this!" he said to Miss Bessemer. 
"I'm afraid your bathroom is down the passage," said Miss Bessemer, as if this 
was a drawback. But, as Cat had never had a private bathroom before, he did not 
mind in the least. 
As soon as Miss Bessemer had gone, he hastened along to have a look at it. To 
his awe, there were three sizes of red towel and a sponge as big as a melon. The 
bath had feet like a lion's. One corner of the room was tiled, and with red 
rubber curtains, for a shower. Cat could not resist experimenting. The bathroom 
was rather wet by the time he had finished. He went back to his room, a little 
damp himself. His trunk and box were there by this time, and a maid with red 
hair was unpacking them. She told Cat her name was Mary and wanted to know if 
she was putting things in the right places. She was perfectly pleasant, but Cat 
was very shy of her. The red hair reminded him of Miss Larkins, and he could not 
think what to say to her. 
"Er—may I go down and have some tea?" he stammered. 
"Please yourself," she said—rather coldly, Cat thought. He ran downstairs again, 
feeling he might have gotten off on the wrong foot with her. 
Gwendolen's trunk was standing in the middle of her room. Gwendolen herself was 
sitting in a very queenly way at a round table by the window, with a big pewter 
teapot in front of her, a plate of brown bread and butter, and a plate of 
biscuits. 
"I told the girl I'd unpack for myself," she said. "I've got secrets in my trunk 
and my box. And I asked her to bring tea at once because I'm starving. And just 
look at it! Did you ever see anything so dull? Not even jam!" 
"Perhaps the biscuits are nice," Cat said hopefully. But they were not, or not 
particularly. 
"We shall starve, in the midst of luxury!" sighed Gwendolen. 
Her room was certainly luxurious. The wallpaper seemed to be made of blue 
velvet. The top and bottom of the bed was upholstered like a chair, in blue 
velvet with buttons in it, and the blue velvet bedspread matched it exactly. The 
chairs were painted gold. There was a dressing table fit for a princess, with 
little golden drawers, gold-backed brushes, and a long oval mirror surrounded by 
a gilded wreath. Gwendolen admitted that she liked the dressing table, though 
she was not so sure about the wardrobe, which had painted garlands and maypole 
dancers on it. 
"It's to hang clothes in, not to look at," she said. "It distracts me. But the 
bathroom is lovely." 
The bathroom was tiled with blue and white tiles, and the bath was sunk down 
into the tiled floor. Over it, draped like a baby's cradle, were blue curtains 
for when you wanted a shower. The towels matched the tiles. Cat preferred his 
own bathroom, but that may have been because he had to spend rather a long time 
in Gwendolen's. Gwendolen locked him in it while she unpacked. Through the hiss 
of the shower—Gwendolen had only herself to blame that she found her bathroom 
thoroughly soaked afterwards—Cat heard her voice raised in annoyance at someone 
who had come in to take the dull tea away and caught her with her trunk open. 
When Gwendolen finally unlocked the bathroom door, she was still angry. 
"I don't think the servants here are very civil," she said. "If that girl says 
one thing more, she'll find herself with a boil on her nose—even if her name is 
Euphemia! Though," Gwendolen added charitably, "I'm inclined to think being 
called Euphemia is punishment enough for anyone. You have to go and get your new 
suit on, Cat. She says dinner's in half an hour and we have to change for it. 
Did you ever hear anything so formal and unnatural!" 
"I thought you were looking forward to that kind of thing," said Cat, who most 
certainly was not. 
"You can be grand and natural," Gwendolen retorted. But the thought of the 
coming grandeur soothed her all the same. "I shall wear my blue dress with the 
lace collar," she said. "And I do think being called Euphemia is a heavy enough 
burden for anyone to bear, however rude they are." 
As Cat went up his winding stair, the Castle filled with a mysterious booming. 
It was the first noise he had heard. It alarmed him. He learned later that it 
was the dressing gong, to warn the Family that they had half an hour to change 
in. Cat, of course, did not take nearly that time to put his suit on. So he had 
yet another shower. He felt damp and weak and almost washed out of existence by 
the time the maid who was so unfortunate in being called Euphemia came to take 
him and Gwendolen downstairs to the drawing room where the Family was waiting. 
Gwendolen, in her pretty blue dress, sailed in confidently. Cat crept behind. 
The room seemed full of people. Cat had no idea how all of them came to be part 
of the Family. There was an old lady in lace mittens, and a small man with large 
eyebrows and a loud voice who was talking about stocks and shares; Mr. Saunders, 
whose wrists and ankles were too long for his shiny black suit; and at least two 
younger ladies; and at least two younger men. Cat saw Chrestomanci, quite 
splendid in very dark red velvet; and Chrestomanci saw Cat and Gwendolen and 
looked at them with a vague, perplexed smile, which made Cat quite sure that 
Chrestomanci had forgotten who they were. 
"Oh," said Chrestomanci. "Er. This is my wife." 
They were ushered in front of a plump lady with a mild face. She had a gorgeous 
lace dress on—Gwendolen's eyes swept up and down it with considerable awe—but 
otherwise she was one of the most ordinary ladies they had ever seen. She gave 
them a friendly smile. "Eric and Gwendolen, isn't it? You must call me Millie, 
my dears." This was a relief, because neither of them had any idea what they 
should have called her. "And now you must meet my Julia and my Roger," she said. 

Two plump children came and stood beside her. They were both rather pale and had 
a tendency to breathe heavily. The girl wore a lace dress like her mother's, and 
the boy had on a blue velvet suit, but no clothes could disguise the fact that 
they were even more ordinary-looking than their mother. They looked politely at 
Gwendolen and at Cat, and all four said, "How do you do?" Then there seemed 
nothing else to say. 
Luckily, they had not stood there long before a butler came and opened the 
double doors at the end of the room, and told them that dinner was served. 
Gwendolen looked at this butler in great indignation. "Why didn't he open the 
door to us?" she whispered to Cat as they all went in a ragged sort of 
procession to the dining room. "Why were we fobbed off with the housekeeper?" 
Cat did not answer. He was too busy clinging to Gwendolen. They were being 
arranged around a long polished table, and if anyone had tried to put Cat in a 
chair that was not next to Gwendolen's, he thought he would have fainted from 
terror. Luckily, no one tried. Even so, the meal was terrifying enough. Footmen 
kept pushing delicious food in silver plates over Cat's left shoulder. Each time 
that happened, it took Cat by surprise, and he jumped and jogged the plate. He 
was supposed to help himself off the silver plate, and he never knew how much he 
was allowed to take. But the worst difficulty was that he was left-handed. The 
spoon and fork that he was supposed to lift the food with from the footman's 
plate to his own were always the wrong way around. He tried changing them over, 
and dropped a spoon. He tried leaving them as they were, and spilled gravy. The 
footman always said, "Not to worry, sir," and made him feel worse than ever. 
The conversation was even more terrifying.; At one end of the table, the small 
loud man talked endlessly of stocks and shares. At Cat's end, they talked about 
Art. Mr. Saunders seemed to have spent the summer traveling abroad. He had seen 
statues and paintings all over Europe and much admired them. He was so eager 
that he slapped the table as he talked. He spoke of Studios and Schools, 
Quattrocento and Dutch Interiors, until Cat's head went around. Cat looked at 
Mr. Saunders' thin, square-cheeked face and marveled at all the knowledge behind 
it. Then Millie and Chrestomanci joined in. Millie recited a string of names Cat 
had never heard in his life before. Chrestomanci made comments on them, as if 
these names were intimate friends of his. Whatever the rest of the Family was 
like, Cat thought, Chrestomanci was not ordinary. He had very black bright eyes, 
which were striking even when he was looking vague and dreamy. When he was 
interested—as he was about Art—the black eyes screwed up in a way that seemed to 
spill the brightness of them over the rest of his face. And, to Cat's dismay, 
the two children were equally interested. They kept up a mild chirp, as if they 
actually knew what their parents were talking about. 
Cat felt crushingly ignorant. What with this talk, and the trouble over the 
suddenly appearing silver plates, and the dull biscuits he had eaten for tea, he 
found he had no appetite at all. He had to leave half his ice-cream pudding. He 
envied Gwendolen for being able to sit so calmly and scornfully, enjoying her 
food. 
It was over at last. They were allowed to escape up to her upholstered bed with 
a bounce. 
"What a childish trick!" she said. "They were showing off just to make us feel 
small. Mr. Nostrum warned me they would. It's to disguise the thinness of their 
souls. What an awful, dull wife! And did you ever see anyone so plain and stupid 
as those two children! I know I'm going to hate it here. This Castle's crushing 
me already." 
"It may not be so bad once we get used to it," Cat said, without hope. 
"It'll be worse," Gwendolen promised him. "There's something about this Castle. 
It's a bad influence, and a deadness. It's squashing the life and the witchcraft 
out of me. I can hardly breathe." 
"You're imagining things," said Cat, "because you want to be back with Mrs. 
Sharp." And he sighed. He missed Mrs. Sharp badly. 
"No, I'm not imagining it," said Gwendolen. "I should have thought it was strong 
enough even for you to feel. Go on, try. Can't you feel the deadness?" 
Cat did not really need to try, to see what she meant. There was something 
strange about the Castle. He had thought it was simply that it was so quiet. But 
it was more than that: there was a softness to the atmosphere, a weightiness, as 
if everything they said or did was muffled under a great feather quilt. Normal 
sounds, like their two voices, seemed thin. There were no echoes to them. "Yes, 
it is queer," he agreed. 
"It's more than queer—it's terrible," said Gwendolen. "I shall be lucky if I 
survive." Then she added, to Cat's surprise, "So I'm not sorry I came." 
"I am," said Cat. 
"Oh, you would need looking after!" said Gwendolen. "All right. There's a pack 
of cards on the dressing table. They're for divination, really, but if we take 
the trumps out we can use them to play Snap with, if you like." 



4
The same softness and silence were there when the red-haired Mary woke Cat the 
next morning and told him it was time to get up. Bright morning sunshine was 
flooding the curved walls of his room. Though Cat knew now that the Castle must 
be full of people, he could hear not a sound from any of them. Nor could he hear 
anything from outside the windows. 
I know what it's like! Cat thought. It's like when it's snowed in the night. The 
idea made him feel so pleased and so warm that he went to sleep again. 
"You really must get up, Eric," Mary said, shaking him. "I've run your bath, and 
your lessons start at nine. Make haste, or you won't have time for breakfast." 
Cat got up. He had so strong a feeling that it had snowed in the night that he 
was quite surprised to find his room warm in the sun. He looked out of the 
windows, and there were green lawns and flowers, and rooks circling the green 
trees, as if there had been some mistake. Mary had gone. Cat was glad, because 
he was not at all sure he liked her, and he was afraid of missing breakfast. 
When he was dressed, he went along to the bathroom and let the hot water out of 
the bath. Then he dashed down the twisting stairs to find Gwendolen. 
"Where do we go for breakfast?" he asked her anxiously. 
Gwendolen was never at her best in the morning. She was sitting on her blue 
velvet stool in front of her garlanded mirror, crossly combing her golden hair. 
Combing her hair was another thing which always made her cross. "I don't know 
and I don't care! Shut up!" she said. 
"Now that's no way to speak," said the maid called Euphemia, briskly following 
Cat into the room. She was rather a pretty girl, and she did not seem to find 
her name the burden it should have been. "We're waiting to give you breakfast 
along here. Come on." 
Gwendolen hurled her comb down expressively and they followed Euphemia to a room 
just along the corridor. It was a square, airy room, with a row of big windows 
but, compared with the rest of the Castle, it was rather shabby. The leather 
chairs were battered. The grassy carpet had stains on it. None of the cupboards 
would shut properly. Things like clockwork trains and tennis rackets bulged out. 
Julia and Roger were sitting waiting at a table by the windows, in clothes as 
shabby as the room. 
Mary, who was waiting there too, said, "And about time!" and began to work an 
interesting lift in a cupboard by the fireplace. There was a clank. Mary opened 
the lift and fetched out a large plate of bread and butter and a steaming brown 
jug of cocoa. She brought these over to the table and Euphemia poured each child 
a mug of the cocoa. 
Gwendolen stared from her mug to the plate of bread. "Is this all there is?" 
"What else do you want?" asked Euphemia. 
Gwendolen could not find words to express what she wanted. Porridge, bacon and 
eggs, grapefruit, toast and kippers all occurred to her at once, and she went on 
staring. 
"Make up your mind," Euphemia said at last. "My breakfast's waiting for me too, 
you know." 
"Isn't there any marmalade?" said Gwendolen. 
Euphemia and Mary looked at one another. "Julia and Roger are not allowed 
marmalade," Mary said. 
"Nobody forbade me to have it," said Gwendolen. "Get me some marmalade at once." 

Mary went to a speaking tube by the lift and, after much rumbling and another 
clank, a pot of marmalade arrived. Mary brought it and put it in front of 
Gwendolen. 
"Thank you," Cat said fervently. He felt as strongly about it as Gwendolen—more, 
in fact, because he hated cocoa. 
"Oh, no trouble, I'm sure!" Mary said, in what was certainly a sarcastic way, 
and the two maids went out. 
For a while, nobody said anything. Then Roger said to Cat, "Pass the marmalade, 
please." 
"You're not supposed to have it," said Gwendolen, whose temper had not improved. 

"Nobody will know if I use one of your knives," Roger said placidly. 
Cat passed him the marmalade and his knife too. "Why aren't you allowed it?" 
Julia and Roger looked at one another in a mild, secretive way. "We're too fat," 
Julia said, calmly taking the knife and the marmalade after Roger had done with 
them. Cat was not surprised when he saw how much marmalade they had managed to 
pile on their bread. Marmalade stood on both slices like a sticky brown cliff. 
Gwendolen looked at them with disgust, and then, rather complacently, down at 
her trim linen dress. The contrast was certainly striking. "Your father is such 
a handsome man," she said. "It must be such a disappointment to him that you're 
both pudgy and plain, like your mother." 
The two children looked at her placidly over their cliffs of marmalade. "Oh, I 
wouldn't know," said Roger. 
"Pudgy is comfortable," said Julia. "It must be a nuisance to look like a china 
doll, the way you do." 
Gwendolen's blue eyes glared. She made a small sign under the edge of the table. 
The bread and thick marmalade whisked itself from Julia's hands and slapped 
itself on Julia's face, marmalade side inward. Julia gasped a little. "How dare 
you insult me!" said Gwendolen. 
Julia peeled the bread slowly off her face and then fumbled out a handkerchief. 
Cat supposed she was going to wipe her face. But she let the marmalade stay 
where it was, trundling in blobs down her plump cheeks, and simply tied a knot 
in the handkerchief. She pulled the knot slowly tight, looking meaningly at 
Gwendolen while she did so. With the final pull, the half-full jug of cocoa shot 
steaming into the air. It hovered for a second, and then shot sideways to hang 
just above Gwendolen's head. Then it began to joggle itself into tipping 
position. 
"Stop it!" gasped Gwendolen. She put up a hand to ward the jug off. The jug 
dodged her and went on tipping. Gwendolen made another sign and gasped out 
strange words. The jug took not the slightest notice. It went on tipping until 
cocoa was brimming in the very end of its spout. Gwendolen tried to lean out 
sideways away from it. The jug simply joggled along in the air until it was 
hanging over her head again. 
"Shall I make it pour?" Julia asked. There was a bit of a smile under the 
marmalade. 
"You dare!" screamed Gwendolen. "I'll tell Chrestomanci on you! I'll—oh!" She 
sat up straight again, and the jug followed her faithfully. Gwendolen made 
another grab at it, and it dodged again. 
"Careful. You'll make it spill. And what a shame about your pretty dress," Roger 
said, watching complacently. 
"Shut up, you!" Gwendolen shouted at him, leaning out the other way so that she 
was nearly in Cat's lap. Cat looked up nervously as the jug came and hovered 
over him too. It seemed to be going to pour. 
But, at that moment, the door opened and Chrestomanci came in, wearing a 
flowered silk dressing gown. It was a red and purple dressing gown, with gold at 
the neck and sleeves. It made Chrestomanci look amazingly tall, amazingly thin, 
and astonishingly stately. He could have been an emperor, or a particularly 
severe bishop. He was smiling as he came in, but the smile vanished when he saw 
the jug. 
The jug tried to vanish too. It fled back to the table at the sight of him, so 
quickly that cocoa slopped out of it onto Gwendolen's dress—which may or may not 
have been an accident. Julia and Roger both looked stricken. Julia unknotted her 
handkerchief as if for dear life. 
"Well, I was coming in to say good morning," Chrestomanci said. "But I see that 
it isn't." He looked from the jug to Julia's marmalade-glistening cheeks. "If 
you two ever want to eat marmalade again," he said, "you'd better do as you're 
told. And the same goes for all four of you." 
"I wasn't doing anything wrong," Gwendolen said, as if butter—not to speak of 
marmalade—would not have melted in her mouth. 
"Yes, you were," said Roger. 
Chrestomanci came to the end of the table and stood looking down on them, with 
his hands in the pockets of his noble robe. He looked so tall like that that Cat 
was surprised that his head was still under the ceiling. "There's one absolute 
rule in this Castle," he said, "which it will pay you all to remember. No 
witchcraft of any kind is to be practiced by children, unless Michael Saunders 
is here to supervise you. Have you understood, Gwendolen?" 
"Yes," said Gwendolen. She gripped her lips together and clenched her hands, but 
she was still shaking with rage. "I refuse to keep such a silly rule!" 
Chrestomanci did not seem to hear, or to notice how angry she was. He turned to 
Cat. "Have you understood too, Eric?" 
"Me?" Cat said in surprise. "Yes, of course." 
"Good," said Chrestomanci. "Now I will say good morning." 
"Good morning, Daddy," said Julia and Roger. "Er—good morning," Cat said. 
Gwendolen pretended not to hear. Two could play at that game. Chrestomanci 
smiled and swept out of the room like a very long procession of one person. 
"Telltale!" Gwendolen said to Roger, as soon as the door had shut. "And that was 
a dirty trick with that jug! You were both doing it, weren't you?" 
Roger smiled sleepily, not in the least disturbed. 
"Witchcraft runs in our family," he said. 
"And we've both inherited it," said Julia. "I must go and wash." She picked up 
three slices of bread to keep her going while she did so, and left the room, 
calling over her shoulder, "Tell Michael I won't be long, Roger." 
"More cocoa?" Roger said politely, picking up the jug. 
"Yes, please," said Cat. It never bothered him to eat or drink things that had 
been bewitched, and he was thirsty. He thought that if he filled his mouth with 
marmalade and strained the cocoa through it, he might not taste the cocoa. 
Gwendolen, however, was sure Roger was trying to insult her. She flounced around 
in her chair and stayed haughtily looking at the wall until Mr. Saunders 
suddenly threw open a door Cat had not noticed before and said cheerfully: 
"Right, all of you. Lesson time. Come on through and see how you stand up to 
some grilling." 
Cat hastily swallowed his cocoa-flavored marmalade. Beyond the door was a 
schoolroom. It was a real, genuine schoolroom, although there were only four 
desks in it. There was a blackboard, a globe, the pitted school floor, and the 
schoolroom smell. There was that kind of glass-fronted bookcase without which no 
schoolroom is complete, and the bartered gray-green and dark blue books without 
which no schoolroom bookcase is complete. On the walls were big pictures of the 
statues Mr. Saunders had found so interesting. 
Two of the desks were brown and old. Two were new and yellow with varnish. 
Gwendolen and Cat sat silently in the new desks. Julia hurried in, with her face 
shining from soap, and sat in the old desk beside Roger's, and the grilling 
began. Mr. Saunders strode gawkily up and down in front of the blackboard, 
asking keen questions. His tweed jacket billowed out from his back, just as his 
coat had done in the wind. Perhaps that was why the sleeves of the jacket were 
so much too short for Mr. Saunders' long arms. The long arm shot out, and a foot 
of bony wrist with a keen finger on the end of it pointed at Cat. "What part did 
witchcraft play in the Wars of the Roses?" 
"Er," said Cat. "Ung. I'm afraid I haven't done them yet, sir." 
"Gwendolen," said Mr. Saunders. 
"Oh—a very big part," Gwendolen guessed airily. 
"Wrong," said Mr. Saunders. "Roger." 
From the grilling, it emerged that, Roger and Julia had forgotten a great deal 
over the summer but, even so, they were well ahead of Cat in most things, and 
far ahead of Gwendolen in everything. 
"What did you learn at school?" Mr. Saunders asked her, in some exasperation. 
Gwendolen shrugged. "I've forgotten. It wasn't interesting. I was concentrating 
on witchcraft, and I intend to go on doing that, please." 
"I'm afraid you can't," said Mr. Saunders. 
Gwendolen stared at him, hardly able to believe she had heard him right. "What!" 
she almost shrieked. "But—but I'm terribly talented! I have to go on with it!" 
"Your talents will keep," said Mr. Saunders. "You can take up witchcraft again 
when you've learned something else. Open your arithmetic book and do me the 
first four exercises. Eric, I think I'll set you going on some History. Write me 
an essay on the reign of King Canute." He moved on to set work for Roger and 
Julia. 
Cat and Gwendolen opened books. Gwendolen's face was red, then white. As Mr. 
Saunders bent over Roger, her inkwell sailed up out of the socket in her desk 
and emptied itself over the back of Mr. Saunders' billowing tweed jacket. Cat 
bit his lip in order not to laugh. Julia watched with calm interest. Mr. 
Saunders did not seem to notice. The inkwell returned quietly to its socket. 
"Gwendolen," said Mr. Saunders without turn-ing around. "Get the ink jar and 
funnel out of the bottom of the cupboard and refill that inkwell. And fill it 
properly, please."
Gwendolen got up, jauntily and defiantly, found the big flask and funnel, and 
started to fill her inkwell. Ten minutes later, she was still pouring away. Her 
face was puzzled at first, then red, then white with fury again. She tried to 
put the flask down, and found she could not. She tried whispering a spell. 
Mr. Saunders turned and looked at her. 
"You're being perfectly horrible!" said Gwendolen. "Besides, I'm allowed to do 
witchcraft when you're here." 
"No one is allowed to pour ink over their tutor," Mr. Saunders said cheerfully. 
"And I'd already told you that you've given up witchcraft for the time being. 
Keep on pouring till I tell you to stop." 
Gwendolen poured ink for the next half hour, and got angrier every minute of it. 

Cat was impressed. He suspected that Mr. Saunders was rather a powerful 
magician. Certainly, when he next looked at Mr. Saunders, there was no sign of 
any ink on his back. Cat looked at Mr. Saunders fairly often, to see whether it 
was safe to change his pen from his right to his left hand. He had been punished 
so often for writing left-handed that he was good at keeping an eye on his 
teachers. When Mr. Saunders turned his way, Cat used his right hand. It was slow 
and reluctant. But as soon as Mr. Saunders turned away again, Cat changed his 
pen over and got on like a house on fire. The main trouble was that, in order 
not to smudge the ink with his left hand, he had to hold the paper sideways. But 
he was pretty deft at flicking his book straight again whenever Mr. Saunders 
seemed likely to look at him. 
When the half hour was over, Mr. Saunders, without turning around, told 
Gwendolen to stop pouring ink and do sums. Then, still without turning around, 
he said to Cat, "Eric, what are you doing?" 
"An essay on King Canute," Cat said innocently. 
Then Mr. Saunders did turn around, but by that time the paper was straight and 
the pen in Cat's right hand. "Which hand were you writing with?" he said. Cat 
was used to this. He held up his right hand with the pen in it. "It looked like 
both hands to me," Mr. Saunders said, and he came over and looked at the page 
Cat had written. "It was both." 
"It doesn't show," Cat said miserably. 
"Not much," Mr. Saunders agreed. "Does it amuse you to write with alternate 
hands, or something?" 
"No," Cat confessed. "But I'm left-handed." 
Then, as Cat had feared, Mr. Saunders flew into a towering rage. His face went 
red. He slammed his big, knobby hand down on Cat's desk so that Cat jumped and 
the inkwell jumped too, sending ink splashing over Mr. Saunders' great hand and 
over Cat's essay. "Left-handed!" he roared. "Then why the Black Gentleman don't 
you write with your left hand, boy?" 
"They—they punish me if I do," Cat faltered, very shaken, and very perplexed to 
find Mr. Saunders was angry for such a peculiar reason. 
"Then they deserve to be tied up in knots and roasted!" roared Mr. Saunders, 
"whoever they are! You're doing yourself untold harm by obeying them, boy! If I 
catch you writing with your right hand again, you'll be in really serious 
trouble!" 
"Yes," Cat said, relieved but still very shaken. 
He looked mournfully at his ink-splashed essay and hoped Mr. Saunders might use 
a little witchcraft on that too. But Mr. Saunders took the book and tore the 
page right out. 
"Now do it again properly!" he said, slapping the book back in front of Cat. 
Cat was still writing all over again about Canute when Mary came in with a tray 
of milk and biscuits and a cup of coffee for Mr. Saunders. And after the milk 
and biscuits, Mr. Saunders told Cat and Gwendolen they were free till lunch. 
"Though not because of a good morning's work," he said. "Go out and get some 
fresh air." As they went out of the schoolroom, he turned to Roger and Julia. 
"Now we'll have a little witchcraft," he said. "And let's hope you haven't 
forgotten all that too." 
Gwendolen stopped in the doorway and looked at him. 
"No. Not you," Mr. Saunders said to her. "I told you." 
Gwendolen whirled around and ran away, through the shabby playroom and down the 
corridor beyond. Cat ran after her as hard as he could, but he did not catch up 
with her until they came to a much grander part of the Castle, where a big 
marble staircase curled away downward and the light came from an elegant dome in 
the roof. 
"This isn't the right way," Cat panted. 
"Yes it is," Gwendolen said fiercely. "I'm going to find Chrestomanci. Why 
should those two fat little fools learn witchcraft and not me? I've got twice 
their gifts. It took two of them just to levitate a jug of cocoa! So I want 
Chrestomanci." 
By a stroke of good fortune, Chrestomanci was coming along the gallery on the 
other side of the staircase, behind a curly marble balustrade. He was wearing a 
fawn-colored suit now, instead of the imperial dressing gown, but he looked, if 
possible, even more elegant. By the look on his face, his thoughts were miles 
away. Gwendolen ran around the head of the marble staircase and stood herself in 
front of him. Chrestomanci blinked, and looked vaguely from her to Cat. "Was one 
of you wanting me?" 
"Yes. Me," said Gwendolen. "Mr. Saunders won't give me witchcraft lessons, and I 
want you to tell him he must." 
"Oh, but I can't do that," Chrestomanci said absentmindedly. "Sorry and so on." 
Gwendolen stamped her foot. It made no noise to speak of, even there on the 
marble floor, and there was no echo. Gwendolen was forced to shout instead. "Why 
not? You must, you must, you must!" 
Chrestomanci looked down at her in a peering, surprised way, as if he had only 
just seen her. "You seem to be annoyed," he said. "But I'm afraid it's 
unavoidable. I told Michael Saunders that he was on no account to teach either 
of you witchcraft." 
"You did! Why not?" Gwendolen shouted. 
"Because you were bound to misuse it, of course," said Chrestomanci, as if it 
were quite obvious. "But I'll reconsider it in a year or so, if you still want 
to learn." Then he smiled kindly at Gwendolen, obviously expecting her to be 
pleased, and drifted dreamily away down the marble stairs. 
Gwendolen kicked the marble balustrade and hurt her foot. That sent her into a 
rage as strong as Mr. Saunders'. She danced and jumped and shrieked at the head 
of the stairs until Cat was quite frightened of her. She shook her fist after 
Chrestomanci. "I'll show you! You wait!" she screamed. But Chrestomanci had gone 
out of sight around the bend in the staircase and perhaps he could not hear. 
Even Gwendolen's loudest scream sounded thin and small. 
Cat was puzzled. What was it about this Castle? He looked up at the dome where 
the light came in and thought that Gwendolen's screaming ought to have echoed 
around it like the dickens. Instead, it made a small, high squawking. While he 
waited for her to get her temper back, Cat experimentally put his fingers to his 
mouth and whistled as hard as he could. It made a queer, blunt noise, like a 
squeaky boot. It also brought the old lady with the mittens out of a door in the 
gallery. 
"You noisy little children!" she said. "If you want to scream and whistle, you 
must go out in the grounds and do it there." 
"Oh, come on!" Gwendolen said crossly to Cat, and the two of them ran away to 
the part of the Castle they were used to. After a bit of muddling around, they 
discovered the door they had first come in by and let themselves outside through 
it. 
"Let's explore everywhere," said Cat. Gwendolen shrugged and said it suited her, 
so they set off. 
Beyond the shrubbery of rhododendrons, they found themselves out on the great 
smooth lawn with the cedar trees. It spread across the entire front of the newer 
part of the Castle. On the other side of it, Cat saw the most interesting high 
sun-soaked old wall, with trees hanging over it. It was clearly the ruins of an 
even older castle. Cat set off towards it at a trot, past the big windows of the 
newer Castle, dragging Gwendolen with him. But, halfway there, Gwendolen stopped 
and stood poking at the shaved green grass with her toe. 
"Hm," she said. "Do you think this counts as in the Castle?" 
"I expect so," said Cat. "Do come on. I want to explore those ruins there." 
However, the first wall they came to was a low one, and the door in it led them 
into a very formal garden. It had broad gravel paths, running very straight, 
between box hedges. There were yew trees everywhere, clipped into severe 
pyramids, and all the flowers were yellow, in tidy clumps. 
"Boring," said Cat, and led the way to the ruined wall beyond. 
But once again there was a lower wall in the way, and this time they came out 
into an orchard. It was a very tidy orchard, in which all the trees were trained 
flat, to stand like hedges on either side of the winding gravel paths. They were 
loaded with apples, some of them quite big. After what Chrestomanci had said 
about scrumping, Cat did not quite dare pick one, but Gwendolen picked a big red 
Worcester and bit into it. 
Instantly, a gardener appeared from around a corner and told them reproachfully 
that picking apples was forbidden. 
Gwendolen threw the apple down in the path. "Take it then. There was a maggot in 
it anyway." 
They went on, leaving the gardener staring ruefully at the bitten apple. And 
instead of reaching the ruins, they came to a goldfish pond, and after that to a 
rose garden. Here Gwendolen, as an experiment, tried picking a rose. Instantly 
another gardener appeared and explained respectfully that they were not allowed 
to pick roses. So Gwendolen threw the rose down too. Then Cat looked over his 
shoulder and discovered that the ruins were somehow behind them now. He turned 
back. But he still did not seem to reach them. It was nearly lunchtime before he 
suddenly turned into a steep little path between two walls and found the ruins 
above him, at the top of the path. 
Cat pelted joyfully up the steep path. The sun-soaked wall ahead was taller than 
most houses, and there were trees at the top of it. When he was close enough, 
Cat saw that there was a giddy stone staircase jutting out of the wall, more 
like a stone ladder than a stair. It was so old that snapdragons and wallflowers 
had rooted in it, and hollyhocks had grown up against the place where the stair 
met the ground. Cat had to push aside a tall red hollyhock in order to put his 
foot on the first stair. 
No sooner had he done so than yet another gardener came puffing up the steep 
path. "You can't go there! That's Chrestomanci's garden up there, that is!" 
"Why can't we?" said Cat, deeply disappointed. 
"Because it's not allowed, that's why." 
Slowly and reluctantly, Cat came away. The gardener stood at the foot of the 
stair to make sure he went. "Bother!" Cat said. 
"I'm getting rather sick of Chrestomanci forbidding things," said Gwendolen. 
"It's time someone taught him a lesson." 
"What are you going to do?" said Cat. 
"Wait and see," said Gwendolen, pressing her lips together in her stormiest way. 




5
Gwendolen refused to tell Cat what she was going to do. This meant that Cat had 
rather a melancholy time. After a wholesome lunch of turnips and boiled mutton, 
they had lessons again. After that, Gwendolen ran hastily away and would not let 
Cat come with her. Cat did not know what to do. 
"Would you care to come out and play?" Roger asked. 
Cat looked at him and saw that he was just being polite. "No, thank you," he 
said politely. He was forced to wander around the gardens on his own. There was 
a wood lower down, full of horse chestnuts, but they were not nearly ripe. As 
Cat was halfheartedly staring up into one, he saw there was a tree house in it, 
about halfway up. This was more like it. Cat was just about to climb up to it 
when he heard voices and saw Julia's skirt flutter among the leaves. So that was 
no good. It was Julia and Roger's private tree house, and they were in it. 
Cat wandered away again. He came to the lawn, and there was Gwendolen, crouching 
under one of the cedars, very busy digging a small hole. 
"What are you doing?" said Cat. 
"Go away," said Gwendolen. 
Cat went away. He was sure what Gwendolen was doing was witchcraft and had to do 
with teaching Chrestomanci a lesson, but it was no good asking Gwendolen when 
she was being this secretive. Cat had to wait. He waited through another 
terrifying dinner, and then through a long, long evening. Gwendolen locked 
herself in her room after dinner and told him to go away when he knocked. 
Next morning, Cat woke up early and hurried to the nearest of his three windows. 
He saw at once what Gwendolen had been doing. The lawn was ruined. It was not a 
smooth stretch of green velvet any longer. It was a mass of molehills. As far as 
Cat could see in both directions, there were little green mounds, little heaps 
of raw earth, long lines of raw earth and long green furrows of raised grass. 
There must have been an army of moles at work on it all night. About a dozen 
gardeners were standing in a gloomy huddle, scratching their heads over it. 
Cat threw on his clothes and dashed downstairs. 
Gwendolen was leaning out of her window in her frilly cotton nightdress, glowing 
with pride. "Look at that!" she said to Cat. "Isn't it marvelous! There's acres 
of it too. It took me hours yesterday evening to make sure it was all spoiled. 
That will make Chrestomanci think a bit!" 
Cat was sure it would. He did not know how much a huge stretch of turf like that 
would cost to replace, but he suspected it was a great deal. He was afraid 
Gwendolen would be in really bad trouble. 
But, to his astonishment, nobody so much as mentioned the lawn. Euphemia came in 
a minute later, but all she said was, "You'll both be late for your breakfast 
again." Roger and Julia said nothing at all. They silently accepted the 
marmalade and Cat's knife when he passed them over, but the sole thing either of 
them said was when Julia dropped Cat's knife and picked it up again, all fluffy. 
She said, "Bother!" And when Mr. Saunders called them through for lessons, the 
only things he talked about were what he was teaching them. Cat decided that 
nobody knew Gwendolen had caused the moles. They could have no idea what a 
strong witch she was. 
There were no lessons after lunch that day. Mr. Saunders explained that they 
always had Wednesday afternoons off. And at lunchtime, every molehill had gone. 
When they looked out of the playroom window, the lawn was like a sheet of velvet 
again. 
"I don't believe it!" Gwendolen whispered to Cat. "It must be an illusion. 
They're trying to make me feel small." 
They went out and looked after lunch. They had to be fairly cautious about it 
because Mr. Saunders was taking his afternoon off in a deck chair under one of 
the cedars, reading a yellow paperback book which seemed to amuse him a great 
deal. Gwendolen sauntered out into the middle of the lawn and pretended to be 
admiring the Castle. She pretended to tie her bootlace and prodded the turf with 
her fingers. 
"I don't understand it!" she said. Being a witch, she knew the close, smooth 
turf was no illusion. "It really is all right! How was it done?" 
"They must have carted in new turf while we were having lessons," Cat suggested. 

"Don't be stupid!" said Gwendolen. "New turf would all be in squares still, and 
this isn't." 
Mr. Saunders called to them. 
Gwendolen looked, for a second, more apprehensive than Cat had ever seen her. 
But she hid it fairly well and led the way casually over to the deck chair. Cat 
saw that the yellow book was in French. Fancy being able to laugh at something 
in French! Mr. Saunders must be a learned magician as well as a strong one. 
Mr. Saunders laid the book facedown on the once-more-beautiful grass and smiled 
up at them. "You two went away so quickly that you never gave me time to dish 
you out your pocket money. Here you are." He handed them each a large silver 
coin. Cat stared at his. It was a crown piece—five whole shillings. He had never 
had so much money to spend in his life. Mr. Saunders added to his amazement by 
saying, "You'll get that every Wednesday. I don't know whether you're savers or 
spenders. What Julia and Roger usually do is to go down to the village and blow 
it all on sweets." 
"Thank you," said Cat, "very much. Shall we go down to the village, Gwendolen?" 
"We may as well," Gwendolen agreed. She was divided between a defiant desire to 
stay at the Castle and face whatever trouble was coming over the moles and 
relief at an excuse to get away. "I expect Chrestomanci will send for me as soon 
as he realizes it was me," she said as they walked down the avenue of trees. 
"Do you think it was Mr. Saunders who put the lawn right?" Cat asked. 
Gwendolen frowned. "He couldn't have. He was teaching us." 
"Those gardeners," suggested Cat. "Some of them could be warlocks. They did turn 
up awfully quickly to forbid us things." 
Gwendolen laughed scornfully. "Think of the Willing Warlock." 
Cat did, a little dubiously. The Willing Warlock was not much more gifted than 
Mrs. Sharp. He was usually hired for heavy carrying jobs, or to make the wrong 
horse win at the races. "All the same," he argued, "they could be 
specialists—garden warlocks." 
Gwendolen only laughed again. 
The village was just beyond the Castle gates, at the foot of the hill where the 
Castle stood. It was a pretty place, around a big green. Across the green, there 
were shops: a beautiful bow-fronted baker's and an equally beautiful sweet shop 
and post office. Cat wanted to visit both, but Gwendolen stopped at a third 
shop, which was a junk shop. Cat did not mind going into that either. It looked 
interesting. But Gwendolen shook her head irritably and stopped a village boy 
who was loitering near it. 
"I was told a Mr. Baslam lives in this village. Can you tell me where he lives?" 

The boy made a face. "Him? He's no good. Down there, at the end of that alley, 
if you really want to know." And he stood looking at them, with the air of 
someone who has earned sixpence for his pains. 
Neither Cat nor Gwendolen had any money beside their crown pieces. They had to 
go away without giving him anything. The boy shouted after them. 
"Stuck-up little witch! Mingy little warlock!" 
Gwendolen did not mind this in the least, but Cat was so ashamed that he wanted 
to go back and explain. 
Mr. Baslam lived in a shabby cottage with an ill-written notice propped in one 
window: Eggsotick Serplys. Gwendolen looked at it rather pityingly as she 
hammered on the door with the dingy knocker. When Mr. Baslam opened his door, he 
proved to be a fat person in old trousers which sagged to make room for his 
fatness, and with red, drooping eyes like a St. Bernard's. He started to shut 
the door again as soon as he saw them. 
"Not today, thank you," he said, and a strong smell of beer came out with the 
words. 
"Mr. Nostrum sent me," said Gwendolen. "Mr. William Nostrum." 
The door stopped shutting. "Ah," said Mr. Baslam. "Then you better both come in. 
This way." He led them into a poky room containing four chairs, a table, and 
several dozen cases of stuffed animals. There was hardly room for all the cases 
of stuffed animals. They stood higgledy-piggledy, one on top of another, and 
they were all very dusty. "Sit down then," said Mr. Baslam, rather grudgingly. 
Cat sat down gently and tried not to breathe too deeply. Beside the beery smell 
from Mr. Baslam, there was a faint rotting smell and a smell like pickles. Cat 
thought that some of the stuffed animals had not been properly cured. The smell 
did not seem to bother Gwendolen. She sat looking like a picture of a perfect 
little girl. Her cream-colored dress spread crisply around her and her broad hat 
becomingly shaded her golden hair. She looked at Mr. Baslam with severe blue 
eyes. 
"I think your notice is spelled wrong." 
Mr. Baslam drooped his St. Bernard eyes and made gestures that were meant to be 
joking. "I know. I know. But I don't want to be taken serious, do I? Not on the 
very threshold, as it were. Now what was you wanting? Mr. William Nostrum don't 
tell me too much of his plans. I'm only a humble supplier." 
"I want some supplies, of course," said Gwendolen. 
Cat listened, rather bored, to Gwendolen bargaining for the materials of 
witchcraft. Mr. Baslam fumbled in the backs of stuffed animal cases and fetched 
out newspaper screws of this and that— newts' eyes, snakes' tongues, cardamom, 
hellebore, mummy, niter, seed of moly, and various resins— which probably 
accounted for the unpleasant smell. He wanted more for them than Gwendolen would 
pay. She was determined to lay out her five shillings to the best possible 
advantage. Mr. Baslam seemed to resent it. "Know your own mind, don't you?" he 
said peevishly. 
"I know how much things should cost," said Gwendolen. She took her hat off, 
packed the little screws of newspaper carefully into its crown, and put it 
neatly back on her head again. "And last, I think I shall be wanting some 
dragons' blood," she said. 
"Ooooh!" said Mr. Baslam, dolefully shaking his head so that his hanging cheeks 
flapped. "Dragons' blood is banned from use, young lady. You ought to know that. 
I don't know as I can manage you any of that." 
"Mr. Nostrum—both Mr. Nostrums—told me you could get anything" said Gwendolen. 
"They said you were the best agent they knew. And I'm not asking for dragons' 
blood now. I'm ordering some." 
Mr. Baslam looked gratified at being praised by the Nostrum brothers, but he was 
still dubious. "It's a fearful strong charm needs dragons' blood," he said 
plaintively. "You won't be doing anything that strong yourself, a young lady 
like you, now." 
"I don't know yet," said Gwendolen. "But I think I might. I'm on Advanced Magic, 
you know. And I want dragons' blood in case I need it." 
"It'll come dear," Mr. Baslam warned her. "It's costly stuff. There's the risk 
to pay for, you see. I don't want the law on me." 
"I can pay," said Gwendolen. "I'll pay in installments. You can take the rest of 
the five shillings on account." 
Mr. Baslam was unable to resist this. The way he looked at the crown piece 
Gwendolen handed to him made Cat see vividly a long row of frothing pints of 
beer. "Done," said Mr. Baslam. Gwendolen smiled graciously and got up to go. Cat 
thankfully leaped up too. "What about you, young gentleman?" Mr. Baslam asked 
wheedlingly. "Aren't you going to try your hand at a bit of necromancy at all?" 
"He's just my brother," said Gwendolen. 
"Oh. Ah. Urn. Yes," said Mr. Baslam. "He's that one, of course. Well, good day 
to you both. Come again, any time." 
"When will you have the dragons' blood?" Gwendolen asked him on the doorstep. 
Mr. Baslam thought. "Say a week?" 
Gwendolen's face glowed. "How quick! I knew you were a good agent. Where do you 
get it from so quickly?" 
"Now that would be telling, wouldn't it?" said Mr. Baslam. "It has to come from 
another world, but which one is a trade secret, young lady." 
Gwendolen was jubilant as they went back along the alley. "A week!" she said. 
"That's the quickest I've ever heard. It has to be smuggled in from this other 
world, you know. He must have awfully good connections there." 
"Or he's got some already, inside a stuffed bird," said Cat, who had not liked 
Mr. Baslam at all. "Whatever do you want dragons' blood for? Mrs. Sharp says it 
costs fifty pounds an ounce." 
"Be quiet," said Gwendolen. "Oh, quick! Hurry, Cat! Get into that sweet shop. 
She mustn't know where I've been." 
Out on the village green, a lady carrying a parasol was talking to a clergyman. 
She was Chrestomanci's wife. Cat and Gwendolen bundled themselves into the shop 
and hoped she had not seen them. There, Cat bought them a bag of toffee each. 
Millie was still there, so he bought some licorice too. Millie was still talking 
to the clergyman even then, so he bought Gwendolen a pen wiper and himself a 
postcard of the Castle. Millie was still there. But Cat could not think of 
anything else to buy, so they had to come out of the shop. 
Millie beckoned to them as soon as they did. "Come and meet the dear vicar." 
The vicar, who was old, with a weak and wandering look, shakily shook hands with 
them and said he would see them on Sunday. Then he said he really must be going 
now. 
"And so must we," said Millie. "Come on, my dears. We'll walk back to the Castle 
together." 
There was nothing to do but walk beside her under the shadow of her parasol, 
across the green and between the lodge gates. Cat was afraid she was going to 
ask them why they had been visiting Mr. Baslam. Gwendolen was sure she was going 
to ask her about the moles in the lawn. But what Millie said was, "I am glad of 
a chance to talk to you, my loves. I haven't had a moment to see how you were 
getting on. Are you all right? Are you finding it very strange?" 
"A—a little," Cat admitted. 
"The first few days are always the worst, anywhere," said Millie. "I'm sure 
you'll soon find your way around. And don't hesitate to use the toys in the 
playroom if you want. They're for everyone. Private toys are in one's own room. 
How are you liking your rooms?" 
Cat looked up at her in astonishment. She was talking as if moles and witchcraft 
had never existed. Millie beamed back at him. Despite her elegant ruched dress 
and her lacy parasol, she was a most ordinary, kind, good-natured lady. Cat 
liked her. He assured Millie that he liked his room, and his 
bathroom—particularly the shower—and explained that he had never had a bathroom 
to himself before. 
"Oh, I'm glad. I did so hope you'd like it," said Millie. "Miss Bessemer wanted 
to put you next to Roger, but I thought that room was so dull—and it doesn't 
have a shower. Look at it sometime and you'll see what I mean." 
She walked on up the avenue, chattering away, and Cat found himself doing all 
the rest of the talking. As soon as it was clear that Millie was not going to 
mention either lawns or exotic supplies, Gwendolen began to despise her. She 
kept up a scornful silence, and left Cat to talk. After a while, Millie asked 
Cat what thing about the Castle he was finding strangest. 
Cat answered shyly, but without hesitation, "The way everyone talks at supper." 
Millie let out such a yell of despair that Cat jumped and Gwendolen was more 
scornful than ever. "Oh dear! Poor Eric! I've seen you looking! Isn't it awful? 
Michael gets these enthusiasms, and then he can talk of nothing else. It should 
be wearing off in a day or so, though, and then we can have reasonable talk 
again and make a few jokes. I like to laugh at dinner, don't you? I'm afraid 
nothing will stop poor Bernard talking about stocks and shares, but you mustn't 
take any notice of that. Nobody listens to Bernard. Do you like eclairs, by the 
way?" 
"Yes," said Cat. 
"Oh good!" said Millie. "I've ordered tea for us on the lawn, since this is your 
first Wednesday and I didn't want to waste this lovely weather. Isn't it funny 
how September's nearly always fine? If we slip through the trees here, we should 
be on the lawn as soon as tea is." 
Sure enough, they followed Millie out of the shrubbery to find a whole cluster 
of deck chairs around the one where Mr. Saunders was, and footmen putting out 
tables and carrying trays. Most of the Family were gathering among the deck 
chairs. Gwendolen followed Millie and Cat over, looking nervous and defiant. She 
knew Chrestomanci was going to speak to her about the lawn now and, to make 
matters worse, she was not going to have a chance to take the exotic supplies 
out of her hat before he did. 
But Chrestomanci was not there, though everyone else was. Millie pushed between 
stocks-and-shares Bernard and Julia, and past the old lady with mittens, to 
point her parasol sternly at Mr. Saunders. "Michael, you are absolutely 
forbidden to talk about Art during tea," she said, and spoiled the sternness 
rather by laughing. 
The Family evidently felt much the same as Cat. Several of them said "Hear, 
hear!" and Roger said, "Can we start, Mummy?" 
Cat enjoyed the tea. It was the first time he had enjoyed anything since he came 
to the Castle. There were paper-thin cucumber sandwiches and big squashy 
eclairs. Cat ate even more than Roger did. He was surrounded by cheerful, 
ordinary chat from the Family, with a hum of stocks and shares in the 
background, and the sun lay warm and peaceful on the green stretches of the 
lawn. Cat was glad someone had somehow restored it. He liked it better smooth. 
He began to think he could almost be happy at the Castle, with a little 
practice. 
Gwendolen was nothing like so happy. The newspaper packets weighed on her head. 
Their smell spoiled the taste of the eclairs. And she knew she would have to 
wait until dinner before Chrestomanci spoke to her about the lawn. 
Dinner was later that night because of the tea. Dusk was falling when they filed 
into the dining room. There were lighted candles all down the polished table. 
Cat could see them, and the rest of the room, reflected in the row of long 
windows facing him. It was a pleasing sight, and a useful one. Cat could see the 
footman coming. For once he was not taken by surprise when the man thrust a tray 
of little fish and pickled cabbage over his shoulder. And, as he was now 
forbidden to use his right hand, Cat felt quite justified in changing the 
serving things over. He began to feel he was settling in. 
Because he had not been allowed to talk about Art at tea, Mr. Saunders was more 
than usually eloquent at dinner. He talked and he talked. He took Chrestomanci's 
attention to himself, and he talked at him. Chrestomanci seemed dreamy and 
good-humored. He listened and nodded. And Gwendolen grew crosser every minute. 
Chrestomanci said not a word about lawns, neither here nor in the drawing room 
beforehand. It became clearer and clearer that no one was going to mention the 
matter at all. 
Gwendolen was furious. She wanted her powers recognized. She wanted to show 
Chrestomanci she was a witch to be reckoned with. So there was nothing for it 
but to begin on another spell. She was a little hampered by not having any 
ingredients to hand, but there was one thing she could do quite easily. 
The dinner went on. Mr. Saunders talked on. Footmen came around with the next 
course. Cat looked over at the windows to see when the silver plate would come 
to him. And he nearly screamed. 
There was a skinny white creature there. It was pressed against the dark outside 
of the glass, mouthing and waving. It looked like the lost ghost of a lunatic. 
It was weak and white and loathsome. It was draggled and slimy. Even though Cat 
realized almost at once that it was Gwendolen's doing, he still stared at it in 
horror. 
Millie saw him staring. She looked herself, shuddered, and tapped Chrestomanci 
gently on the back of the hand with her spoon. Chrestomanci came out of his 
gentle dream and glanced at the window too. He gave the piteous creature a bored 
look, and sighed. 
"And so I still think Florence is the finest of all the Italian states," said 
Mr. Saunders. 
"People usually put in a word for Venice," said Chrestomanci. "Frazier, would 
you draw the curtains, please? Thank you." 
"No, no. In my opinion, Venice is overrated," Mr. Saunders asserted, and he went 
on to explain why, while the butler drew the long orange curtains and shut the 
creature out of sight. 
"Yes, maybe you're right. Florence has more to offer," Chrestomanci agreed. "By 
the way, Gwendolen, when I said the Castle, I meant of course the Castle grounds 
as well as indoors. Now, do carry on, Michael. Venice." 
Everyone carried on, except Cat. He could imagine the creature still mouthing 
and fumbling at the glass behind the orange curtains. He could not eat for 
thinking of it. 
"It's all right, stupid! I've sent it away," said Gwendolen. Her voice was 
sticky with rage. 



6
Gwendolen gave vent to her fury in her room after dinner. She jumped on her bed 
and threw cushions about, screaming. Cat stood prudently back against the wall 
waiting for her to finish. But Gwendolen did not finish until she had pledged 
herself to a campaign against Chrestomanci. 
"I hate this place!" she bawled. "They try to cover everything up in soft, sweet 
niceness. I hate it, I hate it!" Her voice was muffled among the velvets of her 
room and swallowed up in the prevailing softness of the Castle. "Do you hear 
it?" Gwendolen screamed. "It's an eiderdown of hideous niceness! I wreck their 
lawn, so they give me tea. I conjure up a lovely apparition, and they have the 
curtains drawn. Frazier, would you draw the curtains, please! Ugh! Chrestomanci 
makes me sick!" 
"I didn't think it was a lovely apparition," Cat said, shivering. 
"Ha, ha! You didn't know I could do that, did you?" said Gwendolen. "It wasn't 
to frighten you, you idiot. It was to give Chrestomanci a shock. I hate him! He 
wasn't even interested." 
"What did he have us to live here for, if he isn't interested in you either?" 
Cat wondered. 
Gwendolen was rather struck by this. "I hadn't thought of that," she said. "It 
may be serious. Go away. I want to think about it. Anyway," she shouted, as Cat 
was going to the door, "he's going to be interested, if it's the last thing I 
do! I'm going to do something every day until he notices!" 
Once again, Cat was mournfully on his own. Remembering what Millie had said, he 
went along to the playroom. But Roger and Julia were there, playing with 
soldiers on the stained carpet. The little tin grenadiers were marching about. 
Some were wheeling up cannon. Others were lying behind cushions, firing their 
rifles with little pinpricks of bangs. Roger and Julia turned around guiltily. 
"You won't mention this, will you?" said Julia. "Would you like to come and play 
too?" Roger asked politely. 
"Oh, no thanks," Cat said hastily. He knew he could never join in this kind of 
game unless Gwendolen helped him. But he did not dare disturb Gwendolen in her 
present mood. And he had nothing to do. Then he remembered that Millie had 
obviously expected him to poke about the Castle more than he had done. So he set 
off to explore, feeling rather daring. 
The Castle seemed strange at night. There were dim little electric lights at 
regular intervals. The green carpet glowed gently, and things were reflected in 
the polished floor and walls even more strongly than they were by day. Cat 
walked softly along, accompanied by several reflected ghosts of himself, until 
he hardly felt real. All the doors he saw were closed. Cat listened at one or 
two and heard nothing. He had not quite the courage to open any of them. He went 
on and on. 
After a while he found he had somehow worked around to the older part of the 
Castle. Here the walls were whitewashed stone and all the windows went in nearly 
three feet before there was any glass. Then Cat came to a staircase which was 
the twin of the one that twisted up to his room, except that it twisted in the 
opposite direction. Cat went cautiously up it. 
He was just on the last bend when a door at the top opened. A brighter square of 
light shone on the wall at the head of the stairs, and a shadow stood in it that 
could only belong to Chrestomanci. No one else's shadow could be so tall, with 
such a smooth head and such a lot of ruffles on its shirt front. Cat stopped. 
"And let's hope the wretched girl won't try that again," Chrestomanci said, out 
of sight above. He sounded a good deal more alert than usual, and rather angry. 
Mr. Saunders' voice, from farther away, said, "I've had about enough of her 
already, frankly. I suppose she'll come to her senses soon. What possessed her 
to give away the source of her power like that?" 
"Ignorance," said Chrestomanci. "If I thought she had the least idea what she 
was doing, it would be the last thing she ever did in that line—or any other." 
"My back was to it," said Mr. Saunders. "Which was it? Number five?" 
"No. Number three, by the look of its hair. A revenant," said Chrestomanci. "For 
which we must be thankful." He began to come down the stairs. Cat was too scared 
to move. "I'll have to get the Examining Board to revise their Elementary Magic 
Courses," Chrestomanci called back as he came downstairs, "to include more 
theory. These hedge wizards push their good pupils straight on to advanced work 
without any proper grounding at all." Saying this, Chrestomanci came down around 
the corner and saw Cat. "Oh, hello," he said. "I'd no idea you were here. Like 
to come up and have a look at Michael's workshop?" 
Cat nodded. He did not dare do otherwise. 
Chrestomanci seemed quite friendly, however, and so did Mr. Saunders when 
Chrestomanci ushered Cat into the room at the top of the stairs. "Hello, Eric," 
he said in his cheerful way. "Have a look around. Does any of this mean anything 
to you?" 
Cat shook his head. The room was round, like his own, but larger, and it was a 
regular magician's workshop. That much he could see. He recognized the 
five-pointed star painted on the floor. The smell coming from the burning 
cresset hanging from the ceiling was the same smell that had hung about Coven 
Street, back in Wolvercote. But he had no idea of the use of the things set out 
on the various trestle tables. One table was crowded with torts and limbecks, 
some bubbling, some empty. A second was piled with books and scrolls. The third 
bench had signs chalked all over it and a mummified creature of some sort lying 
among the signs. 
Cat's eyes traveled over all this, and over more books crammed into shelves 
around the walls, and more shelves filled with jars of ingredients—big jars, 
like the ones in sweet shops. He realized Mr. Saunders worked in a big way. His 
scudding eyes raced over some of the labels on the huge jars: Newts' Eyes, Gum 
Arabic, Elixir St. John's Wort, Dragons' blood (dried). The last jar was almost 
full of dark brown powder. Cat's eyes went back to the mummified animal 
stretched among the signs chalked on the third table. Its feet had claws like a 
dog's. It looked like a large lizard. But there seemed to be wings on its back. 
Cat was almost sure it had once been a small dragon. 
"Means nothing, eh?" said Mr. Saunders. 
Cat turned around and found that Chrestomanci had gone. That made him a little 
easier. "This must have cost a lot," he said. 
"The taxpayer pays, fortunately," said Mr. Saunders. "Would you like to learn 
what all this is about?" 
"You mean, learn witchcraft?" Cat asked. "No. No thanks. I wouldn't be any good 
at it." 
"Well, I had at least two other things in mind besides witchcraft," Mr. Saunders 
said. "But what makes you think you'd be no good?" 
"Because I can't do it," Cat explained. "Spells just don't work for me." 
"Are you sure you went about them in the right way?" Mr. Saunders asked. He 
wandered up to the mummified dragon—or whatever—and gave it an absentminded 
flick. To Cat's disgust, the thing twitched all over. Filmy wings jerked and 
spread on its back. Then it went lifeless again. The sight sent Cat backing 
towards the door. He was almost as alarmed as he was the time Miss Larkins 
suddenly spoke with a man's voice. And, come to think of it, the voice had been 
not so unlike Mr. Saunders'. 
"I went about it every way I could think," Cat said, backing. "And I couldn't 
even turn buttons into gold. And that was simple." 
Mr. Saunders laughed. "Perhaps you weren't greedy enough. All right. Cut along, 
if you want to go." 
Cat fled, in great relief. As he ran through the strange corridors, he thought 
he ought to let Gwendolen know that Chrestomanci had, after all, been interested 
in her apparition, and even angry. But Gwendolen had locked her door and would 
not answer when he called to her. 
He tried again next morning. But before he had a chance to speak to Gwendolen, 
Euphemia came in, carrying a letter. As Gwendolen snatched it eagerly from 
Euphemia, Cat recognized Mr. Nostrum's jagged writing on the envelope. 
The next moment, Gwendolen was raging again. "Who did this? When did this come?" 
The envelope had been neatly cut open along the top. 
"This morning, by The postmark," said Euphemia. "And don't look at me like that. 
Miss Bessemer gave it to me open." 
"How dare she!" said Gwendolen. "How dare she read my letters! I'm going 
straight to Chrestomanci about this!" 
"You'll regret it if you do," said Euphemia, as Gwendolen pushed past her to the 
door. 
Gwendolen whirled around on her. "Oh, shut up, you stupid frog-faced girl!" Cat 
thought that was a little unfair. Euphemia, though she did have rather goggling 
eyes, was actually quite pretty. "Come on, Cat!" Gwendolen shouted at him, and 
she ran away along the corridor with her letter. Cat panted behind her and, once 
again, did not catch up with her until they were beside the marble staircase. 
"Chrestomanci!" bawled Gwendolen, thin and small and unechoing. 
Chrestomanci was coming up the marble staircase in a wide, flowing dressing gown 
that was partly orange and partly bright pink. He looked like the Emperor of 
Peru. By the suave, vague look on his face, he had not noticed Gwendolen and 
Cat. 
Gwendolen shouted down at him. "Here, you! Come here at once!" Chrestomanci's 
face turned upwards and his eyebrows went up. "Someone's been opening my 
letters," said Gwendolen. "And I don't care who it is, but I'm not having it! Do 
you hear?" 
Cat gasped at the way she spoke. Chrestomanci seemed perplexed. "How are you not 
having it?" he said. 
"I won't put up with it!" Gwendolen shouted at him. "In future, my letters are 
going to come to me closed!" 
"You mean you want me to steam them open and stick them down afterward?" 
Chrestomanci asked doubtfully. "It's more trouble, but I'll do that if it makes 
you happier." 
Gwendolen stared at him. "You mean you did it? You read a letter addressed to 
me?" 
Chrestomanci nodded blandly. "Naturally. If someone like Henry Nostrum writes 
letters to you, I have to make sure he's not writing anything unsuitable. He's a 
very seedy person." 
"He was my teacher!" Gwendolen said furiously. "You've no right to!" 
"It's a pity," said Chrestomanci, "that you were taught by a hedge wizard. 
You'll have to unlearn such a lot. And it's a pity too that I've no right to 
open your letters. I hope you don't get many, or my conscience will give me no 
peace." 
"You intend to go on?" Gwendolen said. "Then watch out. I warn you!" 
"That is very considerate of you," said Chrestomanci. "I like to be warned." He 
came up the rest of the marble stairs and went past Gwendolen and Cat. The pink 
and orange dressing gown swirled, revealing a bright scarlet lining. Cat 
blinked. 
Gwendolen stared vengefully as the dazzling dressing gown flowed away along the 
gallery. "Oh no, don't notice me, will you!" she said. "Make jokes. You wait! 
Cat, I'm so furious!" 
"You were awfully rude," said Cat. 
"He deserved it," said Gwendolen, and began to hurry back towards the playroom. 
"Opening poor Mr. Nostrum's letter! It isn't that I mind him reading it. We 
arranged a code, so horrid Chrestomanci will never know what it's really saying, 
but there is the signature. But it's the insult. The indignity. I'm at their 
mercy in this Castle. I'm all on my own in distress and I can't even stop them 
reading my letters. But I'll show them. You wait!" 
Cat knew better than to say anything. Gwendolen slammed into the playroom, 
flounced down at the table, and began at last to read her letter. 
"I told you so," said Euphemia, while Mary was working the lift. 
Gwendolen shot her a look. "You wait too," she said, and went on reading. After 
a bit, she looked in the envelope again. "There's one for you too," she said to 
Cat, and tossed him a sheet of paper. "Mind you reply to it." 
Cat took it, wondering nervously why Mr. Nostrum should write to him. But it was 
from Mrs. Sharp. She wrote: 
Me dear Cat, 
Ow are you doin then me love? I fine meself lonesum an missin you both 
particular you the place seems so quiete. Thourght I was lookin forward to a bit 
peace but missin yer voice an wishin you was comin in bringin appels. One thing 
happen an that was a gen-nelman come an give five poun for the ole cat that was 
yerfidel so I feel flush and had idear of packin you up a parsel of 
jinjerbredmen and mebbe bringin them to you one of these days but Mr. Nostrum 
sez not to. Spect your in the lap of luckshury anyhows. Love to Gwendolen. Wish 
you was back here Cat and the money means nothin. 
Your loving, Ellen Sharp 
Cat read this with a warm, smiling, tearful feeling. He found he was missing 
Mrs. Sharp as much as she evidently missed him. He was so homesick he could not 
eat his bread, and the cocoa seemed to choke him. He did not hear one word in 
five that Mr. Saunders said. 
"Is something the matter with you, Eric?" Mr. Saunders demanded. 
As Cat dragged his mind back from Coven Street, the window blacked out. The room 
was suddenly pitch dark. Julia squeaked. Mr. Saunders groped his way to the 
switch and turned the light on. As he did so, the window became transparent 
again, revealing Roger grinning, Julia startled, Gwendolen sitting demurely, and 
Mr. Saunders with his hand on the switch looking irritably at her. 
"I suppose the cause of this is outside the Castle grounds, is it?" he said. 
"Outside the lodge gates," Gwendolen said smugly. "I put it there this morning." 
By this, Cat knew her campaign against Chrestomanci had been launched. 
The window blacked out again. 
"How often are we to expect this?" Mr. Saunders said in the dark. 
"Twice every half hour," said Gwendolen. 
"Thank you," Mr. Saunders said nastily, and he left the light on. "Now we can 
see, Gwendolen, write out one hundred times, I must keep the spirit of the law 
and not the letter and, Roger, take that grin off your face." 
All that day, all the windows in the Castle blacked out regularly twice every 
half hour. But if Gwendolen had hoped to make Chrestomanci angry, she did not 
succeed. Nothing happened, except that everyone kept the lights on all the time. 
It was rather a nuisance, but no one seemed to mind. 
Before lunch, Cat went outside onto the lawn to see what the blackouts looked 
like from the other side. It was rather as if two black shutters wereflicking 
regularly across the rows of windows. They started at the top right-hand corner 
and flicked steadily across, along the next row from left to right, and then 
from right to left along the next, and so on, until they reached the bottom. 
Then they started at the top again. Cat had watched about half a complete 
performance when he found Roger beside him, watching critically with his pudgy 
hands in his pockets. 
"Your sister must have a very tidy mind," Roger said. 
"I think all witches have," said Cat. Then he was embarrassed. Of course he was 
talking to one—or at least to a warlock in the making. 
"I don't seem to have," Roger remarked, not in the least worried. "Nor has 
Julia. And I don't think Michael has, really. Would you like to come and play in 
our tree house after lessons?" 
Cat was very flattered. He was so pleased that he forgot how homesick he was. He 
spent a very happy evening down in the wood, helping to rebuild the roof of the 
tree house. He came back to the Castle when the dressing gong went, and found 
that the window-spell was fading. When the windows darkened, it only produced a 
sort of gray twilight indoors. By the following morning it was gone, and 
Chrestomanci had not said a word. 
Gwendolen returned to the attack the next morning. She caught the baker's boy as 
he cycled through the lodge gates with the square front container of his bicycle 
piled high with loaves for the Castle. The baker's boy arrived at the kitchen 
looking a little dazed and saying his head felt swimmy. As a consequence, the 
children had to have scones for breakfast. It seemed that when the bread was 
cut, the most interesting things happened. 
"You're giving us all a good laugh," Mary said, as she brought the scones from 
the lift. "I'll say that for your naughtiness, Gwendolen. Roberts thought he'd 
gone mad when he found he was cutting away at an old boot. So Cook cuts another, 
and next moment she and Nancy are trying to climb on the same chair because of 
all those white mice. But it was Mr. Frazier's face that made me laugh the most, 
when he says 'Let me' and finds himself chipping at a stone. Then the—" 
"Don't encourage her. You know what she's like," said Euphemia. 
"Be careful I don't start on you," Gwendolen said sourly. 
Roger found out privately from Mary what had happened to the other loaves. One 
had become a white rabbit, one had been an ostrich egg—which had burst 
tremendously all over the bootboy—and another a vast white onion. After that, 
Gwendolen's invention had run out and she had turned the rest into cheese. "Old 
bad cheese, though," Roger said, giving honor where honor was due. 
It was not known whether Chrestomanci also gave honor where it was due because, 
once again, he said not a word to anyone. 
The next day was Saturday. Gwendolen caught the farmer delivering the churn of 
milk the Castle used daily. The breakfast cocoa tasted horrible. 
"I'm beginning to get annoyed," Julia said tartly. "Daddy may take no notice, 
but he drinks tea with lemon." She stared meaningly at Gwendolen. Gwendolen 
stared back, and there was that invisible feeling of clashing Cat had noticed 
when Gwendolen had wanted her mother's earrings from Mrs. Sharp. This time, 
however, Gwendolen did not have things all her own way. She lowered her eyes and 
looked peevish. 
"I'm getting sick of getting up early, anyway," she said crossly. 
This, from Gwendolen, simply meant she would do something later in the day in 
future. But Julia thought she had beaten Gwendolen, and this was a mistake. 
They had lessons on Saturday morning, which annoyed Gwendolen very much. "It's 
monstrous," she said to Mr. Saunders. "Why do we have to be tormented like 
this?" 
"It's the price I have to pay for my holiday on Wednesday," Mr. Saunders told 
her. "And, speaking of tormenting, I prefer you to bewitch something other than 
the milk." 
"I'll remember that," Gwendolen said sweetly. 



7
It rained on Saturday afternoon. Gwendolen shut herself into her room and, once 
again, Cat did not know what to do. He wrote to Mrs. Sharp on the back of his 
postcard of the Castle, but that only took ten minutes, and it was too wet to go 
out and mail it. Cat was hanging about at the foot of his stairs, wondering what 
to do now, when Roger came out of the playroom and saw him. 
"Oh, good," said Roger. "Julia won't play soldiers. Will you?" 
"But I can't—not like you do," Cat said. 
"It doesn't matter," said Roger. "Honestly." 
But it did. No matter how cunningly Cat deployed his lifeless tin army, as soon 
as Roger's soldiers began to march, Cat's men fell over like ninepins. They fell 
in batches and droves and in battalions. Cat moved them furiously this way and 
that, grabbing them by handfuls and scooping them with the lid of the box, but 
he was always on the retreat. In five minutes he was reduced to three soldiers 
hidden behind a cushion. 
"This is no good," said Roger. 
"No, it isn't," Cat agreed mournfully. 
"Julia," said Roger. 
"What?" said Julia. She was curled in the shabbiest armchair, managing to suck a 
lollipop, to read a book called In the Hands of the Lamas, and to knit, all at 
the same time. Her knitting, hardly surprisingly, looked like a vest for a 
giraffe which had been dipped in six shades of gray dye. 
"Can you make Cat's soldiers move for him?" said Roger. 
"I'm reading," said Julia, around the edges of the lollipop. "It's thrilling. 
One of them's got lost and they think he's perished miserably." 
"Be a sport," said Roger. "I'll tell you whether he did perish, if you don't." 
"If you do, I'll turn your underpants to ice," Julia said amiably. "All right." 
Without taking her eyes off her book or the lollipop out of her mouth, she 
fumbled out her handkerchief and tied a knot in it. She laid the knotted 
handkerchief on the arm of her chair and went on knitting. 
Cat's fallen soldiers picked themselves up from the floor and straightened their 
tin tunics. This was a great improvement, though it was still not entirely 
satisfactory. Cat could not tell his soldiers what to do. He had to shoo them 
into position with his hands. The soldiers did not seem happy. They looked up at 
the great flapping hands above them in the greatest consternation. Cat was sure 
one fainted from terror. But he got them positioned in The battle began. The 
soldiers seemed to know how to do that for themselves. Cat had a company in 
reserve behind a cushion and, when the battle was at its fiercest, he shooed 
them out to fall on Roger's right wing. Roger's right wing turned and fought. 
And every one of Cat's reserve turned and ran. The rest of his army saw them 
running away and ran too. In three seconds, they were all trying to hide in the 
toy cupboard, and Roger's soldiers were cutting them down in swathes. 
Roger was exasperated. "Julia's soldiers always run away!" 
"Because that's just what I would do," Julia said, putting out a knitting needle 
to mark her place in her book. "I can't think why all soldiers don't." 
"Well, make them a bit braver," said Roger. "It's not fair on Eric." 
"You only said make them move," Julia was arguing when the door opened and 
Gwendolen put her head in. 
"I want Cat," she said. 
"He's busy," said Roger. 
"That doesn't matter," said Gwendolen. "I need him." 
Julia stretched out a knitting needle towards Gwendolen and wrote a little cross 
in the air with it. The cross floated, glowing, for a second. "Out," said Julia. 
"Go away." Gwendolen backed away from the cross and shut the door again. It was 
as if she could not help herself. The expression on her face was very annoyed 
indeed. Julia smiled placidly and pointed her knitting needle towards Cat's 
soldiers. "Carry on," she said. "I've filled their hearts with courage." 
When the dressing gong sounded, Cat went to find out what Gwendolen had wanted 
him for. Gwendolen was very busy reading a fat, new-looking book and could not 
spare him any attention at first. Cat tipped his head sideways and read the 
title of the book. Otherworld Studies, Series III. While he was doing it, 
Gwendolen began to laugh. "Oh, I see how it works now!" she exclaimed. "It's 
even better than I thought! I know what to do now!" Then she lowered the book 
and asked Cat what he thought he was doing. 
"Why did you need me?" said Cat. "Where did you get that book?" 
"From the Castle library," said Gwendolen. "And I don't need you now. I was 
going to explain to you about Mr. Nostrum's plans, and I might even have told 
you about mine, but I changed my mind when you just sat there and let that fat 
prig Julia send me away." 
"I didn't know Mr. Nostrum had any plans," Cat said. "The dressing gong's gone." 

"Of course he has plans—and I heard it—why do you think I wrote to 
Chrestomanci?" said Gwendolen. "But it's no good trying to wheedle me. I'm not 
going to tell you and you're going to be sorry. And piggy-priggy Julia is going 
to be sorrier even sooner!" 
Gwendolen revenged herself on Julia at the start of dinner. A footman was just 
passing a bowl of soup over Julia's shoulder when the skirt of Julia's dress 
turned to snakes. Julia jumped up with a shriek. Soup poured over the snakes and 
flew far and wide, and the footman yelled, "Lord have mercy on us!" among the 
sounds of the smashing soup bowl. 
Then there was dead silence, except for the hissing of snakes. There were twenty 
of them, hanging by their tails from Julia's waistband, writhing and striking. 
Everyone froze, with their heads stiffly turned Julia's way. Julia stood like a 
statue, with her arms up out of reach of the snakes. She swallowed and said the 
words of a spell. 
Nobody blamed her. Mr. Saunders said, "Good girl!" 
Under the spell, the snakes stiffened and fanned out, so that they were standing 
like a ballet skirt above Julia's petticoats. Everyone could see where Julia had 
torn a flounce of a petticoat building the tree house and mended it in a hurry 
with red darning wool. 
"Have you been bitten?" said Chrestomanci. 
"No," said Julia. "The soup muddled them. If you don't mind, I'll go and change 
this dress now." 
She left the room, walking very slowly and carefully, and Millie went with her. 
While the footmen, all rather green in the face, were clearing up the spilled 
soup, Chrestomanci said, "Spitefulness is one thing I won't have at the dinner 
table. Gwendolen, oblige me by going to the playroom. Your food will be brought 
to you there." 
Gwendolen got up and went without a word. As Julia and Millie did not come back, 
the dining table seemed rather empty that evening. It was all stocks and shares 
from Bernard at one end, and statues again from Mr. Saunders at the other. 
Cat found that Gwendolen was rather triumphant. She felt she had made an 
impression on Chrestomanci at last. So she returned to the attack with a will on 
Sunday. 
On Sunday the Family dressed in its best and walked down to Morning Service at 
the village church. Witches are not supposed to like church. Nor are they 
supposed to be able to work magic there. But this never bothered Gwendolen at 
all. Mrs. Sharp had many times remarked on it, as showing what exceptional 
talents Gwendolen had. Gwendolen sat next to Cat in the Chrestomanci pew, 
looking the picture of demure innocence in her broiderie anglaise Sunday dress 
and hat, and found her place in her prayer book as if she were truly saintly. 
The village people nudged one another and whispered about her. This rather 
pleased Gwendolen. She liked to be well known. She kept up the pretense of 
saintliness until the sermon had begun. 
The vicar climbed shakily into the pulpit and gave his text in a weak, wandering 
voice. "For there were many in the congregation that were not sanctified." This 
was certainly to the point. Unfortunately, nothing else he said was. He told, in 
his weak, wandering voice, of weak, wandering episodes in his early life. He 
compared them with weak, wandering things he thought were happening in the world 
today. He told them they had better be sanctified or all sorts of things—which 
he forgot to mention—would happen, which reminded him of a weak, wandering thing 
his aunts used to tell him. 
Mr. Saunders was asleep by this time, and so was stocks-and-shares Bernard. The 
old lady with mittens was nodding. One of the saints in the stained-glass 
windows yawned, and put up his crosier elegantly to cover his mouth. He looked 
around at his neighbor, who was a formidable nun. Her robes hung in severe 
folds, like a bundle of sticks. The bishop stretched out his stained-glass 
crosier and tapped the nun on the shoulder. She resented it. She marched into 
his window and began shaking him. 
Cat saw her. He saw the colored, transparent bishop clouting the nun over the 
wimple, and the nun giving him as good as she got. Meanwhile, the hairy saint 
next to them made a dive for his neighbor, who was a kingly sort of saint, 
holding a model of the Castle. The kingly saint dropped his model and fled for 
protection, in a twinkle of glassy feet, behind the robes of a simpering lady 
saint. The hairy saint jumped gleefully up and down on the model of the Castle. 
One by one, all the windows came to life. Almost every saint turned and fought 
the one next to him. Those who had no one to fight either hitched up their robes 
and did silly dances, or waved to the vicar, who rambled on without noticing. 
The little tiny people blowing trumpets in the corners of the windows sprang and 
gamboled and frisked, and pulled transparent faces at anyone who was looking. 
The hairy saint winkled the kingly one out from behind the simpering lady and 
chased him from window to window in and out of all the other fighting couples. 
By this time, the whole congregation had seen. Everyone stared, or whispered, or 
leaned craning this way and that to watch the twinkling glass toes of the kingly 
saint. 
There was such a disturbance that Mr. Saunders woke up, puzzled. He looked at 
the windows, understood, and looked sharply at Gwendolen. She sat with her eyes 
demurely cast down, the picture of innocence. Cat glanced at Chrestomanci. For 
all he could tell, Chrestomanci was attending to the vicar's every word and had 
not even noticed the windows. Millie was sitting on the edge of her seat, 
looking agitated. And the vicar still rambled on, quite unconscious of the 
turmoil. 
The curate, however, felt he ought to put a stop to the unseemly behavior of the 
windows. He fetched a cross and a candle. Followed by a giggling choirboy 
swinging incense, he went from window to window murmuring exorcisms. Gwendolen 
obligingly stopped each saint in its tracks as he came to it—which meant that 
the kingly saint was stranded halfway across the wall. But, as soon as the 
curate's back was turned, he began to run again, and the free-for-all went on 
more riotously than before. The congregation rolled about, gasping. 
Chrestomanci turned and looked at Mr. Saunders. Mr. Saunders nodded. There was a 
sort of flicker, which jolted Cat where he sat and, when he looked at the 
windows, every saint was standing stiff and glassy there, as they should be. 
Gwendolen's head came up indignantly. Then she shrugged. At the back of the 
church a great stone crusader sat up on his tomb and, with much rasping of 
stone, thumbed his nose at the vicar. 
"Dearly beloved—" said the vicar. He saw the crusader. He stopped, confounded. 
The curate hastened up and tried to exorcise the crusader. A look of irritation 
crossed the crusader's face. He lifted his great stone sword. But Mr. Saunders 
made a sharp gesture. The crusader, looking even more irritated, lowered his 
sword and lay down again with a thump that shook the church. 
"There are some in this congregation who are certainly not sanctified," the 
vicar said sadly. "Let us pray." 
When everyone straggled out of church, Gwendolen sauntered out among them, quite 
impervious to the shocked looks everyone gave her as she passed. Millie hurried 
after her and seized her arm. She looked most upset. "That was disgraceful, you 
ungodly child! I don't dare speak to the poor vicar. There is such a thing as 
going too far, you know!" 
"Have I gone it?" Gwendolen asked, really interested. 
"Very nearly," said Millie. 
But not quite, it seemed. Chrestomanci did not say anything to Gwendolen, though 
he said a great deal, very soothingly, both to the vicar and to the curate. 
"Why doesn't your father tell Gwendolen off?" Cat asked Roger as they walked 
back up the avenue. "Taking no notice of her just makes her worse." 
"I don't know," said Roger. "He comes down on us hard enough if we use 
witchcraft. Perhaps he thinks she'll get tired of it. Has she told you what 
she's going to do tomorrow?" It was clear Roger could hardly wait. 
"No. She's cross with me for playing soldiers with you," said Cat. 
"Her stupid fault for thinking she owns you," said Roger. "Let's get into old 
clothes and build some more of the tree house." 
Gwendolen was angry when Cat went off with Roger again. Maybe that was why she 
thought of what she did next. Or perhaps, as she said, she had other reasons. At 
all events, when Cat woke up on Monday morning, it was dark. It felt very early. 
It looked even earlier. So Cat turned over and went to sleep again. 
He was astonished to find Mary shaking him a minute later. "It's twenty to nine, 
Eric. Get up, do!" 
"But it's dark!" Cat protested. "Is it raining?" 
"No," said Mary. "Your sister's been hard at it again. And where she gets the 
strength from, a little girl like her, beats me!" 
Feeling tired and Mondayish, Cat dragged himself out of bed and found he could 
not see out of the windows. Each window was a dark crisscross of branches and 
leaves—green leaves, bluish cedar sprays, pine needles, and leaves just turning 
yellow and brown. One window had a rose pressed against it, and there were 
bunches of grapes squashed on both of the others. And behind them, it looked as 
if there was a mile-thick forest. "Good Lord!" he said. 
"You may well look!" said Mary. "That sister of yours has fetched every tree in 
the grounds and stood them as close as they can get to the Castle. You wonder 
what she'll think of next." 
The darkness made Cat weary and gloomy. He did not want to get dressed. But Mary 
stood over him, and made him wash too. The reason she was so dutiful, Cat 
suspected, was that she wanted to tell someone all about the difficulties the 
trees were causing. She told Cat that the yew trees from the formal garden were 
packed so tight by the kitchen door that the men had to hack a path for the milk 
to come through. There were three oak trees against the main front door, and no 
one could budge it. "And the apples are all underfoot among the yew trees, so it 
smells like a cider press in the kitchen," Mary said. 
When Cat arrived wearily in the playroom, it was even darker there. In the deep 
greenish light, he could see that Gwendolen was, understandably, white and 
tired. But she looked satisfied enough. 
"I don't think I like these trees," Cat whispered to her when Roger and Julia 
had gone through to the schoolroom. "Why couldn't you do something smaller and 
funnier?" 
"Because I'm not a laughingstock!" Gwendolen hissed back. "And I needed to do 
it. I had to know how much power I could draw on." 
"Quite a lot, I should think," Cat said, looking at the mass of horse-chestnut 
leaves pressed against the window. 
Gwendolen smiled. "Better still when I've got my dragons' blood." 
Cat nearly blurted out that he had seen dragons' blood in Mr. Saunders' 
workshop. But he stopped himself in time. He did not care for mighty works like 
this. 
They spent another morning with the lights on, and at lunchtime, Cat, Julia, and 
Roger went out to have a look at the trees. They were disappointed to find that 
it was quite easy to get out of their private door. The rhododendrons were three 
feet away from it. Cat thought Gwendolen must intentionally have left them a way 
out, until he looked up and saw, from their bent branches and mashed leaves, 
that the bushes had indeed been squashed against the door earlier. It looked as 
if the trees were retreating. 
Beyond the rhododendrons, they had to fight their way through something like a 
jungle. The trees were rammed so tight that, not only had twigs and leaves 
broken off by cartloads, but great branches had been torn away too, and fallen 
tangled with smashed roses, broken clematis, and mangled grapes. When the 
children tore themselves out on the other side of the jungle, blank daylight hit 
them like a hammer blow. They blinked. The gardens, the village, and even the 
hills beyond were bald. The only place where they could still see trees was 
above the old, gray, ruined wall of Chrestomanci's garden. 
"It must have been a strong spell," said Roger. 
"It's like a desert," said Julia. "I never thought I'd miss the trees so much!" 
But halfway through the afternoon it became clear that the trees were going back 
to their proper places. They could see sky through the schoolroom window. A 
little later the trees had spread out and retreated so much that Mr. Saunders 
turned the light off. Shortly after that Cat and Roger noticed the ruins of the 
tree house, smashed to bits in the crowding, dangling-out of a chestnut tree. 
"Now what are you staring at?" said Mr. Saunders. 
"The tree house is broken," Roger said, looking moodily at Gwendolen. 
"Perhaps Gwendolen would be kind enough to mend it again," Mr. Saunders 
suggested sarcastically. 
If he was trying to goad Gwendolen into doing a kindly act, he failed. Gwendolen 
tossed her head. "Tree houses are stupid babyish things," she said coldly. She 
was very annoyed at the way the trees were retreating. "It's too bad!" she told 
Cat just before dinner. By that time the trees were almost back to their usual 
places. The only ones nearer than they should be were those on the hill 
opposite. The view looked smaller, somehow. "I hoped it would do for tomorrow 
too," Gwendolen said discontentedly. "Now I shall have to think of something 
else." 
"Who sent them back? The garden warlocks?" Cat asked. 
"I wish you wouldn't talk nonsense," said Gwendolen. "It's obvious who did it." 
"You mean Mr. Saunders?" said Cat. "But couldn't the spell have been used up 
just pulling all the trees here?" 
"You don't know a thing about it," said Gwendolen. 
Cat knew he knew nothing of magic, but he found it queer all the same. The next 
day, when he went to see, there were no fallen twigs, torn-off branches, or 
squashed grapes anywhere. The yew trees in the formal garden did not seem to 
have been hacked at all. And though there was not a trace of an apple underfoot 
around the kitchen, there were boxes of firm, round apples in the courtyard. In 
the orchard, the apples were all either hanging on the trees or being picked and 
put in more boxes. 
While Cat was finding this out, he had to flatten himself hastily against one of 
the hedge-like apple trees to make way for a galloping Jersey cow pursued by two 
gardeners and a farm boy. There were cows galloping in the wood when Cat went 
hopefully to look at the tree house. Alas, that was still a ruin. And the cows 
were doing their best to ruin the flowerbeds and not making much impression. 
"Did you do the cows?" he asked Gwendolen. 
"Yes. But it was just something to show them I'm not giving up," said Gwendolen. 
"I shall get my dragons' blood tomorrow and then I can do something really 
impressive." 



8
Gwendolen went down to the village to get her dragons' blood on Wednesday 
afternoon. She was in high glee. There were to be guests that night at the 
Castle and a big dinner party. Cat knew that everyone had carefully not 
mentioned it before, for fear Gwendolen would take advantage of it. But she had 
to be told on Wednesday morning because there were special arrangements for the 
children. They were to have their supper in the playroom, and they were supposed 
to keep out of the way after that. 
"I'll keep out of the way, all right," Gwendolen promised. "But that won't make 
any difference." She chuckled about it all the way to the village. 
Cat was embarrassed when they got to the village. Everyone avoided Gwendolen. 
Mothers dragged their children indoors and snatched babies out of her way. 
Gwendolen hardly noticed. She was too intent on getting to Mr. Baslam and 
getting her dragons' blood. Cat did not fancy Mr. Baslam, or the decaying pickle 
smell among his stuffed animals. He let Gwendolen go there on her own, and went 
to mail his postcard to Mrs. Sharp in the sweet shop. The people there were 
rather cool with him, even though he spent nearly two shillings on sweets, and 
they were positively cold in the cake shop next door. When Cat came out onto the 
green with his parcels, he found that children were being snatched out of his 
way too. 
This so shamed Cat that he fled back to the Castle grounds and did not wait for 
Gwendolen. There he wandered moodily, eating toffees and penny buns, and wishing 
he was back with Mrs. Sharp. From time to time he saw Gwendolen in the distance. 
Sometimes she was dashing about. Sometimes she was squatting under a tree, 
carefully doing something. Cat did not go near her. If they were back with Mrs. 
Sharp, he thought, Gwendolen would not need to do whatever impressive thing she 
was planning. He found himself wishing she was not quite such a strong and 
determined witch. He tried to imagine a Gwendolen who was not a witch, but he 
found himself quite unable to. She just would not be Gwendolen. 
Indoors, the usual silence of the Castle was not quite the same. There were 
tense little noises, and the thrumming feeling of people diligently busy just 
out of earshot. Cat knew it was going to be a big, important dinner party. 
After supper, he craned out of Gwendolen's window watching the guests come up 
the piece of avenue he could see from there. They came in carriages and in cars, 
all very large and rich-looking. One carriage was drawn by six white horses and 
looked so impressive that Cat wondered if it might not even be the King. 
"All the better," said Gwendolen. She was squatting in the middle of the carpet, 
beside a sheet of paper. At one end of the paper was a bowl of ingredients. At 
the other crawled, wriggled, or lay a horrid heap of things. Gwendolen had 
collected two frogs, an earthworm, several earwigs, a black beetle, a spider, 
and a little pile of bones. The live things were charmed and could not move off 
the paper. 
As soon as Cat was sure that there were no more carriages arriving, Gwendolen 
began pounding the ingredients together in the bowl. As she pounded, she 
muttered things in a groaning hum, and her hair hung down and quivered over the 
bowl. Cat looked at the wriggling, hopping creatures and hoped that they were 
not going to be pounded up as ingredients too. It seemed not. Gwendolen at 
length sat back on her heels and said, "Now!" 
She snapped her fingers over the bowl. The ingredients caught fire, all by 
themselves, and burned with small blue flames. "It's working!" Gwendolen said 
excitedly. She snatched up a twist of newspaper from beside her and carefully 
untwisted it. "Now for a pinch of dragons' blood." She took a pinch of the dark 
brown powder and sprinkled it on the flames. There was a fizzing, and a thick 
smell of burning. Then the flames leaped up, a foot high, blazing a furious 
green and purple, coloring the whole room with dancing light. 
Gwendolen's face glowed in the green and purple. She rocked on her heels, 
chanting, chanting strings of things Cat could not understand. Then, still 
chanting, she leaned over and touched the spider. The spider grew. And grew. And 
grew more. It grew into a five-foot monster—a greasy roundness with two little 
eyes on the front, hanging like a hammock amid eight bent and jointed furry 
legs. Gwendolen pointed. The door of her room sprang open of its own 
accord—which made her smile exultantly—and the huge spider went silently 
creeping towards it, swaying on its hairy legs. It squeezed its legs inward to 
get through the door, and crept onward, down the passage beyond. 
Gwendolen touched the other creatures, one by one. The earwigs lumbered up and 
off, like shiny horned cows, bright brown and glistening. The frogs rose up, as 
big as men, and walked flap, flop on their enormous feet, with their arms 
trailing like gorillas. Their mottled skin quivered, and little holes in it kept 
opening and shutting. The puffy place under their chins made gulping movements. 
The black beetle crawled on branched legs, such a big black slab that it could 
barely get through the door. Cat could see it, and all the others, going in a 
slow, silent procession down the grass-green glowing corridor. 
"Where are they going?" he whispered. 
Gwendolen chuckled. "I'm sending them to the dining room, of course. I don't 
think the guests will want much supper." 
She took up a bone next, and knocked each end of it sharply on the floor. As 
soon as she let go of it, it floated up into the air. There was a soft 
clattering, and more bones came out of nowhere to join it. The green and purple 
flames roared and rasped. A skull arrived last of all, and a complete skeleton 
was dangling there in front of the flames. Gwendolen smiled with satisfaction 
and took up another bone. 
But bones when they are bewitched have a way of remembering who they were. The 
dangling skeleton sighed, in a hollow, singing voice, "Poor Sarah Jane. I'm poor 
Sarah Jane. Let me rest." 
Gwendolen waved it impatiently towards the door. It went dangling off, still 
sighing, and a second skeleton dangled after it, sighing, "Bob the gardener's 
boy. I din't mean to do it." They were followed by three more, each one singing 
softly and desolately of who it had been, and all five went slowly dangling 
after the black beetle. "Sarah Jane," Cat heard from the corridor. "I din't mean 
to." "I was Duke of Buckingham once." 
Gwendolen took no notice of them and turned to the earthworm. It grew too. It 
grew into a massive pink thing as big as a sea serpent. Loops of it rose and 
fell and writhed all over the room. Cat was nearly sick. Its bare pink flesh had 
hairs on it like a pig's bristles. There were rings on it like the wrinkles 
around his own knuckles. Its great sightless front turned blindly this way and 
that until Gwendolen pointed to the door. Then it set off slowly after the 
skeletons, length after length of bare pink loops. 
Gwendolen looked after it critically. "Not bad," she said. "I need one last 
touch though." 
Carefully, she dropped another tiny pinch of dragons' blood on the flames. They 
burned with a whistling sound—brighter, sicker, yellower. Gwendolen began to 
chant again, waving her arms this time. After a moment, a shape seemed to be 
gathering in the quivering air over the flames. Whiteness was boiling, moving, 
forming into a miserable bent thing with a big head. Three more somethings were 
roiling and hardening beneath it. When the first thing flopped out of the flames 
onto the carpet, Gwendolen gave a gurgle of pleasure. Cat was amazed at how 
wicked she looked. 
"Oh don't!" he said. The three other somethings flopped onto the carpet too, and 
he saw they were the apparition at the window and three others like it. The 
first was like a baby that was too small to walk—except that it was walking, 
with its big head wobbling. The next was a cripple, so twisted and cramped upon 
itself that it could barely hobble. The third was the apparition at the 
window—pitiful, wrinkled, and draggled. The last had its white skin barred with 
blue stripes. All were weak and white and horrible. Cat shuddered all over. 
"Please send them away!" he said. 
Gwendolen only laughed again and waved the four apparitions towards the door. 
They set off, toiling weakly. But they were only halfway there when Chrestomanci 
came through the door and Mr. Saunders came after him. In front of them came a 
shower of bones and small dead creatures, pattering onto the carpet and getting 
squashed under Chrestomanci's long, shiny shoes. The apparitions hesitated, 
gibbering. Then they fled back to the flaming bowl and vanished. The flames 
vanished at the same time, into thick, black, smelly smoke. 
Gwendolen stared at Chrestomanci and Mr. Saunders through the smoke. 
Chrestomanci was magnificent in dark blue velvet, with lace ruffles at his 
wrists and on the front of his shirt. Mr. Saunders seemed to have made an effort 
to find a suit that reached to the ends of his legs and arms, but had not quite 
succeeded. One of his big, black patent-leather boots was unlaced, and there was 
a lot of shirt and wrist showing as he slowly coiled an invisible skein of 
something around his bony right hand. Both he and Chrestomanci looked back at 
Gwendolen most unpleasantly. 
"You were warned, you know," Chrestomanci said. "Carry on, Michael." 
Mr. Saunders put the invisible skein in his pocket. "Thanks," he said. "I've 
been itching to for a week now." He strode down on Gwendolen in a billow of 
black coat, yanked her to her feet, hauled her to a chair, and put her facedown 
over his knee. There he dragged off his unlaced, big black boot and commenced 
spanking her with it hard and often. 
While Mr. Saunders labored away, and Gwendolen screamed and squirmed and kicked, 
Chrestomanci marched up to Cat and boxed Cat's ears, twice on each side. Cat was 
so surprised that he would have fallen over, had not Chrestomanci hit the other 
side of his head each time and brought him upright again. 
"What did you do that for?" Cat said indignantly, clutching both sides of his 
ringing face. "I didn't do anything." 
"That's why I hit you," said Chrestomanci. "You didn't try to stop her, did 
you?" While Cat was gasping at the unfairness of this, he turned to the laboring 
Mr. Saunders. "I think that'll do now, Michael." 
Mr. Saunders ceased swatting, rather regretfully. Gwendolen slid to her knees on 
the floor, sobbing with pain, and making screams in between her sobs at being 
treated like this. 
Chrestomanci went over and poked at her with his shiny foot. "Stop it. Get up 
and behave yourself." And, when Gwendolen rose to her knees, staring piteously 
and looking utterly wronged, he said, "You thoroughly deserved that spanking. 
And, as you probably realize, Michael has taken away your witchcraft too. You're 
not a witch any longer. In future, you are not going to work one spell, unless 
you can prove to both of us that you are not going to do mischief with it. Is 
that clear? Now go to bed, and for goodness sake try and think about what you've 
been doing." 
He nodded to Mr. Saunders, and they both went out, Mr. Saunders hopping because 
he was still putting his boot back on, and squashing the rest of the dead 
creatures as he hopped. 
Gwendolen flopped forward on her face and drummed her toes on the carpet. "The 
beast! The beasts! How dare they treat me like this! I shall do a worse thing 
than this now, and serve you all right!" 
"But you can't do things without witchcraft," Cat said. "Was what Mr. Saunders 
was winding up your witchcraft?" 
"Go away!" Gwendolen screamed at him. "Leave me alone. You're as bad as the rest 
of them!" And, as Cat went to the door, leaving her drumming and sobbing, she 
raised her head and shouted after him, "I'm not beaten yet! You'll see!" 
Not surprisingly, Cat had bad dreams that night. They were terrible dreams, full 
of giant earthworms and great, slimy, porous frogs. They became more and more 
feverish. Cat sweated and moaned and finally woke up, feeling wet and weak and 
rather too bony, the way you do when you have just had a bad illness or a 
fearsome dream. He lay for a little while feeling wretched. Then he began to 
feel better and fell asleep again. 
When Cat woke again, it was light. He opened his eyes on the snowy silence of 
the Castle and was suddenly convinced that Gwendolen had done something else. He 
had no idea what made him so sure. He thought he was probably imagining it. If 
Mr. Saunders had truly taken Gwendolen's witchcraft away from her, she could not 
have done a thing. But he still knew she had. 
He got up and padded to the windows to see what it was. But, for once, there was 
nothing abnormal about the view from any of them. The cedars spread above the 
lawn. The gardens blazed down the hill. The day was swimming in sun and mist, 
and not so much as a footprint marked the pearly gray-green of the grass. But 
Cat was still so sure that something, somewhere, was different that he got 
dressed and stole off downstairs to ask Gwendolen what she had done. 
When Cat opened the door of her room, he could smell the sweet, charred, heavy 
smell that went with witchcraft. But that could have been left over from last 
night. The room was quite tidy. The dead creatures and the burned bowl had been 
cleared away. The only thing out of place was Gwendolen's box, which had been 
pulled out of the painted wardrobe and stood with its lid half off near her bed. 

Gwendolen was a sleeping hump under the blue velvet bedspread. Cat shut the door 
very gently behind him, in order not to disturb her. Gwendolen heard it. She sat 
up in bed with a bounce and stared at him. 
As soon as she did, Cat knew that whatever was wrong, it was wrong with 
Gwendolen herself. She had her nightdress on back to front. The ribbons which 
usually tied it at the back were dangling at the front. That was the only thing 
obviously wrong. But there was something odd about the way Gwendolen was staring 
at him. She was astonished, and rather frightened. 
"Who are you?" she said. 
"I'm Cat, of course," said Cat. 
"No you're not. You're a boy," said Gwendolen. "Who are you?" 
Cat realized that when witches lost their witchcraft, they also lost their 
memories. He saw he would have to be very patient with Gwendolen. "I'm your 
brother, Eric," he said patiently, and came across to the bed so that she could 
look at him. "Only you always call me Cat." 
"My brother!" she exclaimed, in the greatest astonishment. "Well, that can't be 
bad. I've always wanted a brother. And I know I can't be dreaming. It was too 
cold in the bath, and it hurts when I pinch myself. So would you mind telling me 
where I am? It's a Stately Home of some kind, isn't it?" 
Cat stared at her. He began to suspect that her memory was perfectly good. It 
was not only the way she spoke and what she said. She was thinner than she 
should be. Her face was the right pretty face, with the right blue eyes, but the 
downright look on it was not right. The golden hair hanging over her shoulders 
was an inch longer than it had been last night. 
"You're not Gwendolen!" he said. 
"What a dreadful name!" said the girl in the bed. "I should hope not! I'm Janet 
Chant." 



9
By this time, Cat was as bewildered as the strange girl seemed to be. Chant? he 
thought. Chant? Has Gwendolen a twin sister she hasn't told me about? "But my 
name's Chant too," he said. 
"Is it, now?" said Janet. She knelt up in bed and scrubbed her hands 
thoughtfully about in her hair, in a way Gwendolen never would have done. "Truly 
Chant? It's not that much of a common name. And you thought I was your sister? 
Well, I've put two and two together about a hundred times since I woke up in the 
bath, and I keep getting five. Where are we?" 
"In Chrestomanci Castle," said Cat. "Chrestomanci had us to live here about a 
year after our parents died." 
"There you are!" said Janet. "My mum and dad are alive and kicking—or they were 
when I said good night to them last night. Who's Chrestomanci? Could you just 
sketch your life history for me?" 
Puzzled and uneasy, Cat described how and why he and Gwendolen had come to live 
in the Castle, and what Gwendolen had done then. 
"You mean Gwendolen really was a witch!" Janet exclaimed. 
Cat wished she had not said was. He had a growing suspicion that he would never 
see the real Gwendolen again. "Of course she is," he said. "Aren't you?" 
"Great heavens, no!" said Janet. "Though I'm beginning to wonder if I mightn't 
have been, if I'd lived here all my life. Witches are quite common, are they?" 
"And warlocks and necromancers," said Cat. "But wizards and magicians don't 
happen so often. I think Mr. Saunders is a magician." 
"Medicine men, witch doctors, shamans, devils, enchanters?" Janet asked rapidly. 
"Hags, fakirs, sorcerers? Are they thick on the ground too?" 
"Most of those are for savages," Cat explained. "Hag is rude. But we have 
sorcerers and enchanters. Enchanters are very strong and important. I've never 
met one." 
"I see," said Janet. She thought for a moment and then swung herself out of bed, 
in a sort of scramble that was more like a boy's than a girl's, and again quite 
unlike the way Gwendolen would have done it. "We'd better have a hunt around," 
she said, "in case dear Gwendolen has been kind enough to leave a message." 
"Don't call her that," Cat said desolately. "Where do you think she is?" 
Janet looked at him and saw he was miserable. "Sorry," she said. "I won't again. 
But you do see I might be a bit cross with her, don't you? She seems to have 
dumped me here and gone off somewhere. Let's hope she has a good explanation." 
"They spanked her with a boot and took away her magic," Cat said. 
"Yes, you said," Janet replied, pulling open drawers in the golden dressing 
table. "I'm terrified of Chrestomanci already. But did they really take away her 
magic? How did she manage to do this, if they did?" 
"I don't understand that either," Cat said, joining in the search. By now, he 
would have given his little finger for a word from Gwendolen—any kind of word. 
He felt horribly lonely. "Why were you in the bath?" he said, wondering whether 
to search the bathroom. 
"I don't know. I just woke up there," said Janet, shaking out a tangle of hair 
ribbons in the bottom drawer. "I felt as if I'd been dragged through a hedge 
backwards, and I'd no clothes on, so I was freezing." 
"Why had you no clothes on?" Cat said, stirring Gwendolen's underclothes about, 
without success. 
"I was hot in bed last night," said Janet. "So naked I came into this world. And 
I wandered about pinching myself—especially after I found this fabulous room. I 
thought I must have been turned into a princess. But there was this nightdress 
lying on the bed, so I put it on—" 
"You've got it on back to front," said Cat. 
Janet stopped scanning the things on the mantelpiece to look down at the 
trailing ribbons. "Have I? It won't be the only thing I'm going to get back to 
front, by the sound of it. Try looking in that artistic wardrobe. Then I 
explored outside here, and all I found was miles of long green corridor, which 
gave me the creeps, and stately grounds out of the windows, so I came back in 
here and went to bed. I hoped that when I woke up it would all have gone away. 
And instead there was you. Found anything?" 
"No," said Cat. "But there's her box—" 
"It must be in there," said Janet. 
They squatted down and unpacked the box. There was not much in it. Cat knew that 
Gwendolen must have taken a lot of things with her to wherever she had gone. 
There were two books, Elementary Spells and Magic for Beginners, and some pages 
of notes on them. Janet looked at Gwendolen's large, round writing. 
"She writes just like I do. Why did she leave these books? Because they're First 
Form standard and she's up to O Levels, I suppose." She put the books and notes 
to one side and, as she did so, the little red book of matches fell out from 
among them. Janet picked it up and opened it, and saw that half the matches were 
burned without having been torn out. "That looks suspiciously like a spell to 
me," she said. "What are these bundles of letters?" 
"My parents' love letters, I think," said Cat. 
The letters were in their envelopes still, stamped and addressed. Janet squatted 
with a bundle in each hand. "These stamps are penny blacks! No, it's a man's 
head on them. What's your King called?" 
"Charles the Seventh," said Cat. 
"No Georges?" Janet asked. But she saw Cat was mystified and looked back at the 
letters again. "Your mother and father were both called Chant, I see. Were they 
first cousins? Mine are. Granny didn't want them to marry, because it's supposed 
to be a bad thing." 
"I don't know. They may have been. They looked rather alike," Cat said, and felt 
lonelier than ever. 
Janet looked rather lonely too. She tucked the little book of matches carefully 
inside the pink tape that tied together the letters addressed to Miss Caroline 
Chant—like Gwendolen, she evidently had a tidy mind—and said, "Both tall and 
fair, with blue eyes? My mum's name is Caroline too. I'm beginning to see. Come 
on, Gwendolen, give!" And saying this, Janet tossed aside the letters and, in a 
most untidy way, scrabbled up the remaining folders, papers, writing sets, pen 
wipers, and the bag with Souvenir from Blackpool on it. At the very bottom of 
the box was a large pink sheet of paper, covered all over with Gwendolen's best 
and roundest writing. "Ah!" said Janet, pouncing on it. "I thought so! She's got 
the same secretive mind as I have." And she spread the letter on the carpet so 
that Cat could read it too. Gwendolen had written: 
Dear Replacement, 
I have to leave this terrible place. Nobody understands me. Nobody notices my 
talents. You will soon see because you are my exact double so you will be a 
witch too. I have been very clever. They do not know all my resauces. I have 
found out how to go to another world and I am going there for good. I know I 
shall be Queen of it because my fortune was told and said so. There are hundreds 
of other worlds only some are nicer than others, they are formed when there is a 
big event in History like a battle or an earthquake when the result can be two 
or more quite diferent things. Both those things hapen but they cannot exist 
together so the world splits into two worlds witch start to go diferent after 
that. I know there must be Gwendolens in a lot of worlds but not how many. One 
of you will come here when I go because when I move it will make an empty space 
that will suck you in. Do not greive however if your parents still live. Some 
other Gwendolen will move into your place and pretend to be you because we are 
all so clever. You can carry on here making Chrestomanci's life a misery and I 
shall be greatful knowing it is in good hands. 
Your loving 
Gwendolen Chant PS. Burn this. 
PS2. Tell Cat I am quite sorry but he must do what Mr. Nostrum says. 
Having read this, Cat knelt wanly beside Janet, knowing he really would never 
see Gwendolen again. He seemed to be stuck with Janet instead. If you know a 
person as well as Cat knew Gwendolen, an exact double is hardly good enough. 
Janet was not a witch. The expressions on her face were nothing like the same. 
Looking at her now, Cat saw that, where Gwendolen would have been furious at 
being dragged into another world, Janet was looking as wan as he felt. 
"I wonder how Mum and Dad are getting on with my Dear Replacement," she said 
wryly. Then she pulled herself together. "Do you mind if I don't burn this? It's 
the only proof I've got that I'm not Gwendolen who's suddenly gone mad and 
thinks she's this girl called Janet Chant. May I hide it?" 
"It's your letter," said Cat. 
"And your sister," said Janet. "God bless her dear little sugar-coated shining 
soul! Don't get me wrong, Cat. I admire your sister. She thinks big. You have to 
admire her! All the same, I wonder if she's thought of the clever hiding place 
where I'm going to put her letter. I shall feel better if she hasn't." 
Janet bounced up in her un-Gwendolen-like way and took the letter over to the 
gilded dressing table. Cat bounced up and followed her. Janet took hold of the 
gold-garlanded mirror and swung it towards her on its swivels. The back was 
plain plywood. She dug her nails under the edge of the plywood and prised. It 
came free quite easily. 
"I do this with my mirror at home," Janet explained. "It's a good hiding 
place—it's about the one place my parents never think of. Mum and Dad are dears, 
but they're terribly nosy. I think it's because I'm their only one. And I like 
to be private. I write private stories for my eyes only, and they will try to 
read them. Oh, purple-spotted dalmatians!" 
She raised the wood up and showed Cat the signs painted on the red-coated back 
of the glass itself. 
"Cabala, I think," said Cat. "It's a spell." 
"So she did think of it!" said Janet. "Really, it's hell having a double. You 
both get the same ideas. And working on that principle," she said, sliding 
Gwendolen's letter between the plywood and the glass and pressing the plywood 
back in place, "I bet I know what the spell's for. It's so Gwendolen can have a 
look from time to time and see how Dear Replacement's getting on. I hope she's 
looking now." 
Janet swung the mirror back to its usual position and crossed her eyes at it, 
hideously. She took hold of the corners of her crossed eyes and pulled them long 
and Chinese, and stuck her tongue out as far as it would go. Then she pushed her 
nose up with one finger and twisted her mouth right around to one cheek. Cat 
could not help laughing. "Can't Gwendolen do this?" Janet said out of the side 
of her face. 
"No." Cat giggled. 
That was the moment when Euphemia opened the door. Janet jumped violently. She 
was much more nervous than Cat had realized. "I'll thank you to stop pulling 
faces," said Euphemia, "and get out of your nightdress, Gwendolen." She came 
into the room to make sure that Gwendolen did. She gave a croaking sort of 
shriek. Then she melted into a brown lump. 
Janet's hands went over her mouth. She and Cat stared in horror as the brown 
lump that had been Euphemia grew smaller and smaller. When it was about three 
inches high, it stopped shrinking and put out large webbed feet. On these webbed 
feet, it crawled forward and stared at them reproachfully out of protruding 
yellowish eyes near the top of its head. 
"Oh dear!" said Cat. It seemed that Gwendolen's last act had been to turn 
Euphemia into a frog. 
Janet burst into tears. Cat was surprised. She had seemed so self-assured. 
Sobbing heavily, Janet knelt down and tenderly picked up the brown, crawling 
Euphemia. "You poor girl!" she wept. "I know just how you feel. Cat, what are we 
to do? How do you turn people back? " 
"I don't know," Cat said soberly. He was suddenly burdened with huge 
responsibilities. Janet, in spite of the confident way she talked, clearly 
needed looking after. Euphemia clearly needed it even more. If it had not been 
for Chrestomanci, Cat would have raced off to get Mr. Saunders to help that 
moment. But he suddenly realized that if Chrestomanci ever found out what 
Gwendolen had done this time, the most terrible things would happen. Cat was 
quite sure of this. He discovered that he was terrified of Chrestomanci. He had 
been terrified of him all along, without realizing it. He knew he would have to 
keep both Janet and Euphemia a secret somehow. 
Feeling desperate, Cat raced to the bathroom, found a damp towel, and brought it 
to Janet. "Put her down on this. She'll need to be wet. I'll ask Roger and Julia 
to turn her back. I'll tell them you won't. And for goodness sake don't tell 
anyone you aren't Gwendolen—please!" 
Janet lowered Euphemia gently onto the towel. Euphemia scrambled around in it 
and continued to stare accusingly at Janet. "Don't look like that. It wasn't 
me," Janet said, sniffing. "Cat, we'll have to hide her. Would she be 
comfortable in the wardrobe?" 
"She'll have to be," said Cat. "You get dressed." 
A look of panic came over Janet's face. "Cat, what does Gwendolen wear?" 
Cat thought all girls knew what girls wore. "The usual things—petticoats, 
stockings, dress, boots—you know." 
"No, I don't," said Janet. "I always wear trousers." 
Cat felt his problems mounting up. He hunted for clothes. Gwendolen seemed to 
have taken her best things with her, but he found her older boots, her green 
stockings and the garters to match, her second-best petticoats, her green 
cashmere dress with the smocking and—with some embarrassment—her bloomers. 
"There," he said. 
"Does she really wear two petticoats?" said Janet. 
"Yes," said Cat. "Get them on." 
But Janet proved quite unable to get them on without his help. If he left her to 
do anything, she put it on back to front. He had to put her petticoats on her, 
button her up the back, tie her garters, fasten her boots, and put her dress on 
a second time, right way around, and tie its sash for her. When he had finished, 
it looked all right, but Janet had an odd air of being dressed up, rather than 
dressed. She looked at herself critically in the mirror. "Thanks, you're an 
angel. I look rather like an Edwardian child. And I feel a right Charley." 
"Come on," said Cat. "Breakfast." He carried Euphemia, croaking furiously, to 
the wardrobe and wrapped her firmly in the towel. "Be quiet," he told her. "I'll 
get you changed back as soon as I can, so stop making that fuss, please!" He 
shut the door on her and wedged it with a page of Gwendolen's notes. Faint 
croaking came from behind it. Euphemia had no intention of being quiet. Cat did 
not really blame her. 
"She's not happy in there," Janet said, weakening. "Can't she stay out in the 
room?" 
"No," said Cat. Frog though she was, Euphemia still looked like Euphemia. He 
knew Mary would recognize her as soon as she set eyes on her. He took Janet's 
resisting elbow and towed her along to the playroom. 
"Don't you two ever get up till the last minute?" said Julia. "I'm sick of 
waiting politely for breakfast." 
"Eric's been up for hours," said Mary, hovering about. "So I don't know what 
you've both been up to. Oh, what's Euphemia doing?" 
"Mary's beside herself this morning," Roger said. He winked. For a moment there 
were two Marys, one real and one vague and ghostly. Janet jumped. It was only 
the second piece of witchcraft she had seen and she did not find it easy to get 
used to. 
"I expect it's Gwendolen's fault," said Julia, and she gave Janet one of those 
meaning stares. 
Janet was very put-out. Cat had forgotten to warn her how much Julia had 
disliked Gwendolen ever since the snakes. And a meaning stare from a witch is 
worse than a meaning stare from an ordinary person. Julia's pushed Janet 
backward across the room, until Cat put himself in the way of it. 
"Don't do that," he said. "She's sorry." 
"Is she?" said Julia. "Are you?" she asked, trying to get the stare around Cat 
to Janet again. 
"Yes, horribly sorry," Janet said fervently, not having the least idea why. 
"I've had a complete change of heart." 
"I'll believe that when I see it," said Julia. But she left off staring in order 
to watch Mary bringing the usual bread, the marmalade, and the jug of cocoa. 
Janet looked, sniffed the cocoa steaming from the jug, and her face fell, rather 
like Gwendolen's on the first day. "Oh dear. I hate cocoa," she said. 
Mary rolled her eyes to the ceiling. "You and your airs and graces! You never 
said you hated it before." 
"I—I've had a revulsion of feeling," Janet invented. "When I had my change of 
heart, all my taste buds changed too. I—you haven't any coffee, have you?" 
"Where? Under the carpet or something?" Mary demanded. "All right. I'll ask the 
kitchen. I'll tell them your taste buds are revolting, shall I?" 
Cat was very pleased to hear that cocoa was not compulsory after all. "Could I 
have coffee too?" he asked, as Mary went to the lift. "Or I prefer tea, really." 

"But you waited to say so until Euphemia goes missing and leaves me all on my 
own!" Mary said, getting Very put-upon. 
"She never does anything anyway," Cat said in surprise. 
Mary flounced crossly to the speaking tube and ordered a pot of coffee and a pot 
of tea. "For Her Highness and His Nibs," she said to it. "He seems to have 
caught it now. What wouldn't I give for a nice normal child in this place, 
Nancy!" 
"But I am a nice normal child!" Janet and Cat protested in unison. 
"And so are we—nice, anyhow," Julia said comfortably. 
"How can you be normal?" Mary demanded as she let down the lift. "All four of 
you are Chants. And when was a Chant ever normal? Answer me that." 
Janet looked questioningly at Cat, but Cat was as puzzled as she was. "I thought 
your name was Chrestomanci," he said to Roger and Julia. 
"That's just Daddy's title," said Julia. 
"You're some kind of cousin of ours," said Roger. "Didn't you know? I always 
thought that was why Daddy had you to live here." 
As they started breakfast, Cat thought that this, if anything, made the 
situation more difficult than ever. 



10
Cat watched his moment and, when Mr. Saunders called them to lessons, he caught 
Roger's arm and whispered, "Look, Gwendolen's turned Euphemia into a frog and—" 
Roger gave a great snore of laughter. Cat had to wait for him to stop. 
"And she won't turn her back. Can you?" 
Roger tried to look serious, but laughter kept breaking through. "I don't know. 
Probably not, unless she'll tell you what spell she used. Finding out which 
spell without knowing is Advanced Magic, and I'm not on that yet. Oh, how 
funny!" He bent over the table and yelled with laughter. 
Naturally, Mr. Saunders appeared at the door, remarking that the time for 
telling jokes was after lessons. They had to go through to the schoolroom. 
Naturally, Cat found Janet had sat in his desk by mistake. He got her out as 
quietly as he could and sat in it himself, distractedly wondering how he could 
find out which spell Gwendolen had used. 
It was the most uncomfortable morning Cat had ever known. He had forgotten to 
tell Janet that the only thing Gwendolen knew about was witchcraft. Janet, as he 
had rather suspected, knew a lot, about a lot of things. But it all applied to 
her own world. About the only subject she would have been safe in was simple 
arithmetic. And Mr. Saunders chose that morning to give her a History test. Cat, 
as he scratched away left-handed at an English essay, could see the panic 
growing on Janet's face. 
"What do you mean, Henry the Fifth?" barked Mr. Saunders. "Richard the Second 
was on the throne until long after Agincourt. What was his greatest magical 
achievement?" 
"Defeating the French," Janet guessed. Mr. Saunders looked so exasperated that 
she babbled, "Well, I think it was. He hampered the French with iron underwear, 
and the English wore wool, so they didn't stick in the mud, and probably their 
longbows were enchanted too. That would account for them not missing." 
"Who," said Mr. Saunders, "do you imagine won the Battle of Agincourt?" 
"The English," said Janet. This of course was true for her world, but the 
panic-stricken look on her face as she said it suggested that she suspected the 
opposite was true in this world. Which, of course, it was. 
Mr. Saunders put his hands to his head. "No, no, no! The French! Don't you know 
anything, girl?" 
Janet looked to be near tears. Cat was terrified. She was going to break down 
any second and tell Mr. Saunders she was not Gwendolen. She did not have Cat's 
reasons for keeping quiet. "Gwendolen never knows anything," he remarked loudly, 
hoping Janet would take the hint. She did. She sighed with relief and relaxed. 
"I'm aware of that," said Mr. Saunders. "But somewhere, somewhere inside that 
marble head there must be a little cell of gray matter. So I keep looking." 
Unfortunately, Janet, in her relief, became almost jolly. "Would you like to 
take my head apart and look?"she asked. 
"Don't tempt me!" cried Mr. Saunders. He hid his eyes with one knobby hand and 
fended at Janet with the other. He looked so funny that Janet laughed. This was 
so unlike Gwendolen that Mr. Saunders lowered his hand across his nose and 
stared at her suspiciously over it. "What have you been up to now?" 
"Nothing," Janet said guiltily. 
"Hm," said Mr. Saunders, in a way which made both Cat and Janet very 
uncomfortable. 
At last—very long last—it was time for Mary to bring the milk and biscuits, 
which she did, with a very portentous look. Crouched on the tray beside Mr. 
Saunders' cup of coffee was a large, wet-looking, brown thing. Cat's stomach 
seemed to leave him and take a plunge into the Castle cellars. From the look of 
Janet, hers was doing the same. 
"What have you got there?" said Mr. Saunders. 
"Gwendolen's good deed for today," Mary said grimly. "It's Euphemia. Look at its 
face." 
Mr. Saunders bent and looked. Then he whirled around on Janet so fiercely that 
Janet half got out of her seat. "So that's what you were laughing about!" 
"I didn't do it!" said Janet. 
"Euphemia was in Gwendolen's room, shut in the wardrobe, croaking her poor head 
off," said Mary. 
"I think this calls for Chrestomanci," Mr. Saunders said. He strode towards the 
door. 
The door opened before he got there and Chrestomanci himself came in, cheerful 
and busy, with some papers in one hand. "Michael," he said, "have I caught you 
at the right—?" He stopped when he saw Mr. Saunders' face. "Is something wrong?" 

"Will you please to look at this frog, sir," said Mary. "It was in Gwendolen's 
wardrobe." 
Chrestomanci was wearing an exquisite gray suit with faint lilac stripes to it. 
He held his lilac silk cravat out of the way and bent to inspect the frog. 
Euphemia lifted her head and croaked at him beseechingly. There was a moment of 
ice-cold silence. It was a moment such as Cat hoped never to live through again. 
"Bless my soul!" Chrestomanci said, gently as frost freezes a window. "It's 
Eugenia." 
"Euphemia, Daddy," said Julia. 
"Euphemia," said Chrestomanci. "Of course. 
Now who did this?" Cat wondered how such a mild voice could send the hair 
pricking upright at the back of his head. 
"Gwendolen, sir," said Mary. 
But Chrestomanci shook his smooth black head. "No. Don't give a dog a bad name. 
It couldn't have been Gwendolen. Michael took her witchcraft away last night." 
"Oh," said Mr. Saunders, rather red in the face. "Stupid of me!" 
"So who could it have been?" Chrestomanci wondered. 
There was another freezing silence. It seemed to Cat about as long as an Ice 
Age. During it, Julia began to smile. She drummed her fingers on her desk and 
looked meditatively at Janet. Janet saw her and jumped. She drew in her breath 
sharply. Cat panicked. He was sure Janet was going to say what Gwendolen had 
done. He said the only thing he could think of to stop her. 
"I did it," he said loudly. 
Cat could hardly bear the way they all looked at him. Julia was disgusted, Roger 
astonished. Mr. Saunders was fiercely angry. Mary looked at him as if he was a 
frog himself. But Chrestomanci was politely incredulous, and he was worst of 
all. "I beg your pardon, Eric," he said. "This was you?" 
Cat stared at him with a strange misty wetness around his eyes. He thought it 
was due to terror. "It was a mistake," he said. "I was trying a spell. I— I 
didn't expect it to work. And then—and then Euphemia came in and turned into a 
frog. Just like that," he explained. 
Chrestomanci said, "But you were told not to practice magic on your own." 
"I know." Cat hung his head, without having to pretend. "But I knew it wouldn't 
work. Only it did, of course," he explained. 
"Well, you must undo the spell at once," said Chrestomanci. 
Cat swallowed. "I can't. I don't know how to." 
Chrestomanci treated him to another look so polite, so scathing, and so 
unbelieving, that Cat would gladly have crawled under his desk had he been able 
to move at all. "Very well," said Chrestomanci. "Michael, perhaps you could 
oblige?" 
Mary held the tray out. Mr. Saunders took Euphemia and put her on the schoolroom 
table. Euphemia croaked agitatedly. "Only a minute now," Mr. Saunders said 
soothingly. He held his hands cupped around her. Nothing happened. Looking a 
little puzzled, Mr. Saunders began to mutter things. Still nothing happened. 
Euphemia's head bobbed anxiously above his bony fingers, and she was still a 
frog. Mr. Saunders went from looking puzzled to looking baffled. "This is a very 
strange spell," he said. "What did you use, Eric?" 
"I can't remember," said Cat. 
"Well, it doesn't respond to anything I can do," said Mr. Saunders. "You'll have 
to do it, Eric. Come over here." 
Cat looked helplessly at Chrestomanci, but Chrestomanci nodded as if he thought 
Mr. Saunders was quite right. Cat stood up. His legs had gone thick and weak, 
and his stomach seemed to have taken up permanent quarters in the Castle 
cellars. He slunk towards the table. When Euphemia saw him coming, she showed 
her opinion of the matter by taking a frantic leap off the edge of the table. 
Mr. Saunders caught her in midair and put her back. 
"What do I do?" Cat said, and his voice sounded like Euphemia croaking. 
Mr. Saunders took Cat by his left wrist and planted Cat's left hand on 
Euphemia's clammy back. "Now take it off her," he said. 
"I—I—" said Cat. He supposed he ought to pretend to try. "Stop being a frog and 
turn into Euphemia again," he said, and wondered miserably what they would do to 
him when Euphemia didn't. 
But, to his astonishment, Euphemia did. The frog turned warm under his fingers 
and burst into growth. Cat shot a look at Mr. Saunders as the brown lump grew 
furiously larger and larger. He was almost sure he caught a secret smile on Mr. 
Saunders' face. The next second, Euphemia was sitting on the edge of the table. 
Her clothes were a little crumpled and brown, but there was nothing else 
froggish about her. "I never dreamed it was you!" she said to Cat. Then she put 
her face in her hands and cried. 
Chrestomanci came up and put his arm around her. "There, there, my dear. It must 
have been a terrible experience. I think you need to go and lie down." And he 
took Euphemia out of the room. 
"Phew!" said Janet. 
Mary grimly handed out the milk and biscuits. Cat did not want his. His stomach 
had not yet come back from the cellars. Janet refused biscuits. 
"I think the food here is awfully fattening," she said unwisely. Julia took that 
as a personal insult. Her handkerchief came out and was knotted. Janet's glass 
of milk slipped through her fingers and smashed on the pitted floor. 
"Clean it up," said Mr. Saunders. "Then get out, you and Eric. I've had enough 
of both of you. Julia and Roger, get out magic textbooks, please." 
Cat took Janet out into the gardens. It seemed safest there. They wandered 
across the lawn, both rather limp after the morning's experiences. 
"Cat," said Janet, "you're going to be very annoyed with me, but it's absolutely 
essential that I cling to you like a limpet all the time we're awake, until I 
know how to behave. You saved my bacon twice this morning. I thought I was going 
to die when she brought in that frog. Rigor mortis was setting in, and then you 
turned her back again! I didn't realize you were a witch too—no, it's a warlock, 
isn't it? Or are you a wizard?" 
"I'm not," said Cat. "I'm not any of those things. Mr. Saunders did it to give 
me a fright." 
"But Julia is a witch, isn't she?" said the shrewd Janet. "What have I done to 
make her hate me so—or is it just general Gwendolenitis?" 
Cat explained about the snakes. 
"In which case I don't blame her," said Janet. "But it's hard that she's in the 
schoolroom at the moment brushing up her witchcraft, and here I am without a rag 
of a spell to defend myself with. You don't know of a handy karate teacher, do 
you?" 
"I never heard of one," Cat said cautiously, wondering what karate might be. 
"Oh well," said Janet. "Chrestomanci's a wonderfully fancy dresser, isn't he?" 
Cat laughed. "Wait till you see him in a dressing gown!" 
"I hardly can. It must be something! Why is he so terrifying?" 
"He just is," said Cat. 
"Yes," said Janet. "He just is. When he saw the frog was Euphemia and went all 
mild and astonished like that, it froze the goose pimples on my back. I couldn't 
have told him I wasn't Gwendolen—not even under the most refined modern 
tortures— and that's why I shall have to stick to you. Do you mind terribly?" 
"Not at all," said Cat. But he did rather. Janet could not have been more of a 
burden if she had been sitting on his shoulders with her legs wrapped around his 
chest. And to crown it all, it seemed as if there had been no need for his false 
confession. He took Janet to the ruins of the tree house because he wanted 
something else to think about. Janet was enchanted with it. She swung herself up 
into the horse chestnut to look at it, and Cat felt rather as you do when 
someone else gets into your railway carriage. "Be careful," he called crossly. 
There was a strong rending noise up in the tree. "Drat!" said Janet. "These are 
ridiculous clothes for climbing trees in." 
"Can't you sew?" Cat called as he climbed up too. 
"I despise it as female bondage," said Janet. "Yes, I can, actually. And I'm 
going to have to. It was both petticoats." She tested the creaking floor that 
was all that remained of the house and stood up on it, trailing two different 
colors of frill below the hem of Gwendolen's dress. "You can see into the 
village from here. There's a butcher's cart just turning in to the Castle 
drive." 
Cat climbed up beside her and they watched the cart and the dappled horse 
pulling it. 
"Don't you have cars at all?" Janet asked. "Everyone has cars in my world." 
"Rich people do," said Cat. "Chrestomanci sent his to meet us off the train." 
"And you have electric light," said Janet. "But everything else is old-fashioned 
compared with my world. I suppose people can get what they want by witchcraft. 
Do you have factories, or long-playing records, or high-rise buildings, or 
television, or airplanes at all?" 
"I don't know what airplanes are," said Cat. He had no idea what most of the 
other things were either, and he was bored with this talk. 
Janet saw he was. She looked around for a change of subject and saw clusters of 
big green horse chestnut cases hanging all around them at the ends of the 
branches. The leaves there were already singed-looking around the edges, 
suggesting that the chestnuts could not be far off ripe. Janet edged out along a 
branch and tried to reach the nearest cluster of green cases. They bobbed at the 
tips of her fingers, just out of reach. "Oh, dachshunds!" she said. "They look 
almost ripe." 
"They aren't," said Cat. "But I wish they were." He took a lathe out of the 
wreckage of the house and slashed at the chestnut cases with it. He missed, but 
he must have shaken them. Eight or so dropped off the tree and went plomp on the 
ground below. 
"Who says they're not ripe?" said Janet, leaning down. 
Cat craned out of the tree and saw brown shiny chestnuts showing in the split 
green cases. "Oh, hurray!" He came down the tree like a monkey, and Janet 
crashed after him, with her hair full of twigs. They scooped up the chestnuts 
greedily— wonderful chestnuts with grain on them like the contours in a map. 
"A skewer!" Janet moaned. "My kingdom for a skewer! We can thread them on my 
bootlaces." 
"Here's a skewer," said Cat. There was one lying on the ground by his left hand. 
It must have fallen out of the tree house. 
They drilled chestnuts furiously. They took the laces out of Gwendolen's 
second-best boots. They discovered the rules of the game were the same in both 
their worlds, and they went to the formal garden and held a battle royal there 
on the gravel path. As Janet firmly smashed Cat's last chestnut and yelled, 
"Mine! Mine's a sevener now!" Millie came around a corner past a yew tree and 
stood laughing at them. 
"Do you know, I wouldn't have thought the chestnuts were ripe yet. But it's been 
a lovely summer." 
Janet looked at her in consternation. She had no idea who this plump lady in the 
beautiful flowered silk dress could be. 
"Hallo, Millie," said Cat. Not that this helped Janet much. 
Millie smiled and opened the handbag she was carrying. "There are three things 
Gwendolen needs, I think. Here." She handed Janet two safety pins and a packet 
of bootlaces. "I always believe in being prepared." 
"Th-thanks," Janet stammered. She was horribly conscious of her gaping boots, 
her twig-filled hair, and the two trailing strips of petticoat. She was even 
more confused by not knowing who Millie was. 
Cat knew that. He knew by now that Janet was one of those people who are not 
happy unless they have an explanation for everything. So he said fulsomely to 
Millie, "I do think Roger and Julia are lucky, having a mother like you, 
Millie." 
Millie beamed and Janet looked enlightened. Cat felt dishonest. He did think 
that, but he would never have dreamed of saying it but for Janet. 
Having gathered that Millie was Chrestomanci's wife, Janet was quite unable to 
resist going on and gathering as much more information as she could. "Millie," 
she said, "were Cat's parents first cousins like—I mean, were they? And what 
relation is Cat to you?" 
"That sounds like those questions they ask you to find out how clever you are," 
said Millie. "And I don't know the answer, Gwendolen. It's my husband's family 
you're related to, you see, and I don't know too much about them. We need 
Chrestomanci here to explain, really." 
As it happened, Chrestomanci came through the doorway in the garden wall at that 
moment. Millie rustled up to him, beaming. 
"My love, we were needing you." 
Janet, who had her head down, trying to pin her petticoats, glanced up at 
Chrestomanci and then looked thoughtfully down at the path, as if the stones and 
sand there had suddenly become rather interesting. 
"It's quite simple," Chrestomanci said, when Millie had explained the question. 
"Frank and Caroline Chant were my cousins—and first cousins to one another too, 
of course. When they insisted on getting married, my family made a great fuss, 
and my uncles cut them off without a shilling in a thoroughly old-fashioned way. 
It is, you see, rather a bad thing for cousins to marry when there's witchcraft 
in the family. Not that cutting them off made the slightest difference, of 
course." He smiled at Cat. He seemed thoroughly friendly. "Does that answer the 
question?" 
Cat had an inkling of how Gwendolen had felt. It was confusing and exasperating 
the way Chrestomanci would seem friendly when one ought to have been in 
disgrace. He could not resist asking, "Is Euphemia all right?" 
Then he wished he had not asked. Chrestomanci's smile snapped off like a light. 
"Yes. She's feeling better now. You show touching concern, Eric. I believe you 
were so sorry for her that you hid her in a wardrobe?" 
"My love, don't be so terrifying," Millie said, hooking her arm through 
Chrestomanci's. "It was an accident, and it's all over now." She led him away 
down the path. But, just before they went out of sight behind a yew tree, 
Chrestomanci turned and looked over his shoulder at Cat and Janet. It was his 
bewildered look, but it was far from reassuring. 
"Hot-cross bun-wrappers! Jiminy purple creepers!" Janet whispered. "I'm 
beginning to hardly dare move in this place!" She finished pinning her 
petticoat. When Millie and Chrestomanci had had nearly a minute in which to walk 
out of hearing, she said, "She's sweet—Millie—an absolute honey. But him! Cat, 
is it possible Chrestomanci is a rather powerful enchanter?" 
"I don't think he is," said Cat. "Why?" 
"Well," said Janet, "partly it's the feeling he gives—" 



"I don't get a feeling," said Cat. "I'm just frightened of him." 
"That's it" said Janet. "You're probably muddled anyhow from having lived with 
witches all your life. But it isn't only a feeling. Have you noticed how he 
always comes when people call him? He's done it twice now." 
"Those were two complete accidents," said Cat. "You can't build ideas on 
accidents." 
"He disguises it quite well, I admit," said Janet. "He comes looking as if it 
was something else he was doing, but—" 
"Oh, do shut up! You're getting as bad as Gwendolen. She couldn't stop thinking 
of him for a moment," Cat said crossly. 
Janet pounded her open right boot on the gravel. "I am not Gwendolen! I'm not 
even really like her! Get that into your fat head, will you!" 
Cat started to laugh. 
"Why are you laughing?" said Janet. 
"Gwendolen always stamps when she's angry too," said Cat. 
"Gah!" said Janet. 



11 
By the time Janet had laced both her boots, Cat was sure it was lunchtime. He 
hurried Janet back to the private door. They had nearly reached it when a thick 
voice spoke among the rhododendrons. 
"Young lady! Here a minute!" 
Janet gave Cat an alarmed look and they both hurried for the door. It was not a 
pleasant voice. The rhododendrons clashed and rustled indignantly beside them. A 
fat old man in a dirty raincoat spilled out of them. Before they had recovered 
from the surprise of seeing him, he had scuttled around between them and the 
door, where he stood looking at them reproachfully out of drooping red eyes and 
breathing beer-scented breath over them. 
"Hallo, Mr. Baslam," Cat said, for Janet's benefit. 
"Didn't you hear me, young lady?" Mr. Baslam demanded. 
Cat could see Janet was frightened of him, but she answered as coolly as 
Gwendolen might have done. "Yes, but I thought it was the tree speaking." 
"The tree speaking!" said Mr. Baslam. "After all the trouble I been to for you, 
you take me for a tree! Three whole pints of butter I had to buy that butcher to 
have him bring me in that cart of his, and I'm fair jolted to bits!" 
"What do you want?" Janet said nervously. 
It's like this," said Mr. Baslam. He pulled aside his raincoat and searched 
slowly in the pockets of his loopy trousers. 
"We have to go in for lunch," said Cat. 
"All in good time, young gentleman. Here we are," said Mr. Baslam. He held his 
pale, grubby hand out towards Janet with two twinkling things in it. "These." 
"Those are my mother's earrings!" Cat said, in surprise and for Janet's benefit. 
"How did you get those?" 
"Your sister give them to me to pay for a little matter of some dragons' blood," 
said Mr. Baslam. "And I dare say it was in good faith, young lady, but they're 
no good to me." 
"Why not?" asked Janet. "They look like—I mean, they're real diamonds." 
"True enough," said Mr. Baslam. "But you never told me they was charmed, did 
you? They got a fearsome strong spell on them to stop them getting lost, these 
have. Terrible noisy spell. They was all night in the stuffed rabbit shouting 
out 'I belong to Caroline Chant,' and this morning I has to wrap them in a 
blanket before I dares take them to a man I know. And he wouldn't touch them. He 
said he wasn't going to risk anything shouting the name of Chant. So have them 
back, young lady. And you owe me fifty-five quid." 
Janet swallowed. So did Cat. "I'm very sorry," Janet said. "I really had no 
idea. But—but I'm afraid I haven't any source of income at all. Couldn't you get 
the charm taken off?" 
"And risk inquiries?" said Mr. Baslam. "That charm's deep in, I tell you." 
"Then why aren't they shouting now?" said Cat. 
"What do you think I am?" said Mr. Baslam. "Could I sit in the joints of mutton 
shouting out I belonged to Miss Chant? No. This man I know obliges me with a bit 
of a spell on account. But he says to me, he says, 'I can't only shut them up 
for an hour or so. That's a real strong charm. If you want it took off 
permanent, you'd have to take them to an enchanter. And that would cost you as 
much as the earrings are worth, besides getting questions asked.' Enchanters are 
important people, young lady. So here I sits in them bushes, scared to death the 
spell's going to wear off before you comes by, and now you say you've no income! 
No—you have them back, young lady, and hand over a little something on account 
instead." 
Janet looked nervously at Cat. Cat sighed and felt in his pockets. All he had 
was half a crown. He offered it to Mr. Baslam. 
Mr. Baslam backed away from it with a hurt, drooping look, like a whipped St. 
Bernard. "Fifty-five quid I ask for, and you offer me half a crown! Son, are you 
having a joke on me?" 
"It's all either of us has got," said Cat, "at the moment. But we each get a 
crown piece every week. If we give you that, we'll have paid you back in—" He 
did hurried calculations. Ten shillings a week, fifty-two weeks in a year, 
twenty-six pounds a year. "It'll only take two years." Two years was an 
appalling time to be without money. Still, Mr. Baslam had got Gwendolen her 
dragons' blood, and it seemed fair that he should be paid. 
But Mr. Baslam looked more hurt than ever. He turned away from Cat and Janet and 
gazed mournfully up at the Castle walls. "You live in a place like this, and 
tell me, you can only get hold of ten bob a week! Don't play cruel games with 
me. You can lay your hands on no end of lucre if you puts your minds to it." 
"But we can't, honestly," Cat protested. 
"I think you should try, young gentleman," said Mr. Baslam. "I'm not 
unreasonable. All I'm asking is twenty quid part payment, interest of ten 
percent included, and the price of the shutting-up spell thrown in. That should 
come quite easy to you." 
"You know perfectly well it won't!" Janet said indignantly. "You'd better keep 
those earrings. Your stuffed rabbit may look pretty in them." 
Mr. Baslam gave her a very whipped look. At the same time, a thin, singing noise 
began to come from the palm of his hand where the earrings lay. It was too faint 
for Cat to pick out the words, but it put paid to any notion that Mr. Baslam had 
been lying. Mr. Baslam's drooping look became less whipped. He looked more like 
a bloodhound hot on the trail. He let the earrings slide between his fat fingers 
and fall on the gravel. 
"There they lie," he said, "if you care to stoop for them. I may remind you, 
young lady, that trade in dragons' blood is illicit, illegal, and banned. I've 
obliged you in it. You've fobbed me off. Now I'm telling you that I need twenty 
quid by next Wednesday. That should give you time. If I don't get it, then 
Chrestomanci hears of the dragons' blood Wednesday evening. And if he does, then 
I wouldn't be in your shoes, young lady, not for twenty thousand quid and a 
diamond tiara. Have I made myself clear?" 
He had, appallingly. "Suppose we give you the dragons' blood back?" Cat 
suggested desperately. Gwendolen had taken Mr. Baslam's dragons' blood with her, 
of course, but there was always that huge jar of it in Mr. Saunders' workshop. 
"What would I do with dragons' blood, son?" said Mr. Baslam. "I'm not a warlock. 
I'm only a poor supplier, and there's no demand for dragons' blood around here. 
It's the money I need. Twenty quid of it, by next Wednesday, and don't forget." 
He gave them a bloodhound nod which flapped his eyes and his cheeks, and edged 
back into the rhododendrons. They heard him rustling stealthily away. 
"What a nasty old man!" Janet said in a shaken whisper. "I wish I really was 
Gwendolen. I'd turn him into a four-headed earwig. Ugh!" She bent and scrabbled 
the earrings up off the gravel. 
Immediately the air by the door was filled with high, singing voices. "I belong 
to Caroline Chant! I belong to Caroline Chant!" 
"Oh dear!" said Janet. "They know." 
"Give them to me," said Cat. "Quick. Someone will hear." 
Janet poured the earrings into Cat's palm. The voices stopped at once. "I can't 
get used to all this magic," said Janet. "Cat, what am I to do? How can I pay 
that horrible man?" 
"There must be something we can sell," said Cat. "There's a junk shop in the 
village. Come on. We must get to lunch." 
They hurried up to the playroom, to find that Mary had already put plates of 
stew and dumplings in their places. 
"Oh, look," said Janet, who needed to relieve her feelings somehow. "Nourishing 
fattening lunch. How nice!" 
Mary glared at both of them and left the room without speaking. Julia's look was 
quite as unpleasant. As Janet sat down in front of her stew, Julia pulled her 
handkerchief out of her sleeve, already knotted, and laid it in her lap. Janet 
put her fork into a dumpling. It stuck there. The dumpling was a white pebble, 
swimming with two others in a plateful of mud. 
Janet carefully laid down her fork, with the pebble impaled on it, and put her 
knife neatly across the mud. She was trying to control herself but, for a 
moment, she looked like Gwendolen at her most furious. "I was quite hungry," she 
said. 
Julia smiled. "What a pity," she said cosily. "And you've got no witchcraft to 
defend yourself with, have you?" She tied another smaller knot at the end of her 
handkerchief. "You've got all sorts of things in your hair, Gwendolen," she said 
as she pulled it tight. The twigs sticking in Janet's hair writhed and began 
dropping on the table and over her skirt. Each one was a large, stripy 
caterpillar. 
Janet was no more bothered by wriggly things than Gwendolen. She picked the 
caterpillars off and put them in a heap in front of Julia. "I've a good mind to 
shout for your father," she said. 
"Oh, no, don't be a telltale," said Roger. "Let her be, Julia." 
"Certainly not," said Julia. "She's not getting any lunch." 
After the meeting with Mr. Baslam, Cat was not really very hungry. "Here," he 
said, and changed his plate of stew with Janet's mud. Janet started to protest. 
But, as soon as the plate of mud was in front of Cat, it was steaming stew 
again. And the looping heap of caterpillars was simply a pile of twigs. 
Julia turned to Cat, not at all pleased. "Don't you interfere. You annoy me. She 
treats you like a slave and all you do is stick up for her." 
"But I only changed the plates!" Cat said, puzzled. "Why—?" 
"It could have been Michael," Roger suggested. 
Julia glowered at him too. "Was it you?" Roger blandly shook his head. Julia 
looked at him uncertainly. "If I have to go without marmalade again," she said 
at length, "Gwendolen's going to know about it. And I hope the stew chokes you." 

Cat found it hard to concentrate on lessons that afternoon. He had to watch 
Janet like a hawk. Janet had decided that the only safe thing was to be totally 
stupid—she thought Gwendolen must have been pretty stupid anyway—and Cat knew 
she was overdoing it. Even Gwendolen had known the twice-times table. Cat was 
worried too, in case Julia started knotting that handkerchief of hers when Mr. 
Saunders' back was turned. Luckily, Julia did not quite dare. But Cat's main 
worry was how to find twenty pounds by next Wednesday. He could hardly bear to 
think of what might happen if he did not. The very least thing, he knew, would 
be Janet confessing she was not Gwendolen. He thought of Chrestomanci giving him 
that scathing stare and saying, "You went with Gwendolen to buy dragons' blood, 
Eric? But you knew it was illegal. And you tried to cover up by making Janet 
pretend to be Gwendolen? You show touching concern, Eric." The mere idea made 
Cat shrivel up inside. But he had nothing to sell except a pair of earrings that 
shouted that they belonged to someone else. If he wrote to the Mayor of 
Wolvercote and asked if he could have twenty pounds out of the Fund, the Mayor 
would only write to Chrestomanci to ask why Cat wanted it. And then Chrestomanci 
would stare scathingly and say, "You went with Gwendolen to buy dragons' blood, 
Eric?" It was hopeless. 
"Are you feeling well, Eric?" Mr. Saunders asked several times. 
"Oh, yes," Cat replied each time. He was fairly sure that having your mind in 
three places at once did not count as illness, much as it felt like it. 
"Play soldiers?" Roger suggested after lessons. 
Cat would have liked to, but he dared not leave Janet on her own. "I've got to 
do something," he said. 
"With Gwendolen. I know," Roger said wearily. "Anyone would think you were her 
left leg, or something." 
Cat felt hurt. The annoying thing was that he knew Janet could have done without 
her left leg more easily than she could have done without him. As he hurried 
after Janet to Gwendolen's room, he wished heartily it was really Gwendolen he 
was hurrying after. 
Inside the room, Janet was feverishly collecting things: Gwendolen's spell 
books, the ornaments on the mantelpiece, the gold-backed brush and hand mirror 
off the dressing table, the jar on the bedside table, and half the towels from 
the bathroom. 
"What are you doing?" said Cat. 
"Finding things we can sell. Is there anything you can bear to spare from your 
room?" said Janet. 
"Don't look like that. I know it amounts to stealing, but I get so desperate 
when I think of that horrible Mr. Bisto going to Chrestomanci that I don't care 
anymore." She went to the wardrobe and rattled the clothes along the rail. 
"There's an awfully good coat in here." 
"You'll need that on Sunday if it turns cold," Cat said drearily. "I'll go and 
see what I've got— only promise me to stay here until I come back." 
"Sho' ting," said Janet. "I daren't move widd-out you, bwana. But hurry up." 
There were fewer things in Cat's room, but he collected what he could find, and 
added the great sponge from the bathroom. He felt like a criminal. Janet and he 
wrapped their finds in two towels and crept downstairs with their chinking 
bundles, expecting someone to discover them any minute. 
"I feel like a thief with the swag," Janet whispered. "Someone's going to shine 
a searchlight any second, and then the police will close in. Are there police 
here?" 
"Yes," said Cat. "Do shut up." 
But, as usual, there was no one about near the private door. They crept down the 
shiny passage and peeped outside. The space by the rhododendrons was empty. They 
crept out towards them. Trees that would hide Mr. Baslam would hide them and 
their loot. 
They were three steps outside the door when a massed choir burst into song. 
Janet and Cat nearly jumped out of their skins. "We belong to Chrestomanci 
Castle! We belong to Chrestomanci Castle!" thundered forty voices. Some were 
deep, some were shrill, but all were very loud. They made a shattering noise. It 
took them a second or so to realize that the voices were coming from their 
bundles. 
"Creeping antimacassars!" said Janet. 
They turned around and ran for the door again, with the forty voices bawling in 
their ears. 
Miss Bessemer opened the door. She stood tall and narrow and purple, waiting for 
them to come through it. There was nothing Janet and Cat could do but scuttle 
guiltily past her into the passage, where they put their suddenly silent bundles 
down on the floor and steeled themselves for trouble. 
"What an awful noise, my loves!" said Miss Bessemer. "I haven't heard the like 
since a silly warlock tried to burgle us. What were you doing?" 
Janet did not know who the stately purple lady was. She was too scared to speak. 
Cat had to say something. "We were wanting to play houses in the tree house," he 
said. "We needed some things for it." He was surprised how likely he made it 
sound. 
"You should have told me, sillies!" said Miss Bessemer. "I could have given you 
some things that don't mind being taken outside. Run and put those back, and 
I'll look you out some nice furnishings for tomorrow." 
They crept dismally back to Janet's room. "I just can't get used to the way 
everything's magic here," Janet moaned. "It's getting me down. Who was that long 
purple lady? I'm offering even money she's a sorceress." 
"Miss Bessemer. The housekeeper," said Cat. 
"Any hope that she'll give us splendid castoffs that will fetch twenty quid in 
the open market?" Janet asked. They both knew that was unlikely. They were no 
nearer thinking of another way to earn twenty pounds when the dressing gong 
went. 
Cat had warned Janet what dinner was like. She had promised not to jump when 
footmen passed things over her shoulder, and sworn not to try and talk about 
statues with Mr. Saunders. She assured Cat she would not mind hearing Bernard 
talk of stocks and shares. So Cat thought that for once he could be easy. He 
helped Janet dress and even had a shower himself, and when they went into the 
drawing room, he thought that they both did him credit. 
But Mr. Saunders proved at last to have worn out his craze for statues. Instead, 
everyone began to talk about identical twins, and then about exact doubles who 
were no relation. Even Bernard forgot to talk about shares in his interest in 
this new subject. 
"The really difficult point," he boomed, leaning forward with his eyebrows 
working up and down his forehead, "is how such people fit in with a series of 
other worlds." 
And, to Cat's dismay, the talk turned to other worlds. He might have been 
interested at any other time. Now he dared not look at Janet, and could only 
wish that everyone would stop. But they talked eagerly, all of them, 
particularly Bernard and Mr. Saunders. Cat learned that a lot was known about 
other worlds. Numbers had been visited. Those which were best known had been 
divided into sets, called series, according to the events in History which were 
the same in them. It was very uncommon for people not to have at least one exact 
double in a world of the same series—usually people had a whole string of 
doubles, all along the set. 
"But what about doubles outside a series?" Mr. Saunders said. "I have at least 
one double in Series Three, and I suspect the existence of another in—" 
Janet sat up sharply, gasping. "Cat, help! It's like sitting on pins!" 
Cat looked at Julia. He saw the little smile on her face, and the tail end of 
her handkerchief above the table. "Change places," he whispered, feeling rather 
tired. He stood up. Everyone stared. 
"All of which makes me feel that a satisfactory classification has not yet been 
found," Mr. Saunders said, as he turned Cat's way. 
"Do you think," said Cat, "that I could change places with J-Gwendolen, please? 
She can't quite hear what Mr. Saunders is saying from there." 
"Yes, and it's rivetingly interesting," Janet gasped, shooting from her chair. 
"If you find it essential," Chrestomanci said, a little annoyed. 
Cat sat in Janet's chair. He could feel nothing wrong with it. Julia put her 
head down and gave him a long, unpleasant look, and her elbows worked as she 
crossly untied her handkerchief. Cat saw that she was going to hate him too, 
now. He sighed. It was one thing after another. 
Nevertheless, when Cat fell asleep that night, he was not feeling hopeless. He 
could not believe things could get any worse—so they had to get better. Perhaps 
Miss Bessemer would give them something very valuable, and they could sell it. 
Or, better still, perhaps Gwendolen would be back when he woke up, and already 
solving all his problems. 
But when he went to Gwendolen's room in the morning, it was still Janet, 
struggling to tie her garters and saying over her shoulder, "These things are 
probably very bad for people. Do you wear them too? Or are they a female 
torture? And one useful thing magic could do would be to hold one's stockings 
up. It makes you think that witches can't be very practical." 
She did talk a lot, Cat thought. But it was better than having no one in 
Gwendolen's place. 
At breakfast, neither Mary nor Euphemia were at all friendly and, as soon as 
they left the room, one of the curtains wrapped itself around Janet's neck and 
tried to strangle her. Cat took it away. It fought him like a live thing because 
Julia was holding both ends of her handkerchief and pulling hard on the knot. 
"Oh, do stop it, Julia!" he begged her. 
"Yes, do," Roger agreed. "It's silly and it's boring. I need to enjoy my food in 
peace." 
"I'm quite willing to be friends," Janet offered. 
"That makes one of us," said Julia. "No." 
"Then be enemies!" Janet snapped, almost in Gwendolen's manner. "I thought at 
first that you might be nice, but I can see now that you're just a tedious, 
pigheaded, cold-hearted, horny-handed, cross-eyed hag!" 
That, of course, was calculated to make Julia adore her. 
Luckily, Mr. Saunders appeared earlier than usual. There had only been time for 
Janet's marmalade to turn to orange worms, and change back again when Cat gave 
her his instead, and for Janet's coffee to become rich brown gravy, and turn to 
coffee again when Cat drank it, before Mr. Saunders stuck his head around the 
door. At least, Cat thought it was lucky, until Mr. Saunders said, "Eric, 
Chrestomanci wants to see you now, in his study." 
Cat stood up. His stomach, full of charmed marmalade as it was, made an 
unusually rapid descent to the Castle cellars. Chrestomanci's found out, he 
thought. He knows about the dragons' blood and about Janet, and he's going to 
look at me politely and— Oh, I do hope he isn't an enchanter! 
"Where—where do I go?" he managed to say. 
"Take him, Roger," said Mr. Saunders. 
"And—and why?" Cat asked. 
Mr. Saunders smiled. "You'll find out. Off you go." 



12 
Chrestomanci's study was a large, sun-filled room with books in shelves all 
around it. There was a desk, but Chrestomanci was not sitting at it. He was 
sprawled on a sofa in the sun, reading a newspaper and wearing a green dressing 
gown with golden dragons on it. The gold embroidery of the dragons winked and 
glittered in the sun. Cat could not take his eyes off them. He stood just inside 
the door, not daring to go any farther, and he thought: He has found out about 
the dragons' blood. 
Chrestomanci looked up and smiled. "Don't look so frightened," he said, laying 
down his newspaper. "Come and sit down." 
He pointed to a large leather armchair. It was all in his friendliest way but, 
these days, Cat was sure this meant precisely nothing. He was sure that the 
friendlier Chrestomanci seemed, the angrier this meant he was. He stole over to 
the armchair and sat in it. It proved to be one of those deep, sloping kind of 
chairs. Cat slid backwards down the slippery leather slope of its seat until he 
found he was having to look at Chrestomanci from between his knees. He felt 
quite defenseless. He thought he ought to say something, so he whispered, "Good 
morning." 
"You don't look as if you thought so," observed Chrestomanci. "No doubt you have 
your reasons. But don't worry. This isn't exactly about the frog again. You see, 
I've been thinking about you—" 
"Oh, you needn't!" Cat said from his half-lying position. He felt that if 
Chrestomanci were to fix his thoughts on something on the other side of the 
universe, it would hardly be too far away. 
"It didn't hurt much," said Chrestomanci. "Thank you all the same. As I was 
saying, the frog affair set me thinking. And though I fear you probably have as 
little moral sense as your wretched sister, I wondered if I could trust you. Do 
you think I can trust you?" 
Cat had no idea where this could be leading, except that from the way 
Chrestomanci put it, he did not seem to trust Cat very much. "Nobody's ever 
trusted me before," Cat said cautiously— except Janet, he thought, and only 
because she had no choice. 
"But it might be worth trying, don't you think?" suggested Chrestomanci. "I ask 
because I'm going to start you on witchcraft lessons." 
Cat had simply not expected this. He was horrified. His legs waved about in the 
chair with the shock. He managed to stop them, but he was still horrified. The 
moment Mr. Saunders started trying to teach him magic, it would be obvious that 
Cat had no witchcraft at all. Then Chrestomanci would start to think about the 
frog all over again. Cat cursed the chance that had made Janet draw in her 
breath and caused him to confess. "Oh, you mustn't do that!" he said. "It would 
be quite fatal. I mean, you can't trust me at all. I'm black-hearted. I'm evil. 
It was living with Mrs. Sharp that did it. If I learned witchcraft, there's no 
knowing what I'd do. Look what I did to Euphemia." 
"That," said Chrestomanci, "is just the kind of accident I'm anxious to prevent. 
If you learn how and what to do, you're far less likely to make that kind of 
mistake again." 
"Yes, but I'd probably do it on purpose," Cat assured him. "You'll be putting 
the means in my hands." 
"You have it there anyway," Chrestomanci said. "And witchcraft will out, you 
know. No one who has it can resist using it forever. What exactly makes you 
think you're so wicked?" 
That question rather stumped Cat. "I steal apples," he said. "And," he 
suggested, "I was quite keen on some of the things Gwendolen did." 
"Oh, me too," Chrestomanci agreed. "One wondered what she would think of next. 
How about her procession of nasties? Or those four apparitions?" 
Cat shivered. He felt sick to think of them. 
"Precisely," said Chrestomanci, and to Cat's dismay, he smiled warmly at him. 
"Right. We'll let Michael start you on Elementary Witchcraft on Monday." 
"Oh, please don't!" Cat struggled out of the slippery chair in order to plead 
better. "I'll bring a plague of locusts. I'll be worse than Moses and Aaron." 
Chrestomanci said musingly, "It might be quite useful if you parted the waters 
of the English Channel. Think of all the seasickness you'd save. Don't be so 
alarmed. We've no intention of teaching you to do things the way Gwendolen did." 

Cat trailed forlornly back to the schoolroom to find them having Geography. Mr. 
Saunders was raging at Janet for not knowing where Atlantis was. 
"How was I to know it's what I call America?" Janet asked Cat at lunchtime. 
"Though, mind you, that was a lucky guess when I said it was ruled by the Incas. 
What's the matter, Cat? You look ready to cry. He's not found out about Mr. 
Biswas, has he?" 
"No, but it's quite as bad," said Cat, and he explained. 
"This was all we needed!" said Janet. "Discovery threatens on all sides. But it 
may not be quite as bad as it seems, when I think. You might be able to work up 
a little magic if you practiced first. Let's see what we can do after school 
with Gwendolen's books that the dear, kind girl so obligingly left us." 
Cat was quite glad when lessons started again. He was sick of changing plates 
with Janet, and Julia's handkerchief must have been worn to rags with the number 
of knots tied in it. After lessons, he and Janet collected the two magic books 
and took them up to Cat's room. Janet looked around it with admiration. 
"I like this room much better than mine. It's cheerful. Mine makes me feel like 
the Sleeping Beauty and Cinderella, and they were both such sickeningly sweet 
girls. Now let's get down to work. What's a really simple spell?" 
They knelt on the floor, leafing through a book each. "I wish I could find how 
to turn buttons into sovereigns," said Cat. "We could pay Mr. Baslam then." 
"Don't talk about it," said Janet. "I'm at our wits' end. How about this? 
'Simple flotation exercise. Take a small mirror and lay it so that your face is 
visible in it. Keeping face visible, move around widder-shins three times, twice 
silently willing, the third time saying: "Rise little mirror, rise in air, rise 
to my head and then stay there." Mirror should then rise—' I think you ought to 
be able to manage that, Cat." 
"I'll have a go," Cat said dubiously. "What's widdershins?" 
"Anticlockwise," said Janet. "That I do know." 
"I thought it meant crawling," Cat said humbly. 
Janet looked at him consideringly. "I suppose you're quite small still," she 
said, "but you do worry me when you go all cowed. Has anyone done anything to 
you?" 
"I don't think so," Cat said, rather surprised. "Why?" 
"Well, I never had a brother," said Janet. "Fetch a mirror." 
Cat got the hand mirror from his chest of drawers and laid it carefully in the 
middle of the floor. "Like that?" 
Janet sighed. "That's what I mean. I knew you'd get it if I ordered you to. Do 
you mind not being so kind and obedient? It makes me nervous. Anyway—" She took 
up the book. "Can you see your face in it?" 
"Almost nothing else," said Cat. 
"Funny. I can see my face," said Janet. "Can I do it, too?" 
"You're more likely to get it to work than I am," said Cat. 
So they both circled the mirror, and they said the words in chorus. The door 
opened. Mary came in. Janet guiltily put the book behind her back. 
"Yes, here he is," Mary said. She stood aside to let a strange young man come 
into the room. "This is Will Suggins," she said. "He's Euphemia's young man. He 
wants to talk to you, Eric." 
Will Suggins was tall and burly and rather handsome. His clothes looked as if he 
had brushed them carefully after working in a bakery all day. He was not 
friendly. "It was you turned Euphemia into a frog, was it?" he said to Cat. 
"Yes," said Cat. He dared say nothing else with Mary there. 
"You're rather small," said Will Suggins. He seemed disappointed about it. 
"Anyway," he said, "whatever size you are, I'm not having Euphemia turned into 
things. I take exception to it. Understand ?" 
"I'm very sorry," said Cat. "I won't do it again." 
"Too right you won't!" said Will Suggins. "You got off too light over this, by 
what Mary tells me. I'm going to teach you a lesson you won't forget in a 
hurry." 
"No you're not!" said Janet. She marched up to Will Suggins and pushed Magic for 
Beginners threateningly towards him. "You're three times his size, and he's said 
he's sorry. If you touch Cat, I shall—" She took the book out of Will Suggins' 
chest in order to leaf hastily through it. "I shall induce complete immobility 
in the legs and trunk." 
"And very pretty I shall look, I'm sure!" Will Suggins said, much amused. "How 
are you going to do that without your witchcraft, may I ask? And if you did, I 
daresay I could get out of it fast enough. I'm a fair warlock myself. Though," 
he said, turning to Mary, "you might have warned me he was this small." 
"Not so small where witchcraft and mischief are concerned," said Mary. "Neither 
of them are. They're a pair of real bad lots." 
"Well, I'll do it by witchcraft then. I'm easy," said Will Suggins. He searched 
in the pockets of his slightly floury jacket. "Ah!" he said, and fetched out 
what seemed to be a lump of dough. For a moment he shaped it vigorously in both 
powerful hands. Then he rolled it into a ball and threw it at Cat's feet. It 
landed on the carpet with a soft plop. Cat looked at it in great apprehension, 
wondering what it was supposed to do. 
"That'll lie there," said Will Suggins, "until three o'clock Sunday. Sunday's a 
bad time to be at witchcraft, but it's my free day. I shall be waiting for you 
then in Bedlam Field, in the form of a tiger. I make a good tiger. You can turn 
yourself into something as large as you like, or small and fast, if you prefer, 
and I'll teach you that lesson whatever you are. But if you don't come to Bedlam 
Field in the form of something, that lump of dough will start to work and you'll 
be a frog yourself—for as long as I feel like keeping you that way. Right, Mary. 
I'm through now." 
Will Suggins turned and marched out of the room. Mary followed him, but she was 
unable to resist putting her head back around the door to say, "And see how you 
like that, Eric!" before she shut it. 
Cat and Janet looked at one another and then at the lump of dough. "What am I 
going to do?" said Cat. 
Janet threw her book onto Cat's bed and tried to pick up the lump of dough. But 
it had grown to the carpet. She could not shift it. "You'd only get this up by 
cutting a hole in the floor," she said. "Cat, this gets worse and worse. If 
you'll forgive my saying so, I've stopped loving your sugar-coated sister even 
one tiny bit!" 
"It was my fault," said Cat. "I shouldn't have lied about Euphemia. That's what 
got me in this mess, not Gwendolen." 
"Mess is not a strong enough word," said Janet. "On Sunday, you get mauled by a 
tiger. On Monday, it comes out that you can't do magic. And if the whole story 
doesn't come out then, it will on Wednesday, when Mr. Bedlam calls for his 
money. Do you think Fate has something up its sleeve for Tuesday too? I suppose 
if you go to meet him on Sunday in the form of yourself, he can't hurt you much, 
can he? It's better than waiting to be turned into a frog." 
"I'd better do that," Cat agreed, looking at that ominous lump of dough. "I wish 
I really could turn into things, though. I'd go as a flea. He'd scratch himself 
to bits trying to find me." 
Janet laughed. "Let's see if there's a spell for it." She turned around to fetch 
Magic for Beginners and hit her head on the mirror. It was hanging in the air, 
level with her forehead. "Cat! One of us did it! Look!" 
Cat looked, without much interest. He had too much else on his mind. "I expect 
it was you. You're the same as Gwendolen, so you're bound to be able to work 
spells. But changing into things won't be in either of those books. That's 
Advanced Magic." 
"Then I'll do the spell to get the mirror down," said Janet. "Not that I want to 
be a witch. The more I see of witchcraft, the more it seems just an easy way to 
be nasty." 
She had opened the book, when there was a knock at the door. Janet seized the 
chair beside Cat's bed and stood on it, so as to hide the mirror. Cat hastily 
dropped to one knee on top of the lump of dough. Neither of them wanted any more 
trouble. 
Janet doubled Magic for Beginners inside out so that it could have been any 
book, and waved it at Cat. "'Come into the garden, Maud,'" she proclaimed. 
Taking this as an invitation, Miss Bessemer opened the door and came in. She was 
carrying an armful of things, with a chipped teapot hanging off one finger. "The 
furnishings I promised you, loves," she said. 
"Oh," said Janet. "Oh, thanks very much. We were just having a poetry reading, 
you know." 
"And I made sure you were talking to me!" Miss Bessemer said, laughing. "My 
name's Maud. Will these be all right on the bed?" 
"Yes, thanks," said Cat. 
Neither of them dared move. They twisted around to watch Miss Bessemer dump the 
armful on the bed and, still twisted, they thanked her profusely. As soon as 
Miss Bessemer had gone, they dived to see if, by any blessed chance, any of the 
pile was valuable. Nothing was. As Janet said, if they really had wanted to play 
houses, two stools and an old carpet would have been just the thing, but from a 
selling point of view, they were just a dead loss. 
"It was kind of her to remember," Cat said as he packed the heap into his 
cupboard. 
"Except that now we'll have to remember to play houses with them," Janet said 
morosely. "As if we hadn't enough to do. Now, I will get this mirror down. I 
will!" 
But the mirror refused to come down. Janet tried all three spells in both books, 
and it still stayed hanging in the air level with her head. 
"You try, Cat," said Janet. "We can't leave it there." 
Cat roused himself from gloomily staring at the ball of dough. It was still 
round. There was no sign that he had knelt on it, and that alarmed him. He knew 
it must be a very strong charm. But when Janet appealed to him, he sighed and 
reached up to pull the mirror down. His experience with Julia had taught him 
that a simple spell could usually be broken quite simply. 
The mirror refused to descend an inch. But it slid about in the air. Cat was 
interested. He hung on to it with both hands, pushed off with his feet, and went 
traveling across the room in a most agreeable way. 
"That looks fun," said Janet. 
"It is," said Cat. "You try." 
They played with the mirror for some time after that. It could go as fast as 
they could push it, and it took the weight of both of them easily. Janet 
discovered that the best ride was to be had by standing on the chest of drawers 
and jumping. Then, provided you kept your feet up, you could swing across the 
room and land on Cat's bed. They were whirling together across the carpet, 
tangled up and laughing a good deal, when Roger knocked at the door and came in. 

"I say, that's a good idea!" he said. "We've never thought of that. Can I have a 
go? And I met a peculiar cross-eyed man in the village, Gwendolen, and he gave 
me this letter for you." 
Cat dropped off onto the carpet and took the letter. It was from Mr. Nostrum. 
Cat recognized the writing. He was so pleased that he said to Roger, "Have 
twenty goes if you want!" and rushed up to Janet with the letter. "Read it, 
quick! What does it say?" 
Mr. Nostrum could get them out of their troubles. He might not be much of a 
necromancer, but he was surely able to turn Cat into a flea, if Janet asked him 
nicely. He would certainly have a charm that could make Cat look as if he could 
do magic. And though Mr. Nostrum was not rich, his brother William was. He could 
lend Cat twenty pounds, if he thought he was helping Gwendolen. 
Cat sat on the bed beside Janet and they read the letter, while Roger trundled 
about the room dangling from the mirror and chuckling placidly at what fun it 
was. Mr. Nostrum wrote: 
My dear and favorite pupil, 
I am here, domiciled at the White Hart Inn. It is most important—/ repeat, of 
the utmost importance—that you come to me here on Saturday afternoon, bringing 
your brother to be briefed by me. 
Your affectionate and proud teacher, Henry Nostrum 
At this, Janet looked nervous and mystified and moaned gently. 
"I hope it's not bad news," Roger said, sailing past with his feet hooked up 
behind him. 
"No, it's the best news we could have had!" Cat said. He dug Janet in the ribs 
to make her smile. She smiled dutifully, but he could not make her see that it 
was good news, even when he had a chance to explain. 
"If he taught Gwendolen, he'll know I'm not her," she said. "And if he doesn't 
know, he won't understand why you want to be turned into a flea. It is an odd 
thing to go and ask, even in this world. And he'd want to know why I couldn't do 
it to you. Couldn't we tell him the truth?" 
"No, because it's Gwendolen he's fond of," Cat explained. Something told him 
that Mr. Nostrum would be almost as little pleased as Chrestomanci to find that 
Gwendolen had departed for another world. "And he's got some kind of plans for 
her." 
"Yes, this briefing," Janet said irritably. "He obviously thinks I know all 
about it. If you ask me, Cat, it's just one more damned thing!" 
Nothing could convince Janet that salvation was at hand. Cat was quite sure it 
was. He went to sleep rejoicing, and woke up happy. He still felt happy, even 
when he trod on the lump of dough and it was cold and froglike under his foot. 
He covered it up with Magic for Beginners. Then he had to turn his attention to 
the mirror. It would keep drifting out into the middle of the room. Cat had to 
tether it to the bookcase with his Sunday bootlace in the end. 
He found Janet less happy than ever. Julia's latest idea was a mosquito. It met 
Janet as she came into breakfast, and it kept with her, whining in and biting, 
all through lessons, until Cat swatted it with his arithmetic book. What with 
this, and nasty looks from both Julia and Mary, and then having to meet Mr. 
Nostrum, Janet became both peevish and miserable. 
"It's all right for you," she said morbidly, as they tramped down the avenue on 
their way to the village that afternoon. "You've been brought up with all this 
magic and you're used to it. But I'm not. And what scares me is that it's 
forever. And it scares me even more that it isn't forever. Suppose Gwendolen 
gets tired of her new world and decides to move on again? When that happens, off 
we shall be dragged, a whole string of us doubles, and I'll be having to cope in 
her world, and you'll have all your troubles over again with a new one." 
"Oh, I'm sure that won't happen," Cat said, rather startled at the possibility. 
"She's bound to come back soon." 
"Oh, is she?" said Janet. They came through the gates, and again mothers 
snatched children out of their sight, and the village green emptied as they 
reached it. "I wish I was back at home!" Janet wailed, almost in tears at the 
way everyone ran away. 



13
They were ushered into a private parlor in the White Hart. Mr. Henry Nostrum 
rolled pompously to meet them. 
"My dear young friends!" He put his hands on Janet's shoulders and kissed her. 
Janet started backwards, knocking her hat over one ear. Cat was a little shaken. 
He had forgotten Mr. Nostrum's seedy, shabby look, and the weird effect of his 
wandering left eye. "Sit down, sit down!" said Mr. Nostrum heartily. "Have some 
ginger beer." 
They sat down. They sipped ginger beer, which neither of them liked. "What did 
you want me for, as well as Gwendolen?" Cat asked. 
"Because," said Mr. Nostrum, "to come straight to the point and not to beat 
about the bush, we find, as we rather feared we would, that we are quite unable 
to make use of those three signatures which you were kind enough to donate to me 
for services rendered in the tuition line. The Person Who Inhabits That Castle 
Yonder, whose name I disdain to say, signs his name under unbreakable 
protections. You may call it prudent of him. But I fear it necessitates our 
using Plan Two. Which was why, my dear Cat, we were so glad to arrange for you 
to live at the Castle." 
"What is Plan Two?" said Janet. 
Mr. Nostrum's odd eye slipped sideways across Janet's face. He did not seem to 
realize she was not Gwendolen. Perhaps his wandering eye did not see very well. 
"Plan Two is just as I described it to you, my dear Gwendolen," he said. "We 
have not changed it one whit." 
Janet had to try another way to find out what he was talking about. She was 
getting quite good at it. "I want you to describe it to Cat, though," she said. 
"He doesn't know about it, and he may need to because—-because most 
unfortunately they've taken my witchcraft away." 
Mr. Nostrum wagged a playful finger at her. "Yes, naughty girl. I've been 
hearing things about you in the village. A sad thing to lose, but let us hope it 
will only be temporary. Now—as to explaining to Young Chant—how shall I best go 
about it?" He thought, smoothing his frizzy wings of hair, as his habit was. 
Somehow, the way he did it showed Cat that whatever Mr. Nostrum was going to 
tell him, it would not be quite the truth. It was in the movement of Mr. 
Nostrum's hands, and in the very sit of his silver watch-chain across his 
shabby, rounded waistcoat. 
"Well, Young Chant," said Mr. Nostrum, "this is the matter in a nutshell. There 
is a group, a clique, a collection of people, headed by the Master of the 
Castle, who are behaving very selfishly in connection with witchcraft. They are 
keeping all the best things to themselves, which of course makes them very 
dangerous—a threat to all witches, and a looming disaster to ordinary people. 
For instance, take dragons' blood. You know that it is banned. These people, 
with That Person at their head, had it banned, and yet—mark this well, Young 
Chant— they use it daily themselves. And—here is my point—they keep tight 
control of the ways to get to the worlds where dragons' blood comes from. An 
ordinary necromancer like myself can only get it at great risk and expense, and 
our exotic suppliers have to endanger themselves to get it for us. And the same 
goes for almost any product from another world. 
"Now, I ask you, Young Chant, is this fair? No. And I'll tell you why not, young 
Eric. It is not fair that the ways to other worlds should be in the hands of a 
few. That is the crux of the matter: the ways to other worlds. We want them 
opened up, made free to everyone. And that is where you come in, Young Chant. 
The best and easiest way, the broadest Gateway to Elsewhere, if I may put it 
like that, is a certain enclosed garden in the grounds of this said Castle. I 
expect you have been forbidden to enter it—" 
"Yes," said Cat. "We have been." 
"And consider how unfair!" said Mr. Nostrum. "The Master of That Place uses it 
every day and travels where he pleases. So what I want you to do, Young Chant, 
and this is all Plan Two amounts to, is to go into that garden at two-thirty 
precisely on Sunday afternoon. Can you promise me to do that?" 
"What good would that do?" asked Cat. 
"It would break the seal of enchantment these dastardly persons have set on the 
Gateways to Elsewhere," Mr. Nostrum said. 
"I've never quite understood," Janet said, with a very convincing wrinkle in her 
forehead, "how Cat could break the seals just by going into the garden." 
Mr. Nostrum looked a little irritated. "By being an ordinary innocent lad, of 
course. My dear Gwendolen, I have stressed to you over and over again the 
importance of having an innocent lad at the center of Plan Two. You must 
understand." 
"Oh, I do, I do," Janet said hastily. "And has it to be this Sunday at 
two-thirty?" 
"As ever is," said Mr. Nostrum, smiling again. "It's a good strong time. Will 
you do that for us, Young Chant? Will you, by this simple act, set your sister 
and people like her free—free to do as they need in the practice of magic?" 
"I'll get into trouble if I'm caught," said Cat. 
"A bit of boyish cunning will see you through. Then, never fear, we'll take care 
of you afterwards," Mr. Nostrum persuaded. 
"I suppose I can try," said Cat. "But do you think you can help me a bit in 
return? Do you think your brother could very kindly lend us twenty pounds by 
next Wednesday?" 
A vague, though affable, look affected Mr. Nostrum's left eye. It pointed 
benevolently to the farthest corner of the parlor. "Anything you please, dear 
boy. Just get into that garden, and the fruits of all the worlds will be yours 
for the picking." 
"I need to be a flea half an hour later, and I want to look as if I can do magic 
on Monday," said Cat. "That's all I need, apart from the twenty pounds." 
"Anything, anything! Just get into that garden for us," said Mr. Nostrum 
expansively. 
With that, it seemed Cat and Janet had to be content. Cat made several efforts 
to fix Mr. Nostrum in a definite promise, but all he would say was, "Just get 
into that garden." Janet looked at Cat and they got up to go. 
"Let us gossip," suggested Mr. Nostrum. "I have at least two items of interest 
to you." 
"We haven't time," Janet lied firmly. "Come on, Cat." 
Mr. Nostrum was used to Gwendolen being equally firm. He got up and led them to 
the Inn door like royalty and waved to them as they went out onto the green. 
"I'll see you on Sunday," he called after them. 
"No you won't!" Janet whispered. Keeping her head down so that Gwendolen's broad 
hat hid her from Mr. Nostrum, she whispered to Cat, "Cat, if you do one thing 
that unbelievably dishonest man wants, you'll be a fool! I know he told you a 
pack of lies. I don't know what he's really after, but please don't do it." 
"I know—" Cat was beginning, when Mr. Baslam got up from a bench outside the 
White Hart and shambled after them. 
"Wait!" he puffed, rolling beer fumes over them. "Young lady, young sir, I hope 
you're bearing in mind what I said to you. Wednesday. Don't forget Wednesday." 
"No fear. It haunts my dreams," said Janet. "Please. We're busy, Mr. Bustle." 
They walked quickly away across the green. The only other living soul in sight 
was Will Suggins, who came out of the backyard of the bread shop in order to 
stare meaningly after them. 
"I think I've got to do what he wants," Cat said. 
"Don't," said Janet. "Though I must say I can't see what else we can do." 
"About the only thing left is running away," said Cat. 
"Then let's do that—at once," said Janet. 
They did not exactly run. They walked briskly out of the village on the road Cat 
thought pointed nearest to Wolvercote. When Janet objected that Wolvercote was 
the first place anyone at the Castle would think of looking, Cat explained about 
Mrs. Sharp's grand contacts in London. He knew Mrs. Sharp would smuggle them 
away somewhere, and no questions asked. He made himself very homesick by talking 
of Mrs. Sharp. He missed her dreadfully. He trudged along the country road, 
wishing it was Coven Street and wishing Janet was not walking beside him making 
objections. 
"Well, you may be right," Janet said, "and I don't know where else we could go. 
How do we get to Wolvercote? Hitchhike?" When Cat did not understand, she 
explained that it meant getting lifts by waving your thumb. 
"That would save a lot of walking," Cat agreed. 
The road he had chosen shortly turned into a very country lane, rutted and 
grassy and lined with high hedges hung with red bryony berries. There was no 
traffic of any kind. 
Janet managed not to point this out. "One thing," she said. "If we're going to 
make a proper go of this, do promise me you won't happen to mention You Know 
Who." When Cat did not understand this either, she explained, "The man Mr. 
Nostrum kept calling That Person and the Master of the Castle—you know!" 
"Oh," said Cat. "You mean Chrest—" 
"Quiet!" bawled Janet. "I do mean him, and you mustn't say it. He's an enchanter 
and he comes when you call him, stupid! Just think of the way that Mr. Nostrum 
was scared stiff to say his name." 
Cat thought about this. Gloomy and homesick as he was, he was not anxious to 
agree with anything Janet said. She was not really his sister, after all. 
Besides, Mr. Nostrum had not been telling the truth. And Gwendolen had never 
said Chrestomanci was an enchanter. She would surely never have dared do all the 
magic she did if she thought he was. "I don't believe you," he said. 
"All right. Don't," said Janet. "Just don't say his name." 
"I don't mind," said Cat. "I hope I never see him again anyway." 
The lane grew wilder as they walked. It was a crisp, warm afternoon. There were 
nuts in the hedges and great bushes of blackberries. Before they had gone 
another half mile, Cat found his feelings had changed entirely. He was free. His 
troubles had been left behind. He and Janet picked the nuts, which were just 
ripe enough to eat, and laughed a good deal over cracking them. Janet took her 
hat off-—as she told Cat repeatedly, she hated hats—and they tilled the crown of 
it with blackberries for later on. They laughed when the juice oozed through the 
hat and dripped down Janet's dress. 
"I think running away is fun," said Cat. 
"Wait till we're spending the night in a rat-infested barn," said Janet. 
"Flitterings and squeak-ings. Are there ghouls and goblins in this wor—? Oh, 
look! There's a car coming! Thumb—no, wave. They probably don't understand 
thumbing." 
They waved furiously at the big black car that was whispering and bouncing along 
the ruts towards them. To their delight, it sighed to a stop beside them. The 
nearest window rolled down. They got a very rude shock when Julia put her head 
out of it. 
Julia was pale and agitated. "Oh please come back!" she said. "I know you ran 
away because of me, and I'm sorry! I swear I won't do it anymore!" 
Roger put his head out of the back window. "I kept telling her you would," he 
said. "And she didn't believe me. Do come back. Please." 
The driver's door had opened by then. Millie came hurrying around the long 
bonnet of the car. She looked much more homely than usual, because her skirts 
were looped up for driving and she was wearing stout shoes and an old hat. She 
was as agitated as Julia. When she reached Janet and Cat, she flung an arm 
around each of them and hugged them so hard and thankfully that Cat nearly fell 
over. 
"You poor darlings! Another time you get unhappy, you must come and tell me at 
once\ And what a thing too! I was so afraid you'd got into real trouble, and 
then Julia told me it was her. I'm extremely vexed with her. A girl did that to 
me once and I know how miserable it made me. Now, please, please come back. I've 
got a surprise waiting for you at the Castle." 
There was nothing Cat and Janet could do but climb into the back of the car and 
be driven back to the Castle. They were miserable. Cat's misery was increased by 
the fact that he began to feel sick from the moment Millie started to bump the 
car backwards down the lane to a gate where she could turn it. The smell of 
blackberry coming from Janet's squashy hat made him feel worse. 
Millie, Roger, and Julia were very relieved to have found them. They chattered 
joyfully the whole way. Through his sickness, Cat got the impression that, 
although none of them said so, what they were particularly glad about was to 
have found Janet and Cat before Chrestomanci came to hear they were gone. This 
did not make either Cat or Janet feel any better. 
In five minutes, the car had whispered up the avenue and stopped at the main 
door of the Castle. The butler opened it for them just, Cat thought sadly, as 
Gwendolen would have wished. The butler, furthermore, ceremoniously took Janet's 
leaking hat away from her. "I'll see that these get to Cook," he said. 
Millie told Janet that her dress would just pass muster and hurried them to what 
was called the Little Drawing Room. "Which means, of course, that it's a mere 
seventy feet square," she said. "Go in. Tea will be there for you." 
They went in. In the middle of the big, square room, a wispy, skinny woman in 
beaded black clothes was sitting nervously on the edge of a gilded chair. She 
jumped around when the door opened. 
Cat forgot he felt sick. "Mrs. Sharp!" he shouted, and ran to hug her. 
Mrs. Sharp was overjoyed, in spite of her nervousness. "It's my Cat, then! Here, 
stand back, let me look at you, and you too, Gwendolen, love. My word, you do 
wear fine clothes to go playing about in! You're fatter, Cat. And Gwendolen, 
you've gone thin. I can understand that, dear, believe me! And would you just 
look at the tea they've brought for the three of us!" 
It was a marvelous tea, even better than the tea on the lawn. Mrs. Sharp, in her 
old greedy way, settled down to eat as much as she could, and to gossip hard. 
"Yes, we came up on the train yesterday, Mr. Nostrum and me. After I got your 
postcard, Cat, I couldn't rest till I'd had a look at you both, and seeing as 
how my contacts and other things have been paying nicely, I felt I owed it to 
myself. They treated me like royalty when I turned up here at the door too. I 
can't fault them. But I wish I cared for it in this Castle. Tell me, Gwendolen, 
love, does it get you like it gets me?" 
"How does it get you?" Janet asked cautiously. 
"I'm nerves all over," said Mrs. Sharp. "I feel weak and jumpy as a kitten—and 
that reminds me, Cat, but I'll tell you later. It's so quiet here. I kept trying 
to think what it was before you came— and you were a long time, my loves—and at 
last it came to me. It's an enchantment, that's what it is, a terrible strong 
one too, against us witches. I said, 'This Castle does not love witches, that's 
what it is!' and I felt for you, Gwendolen. Make him send you to school away 
somewhere. You'd be happier." 
She chattered on. She was delighted to see them both, and she kept giving Cat 
particularly proud and affectionate looks. Cat thought she had convinced herself 
she had brought him up from a baby. After all, she had known him since he was 
born. 
"Tell us about Coven Street," he said yearningly. 
"I was coming to that," said Mrs. Sharp. "You remember Miss Larkins? 
Bad-tempered girl with red hair who used to tell fortunes? I never thought much 
of her myself. But someone did. She's been set up by a grateful client in a 
Salon in Bond Street. Coven Street's not good enough for her anymore. The luck 
some people have! But I've had a stroke of luck myself too. I told you in my 
letter—didn't I, Cat?—about being given five pounds for that old cat you turned 
our Cat's fiddle into, Gwendolen. Well, he was ever such a funny little man who 
bought him. While we were waiting to catch the old cat—you know how he never 
would come if you wanted him—this little man kept at me, telling me all about 
stocks and shares and capital investment and such like. Things I never could 
understand. He told me what I ought to be doing with that five pound he was 
giving me, and making my head go around with it. Well, I didn't think too much 
of it, but I thought I'd have a go. And I did what he said, as far as I could 
remember. And do you know, that five pounds has brought in one hundred! One 
hundred pounds, he got me!" 
"He must have been a financial wizard," Janet said. 
She meant it as a joke to cheer herself up. She needed cheering up for several 
reasons. But Mrs. Sharp took her literally. "He was, my dear! You're always so 
clever. I know he was, because I told Mr. Nostrum, and Mr. Nostrum did exactly 
what I did with five pounds of his own—or it may have been more—and he lost 
every penny of it. And another thing-—" 
Cat watched Mrs. Sharp as she chattered on. He was puzzled and sad. He was still 
just as fond of Mrs. Sharp. But he knew it would have been no use whatsoever 
running away to her. She was a weak, dishonest person. She would not have helped 
them. She would have sent them back to the Castle and tried to get money out of 
Chrestomanci for doing it. And the London contacts she was boasting of at that 
moment were just boasts. Cat wondered how much he had changed inside—and why he 
had—enough to know all this. But he did know, just as surely as if Mrs. Sharp 
had turned around in her gilded chair and assured him of it herself, and it 
upset him. 
As Mrs. Sharp came to the end of the food, she seemed to become very nervous. 
Perhaps the Castle was getting her down. At length she got up and took a nervous 
trot to the distant window, absent-mindedly taking her teacup with her. 
"Come and explain this view," she called. "It's so grand I can't understand it." 
Cat and Janet obligingly went over to her. Whereupon Mrs. Sharp became astounded 
to find she had an empty teacup in her hand. "Oh, look at this," she said, 
shaking with nervousness. "I'll be carrying it away with me if I'm not careful." 

"You'd better not," said Cat. "It's bound to be charmed. Everything you take 
outside shouts where it came from." 
"Is that so?" All of a flutter, Mrs. Sharp passed Janet her cup and followed it 
up, very guiltily, with two silver spoons and the sugar tongs out of her 
handbag. "There, dear. Would you mind taking those back to the table?" Janet set 
off across the yards of carpet and, as soon as she was out of hearing, Mrs. 
Sharp bent and whispered, "Have you talked to Mr. Nostrum, Cat?" 
Cat nodded. 
Mrs. Sharp at once became nervous in a much more genuine way. "Don't do what he 
says, love," she whispered. "Not on any account. You hear me? It's a wicked, 
crying shame, and you're not to do it!" Then, as Janet came slowly back—slowly, 
because she could see Mrs. Sharp had something private to say to Cat—Mrs. Sharp 
burst out artificially, "Oh, those great immemorial oaks! They must be older 
than I am!" 
"They're cedars," was all Cat could think of to say. 
"Well, that was a nice tea, my loves, and lovely to see you," said Mrs. Sharp. 
"And I'm glad you warned me about those spoons. It's a mean, wicked trick, 
enchanting property, I always think. I must be going now. Mr. Nostrum's 
expecting me." And go Mrs. Sharp did, through the Castle hall and away down the 
avenue with such speed that it was clear she was glad to go. 
"You can see the Castle really upsets her," Janet said, watching Mrs. Sharp's 
trotting black figure. "There is this quiet. I know what she means. But I think 
it's cheerful—or it would be if everything else wasn't so miserable. Cat, it 
would have been no good running away to her, I'm afraid." 
"I know," said Cat. 
"I thought you did," said Janet. 
She was wanting to say more, but they were interrupted by Roger and Julia. Julia 
was so contrite and trying so hard to be friendly that neither Janet nor Cat had 
the heart to go off on their own. They played with hand mirrors instead. Roger 
fetched the mirror tethered to Cat's bookcase, and collected his own and Julia's 
and Gwendolen's too. Julia took a firm little reef in that handkerchief of hers 
and sent all four aloft in the playroom. Until supper, they had great fun 
whizzing around the playroom, not to speak of up and down the passage outside. 
Supper was in the playroom that evening. There were guests to dinner again 
downstairs. Roger and Julia knew, but no one had mentioned it to Cat and Janet 
for fear the supposed Gwendolen might try to ruin it again. 
"They always entertain a lot in the month before Halloween," Julia said as they 
finished the blackberry tart Cook had made specially out of Janet's hatful. 
"Shall we play soldiers now, or mirrors again?" 
Janet was signaling so hard that she had something urgent to say that Cat had to 
refuse. "I'm awfully sorry. We've got to talk about something Mrs. Sharp told 
us. And don't say Gwendolen owns me. It's not that at all." 
"We forgive you," Roger said. "We might forgive Gwendolen too, with luck." 
"We'll come back when I've said it," said Janet. 
They hurried along to her room, and Janet locked the door in case Euphemia tried 
to come in. 
"Mrs. Sharp said I wasn't on any account to do what Mr. Nostrum says," Cat told 
her. "I think she came specially to tell me." 
"Yes, she's fond of you," said Janet. "Oh—oh— oh drat!" She clasped her hands 
behind her back and marched up and down with her head bent. She looked so like 
Mr. Saunders teaching that Cat started to laugh. "Bother," said Janet. "Bother, 
bother, bother bother botherbotherbother!" She marched some more. "Mrs. Sharp is 
a highly dishonest person, almost as bad as Mr. Nostrum, and probably worse than 
Mr. Bistro, so if she thinks you oughtn't to do it, it must be bad. What are you 
laughing about?" 
"You keep getting Mr. Baslam's name wrong," said Cat. 
"He doesn't deserve to have it got right," Janet said, marching on. "Oh, 
confusticate Mrs. Sharp! After I saw she wasn't any good for any kind of help, I 
was in such despair that I suddenly saw the ideal way out—and she's stopped it. 
You see, if that garden is a way to go to other worlds, you and I could go back 
to my world, and you could live there with me. Don't you think that was a good 
idea? You'd be safe from Chrestomanci and Mr. Baalamb, and I'm sure Will Suggins 
couldn't turn you into a frog there, either, could he?" 
"No," Cat said dubiously. "But I don't think Mr. Nostrum was telling quite the 
truth. All sorts of things could be wrong." 
"Don't I know it!" said Janet. "Especially after Mrs. Sharp. Mum and Dad would 
be another difficulty too—though I'm sure they'd like you when they understood. 
They must be fearfully puzzled by my Dear Replacement by now, as it is. And I 
did have a brother, who died when he was born, so perhaps they'd think you were 
his Dear Replacement." 
"That's funny!" said Cat. "I nearly died being born too." 
"Then you must be him," said Janet, swinging around at the end of her march. 
"They'd be delighted—I hope. And the best of it would have been that Gwendolen 
would have been dragged back here to face the music—and serve her right! This is 
all her fault." 
"No, it isn't," said Cat. 
"Yes, it is!" said Janet. "She did magic when she was forbidden to, and gave Mr. 
Blastoff dud earrings for something she wasn't supposed to have anyway, and 
dragged me here, and turned Euphemia into a frog, and got you into an even worse 
mess than I'm in. Will you stop being so loyal for a moment and notice!" 
"It's no good getting angry," said Cat, and he sighed. He missed Gwendolen even 
more than he had missed Mrs. Sharp. 
Janet sighed too, but with exasperation. She sat down at the dressing table with 
a thump and stared into her own cross face. She pushed its nose up and crossed 
her eyes. She had been doing this every spare minute. It relieved her feelings 
about Gwendolen a little. 
Cat had been thinking. "I think it's a good idea," he said dolefully. "We'd 
better go to the garden. But I think you need some kind of magic to go to 
another world." 
"Thus we find ourselves stumped," said Janet. "It's dangerous, and we can't 
anyway. But they'd taken Gwendolen's witchcraft away, and she did it. How? 
That's been puzzling me a lot." 
"I expect she used dragons' blood," said Cat. "She still had that. Mr. Saunders 
has a whole jar of dragons' blood up in his workshop." 
"Why didn't you say so?" Janet yelled, jumping around on her stool. 
She really might have been Gwendolen. At the sight of her fierce face Cat missed 
Gwendolen more than ever. He resented Janet. She had been ordering him about all 
day. Then she tried to make out it was all Gwendolen's fault. He shrugged 
mulishly and went very unhelpful. "You didn't ask." 
"But can you get some?" 
"Maybe. But," Cat added, "I don't want to go to another world, really." 
Janet drew a long, quiet breath and managed not to tell him to stay and be 
turned into a frog then. She made a very ingenious face at the mirror and 
counted up to ten. "Cat," she said carefully, "we really are in such a mess here 
that I can't see any other way out. Can you?" 
"No," Cat admitted grudgingly. "I said I'd go." 
"And thank you, dear Janet, for your kind invitation, I notice," Janet said. To 
her relief, Cat grinned. "But we'll have to be hideously careful about going," 
she said, "because I suspect that if Chrestomanci doesn't know what we're doing, 
Millie will." 
"Millie?" said Cat. 
"Millie," said Janet. "I think she's a witch." She ducked her head down and 
fiddled with the gold-backed hairbrush. "I know you think I go around seeing 
sorcery everywhere with my nasty, suspicious mind, like you did about 
Chrestomanci, but I really am sure, Cat. A sweet, kind honey of a witch, if you 
like. But she is one. How else did she know we were running away this 
afternoon?" 
"Because Mrs. Sharp came and they wanted us," Cat said, puzzled. 
"But we'd only been gone for an hour or so, and we could have been just going 
blackberrying. We hadn't even taken our nightclothes," Janet explained. "Now do 
you see?" 
Though Cat was indeed sure that Janet had an obsession about witchcraft, and he 
was still feeling sulky and unhelpful, he could not help seeing that Janet had a 
point. "A very nice witch, then," he conceded. "I don't mind." 
"But, Cat, you do see how difficult she's going to make it," Janet said. "Do 
you? You know, you should be called Mule, not Cat. If you don't want to know a 
thing, you don't. How did you get to be called Cat anyway?" 
"That was just a joke Gwendolen made," said Cat. "She always said I'd got nine 
lives." 
"Gwendolen made jokes?" Janet asked unbelievingly. She stopped, with an arrested 
look, and turned stiffly away from the mirror. 
"Not usually," said Cat. 
"Great heavens! I wonder!" said Janet. "In this place, where every other thing 
turns out to be enchanted, it almost must be! In which case, how horrible!" She 
pushed the mirror up until the glass faced the ceiling, jumped off the stool, 
and raced to the wardrobe. She dragged Gwendolen's box out of it and sorted 
fiercely through it. "Oh, I do hope I'm wrong! But I'm almost sure there were 
nine." 
"Nine what?" asked Cat. 
Janet had found the bundle of letters addressed to Miss Caroline Chant. The red 
book of matches was tucked in front of it. Janet took the little book carefully 
out and chucked the letters back in the box. "Nine matches," she said, as she 
opened the book. "And there are too! Oh, good Lord, Cat! Five of them are 
burned. Look." 
She held the book out to Cat. He saw there were indeed nine matches in it. The 
heads of the first two were black. The third was charred right down to the base. 
The fourth had a black head again. But the fifth had burned so fiercely that the 
paper behind was singed and there was a hole in the sandpaper beneath it. It was 
a wonder the whole book had not caught fire—or at least the last four matches. 
They were as new, however. Their heads were bright red, with yellowish oily 
paper below, and bright white cardboard below that. 
"It does look like a charm of some kind," Cat said. 
"I know it is," said Janet. "These are your nine lives, Cat. How did you come to 
lose so many?" 
Cat simply could not believe her. He was feeling surly and resistant anyway, and 
this was too much. "They can't be," he said. Even if he had nine lives, he knew 
he could only have lost three, and that was counting the time Gwendolen gave him 
cramps. The other two would be when he was born and on the paddleboat. But, as 
he thought this, Cat found he was remembering those four apparitions coming from 
the flaming bowl to join Gwendolen's gruesome procession. One had been a baby, 
one wet. The crippled one had seemed to have cramps. But why had there been four 
of them, when five matches were burned? 
Cat began shivering, and this made him all the more determined to prove Janet 
wrong. 
"You couldn't have died in the night once or twice without noticing?" Janet 
wondered. 
"Of course I didn't." Cat reached down and took the book. "Look, I'll prove it 
to you." He tore the sixth match off and dragged it along the sandpaper. 
Janet leaped up, shrieking to him to stop. The match burst into flame. 
So, almost at the same instant, did Cat himself. 



14 
Cat SCREAMED. Flames burst out of him all over. He screamed again, and beat at 
himself with flaming hands, and went on screaming. They were pale, shimmering, 
transparent flames. They burst out through his clothes, and his shoes, his hair, 
across his face, so that, in seconds, he was wrapped in pale flame from head to 
foot. He fell on the floor, still screaming, and rolled there, blazing. 
Janet kept her presence of mind. She dragged up the nearest corner of the carpet 
and threw it over Cat. She had heard that this smothered flames. But it did not 
smother these. To Janet's horror, the pale, ghostly flames came straight through 
the carpet as if it was not there, and played on the black underside of it more 
fiercely than ever. They did not burn the carpet, nor did they burn Janet's 
hands as she frantically rolled Cat over in the carpet, and then over again. But 
no matter how much carpet she wrapped around Cat, the flames still came through, 
and Cat went on blazing and screaming. His head was half outside the flaming 
bundle she had made of him, and it was a sheaf of flames. She could see his 
screaming face inside the fire. 
Janet did the only other thing she could think of. She jumped up and screamed 
herself. "Chrestomanci, Chrestomanci! Come quickly!" 
The door burst open while she was still screaming. Janet had forgotten it was 
locked, but the lock did not bother Chrestomanci. She could see it sticking out 
from the edge of the door as he flung it open. She had forgotten there were 
guests to dinner too. She remembered when she saw Chrestomanci's lace ruffles, 
and his black velvet suit which glimmered all over like an opal, blue, crimson, 
yellow, and green. But that did not seem to bother Chrestomanci either. He took 
one look at the flaming bundle on the floor and said "Good God!" Then he was 
down on his elegant knees unwrapping the carpet as frantically as Janet had 
wrapped it. 
"I'm awfully sorry. I thought that would help," Janet stammered. 
"It ought to have done," said Chrestomanci, rolling Cat over, with flames 
whirling through, over, and along his velvet arms. "How did he do it?" 
"He struck one of the matches. I told him—" 
"You stupid child!" Chrestomanci was so angry that Janet burst into tears. He 
lugged at the last of the carpet and Cat rolled free, flaming like a straw 
faggot. He was not really screaming anymore. He was making a long thin noise 
that had Janet covering her ears. Chrestomanci dived into the heart of the 
flames and found the book of matches. It was tightly clasped in Cat's right 
hand. "Thank God he didn't have it in the left one," he said. "Go and turn your 
shower on. Quick!" 
"Of course. Of course," Janet sobbed, and raced to do it. 
She fumbled with the taps and had just got a strong spray of cold water hissing 
into the sunken blue bath as Chrestomanci hurried in carrying Cat, in a ball of 
roaring flame. He dumped Cat down into the bath and held him there, turning him 
this way and that to get him wet all over. 
Cat steamed and hissed. The water coming from the sprayhead shone like water 
against the sun, golden as the sun itself. It came down like a beam of light. 
And, as the bath began to fill up, Cat seemed to be turning and threshing in a 
pool of sunshine. He boiled it into golden bubbles. The room filled with steam. 
Coils of smoke drifted up from the bath, smelling thick and sweet. It was the 
same smell that Janet remembered from the morning she had first found herself 
there. As far as she could see through the smoke, Cat seemed to be turning black 
in the golden pool. But the water was wet. Chrestomanci was getting soaked. 
"Don't you understand?" he said to Janet over his shoulder while he heaved at 
Cat to keep his head under the spray. "You shouldn't go telling him things like 
this until the Castle has had time to work on him. He wasn't ready to 
understand. You've given him the most appalling shock." 
"I'm truly enormously sorry," Janet said, crying heavily. 
"We'll just have to make the best of it," said Chrestomanci. "I'll try and 
explain to him. Run along to the speaking tube at the end of the corridor and 
tell them to send me some brandy and a pot of strong tea." 
As Janet raced away, Cat found himself soaking wet, with water hissing down on 
him. He tried to roll away from it. Someone held him in it. A voice said 
insistently in his ear, "Cat. Cat, will you listen to me? Do you understand? 
Cat, you've only got three lives left now." 
Cat knew that voice. "You told me I'd got five when you spoke to me through Miss 
Larkins," he grumbled. 
"Yes, but you've only got three now. You'll have to be more careful," said 
Chrestomanci. 
Cat opened his eyes and looked up at him. Chrestomanci was fearfully wet. The 
usually smooth black hair was hanging over his forehead in wriggles, with drips 
on the ends. "Oh. Was it you?" he said. 
"Yes. You took a long time recognizing me, didn't you?" said Chrestomanci. "But 
then I didn't know you straightaway when I saw you, either. I think you can come 
out of this water now." 
Cat was too weak to get out of the bath alone. But Chrestomanci heaved him out, 
stripped off his wet clothes, dried him and wrapped him in another towel in no 
time at all. Cat's legs kept folding. "Up you come," said Chrestomanci, and 
carried him again, to the blue velvet bed, and tucked him in it. "Better now, 
Cat?" 
Cat lay back, limp but luxurious, and nodded. "Thanks. You've never called me 
Cat before." 
"Perhaps I should have done. You just might have understood." Chrestomanci sat 
beside the bed, looking very serious. "You do understand now?" 
"The book of matches was my nine lives," Cat said. "And I've just burned one. I 
know it was stupid, but I didn't believe it. How can I have nine lives?" 
"You have three," said Chrestomanci. "Get that into your head. You did have 
nine. In some manner and by someone, they were put into that book of matches, 
and that book I am now going to put in my secret safe, sealed with the strongest 
enchantments I know. But that will only stop people using them. It won't stop 
you losing them yourself." 
Janet came hurrying in, still tearful, but very thankful to be of use. "It's 
coming," she said. 
"Thank you," said Chrestomanci, and he gave her a long, thoughtful look. Janet 
was sure he was going to accuse her of not being Gwendolen, but what he said 
was, "You may as well hear this too, in order to prevent more accidents." 
"Can I get you a towel first?" Janet said humbly. "You're so wet." 
"I'm drying out, thank you," he said, smiling at her. "Now listen. People with 
nine lives are very important and very rare. They only happen when, for one 
reason or another, there are no counterparts of them living in any other world. 
Then the lives that would have been spread out over a whole set of worlds get 
concentrated in one person. And so do all the talents that those other eight 
people might have had." 
Cat said, "But I haven't any talents," and Janet said at the same time, "How 
rare are these people?" 
"Extremely rare," said Chrestomanci. "Apart from Cat, the only other person with 
nine lives that I know of on this world is myself." 
"Really?" Cat was pleased and interested. "Nine?" 
"I did have nine. I've only got two now. I was even more careless than Cat," 
Chrestomanci said. He sounded a little ashamed. "Now I have to take care to keep 
each life separately in the safest place I can think of. I advise Cat to do the 
same." 
Janet's ready brain promptly got to work on this. "Is one life here and the 
other downstairs having supper at this moment?" 
Chrestomanci laughed. "It doesn't work like that. I—" 
To Janet's disappointment, Euphemia hurried in with a tray and prevented 
Chrestomanci explaining how it did work. Mr. Saunders came in on Euphemia's 
heels, still unable to find evening clothes that covered his wrists and ankles. 
"Is he all right?" Euphemia asked anxiously. "My Will was uttering threats, but 
if it was him I'll never speak to him again. And whatever happened to this 
carpet?" 
Mr. Saunders was looking at the wrinkled and heaped-up carpet too. "What did 
it?" he said. "There were surely enough charms in this carpet to stop any kind 
of accident." 
"I know," said Chrestomanci. "But this was amazingly strong." The two of them 
looked at one another significantly. 
Then everyone fussed over Cat. He had a most enjoyable time. Mr. Saunders sat 
him up on pillows, and Euphemia put him in a nightshirt and then stroked Cat's 
head, just as if he had never confessed to turning her into a frog. "It wasn't 
Will," Cat said to her. "It was me." Chrestomanci gave him a fierce swig of 
brandy and then made him drink a cup of sweet tea. Janet had a cup of tea too, 
and felt much better for it. Mr. Saunders helped Euphemia straighten the carpet, 
and then asked if he should strengthen the charms in it. 
"Dragons' blood might do the trick," he suggested. 
"Frankly, I don't think anything will," said Chrestomanci. "Leave it." He got up 
and turned the mirror straight. "Do you mind sleeping tonight in Cat's room?" he 
asked Janet. "I want to be able to keep an eye on Cat." 
Janet looked from the mirror to Chrestomanci, and her face became very pink. 
"Er," she said. "I've been making faces—" 
Chrestomanci laughed. Mr. Saunders was so amused that he had to sit on the blue 
velvet stool. "I suppose it serves me right," said Chrestomanci. "Some of the 
faces were highly original." 
Janet laughed too, a little foolishly. 
Cat lay, feeling comfortable and almost cheerful. For a while, everyone was 
there, settling him in. Then there seemed only to be Janet, talking as usual. 
"I'm so glad you're all right," she said. "Why did I open my big mouth about 
those matches? I had the dreaded umjams when you suddenly flared up, and when 
the carpet didn't work, the only thing I could think of was to yell for 
Chrestomanci. I was right. He came before the words were out of my mouth, even 
though the door was locked. It was still locked when he opened it, but the lock 
isn't broken, because I tried it. So he is an enchanter. And he ruined a suit 
over you, Cat, and didn't seem to mind, so I think that when he isn't being like 
freezing fog over the Grampians, he's really very nice. This isn't for the 
benefit of the mirror. I mean it. I suppose that mirror is the magic equivalent 
of...." 
Cat thought he had been meaning to say something about freezing fog in the 
Grampians, but he drifted away to sleep while Janet talked, feeling snug and 
cared for. 
He woke on Sunday morning, quite the opposite: cold and quivering. This 
afternoon he was due to be turned into a frog or face a tiger—and a rather heavy 
strong tiger Will Suggins would make too, he thought. Beyond the tiger—if there 
was a beyond—lay the horrors of Monday without magic. Julia and Roger might help 
there, except that it would be no use when Mr. Baslam came on Wednesday and 
demanded twenty pounds Cat knew he could not get. Mr. Nostrum was no help. Mrs. 
Sharp was even less. The only hope seemed to be to take Janet and some dragons' 
blood to the forbidden garden and try to get away. 
Cat climbed out of bed to go and get some dragons' blood from Mr. Saunders' 
workshop. Euphemia came in with his breakfast on a tray, and he had to climb 
back into bed again. Euphemia was quite as kind as she had been last night. Cat 
felt bad. And when he had finished breakfast, Millie came. She scooped Cat off 
his pillows and hugged him. 
"You poor silly darling! Thank goodness you're all right. I was aching to come 
and see you last night, but someone had to stay with our poor guests. Now, 
you're to stay in bed all today, and you must ask for anything you want. What 
would you like?" 
"I couldn't have some dragons' blood, could I?" Cat asked hopefully. 
Millie laughed. "Good heavens, Eric! You go and have that fearsome accident and 
then you ask for the most dangerous stuff in the world. No, you may not have 
dragons' blood. It's one of the few things in the Castle that really are 
forbidden." 
"Like Chrestomanci's garden?" Cat asked. 
"Not quite like that," Millie answered. "The garden is old as the hills and 
stuffed with magic of every kind. That's dangerous in another way. Everything's 
stronger there. You'll be taken into the garden when you know enough magic to 
understand it. But dragons' blood is so harmful that I'm never happy even when 
Michael uses it. You're on no account to touch any." 
Julia and Roger came in next, dressed ready for church, with armfuls of books 
and toys and a great many interested questions. They were so kind that Cat was 
quite unhappy by the time Janet arrived. He did not want to leave the Castle. He 
felt he was truly settling in to it. 
"That lump of dough is still stuck to your carpet," Janet said gloomily, which 
made Cat feel rather less settled. "I've just been seeing Chrestomanci, and it 
is hard to be punished for other people's sins," Janet went on, "even though 
I've been rewarded with the sight of a sky-blue dressing gown with golden lions 
on it." 
"I've not seen that one," said Cat. 
"I think he has one for every day of the week," said Janet. "All he needed was a 
flaming sword. He forbade me to go to church. The vicar won't have me because of 
what Gwendolen did last Sunday. And I was so cross at being blamed for it that 
I'd got my mouth open to say I wasn't Gwendolen when I remembered that if I went 
to church I'd have to wear that stupid white hat with little holes in it—can he 
hear through that mirror, do you think?" 
"No," said Cat. "Just see. Or he'd know all about you. I'm glad you're staying 
behind. We can go and get the dragons' blood while they're at church." 
Janet kept watch at the window to see when the Family left. After about half an 
hour, she said, "Here they are at last, walking in a crowd down the avenue. All 
the men have got toppers, but Chrestomanci looks as if he's come out of a shop 
window. Who are they all, Cat? Who's the old lady in purple mittens, and the 
young one in green, and the little fellow who's always talking?" 
"I've no idea," said Cat. He scrambled out of bed and scuttled up to his room to 
find some clothes. He felt perfectly well—marvelously well, in fact. He danced 
around his room while he put on his shirt. He sang putting on his trousers. Even 
the cold lump of dough on the carpet could not damp his spirits. He whistled 
tying his boots. 
Janet came into the room as Cat was shooting out of it, pulling on his jacket 
and beaming with health. "I don't know," Janet said, as Cat shot past her and 
hammered away down the stairs. "Dying must agree with you, or something." 
"Hurry up!" Cat called from the bottom of the stairs. "It's on the other side of 
the Castle from here. Millie says dragons' blood is very dangerous, so don't you 
touch it. I can spare a life on it and you can't." 
Janet wanted to remark that Cat had not spared the last one very easily, but she 
never caught up with Cat sufficiently. Cat whirled through the green corridors 
and stormed up the winding stairs to Mr. Saunders' room, and Janet only reached 
him when he was actually inside it. Then there was too much else to take up her 
attention. 
The room was heavy with the scent of stale magic. Though it was much the same as 
when Cat had seen it before, Mr. Saunders had tidied it a little for Sunday. The 
cresset was out. The torts and limbecks and other vessels were all clean. The 
books and scrolls had been piled in heaps on the second bench. The five-pointed 
star was still there, blazoned on the floor, but there was a new set of signs 
chalked on the third bench, and the mummified animal had been neatly laid at one 
end of it. 
Janet was immensely interested. "It's like a laboratory," she said, "except that 
it isn't. What weird things! Oh, I see the dragons' blood. Does he need all that 
huge jar? He won't miss a bit out of that lot." 
There was a rustling at the end of the third bench. Janet's head perked towards 
it. The mummified creature was twitching and spreading its filmy little wings. 
"It did that before," said Cat. "I think it's all right." 
He was not so sure, however, when the creature stretched and got to its doglike 
feet, yawning. The yawn showed them dozens of small, sharp teeth and also let 
out a cloud of bluish smoke. The creature ran pattering along the bench towards 
them. The little wings rattled on its back as it came, and two small puffs of 
smoke streamed behind it from its nostrils. It stopped at the edge of the bench 
to look up at them inquisitively from a melting glitter of golden eyes. They 
backed nervously away from it. 
"It's alive!" said Janet. "I think it's a small dragon." 
"Of course I am," said the dragon, which made both of them jump violently. Even 
more alarming, tiny flames played out of its mouth as it spoke, and they could 
feel the heat from them where they stood. 
"I didn't know you could talk," said Cat. 
"I speak English quite well," said the dragon, flickering flame. "Why do you 
want my blood?" 
They looked guiltily at the great jar of powder on the shelf. "Is that all 
yours?" said Cat. 
"If Mr. Saunders is making it give blood all the time, I think that's rather 
cruel," Janet said. 
"Oh, that!" said the dragon. "That's powdered blood from older dragons. They 
sell it to people. You can't have any of that." 
"Why not?" said Cat. 
"Because I don't want you to," said the dragon, and a regular roll of fire came 
from its mouth, making them back away again. "How would you like to see me 
taking human blood and playing games with it?" 
Though Cat felt the dragon had a point here, Janet did not. "It doesn't worry 
me," she said. "Where I come from we have blood transfusions and blood banks. 
Dad once showed me some of my blood under a microscope." 
"It worries me," said the dragon, uttering another roll of fire. "My mother was 
killed by unlawful blood-stealers." It crept to the very end of the bench and 
stared up at Janet. The flickers in its golden eyes melted and changed and 
melted again. It was like being looked at by two small, golden kaleidoscopes. "I 
was too small to hold enough blood," it flickered softly to Janet, "so they left 
me. I'd have died if Chrestomanci hadn't found me. So you see why it worries 
me?" 
"Yes," said Janet. "What do baby dragons feed on? Milk?" 
"Michael tried me with milk, but I didn't like it," said the dragon. "I have 
minced steak now, and I'm growing beautifully. When I'm big enough, he's going 
to take me back, but meanwhile I'm helping him with his magic. I'm a great 
help." 
"Are you?" said Janet. "What do you do?" 
"I find old things he can't find himself." The dragon fell into a flickering 
croon. "I fetch him animals from the abyss—old golden creatures, things with 
wings, pearl-eyed monsters from the deep sea, and whispering plants from long 
ago." It stopped and looked at Janet with its head on one side. "That was easy," 
it remarked to Cat. "I've always wanted to do that, but no one let me before." 
It sighed a long blue fume of smoke. "I wish I was bigger. I could eat her now." 

Cat took an alarmed look at Janet and found her staring like a sleepwalker, with 
a silly smile on her face. "Of all the mean tricks!" he said. 
"I think I'll just have a nibble," said the dragon. 
Cat realized it was being playful. "I'll wring your neck if you do," he said. 
"Haven't you got anything else to play with?" 
"You sound just like Michael," said the dragon in a sulky roll of smoke. "I'm 
bored with mice." 
"Tell him to take you for walks." Cat took Janet's arm and shook her. Janet came 
to herself with a little jump and seemed quite unaware that anything had 
happened to her. "And I can't help the way you feel," said Cat to the dragon. "I 
need some dragons' blood." He pulled Janet well out of range, just to be on the 
safe side, and picked up a little china crucible from the next bench. 
The dragon hunched up irritably and scratched itself like a dog under the chin 
until its wings rattled. "Michael says dragons' blood always does harm 
somewhere," it said, "even when an adept uses it. If you're not careful, it 
costs a life." 
Cat and Janet looked at one another through the smoke it had made with its 
speech. "Well, I can spare one," said Cat. He took the glass stopper off the big 
jar and scooped up some brown powder in the crucible. It had a strong, strange 
smell. 
"I suppose Chrestomanci manages all right with two lives," Janet said nervously. 

"But he's rather special," said the dragon. It was standing on the very edge of 
the bench, rattling with anxiety. Its golden eyes followed Cat's hands as he 
wrapped the crucible in his handkerchief and pushed the bundle cautiously into 
his pocket. It seemed so worried that Cat went over to it and, a little 
nervously, rubbed it under the chin where it had been scratching. The dragon 
stretched its neck and pressed against his fingers. The smoke came out of its 
nostrils in purring puffs. 
"Don't worry," Cat said. "I've got three lives left, you see." 
"That explains why I like you," said the dragon, and almost fell off the bench 
in its effort to follow Cat's fingers. "Don't go yet!" 
"We've got to." Cat pushed the dragon back on the bench and patted its head. 
Once he was used to it, he found he did not mind touching its warm, horny hide a 
bit. "Good-bye." 
"Good-bye," said the dragon. 
They left it staring after them like a dog whose master has gone for a walk 
without it. 
"I think it's bored," Cat said when he had shut the door. 
"It's a shame! It's only a baby," said Janet. She stopped on the first turn of 
the stair. "Let's go back and take it for a walk. It was sweet!" 
Cat was sure that if Janet did any such thing, she would come to herself to find 
the dragon browsing on her legs. "It wasn't that sweet," he said. "And we'll 
have to go to the garden straightaway now. It's going to tell Mr. Saunders we 
took some dragons' blood as soon as it sees him." 
"Yes, I suppose it does make a difference that it can talk," Janet agreed. "We'd 
better hurry then." 
Cat walked very carefully through the Castle, down and out of doors, and kept a 
hand on his pocket in case of accidents. He was afraid he might arrive at the 
forbidden garden with one life less. He seemed to have lost three of his lives 
so easily. That kept puzzling him. From the look of those matches, losing life 
number five ought to have been as much of a disaster as losing the sixth one 
last night. But he had not noticed it go at all. He could not understand it. His 
lives did not seem to be properly attached to him, like ordinary people's. But 
at least he knew there were no other Cat Chants to be dragged into trouble in 
this world, when he left it. 



15
It was a glorious start-of-autumn day, with everything green and gold, hot and 
still. There was not a soul around, and very little sound except the lonely 
crunch of Cat's and Janet's feet as they hurried through the formal garden. 
Halfway through the orchard, Janet said, "If the garden we want looks like a 
ruined castle, we're going away from it now." 
Cat could have sworn they were heading straight for it but, sure enough, when he 
stopped and looked around, the high, sun-soaked old wall was right behind them. 
And now he came to think of it, he could not remember how he and Gwendolen had 
got to it before. 
They turned back and walked towards the high wall. All they found was the long, 
low wall of the orchard. There was no gate in it, and the forbidden garden was 
beyond it. They went along the orchard wall to the nearest gate. Whereupon they 
were in the rose garden, and the ruined wall was behind them again, towering 
above the orchard. 
"This couldn't be an enchantment to stop people getting into it, could it?" said 
Janet, as they plodded through the orchard again. 
"I think it must be," said Cat. And they were in the formal garden again, with 
the high wall behind them. 
"They'll be coming out of church before we've found it, at this rate," Janet 
said anxiously. 
"Try keeping it in the corner of your eye and not going straight to it," said 
Cat. 
They did that. They walked slantwise with the garden, not really looking at it. 
It seemed to keep pace with them. And suddenly they came out somehow beyond the 
orchard into a steep, walled path. Up at the top of it stood the high old wall, 
with its stairway masked by hollyhocks and bright with snapdragons, breathing 
warmth out of its crumbling stones into their worried faces. Neither of them 
dared look straight at the tall ruins, even while they were running up the path. 
But the wall was still there when they reached the end, and so was the overgrown 
stair. 
The stair made a nerve-racking climb. They had to go up it twice as high as a 
house, with one side of themselves pressed against the hot stones of the wall, 
and a sheer drop on the other side. The stairs were frighteningly old and 
irregular. And they grew hotter and hotter. Towards the end, Cat had to keep his 
head tipped up to the trees hanging over the top of the ruins, because looking 
anywhere else began to make him dizzy. He had glimpses of the Castle in the 
distance from more angles than he would have thought possible. He suspected that 
the ruins he was on were moving about. 
There was a notch in the wall at the top, not like a proper entrance at all. 
They swung themselves in through it, secret and guilty, and found the ground 
beyond worn smooth, as if other people had been coming that way for centuries. 
There were trees, thick and dark and close together. It was wonderfully cool. 
The smoothly worn path twined among them. Janet and Cat stole along it. As they 
went, the trees, as closely growing trees often seem to do when you walk among 
them, appeared to move this way and that and spread into different distances. 
But Cat was not altogether sure it was only an appearance. 
One new distance opened into a dell. And then they were in the dell. 
"What a lovely place!" Janet whispered. "But how peculiar!" 
The little dip was full of spring flowers. Daffodils, scillas, snowdrops, 
hyacinths, and tiny tulips were all growing there in September in the most 
improbable profusion. There was a slight chill in the dip, which may have 
accounted for it. Janet and Cat picked their way among these flowers, shivering 
a little. There were the scents of spring, chilly and heady, clean and wild, but 
strong with magic. Before they had taken two steps, Cat and Janet were smiling 
gently. Another step and they were laughing. 
"Oh, look!" said Janet. "There's a cat." 
It was a large stripy torn. It stood arched suspiciously beside a clump of 
primroses, not sure whether to run away or not. It looked at Janet. It looked at 
Cat. And Cat knew it. Though it was firmly and definitely a cat, there was just 
a suggestion of a violin about the shape of its face. 
He laughed. Everything made him happy in that place. "That's old Fiddle," he 
said. "He used to be my violin. What's he doing here?" 
Janet knelt down and held out her hand. "Here, Fiddle. Here, puss." Fiddle's 
nature must have been softened by being in that dell. He let Janet rub his chin 
and stroke him. Then, in the most unheard-of way, he let Janet pick him up and 
stand up hugging him. He even purred. Janet's face glowed. She could almost have 
been Gwendolen coming home from a witchcraft lesson, except that she looked 
kinder. She winked at Cat. "I love all kinds of Cat!" 
Cat laughed. He put out his left hand and stroked Fiddle's head. It felt 
strange. He could feel the wood of the violin. He took his hand away quickly. 
They went on through a white spread of narcissi, smelling like paradise, Janet 
still carrying Fiddle. There had been no white flowers until then. Cat began to 
be almost sure that the garden was moving around them of its own accord. When he 
stepped among bluebells, and then big red tulips, he was sure. He almost—but not 
quite—saw the trees softly and gently sliding about at the sides of what he 
could see. They slid him among buttercups and cow-parsley, into a sunny, sloping 
stretch. And here was a wild rose, tangled with a creeper covered in great blue 
flowers. Cat could definitely feel the sliding movement now. They were being 
moved around and down somehow. If he thought about the way the garden had also 
been moving about in the Castle grounds, he started to feel almost as sick as he 
did in the car. He found it was best just to keep walking and looking. 
When they slid through the trees among flowers of high summer, Janet noticed 
too. "Aren't we getting a lightning tour of the year?" she said. "I feel as if 
I'm running down a moving staircase." 
It was more than the ordinary year. Fig trees, olives, and date palms moved them 
around into a small desert, where there were cacti like tormented cucumbers and 
spiny green armchairs. Some had bright flowers on them. The sun burned down. But 
they had hardly time to get uncomfortable before the trees circled around them 
again and brought them into a richer, sadder light, and autumn flowers. They had 
barely got used to that when the trees put out berries, turned amber and lost 
their leaves. They moved towards a thick holly, full of red berries. It was 
colder. Fiddle did not like this part. He struggled out of Janet's arms and ran 
away to warmer climes. 
"Which are the gates to other worlds?" Janet said, brought back to a sense of 
purpose. 
"Soon, I think," said Cat. He felt them coming to the center of the garden. He 
had seldom felt anything magical so strongly. 
The trees and bushes around them now were embalmed in frost. They could see 
bright berries in bright casings of ice. Yet Janet had scarcely time to rub her 
arms and shiver before a tree met them that was a wintry mass of pink blossom. 
Straight stalks of winter jasmine hung from the next, in lines of small yellow 
stars. And then came a mighty black thorn tree, twisted in all directions. It 
was just putting out a few white blossoms. 
As it took them in under its dark hood, Janet looked up into its black 
twistings. "The one at Glastonbury looks like this," she said. "They say it 
blooms at Christmas." 
Then Cat knew they were in the heart of the garden. They were in a small bowl of 
meadowland. All the trees were up around the edges, except one. And here it 
seemed the right season of the year, because the apples were just ripening on 
that one tree. It stood leaning over the center of the meadow, not quite 
overshadowing the queer ruin there. As Janet and Cat passed quietly towards this 
place, they found a little spring of water near the roots of the apple tree, 
which bubbled up from nowhere, and bubbled away again into the earth almost at 
once. Janet thought the clear water looked unusually golden. It reminded her of 
the water from the shower when it stopped Cat from burning. 
The ruins were two sides of a broken archway. 
There was a slab of stone which must have fallen from the top of the arch lying 
nearby at the foot of the tree. There was no other sign of a gate. 
"I think this is it," said Cat. He felt very sad to be leaving. 
"I think it is too," Janet agreed in an awed, muffled voice. "I feel a bit 
miserable to be going, as a matter of fact. How do we go?" 
"I'm going to try sprinkling a pinch of dragons' blood in the archway," said 
Cat. 
He fumbled out the crucible wrapped in his handkerchief from his pocket. He 
smelled the strong smell of the dragons' blood and knew he was doing wrong. It 
was wrong to bring this harmful stuff into a place that was so strongly magic in 
such a different way. 
But, since he did not know what else to do, Cat carefully took a pinch of the 
smelly brown powder between the finger and thumb of his right hand, wrapped the 
crucible away again with his left hand, and then, carefully and guiltily, 
sprinkled the powder between the pillars of broken stone. 
The air between the pillars quivered like air that is hot. The piece of sunny 
meadow they could see beyond grew misty, then milky pale, then dark. The 
darkness cleared slowly, away into the corners of the space, and they found they 
could see into a huge room. There seemed acres of it. All of it was covered in a 
carpet of a rather ugly playing-card sort of design in red, blue, and yellow. 
The room was full of people. They reminded Cat of playing cards too, because 
they were dressed in stiff, bulky clothes in flat, bright colors. They were all 
trailing about, this way and that, looking important and agitated. The air 
between them and the garden was still quivering and, somehow, Cat knew they 
would not be able to get into the huge room. 
"This is not right," said Janet. "Where is it?" Cat was just about to say that 
he did not know either, when he saw Gwendolen. She was being carried by, quite 
near, on a sort of bed with handholds. The eight men carrying it all wore bulky 
golden uniforms. The bed was gold, with gold hangings and gold cushions. 
Gwendolen was dressed in even bulkier clothes than the rest, that were white and 
gold, and her hair was done up into a high golden headdress which may have been 
a crown. From the way she was behaving, she was certainly a queen. She nodded to 
some of the important people and they leaped eagerly to the side of her bed and 
listened with feverish intelligence to what she was saying. She waved to some 
others, and they ran to do things. She made a sign at another person and he fell 
on his knees, begging for mercy. He was still begging when other people dragged 
him away. Gwendolen smiled as if this amused her. By this time, the golden bed 
was right beside the archway, and the space was a turmoil of people racing to do 
what Gwendolen wanted. 
And Gwendolen saw Cat and Janet. Cat knew she did, from the expression of 
surprise and faint annoyance on her face. Maybe she worked some magic of her 
own, or maybe the magic in the dragons' blood was simply used up. Whatever it 
was, the broken archway turned dark again, then milky, then to mist; and 
finally, there was nothing but meadow again between the pillars, and the air had 
stopped shimmering. 
"That was Gwendolen," Cat said. 
"I thought it was," Janet said unappreciatively. "She'll get fat if she has 
herself carried about like that all the time." 
"She was enjoying herself," Cat said wistfully. 
"I could see that," said Janet. "But how do we find my world?" 
Cat was not at all sure. "Shall we try going around to the other side of the 
arch?" 
"Seems reasonable," Janet agreed. She started to walk around the pillars, and 
stopped. "We'd better get it right this time, Cat. You can only afford one more 
try. Or didn't you lose a life on that one?" 
"I didn't feel—" Cat began. 
Then Mr. Nostrum was suddenly standing in the broken arch. He was holding the 
postcard Cat had sent to Mrs. Sharp, and he was cross and flustered. 
"My dear boy," he said to Cat, "I told you two-thirty, not midday. It was the 
merest chance that I had my hand on your signature. Let us hope all is not 
lost." He turned and called over his shoulder, apparently into the empty meadow, 
"Come on, William. The wretched boy seems to have misunderstood me, but the 
spell is clearly working. Don't forget to bring the—ah—equipment with you." 
He stepped out from between the pillars, and Cat backed away before him. 
Everything seemed to have gone very quiet. The leaves of the apple tree did not 
stir, and the small, small bubbling from the little spring changed to a soft, 
slow dripping. Cat had a strong suspicion that he and Janet had done something 
terrible. Janet was beyond the archway with her hands to her mouth, looking 
horrified. She was suddenly hidden by the large figure of Mr. William Nostrum, 
who popped into being from nowhere between the two pillars. He had a coil of 
rope around one arm, and there were shiny things sticking out of the pockets of 
his frock coat. His eyes were swiveling in an agitated way. He was a little out 
of breath. 
"Premature but successful, Henry," he puffed. "The rest have been summoned." 
William Nostrum stepped imposingly out beneath the apple tree beside his 
brother. The ground shook a little. The garden was quite silent. Cat backed away 
again and found that the little spring had stopped flowing. There was nothing 
but a muddy hole left. Cat was quite certain now that he and Janet had done 
something terrible. 
Behind the Nostrums, other people came hurrying through the broken archway. The 
first one who came was one of the Accredited Witches from farther down Coven 
Street, puce in the face and very startled. She had been to church in her Sunday 
best: a monster of a hat with fruit and flowers in it, and a black and red satin 
dress. Most of the people who followed her were in Sunday best too: warlocks in 
blue serge and hard hats, witches in silk and bombazine and hats of all shapes 
and sizes, respectable-looking necromancers in frock coats like William 
Nostrum's, skinny sorcerers in black, and quite a sprinkling of impressive 
wizards, who had either been to church in long black cloaks, or playing golf in 
very freckled plus fours. They came crowding between the pillars, first by twos 
and threes and then by sixes and sevens, all a little hasty and startled. Among 
them Cat recognized most of the witches and fortune-tellers from Coven Street, 
though he did not see either Mrs. Sharp or Miss Larkins—but this may have been 
simply that, in no time at all, he was being jostled this way and that in the 
middle of a large and steadily growing crowd. 
William Nostrum was shouting to each group who hurried through, "Spread out. 
Spread out up the meadow. Surround the gate there! Leave no avenue of escape." 
Janet forced her way among them and seized Cat's arm. "Cat! What have we done? 
Don't tell me these aren't all witches and warlocks, because I won't believe 
you!" 
"Ah, my dear Gwendolen!" said Mr. Henry Nostrum. "Plan Two is under way." 
By this time, the sloping sides of the meadow were crowded with witches and 
warlocks. The ground quivered to their trampling and buzzed with their cheerful 
conversation. There were hundreds of them—a nodding of garish hats and shiny 
toppers, like the audience at the opening of a bazaar. 
As soon as the last necromancer had hurried between the pillars, Henry Nostrum 
put a heavy possessive hand on Cat's shoulder. Cat wondered uneasily whether it 
was just an accident that it was the same hand which held his postcard to Mrs. 
Sharp. He saw that the Willing Warlock had stationed himself by one of the 
broken pillars, blue-chinned and cheerful as ever in his tight Sunday suit. Mr. 
William Nostrum had put as much of himself as would go behind the other pillar 
and, for some reason, he had taken off his heavy silver watch-chain and was 
swinging it in one hand. 
"Now, my dear Gwendolen," said Henry Nostrum, "would you care for the honor of 
summoning Chrestomanci?" 
"I—I'd rather not," said Janet. 
"Then I'll take it upon myself," said Henry Nostrum, perfectly well pleased. He 
cleared his throat and shouted in a fluting tenor, "Chrestomanci! Chrestomanci! 
Come to me." 
And Chrestomanci was standing between the pillars. 
Chrestomanci must have been on his way up the avenue from church. He had his 
tall gray hat in one hand and, with the other, he was in the act of putting his 
prayer book into the pocket of his beautiful dove-gray coat. The assembled 
witches and necromancers greeted him with a sort of groaning sigh. Chrestomanci 
blinked around at them, in his mildest and most bewildered way. He became even 
vaguer and more bewildered when he happened to see Cat and Janet. 
Cat opened his mouth to shout at Chrestomanci to go away. But the Willing 
Warlock leaped on Chrestomanci the moment he appeared. He was growling. His 
fingernails were growing into claws and his teeth into fangs. 
Chrestomanci stuffed the prayer book into his pocket and turned his vague look 
on the Willing Warlock. The Willing Warlock stood still in midair and shrank. He 
shrank so fast, he made a whirring sound. Then he was a small brown caterpillar. 
He dropped to the grass and wriggled there. But, while he was still shrinking, 
William Nostrum pounced out from behind the other pillar and deftly wrapped his 
watch-chain around Chrestomanci's right hand. 
"Behind you!" shrieked Cat and Janet, too late. 
After barely one wriggle, the caterpillar burst up out of the grass and became 
the Willing Warlock again, a little disheveled, but very pleased with himself. 
He threw himself on Chrestomanci again. As for Chrestomanci, it was plain that 
the watch-chain had somehow disabled him completely. There was a second or so of 
furious struggle in the archway, while the Willing Warlock tried to grab 
Chrestomanci in both brawny arms, and Chrestomanci tried to get the watch-chain 
off his wrist using his left hand, and William Nostrum hung on to it fiercely. 
None of them used any magic, and Chrestomanci seemed only able to shoulder the 
Willing Warlock weakly aside. After two attempts, the Willing Warlock wrapped 
his arms around Chrestomanci from behind and William Nostrum dragged a pair of 
silver handcuffs from his pocket and snapped them on both Chrestomanci's wrists. 

There was a scream of triumph from under the nodding hats of the audience—the 
scream of true witchcraft, which made the sunlight tremble. Chrestomanci, even 
more disheveled than the Willing Warlock, was dragged out from between the 
pillars. His tall gray hat rolled near Cat's feet and Henry Nostrum stamped on 
it, with the greatest satisfaction. Cat tried to get out from under Henry 
Nostrum's hand while he did it. And he found he could not move. Mr. Nostrum had 
seen to that with Mrs. Sharp's postcard. Cat had to face the fact that he was as 
helpless as Chrestomanci seemed to be. 
"So it is true!" Henry Nostrum said joyously, as the Willing Warlock bundled 
Chrestomanci towards the apple tree. "The touch of silver conquers 
Chrestomanci—the great Chrestomanci!" 
"Yes. Isn't it a nuisance?" Chrestomanci remarked. He was dragged to the apple 
tree and pushed against it. William Nostrum hurried over to his brother and 
pulled the watch-chain off Henry's bulging waistcoat. Two silver watch-chains 
from two such ample brothers were more than enough to tie Chrestomanci to the 
tree. William Nostrum hastily twisted the ends into two charmed knots and stood 
back rubbing his hands. The audience screamed eldritch laughter and clapped. 
Chrestomanci sagged as if he were tired. His hair hung over his face, his tie 
was under his left ear, and there was green from the bark of the tree all over 
his dove-gray coat. Cat felt somehow ashamed to look at him in that state. But 
Chrestomanci seemed quite composed. "Now you've got me all tied up in silver, 
what do you propose doing?" he said. 
William Nostrum's eyes swirled joyfully about. "Oh, the worst we can, my dear 
sir," he said. "Be assured of that. We're sick of you imposing restraints on us, 
you see. Why shouldn't we go out and conquer other worlds? Why shouldn't we use 
dragons' blood? Why shouldn't we be as wicked as we want? Answer me that, sir!" 
"You might find the answer for yourself, if you thought," Chrestomanci 
suggested. But his voice was drowned in the yelling from the assembled witches 
and necromancers. While they shouted, Janet began edging quietly towards the 
tree. She supposed Cat dared not move with Henry Nostrum's hand on his shoulder, 
and she felt someone ought to do something. 
"Oh, yes," said Henry Nostrum, cock-a-hoop with pleasure. "We are taking the 
arts of magic into our own hands today. This world will be ours by this evening. 
Come Halloween, dear sir, we shall be going out to conquer every other world we 
know. We are going to destroy you, my dear fellow, and your power. But before we 
do that, of course, we shall have to destroy this garden." 
Chrestomanci looked thoughtfully down at his hands, hanging limply in the silver 
handcuffs. "I shouldn't advise that," he said. "This garden has things in it 
from the dawn of all the worlds. It's a good deal stronger than I am. You'd be 
striking at the roots of witchcraft—and you'd find it shockingly hard to 
destroy." 
"Ah," said Henry Nostrum. "But we know we can't destroy you unless we destroy 
the garden, my wily sir. And don't think we don't know how to destroy the 
garden." He lifted his free hand and clapped Cat on the other shoulder with it. 
"The means are here." 
Janet, at that moment, stumbled over the block of stone that lay in the grass 
near the apple tree. "Dratitude!" she said and fell heavily across it. The 
audience pointed and screamed with laughter, which annoyed her very much. She 
glared around the circle of Sunday bonnets and hats. 
"Up you get, dear Gwendolen," Henry Nostrum said gleefully. "It's young Cat who 
has to go on there." He put an arm around the helpless Cat, plucked him off the 
ground, and carried him towards the block of stone. William Nostrum bustled up, 
beaming and uncoiling his rope. The Willing Warlock bounced up willingly to help 
too. 
Cat was so terrified that he managed somehow to break the spell. He twisted out 
of Henry Nostrum's arms and ran for all he was worth towards the two pillars, 
trying to fetch out his dragons' blood as he ran. It was only a few steps to 
run. But naturally every witch, warlock, necromancer, and wizard there instantly 
cast a spell. The thick smell of magic coiled around the meadow. Cat's legs felt 
like two lead posts. His heart hammered. He felt himself running in slow motion, 
slower and slower, like a clockwork toy running down. He heard Janet scream at 
him to run, but he could not move any longer. He stuck just in front of the 
ruined archway, and he was stiff as a board. It was all he could do to breathe. 
The Nostrum brothers and the Willing Warlock collected him from there, and wound 
the rope around his stiff body. Janet did her best to prevent them. 
"Oh, please stop! What are you doing?" 
"Now, now, Gwendolen," Henry Nostrum said, rather perplexed. "You know perfectly 
well. I explained to you most carefully that the garden has to be disenchanted 
by cutting the throat of an innocent child on that slab of stone there. You 
agreed it must be so." 
"I didn't! It wasn't me!" said Janet. 
"Be quiet!" Chrestomanci said from the tree. "Do you want to be put in Cat's 
place?" 
Janet stared at him, and went on staring as all the implications struck her. 
While she stared, Cat, stiff as a mummy and wound in rope, was carried by the 
Willing Warlock and dumped rather painfully down on the block of stone. Cat 
stared resentfully at the Willing Warlock. He had always seemed so friendly. 
Apart from that, Cat was not as frightened as he might have been. Of course 
Gwendolen had known he had lives to spare. But he hoped his throat would heal 
after they cut it. He was bound to be very uncomfortable until it did. He turned 
his eyes up to Janet, meaning to give her a reassuring look. 
To his astonishment, Janet was snatched away backwards into nothingness. The 
only thing which remained of her was a yell of surprise. And the same yell 
rumbled around the meadow. Everyone there was quite as astonished as Cat. 
"Oh, good!" Gwendolen said, from the other side of the stone. "I got here in 
time." 
Everyone stared at her. Gwendolen came from between the pillars, dusting off the 
dragons' blood from her fingers with one of Cat's school essays. Cat could see 
his signature at the top: Eric Emelius Chant, 26 Coven St., Wolvercote, England, 
Europe, The World, The Universe—it was his, all right. Gwendolen still had her 
hair up in that strange headdress, but she had taken off the massive golden 
robes. She had on what must have amounted to underclothes in her new world. They 
were more magnificent than any of Chrestomanci's dressing gowns. 
"Gwendolen!" exclaimed Henry Nostrum. He pointed to the space Janet had vanished 
from. "What—who— ?" 
"Just a replacement," Gwendolen explained, in her airiest way. "I saw her and 
Cat here just now, so I knew—" She noticed Chrestomanci limply tied to the apple 
tree. "Oh, good! You caught him! Just a moment." She marched over to 
Chrestomanci and held up her golden underclothes in order to kick him hard on 
both shins. "Take that! And that!" Chrestomanci did not try to pretend the kicks 
did not hurt. He doubled up. The toes of Gwendolen's shoes were as pointed as 
nails. 
"Now, where was I?" Gwendolen said, turning back to the Nostrum brothers. "Oh, 
yes. I thought I'd better come back because I wanted to see the fun, and I 
remembered I'd forgotten to tell you Cat has nine lives. You'll have to kill him 
several times, I'm afraid." 
"Nine lives!" shouted Henry Nostrum. "You foolish girl!" 
After that, there was such a shouting and outcry from every witch and warlock in 
the meadow, that no one could have heard anything else. From where Cat lay, he 
could see William Nostrum leaning towards Gwendolen, red in the face, both eyes 
whirling, bawling furiously at her, and Gwendolen leaning forward to shout back. 
As the noise died down a little, he heard William Nostrum booming, "Nine lives! 
If he has nine lives, you stupid girl, that means he's an enchanter in his own 
right!" 
"I'm not stupid!" Gwendolen yelled back. "I know that as well as you do! I've 
been using his magic ever since he was a baby. But I couldn't go on using it if 
you were going to kill him, could I? That's why I had to go away. I think it was 
nice of me to come back and tell you. So there!" 
"How can you have used his magic?" demanded Henry Nostrum, even more put out 
than his brother. 
"I just did," said Gwendolen. "He never minds." 
"I do mind, rather," Cat said from his uncomfortable slab. "I am here, you 
know." 
Gwendolen looked down at him as if she was rather surprised that he was. But 
before she could say anything to Cat, William Nostrum was loudly shushing for 
silence. He was very agitated. He took a long shiny thing out of his pocket and 
nervously bent it about. 
"Silence!" he said. "We've gone too far to draw back now. We'll just have to 
discover the boy's weak point. We certainly can't kill him unless we find it. He 
must have one. All enchanters do." So saying, William Nostrum rounded on Cat and 
pointed the shiny thing at him. Cat was appalled to see that it was a long 
silver knife. The knife pointed at his face, even though William Nostrum's eyes 
did not. "What is your weak point, boy? Out with it." 
Cat was not saying. It seemed the only chance he had of keeping any of his 
lives. 
"I know," said Gwendolen. "I did it. I put all his lives into a book of matches. 
They were easier to use like that. It's in my room in the Castle. Shall I get 
it?" 
Everyone Cat could see from his uncomfortable position looked relieved to hear 
this. "That's all right, then," said Henry Nostrum. "Can he be killed without 
burning a match?" 
"Oh, yes," said Gwendolen. "He drowned once." 
"So the question," said William Nostrum, very much relieved, "is simply how many 
lives he has left. How many have you, boy?" The knife pointed at Cat again. 
Again Cat was not saying. 
"He doesn't know," Gwendolen said impatiently. "I had to use quite a few. He 
lost one being born and another being drowned. And I used one to put him in the 
book of matches. It gave him cramps, for some reason. Then that toad tied up in 
silver there wouldn't give me magic lessons and took my witchcraft away, so I 
had to fetch another of Cat's lives in the night and make it send me to my nice 
new world. He was awfully disobliging about it, but he did it. And that was the 
end of that life. Oh, I nearly forgot! I put his fourth life into that violin he 
kept playing, to turn it into a cat— Fiddle—remember, Mr. Nostrum?" 
Henry Nostrum clutched his two wings of hair. Consternation broke out around the 
meadow again. "You are a foolish girl! Someone took that cat away. We can't kill 
him at all!" 
For a moment, Gwendolen looked very dashed. Then an idea struck her. "If I go 
away again, you can use my replacem—" 
The watch-chains around Chrestomanci chinked. "Nostrum, you're upsetting 
yourself needlessly. It was I who had the cat-violin removed. The creature's 
around in the garden somewhere." 
Henry Nostrum swung around to look at Chrestomanci suspiciously, still hanging 
on to his two wings of hair as if that kept his mind in place. "I doubt you, 
sir, very seriously. You are known to be a very wily person." 
"You flatter me," said Chrestomanci. "Unfortunately I can't speak anything but 
the truth tied up in silver like this." 
Henry Nostrum looked at his brother. "That is correct," William said, dubiously. 
"Silver constrains him to utter facts. Then I suppose the boy's missing life 
must be here somewhere." 
This was enough for Gwendolen, the Willing Warlock, and for most of the witches 
and necromancers. Gwendolen said, "I'll go and find it, then," and minced up the 
meadow towards the trees as fast as she could in her pointed shoes, with the 
Willing Warlock bouncing ahead. As they pushed past a witch in a high green hat, 
the witch said, "That's right, dear. We must all hunt for the pussy." She turned 
to the crowd with a witch's piercing scream. "Hunt for pussy, everyone!" 
And everyone raced off to do it, picking up skirts and holding on Sunday hats. 
The meadow emptied. The trees around it shook and waved and crashed. But the 
garden would not let anyone get very far. Brightly colored witches, cloaked 
wizards, and dark warlocks kept being spilled out of the trees into the meadow 
again. Cat heard Chrestomanci say, "Your friends seem very ignorant, Nostrum. 
The way out is widdershins. Perhaps you should tell them so. The cat will 
certainly be in summer or spring." 
William Nostrum gave him a swirling glare and hurried off shouting, 
"Widdershins, brothers and sisters! Widdershins!" 
"Let me tell you, sir," Henry Nostrum said to Chrestomanci, "you are beginning 
to annoy me considerably." He hovered for a second but, as quite a crowd of 
people, with Gwendolen and the Willing Warlock among them, were whirled out of 
the trees into the meadow again, and seemed very indignant about it, Henry 
Nostrum set off trotting towards them, calling, "No, my dear friends! My dear 
pupil! Widdershins. You have to go widdershins." 
Cat and Chrestomanci were left alone for the time being by the broken arch and 
the apple tree. 



16 
"Cat," said Chrestomanci, from almost behind Cat's head. "Cat!" 
Cat did not want to talk. He was lying looking up at the blue sky through the 
leaves of the apple tree. Every so often it went blurred. Then Cat shut his eyes 
and tears ran out across both his ears. Now he knew how little Gwendolen cared 
about him, he was not sure he wanted any lives at all. He listened to the 
shouting and crashing among the trees and almost wished Fiddle would be caught 
soon. From time to time, he had an odd feeling that he was Fiddle himself—Fiddle 
furious and frightened, lashing out and scratching a huge fat witch in a flower 
hat. 
"Cat," said Chrestomanci. He sounded almost as desperate as Fiddle. "Cat, I know 
how you're feeling. We hoped you wouldn't find out about Gwendolen for years 
yet. But you are an enchanter. I suspect that you're a stronger enchanter than I 
am when you set your mind to it. Could you use some of your magic now, before 
someone catches poor Fiddle? Please. As a great favor. Just to help me get out 
of this wretched silver, so that I can summon the rest of my power." 
Cat was being Fiddle again while Chrestomanci talked. He climbed a tree, but the 
Willing Warlock and the Accredited Witch shook him out of it. He ran and he ran, 
and then jumped from between the Willing Warlock's grabbing hands, a huge jump, 
from somewhere immensely high. It was such a sickening jump that Cat opened his 
eyes. The apple leaves fluttered against the sky. The apple he could see was 
nearly ripe. 
"What do you want me to do?" he said. "I don't know how to do anything." 
"I know," said Chrestomanci. "I felt the same when they told me. Can you move 
your left hand at all?" 
"Backwards and forwards," Cat said, trying. "I can't get it out of the rope 
though." 
"No need," said Chrestomanci. "You've more ability in the little finger of that 
hand than most people—including Gwendolen—have in their entire lives. And the 
magic of the garden should help you. Just saw at the rope with your left hand 
and presume that the rope is made of silver." 
Cat tipped his head back and looked at Chrestomanci unbelievingly. Chrestomanci 
was untidy and pale and very much in earnest. He must be telling the truth. Cat 
moved his left hand against the rope. It felt rough and ropish. He told himself 
it was not rough rope, it was silver. And the rope felt smooth. But sawing was 
rather a strain. Cat lifted his hand as far as he could get it and brought the 
edge of it down on the silver rope. 
Clink. Jingle. The rope parted. 
"Thank you," said Chrestomanci. "There go two watch-chains. But there seems to 
be a very firm spell on these handcuffs. Can you try again?" 
The rope was a great deal looser. Cat fought his way out of it with a series of 
clatters and thumps— he was not sure quite what he had turned it into— and knelt 
up on the stone. Chrestomanci walked weakly towards him, with his hands still 
hanging limply in the handcuffs. At the same time, the Willing Warlock spilled 
out of the trees, arguing with the witch in the flower hat. 
"I tell you the cat's dead. It fell a good fifty feet." 
"But I tell you they always fall on their feet." 
"Then why didn't it get up then?" 
Cat realized there was no time to waste trying to imagine things. He put both 
hands to the handcuffs and wrenched. 
"Ow!" said Chrestomanci. 
But the handcuffs were off. Cat was suddenly very pleased with his newfound 
talent. He took the handcuffs in two and told them to be ferocious eagles. "Get 
after the Nostrums," he said. The left handcuff took off savagely as ordered, 
but the right half was still a silver handcuff and it fell on the grass. Cat had 
to pick it up in his left hand before it would do as it was told. 
Cat looked around then to see what Chrestomanci was doing. He was standing under 
the apple tree, and the talkative little man called Bernard was stumbling down 
the hillside towards him. Bernard's Sunday cravat was comfortably undone. He was 
carrying a pencil and a newspaper folded open at the crossword. "Enchantment, 
five letters, ending in C," he was murmuring, before he looked up and saw 
Chrestomanci green with tree mold. He stared at the two watch-chains, Cat, the 
rope, and the numbers of people who were hurrying among the trees around the top 
of the meadow. "Bless my soul!" he said. "I'm sorry—I had no idea I was needed. 
You need the others too?" 
"Rather quickly," said Chrestomanci. 
The witch in the flower hat saw him standing away from the tree and raised her 
voice in a witch's scream. "They're getting away! Stop them!" 
Witches, warlocks, necromancers, and wizards poured out into the meadow, with 
Gwendolen mincing among them, and hurriedly cast spells as they came. Muttering 
rolled around the garden. The smell of magic grew thick. Chrestomanci held up 
one hand as if he was asking for silence. The muttering grew instead, and 
sounded angry. But none of the people muttering came any nearer. The only ones 
who were still moving were William and Henry Nostrum, who kept spilling out from 
the trees, running hard and bawling faintly, each with a large flapping eagle 
after him. 
Bernard chewed his pencil and his face looked ribby. "This is awful! There are 
so many of them!" 
"Keep trying. I'm giving you all the help I can spare," Chrestomanci said, with 
an anxious look at the muttering crowd. 
Bernard's bushy eyebrows bobbed up. "Ah!" Miss Bessemer was standing above him 
on the slope. She had the works of a clock in one hand and a cloth in the other. 
Perhaps because of the slope, she seemed taller and more purple of dress than 
usual. She took in the situation at a glance. "You'll need a full muster to deal 
with this lot," she said to Chrestomanci.
A witch in the muttering crowd screamed, "He's getting help!" Cat thought it was 
Gwendolen. The smell of magic grew, and the muttering became like a long roll of 
thunder. The crowd seemed to be edging forward slowly, in a bobbing of fancy 
hats and a bristle of dark suits. The hand Chrestomanci was holding up to stop 
them began to shake. 
"The garden's helping them too," said Bernard. "Put forth your best, 
Bessie-girl." He chewed his pencil and frowned intensely. Miss Bessemer wrapped 
her cloth neatly around her pieces of clock and grew noticeably taller. 
And suddenly the rest of the Family began to appear around the apple tree, all 
in the middle of the peaceful Sunday things they had been doing when they were 
summoned. One of the younger ladies had a skein of wool between her hands, and 
one of the younger men was winding it. The next man was holding a billiard cue, 
and the other young lady had a lump of chalk. The old lady with mittens was 
crocheting a new pair of mittens. Mr. Saunders appeared with a thump. He had the 
dragon tucked playfully under one arm, and both of them looked startled to be 
fetched in the middle of a romp. 
The dragon saw Cat. It wriggled out from under Mr. Saunders' arm, bounded across 
the grass, and jumped rattling and flaming into Cat's arms. Cat found himself 
staggering about under the apple tree with quite a heavy dragon squirming on his 
chest and enthusiastically licking his face with flame. It would have burned him 
badly if he had not remembered in time to tell the flames they were cool. 
He looked up to see Roger and Julia appearing. They both had their arms 
stretched stiffly above their heads, because they had been playing mirrors 
again, and they were both very much astonished. "It's the garden!" said Roger. 
"And loads of people!" 
"You never summoned us before, Daddy," said Julia. 
"This is rather special," said Chrestomanci. He was holding his right hand up 
with his left one by now, and looking tired out. "I need you to fetch your 
mother. Quickly." 
"We're holding them," Mr. Saunders said. He was trying to sound encouraging, but 
he was nervous. The muttering crowd was coming nearer. 
"No, we aren't!" snapped the old lady in mittens. "We can't do anything more 
without Millie." 
Cat had a feeling that everyone was trying to fetch Millie. He thought he ought 
to help, since they needed her so much, but he did not know what to do. Besides, 
the dragon's flames were so hot that he needed all his energy not to get burned. 

Roger and Julia could not fetch Millie. "What's wrong?" said Julia. "We've 
always been able to before." 
"All these people's spells are stopping us," said Roger.
"Try again," said Chrestomanci. "I can't. Something's stopping me too." 
"Are you joining in the magic?" the dragon asked Cat. Cat was finding the heat 
of it really troublesome by now. His face was red and sore. But, as soon as the 
dragon spoke, he understood. He was joining in the magic. Only he was joining in 
on the wrong side, because Gwendolen was using him again. He was so used to her 
doing it that he barely noticed. But he could feel her doing it now. She was 
using so much of his power to stop Chrestomanci fetching Millie that Cat was 
getting burned. 
For the first time in his life, Cat was angry about it. "She's no business to!" 
he told the dragon. And he took his magic back. It was like a cool draft in his 
face. 
"Cat! Stop that!" Gwendolen screamed from the crowd. 
"Oh, shut up!" Cat shouted back. "It's mine!" 
At his feet, the little spring ran bubbling out of the grass again. Cat was 
looking down at it, wondering why it should, when he noticed a sort of gladness 
come over the anxious Family around him. Chrestomanci was looking upwards, and a 
light seemed to have fallen across his face. Cat turned around and found Millie 
was there at last. He supposed it was some trick of the hillside that made her 
look tall as the apple tree. But it seemed no trick that she also looked kind as 
the end of a long day. She had Fiddle in her arms. Fiddle was draggled and 
miserable, but purring. 
"I'm so sorry," Millie said. "I'd have come sooner if I'd known. This poor beast 
had fallen off the garden wall and I wasn't thinking of anything else." 
Chrestomanci smiled, and let his hand go. He did not seem to need it to hold 
back the crowd anymore. They stood where they were, and their muttering had 
stopped. "It doesn't matter," he said. "But we must get to work now." 
The Family got to work at once. Cat found it hard to describe or remember 
afterward just how, they did. He remembered claps and peals of thunder, 
darkness, and mist. He thought Chrestomanci grew taller than Millie, tall as the 
sky—but that could have been because the dragon got extremely scared and Cat was 
kneeling in the grass to make it feel safer. From there he saw the Family from 
time to time, striding about like giants. Witches screamed and screamed. 
Warlocks and wizards roared and howled. Sometimes there was whirling white rain, 
or whirling white snow, or perhaps just whirling white smoke, whirling and 
whirling. Cat was sure the whole garden was spinning, faster and faster. Among 
the whirling and the whiteness came flying necromancers, or Bernard striding, or 
Mr. Saunders, billowing, with snow in his hair. Julia ran past, making knot 
after knot in her handkerchief. And Millie must have brought reinforcements with 
her; Cat glimpsed Euphemia, the butler, a footman, two gardeners and, to his 
alarm, Will Suggins once, breasting the whiteness in the howling, spinning, 
screaming garden. 
The spinning got so fast that Cat was no longer giddy. It was spinning 
rock-steady, and humming. Chrestomanci stepped out of the whiteness and under 
the apple tree and held out one hand to Cat. He was wet and windswept, and Cat 
was still not sure how tall he was. "Can I have some of your dragons' blood?" 
Chrestomanci said. 
"How did you know I'd got it?" Cat said guiltily, letting go of the dragon in 
order to get at his crucible. 
"The smell," said Chrestomanci. 
Cat passed his crucible over. "Here you are. Have I lost a life over it?" 
"Not you," said Chrestomanci. "But it was lucky you didn't let Janet touch it." 
He stepped to the whirling, and emptied the whole crucible into it. Cat saw the 
powder snatched away and whirled. The mist turned brownish-red and the humming 
to a terrible bell note that hurt Cat's ears. He could hear witches and warlocks 
howling with horror. "Let them roar," said Chrestomanci. He was leaning against 
the right-hand pillar of the archway. "Every single one of them has now lost his 
or her witchcraft. They'll complain to their MPs and there'll be questions asked 
in Parliament, but I daresay we shall survive it." He raised his hand and 
beckoned. 
Frantic people in soaking-wet Sunday clothes came whirling out of the whiteness 
and were sucked through the broken arch like dead leaves in a whirlpool. More 
and more and more came. They sailed through in crowds. Out of the whirling many, 
Chrestomanci somehow collected the two Nostrums and put them down for a minute 
in front of Cat and the dragon. Cat was charmed to see one of his eagles sitting 
on Henry Nostrum's shoulders, pecking at his bald pate, and the other eagle 
fluttering around William, stabbing at the stouter parts of him. 
"Call them off," said Chrestomanci. 
Cat called them off, rather regretfully, and they fell on the grass as 
handcuffs. Then the handcuffs were swept away with the Nostrum brothers and 
whirled through the archway with them in the last of the crowd. 
Last of all came Gwendolen. Chrestomanci stopped her too. As he did so, the 
whiteness cleared, the humming died away, and the rest of the Family began to 
collect on the sunny hillside, panting a little but not very wet. Cat thought 
the garden was probably still spinning. But perhaps it always did. Gwendolen 
stared around in horror. 
"Let me go! I've got to go back and be queen." 
"Don't be selfish," said Chrestomanci. "You've no right to keep snatching eight 
other people from world to world. Stay here and learn how to do it properly. And 
those courtiers of yours don't really do what you say, you know. They only 
pretend." "I don't care!" Gwendolen screamed. She held up her golden clothes, 
kicked off her pointed shoes, and ran for the archway. Chrestomanci reached out 
to stop her. Gwendolen spun around and hurled her last handful of dragons' blood 
in his face and, while Chrestomanci was forced to duck and put one arm over his 
face, Gwendolen backed hastily through the archway. There was a mighty bang. The 
space between the pillars turned black. When everyone recovered, Gwendolen was 
gone. There was nothing but meadow between the pillars again. Even the pointed 
shoes had gone. 
"What did the child do?" said the old lady with mittens, very shaken. 
"Sealed herself in that world," said Chrestomanci. He was even more shaken. 
"Isn't that so, Cat?" he said. 
Cat nodded mulishly. It had seemed worth it. He was not sure he wanted to see 
Gwendolen again. 
"And look what that's done," said Mr. Saunders, nodding at the hillside. 
Janet was stumbling down the slope, past Millie, and she was crying. Millie 
handed Fiddle carefully to Julia and put her arms around Janet. Janet sobbed 
heavily. The rest crowded around her. Bernard patted Janet's back and the old 
lady with mittens made soothing noises. 
Cat stood on his own near the ruins, with the dragon looking inquiringly up at 
him from the grass. Janet had been happy in her own world. She had missed her 
mother and father. Now she was probably in this world for good, and Cat had done 
it. And Chrestomanci had called Gwendolen selfish! 
"No, it's not that, quite, really," Janet said from the midst of the Family. She 
tried to sit down on the fallen block of stone, and got up quickly, remembering 
the way it was being used when she last saw it. 
Cat had a very gallant idea. He sent for a blue velvet chair from Gwendolen's 
room and put it down on the grass beside Janet. Janet gave a tearful laugh. 
"That was kind." She started to sit in it. 
"I belong to Chrestomanci Castle," said the chair. "I belong to Chresto-—" Miss 
Bessemer looked at it sternly and it stopped. 
Janet sat in the chair. It was a little wobbly because the grass was uneven. 
"Where's Cat?" she said anxiously. 
"I'm here," said Cat. "I got the chair for you." He thought it was kind of Janet 
to look so relieved to see him. 
"What do you say to a little lunch?" Millie asked Miss Bessemer. "It must be 
nearly two o'clock." 
"Agreed," said Miss Bessemer, and made a stately half-turn towards the butler. 
He nodded. The footman and the gardeners staggered forward with great hampers 
like laundry baskets which, when the lids were thrown back, proved to be full of 
chickens, hams, meat pies, ice cream, fruit, and wine. 
"Oh, beautiful!" said Roger. 
Everyone sat around to eat the lunch. Most of them sat on the grass, and Cat 
made sure to sit as far away from Will Suggins as he could. Millie sat on the 
stone slab. Chrestomanci splashed some of the water from the bubbling spring 
over his face— which seemed to refresh him wonderfully—and sat leaning against 
the slab. The old lady with mittens produced a tuffet out of nowhere, which she 
said was more comfortable; and Bernard thoughtfully shook out the remains of the 
rope that Cat had left by the rock. It became a hammock. Bernard strung it 
between the pillars of the archway and lay in it, looking defiantly comfortable, 
even though he had the greatest difficulty keeping his balance and eating as 
well. Fiddle was given a wing of chicken and took it into the apple tree to eat, 
out of the way of the dragon. The dragon was jealous of Fiddle. It divided its 
time between breathing resentful smoke up into the tree and leaning heavily 
against Cat, begging for chicken and meat pie. 
"I warn you," said Mr. Saunders. "That is the most spoiled dragon in the world." 

"I'm the only dragon in the world," the dragon said smugly. 
Janet was still inclined to be tearful. "My dear, we do understand," said 
Millie, "and we're so very sorry." 
"I can send you back," said Chrestomanci. "It's not quite so easy with 
Gwendolen's world missing from the series, but don't think it can't be done." 
"No, no. That's all right," Janet gulped. "At least, it will be all right when 
I'm used to it. I was hoping to come back here—but it is rather a wrench. You 
see—" Her eyes filled and her mouth trembled. A handkerchief came out of the air 
and pushed itself into her hand. Cat did not know who had done it, but he wished 
he had thought of it. "Thanks," said Janet. "You see, Mum and Dad haven't 
noticed the difference." She blew her nose furiously. "I got back to my bedroom, 
and the other girl—she's called Romillia really—had been writing her diary. She 
got called away in midsentence and left it lying there, so I read it. And it was 
all about how scared she had been in case my parents noticed she wasn't me, and 
how glad she was when she was clever enough to make sure they didn't. She was 
utterly terrified of being sent back. She'd had a dreadful life as an orphan in 
her own world, and she was miserable there. She'd written things that made me 
feel really sorry for her. Mind you," Janet said severely, "she was just asking 
for trouble keeping a diary in the same house as my parents. I wrote a note in 
it telling her so, and I said if she must keep one, she'd better put it in one 
of my good hiding places. And then—and then I sat there and rather hoped I'd 
come back." 
"That was kind of you," said Cat. 
"It was, and you're truly welcome, my love," \said Millie. 
"You're sure?" Chrestomanci asked, looking searchingly at Janet over the chicken 
leg he was eating. 
Janet nodded, quite firmly, though most of her face was still hidden in the 
handkerchief. 
"You were the one I was most worried about," Chrestomanci said. "I'm afraid I 
didn't realize at once what had happened. Gwendolen had found out about the 
mirror, you see, and she worked the change in her bathroom. And anyway, none of 
us had the slightest idea Cat's powers were that strong. The truth only dawned 
on me during that unfortunate affair of the frog, and then of course I took a 
look at once to see what had happened to Gwendolen and the seven other girls. 
Gwendolen was in her element. And Jennifer, who came after Romillia, is as tough 
as Gwendolen and has always wished she was an orphan; whereas Queen Caroline, 
whom Gwendolen displaced, was as miserable as Romillia, and had run away three 
times already. And it was the same with the other five. They were all much 
better suited—except perhaps you." 
Janet took her face out of the handkerchief and looked at him in large 
indignation. "Why couldn't you have told me you knew? I wouldn't have been 
nearly so scared of you! And you wouldn't believe the troubles Cat got into 
because of it—not to speak of me owing Mr. Bagwash twenty pounds and not knowing 
the Geography and History here! And you needn't laugh!" she said, as nearly 
everyone did. 
"I apologize," said Chrestomanci. "Believe me, it was one of the most troubling 
decisions I've ever had to make. But who on earth is Mr. Bagwash?" 
"Mr. Baslam," Cat explained reluctantly. "Gwendolen bought some dragons' blood 
from him and didn't really pay." 
"He's asking outrageously much," said Millie. "And it is illegal, you know." 
"I'll go and have a word with him tomorrow," Bernard said from his hammock. 
"Though he'll probably be gone by then. He knows I've got my eye on him." 
"Why was it a troubling decision?" Janet asked Chrestomanci. 
Chrestomanci tossed his chicken bone to the dragon and slowly wiped his fingers 
on a handkerchief with a gold-embroidered C in one corner. This gave him an 
excuse to turn Cat's way and stare, in his vaguest way, into the air above Cat's 
head. Since Cat was fairly clear by now that the vaguer Chrestomanci seemed 
about something, the more acutely he was attending to it, he was not altogether 
surprised when Chrestomanci said, "Because of Cat. We would have felt a good 
deal easier if Cat could have brought himself to tell someone what had happened. 
We gave him a number of opportunities to. But when he held his tongue, we 
thought perhaps he did know the extent of his powers after all." 
"But I don't," said Cat. 
And Janet, who was becoming thoroughly cheerful now she was being allowed to ask 
questions, said, "I think you were quite wrong. We both got so frightened that 
we came into this garden and nearly got you and Cat killed. You should have 
said." 
"Perhaps," agreed Chrestomanci, and peeled a banana in a thoughtful way. He was 
still turned towards Cat. "Normally we're more than a match here for people like 
the Nostrums. I knew they were planning something through Gwendolen, and I 
thought Cat knew it too—my apologies, Cat. I wouldn't have had Gwendolen here 
for a minute, except that we had to have Cat. Chrestomanci has to be a 
nine-lived enchanter. No one else is strong enough for the post." 
"Post?" said Janet. "Isn't it a hereditary title then?" 
Mr. Saunders laughed, and threw his bone to the dragon too. "Heavens no! We're 
all Government employees here. The job Chrestomanci has is to make sure this 
world isn't run entirely by witches. Ordinary people have rights too. And he has 
to make sure witches don't get out into worlds where there isn't so much magic 
and play havoc there. It's a big job. And we're the staff that helps him." 
"And he needs us like he needs two left legs," Bernard remarked, jerking about 
in the hammock as he tried to eat ice cream. 
"Oh, come now!" said Chrestomanci. "I'd have been sunk without you today." 
"I was thinking of the way you found the next Chrestomanci," Bernard said, 
spooning ice cream off his waistcoat. "You did it when we were just going around 
in circles." 
"Nine-lived enchanters are not easy to find," Chrestomanci explained to Janet. 
"In the first place, they're very rare, and in the second, they have to use 
their magic before they can be found. And Cat didn't. We were actually thinking 
of bringing someone in from another world, when Cat happened to fall into the 
hands of a clairvoyant. Even then, we only knew where he was, not who. I'd no 
idea he was Eric Chant, or any relation of mine at all—though I suppose I might 
have remembered that his parents were cousins, which doubled the chance of their 
children being witches. And I must confess that Frank Chant wrote to me to say 
his daughter was a witch and seemed to be using her younger brother in some way. 
Forgive me, Cat. I ignored that letter because your father had been so very rude 
when I offered to make sure his children would be born without witchcraft." 
"Just as well he was rude, you know," Bernard said. 
"Was that what the letters were about?" said Cat. 
"I don't understand," said Janet, "why you didn't say anything at all to Cat. 
Why couldn't you?" 
Chrestomanci was still looking vaguely in Cat's direction. Cat could tell he was 
very wary indeed. "Like this," he said. "Remember we hadn't known one another 
very long. Cat appears to have no magic at all. Yet his sister works magic far 
beyond her own abilities, and goes on doing it even when her witchcraft is taken 
away. What am I to think? Does Cat know what he's doing? If he doesn't, why 
doesn't he? And if he does know, what is he up to? When Gwendolen removed 
herself, and nobody mentioned the fact, I hoped some of the answers might 
emerge. And Cat still does nothing—" 
"What do you mean, nothing?" said Janet. "There were some fabulous horse 
chestnuts, and he kept stopping Julia." 
"Yes, and I couldn't think what was happening," Julia said, rather ashamed. 
Cat felt hurt and uncomfortable. "Leave me alone!" he said, and he stood up. 
Everyone, even Chrestomanci, went tense. The only person who did not was Janet, 
and Cat could hardly count her, because she was not used to magic. He found he 
was trying not to cry, which made him very much ashamed. "Stop treating me so 
carefully!" he said. "I'm not a fool, or a baby. You're all afraid of me, aren't 
you? You didn't tell me things and you didn't punish Gwendolen because you were 
afraid I'd do something dreadful. And I haven't. I don't know how to. I didn't 
know I could." 
"My love, it was just that no one was sure," said Millie. 
"Well, be sure now!" said Cat. "The only things I did were by mistake, like 
coming here in this garden—and turning Euphemia into a frog, I suppose, but I 
didn't know it was me." 
"You're not to worry about that, Eric," said Euphemia from the hillside, where 
she was sitting with Will Suggins. "It was the shock upset me. I know enchanters 
are different from us witches. And I'll speak to Mary. I promise." 
"Speak to Will Suggins too, while you're at it," said Janet. "Because he's going 
to turn Cat into a frog in revenge any minute now." 
Euphemia bounced around on the hillside to look at Will. "What?" she said. 
"What is this, Will?" Chrestomanci asked, 
"I laid it on him—for three o'clock, sir," Will Suggins said apprehensively, "if 
he didn't meet me as a tiger." 
Chrestomanci took out a large gold watch. "Hm. It's about due now. If you don't 
mind my saying so, that was a little foolish of you, Will. Suppose you carry on. 
Turn Cat into a frog, or yourself into a tiger, or both. I shan't interfere." 
Will Suggins climbed heavily to his feet and stood facing Cat, looking as if he 
would prefer to be several miles away. "Let the dough work, then," he said. 
Cat was still feeling so upset and tearful that he wondered whether to oblige 
Will Suggins and become a frog. Or he could try being a flea instead. But it all 
seemed rather silly. "Why don't you be a tiger?" he said. 
As Cat expected, Will Suggins made a beautiful tiger, long-backed and sleek and 
sharply striped. He was heavy as he padded up and down the slope, but his legs 
slid so easily in the silky folds of his hide that he almost seemed light. But 
Will Suggins himself spoiled the effect by rubbing a distressed paw over his 
huge cat face and staring appealingly at Chrestomanci. Chrestomanci simply 
laughed. The dragon trotted up the hill to investigate this new beast. Will 
Suggins was so alarmed that he reared up on his great hind legs to get away from 
it. It looked so ungainly for a tiger to be doing that, that Cat turned him back 
to Will Suggins on the spot. 
"It wasn't real?" asked the dragon. 
"No!" said Will Suggins, mopping his face with his sleeve. "All right, lad, you 
win. How did you do it so quick?" 
"I don't know," Cat said apologetically. "I've really no idea. Shall I learn 
when you teach me magic?" he asked Mr. Saunders. 
Mr. Saunders looked a little blank. "Well—" 
"No, Michael," said Chrestomanci, "is the right answer. It's quite clear 
Elementary Magic isn't going to mean much to Cat. I'll have to teach you myself, 
Cat, and we'll be starting on Advanced Theory, I think, by the look of it. You 
seem to start where most people leave off." 
"But why didn't he know?" Janet demanded. "It always makes me angry not to know 
things, and I feel especially angry about this, because it seems so hard on 
Cat." 
"It is, I agree," said Chrestomanci. "But it's something in the nature of 
enchanters' magic, I think. Something the same happened to me. I couldn't do 
magic either. I couldn't do anything. But they found I had nine lives—I lost 
them at such a rate that it soon became obvious—and they told me I had to be the 
next Chrestomanci when I grew up, which absolutely appalled me, because I 
couldn't work the simplest spell. So they sent me to a tutor, the most 
terrifying old person, who was supposed to find what the trouble was. And he 
took one look at me and snarled, 'Empty your pockets, Chant!' Which I did. I was 
too scared not to. I took out my silver watch, and one and sixpence, and a 
silver charm from my godmother, and a silver tiepin I had forgotten to wear, and 
a silver brace I was supposed to wear in my teeth. And as soon as they were 
gone, I did some truly startling things. As I remember, the roof of the tutor's 
house came off." 
"Is it really true about silver, then?" Janet said. 
"For me, yes," said Chrestomanci. 
"Yes, poor darling," Millie said, smiling at him. "It's so awkward with money. 
He can only handle pound notes and coppers." 
"He has to give us our pocket money in pennies, if Michael hasn't got it," said 
Roger. "Imagine sixty pennies in your pocket." 
"The really difficult thing is mealtimes," said Millie. "He can't do a thing 
with a knife and fork in his hands—and Gwendolen would do awful things during 
dinner." 
"How stupid!" said Janet. "Why on earth don't you use stainless steel cutlery?" 
Millie and Chrestomanci looked at one another. "I never thought of it!" said 
Millie. "Janet, my love, it's a very good thing you're staying here!" 
Janet looked at Cat and laughed. And Cat, though he was still a little lonely 
and tearful, managed to laugh too.