&21$17+(:$55,25
E\5REHUW(+RZDUG

&RS\ULJKWE\/6SUDJXHGH&DPS$OOULJKWUHVHUYHG


5HG1DLOVZDVRULJLQDOO\SXEOLVKHGLQB:HLUG7DOHVBIRU-XO\$XJXVW
6HSWHPEHUDQG2FWREHUFRS\ULJKWE\3RSXODU)LFWLRQ
3XEOLVKLQJ&R,WZDVUHSULQWHGLQB7KH6ZRUGRI&RQDQBE\5REHUW(
+RZDUG1<*QRPH3UHVV,QF

-HZHOVRI*ZDKOXUZDVRULJLQDOO\SXEOLVKHGLQB:HLUG7DOHVBIRU
0DUFKFRS\ULJKWE\3RSXODU)LFWLRQ3XEOLVKLQJ&R,WZDV
UHSULQWHGLQB.LQJ&RQDQBE\5REHUW(+RZDUG1<*QRPH3UHVV
,QF

%H\RQGWKH%ODFN5LYHUZDVRULJLQDOO\SXEOLVKHGLQB:HLUG7DOHVBIRU
0D\DQG-XQHFRS\ULJKWE\3RSXODU)LFWLRQ3XEOLVKLQJ&R
,WZDVUHSULQWHGLQB.LQJ&RQDQB


     'LVWULEXWHGE\$FH%RRNV
     $GLYLVLRQRI&KDUWHU&RPPXQLFDWLRQV,QF
     $*URVVHW	'XQODS&RPSDQ\

     3ULQWHGLQWKH86$


     &RQWHQWV
,QWURGXFWLRQ                      
5HG1DLOV                   
-HZHOVRI*ZDKOXU                 
%H\RQGWKH%ODFN5LYHU            


3DJHVDQG$PDSRIWKHZRUOGRI&RQDQLQWKH+\ERULDQ$JHEDVHG
XSRQQRWHVDQGVNHWFKHVE\5REHUW(+RZDUGDQGXSRQSUHYLRXVPDSVE\
36FKX\OHU0LOOHU-RKQ'&ODUN'DYLG.\OHDQG/6SUDJXHGH
&DPSZLWKDPDSRI(XURSHDQGDGMDFHQWUHJLRQVVXSHULPSRVHGIRU
UHIHUHQFH

&RYHU3DLQWLQJE\)UDQN)UD]HWWDZLWKJUDWHIXODFNQRZOHGJHPHQW
WR5R\.UHQNHODGYLVRU

7KHELRJUDSKLFDOSDUDJUDSKVEHWZHHQWKHVWRULHVDUHEDVHGXSRQB$
3UREDEOH2XWOLQHRI&RQDQ
V&DUHHUBE\36FKX\OHU0LOOHUDQG'U
-RKQ'&ODUNSXEOLVKHGLQB7KH+\ERULDQ$JHB/RV$QJHOHV/$1<
&RRSHUDWLYH3XEOLFDWLRQVDQGRQWKHH[SDQGHGYHUVLRQRIWKLV
HVVD\B$Q,QIRUPDO%LRJUDSK\RI&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQBE\36FKX\OHU
0LOOHU-RKQ'&ODUNDQG/6SUDJXHGH&DPSSXEOLVKHGLQB$PUDB
9RO1RFRS\ULJKWE\*+6FLWKHUVXVHGE\SHUPLVVLRQRI
*+6FLWKHUVB$PUDB%R[&KLFDJRLVWKHRUJDQRIWKH
+\ERULDQ/HJLRQDORRVHRUJDQL]DWLRQRISHRSOHZKRPDNHDKREE\RI
WDOHVRIKHURLFIDQWDV\DQGRIWKH&RQDQVWRULHVLQSDUWLFXODU



,1752'8&7,21

2IDOOWKHPDQ\NLQGVRIILFWLRQWKHRQHWKDWJLYHVWKHSXUHVW
HQWHUWDLQPHQWLVKHURLFIDQWDV\WKHVWRU\RIVZRUGSOD\DQGVRUFHU\
ODLGLQDQLPDJLQDU\ZRUOGHLWKHUWKLVSODQHWDVLWZDVORQJDJR
RULQWKHUHPRWHIXWXUHRURQDQRWKHUZRUOGRULQDQRWKHUGLPHQVLRQ
ZKHUHPDJLFZRUNVDQGDOOPHQDUHPLJKW\DOOZRPHQEHDXWLIXODOO
SUREOHPVVLPSOHDQGDOOOLIHDGYHQWXURXV,QVXFKDZRUOGJOHDPLQJ
FLWLHVUDLVHWKHLUVKLQLQJVSLUHVDJDLQVWWKHVWDUVVRUFHUHUFDVW
VLQLVWHUVSHOOVIURPVXEWHUUDQHDQODLUVEDOHIXOVSLULWVVWDON
FUXPEOLQJUXLQVSULPHYDOPRQVWHUVFUDVKWKURXJKMXQJOHWKLFNHWVDQG
WKHIDWHRINLQJGRPVLVEDODQFHGRQWKHEORRG\EODGHVRIEURDGVZRUGV
EUDQGLVKHGE\KHURHVRISUHWHUQDWXUDOPLJKWDQGYDORU
2QHRIWKHJUHDWHVWZULWHUVRIKHURLFIDQWDV\ZDV5REHUW(UYLQ
+RZDUGZKROLYHGPRVWRIKLVVKRUWOLIHLQ&URVV3ODLQV
7H[DV+RZDUGZDVDYROXPLQRXVZULWHUIRUWKHSXOSPDJD]LQHVRIWKH
WLPH-DFN/RQGRQ7DOERW0XQG\+DUROG/DPE(GJDU5LFH%XUURXJKV
DQG+3/RYHFUDIWDOOLQIOXHQFHGKLP
+RZDUG
VPRVWPHPRUDEOHFKDUDFWHUZDV&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQ&RQDQ
LVVXSSRVHGWRKDYHOLYHGDERXWWZHOYHWKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRLQWKH
+\ERULDQ$JHEHWZHHQWKHVLQNLQJRI$WODQWLVDQGWKHEHJLQQLQJVRI
UHFRUGHGKLVWRU\$JLJDQWLFEDUEDULDQDGYHQWXUHUIURPWKHQRUWKHUQ
ODQGRI&LPPHULD&RQDQZDGHVWKURXJKULYHUVRIEORRGDQGRYHUFRPHV
IRHVERWKQDWXUDODQGVXSHUQDWXUDOWREHFRPHDWODVWNLQJRIWKH
+\ERULDQNLQJGRPRI$TXLORQLD
(LJKWHHQ&RQDQVWRULHVZHUHSXEOLVKHGLQ+RZDUG
VOLIHWLPHDQG
VHYHUDOPRUHKDYHEHHQGLVFRYHUHGLQPDQXVFULSWVLQFHKLVHDUO\
GHDWK,WKDVEHHQP\SULYLOHJHWRHGLWWKHVHIRUSXEOLFDWLRQDQGWR
UHYLVHDQGFRPSOHWHWKRVHWKDWZHUHXQILQLVKHG

&RQDQDUULYHGDVD\RXWKLQWKHNLQJGRPRI=DPRUDVHHWKHPDS
DQGIRUVHYHUDO\HDUVPDGHDSUHFDULRXVOLYLQJDVDWKLHIWKHUHDQG
LQ&RULQWKLDDQG1HPHGLD7KHQKHZDVDPHUFHQDU\VROGLHUILUVWLQ
WKHRULHQWDOUHDOPRI7XUDQDQGWKHQLQWKH+\ERULDQNLQJGRPV)RUFHG
WRIOHHIURP$UJRVKHEHFDPHDSLUDWHDORQJWKHFRDVWRI.XVKLQ
SDUWQHUVKLSZLWKD6KHPLWLVKVKHSLUDWH%HOLWDQGZLWKDFUHZRI
EODFNFRUVDLUV+HUHKHHDUQHGWKHQDPHRI$PUDWKH/LRQ
$IWHU%HOLW
VGHDWK&RQDQUHWXUQHGWRWKHWUDGHRIPHUFHQDU\LQ
6KHPDQGLQWKHDGMDFHQW+\ERULDQNLQJGRPV6XEVHTXHQWO\KH
DGYHQWXUHGDPRQJWKHQRPDGLFRXWODZVWKHBNR]DNVBRIWKHHDVWHUQ
VWHSSHVWKHSLUDWHVRIWKH6HDRI9LOD\HWDQGWKHKLOOWULEHVRI
WKH+LPHOLDQ0RXQWDLQVRQWKHERUGHUVRI,UDQLVWDQDQG9HQGK\D7KHQ
DQRWKHUVWUHWFKRIVROGLHULQJLQ.RWKDQG$UJRVLQWKHFRXUVHRI
ZKLFKKHZDVEULHIO\FRUXOHURIWKHGHVHUWFLW\RI7RPEDONX7KHQ
EDFNWRWKHVHDILUVWDVDSLUDWHRIWKH%DUDFKD,VOHVWKHQDV
FDSWDLQRIDVKLSRIWKH=LQJDUDQEXFFDQHHUV:KHQWKLVYROXPHWDNHV
XSKHZDVLQKLVODWHWKLUWLHV

                             /6SUDJXHGH&DPS




5('1$,/6


)RUVRPHWZR\HDUVDVFDSWDLQRIWKHB:DVWUHOB&RQDQFRQWLQXHVD
KLJKO\VXFFHVVIXOFDUHHUDVDIUHHERRWHU+RZHYHUWKHRWKHU=LQJDUDQ
SLUDWHVMHDORXVRIWKHRXWODQGHULQWKHLUPLGVWDWODVWEULQJKLP
GRZQRIIWKHFRDVWRI6KHP(VFDSLQJLQODQGDQGKHDULQJWKDWZDUVDUH
LQWKHRIILQJDORQJWKHERUGHUVRI6W\JLD&RQDQMRLQVWKH)UHH
&RPSDQLRQVDEDQGRIFRQGRWWLHULXQGHUWKHFRPPDQGRIRQH=DUDOOR
,QVWHDGRIULFKSOXQGHUKRZHYHUKHILQGVKLPVHOIHQJDJHGLQ
XQHYHQWIXOJXDUGGXW\LQWKHERUGHUSRVWRI6XNKPHWRQWKHIURQWLHU
RIWKHEODFNNLQJGRPV7KHZLQHLVVRXUDQGWKHSLFNLQJVSRRUDQG
&RQDQVRRQJHWVWLUHGRIEODFNZRPHQ+LVERUHGRPHQGVZLWKWKH
DSSHDUDQFHLQ6XNKPHWRI9DOHULDRIWKH5HG%URWKHUKRRGDZRPDQ
SLUDWHZKRPKHKDGNQRZQLQKLV%DUDFKDQGD\V:KHQVKHWDNHVGUDVWLF
PHDVXUHVWRUHSXOVHD6W\JLDQRIILFHU&RQDQIROORZVKHUVRXWKLQWR
WKHODQGVRIWKHEODFNV



7KH6NXOORQWKH&UDJ

7KHZRPDQRQWKHKRUVHUHLQHGLQKHUZHDU\VWHHG,WVWRRGZLWK
LWVOHJVZLGHEUDFHGLWVKHDGGURRSLQJDVLILWIRXQGHYHQWKH
ZHLJKWRIWKHJROGWDVVOHGUHGOHDWKHUEULGOHWRRKHDY\7KHZRPDQ
GUHZDERRWHGIRRWRXWRIWKHVLOYHUVWLUUXSDQGVZXQJGRZQIURPWKH
JLOWZRUNHGVDGGOH6KHPDGHWKHUHLQVIDVWWRWKHIRUNRIDVDSOLQJ
DQGWXUQHGDERXWKDQGVRQKHUKLSVWRVXUYH\KHUVXUURXQGLQJV
7KH\ZHUHQRWLQYLWLQJ*LDQWWUHHVKHPPHGLQWKHVPDOOSRROZKHUH
KHUKRUVHKDGMXVWGUXQN&OXPSVRIXQGHUJURZWKOLPLWHGWKHYLVLRQ
WKDWTXHVWHGXQGHUWKHVRPEHUWZLOLJKWRIWKHORIW\DUFKVIRUPHGE\
LQWHUWZLQLQJEUDQFKHV7KHZRPDQVKLYHUHGZLWKDWZLWFKRIKHU
PDJQLILFHQWVKRXOGHUVDQGWKHQFXUVHG
6KHZDVWDOOIXOOERVRPHGDQGODUJHOLPEHGZLWKFRPSDFW
VKRXOGHUV+HUZKROHILJXUHUHIOHFWHGDQXQXVXDOVWUHQJWKZLWKRXW
GHWUDFWLQJIURPWKHIHPLQLQLW\RIKHUDSSHDUDQFH6KHZDVDOOZRPDQ
LQVSLWHRIKHUEHDULQJDQGKHUJDUPHQWV7KHODWWHUZHUH
LQFRQJUXRXVLQYLHZRIKHUSUHVHQWHQYLURQV,QVWHDGRIDVNLUWVKH
ZRUHVKRUWZLGHOHJJHGVLONEUHHFKHVZKLFKFHDVHGDKDQG
VEUHDGWK
VKRUWRIKHUNQHHVDQGZHUHXSKHOGE\DZLGHVLONHQVDVKZRUQDVD
JLUGOH)ODULQJWRSSHGERRWVRIVRIWOHDWKHUFDPHDOPRVWWRKHU
NQHHVDQGDORZQHFNHGZLGHFROODUHGZLGHVOHHYHGVLONVKLUW
FRPSOHWHGKHUFRVWXPH2QHRQHVKDSHO\KLSVKHZRUHDVWUDLJKW
GRXEOHHGJHGVZRUGDQGRQWKHRWKHUDORQJGLUN+HUXQUXO\JROGHQ
KDLUFXWVTXDUHDWKHUVKRXOGHUVZDVFRQILQHGE\DEDQGRIFULPVRQ
VDWLQ
$JDLQVWWKHEDFNJURXQGRIVRPEHUSULPLWLYHIRUHVWVKHSRVHGZLWK
DQXQFRQVFLRXVSLFWXUHVTXHQHVVEL]DUUHDQGRXWRISODFH6KHVKRXOG
KDYHEHHQSRVHGDJDLQVWDEDFNJURXQGRIVHDFORXGVSDLQWHGPDVWV
DQGZKHHOLQJJXOOV7KHUHZDVWKHFRORURIWKHVHDLQKHUZLGHH\HV
$QGWKDWZDVDWLWVKRXOGKDYHEHHQEHFDXVHWKLVZDV9DOHULDRIWKH
5HG%URWKHUKRRGZKRVHGHHGVDUHFHOHEUDWHGLQVRQJDQGEDOODG
ZKHUHYHUVHDIDUHUVJDWKHU
6KHVWURYHWRSLHUFHWKHVXOOHQJUHHQURRIRIWKHDUFKHGEUDQFKHV
DQGVHHWKHVN\ZKLFKSUHVXPDEO\OD\DERYHLWEXWSUHVHQWO\JDYHLW
XSZLWKDPXWWHUHGRDWK
/HDYLQJKHUKRUVHWLHGVKHVWURGHRIIWRZDUGWKHHDVWJODQFLQJ
EDFNWRZDUGWKHSRROIURPWLPHWRWLPHLQRUGHUWRIL[KHUURXWHLQ
KHUPLQG7KHVLOHQFHRIWKHIRUHVWGHSUHVVHGKHU1RELUGVVDQJLQ
WKHORIW\ERXJKVQRUGLGDQ\UXVWOLQJLQWKHEXVKHVLQGLFDWHWKH
SUHVHQFHRIVPDOODQLPDOV)RUOHDJXHVVKHKDGWUDYHOHGLQDUHDOPRI
EURRGLQJVWLOOQHVVEURNHQRQO\E\WKHVRXQGVRIKHURZQIOLJKW
6KHKDGVODNHGKHUWKLUVWDWWKHSRROEXWQRZIHOWWKHJQDZLQJV
RIKXQJHUDQGEHJDQORRNLQJDERXWIRUVRPHRIWKHIUXLWRQZKLFKVKH
KDGVXVWDLQHGKHUVHOIVLQFHH[KDXVWLQJWKHIRRGRULJLQDOO\LQKHU
VDGGOHEDJV
$KHDGRIKHUSUHVHQWO\VKHVDZDQRXWFURSSLQJRIGDUNIOLQWOLNH
URFNWKDWVORSHGXSZDUGLQWRZKDWORRNHGOLNHDUXJJHGFUDJULVLQJ
DPRQJWKHWUHHV,WVVXPPLWZDVORVWWRYLHZDPLGVWDFORXGRI
HQFLUFOLQJOHDYHV3HUKDSVLWVSHDNURVHDERYHWKHWUHHWRSVDQGIURP
LWVKHFRXOGVHHZKDWOD\EH\RQGLILQGHHGDQ\WKLQJOD\EH\RQG
EXWPRUHRIWKLVDSSDUHQWO\LOOLPLWDEOHIRUHVWWKURXJKZKLFKVKHKDG
ULGGHQIRUVRPDQ\GD\V
$QDUURZULGJHIRUPHGDQDWXUDOUDPSWKDWOHGXSWKHVWHHSIDFHRI
WKHFUDJ$IWHUVKHKDGDVFHQGHGVRPHILIW\IHHWVKHFDPHWRWKH
EHOWRIOHDYHVWKDWVXUURXQGHGWKHURFN7KHWUXQNVRIWKHWUHHVGLG
QRWFURZGFORVHWRWKHFUDJEXWWKHHQGVRIWKHLUORZHUEUDQFKHV
H[WHQGHGDERXWLWYHLOLQJLWZLWKWKHLUIROLDJH6KHJURSHGRQLQ
OHDI\REVFXULW\QRWDEOHWRVHHHLWKHUDERYHRUEHORZKHUEXW
SUHVHQWO\VKHJOLPSVHGEOXHVN\DQGDPRPHQWODWHUFDPHRXWLQWKH
FOHDUKRWVXQOLJKWDQGVDZWKHIRUHVWURRIVWUHWFKLQJDZD\XQGHUKHU
IHHW
6KHZDVVWDQGLQJRQDEURDGVKHOIZKLFKZDVDERXWHYHQZLWKWKH
WUHHWRSVDQGIURPLWURVHDVSLUHOLNHMXWWKDWZDVWKHXOWLPDWHSHDN
RIWKHFUDJVKHKDGFOLPEHG%XWVRPHWKLQJHOVHFDXJKWKHUDWWHQWLRQ
DWWKHPRPHQW+HUIRRWKDGVWUXFNVRPHWKLQJLQWKHOLWWHURIEORZQ
GHDGOHDYHVZKLFKFDUSHWHGWKHVKHOI6KHNLFNHGWKHPDVLGHDQG
ORRNHGGRZQRQWKHVNHOHWRQRIDPDQ6KHUDQDQH[SHULHQFHGH\HRYHU
WKHEOHDFKHGIUDPHEXWVDZQREURNHQERQHVQRUDQ\VLJQRIYLROHQFH
7KHPDQPXVWKDYHGLHGDQDWXUDOGHDWKWKRXJKZK\KHVKRXOGKDYH
FOLPEHGDWDOOFUDJWRGLHVKHFRXOGQRWLPDJLQH
6KHVFUDPEOHGXSWRWKHVXPPLWRIWKHVSLUHDQGORRNHGWRZDUGWKH
KRUL]RQV7KHIRUHVWURRIZKLFKORRNHGOLNHDIORRUIURPKHU
YDQWDJHSRLQWZDVMXVWDVLPSHQHWUDEOHDVIURPEHORZ6KHFRXOG
QRWHYHQVHHWKHSRROE\ZKLFKVKHKDGOHIWKHUKRUVH6KHJODQFHG
QRUWKZDUGLQWKHGLUHFWLRQIURPZKLFKVKHKDGFRPH6KHVDZRQO\WKH
UROOLQJJUHHQRFHDQVWUHWFKLQJDZD\DQGDZD\ZLWKMXVWDYDJXHEOXH
OLQHLQWKHGLVWDQFHWRKLQWRIWKHKLOOUDQJHVKHKDGFURVVHGGD\V
EHIRUHWRSOXQJHLQWRWKLVOHDI\ZDVWH
:HVWDQGHDVWWKHYLHZZDVWKHVDPHWKRXJKWKHEOXHKLOOOLQHZDV
ODFNLQJLQWKRVHGLUHFWLRQV%XWZKHQVKHWXUQHGKHUH\HVVRXWKZDUG
VKHVWLIIHQHGDQGFDXJKWKHUEUHDWK$PLOHDZD\LQWKDWGLUHFWLRQ
WKHIRUHVWWKLQQHGRXWDQGFHDVHGDEUXSWO\JLYLQJZD\WRDFDFWXV
GRWWHGSODLQ$QGLQWKHPLGVWRIWKDWSODLQURVHWKHZDOOVDQG
WRZHUVRIDFLW\9DOHULDVZRUHLQDPD]HPHQW7KLVSDVVHGEHOLHI6KH
ZRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQVXUSULVHGWRVLJKWKXPDQKDELWDWLRQVRIDQRWKHU
VRUWWKHEHHKLYHVKDSHGKXWVRIWKHEODFNSHRSOHRUWKHFOLII
GZHOOLQJVRIWKHP\VWHULRXVEURZQUDFHZKLFKOHJHQGVGHFODUHG
LQKDELWHGVRPHFRXQWU\RIWKLVXQH[SORUHGUHJLRQ%XWLWZDVD
VWDUWOLQJH[SHULHQFHWRFRPHXSRQDZDOOHGFLW\KHUHVRPDQ\ORQJ
ZHHNV
PDUFKIURPWKHQHDUHVWRXWSRVWVRIDQ\VRUWRIFLYLOL]DWLRQ
+HUKDQGVWLULQJIURPFOLQJLQJWRWKHVSLUHOLNHSLQQDFOHVKHOHW
KHUVHOIGRZQRQWKHVKHOIIURZQLQJLQLQGHFLVLRQ6KHKDGFRPHIDU
IURPWKHFDPSRIWKHPHUFHQDULHVE\WKHERUGHUWRZQRI6XNKPHW
DPLGVWWKHOHYHOJUDVVODQGVZKHUHGHVSHUDWHDGYHQWXUHUVRIPDQ\
UDFHVJXDUGWKH6W\JLDQIURQWLHUDJDLQVWWKHUDLGVWKDWFRPHXSOLNH
DUHGZDYHIURP'DUIDU+HUIOLJKWKDGEHHQEOLQGLQWRDFRXQWU\RI
ZKLFKVKHZDVZKROO\LJQRUDQW$QGQRZVKHZDYHUHGEHWZHHQDQXUJHWR
ULGHGLUHFWO\WRWKDWFLW\LQWKHSODLQDQGWKHLQVWLQFWRIFDXWLRQ
ZKLFKSURPSHGKHUWRVNLUWLWZLGHO\DQGFRQWLQXHKHUVROLWDU\
IOLJKW
+HUWKRXJKWVZHUHVFDWWHUHGE\WKHUXVWOLQJRIWKHOHDYHVEHORZ
KHU6KHZKHHOHGFDWOLNHVQDWFKHGDWKHUVZRUGDQGWKHQVKHIUR]H
PRWLRQOHVVVWDULQJZLGHH\HGDWWKHPDQEHIRUHKHU
+HZDVDOPRVWDJLDQWLQVWDWXUHPXVFOHVULSSOLQJVPRRWKO\XQGHU
KLVVNLQZKLFKWKHVXQKDGEXUQHGEURZQ+LVJDUEZDVVLPLODUWR
KHUVH[FHSWWKDWKHZRUHDEURDGOHDWKHUEHOWLQVWHDGRIDJLUGOH
%URDGVZRUGDQGSRQLDUGKXQJIURPKLVEHOW
&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQHMDFXODWHGWKHZRPDQ:KDWDUHB\RXB
GRLQJRQP\WUDLO"
+HJULQQHGKDUGO\DQGKLVILHUFHEOXHH\HVEXUQHGZLWKDOLJKW
DQ\ZRPDQFRXOGXQGHUVWDQGDVWKH\UDQRYHUKHUPDJQLILFHQWILJXUH
OLQJHULQJRQWKHVZHOORIKHUVSOHQGLGEUHDVWVEHQHDWKWKHOLJKW
VKLUWDQGWKHFOHDUZKLWHIOHVKGLVSOD\HGEHWZHHQEUHHFKHVDQGERRW
WRSV
'RQ
W\RXNQRZ"KHODXJKHG+DYHQ
W,PDGHP\DGPLUDWLRQIRU
\RXSODLQHYHUVLQFH,ILUVWVDZ\RX"
$VWDOOLRQFRXOGKDYHPDGHLWQRSODLQHUVKHDQVZHUHG
GLVGDLQIXOO\%XW,QHYHUH[SHFWHGWRHQFRXQWHU\RXVRIDUIURPWKH
DOHEDUUHOVDQGPHDWSRWVRI6XNKPHW'LG\RXUHDOO\IROORZPHIURP
=DUDOOR
VFDPSRUZHUH\RXZKLSSHGIRUWKIRUDURJXH"
+HODXJKHGDWKHULQVROHQFHDQGIOH[HGKLVPLJKW\ELFHSV
<RXNQRZ=DUDOORGLGQ
WKDYHHQRXJKNQDYHVWRZKLSPHRXWRI
FDPSKHJULQQHG2IFRXUVH,IROORZHG\RX/XFN\WKLQJIRU\RX
WRRZHQFK:KHQ\RXNQLIHGWKDW6W\JLDQRIILFHU\RXIRUIHLWHG
=DUDOOR
VIDYRUDQGSURWHFWLRQDQG\RXRXWODZHG\RXUVHOIZLWKWKH
6W\JLDQV
,NQRZLWVKHUHSOLHGVXOOHQO\%XWZKDWHOVHFRXOG,GR"<RX
NQRZZKDWP\SURYRFDWLRQZDV
6XUHKHDJUHHG,I,
GEHHQWKHUH,
GKDYHNQLIHGKLPP\VHOI
%XWLIDZRPDQPXVWOLYHLQWKHZDUFDPSVRIPHQVKHFDQH[SHFWVXFK
WKLQJV
9DOHULDVWDPSHGKHUERRWHGIRRWDQGVZRUH
:K\ZRQ
WPHQOHWPHOLIHDPDQ
VOLIH"
7KDW
VREYLRXV$JDLQKLVHDJHUH\HVGHYRXUHGKHU%XW\RXZHUH
ZLVHWRUXQDZD\7KH6W\JLDQVZRXOGKDYHKDG\RXVNLQQHG7KDW
RIILFHU
VEURWKHUIROORZHG\RXIDVWHUWKDQ\RXWKRXJKW,GRQ
W
GRXEW+HZDVQ
WIDUEHKLQG\RXZKHQ,FDXJKWXSZLWKKLP+LVKRUVH
ZDVEHWWHUWKDQ\RXUV+H
GKDYHFDXJKW\RXDQGFXW\RXUWKURDW
ZLWKLQDIHZPRUHPLOHV
:HOO"VKHGHPDQGHG
:HOOZKDW"+HVHHPHGSX]]OHG
:KDWRIWKH6W\JLDQ"
:K\ZKDWGR\RXVXSSRVH"KHUHWXUQHGLPSDWLHQWO\,NLOOHG
KLPRIFRXUVHDQGOHIWKLVFDUFDVVIRUWKHYXOWXUHV7KDWGHOD\HG
PHWKRXJKDQG,DOPRVWORVW\RXUWUDLOZKHQ\RXFURVVHGWKHURFN\
VSXUVRIWKHKLOOV2WKHUZLVH,
GKDYHFDXJKWXSZLWK\RXORQJDJR
$QGQRZ\RXWKLQN\RX
OOGUDJPHEDFNWR=DUDOOR
VFDPS"VKH
VQHHUHG
'RQ
WWDONOLNHDIRROKHJUXQWHG&RPHJLUOGRQ
WEHVXFKD
VSLWILUH,
PQRWOLNHWKDW6W\JLDQ\RXNQLIHGDQG\RXNQRZLW
$SHQQLOHVVYDJDERQGVKHWDXQWHG
+HODXJKHGDWKHU
:KDWGR\RXFDOO\RXUVHOI"<RXKDYHQ
WHQRXJKPRQH\WREX\DQHZ
VHDWIRU\RXUEUHHFKHV<RXUGLVGDLQGRHVQ
WGHFHLYHPH<RXNQRZ
,
YHFRPPDQGHGELJJHUVKLSVDQGPRUHPHQWKDQ\RXHYHUGLGLQ\RXU
OLIH$VIRUEHLQJSHQQLOHVVZKDWURYHULVQ
WPRVWRIWKHWLPH"
,
YHVTXDQGHUHGHQRXJKJROGLQWKHVHDSRUWVRIWKHZRUOGWRILOOD
JDOHRQ<RXNQRZWKDWWRR
:KHUHDUHWKHILQHVKLSVDQGWKHEROGODGV\RXFRPPDQGHGQRZ"
VKHVQHHUHG
$WWKHERWWRPRIWKHVHDPRVWO\KHUHSOLHGFKHHUIXOO\7KH
=LQJDUDQVVDQNP\ODVWVKLSRIIWKH6KHPLWHVKRUHWKDW
VZK\,
MRLQHG=DUDOOR
V)UHH&RPSDQLRQV%XW,VDZ,
GEHHQVWXQJZKHQZH
PDUFKHGWRWKH'DUIDUERUGHU7KHSD\ZDVSRRUDQGWKHZLQHZDVVRXU
DQG,GRQ
WOLNHEODFNZRPHQ$QGWKDW
VWKHRQO\NLQGWKDWFDPHWR
RXUFDPSDW6XNKPHWULQJVLQWKHLUQRVHVDQGWKHLUWHHWKILOHG
EDK:K\GLG\RXMRLQ=DUDOOR"6XNKPHW
VDORQJZD\IURPVDOWZDWHU
5HG2UWKRZDQWHGWRPDNHPHKLVPLVWUHVVVKHDQVZHUHGVXOOHQO\
,MXPSHGRYHUERDUGRQHQLJKWDQGVZDPDVKRUHZKHQZHZHUHDQFKRUHG
RIIWKH.XVKLWHFRDVW2II=DEKHODLWZDV7KHUHZDVD6KHPLWH
WUDGHUWROGPHWKDW=DUDOORKDGEURXJKWKLV)UHH&RPSDQLHVVRXWKWR
JXDUGWKH'DUIDUERUGHU1REHWWHUHPSOR\PHQWRIIHUHG,MRLQHGDQ
HDVWERXQGFDUDYDQDQGHYHQWXDOO\FDPHWR6XNKPHW
,WZDVPDGQHVVWRSOXQJHVRXWKZDUGDV\RXGLGFRPPHQWHG&RQDQ
EXWLWZDVZLVHWRRIRU=DUDOOR
VSDWUROVQHYHUWKRXJKWWRORRN
IRU\RXLQWKLVGLUHFWLRQ2QO\WKHEURWKHURIWKHPDQ\RXNLOOHG
KDSSHQHGWRVWULNH\RXUWUDLO
$QGQRZZKDWGR\RXLQWHQGGRLQJ"VKHGHPDQGHG
7XUQZHVWKHDQVZHUHG,
YHEHHQWKLVIDUVRXWKEXWQRWWKLV
IDUHDVW0DQ\GD\V
WUDYHOLQJWRWKHZHVWZLOOEULQJXVWRWKHRSHQ
VDYDQQDVZKHUHWKHEODFNWULEHVJUD]HWKHLUFDWWOH,KDYHIULHQGV
DPRQJWKHP:H
OOJHWWRWKHFRDVWDQGILQGDVKLS,
PVLFNRIWKH
MXQJOH
7KHQEHRQ\RXUZD\VKHDGYLVHG,KDYHRWKHUSODQV
'RQ
WEHDIRRO+HVKRZHGLUUDWDWLRQIRUWKHILUVWWLPH<RX
FDQ
WNHHSRQZDQGHULQJWKURXJKWKLVIRUHVW
,FDQLI,FKRRVH
%XWZKDWGR\RXLQWHQGGRLQJ"
7KDW
VQRQHRI\RXUDIIDLUVKHVQDSSHG
<HVLWLVKHDQVZHUHGFDOPO\'R\RXWKLQN,
YHIROORZHG\RX
WKLVIDUWRWXUQDURXQGDQGULGHRIIHPSW\KDQGHG"%HVHQVLEOH
ZHQFK,
PQRWJRLQJWRKDUP\RX
+HVWHSSHGWRZDUGKHUDQGVKHVSUDQJEDFNZKLSSLQJRXWKHU
VZRUG
.HHSEDFN\RXEDUEDULDQGRJ,
OOVSLW\RXOLNHDURDVWSLJ
+HKDOWHGUHOXFWDQWO\DQGGHPDQGHG'R\RXZDQWPHWRWDNHWKDW
WR\DZD\IURP\RXDQGVSDQN\RXZLWKLW"
:RUGV1RWKLQJEXWZRUGVVKHPRFNHGOLJKWVOLNHWKHJOHDPRI
WKHVXQRQEOXHZDWHUGDQFLQJLQKHUUHFNOHVVH\HV
+HNQHZLWZDVWKHWUXWK1ROLYLQJPDQFRXOGGLVDUP9DOHULDRI
WKH%URWKHUKRRGZLWKKLVEDUHKDQGV+HVFRZOHGKLVVHQVDWLRQVD
WDQJOHRIFRQIOLFWLQJHPRWLRQV+HZDVDQJU\\HWKHZDVDPXVHGDQG
ILOOHGZLWKDGPLUDWLRQIRUKHUVSLULW+HEXUQHGZLWKHDJHUQHVVWR
VHL]HWKDWVSOHQGLGILJXUHDQGFUXVKLWLQKLVLURQDUPV\HWKH
JUHDWO\GHVLUHGQRWWRKXUWWKHJLUO+HZDVWRUQEHWZHHQDGHVLUHWR
VKDNHKHUVRXQGO\DQGDGHVLUHWRFDUHVVKHU+HNQHZLIKHFDPHDQ\
QHDUHUKHUVZRUGZRXOGEHVKHDWKHGLQKLVKHDUW+HKDGVHHQ9DOHULD
NLOOWRRPDQ\PHQLQERUGHUIRUD\VDQGWDYHUQEUDZOVWRKDYHDQ\
LOOXVLRQVDERXWKHU+HNQHZVKHZDVDVTXLFNDQGIHURFLRXVDVD
WLJUHVV+HFRXOGGUDZKLVEURDGVZRUGDQGGLVDUPKHUEHDWWKHEODGH
RXWRIKHUKDQGEXWWKHWKRXJKWRIGUDZLQJDVZRUGRQDZRPDQHYHQ
ZLWKRXWLQWHQWRILQMXU\ZDVH[WUHPHO\UHSXJQDQWWRKLP
%ODVW\RXUVRXO\RXKXVV\KHH[FODLPHGLQH[DVSHUDWLRQ,
P
JRLQJWRWDNHRII\RXU
+HVWDUWHGWRZDUGKHUKLVDQJU\SDVVLRQPDNLQJKLPUHFNOHVVDQG
VKHSRLVHGKHUVHOIIRUDGHDGO\WKUXVW7KHQFDPHDVWDUWOLQJ
LQWHUUXSWLRQWRDVFHQHDWRQFHOXGLFURXVDQGSHULORXV
B:KDW
VWKDW"B
,WZDV9DOHULDZKRH[FODLPHGEXWWKH\ERWKVWDUWHGYLROHQWO\DQG
&RQDQZKHHOHGOLNHDFDWKLVJUHDWVZRUGIODVKLQJLQWRKLVKDQG
%DFNLQWKHIRUHVWKDGEXUVWIRUWKDQDSSDOOLQJPHGO\RIVFUHDPV
WKHVFUHDPVRIKRUVHVLQWHUURUDQGDJRQ\0LQJOHGZLWKWKHLUVFUHDPV
WKHUHFDPHWKHVQDSRIVSOLQWHULQJERQHV
/LRQVDUHVOD\LQJWKHKRUVHVFULHG9DOHULD
/LRQVQRWKLQJVQRUWHG&RQDQKLVH\HVEOD]LQJ'LG\RXKHDUD
OLRQURDU"1HLWKHUGLG,/LVWHQWRWKRVHERQHVVQDSQRWHYHQD
OLRQFRXOGPDNHWKDWPXFKQRLVHNLOOLQJDKRUVH
+HKXUULHGGRZQWKHQDWXUDOUDPSDQGVKHIROORZHGWKHLUSHUVRQDO
IHXGIRUJRWWHQLQWKHDGYHQWXUHUV
LQVWLQFWWRXQLWHDJDLQVWFRPPRQ
SHULO7KHVFUHDPVKDGFHDVHGZKHQWKH\ZRUNHGWKHLUZD\GRZQZDUG
WKURXJKWKHJUHHQYHLORIOHDYHVWKDWEUXVKHGWKHURFN
,IRXQG\RXUKRUVHWLHGE\WKHSRROEDFNWKHUHKHPXWWHUHG
WUHDGLQJVRQRLVHOHVVO\WKDWVKHQRORQJHUZRQGHUHGKRZKHKDG
VXUSULVHGKHURQWKHFUDJ,WLHGPLQHEHVLGHLWDQGIROORZHGWKH
WUDFNVRI\RXUERRWV:DWFKQRZ
7KH\KDGHPHUJHGIURPWKHEHOWRIOHDYHVDQGVWDUHGGRZQLQWRWKH
ORZHUUHDFKHVRIWKHIRUHVW$ERYHWKHPWKHJUHHQURRIVSUHDGLWV
GXVN\FDQRS\%HORZWKHPWKHVXQOLJKWILOWHUHGLQMXVWHQRXJKWRPDNH
DMDGHWLQWHGWZLOLJKW7KHJLDQWWUXQNVRIWUHHVOHVVWKDQDKXQGUHG
\DUGVDZD\ORRNHGGLPDQGJKRVWO\
7KHKRUVHVVKRXOGEHEH\RQGWKDWWKLFNHWRYHUWKHUHZKLVSHUHG
&RQDQDQGKLVYRLFHPLJKWKDYHEHHQDEUHH]HPRYLQJWKURXJKWKH
EUDQFKHV/LVWHQ
9DOHULDKDGDOUHDG\KHDUGDQGDFKLOOFUHSWWKURXJKKHUYHLQVVR
VKHXQFRQVFLRXVO\ODLGKHUZKLWHKDQGRQKHUFRPSDQLRQ
VPXVFXODU
EURZQDUP)URPEH\RQGWKHWKLFNHWFDPHWKHQRLV\FUXQFKLQJRIERQHV
DQGWKHORXGUHQGLQJRIIOHVKWRJHWKHUZLWKWKHJULQGLQJVOREEHULQJ
VRXQGVRIDKRUULEOHIHDVW
/LRQVZRXOGQ
WPDNHWKDWQRLVHZKLVSHUHG&RQDQ6RPHWKLQJ
V
HDWLQJRXUKRUVHVEXWLW
VQRWDOLRQ&URP
7KHQRLVHVWRSSHGVXGGHQO\DQG&RQDQVZRUHVRIWO\$VXGGHQO\
ULVHQEUHH]HZDVEORZLQJIURPWKHPGLUHFWO\WRZDUGWKHVSRWZKHUHWKH
XQVHHQVOD\HUZDVKLGGHQ
+HUHLWFRPHVPXWWHUHG&RQDQKDOIOLIWLQJKLVVZRUG
7KHWKLFNHWZDVYLROHQWO\DJLWDWHGDQG9DOHULDFOXWFKHG&RQDQ
V
DUPKDUG,JQRUDQWRIMXQJOHORUHVKH\HWNQHZWKDWQRDQLPDOVKH
KDGHYHUVHHQFRXOGKDYHVKDNHQWKHWDOOEUXVKOLNHWKDW
,WPXVWEHDVELJDVDQHOHSKDQWPXWWHUHG&RQDQHFKRLQJKHU
WKRXJKW:KDWWKHGHYLO+LVYRLFHWUDLOHGDZD\LQVWXQQHG
VLOHQFH
7KURXJKWKHWKLFNHWZDVWKUXVWDKHDGRIQLJKWPDUHDQGOXQDF\
*ULQQLQJMDZVEDUHGURZVRIGULSSQLJ\HOORZWXVNVDERYHWKH\DZQLQJ
PRXWKZULQNOHGDVDXULDQOLNHVQRXW+XJHH\HVOLNHWKRVHRID
S\WKRQDWKRXVDQGWLPHVPDJQLILHGVWDUHGXQZLQNLQJO\DWWKH
SHWULILHGKXPDQVFOLQJLQJWRWKHURFNDERYHLW%ORRGVPHDUHGWKH
VFDO\IODEE\OLSVDQGGULSSHGIURPWKHKXJHPRXWK
7KHKHDGELJJHUWKDQWKDWRIDFURFRGLOHZDVIXUWKHUH[WHQGHGRQ
DORQJVFDOHGQHFNRQZKLFKVWRRGXSURZVRIVHUUDWHGVSLNHVDQG
DIWHULWFUXVKLQJGRZQWKHEULDUVDQGVDSOLQJVZDGGOHGWKHERG\RI
DWLWDQDJLJDQWLFEDUUHOEHOOLHGWRUVRRQDEVXUGO\VKRUWOHJV7KH
ZKLWLVKEHOO\DOPRVWUDNHGWKHJURXQGZKLOHWKHVHUUDWHGEDFNERQH
URVHKLJKHUWKDQ&RQDQFRXOGKDYHUHDFKHGRQWLSWRH$ORQJVSLNHG
WDLOOLNHWKDWRIDJDUJDQWXDQVFRUSLRQWUDLOHGRXWEHKLQG
%DFNXSWKHFUDJTXLFNVQDSSHG&RQDQWKUXVWLQJWKHJLUO
EHKLQGKLP,GRQ
WWKLQNKHFDQFOLPEEXWKHFDQVWDQGRQKLVKLQG
OHJVDQGUHDFKXV
:LWKDVQDSSLQJDQGUHQGLQJRIEXVKHVDQGVDSOLQJVWKHPRQVWHU
FDPHKXUWOLQJWKURXJKWKHWKLFNHWVDQGWKH\IOHGXSWKHURFNEHIRUH
KLPOLNHOHDYHVEORZQEHIRUHDZLQG$V9DOHULDSOXQJHGLQWRWKH
OHDI\VFUHHQDEDFNZDUGJODQFHVKRZHGKHUWKHWLWDQUHDULQJXS
IHDUVRPHO\RQKLVPDVVLYHKLQGOHJVHYHQDV&RQDQKDGSUHGLFWHG7KH
VLJKWVHQWSDQLFUDFLQJWKURXJKKHU$VKHUHDUHGWKHEHDVWVHHPHG
PRUHJLJDQWLFWKDQHYHUKLVVQRXWHGKHDGWRZHUHGDPRQJWKHWUHHV
7KHQ&RQDQ
VLURQKDQGFORVHGRQKHUZULVWDQGVKHZDVMHUNHG
KHDGORQJLQWRWKHEOLQGLQJZHOWHURIWKHOHDYHVDQGRXWDJDLQLQWR
WKHKRWVXQVKLQHDERYHMXVWDVWKHPRQVWHUIHOOIRUZDUGZLWKKLV
IURQWIHHWRQWKHFUDJZLWKDQLPSDFWWKDWPDGHWKHURFNYLEUDWH
%HKLQGWKHIXJLWLYHVWKHKXJHKHDGFUDVKHGWKURXJKWKHWZLJVDQG
WKH\ORRNHGGRZQIRUDKRUULI\LQJLQVWDQWDWWKHQLJKWPDUHYLVDJH
IUDPHGDPRQJWKHJUHHQOHDYHVH\HVIODPLQJMDZVJDSLQJ7KHQWKH
JLDQWWXVNVFODVKHGWRJHWKHUIXWLOHO\DQGDIWHUWKDWWKHKHDGZDV
ZLWKGUDZQYDQLVKLQJIURPWKHLUVLJKWDVLILWKDGVXQNLQDSRRO
3HHULQJGRZQWKURXJKEURNHQEUDQFKHVWKDWVFUDSHGWKHURFNWKH\
VDZLWVTXDWWLQJRQLWVKDXQFKHVDWWKHIRRWRIWKHFUDJVWDULQJ
XQEOLQNLQJO\XSDWWKHP
9DOHULDVKXGGHUHG
+RZORQJGR\RXVXSSRVHKH
OOFURXFKWKHUH"
&RQDQNLFNHGWKHVNXOORQWKHOHDIVWUHZQVKHOI
7KDWIHOORZPXVWKDYHFOLPEHGXSKHUHWRHVFDSHKLPRURQHOLNH
KLP+HPXVWKDYHGLHGRIVWDUYDWLRQ7KHUHDUHQRERQHVEURNHQ7KDW
WKLQJPXVWEHDGUDJRQVXFKDVWKHEODFNSHRSOHVSHDNRILQWKHLU
OHJHQGV,IVRLWZRQ
WOHDYHKHUHXQWLOZH
UHERWKGHDG
9DOHULDORRNHGDWKLPEODQNO\KHUUHVHQWPHQWIRUJRWWHQ6KH
IRXJKWGRZQDVXUJLQJRISDQLF6KHKDGSURYHGKHUUHFNOHVVFRXUDJHD
WKRXVDQGWLPHVLQZLOGEDWWOHVRQVHDDQGODQGRQWKHEORRGVOLSSHU\
GHFNVRIEXUQLQJZDUVKLSVLQWKHVWRUPLQJRIZDOOHGFLWLHVDQGRQ
WKHWUDPSOHGVDQG\EHDFKHVZKHUHWKHGHVSHUDWHPHQRIWKH5HG
%URWKHUKRRGEDWKHGWKHLUNQLYHVLQRQHDQRWKHU
VEORRGLQWKHLU
ILJKWVIRUOHDGHUVKLS%XWWKHSURVSHFWQRZFRQIURQWLQJKHUFRQJHDOHG
KHUEORRG$FXWODVVVWURNHLQWKHKHDWRIEDWWOHZDVQRWKLQJEXWWR
VLWLGOHDQGKHOSOHVVRQDEDUHURFNXQWLOVKHSHULVKHGRI
VWDUYDWLRQEHVLHJHGE\DPRQVWURXVVXUYLYDORIDQHOGHUDJHWKH
WKRXJKWVHQWSDQLFWKUREELQJWKURXJKKHUEUDLQ
+HPXVWOHDYHWRHDWDQGGULQNVKHVDLGKHOSOHVVO\
+HZRQ
WKDYHWRJRIDUWRGRHLWKHU&RQDQSRLQWHGRXW+H
V
MXVWJRUJHGRQKRUVHPHDWDQGOLNHDUHDOVQDNHKHFDQJRIRUD
ORQJWLPHZLWKRXWHDWLQJRUGULQNLQJDJDLQ%XWKHGRHVQ
WVOHHS
DIWHUHDWLQJOLNHDUHDOVQDNHLWVHHPV$Q\ZD\KHFDQ
WFOLPE
WKLVFUDJ
&RQDQVSRNHLPSHUWXUEDEO\+HZDVDEDUEDULDQDQGWKHWHUULEOH
SDWLHQFHRIWKHZLOGHUQHVVDQGLWVFKLOGUHQZDVDVPXFKDSDUWRIKLP
DVKLVOXVWVDQGUDJHV+HFRXOGHQGXUHDVLWXDWLRQOLNHWKLVZLWKD
FRROQHVVLPSRVVLEOHWRDFLYLOL]HGSHUVRQ
&DQ
WZHJHWLQWRWKHWUHHVDQGJHWDZD\WUDYHOLQJOLNHDSHV
WKURXJKWKHEUDQFKHV"VKHDVNHGGHVSHUDWHO\
+HVKRRNKLVKHDG,WKRXJKWRIWKDW7KHEUDQFKHVWKDWWRXFKWKH
FUDJGRZQWKHUHDUHWRROLJKW7KH\
GEUHDNZLWKRXUZHLJKW%HVLGHV
,KDYHDQLGHDWKDWGHYLOFRXOGWHDUXSDQ\WUHHDURXQGKHUHE\LWV
URRWV
:HOODUHZHJRLQJWRVLWKHUHRQRXUUXPSVXQWLOZHVWDUYHOLNH
WKDW"VKHFULHGIXULRXVO\NLFNLQJWKHVNXOOFODWWHULQJDFURVVWKH
OHGJH,ZRQ
WGRLW,
OOJRGRZQWKHUHDQGFXWKLVGDPQHGKHDG
RII
&RQDQKDGVHDWHGKLPVHOIRQDURFN\SURMHFWLRQDWWKHIRRWRIWKH
VSLUH+HORRNHGXSZLWKDJOLQWRIDGPLUDWLRQDWKHUEOD]LQJH\HV
DQGWHQVHTXLYHULQJILJXUHEXWUHDOL]LQJWKDWVKHZDVLQMXVWWKH
PRRGIRUDQ\PDGQHVVKHOHWQRQHRIKLVDGPLUDWLRQVRXQGLQKLV
YRLFH
6LWGRZQKHJUXQWHGFDWFKLQJKHUE\KHUZULVWDQGSXOOLQJKHU
GRZQRQKLVNQHH6KHZDVWRRVXUSULVHGWRUHVLVWDVKHWRRNKHU
VZRUGIURPKHUKDQGDQGVKRYHGLWEDFNLQLWVVKHDWK6LWVWLOODQG
FDOPGRZQ<RX
GRQO\EUHDN\RXUVWHHORQKLVVFDOHV+H
GJREEOH\RX
XSDWRQHJXOSRUVPDVK\RXOLNHDQHJJZLWKWKDWVSLNHGWDLORI
KLV:H
OOJHWRXWRIWKLVMDPVRPHZD\EXWZHVKDQ
WGRLWE\
JHWWLQJFKHZHGXSDQGVZDOORZHG
6KHPDGHQRUHSO\QRUGLGVKHVHHNWRUHSXOVHKLVDUPIURPDERXW
KHUZDLVW6KHZDVIULJKWHQHGDQGWKHVHQVDWLRQZDVQHZWR9DOHULD
RIWKH5HG%URWKHUKRRG6RVKHVDWRQKHUFRPSDQLRQ
VRUFDSWRU
V
NQHHZLWKDGRFLOLW\WKDWZRXOGKDYHDPD]HG=DUDOORZKRKDG
DQDWKHPDWL]HGKHUDVDVKHGHYLORXWRI+HOO
VVHUDJOLR
&RQDQSOD\HGLGO\ZLWKKHUFXUO\\HOORZORFNVVHHPLQJO\LQWHQW
RQO\XSRQKLVFRQTXHVW1HLWKHUWKHVNHOHWRQDWKLVIHHWQRUWKH
PRQVWHUFURXFKLQJEHORZGLVWXUEHGKLVPLQGRUGXOOHGWKHHGJHRIKLV
LQWHUHVW
7KHJLUO
VUHVWOHVVH\HVURYLQJWKHOHDYHVEHORZWKHPGLVFRYHUHG
VSODVKHVRIFRORUDPRQJWKHJUHHQ,WZDVIUXLWODUJHGDUNO\
FULPVRQJOREHVVXVSHQGHGIURPWKHERXJKVRIDWUHHZKRVHEURDGOHDYHV
ZHUHDSHFXOLDUO\ULFKDQGYLYLGJUHHQ6KHEHFDPHDZDUHRIERWK
WKLUVWDQGKXQJHUWKRXJKWKLUVWKDGQRWDVVDLOHGKHUXQWLOVKHNQHZ
VKHFRXOGQRWGHVFHQGIURPWKHFUDJWRILQGIRRGDQGZDWHU
:HQHHGQRWVWDUYHVKHVDLG7KHUHLVIUXLWZHFDQUHDFK
&RQDQJODQFHGZKHUHVKHSRLQWHG
,IZHDWHWKDWZHZRXOGQ
WQHHGWKHELWHRIDGUDJRQKH
JUXQWHG7KDW
VZKDWWKHEODFNSHRSOHRI.XVKFDOOWKH$SSOHVRI
'HUNHWD'HUNHWDLVWKH4XHHQRIWKH'HDG'ULQNDOLWWOHRIWKDW
MXLFHRUVSLOOLWRQ\RXUIOHVKDQG\RX
GEHGHDGEHIRUH\RXFRXOG
WXPEOHWRWKHIRRWRIWKLVFUDJ
2K
6KHODSVHGLQWRGLVPD\HGVOLHQFH7KHUHVHHPHGQRZD\RXWRIWKHLU
SUHGLFDPHQWVKHUHIOHFHGJORRPLO\6KHVDZQRZD\RIHVFDSHDQG
&RQDQVHHPHGWREHFRQFHUQHGRQO\ZLWKKHUVXSSOHZDLVWDQGFXUO\
WUHVVHV,IKHZDVWU\LQJWRIRUPXODWHDSODQRIHVFDSHKHGLGQRW
VKRZLW
,I\RX
OOWDNH\RXUKDQGVRIIPHORQJHQRXJKWRFOLPEXSRQWKDW
SHDNVKHVDLGSUHVHQWO\\RX
OOVHHVRPHWKLQJWKDWZLOOVXUSULVH
\RX
+HFDVWKHUDTXHVWLRQLQJJODQFHWKHQREH\HGZLWKDVKUXJRIKLV
PDVVLYHVKRXOGHUV&OLQJLQJWRWKHVSLUHOLNHSLQQDFOHKHVWDUHGRXW
RYHUWKHIRUHVWURRI
+HVWRRGDORQJPRPHQWLQVLOHQFHSRVHGOLNHDEURQ]HVWDWXHRQ
WKHURFN
,W
VDZDOOHGFLW\ULJKWHQRXJKKHPXWWHUHGSUHVHQWO\:DV
WKDWZKHUH\RXZHUHJRLQJZKHQ\RXWULHGWRVHQGPHRIIDORQHWRWKH
FRDVW"
,VDZLWEHIRUH\RXFDPH,NQHZQRWKLQJRILWZKHQ,OHIW
6XNKPHW
:KR
GKDYHWKRXJKWWRILQGDFLW\KHUH",GRQ
WEHOLHYHWKH
6W\JLDQVHYHUSHQHWUDWHGWKLVIDU&RXOGEODFNSHRSOHEXLOGDFLW\
OLNHWKDW",VHHQRKHUGVRQWKHSODLQQRVLJQVRIFXOWLYDWLRQRU
SHRSOHPRYLQJDERXW
+RZFDQ\RXKRSHWRVHHDOOWKDWDWWKLVGLVWDQFH"VKH
GHPDQGHG
+HVKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGGURSSHGGRZQRQWKHVKHOI
:HOOWKHIRONRIWKHFLW\FDQ
WKHOSXVMXVWQRZ$QGWKH\PLJKW
QRWLIWKH\FRXOG7KHSHRSOHRIWKH%ODFN&RXQWULHVDUHJHQHUDOO\
KRVWLOHWRVWUDQJHUV3UREDEO\VWLFNXVIXOORIVSHDUV
+HVWRSSHGVKRUWDQGVWRRGVLOHQWDVLIKHKDGIRUJRWWHQZKDWKH
ZDVVD\LQJIURZLQLQJGRZQDWWKHFULPVRQVSKHUHVJOHDPLQJDPRQJWKH
OHDYHV
6SHDUVKHPXWWHUHG:KDWDEODVWHGIRRO,DPQRWWRKDYH
WKRXJKWRIWKDWEHIRUH7KDWVKRZVZKDWDSUHWW\ZRPDQGRHVWRD
PDQ
VPLQG
:KDWDUH\RXWDONLQJDERXW"VKHLQTXLUHG
:LWKRXWDQVZHULQJKHUTXHVWLRQKHGHVFHQGHGWRWKHEHOWRIOHDYHV
DQGORRNHGGRZQWKURXJKWKHP7KHJUHDWEUXWHVTXDWWHGEHORZ
ZDWFKLQJWKHFUDJZLWKWKHIULJKWIXOSDWLHQFHRIWKHUHSWLOHIRON6R
PLJKWRQHRIKLVEUHHGKDYHJODUHGXSDWWKHLUWURJORG\WHDQFHVWRUV
WUHHGRQDKLJKIOXQJURFNLQWKHGLPGDZQDJHV&RQDQFXUVHGKLP
ZLWKRXWKHDWDQGEHJDQFXWWLQJEUDQFKHVUHDFKLQJRXWDQGVHYHULQJ
WKHPDVIDUIURPWKHHQGDVKHFRXOGUHDFK7KHDJLWDWLRQRIWKH
OHDYHVPDGHWKHPRQVWHUUHVWOHVV+HURVHIURPKLVKDXQFKHVDQG
ODVKHGKLVKLGHRXVWDLOVQDSSLQJRIIVDSOLQJVDVLIWKH\KDGEHHQ
WRRWKSLFNV&RQDQZDWFKHGKLPZDULO\IURPWKHFRUQHURIKLVH\HDQG
MXVWDV9DOHULDEHOLHYHGWKHGUDJRQZDVDERXWWRKXUOKLPVHOIXSWKH
FUDJDJDLQWKH&LPPHULDQGUHZEDFNDQGFOLPEHGXSWRWKHOHGJHZLWK
WKHEUDQFKHVKHKDGFXW7KHUHZHUHWKUHHRIWKHVHVOHQGHUVKDIWV
DERXWVHYHQIHHWORQJEXWQRWODUJHUWKDQKLVWKXPE+HKDGDOVRFXW
VHYHUDOVWUDQGVRIWRXJKWKLQYLQH
%UDQFKHVWRROLJKWIRUVSHDUKDIWVDQGFUHHSHUVQRWKLFNHUWKDQ
FRUGVKHUHPDUNHGLQGLFDWLQJWKHIROLDJHDERXWWKHFUDJ,WZRQ
W
KROGRXUZHLJKWEXWWKHUH
VVWUHQJWKLQXQLRQ7KDW
VZKDWWKH
$TXLORQLDQUHQHJDGHVXVHGWRWHOOXV&LPPHULDQVZKHQWKH\FDPHLQWR
WKHKLOOVWRUDLVHDQDUP\WRLQYDGHWKHLURZQFRXQWU\%XWZHDOZD\V
ILJKWE\FODQVDQGWULEHV
:KDWWKHGHYLOKDVWKDWJRWWRGRZLWKWKRVHVWLFNV"VKH
GHPDQGHG
<RXZDLWDQGVHH
*DWKHULQJWKHVWLFNVLQDFRPSDFWEXQGOHKHZHGJHGKLVSRQLDUG
KLOWEHWZHHQWKHPDWRQHHQG7KHQZLWKWKHYLQHVKHERXQGWKHP
WRJHWKHUDQGZKHQKHKDGFRPSOHWHGKLVWDVNKHKDGDVSHDURIQR
VPDOOVWUHQJWKZLWKDVWXUG\VKDIWVHYHQIHHWLQOHQJWK
:KDWJRRGZLOOWKDWGR"VKHGHPDQGHG<RXWROGPHWKDWDEODGH
FRXOGQ
WSLHUFHKLVVFDOHV
+HKDVQ
WJRWVFDOHVDOORYHUKLPDQVZHUHG&RQDQ7KHUH
VPRUH
WKDQRQHZD\RIVNLQQLQJDSDQWKHU
0RYLQJGRZQWRWKHHGJHRIWKHOHDYHVKHUHDFKHGWKHVSHDUXSDQG
FDUHIXOO\WKUXVWWKHEODGHWKURXJKRQHRIWKH$SSOHVRI'HUNHWD
GUDZLQJDVLGHWRDYRLGWKHGDUNO\SXUSOHGURSVWKDWGULSSHGIURPWKH
SLHUFHGIUXLW3UHVHQWO\KHZLWKGUHZWKHEODGHDQGVKRZHGKHUWKH
EOXHVWHHOVWDLQHGDGXOOSXUSOLVKFULPVRQ
,GRQ
WNQRZZKHWKHULWZLOOGRWKHMRERUQRWTXRWKKH
7KHUH
VHQRXJKSRLVRQWKHUHWRNLOODQHOHSKDQWEXWZHOOZH
OO
VHH
9DOHULDZDVFORVHEHKLQGKLPDVKHOHWKLPVHOIGRZQDPRQJWKH
OHDYHV&DXWLRXVO\KROGLQJWKHSRLVRQHGSLNHDZD\IURPKLPKHWKUXVW
KLVKHDGWKURXJKWKHEUDQFKHVDQGDGGUHVVHGWKHPRQVWHU
:KDWDUH\RXZDLWLQJGRZQWKHUHIRU\RXPLVEHJRWWHQRIIVSULQJRI
TXHVWLRQDEOHSDUHQWV"ZDVRQHRIKLVPRUHSULQWDEOHTXHULHV6WLFN
\RXUXJO\KHDGXSKHUHDJDLQ\RXORQJQHFNHGEUXWHRUGR\RXZDQW
PHWRFRPHGRZQWKHUHDQGNLFN\RXORRVHIURP\RXULOOHJLWLPDWH
VSLQH"
7KHUHZDVPRUHRILWVRPHRILWFURXFKHGLQHORTXHQFHWKDWPDGH
9DOHULDVWDUHLQVSLWHRIKHUSURIDQHHGXFDWLRQDPRQJWKHVHDIDUHUV
$QGLWKDGLWVHIIHFWRQWKHPRQVWHU-XVWDVWKHLQFHVVDQW\DSSLQJ
RIDGRJZRUULHVDQGHQUDJHVPRUHFRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\VLOHQWDQLPDOVVR
WKHFODPRURXVYRLFHRIDPDQURXVHVIHDULQVRPHEHVWLDOERVRPVDQG
LQVDQHUDJHLQRWKHUV6XGGHQO\DQGZLWKDSSDOOLQJTXLFNQHVVWKH
PDVWRGRQLFEUXWHUHDUHGXSRQLWVPLJKW\KLQGOHJVDQGHORQJDWHGLWV
QHFNDQGERG\LQDIXULRXVHIIRUWWRUHDFKWKLVYRFLIHURXVSLJP\
ZKRVHFODPRUZDVGLVWXUELQJWKHSULPHYDOVLOHQFHRILWVDQFLHQW
UHDOP
%XW&RQDQKDGMXGJHGKLVGLVWDQFHZLWKSUHFLVLRQ6RPHILYHIHHW
EHORZKLPWKHPLJKW\KHDGFUDVKHGWHUULEO\EXWIXWLOHO\WKURXJKWKH
OHDYHV$QGDVWKHPRQVWURXVPRXWKJDSHGOLNHWKDWRIDJUHDWVQDNH
&RQDQGURYHKLVVSHDULQWRWKHUHGDQJOHRIWKHMDZERQHKLQJH+H
VWUXFNGRZQZDUGZLWKDOOWKHVWUHQJWKRIERWKDUPVGULYLQJWKHORQJ
SRQLDUGEODGHWRWKHKLOWLQIOHVKVLQHZDQGERQH
,QVWDQWO\WKHMDZVFODVKHGFRQYXOVLYHO\WRJHWKHUVHYHULQJWKH
WULSOHSLHFHGVKDIWDQGDOPRVWSHUFLSLWDWLQJ&RQDQIURPKLVSHUFK+H
ZRXOGKDYHIDOOHQEXWIRUWKHJLUOEHKLQGKLPZKRFDXJKWKLVVZRUG
EHOWLQDGHVSHUDWHJUDVS+HFOXWFKHGDWDURFN\SURMHFWLRQDQG
JULQQHGKLVWKDQNVEDFNDWKHU
'RZQRQWKHJURXQGWKHPRQVWHUZDVZDOORZLQJOLNHDGRJZLWK
SHSSHULQLWVH\HV+HVKRRNKLVKHDGIURPVLGHWRVLGHSDZHGDWLW
DQGRSHQHGKLVPRXWKUHSHDWHGO\WRLWVZLGHVWH[WHQW3UHVHQWO\KH
JRWDKXJHIURQWIRRWRQWKHVWXPSRIWKHVKDIWDQGPDQDJHGWRWHDU
WKHEODGHRXW7KHQKHWKUHZXSKLVKHDGMDZVZLGHDQGVSRXWLQJ
EORRGDQGJODUHGXSDWWKHFUDJZLWKVXFKFRQFHQWUDWHGDQG
LQWHOOLJHQWIXU\WKDW9DOHULDWUHPEOHGDQGGUHZKHUVZRUG7KHVFDOHV
DORQJKLVEDFNDQGIODQNVWXUQHGIURPUXVW\EURZQWRDGXOOOXULG
UHG0RVWKRUULEO\WKHPRQVWHU
VVLOHQFHZDVEURNHQ7KHVRXQGVWKDW
LVVXHGIURPKLVEORRGVWUHDPLQJMDZVGLGQRWVRXQGOLNHDQ\WKLQJWKDW
FRXOGKDYHEHHQSURGXFHGE\DQHDUWKO\FUHDWLRQ
:LWKKDUVKJUDWLQJURDUVWKHGUDJRQKXUOHGKLPVHOIDWWKHFUDJ
WKDWZDVWKHFLWDGHORIKLVHQHPLHV$JDLQDQGDJDLQKLVPLJKW\KHDG
FUDVKHGXSZDUGWKURXJKWKHEUDQFKHVVQDSSLQJYDLQO\RQHPSW\DLU+H
KXUOHGKLVIXOOSRQGHURXVZHLJKWDJDLQVWWKHURFNXQWLOLWYLEUDWHG
IURPEDVHWRFUHVW$QGUHDULQJXSULJKWKHJULSSHGLWZLWKKLVIURQW
OHJVOLNHDPDQDQGWULHGWRWHDULWXSE\WKHURRWVDVLILWKDG
EHHQDWUHH
7KLVH[KLELWLRQRISULPRUGLDOIXU\FKLOOHGWKHEORRGLQ9DOHULD
V
YHLQVEXW&RQDQZDVWRRFORVHWRWKHSULPLWLYHKLPVHOIWRIHHO
DQ\WKLQJEXWDFRPSUHKHQGLQJLQWHUHVW7RWKHEDUEDULDQQRVXFKJXOI
H[LVWHGEHWZHHQKLPVHOIDQGRWKHUPHQDQGWKHDQLPDOVDVH[LVWHGLQ
WKHFRQFHSWLRQRI9DOHULD7KHPRQVWHUEHORZWKHPWR&RQDQZDV
PHUHO\DIRUPRIOLIHGLIIHULQJIURPKLPVHOIPDLQO\LQSK\VLFDO
VKDSH+HDWWULEXWHGWRLWFKDUDFWHULVWLFVVLPLODUWRKLVRZQDQG
VDZLQLWVZUDWKDFRXQWHUSDUWRIKLVUDJHVLQLWVURDUVDQG
EHOORZLQJVPHUHO\UHSWLOLDQHTXLYDOHQWVWRWKHFXUVHVKHKDGEHVWRZHG
XSRQLW)HHOLQJDNLQVKLSZLWKDOOZLOGWKLQJVHYHQGUDJRQVLWZDV
LPSRVVLEOHIRUKLPWRH[SHULHQFHWKHVLFNKRUURUZKLFKDVVDLOHG
9DOHULDDWWKHVLJKWRIWKHEUXWH
VIHURFLW\
+HVDWZDWFKLQJLWWUDQTXLOO\DQGSRLQWHGRXWWKHYDULRXVFKDQJHV
WKDWZHUHWDNLQJSODFHLQLWVYRLFHDQGDFWLRQV
7KHSRLVRQ
VWDNLQJKROGKHVDLGZLWKFRQYLFWLRQ
,GRQ
WEHOLHYHLW7R9DOHULDLWVHHPHGSUHSRVWHURXVWRVXSSRVH
WKDWDQ\WKLQJKRZHYHUOHWKDOFRXOGKDYHDQ\HIIHFWRQWKDWPRXQWDLQ
RIPXVFOHDQGIXU\
7KHUH
VSDLQLQKLVYRLFHGHFODUHG&RQDQ)LUVWKHZDVPHUHO\
DQJU\EHFDXVHRIWKHVWLQJLQJLQKLVMDZ1RZKHIHHOVWKHELWHRI
WKHSRLVRQ/RRN+H
VVWDJJHULQJ+H
OOEHEOLQGLQDIHZPRUH
PLQXWHV:KDWGLG,WHOO\RX"
)RUVXGGHQO\WKHGUDJRQKDGOXUFKHGDERXWDQGZHQWFUDVKLQJRII
WKURXJKWKHEXVKHV
,VKHUXQQLQJDZD\"LQTXLUHG9DOHULDXQHDVLO\
+H
VPDNLQJIRUWKHSRRO&RQDQVSUDQJXSJDOYDQL]HGLQWRVZLIW
DFWLYLW\7KHSRLVRQPDNHVKLPWKLUVW\&RPHRQ+H
OOEHEOLQGLQD
IHZPRPHQWVEXWKHFDQVPHOOKLVZD\EDFNWRWKHIRRWRIWKHFUDJ
DQGLIRXUVFHQW
VKHUHVWLOOKH
OOVLWWKHUHXQWLOKHGLHV$QG
RWKHUVRIKLVNLQGPD\FRPHDWKLVFULHV/HW
VJR
'RZQWKHUH"9DOHULDZDVDJKDVW
6XUH:H
OOPDNHIRUWKHFLW\7KH\PD\FXWRXUKHDGVRIIWKHUH
EXWLW
VRXURQO\FKDQFH:HPD\UXQLQWRDWKRXVDQGPRUHGUDJRQVRQ
WKHZD\EXWLW
VVXUHGHDWKWRVWD\KHUH,IZHZDLWXQWLOKHGLHV
ZHPD\KDYHDGR]HQPRUHWRGHDOZLWK$IWHUPHLQDKXUU\
+HZHQWGRZQWKHUDPSDVVZLIWO\DVDQDSHSDXVLQJRQO\WRDLG
KLVOHVVDJLOHFRPSDQLRQZKRXQWLOVKHVDZWKH&LPPHULDQFOLPEKDG
IDQFLHGKHUVHOIWKHHTXDORIDQ\PDQLQWKHULJJLQJRIDVKLSRURQ
WKHVKHHUIDFHRIDFOLII
7KH\GHVFHQGHGLQWRWKHJORRPEHORZWKHEUDQFKHVDQGVOLGWRWKH
JURXQGVLOHQWO\WKRXJK9DOHULDIHOWDVLIWKHSRXQGLQJRIKHUKHDUW
PXVWVXUHO\EHKHDUGIURPIDUDZD\$QRLV\JXUJOLQJDQGODSSLQJ
EH\RQGWKHGHQVHWKLFNHWLQGLFDWHGWKDWWKHGUDJRQZDVGULQNLQJDW
WKHSRRO
$VVRRQDVKLVEHOO\LVIXOOKH
OOEHEDFNPXWWHUHG&RQDQ,W
PD\WDNHKRXUVIRUWKHSRLVRQWRNLOOKLPLILWGRHVDWDOO
6RPHZKHUHEH\RQGWKHIRUHVWWKHVXQZDVVLQNLQJWRWKHKRUL]RQ
7KHIRUHVWZDVDPLVW\WZLOLJKWSODFHRIEODFNVKDGRZVDQGGLP
YLVWDV&RQDQJULSSHG9DOHULD
VZULVWDQGJOLGHGDZD\IURPWKHIRRW
RIWKHFUDJ+HPDGHOHVVQRLVHWKDQDEUHH]HEORZLQJDPRQJWKHWUHH
WUXQNVEXW9DOHULDIHOWDVLIKHUVRIWERRWVZHUHEHWUD\LQJWKHLU
IOLJKWWRDOOWKHIRUHVW
,GRQ
WWKLQNKHFDQIROORZDWUDLOPXWWHUHG&RQDQ%XWLID
ZLQGEOHZRXUERG\VFHQWWRKLPKHFRXOGVPHOOXVRXW
0LWUDJUDQWWKDWWKHZLQGEORZQRW9DOHULDEUHDWKHG
+HUIDFHZDVDSDOOLGRYDOLQWKHJORRP6KHJULSSHGKHUVZRUGLQ
KHUIUHHKDQGEXWWKHIHHORIWKHVKDJUHHQERXQGKLOWLQVSLUHGRQO\
DIHHOLQJRIKHOSOHVVQHVVLQKHU
7KH\ZHUHVWLOOVRPHGLVWDQFHIURPWKHHGJHRIWKHIRUHVWZKHQ
WKH\KHDUGDVQDSSLQJDQGFUDVKLQJEHKLQGWKHP9DOHULDELWKHUOLS
WRFKHFNDFU\
+H
VRQRXUWUDLOVKHZKLVSHUHGILHUFHO\
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDG
+HGLGQ
WVPHOOXVDWWKHURFNDQGKH
VEOXQGHULQJDERXWWKURXJK
WKHIRUHVWWU\LQJWRSLFNXSRXUVFHQW&RPHRQ,W
VWKHFLW\RU
QRWKLQJQRZ+HFRXOGWHDUGRZQDQ\WUHHZH
GFOLPE,IRQO\WKHZLQG
VWD\VGRZQ
7KH\VWROHRQXQWLOWKHWUHHVEHJDQWRWKLQRXWDKHDGRIWKHP
%HKLQGWKHPWKHIRUHVWZDVDEODFNLPSHQHWUDEOHRFHDQRIVKDGRZV7KH
RPLQRXVFUDFNOLQJVWLOOVRXQGHGEHKLQGWKHPDVWKHGUDJRQEOXQGHUHG
LQKLVHUUDWLFFRXUVH
7KHUH
VWKHSODLQDKHDGEUHDWKHG9DOHULD$OLWWOHPRUHDQG
ZH
OO
&URPVZRUH&RQDQ
0LWUDZKLVSHUHG9DOHULD
2XWRIWKHVRXWKDZLQGKDGVSUXQJXS
,WEOHZRYHUWKHPGLUHFWO\LQWRWKHEODFNIRUHVWEHKLQGWKHP
,QVWDQWO\DKRUULEOHURDUVKRRNWKHZRRGV7KHDLPOHVVVQDSSLQJDQG
FUDFNOLQJRIWKHEXVKHVFKDQJHGWRDVXVWDLQHGFUDVKLQJDVWKHGUDJRQ
FDPHOLNHDKXUULFDQHVWUDLJKWWRZDUGWKHVSRWIURPZKLFKWKHVFHQW
RIKLVHQHPLHVZDVZDIWHG
5XQVQDUOHG&RQDQKLVH\HVEOD]LQJOLNHWKRVHRIDWUDSSHG
ZROI,W
VDOOZHFDQGR
6DLORU
VERRWVDUHQRWPDGHIRUVSULQWLQJDQGWKHOLIHRID
SLUDWHGRHVQRWWUDLQRQHIRUDUXQQHU:LWKLQDKXQGUHG\DUGV
9DOHULDZDVSDQWLQJDQGUHHOLQJLQKHUJDLWDQGEHKLQGWKHPWKH
FUDVKLQJJDYHZD\WRDUROOLQJWKXQGHUDVWKHPRQVWHUEURNHRXWRI
WKHWKLFNHWVDQGLQWRWKHPRUHRSHQJURXQG
&RQDQ
VLURQDUPDERXWWKHZRPDQ
VZDLVWKDOIOLIWHGKHUKHUIHHW
VFDUFHO\WRXFKHGWKHHDUWKDVVKHZDVERUQHDORQJDWDVSHHGVKH
FRXOGQHYHUKDYHDWWDLQHGKHUVHOI,IKHFRXOGNHHSRXWRIWKH
EHDVW
VZD\IRUDELWSUHKDSVWKDWEHWUD\LQJZLQGZRXOGVKLIWEXW
WKHZLQGKHOGDQGDTXLFNJODQFHRYHUKLVVKRXOGHUVKRZHG&RQDQWKDW
WKHPRQVWHUZDVDOPRVWXSRQWKHPFRPLQJOLNHDZDUJDOOH\LQIURQW
RIDKXUULFDQH+HWKUXVW9DOHULDIURPKLPZLWKDIRUFHWKDWVHQWKHU
UHHOLQJDGR]HQIHHWWRIDOOLQDFUXPSOHGKHDSDWWKHIRRWRIWKH
QHDUHVWWUHHDQGWKH&LPPHULDQZKHHOHGLQWKHSDWKRIWKHWKXQGHULQJ
WLWDQ
&RQYLQFHGWKDWKLVGHDWKZDVXSRQKLPWKH&LPPHULDQDFWHG
DFFRUGLQJWRKLVLQVWLQFWDQGKXUOHGKLPVHOIIXOODWWKHDZIXOIDFH
WKDWZDVEHDULQJGRZQRQKLP+HOHDSHGVODVKLQJOLNHDZLOGFDW
IHOWKLVVZRUGFXWGHHSLQWRWKHVFDOHVWKDWVKHDWKHGWKHPLJKW\
VQRXWDQGWKHQDWHUULILFLPSDFWNQRFNHGKLPUROOLQJDQGWXPEOLQJ
IRUILIW\IHHWZLWKDOOWKHZLQGDQGKDOIWKHOLIHEDWWHUHGRXWRI
KLP
+RZWKHVWXQQHG&LPPHULDQUHJDLQHGKLVIHHWQRWHYHQKHFRXOG
KDYHHYHUWROG%XWWKHRQO\WKRXJKWWKDWILOOHGKLVEUDLQZDVRIWKH
ZRPDQO\LQJGD]HGDQGKHOSOHVVDOPRVWLQWKHSDWKRIWKHKXUWOLQJ
ILHQGDQGEHIRUHWKHEUHDWKFDPHZKLVWOLQJEDFNLQWRKLVJXOOHWKH
ZDVVWDQGLQJRYHUKHUZLWKKLVVZRUGLQKLVKDQG
6KHOD\ZKHUHKHKDGWKURZQKHUEXWVKHZDVVWUXJJOLQJWRD
VLWWLQJSRVWXUH1HLWKHUWHDULQJWXVNVQRUWUDPSOLQJIHHWKDGWRXFKHG
KHU,WKDGEHHQDVKRXOGHURUIURQWOHJWKDWVWUXFN&RQDQDQGEOLQG
PRQVWHUUXVKHGRQIRUJHWWQLJWKHYLFWLPVZKRVHVFHQWLWKDGEHHQ
IROORZLQJLQWKHVXGGHQDJRQ\RILWVGHDWKWKURHV+HDGORQJRQLWV
FRXUVHLWWKXQGHUHGXQWLOLWVORZKXQJKHDGFUDVKHGLQWRDJLJDQWLF
WUHHLQLWVSDWK7KHLPSDFWWRUHWKHWUHHXSE\WKHURRWVDQGPXVW
KDYHGDVKHGWKHEUDLQVIURPWKHPLVVKDSHQVNXOO7UHHDQGPRQVWHU
IHOOWRJHWKHUDQGWKHGD]HGKXPDQVVDZWKHEUDQFKHVDQGOHDYHV
VKDNHQE\WKHFRQYXOVLRQVRIWKHFUHDWXUHWKH\FRYHUHGDQGWKHQ
JURZTXLHW
&RQDQOLIWHG9DOHULDWRKHUIHHWDQGWRJHWKHUWKH\VWDUWHGDZD\DW
DUHHOLQJUXQ$IHZPRPHQWVODWHUWKH\HPHUJHGLQWRWKHVWLOO
WZLOLJKWRIWKHWUHHOHVVSODLQ
&RQDQSDXVHGDQLQVWDQWDQGJODQFHGEDFNDWWKHHERQIDVWQHVV
EHKLQGWKHP1RWDOHDIVWLUUHGQRUDELUGFKLUSHG,WVWRRGDV
VLOHQWDVLWPXVWKDYHVWRRGEHIRUH0DQZDVFUHDWHG
&RPHRQPXWWHUHG&RQDQWDNLQJKLVFRPSDQLRQ
VKDQG,W
V
WRXFKDQGJRQRZ,IPRUHGUDJRQVFRPHRXWRIWKHZRRGVDIWHUXV
+HGLGQRWKDYHWRILQLVKWKHVHQWHQFH
7KHFLW\ORRNHGYHU\IDUDZD\DFURVVWKHSODLQIDUWKHUWKDQLW
KDGORRNHGIURPWKHFUDJ9DOHULD
VKHDUWKDPPHUHGXQWLOVKHIHOWDV
LILWZRXOGVWUDQJOHKHU$WHYHU\VWHSVKHH[SHFWHGWRKHDUWKH
FUDVKLQJRIWKHEXVKHVDQGVHHDQRWKHUFRORVVDOQLJKWPDUHEHDULQJ
GRZQXSRQWKHP%XWQRWKLQJGLVWXUEHGWKHVLOHQFHRIWKHWKLFNHWV
:LWKWKHILUVWPLOHEHWZHHQWKHPDQGWKHZRRGV9DOHULDEUHDWKHG
PRUHHDVLO\+HUEXR\DQWVHOIFRQILGHQFHEHJDQWRWKDZRXWDJDLQ7KH
VXQKDGVHWDQGGDUNQHVVZDVJDWKHULQJRYHUWKHSODLQOLJKWHQHGD
OLWWOHE\WKHVWDUVWKDWPDGHVWXQWHGJKRVWVRXWRIWKHFDFWXV
JURZWKV
1RFDWWOHQRSORZHGILHOGVPXWWHUHG&RQDQ+RZGRWKHVH
SHRSOHOLYH"
3HUKDSVWKHFDWWOHDUHLQSHQVIRUWKHQLJKWVXJJHVWHG9DOHULD
DQGWKHILHOGVDQGJUD]LQJSDVWXUHVDUHRQWKHRWKHUVLGHRIWKH
FLW\
0D\EHKHJUXQWHG,GLGQ
WVHHDQ\IURPWKHFUDJWKRXJK
7KHPRRQFDPHXSEHKLQGWKHFLW\HWFKLQJZDOOVDQGWRZHUVEODFNO\
LQWKH\HOORZJORZ9DOHULDVKLYHUHG%ODFNDJDLQVWWKHPRRQWKH
VWUDQJHFLW\KDGDVRPEHUVLQLVWHUORRN
3HUKDSVVRPHWKLQJRIWKHVDPHIHHOLQJRFFXUUHGWR&RQDQIRUKH
VWRSSHGJODQFHGDERXWKLPDQGJUXQWHG:H
OOVWRSKHUH1RXVH
FRPLQJWRWKHLUJDWHVLQWKHQLJKW7KH\SUREDEO\ZRXOGQ
WOHWXVLQ
%HVLGHVZHQHHGUHVWDQGZHGRQWNQRZKRZWKH\
OOUHFHLYHXV$IHZ
KRXUV
VOHHSZLOOSXWXVLQEHWWHUVKDSHWRILJKWRUUXQ
+HOHGWKHZD\WRDEHGRIFDFWXVZKLFKJUHZLQDFLUFOHD
SKHQRPHQRQFRPPRQWRWKHVRXWKHUQGHVHUW:LWKKLVVZRUGKHFKRSSHG
DQRSHQLQJDQGPRWLRQHG9DOHULDWRHQWHU
:H
OOEHVDIHIURPWKHVQDNHVKHUHDQ\KRZ
6KHJODQFHGIHDUIXOO\EDFNWRZDUGWKHEODFNOLQHWKDWLQGLFDWHG
WKHIRUHVWVRPHVL[PLOHVDZD\
6XSSRVHDGUDJRQFRPHVRXWRIWKHZRRGV"
:H
OONHHSZDWFKKHDQVZHUHGWKRXJKKHPDGHQRVXJJHVWLRQDV
WRZKDWWKH\ZRXOGGRLQVXFKDQHYHQW+HZDVVWDULQJDWWKHFLW\D
IHZPLOHVDZD\1RWDOLJKWVKRQHIURPVSLUHRUWRZHU$JUHDWEODFN
PDVVRIP\VWHU\LWUHDUHGFU\SWLFDOO\DJDLQVWWKHPRRQOLWVN\
/LHGRZQDQGVOHHS,
OONHHSWKHILUVWZDWFK
6KHKHVLWDWHGJODQFLQJDWKLPXQFHUWDLQO\EXWKHVDWGRZQFURVV
OHJJHGLQWKHRSHQLQJIDFLQJWRZDUGWKHSODLQKLVVZRUGDFURVVKLV
NQHHVKLVEDFNWRKHU:LWKRXWIXUWKHUFRPPHQWVKHOD\GRZQRQWKH
VDQGLQVLGHWKHVSLN\FLUFOH
:DNHPHZKHQWKHPRRQLVDWLWV]HQLWKVKHGLUHFWHG
+HGLGQRWUHSO\QRUORRNWRZDUGKHU+HUODVWLPSUHVVLRQDVVKH
VDQNLQWRVOXPEHUZDVRIKLVPXVFXODUILJXUHLPPRELOHDVDVWDWXH
KHZQRXWRIEURQ]HRXWOLQHGDJDLQVWWKHORZKDQJLQJVWDUV


%\WKH%OD]HRIWKH)LUH-HZHOV

9DOHULDDZRNHZLWKDVWDUWWRWKHUHDOL]DWLRQWKDWDJUH\GDZQ
ZDVVWHDOLQJRYHUWKHSODLQ
6KHVDWXSUXEELQJKHUH\HV&RQDQVTXDWWHGEHVLGHWKHFDFWXV
FXWWLQJRIIWKHWKLFNSHDUVDQGGH[WHURXVO\WZLWFKLQJRXWWKHVSLNHV
<RXGLGQ
WDZDNHPHVKHDFFXVHG<RXOHWPHVOHHSDOOQLJKW
<RXZHUHWLUHGKHDQVZHUHG<RXUSRVWHULRUPXVWKDYHEHHQ
VRUHWRRDIWHUWKDWORQJULGH<RXSLUDWHVDUHQ
WXVHGWR
KRUVHEDFN
:KDWDERXW\RXUVHOI"VKHUHWRUWHG
,ZDVDBNR]DNBEHIRUH,ZDVDSLUDWHKHDQVZHUHG7KH\OLYH
LQWKHVDGGOH,VQDWFKQDSVOLNHDSDQWKHUZDWFKLQJEHVLGHWKHWUDLO
IRUDGHHUWRFRPHE\0\HDUVNHHSZDWFKZKLOHP\H\HVVOHHS
$QGLQGHHGWKHJLDQWEDUEDULDQVHHPHGDVPXFKUHIUHVKHGDVLIKH
KDGVOHSWWKHZKROHQLJKWRQDJROGHQEHG+DYLQJUHPRYHGWKHWKRUQV
DQGSHHOHGRIIWKHWRXJKVNLQKHKDQGHGWKHJLUODWKLFNMXLF\
FDFWXVOHDI
6NLQ\RXUWHHWKLQWKDWSHDU,W
VIRRGDQGGULQNWRDGHVHUW
PDQ,ZDVDFKLHIRIWKH=XDJLUVRQFHGHVHUWPHQZKROLYHE\
SOXQGHULQJWKHFDUDYDQV
,VWKHUHDQ\WKLQJ\RXKDYHQ
WGRQH"LQTXLUHGWKHJLUOKDOILQ
GHULVLRQDQGKDOILQIDVFLQDWLRQ
,
YHQHYHUEHHQNLQJRIDQ+\ERUHDQNLQJGRPKHJULQQHGWDNLQJ
DQHQRUPRXVPRXWKIXORIFDFWXV%XW,
YHGUHDPHGRIEHLQJHYHQWKDW
,PD\EHWRRVRPHGD\:K\VKRXOGQ
W,"
6KHVKRRNKHUKHDGLQZRQGHUDWKLVFDOPDXGDFLW\DQGIHOOWR
GHYRXULQJKHUSHDU6KHIRXQGLWQRWXQSOHDVLQJWRWKHSDODWHDQG
IXOORIFRRODQGWKLUVWVDWLVI\LQJMXLFH)LQLVKLQJKLVPHDO&RQDQ
ZLSHGKLVKDQGVLQWKHVDQGURVHUDQKLVILQJHUVWKURXJKKLVWKLFN
EODFNPDQHKLWFKHGXSKLVVZRUGEHOWDQGVDLG
:HOOOHW
VJR,IWKHSHRSOHLQWKDWFLW\DUHJRLQJWRFXWRXU
WKURDWVWKH\PD\DVZHOOGRLWQRZEHIRUHWKHKHDWRIWKHGD\
EHJLQV
+LVJULPKXPRUZDVXQFRQVFLRXVEXW9DOHULDUHIOHFWHGWKDWLW
PLJKWEHSURSKHWLF6KHWRRKLWFKHGKHUVZRUGEHOWDVVKHURVH+HU
WHUURUVRIWKHQLJKWZHUHSDVW7KHURDULQJGUDJRQVRIWKHGLVWDQW
IRUHVWZHUHOLNHDGLPGUHDP7KHUHZDVDVZDJJHULQKHUVWULGHDV
VKHPRYHGRIIEHVLGHWKH&LPPHULDQ:KDWHYHUSHULOVOD\DKHDGRI
WKHPWKHLUIRHVZRXOGEHPHQ$QG9DOHULDRIWKH5HG%URWKHUKRRGKDG
QHYHUVHHQWKHIDFHRIWKHPDQVKHIHDUHG
&RQDQJODQFHGGRZQDWKHUDVVKHVWURGHDORQJEHVLGHKLPZLWKKHU
VZLQJLQJVWULGHWKDWPDWFKHGKLVRZQ
<RXZDONPRUHOLNHDKLOOPDQWKDQDVDLORUKHVDLG<RXPXVW
EHDQ$TXLORQLDQ7KHVXQVRI'DUIDUQHYHUEXUQW\RXUZKLWHVNLQ
EURZQ0DQ\DSULQFHVVZRXOGHQY\\RX
,DPIURP$TXLORQLDVKHUHSOLHG+LVFRPSOLPHQWVQRORQJHU
LUULWDWHGKHU+LVHYLGHQWDGPLUDWLRQSOHDVHGKHU)RUDQRWKHUPDQWR
KDYHNHSWKHUZDWFKZKLOHVKHVOHSWZRXOGKDYHDQJHUHGKHUVKHKDG
DOZD\VILHUFHO\UHVHQWHGDQ\PDQ
VDWWHPSWLQJWRVKLHOGRUSURWHFW
KHUEHFDXVHRIKHUVH[%XWVKHIRXQGDVHFUHWSOHDVXUHLQWKHIDFW
WKDWWKLVPDQKDGGRQHVR$QGKHKDGQRWWDNHQDGYDQWDJHRIKHU
IULJKWDQGWKHZHDNQHVVUHVXOWLQJIURPLW$IWHUDOOVKHUHIOHFWHG
KHUFRPSDQLRQZDVQRFRPPRQPDQ
7KHVXQURVHXSEHKLQGWKHFLW\WXUQLQJWKHWRZHUVWRDVLQLVWHU
FULPVRQ
%ODFNODVWQLJKWDJDLQVWWKHPRRQJUXQWHG&RQDQKLVH\V
FORXGLQJZLWKWKHDE\VPDOVXSHUVWLWLRQRIWKHEDUEDULDQ%ORRGUHG
DVDWKUHDWRIEORRGDJDLQVWWKHVXQWKLVGDZQ,GRQRWOLNHWKLV
FLW\
%XWWKH\ZHQWRQDQGDVWKH\ZHQW&RQDQSRLQWHGRXWWKHIDFWWKDW
QRURDGUDQWRWKHFLW\IURPWKHQRUWK
1RFDWWOHKDYHWUDPSOHGWKHSODLQRQWKLVVLGHRIWKHFLW\VDLG
KH1RSORZVKDUHKDVWRXFKHGWKHHDUWKIRU\HDUVPD\EHFHQWXULHV
%XWORRNRQFHWKLVSODLQZDVFXOWLYDWHG
9DOHULDVDZWKHDQFLHQWLUULJDWLRQGLWFKHVKHLQGLFDWHGKDOI
ILOOHGLQSODFHVDQGRYHUJURZQZLWKFDFWXV6KHIURZQHGZLWK
SHUSOH[LW\DVKHUH\HVVZHSWRYHUWKHSODLQWKDWVWUHWFKHGRQDOO
VLGHVRIWKHFLW\WRWKHIRUHVWHGJHZKLFKPDUFKHGLQDYDVWGLP
ULQJ9LVLRQGLGQRWH[WHQGEH\RQGWKDWULQJ
6KHORRNHGXQHDVLO\DWWKHFLW\1RKHOPHWVRUVSHDUKHDGVJOHDPHG
RQEDWWOHPHQWVQRWUXPSHWVVRXQGHGQRFKDOOHQJHUDQJIURPWKH
WRZHUV$VLOHQFHDVDEVROXWHDVWKDWRIWKHIRUHVWEURRGHGRYHUWKH
ZDOOVDQGPLQDUHWV
7KHVXQZDVKLJKDERYHWKHHDVWHUQKRUL]RQZKHQWKH\VWRRGEHIRUH
WKHJUHDWJDWHLQWKHQRUWKHUQZDOOLQWKHVKDGRZQRIWKHORIW\
UDPSDUW5XVWIOHFNHGWKHLURQEUDFLQJVRIWKHPLJKW\EURQ]HSRUWDO
6SLGHUZHEVJOLVWHQHGWKLFNO\RQKLQJHDQGVLOODQGEROWHGSDQHO
,WKDVQ
WEHHQRSHQHGIRU\HDUVH[FODLPHG9DOHULD
$GHDGFLW\JUXQWHG&RQDQ7KDW
VZK\WKHGLWFKHVZHUHEURNHQ
DQGWKHSODLQXQWRXFKHG
%XWZKREXLOWLW":KRGZHOWKHUH":KHUHGLGWKH\JR":K\GLGWKH\
DEDQGRQLW"
:KRFDQVD\"0D\EHDQH[LOHGFODQRI6W\JLDQVEXLOWLW0D\EH
QRW,WGRHVQ
WORRNOLNH6W\JLDQDUFKLWHFWXUH0D\EHWKHSHRSOHZHUH
ZLSHGRXWE\HQHPLHVRUDSODJXHH[WHUPLQDWHGWKHP
,QWKDWFDVHWKHLUWUHDVXUHVPD\VWLOOEHJDWKHULQJGXVWDQG
FREZHEVLQWKHUHVXJJHVWHG9DOHULDWKHDTXLVLWLYHLQVWLQFWVRIKHU
SURIHVVLRQZDNLQJLQKHUSURGGHGWRRE\IHPLQLQHFXULRVLW\&DQ
ZHRSHQWKHJDWH"/HW
VJRLQDQGH[SORUHDELW
&RQDQH\HGWKHKHDY\SRUWDOGXELRXVO\EXWSODFHGKLVPDVVLYH
VKRXOGHUDJDLQVWLWDQGWKUXVWZLWKDOOWKHSRZHURIKLVPXVFXODU
FDOYHVDQGWKLJKV:LWKDUDVSLQJVFUHHFKRIUXVW\KLQJHVWKHJDWH
PRYHGSRQGHURXVO\LQZDUGDQG&RQDQVWUDLJKWHQHGDQGGUHZKLVVZRUG
9DOHULDVWDUHGRYHUKLVVKRXOGHUDQGPDGHDVRXQGLQGLFDWLYHRI
VXUSULVH
7KH\ZHUHQRWORRNLQJLQWRDQRSHQVWUHHWRUFRXUWDVRQHZRXOG
KDYHH[SHFWHG7KHRSHQHGJDWHRUGRRUJDYHGLUHFWO\LQWRDORQJ
EURDGKDOOZKLFKUDQDZD\DQGDZD\XQWLOLWVYLVWDJUHZLQGLVWLQFWLQ
WKHGLVWDQFH,WZDVRIKHURLFSURSRUWLRQVDQGWKHIORRURID
FXULRXVUHGVWRQHFXWLQVTXDUHWLOHVWKDWVHHPHGWRVPROGHUDVLI
ZLWKWKHUHIOHFWLRQRIIODPHV7KHZDOOVZHUHRIDVKLQ\JUHHQ
PDWHULDO
-DGHRU,
PD6KHPLWHVZRUH&RQDQ
1RWLQVXFKTXDQWLW\SURWHVWHG9DOHULD
,
YHORRWHGHQRXJKIURPWKH.KLWDQFDUDYDQVWRNQRZZKDW,
P
WDONLQJDERXWKHDVVHUWHG7KDW
VMDGH
7KHYDXOWHGFHLOLQJZDVRIODSLVOD]XOLDGRUQHGZLWKFOXVWHUVRI
JUHDWJUHHQVWRQHVWKDWJOHDPHGZLWKDSRLVRQRXVUDGLDQFH
*UHHQILUHVWRQHVJURZOHG&RQDQ7KDW
VZKDWWKHSHRSOHRI
3XQWFDOOWKHP7KH\
UHVXSSRVHGWREHWKHSHWULILHGH\HVRIWKRVH
SUHKLVWRULFVQDNHVWKHDQFLHQWVFDOOHG*ROGHQ6HUSHQWV7KH\JORZ
OLNHDFDW
VH\HVLQWKHGDUN$WQLJKWWKLVKDOOZRXOGEHOLJKWHGE\
WKHPEXWLWZRXOGEHDKHOOLVKO\ZHLUGLOOXPLQDWLRQ/HW
VORRN
DURXQG:HPLJKWILQGDFDFKHRIMHZHOV
6KXWWKHGRRUDGYLVHG9DOHULD,
GKDWHWRKDYHWRRXWUXQD
GUDJRQGRZQWKLVKDOO
&RQDQJULQQHGDQGUHSOLHG,GRQ
WEHOLHYHWKHGUDJRQVHYHU
OHDYHWKHIRUHVW
%XWKHFRPSOLHGDQGSRLQWHGRXWWKHEURNHQEROWRQWKHLQQHU
VLGH
,WKRXJKW,KHDUGVRPHWKLQJVQDSZKHQ,VKRYHGDJDLQVWLW7KDW
EROW
VIUHVKO\EURNHQ5XVWKDVHDWHQQHDUO\WKURXJKLW,IWKH
SHRSOHUDQDZD\ZK\VKRXOGLWKDYHEHHQEROWHGRQWKHLQVLGH"
7KH\XQGRXEWHGO\OHIWE\DQRWKHUGRRUVXJJHVWHG9DOHULD
6KHZRQGHUHGKRZPDQ\FHQWXULHVKDGSDVVHGVLQFHWKHOLJKWRI
RXWHUGD\KDGILOWHUHGLQWRWKDWJUHDWKDOOWKURXJKWKHRSHQGRRU
6XQOLJKWZDVILQGLQJLWVZD\VRPHKRZLQWRWKHKDOODQGWKH\TXLFNO\
VDZWKHVRXUFH+LJKXSLQWKHYDXOWHGFHLOLQJVN\OLJKWVZHUHVHWLQ
VORWOLNHRSHQLQJVWUDQVOXFHQWVKHHWVRIVRPHFU\VWDOOLQH
VXEVWDQFH,QWKHVSORWFKHVRIVKDGRZEHWZHHQWKHPWKHJUHHQMHZHOV
ZLQNHGOLNHWKHH\HVRIDQJU\FDWV%HQHDWKWKHLUIHHWWKHGXOO\
OXULGIORRUVPROGHUHGZLWKFKDQJLQJKXHVDQGFRORUVRIIODPH,WZDV
OLNHWUHDGLQJWKHIORRUVRI+HOOZLWKHYLOVWDUVEOLQNLQJRYHUKHDG
7KUHHEDOXVWUDGHGJDOOHULHVUDQDORQJRQHDFKVLGHRIWKHKDOO
RQHDERYHWKHRWKHU
$IRXUVWRULHGKRXVHJUXQWHG&RQDQDQGWKLVKDOOH[WHQGVWR
WKHURRI,W
VORQJDVDVWUHHW,VHHPWRVHHDGRRUDWWKHRWKHU
HQG
9DOHULDVKUXJJHGKHUZKLWHVKRXOGHUV
<RXUH\HVDUHEHWWHUWKDQPLQHWKHQWKRXJK,
PDFFRXQWHGVKDUS
H\HGDPRQJWKHVHDURYHUV
7KH\WXUQHGLQWRDQRSHQGRRUDWUDQGRPDQGWUDYHUHVHGDVHULHV
RIHPSW\FKDPEHUVIORRUHGOLNHWKHKDOODQGZLWKZDOOVRIWKHVDPH
JUHHQMDGHRURIPDUEOHRULYRU\RUFKDOFHGRQ\DGRUQHGZLWKIULH]HV
RIEURQ]HJROGRUVLOYHU,QWKHFHLOLQJVWKHJUHHQILUHJHPVZHUH
VHWDQGWKHLUOLJKWZDVDVJKRVWO\DQGLOOXVLYHDV&RQDQKDG
SUHGLFWHG8QGHUWKHZLWFKILUHJORZWKHLQWUXGHUVPRYHGOLNH
VSHFWHUV
6RPHRIWKHFKDPEHUVODFNHGWKLVLOOXPLQDWLRQDQGWKHLUGRRUZD\V
VKRZHGEODFNDVWKHPRXWKRIWKH3LW7KHVH&RQDQDQG9DOHULD
DYRLGHGNHHSLQJDOZD\VWRWKHOLJKWHGFKDPEHUV
&REZHEVKXQJLQWKHFRUQHUVEXWWKHUHZDVQRSHUFHSWLEOH
DFFXPXODWLRQRIGXVWRQWKHIORRURURQWKHWDEOHVDQGVHDWVRI
PDUEOHMDGHRUFDUQHOLDQZKLFKRFFXSLHGWKHFKDPEHUV+HUHDQG
WKHUHZHUHUXJVRIWKDWVLONNQRZQDV.KLWDQZKLFKLVSUDFWLFDOO\
LQGHVWUXFWLEOH1RZKHUHGLGWKH\ILQGDQ\ZLQGRZVRUGRRUVRSHQLQJ
LQWRVWUHHWVRUFRXUWV(DFKGRRUPHUHO\RSHQHGLQWRDQRWKHUFKDPEHU
RUKDOO
:K\GRQ
WZHFRPHWRDVWUHHW"JUXPEOHG9DOHULD7KLVSDODFHRU
ZKDWHYHUZH
UHLQPXVWEHDVELJDVWKHNLQJRI7XUDQ
VVHUDJOLR
7KH\PXVWQRWKDYHSHULVKHGRISODJXHVDG&RQDQPHGLWDWLQJ
XSRQWKHP\VWHU\RIWKHHPSW\FLW\2WKHUZLVHZH
GILQGVNHOHWRQV
0D\EHLWEHFDPHKDXQWHGDQGHYHU\ERG\JRWXSDQGOHIW0D\EH
0D\EHKHOOEURNHLQ9DOHULDUXGHO\:H
OOQHYHUNQRZ/RRNDW
WKHVHIULH]HV7KH\SRUWUD\PHQ:KDWUDFHGRWKH\EHORQJWR"
&RQDQVFDQQHGWKHPDQGVKRRNKLVKHDG
,QHYHUVDZSHRSOHH[DFWO\OLNHWKHP%XWWKHUH
VWKHVPDFNRI
WKH(DVWDERXWWKHP9HQGK\DPD\EHRU.RVDOD
:HUH\RXDNLQJLQ.RVDOD"VKHDVNHGPDVNLQJKHUNHHQFXULRVLW\
ZLWKGHULVLRQ
1R%XW,ZDVDZDUFKLHIRIWKH$IJKXOLVZKROLYHLQWKH
+LPHOLDQPRXQWDLQVDERYHWKHERUGHUVRI9HQGK\D7KHVHSHRSOHIDYRU
WKH.RVDODQV%XWZK\VKRXOG.RVDODQVEHEXLOGLQJDFLW\WKLVIDUWR
WKHZHVW"
7KHILJXUHVSRUWUD\HGZHUHWKRVHRIVOHQGHUROLYHVNLQQHGPHQDQG
ZRPHQZLWKILQHO\FKLVOHGH[RWLFIHDWXUHV7KH\ZRUHILOP\UREHV
DQGPDQ\GHOLFDWHMHZHOHGRUQDPHQWVDQGZHUHGHSLFWHGPRVWO\LQ
DWWLWXGHVRIIHDVWLQJGDQFLQJRUORYHPDNLQJ
(DVWHUQHUVDOOULJKWJUXQWHG&RQDQEXWIURPZKHUH,GRQ
W
NQRZ7KH\PXVWKDYHOLYHGDGLVJXVWLQJO\SHDFHIXOOLIHWKRXJKRU
WKH\
GKDYHVFHQHVRIZDUVDQGILJKWV/HW
VJRXSWKRVHVWDLUV
,WZDVDQLYRU\VSLUDOWKDWZRXQGXSIURPWKHFKDPEHULQZKLFK
WKH\ZHUHVWDQGLQJ7KH\PRXQWHGWKUHHIOLJKWVDQGFDPHLQWRDEURDG
FKDPEHURQWKHIRXUWKIORRUZKLFKVHHPHGWREHWKHKLJKHVWWLHULQ
WKHEXLOGLQJ6N\OLJKWVLQWKHFHLOLQJLOOXPLQDWHGWKHURRPLQZKLFK
OLJKWWKHILUHJHPVZLQNHGSDOOLGO\*ODQFLQJWKURXJKWKHGRRUVWKH\
VDZH[FHSWRQRQHVLGHDVHLHVRIVLPLODUO\OLJKWHGFKDPEHUV7KLV
RWKHUGRRURSHQHGXSRQDEDOXVWUDGHGJDOOHU\WKDWRYHUKXQJDKDOO
PXFKVPDOOHUWKDQWKHRQHWKH\KDGUHFHQWO\H[SORUHGRQWKHORZHU
IORRU
+HOO9DOHULDVDWGRZQGLVJXVWHGO\RQDMDGHEHQFK7KHSHRSOH
ZKRGHVHUWHGWKLVFLW\PXVWKDYHWDNHQDOOWKHLUWUHDVXUHVZLWKWKHP
,
PWLUHGRIZDQGHULQJWKURXJKWKHVHEDUHURRPVDWUDQGRP
$OOWKHVHXSSHUFKDPEHUVVHHPWREHOLJKWHGVDLG&RQDQ,ZLVK
ZHFRXOGILQGDZLQGRZWKDWRYHUORRNHGWKHFLW\/HW
VKDYHDORRN
WKURXJKWKDWGRRURYHUWKHUH
<RXKDYHDORRNDGYLVHG9DOHULD,
PJRQLJWRVLWKHUHDQG
UHVWP\IHHW
&RQDQGLVDSSHDUHGWKURXJKWKHGRRURSSRVLWHWKDWRQHRSHQLQJXSRQ
WKHJDOOHU\DQG9DOHULDOHDQHGEDFNZLWKKHUKDQGVFODVSHGEHKLQG
KHUKHDGDQGWKUXVWKHUERRWHGOHJVRXWLQIURQWRIKHU7KHVH
VLOHQWURRPVDQGKDOOVZLWKWKHLUJOHDPLQJJUHHQFOXVWHUVRI
RUQDPHQWVDQGEXUQLQJFULPVRQIORRUVZHUHEHJLQQLQJWRGHSUHVVKHU
6KHZLVKHGWKH\FRXOGILQGWKHLUZD\RXWRIWKHPD]HLQWRZKLFKWKH\
KDGZDQGHUHGDQGHPHUJHLQWRDVWUHHW6KHZRQGHUHGLGO\ZKDW
IXUWLYHGDUNIHHWKDGJOLGHGRYHUWKRVHIODPLQJIORRUVLQSDVW
FHQWXULHVKRZPDQ\GHHGVRIFUXHOW\DQGP\VWHU\WKRVHZULQNLQJ
FHLOLQJJHPVKDGEOD]HGGRZQXSRQ
,WZDVDIDLQWQRLVHWKDWEURXJKWKHURXWRIKHUUHIOHFWLRQV6KH
ZDVRQKHUIHHWZLWKKHUVZRUGLQKHUKDQGEHIRUHVKHUHDOL]HGZKDW
KDGGLVWXUEHGKHU&RQDQKDGQRWUHWXUQHGDQGVKHNQHZLWZDVQRWKH
WKDWVKHKDGKHDUG
7KHVRXQGKDGFRPHIURPVRPHZKHUHEH\RQGWKHGRRUWKDWRSHQHGRQ
WRWKHJDOOHU\6RXQGOHVVO\LQKHUVRIWOHDWKHUERRWVVKHJOLGHG
WKURXJKLWFUHSWDFURVVWKHEDOFRQ\DQGSHHUHGGRZQEHWZHHQWKH
KHDY\EDOXVWUDGHV
B$PDQZDVVWHDOLQJDORQJWKHKDOOB
7KHVLJKWRIDKXPDQEHLQJLQWKLVVXSSRVHGO\GHVHUWHGFLW\ZDVD
VWDUWOLQJVKRFN&URXFKLQJGRZQEHKLQGWKHVWRQHEDOXVWHUVZLWK
HYHU\QHUYHWLQJOLQJ9DOHULDJODUHGGRZQDWWKHVWHDOWK\ILJXUH
7KHPDQLQQRZD\UHVHPEOHGWKHILJXUHVGHSLFWHGRQWKHIULH]HV
+HZDVVOLJKWO\DERYHPLGGOHKHLJKWYHU\GDUNWKRXJKQRW1HJURLG
+HZDVQDNHGEXWIRUDVFDQW\VLONFORXWWKDWRQO\SDUWO\FRYHUHGKLV
PXVFXODUKLSVDQGDOHDWKHUJLUGOHDKDQG
VEUHDGWKEURDGDERXW
KLVOHDQZDLVW+LVORQJEODFNKDLUKXQJLQODQNVWUDQGVDERXWKLV
VKRXOGHUVJLYLQJKLPDZLOGDSSHDUDQFH+HZDVJDXQWEXWNQRWVDQG
FRUGVRIPXVFOHVVWRRGRXWRQKLVDUPVDQGOHJVZLWKRXWWKDWIOHVK\
SDGGLQJWKDWSUHVHQWVDSOHDVLQJV\PPHWU\RIFRQWRXU+HZDVEXLOW
ZLWKDQHFRQRP\WKDWZDVDOPRVWUHSHOOHQW
<HWLWZDVQRWVRPXFKKLVSK\VLFDODSSHDUDQFHDVKLVDWWLWXGH
WKDWLPSUHVVHGWKHZRPDQZKRZDWFKHGKLP+HVOXQNDORQJVWRRSHGLQ
DVHPLFURXFKKLVKHDGWXUQLQJIURPVLGHWRVLGH+HJUDVSHGDZLGH
WLSSHGEODGHLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGVKHVDZLWVKDNHZLWKWKH
LQWHQVLW\RIWKHHPRWLRQWKDWJULSSHGKLP+HZDVDIUDLGWUHPEOLQJ
LQWKHJULSRIVRPHGLUHWHUURU:KHQKHWXUQHGKLVKHDGVKHFDXJKW
WKHEOD]HRIZLOGH\HVDPRQJWKHODQNVWUDQGVRIEODFNKDLU
+HGLGQRWVHHKHU2QWLSWRHKHJOLGHGDFURVVWKHKDOODQG
YDQLVKHGWKURXJKDQRSHQGRRU$PRPHQWODWHUVKHKHDUGDFKRNLQJ
FU\DQGWKHQVLOHQFHIHOODJDLQ
&RQVXPHGZLWKFXULRVLW\9DOHULDJOLGHGDORQJWKHJDOOHU\XQWLO
VKHFDPHWRDGRRUDERYHWKHRQHWKURXJKZKLFKWKHPDQKDGSDVVHG,W
RSHQHGLQWRDQRWKHUVPDOOHUJDOOHU\WKDWHQFLUFOHGDODUJHFKDPEHU
7KLVFKDPEHUZDVRQWKHWKLUGIORRUDQGLWVFHLOLQJZDVQRWVR
KLJKDVWKDWRIWKHKDOO,WZDVOLJKWHGRQO\E\WKHILUHVWRQHVDQG
WKHLUZHLUGJUHHQJORZOHIWWKHVSDFHVXQGHUWKHEDOFRQ\LQVKDGRZV
9DOHULD
VH\HVZLGHQHG7KHPDQVKHKDGVHHQZDVVWLOOLQWKH
FKDPEHU
+HOD\IDFHGRZQRQDGDUNFULPVRQFDUSHWLQWKHPLGGOHRIWKH
URRP+LVERG\ZDVOLPSKLVDUPVVSUHDGZLGH+LVFXUYHGVZRUGOD\
QHDUKLP
6KHZRQGHUHGZK\KHVKRXOGOLHWKHUHVRPRWLRQOHVV7KHQKHUH\HV
QDUURZHGDVVKHVWDUHGGRZQDWWKHUXJRQZKLFKKHOD\%HQHDWKDQG
DERXWKLPWKHIDEULFVKRZHGDVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWFRORUDGHHSHU
EULJKWHUFULPVRQ
6KLYHULQJVOLJKWO\VKHFURXFKHGGRZQFORVHUEHKLQGWKH
EDOXVWUDGHLQWHQWO\VFDQQLQJWKHVKDGRZVXQGHUWKHRYHUKDQJLQJ
JDOOHU\7KH\JDYHXSQRVHFUHW
6XGGHQO\DQRWKHUILJXUHHQWHUHGWKHJULPGUDPD+HZDVDPDQ
VLPLODUWRWKHILUVWDQGKHFDPHLQE\DGRRURSSRVLWHWKDWZKLFK
JDYHXSRQWKHKDOO
+LVH\HVJODUHGDWWKHVLJKWRIWKHPDQRQWKHIORRUDQGKHVSRNH
VRPHWKLQJLQDVWDFFDWRYRLFHWKDWVRXQGHGOLNH&KLFPHF7KHRWKHU
GLGQRWPRYH
7KHPDQVWHSSHGTXLFNO\DFURVVWKHIORRUEHQWJULSSHGWKHIDOOHQ
PDQ
VVKRXOGHUDQGWXUQHGKLPRYHU$FKRNLQJFU\HVFDSHGKLPDVWKH
KHDGIHOOEDFNOLPSO\GLVFORVLQJDWKURDWWKDWKDGEHHQVHYHUHGIURP
HDUWRHDU
7KHPDQOHWWKHFRUSVHIDOOEDFNXSRQWKHEORRGVWDLQHGFDUSHW
DQGVSUDQJWRKLVIHHWVKDNLQJOLNHDZLQGEORZQOHDI+LVIDFHZDV
DQDVK\PDVNRIIHDU%XWZLWKRQHNQHHIOH[HGIRUIOLJKWKHIUR]H
VXGGHQO\EHFDPHDVLPPRELOHDVDQLPDJHVWDULQJDFURVVWKHFKDPEHU
ZLWKGLODWHGH\HV
,QWKHVKDGRZVEHQHDWKWKHEDOFRQ\DJKRVWO\OLJKWEHJDQWRJORZ
DQGJURZDOLJKWWKDWZDVQRWSDUWRIWKHILUHVWRQHJOHDP9DOHULD
IHOWKHUKDLUVWLUDVVKHZDWFKHGLWIRUGLPO\YLVLEOHLQWKH
WKUREELQJUDGLDQFHWKHUHIORDWHGDKXPDQVNXOODQGLWZDVIURPWKLV
VNXOOKXPDQ\HWDSSDOOLQJO\PLVVKDSHQWKDWWKHVSHFWUDOOLJKW
VHHPHGWRHPDQDWH,WKXQJWKHUHOLNHDGLVHPERGLHGKHDGFRQMXUHG
RXWRIQLJKWDQGWKHVKDGRZVJURZLQJPRUHDQGPRUHGLVWLQFWKXPDQ
DQG\HWQRWKXPDQDVVKHNQHZKXPDQLW\
7KHPDQVWRRGPRWLRQOHVVDQHPERGLPHQWRISDUDO\]HGKRUURU
VWDULQJIL[HGO\DWWKHDSSDULWLRQ7KHWKLQJPRYHGRXWIURPWKHZDOO
DQGDJURWHVTXHVKDGRZVPRYHGZLWKLW6ORZO\WKHVKDGRZEHFDPH
YLVLEOHDVDPDQOLNHILJXUHZKRVHQDNHGWRUVRDQGOLPEVVKRQH
ZKLWHO\ZLWKWKHKXHRIEOHDFKHGERQHV7KHEDUHVNXOORQLWV
VKRXOGHUVJULQQHGH\HOHVVO\LQWKHPLGVWRILWVXQKRO\QLPEXVDQG
WKHPDQFRQIURQWLQJLWVHHPHGXQDEOHWRWDNHKLVH\HVIURPLW+H
VWRRGVWLOOKLVVZRUGGDQJOLQJIURPQHUYHOHVVILQJHUVRQKLVIDFH
WKHH[SUHVVLRQRIDPDQERXQGE\WKHVSHOOVRIDPHVPHULVW
9DOHULDUHDOL]HGWKDWLWZDVQRWIHDUDORQHWKDWSDUDO\]HGKLP
6RPHKHOOLVKTXDOLW\RIWKDWWKUREELQJJORZKDGUREEHGKLPRIKLV
SRZHUWRWKLQNDQGDFW6KHKHUVHOIVDIHO\DERYHWKHVFHQHIHOWWKH
VXEWOHLPSDFWRIDQDPHOHVVHPDQDWLRQWKDWZDVDWKUHDWWRVDQLW\
7KHKRUURUVZHSWWRZDUGLWVYLFWLPDQGKHPRYHGDWODVWEXWRQO\
WRGURSKLVVZRUGDQGVLQNWRKLVNQHHVFRYHULQJKLVH\HVZLWKKLV
KDQGV'XPEO\KHDZDLWHGWKHVWURNHRIWKHEODGHWKDWQRZJOHDPHGLQ
WKHDSSDULWLRQ
VKDQGDVLWUHDUHGDERYHKLPOLNH'HDWKWULXPSKDQW
RYHUPDQNLQG
9DOHULDDFWHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHILUVWLPSXOVHRIKHUZD\ZDUG
QDWXUH:LWKRQHWLJHULVKPRYHPHQWVKHZDVRYHUWKHEDOXVWUDGHDQG
GURSSLQJWRWKHIORRUEHKLQGWKHDZIXOVKDSH,WZKHHOHGDWWKHWKXG
RIKHUVRIWERRWVRQWKHIORRUEXWHYHQDVLWWXUQHGKHUNHHQEODGH
ODVKHGGRZQDQGDILHUFHH[XOWDWLRQVZHSWKHUDVVKHIHOWWKHHGJH
FOHDYHVROLGIOHVKDQGPRUWDOERQH
7KHDSSDULWLRQFULHGRXWJXUJOLQJO\DQGZHQWGRZQVHYHUHGWKURXJK
WKHVKRXOGHUEUHDVWERQHDQGVSLQHDQGDVLWIHOOWKHEXUQLQJVNXOO
UROOHGFOHDUUHYHDOLQJDODQNPRSRIEODFNKDLUDQGDGDUNIDFH
WZLVWHGLQWKHFRQYXOVLRQVRIGHDWK%HQHDWKWKHKRUULILFPDVTXHUDGH
WKHUHZDVDKXPDQEHLQJDPDQVLPLODUWRWKHRQHNQHHOLQJVXSLQHO\
RQWKHIORRU
7KHODWWHUORRNHGXSDWWKHVRXQGRIWKHEORZDQGWKHFU\DQGQRZ
KHJODUHGLQZLOGH\HVDPD]HPHQWDWWKHZKLWHVNLQQHGZRPDQZKRVWRRG
RYHUWKHFRUSVHZLWKDGULSSLQJVZRUGLQKHUKDQG
+HVWDJJHUHGXS\DPPHULQJDVLIWKHVLJKWKDGDOPRVWXQVHDWHGKLV
UHDVRQ6KHZDVDPD]HGWRUHDOL]HWKDWVKHXQGHUVWRRGKLP+HZDV
JLEEHULQJLQWKH6W\JLDQWRQJXHWKRXJKLQDGLDOHFWXQIDPLOLDUWR
KHU
:KRDUH\RX":KHQFHFRPH\RX":KDWGR\RXLQ;XFKRWO"7KHQ
UXVKLQJRQZLWKRXWZDLWLQJIRUKHUWRUHSO\%XW\RXDUHDIULHQG
JRGGHVVRUGHYLOLWPDNHVQRGLIIHUHQFH<RXKDYHVODLQWKH
%XUQLQJ6NXOO,WZDVEXWDPDQEHQHDWKLWDIWHUDOO:HGHHPHGLWD
GHPRQBWKH\BFRQMXUHGXSRXWRIWKHFDWDFRPEVB/LVWHQB
+HVWRSSHGVKRUWLQKLVUDYLQJVDQGVWLIIHQHGVWUDLQLQJKLVHDUV
ZLWKSDLQIXOLQWHQVLW\7KHJLUOKHDUGQRWKLQJ
:HPXVWKDVWHQKHZKLVSHUHGB7KH\BDUHZHVWRIWKH*UHDW
+DOO7KH\PD\EHDOODURXQGXVKHUH7KH\PD\EHFUHHSLQJXSRQXV
HYHQQRZ
+HVHL]HGKHUZULVWLQDFRQYXOVLYHJUDVSVKHIRXQGKDUGWREUHDN
:KRPGR\RXPHDQE\
WKH\"
VKHGHPDQGHG
+HVWDUHGDWKHUXQFRPSUHKHQGLQJO\IRUDQLQVWDQWDVLIKHIRXQG
KHULJQRUDQFHKDUGWRXQGHUVWDQG
7KH\"KHVWDPPHUHGYDJXHO\:K\ZK\WKHSHRSOHRI;RWDODQF
7KHFODQRIWKHPDQ\RXVOHZ7KH\ZKRGZHOOE\WKHHDVWHUQJDWH
<RXPHDQWRVD\WKLVFLW\LVLQKDELWHG"VKHH[FODLPHG
$\H$\H+HZDVZULWKLQJLQWKHLPSDWLHQFHRIDSSUHKHQVLRQ
&RPHDZD\&RPHTXLFN:HPXVWUHWXUQWR7HFXKOWOL
:KHUHLVWKDW"VKHGHPDQGHG
7KHTXDUWHUE\WKHZHVWHUQJDWH+HKDGKHUZULVWDJDLQDQGZDV
SXOOLQJKHUWRZDUGWKHGRRUWKURXJKZKLFKKHKDGILUVWFRPH*UHDW
EHDGVRISHUVSLUDWLRQGULSSHGIURPKLVGDUNIRUHKHDGDQGKLVH\HV
EOD]HGZLWKWHUURU
:DLWDPLQXWHVKHJURZOHGIOLQJLQJRIIKLVKDQG.HHS\RXU
KDQGVRIIPHRU,
OOVSOLW\RXUVNXOO:KDW
VDOOWKLVDERXW":KR
DUH\RX":KHUHZRXOG\RXWDNHPH"
+HWRRNDILUPJULSRQKLPVHOIFDVWLQJJODQFHVWRDOOVLGHVDQG
EHJDQVSHDNLQJVRIDVWKLVZRUGVWULSSHGRYHUHDFKRWKHU
0\QDPHLV7HFKRWO,DPRI7HFKXOWOL,DQGWKLVPDQZKROLHV
ZLWKKLVWKURDWFXWFDPHLQWRWKH+DOOVRI6LOHQFHWRWU\DQGDPEXVK
VRPHRIWKH;RWDODQFDV%XWZHEHFDPHVHSDUDWHGDQG,UHWXUQHGKHUH
WRILQGKLPZLWKKLVJXOOHWVOLW7KH%XUQLQJ6NXOOGLGLW,NQRZ
MXVWDVKHZRXOGKDYHVODLQPHKDG\RXQRWNLOOHGKLP%XWSHUKDPSV
KHZDVQRWDORQH2WKHUVPD\EHVWHDOLQJIURP;RWDODQF7KHJRGV
WKHPVHOYHVEOHQFKDWWKHIDWHRIWKRVHWKH\WDNHDOLYH
$WWKHWKRXJKWKHVKRRNDVZLWKDDJXHDQGKLVGDUNVNLQJUHZ
DVK\9DOHULDIURZQHGSX]]OHGO\DWKLP6KHVHQVHGLQWHOOLJHQFH
EHKLQGWKLVULJPDUROHEXWLWZDVPHDQLQJOHVVWRKHU
6KHWXUQHGWRZDUGWKHVNXOOZKLFKVWLOOJORZHGDQGSXOVHGRQWKH
IORRUDQGZDVUHDFKLQJDERRWHGWRHWHQWDWLYHO\WRZDUGLWZKHQWKH
PDQZKRFDOOHGKLPVHOI7HFKRWOVSUDQJIRUZDUGZLWKDFU\
'RQRWWRXFKLW'RQRWHYHQORRNDWLW0DGQHVVDQGGHDWKOXUN
LQLW7KHZL]DUGVRI;RWDODQFXQGHUVWDQGLWVVHFUHWWKH\IRXQGLW
LQWKHFDWDFRPEVZKHUHOLHWKHERQHVRIWHUULEOHNLQJVZKRUXOHGLQ
;XFKRWOLQWKHEODFNFHQWXULHVRIWKHSDVW7RJD]HXSRQLWIUHH]HV
WKHEORRGDQGZLWKHUVWKHEUDLQRIDPDQZKRXQGHUVWDQGVQRWLWV
P\VWHU\7RWRXFKLWFDXVHVPDGQHVVDQGGHVWUXFWLRQ
6KHVFRZOHGDWKLPXQFHUWDLQO\+HZDVQRWDUHDVVXULQJILJXUH
ZLWKKLVOHDQPXVFOHNQRWWHGIUDPHDQGVQDN\ORFNV,QKLVH\HV
EHKLQGWKHJORZRIWHUURUOXUNHGDZHLUGOLJKWVKHKDGQHYHUVHHQLQ
WKHH\HVRIDPDQZKROO\VDQH<HWKHVHHPHGVLQFHUHLQKLV
SURWHVWDWLRQV
&RPHKHEHJJHGUHDFKLQJIRUKHUKDQGDQGWKHQUHFRLOLQJDVKH
UHPHPEHUHGKHUZDUQLQJ<RXDUHDVWUDQJHU+RZ\RXFDPHKHUH,GR
QRWNQRZEXWLI\RXZHUHDJRGGHVVRUDGHPRQFRPHWRDLG
7HFXKOWOL\RXZRXOGNQRZDOOWKHWKLQJV\RXKDYHDVNHGPH<RXPXVW
EHIURPEH\RQGWKHJUHDWIRUHVWZKHQFHRXUDQFHVWRUVFDPH%XW\RX
DUHRXUIULHQGRU\RXZRXOGQRWKDYHVODLQP\HQHP\&RPHTXLFNO\
EHIRUHWKH;RWDODQFDVILQGXVDQGVOD\XV
)URPKLVUHSHOOHQWLPSDVVLRQHGIDFHVKHJODQFHGWRWKHVLQLVWHU
VNXOOVPROGHULQJDQGJORZLQJRQWKHIORRUQHDUWKHGHDGPDQ,WZDV
OLNHDVNXOOVHHQLQDGUHDPXQGHQLDEO\KXPDQ\HWZLWKGLVWXUELQJ
GLVWRUWLRQVDQGPDOIRUPDWLRQVRIFRQWRXUDQGRXWOLQH,QOLIHWKH
ZHDUHURIWKDWVNXOOPXVWKDYHSUHVHQWHGDQDOLHQDQGPRQVWURXV
DVSHFW/LIH",WVHHPHGWRSRVVHVVVRPHVRUWRIOLIHRILWVRZQ,WV
MDZV\DZQHGDWKHUDQGVQDSSHGWRJHWKHU,WVUDGLDQFHJUHZEULJKWHU
PRUHYLYLG\HWWKHLPSUHVVLRQRIQLJKWPDUHJUHZWRRLWZDVDGUHDP
DOOOLIHZDVDGUHDPLWZDV7HFKRWO
VXUJHQWYRLFHZKLFKVQDSSHG
9DOHULDEDFNIURPWKHGLPJXOIVZKLWKHUVKHZDVGULIWLQJ
'RQRWORRNDWWKHVNXOO'RQRWORRNDWWKHVNXOO,WZDVDIDU
FU\IURPDFURVVXQUHFNRQHGYRLGV
9DOHULDVKRRNKHUVHOIOLNHDOLRQVKDNLQJKLVPDQH+HUYLVLRQ
FOHDUHG7HFKRWOZDVFKDWWHULQJ,QOLIHLWKRXVHGWKHDZIXOEUDLQ
RIDNLQJRIPDJLFLDQV,WKROGVVWLOOWKHOLIHDQGILUHRIPDJLF
GUDZQIURPRXWHUVSDFHV
:LWKDFXUVH9DOHULDOHDSHGOLWKHDVDSDQWKHUDQGWKHVNXOO
FUDVKHGWRIODPLQJELWVXQGHUKHUVZLQJLQJVZRUG6RPHZKHUHLQWKH
URRPRULQWKHYRLGRULQWKHGLPUHDFKHVRIKHUFRQVFLRXVQHVVDQ
LQKXPDQYRLFHFULHGRXWLQSDLQDQGUDJH
7HFKRWO
VKDQGZDVSOXFNLQJDWKHUDUPDQGKHZDVJLEEHULQJ<RX
KDYHEURNHQLW<RXKDYHGHVWUR\HGLW1RWDOOWKHEODFNDUWVRI
;RWDODQFFDQUHEXLOGLW&RPHDZD\&RPHDZD\TXLFNO\QRZ
%XW,FDQ
WJRVKHSURWHVWHG,KDYHDIULHQGVRPHZKHUHQHDU
E\
7KHIODUHRIKLVH\HVFXWKHUVKRUWDVKHVWDUHGSDVWKHUZLWKDQ
H[SUHVVLRQJURZQJKDVWO\6KHZKHHOHGMXVWDVIRXUPHQUXVKHGWKURXJK
DVPDQ\GRRUVFRQYHUJLQJRQWKHSDLULQWKHFHQWHURIWKHFKDPEHU
7KH\ZHUHOLNHWKHRWKHUVVKHKDGVHHQWKHVDPHNQRWWHGPXVFOHV
EXOJLQJRQRWKHUZLVHJDXQWOLPEVWKHVDPHODQNEOXHEODFNKDLUWKH
VDPHPDGJODUHLQWKHLUZLOGH\HV7KH\ZHUHDUPHGDQGFODGOLNH
7HFKRWOEXWRQWKHEUHDVWRIHDFKZDVSDLQWHGDZKLWHVNXOO
7KHUHZHUHQRFKDOOHQJHVRUZDUFULHV/LNHEORRGPDGWLJHUVWKH
PHQRI;RWDODQFVSUDQJDWWKHWKURDWVRIWKHLUHQHPLHV7HFKRWOPHW
WKHPZLWKWKHIXU\RIGHVSHUDWLRQGXFNHGWKHVZLSHRIDZLGHKHDGHG
EODGHDQGJUDSSOHGZLWKWKHZLHOGHUDQGERUHKLPWRWKHIORRUZKHUH
WKH\UROOHGDQGZUHVWOHGLQPXUGHURXVVLOHQFH
7KHRWKHUWKUHHVZDUPHGRQ9DOHULDWKHLUZHLUGH\HVUHGDVWKH
H\HVRIPDGGRJV
6KHNLOOHGWKHILUVWZKRFDPHZLWKLQUHDFKEHIRUHKHFRXOGVWULNH
DEORZKHUORQJVWUDLJKWEODGHVSOLWWLQJKLVVNXOOHYHQDVKLVRZQ
VZRUGOLIWHGIRUDVWURNH6KHVLGHVWHSSHGDWKUXVWHYHQDVVKH
SDUULHGDVODVK+HUH\HVGDQFHGDQGKHUOLSVVPLOHGZLWKRXWPHUF\
$JDLQVKHZDV9DOHULDRIWKH5HG%URWKHUKRRGDQGWKHKXPRIKHU
VWHHOZDVOLNHDEULGDOVRQJLQKHUHDUV
+HUVZRUGGDUWHGSDVWDEODGHWKDWVRXJKWWRSDUU\DQGVKHDWKHG
VL[LQFKHVRILWVSRLQWLQDOHDWKHUJXDUGHGPLGULII7KHPDQJDVSHG
DJRQL]HGO\DQGZHQWWRKLVNQHHVEXWKLVWDOOPDWHOXQJHGLQLQ
IHURFLRXVVLOHQFHUDLQLQJEORZRQEORZVRIXULRXVO\WKDW9DOHULDKDG
QRRSSRUWXQLW\WRFRXQWHU6KHVWHSSHGEDFNFRROO\SDUU\LQJWKH
VWURNHVDQGZDWFKLQJIRUKHUFKDQFHWRWKUXVWKRPH+HFRXOGQRWORQJ
NHHSXSWKDWIODLOLQJZKLUOZLQG+LVDUPZRXOGWLUHKLVZLQGZRXOG
IDLOKHZRXOGZHDNHQIDOWHUDQGWKHQKHUEODGHZRXOGVOLGH
VPRRWKO\LQWRKLVKHDUW$VLGHORQJJODQFHVKRZHGKHU7HFKRWO
NQHHOLQJRQWKHEUHDVWRIKLVDQWDJRQLVWDQGVWULYLQJWREUHDNWKH
RWKHU
VKROGRQKLVZULVWDQGWRGULYHKRPHDGDJJHU
6ZHDWEHDGHGWKHIRUHKHDGRIWKHPDQIDFLQJKHUDQGKLVH\HVZHUH
OLNHEXUQLQJFRDOV6PLWHDVKHZRXOGKHFRXOGQRWEUHDNSDVWQRU
EHDWGRZQKHUJXDUG+LVEUHDWKFDPHLQJXVW\JXOSVKLVEORZVEHJDQ
WRIDOOHUUDWLFDOO\6KHVWHSSHGEDFNWRGUDZKLPRXWDQGIHOWKHU
WKLJKVORFNHGLQDQLURQJULS6KHKDGIRUJRWWHQWKHZRXQGHGPDQRQ
WKHIORRU
&URXFKLQJRQKLVNQHHVKHKHOGKHUZLWKERWKDUPVORFNHGDERXW
KHUOHJVDQGKLVPDWHFURDNHGLQWULXPSKDQGEHJDQZRUNLQJKLVZD\
DURXQGWRFRPHDWKHUIURPWKHOHIWVLGH9DOHULDZUHQFKHGDQGWRUH
VDYDJHO\EXWLQYDLQ6KHFRXOGIUHHKHUVHOIRIWKLVFOLQJLQJPHQDFH
ZLWKDGRZQZDUGIOLFNRIKHUVZRUGEXWLQWKDWLQVWDQWWKHFXUYHG
EODGHRIWKHWDOOZDUULRUZRXOGFUDVKWKURXJKKHUVNXOO7KHZRXQGHG
PDQEHJDQWRZRUU\DWKHUEDUHWKLJKZLWKKLVWHHWKOLNHDZLOG
EHDVW
6KHUHDFKHGGRZQZLWKKHUOHIWKDQGDQGJULSSHGKLVORQJKDLU
IRUFLQJKLVKHDGEDFNVRWKDWKLVZKLWHWHHWKDQGUROOLQJH\HV
JOHDPHGXSDWKHU7KHWDOO;RWDODQFFULHGRXWILHUFHO\DQGOHDSHG
LQVPLWLQJZLWKDOOWKHIXU\RIKLVDUP$ZNZDUGO\VKHSDUULHGWKH
VWURNHDQGLWEHDWWKHIODWRIKHUEODGHGRZQRQKHUKHDGVRWKDW
VKHVDZVSDUNVIODVKEHIRUHKHUH\HVDQGVWDJJHUHG8SZHQWWKH
VZRUGDJDLQZLWKDORZEHDVWOLNHFU\RIWULXPSKDQGWKHQD
JLDQWIRUPORRPHGEHKLQGWKH;RWDODQFDQGVWHHOIODVKHGOLNHDMHWRI
EOXHOLJKWQLQJ7KHFU\RIWKHZDUULRUEURNHVKRUWDQGKHZHQWGRZQ
OLNHDQR[EHQHDWKWKHSROHD[KLVEUDLQVJXVKLQJIURPKLVVNXOO
WKDWKDGEHHQVSOLWWRWKHWKURDW
&RQDQJDVSHG9DOHULD,QDJXVWRISDVVLRQVKHWXUQHGRQWKH
;RWDODQFZKRVHORQJKDLUVKHVWLOOJULSSHGLQKHUOHIWKDQG'RJRI
KHOO+HUEODGHVZLVKHGDVLWFXWWKHDLULQDQXSVZLQJLQJDUFZLWK
DEOXULQWKHPLGGOHDQGWKHKHDGOHVVERG\VOXPSHGGRZQVSXUWLQJ
EORRG6KHKXUOHGWKHVHYHUHGKHDGDFURVVWKHURRP
:KDWWKHGHYLO
VJRLQJRQKHUH"&RQDQEHVWURGHWKHFRUSVHRIWKH
PDQKHKDGNLOOHGEURDGVZRUGLQKDQGJODULQJDERXWKLPLQ
DPD]HPHQW
7HFKRWOZDVULVLQJIURPWKHWZLWFKLQJILJXUHRIWKHODVW;RWDODQF
VKDNLQJUHGGURSVIURPKLVGDJJHU+HZDVEOHHGLQJIURPWKHVWDEGHHS
LQWKHWKLJK+HVWDUHGDW&RQDQZLWKGLODWHGH\HV
:KDWLVDOOWKLV"&RQDQGHPDQGHGDJDLQQRW\HWUHFRYHUHGIURP
WKHVWXQQLQJVXUSULVHRIILQGLQJ9DOHULDHQJDJHGLQDVDYDJHEDWWOH
ZLWKWKLVIDQWDVWLFILJXUHVLQDFLW\KHKDGWKRXJKWHPSW\DQG
XQLQKDELWHG5HWXUQLQJIURPDQDLPOHVVH[SORUDWLRQRIWKHXSSHU
FKDPEHUVWRILQG9DOHULDPLVVLQJIURPWKHURRPZKHUHKHKDGOHIWKHU
KHKDGIROORZHGWKHVRXQGVRIVWULIHWKDWEXUVWRQKLVGXPIRXQGHG
HDUV
)LYHGHDGGRJVH[FODLPHG7HFKRWOKLVIODPLQJH\HVUHIOHFWLQJD
JKDVWO\H[XOWDWLRQ)LYHVODLQ)LYHFULPVRQQDLOVIRUWKHEODFN
SLOODU7KHJRGVRIEORRGEHWKDQNHG
+HOLIHGTXLYHULQJKDQGVRQKLJKDQGWKHQZLWKWKHIDFHRID
ILHQGKHVSDWRQWKHFRUSVHVDQGVWDPSHGRQWKHLUIDFHVGDQFLQJLQ
KLVJKRXOLVKJOHH+LVUHFHQWDOOLHVH\HGKLPLQDPD]HPHQWDQG&RQDQ
DVNHGLQWKH$TXLORQLDQWRQJXH:KRLVWKLVPDGPDQ"
9DOHULDVKUXJJHGKHUVKRXOGHUV
+HVD\VKLVQDPH
V7HFKRWO)URPKLVEDEEOLQJV,JDWKHUWKDWKLV
SHRSOHOLYHDWRQHHQGRIWKLVFUD]\FLW\DQGWKHVHRWKHUVDWWKH
RWKHUHQG0D\EHZH
GEHWWHUJRZLWKKLP+HVHHPVIULHQGO\DQGLW
V
HDV\WRVHHWKDWWKHRWKHUFODQLVQ
W
7HFKRWOKDGFHDVHGKLVGDQFLQJDQGZDVOLVWHQLQJDJDLQKLVKHDG
WLOWHGVLGHZLVHGRJOLNHWULXPSKVWUXJJOLQJZLWKIHDULQKLV
UHSHOOHQWFRXQWHQDQFH
&RPHDZD\QRZKHZKLVSHUHG:HKDYHGRQHHQRXJK)LYHGHDG
GRJV0\SHRSOHZLOOZHOFRPH\RX7KH\ZLOOKRQRU\RX%XWFRPH,W
LVIDUWR7HFXKOWOL$WDQ\PRPHQWWKH;RWDODQFVPD\FRPHRQXVLQ
QXPEHUVWRRJUHDWHYHQIRU\RXUVZRUGV
/HDGWKHZD\JUXQWHG&RQDQ
7HFKRWOLQVWDQWO\PRXQWHGDVWDLUOHDGLQJXSWRWKHJDOOHU\
EHFNRQLQJWKHPWRIROORZKLPZKLFKWKH\GLGPRYLQJUDSLGO\WRNHHS
RQKLVKHHOV+DYLQJUHDFKHGWKHJDOOHU\KHSOXQJHGLQWRDGRRUWKDW
RSHQHGWRZDUGWKHZHVWDQGKXUULHGWKURXJKFKDPEHUDIWHUFKDPEHU
HDFKOLJKWHGE\VN\OLJKWVRUJUHHQILUHMHZHOV
:KDWVRUWRISODFHFDQWKLVEH"PXWWHUHG9DOHULDXQGHUKHU
EUHDWK
&URPNQRZVDQVZHUHG&RQDQ,
YHVHHQBKLVBNLQGEHIRUH
WKRXJK7KH\OLYHRQWKHVKRUHVRI/DNH=XDGQHDUWKHERUGHURI
.XVK7KH\
UHDVRUWRIPRQJUHO6W\JLDQVPL[HGZLWKDQRWKHUUDFH
WKDWZDQGHUHGLQWR6W\JLDIURPWKHHDVWVRPHFHQWXULHVDJRDQGZHUH
DEVRUEHGE\WKHP7KH\
UHFDOOHG7OD]LWODQV,
PZLOOLQJWREHWLW
ZDVQ
WWKH\ZKREXLOWWKLVFLW\WKRXJK
7HFKRWO
VIHDUGLGQRWVHPWRGLPLQLVKDVWKH\GUHZDZD\IURPWKH
FKDPEHUZKHUHWKHGHDGPHQOD\+HNHSWWZLVWLQJKLVKHDGRQKLV
VKRXOGHUWROLVWHQIRUVRXQGVRISXUVXLWDQGVWDUHGZLWKEXUQLQJ
LQWHQVLW\LQWRHYHU\GRRUZD\WKH\SDVVHG
9DOHULDVKLYHUHGLQVSLWHRIKHUVHOI6KHIHDUHGQRPDQ%XWWKH
ZHLUGIORRUEHQHDWKKHUIHHWWKHXQFDQQ\MHZHOVRYHUKHUKHDG
GLYLGLQJWKHOXUNLQJVKDGRZVDPRQJWKHPWKHVWHDOWKDQGWHUURURI
WKHLUJXLGHLPSUHVVHGKHUZLWKDQDPHOHVVDSSUHKHQVLRQDVHQVDWLRQ
RIOXUNLQJLQKXPDQSHULO
7KH\PD\EHEHWZHHQXVDQG7HFXKOWOLKHZKLVSHUHGRQFH:H
PXVWEHZDUHOHVWWKH\EHO\LQJLQZDLW
:K\GRQ
WZHJHWRXWRIWKLVLQIHUQDOSDODFHDQGWDNHWRWKH
VWUHHWV"GHPDQGHG9DOHULD
7KHUHDUHQRVWUHHWVLQ;XFKRWOKHDQVZHUHG1RVTXDUHVQRU
RSHQFRXUWV7KHZKROHFLW\LVEXLOWOLNHRQHJLDQWSDODFHXQGHURQH
JUHDWURRI7KHQHDUHVWDSSURDFKWRDVWUHHWLVWKH*UHDW+DOOZKLFK
WUDYHUVHVWKHFLW\IURPWKHQRUWKJDWHWRWKHVRXWKJDWH7KHRQO\
GRRUVRSHQLQJLQWRWKHRXWHUZRUOGDUHWKHFLW\JDWHVWKURXJKZKLFK
QROLYLQJPDQKDVSDVVHGIRUILIW\\HDUV
+RZORQJKDYH\RXGZHOWKHUH"DVNHG&RQDQ
,ZDVERUQLQWKHFDVWOHRI7HFXKOWOLWKLUW\ILYH\HDUVDJR,
KDYHQHYHUVHWIRRWRXWVLGHWKHFLW\)RUWKHORYHRIWKHJRGVOHW
XVJRVLOHQWO\7KHVHKDOOVPD\EHIXOORIOXUNLQJGHYLOV2OPHF
VKDOOWHOO\RXDOOZKHQZHUHDFK7HFXKOWOL
6RLQVLOHQFHWKH\JOLGHGRQZLWKWKHJUHHQILUHVWRQHVEOLQNLQJ
RYHUKHDGDQGWKHIODPLQJIORRUVVPROGHULQJXQGHUWKHLUIHHWDQGLW
VHHPHGWR9DOHULDDVLIWKH\IOHGWKURXJK+HOOJXLGHGE\DGDUN
IDFHGODQNKDLUHGJREOLQ
<HWLWZDV&RQDQZKRKDOWHGWKHPDVWKH\ZHUHFURVVLQJDQ
XQXVXDOO\ZLGHFKDPEHU+LVZLOGHUQHVVEUHGHDUVZHUHNHHQHUHYHQ
WKDQWKHHDUVRI7HFKRWOZKHWWHGWKRXJKWKHVHZHUHE\DOLIHWLPHRI
ZDUIDUHLQWKLVVLOHQWFRUULGRUV
<RXWKLQNVRPHRI\RXUHQHPLHVPD\EHDKHDGRIXVO\LQJLQ
DPEXVK"
7KH\SURZOWKURXJKWKHVHURRPVDWDOOKRXUVDQVZHUHG7HFKRWO
DVGRZH7KHKDOOVDQGFKDPEHUVEHWZHHQ7HFXKOWOLDQG;RWDODQFDUH
DGLVSXWHGUHJLRQRZQHGE\QRPDQ:HFDOOLWWKH+DOOVRI6LOHQFH
:K\GR\RXDVN"
%HFDXVHPHQDUHLQWKHFKDPEHUVDKHDGRIXVDQVZHUHG&RQDQ,
KHDUGVWHHOFOLQNDJDLQVWVWRQH
$JDLQDVKDNLQJVHL]HG7HFKRWODQGKHFOHQFKHGKLVWHHWKWRNHHS
WKHPIURPFKDWWHULQJ
3HUKDSVWKH\DUH\RXUIULHQGVVXJJHVWHG9DOHULD
:HGDUHQRWFKDQFHLWKHSDQWHGDQGPRYHGZLWKIUHQ]LHG
DFWLYLW\+HWXUQHGDVLGHDQGJOLGHGWKURXJKDGRRUZD\RQWKHOHIW
ZKLFKOHGLQWRDFKDPEHUIURPZKLFKDQLYRU\VWDLUFDVHZRXQGGRZQ
LQWRGDUNQHVV
7KLVOHDGVWRDQXQOLJKWHGFRUULGRUEHORZXVKHKLVVHGJUHDW
EHDGVRISHUVSLUDWLRQVWDQGLQJRXWRQKLVEURZ7KH\PD\EHOXUNLQJ
WKHUHWRR,WPD\DOOEHDWULFNWRGUDZXVLQWRLW%XWZHPXVW
WDNHWKHFKDQFHWKDWWKH\KDYHODLGWKHLUDPEXVKLQWKHURRPVDERYH
&RPHVZLIWO\QRZ
6RIWO\DVSKDQWRPVWKH\GHVFHQGHGWKHVWDLUDQGFDPHWRWKHPRXWK
RIDFRUULGRUEODFNDVQLJKW7KH\FURXFKHGWKHUHIRUDPRPHQW
OLVWHQLQJDQGWKHQPHOWHGLQWRLW$VWKH\PRYHGDORQJ9DOHULD
V
IOHVKFUDZOHGEHWZHHQKHUVKRXOGHUVLQPRPHQWDU\H[SHFWDWLRQRID
VZRUGWKUXVWLQWKHGDUN%XWIRU&RQDQ
VLURQILQJHUVJULSSLQJKHU
DUPVKHKDGQRSK\VLFDOFRJQL]DQFHRIKHUFRPSDQLRQV1HLWKHUPDGHDV
PXFKQRLVHDVDFDWZRXOGKDYHPDGH7KHGDUNQHVVZDVDEVROXWH2QH
KDQGRXWVWUHWFKHGWRXFKHGDZDOODQGRFFDVLRQDOO\VKHIHOWDGRRU
XQGHUKHUILQJHUV7KHKDOOZD\VHHPHGLQWHUPLQDEOH
6XGGHQO\WKH\ZHUHJDOYDQL]HGE\DVRXQGEHKLQGWKHP9DOHULD
V
IOHVKFUDZOHGDQHZIRUVKHUHFRJQL]HGLWDVWKHVRIWRSHQLQJRID
GRRU0HQKDGFRPHLQWRWKHFRUULGRUEHKLQGWKHP(YHQZLWKWKH
WKRXJKWVKHVWXPEOHGRYHUVRPHWKLQJWKDWIHOWOLNHDKXPDQVNXOO,W
UROOHGDFURVVWKHIORRUZLWKDQDSSDOOLQJFODWWHU
5XQ\HOSHG7HFKRWODQRWHRIK\VWHULDLQKLVYRLFHDQGZDV
DZD\GRZQWKHFRUULGRUOLNHDIO\LQJJKRVW
$JDLQ9DOHULDIHOW&RQDQ
VKDQGEHDULQJKHUXSDQGVZHHSLQJKHU
DORQJDVWKH\UDFHGDIWHUWKHLUJXLGH&RQDQFRXOGVHHLQWKHGDUNQR
EHWWHUWKDQVKHEXWKHSRVVHVVHGDVRUWRILQVWLQFWWKDWPDGHKLV
FRXUVHXQHUULQJ:LWKRXWKLVVXSSRUWDQGJXLGDQFHVKHZRXOGKDYH
IDOOHQRUVWXPEOHGDJDLQVWWKHZDOO'RZQWKHFRUULGRUWKH\VSHG
ZKLOHWKHVZLIWSDWWHURIIO\LQJIHHWGUHZFORVHUDQGFORVHUDQG
WKHQVXGGHQO\7HFKRWOSDQWHG+HUHLVWKHVWDLU$IWHUPHTXLFN
2KTXLFN
+LVKDQGFDPHRXWRIWKHGDUNDQGFDXJKW9DOHULD
VZULVWDVVKH
VWXPEOHGEOLQGO\RQWKHVWHSV6KHIHOWKHUVHOIKDOIGUDJJHGKDOI
OLIWHGXSWKHZLQGLQJVWDLUZKLOH&RQDQUHOHDVHGKHUDQGWXUQHGRQ
WKHVWHSVKLVHDUVDQGLQVWLQFWVWHOOLQJKLPWKHLUIRHVZHUHKDUGDW
WKHLUEDFNVB$QGWKHVRXQGVZHUHQRWDOOWKRVHRIKXPDQIHHWB
6RPHWKLQJFDPHZULWKLQJXSWKHVWHSVVRPHWKLQJWKDWVOLWKHUHGDQG
UXVWOHGDQGEURXJKWDFKLOOLQWKHDLUZLWKLW&RQDQODVKHGGRZQ
ZLWKKLVJUHDWVZRUGDQGIHOWWKHEODGHVKHDUWKURXJKVRPHWKLQJWKDW
PLJKWKDYHEHHQIOHVKDQGERQHDQGFXWGHHSLQWRWKHVWDLUEHQHDWK
6RPHWKLQJWRXFKHGKLVIRRWWKDWFKLOOHGOLNHWKHWRXFKRIIURVWDQG
WKHQWKHGDUNQHVVEHQHDWKKLPZDVGLVWXUEHGE\DIULJKWIXOWKUDVKLQJ
DQGODVKLQJDQGDPDQFULHGRXWLQDJRQ\
7KHQH[WPRPHQW&RQDQZDVUDFLQJXSWKHZLQGLQJVWDLUFDVHDQG
WKURXJKDGRRUWKDWVWRRGRSHQDWWKHKHDG
9DOHULDDQG7HFKRWOZHUHDOUHDG\WKURXJKDQG7HFKRWOVODPPHGWKH
GRRUDQGVKRWDEROWDFURVVLWWKHILUVW&RQDQKDGVHHQVLQFHWKH\
KDGOHIWWKHRXWHUJDWH
7KHQKHWXUQHGDQGUDQDFURVVWKHZHOOOLJKWHGFKDPEHULQWRZKLFK
WKH\KDGFRPHDQGDVWKH\SDVVHGWKURXJKWKHIDUWKHUGRRU&RQDQ
JODQFHGEDFNDQGVDZWKHGRRUJURDQLQJDQGVWUDLQLQJXQGHUKHDY\
SUHVVXUHYLROHQWO\DSSOLHGIURPWKHRWKHUVLGH
7KRXJK7HFKRWOGLGQRWDEDWHHLWKHUKLVVSHHGRUKLVFDXWLRQKH
VHHPHGPRUHFRQILGHQWQRZ+HKDGWKHDLURIDPDQZKRKDGFRPHLQWR
IDPLOLDUWHUULWRU\ZLWKLQFDOORIIULHQGV
%XW&RQDQUHQHZHGKLVWHUURUE\DVNLQJ:KDWZDVWKDWWKLQJ,
IRXJKWRQWKHVWDLUV"
7KHPHQRI;RWDODQFDQVZHUHG7HFKRWOZLWKRXWORRNLQJEDFN,
WROG\RXWKHKDOOVZHUHIXOORIWKHP
7KLVZDVQ
WDPDQJUXQWHG&RQDQ,WZDVVRPHWKLQJWKDW
FUDZOHGDQGLWZDVDVFROGDVLFHWRWKHWRXFK,WKLQN,FXWLW
DVXQGHU,WIHOOEDFNRQWKHPHQZKRZHUHIROORZLQJXVDQGPXVWKDYH
NLOOHGRQHRIWKHPLQLWVGHDWKWKURHV
7HFKRWO
VKHDGMHUNHGEDFNKLVIDFHDVK\DJDLQ&RQYXOVLYHO\KH
TXLFNHQHGKLVSDFH
,WZDVWKH&UDZOHU$PRQVWHUBWKH\BKDYHEURXJKWRXWRIWKH
FDWDFRPEVWRDLGWKHP:KDWLWLVZHGRQRWNQRZEXWZHKDYHIRXQG
RXUSHRSOHKLGHRXVO\VODLQE\LW,Q6HW
VQDPHKDVWHQ,IWKH\SXW
LWRQRXUWUDLOLWZLOOIROORZXVWRWKHYHU\GRRUVRI7HFXKOWOL
,GRXEWLWJUXQWHG&RQDQ7KDWZDVDVKUHZGFXW,GHDOWLWRQ
WKHVWDLU
+DVWHQ+DVWHQJURDQHG7HFKRWO
7KH\UDQWKURXJKDVHULHVRIJUHHQOLWFKDPEHUVWUDYHUVHGDEURDG
KDOODQGKDOWHGEHIRUHDJLDQWEURQ]HGRRU
7HFKRWOVDLG7KLVLV7HFXKOWOL


7KH3HRSOHRIWKH)HXG

7HFKRWOVPRWHRQWKHEURQ]HGRRUZLWKKLVFOHQFKHGKDQGDQGWKHQ
WXUQHGVLGHZLVHVRWKDWKHFRXOGZDWFKEDFNDORQJWKHKDOO
0HQKDYHEHHQVPLWWHQGRZQEHIRUHWKLVGRRUZKHQWKH\WKRXJKW
WKH\ZHUHVDIHKHVDLG
:K\GRQ
WWKH\RSHQWKHGRRU"DVNHG&RQDQ
7KH\DUHORRNLQJDWXVWKURXJKWKH(\HDQVZHUHG7HFKRWO7KH\
DUHSX]]OHGDWWKHVLJKWRI\RX+HOLIWHGKLVYRLFHDQGFDOOHG
2SHQWKHGRRU([FHODQ,WLV,7HFKRWOZLWKIULHQGVIURPWKH
JUHDWZRUOGEH\RQGWKHIRUHVW7KH\ZLOORSHQKHDVVXUHGKLV
DOOLHV
7KH\
GEHWWHUGRLWLQDKXUU\WKHQVDLG&RQDQJULPO\,KHDU
VRPHWKLQJFUDZOLQJDORQJWKHIORRUEH\RQGWKHKDOO
7HFKRWOZHQWDVK\DJDLQDQGDWWDFNHGWKHGRRUZLWKKLVILVWV
VFUHDPLQJ2SHQ\RXIRROVRSHQ7KH&UDZOHULVDWRXUKHHOV
(YHQDVKHEHDWDQGVKRXWHGWKHJUHDWEURQ]HGRRUVZXQJ
QRLVHOHVVO\EDFNUHYHDOLQJDKHDY\FKDLQDFURVVWKHHQWUDQFHRYHU
ZKLFKVSHDUKHDGVEULVWOHGDQGILHUFHFRXQWHQDQFHVUHJDUGHGWKHP
LQWHQWO\IRUDQLQVWDQW7KHQWKHFKDLQZDVGURSSHGDQG7HFKRWO
JUDVSHGWKHDUPVRIKLVIULHQGVLQDQHUYRXVIUHQ]\DQGIDLUO\
GUDJJHGWKHPRYHUWKHWKUHVKROG$JODQFHRYHUKLVVKRXOGHUMXVWDV
WKHGRRUZDVFORVLQJVKRZHG&RQDQWKHORQJGLPYLVWDRIWKHKDOODQG
GLPO\IUDPHGDWWKHRWKHUHQGDQRSKLGLDQVKDSHWKDWZULWKHGVORZO\
DQGSDLQIXOO\LQWRYLHZIORZLQJLQDGXOOKXHGOHQJWKIURPDFKDPEHU
GRRULWVKLGHRXVEORRGVWDLQHGKHDGZDJJLQJGUXQNHQO\7KHQWKH
FORVLQJGRRUVKXWRIIWKHYLHZ
,QVLGHWKHVTXDUHFKDPEHULQWRZKLFKWKH\KDGFRPHKHDY\EROWV
ZHUHGUDZQDFURVVWKHIRRUDQGWKHFKDLQORFNHGLQWRSODFH7KHGRRU
ZDVPDGHWRVWDQGWKHEDWWHULQJRIDVLHJH)RXUPHQVWRRGRQJXDUG
RIWKHVDPHODQNKDLUHGGDUNVNLQQHGEUHHGDV7HFKRWOZLWKVSHDUV
LQWKHLUKDQGVDQGVZRUGVDWWKHLUKLSV,QWKHZDOOQHDUWKHGRRU
WKHUHZDVDFRPSOLFDWHGFRQWULYDQFHRIPLUURUVZKLFK&RQDQJXHVVHG
ZDVWKH(\H7HFKRWOKDGPHQWLRQHGVRDUUDQJHGWKDWDQDUURZ
FU\VWDOSDQHGVORWLQWKHZDOOFRXOGEHORRNHGWKURXJKIURPZLWKLQ
ZLWKRXWEHLQJGLVFHUQLEOHIURPZLWKRXW7KHIRXUJXDUGVPHQVWDUHGDW
WKHVWUDQJHUVZLWKZRQGHUEXWDVNHGQRTXHVWLRQQRUGLG7HFKRWO
YRXFKVDIHDQ\LQIRUPDWLRQ+HPRYHGZLWKHDV\FRQILGHQFHQRZDVLI
KHKDGVKHGKLVFORDNRILQGHFLVLRQDQGIHDUWKHLQVWDQWKHFURVVHG
WKHWKUHVKROG
&RPHKHXUJHGKLVQHZIRXQGIULHQGVEXW&RQDQJODQFHGWRZDUG
WKHGRRU
:KDWDERXWWKRVHIHOORZVZKRZHUHIROORZLQJXV":RQ
WWKH\WU\WR
VWRUPWKDWGRRU"
7HFKRWOVKRRNKLVKHDG
7KH\NQRZWKH\FDQQRWEUHDNGRZQWKH'RRURIWKH(DJOH7KH\ZLOO
IOHHEDFNWR;RWDODQFZLWKWKHLUFUDZOLQJILHQG&RPH,ZLOOWDNH
\RXWRWKHUXOHUVRI7HFXKOWOL
2QHRIWKHIRXUJXDUGVRSHQHGWKHGRRURSSRVLWHWKHRQHE\ZKLFK
WKH\KDGHQWHUHGDQGWKH\SDVVHGWKURXJKLQWRDKDOOZD\ZLFKOLNH
PRVWRIWKHURRPVRQWKDWOHYHOZDVOLJKWHGE\ERWKWKHVORWOLNH
VN\OLJKWVDQGWKHFOXVWHUVRIZLQNLQJILUHJHPV%XWXQOLNHWKHRWKHU
URRPVWKH\KDGWUDYHUVHGWKLVKDOOVKRZHGHYLGHQFHVRIRFFXSDWLRQ
9HOYHWWDSHVWULHVDGRUQHGWKHJORVV\MDGHZDOOVULFKUXJVZHUHRQ
WKHFULPVRQIORRUVDQGWKHLYRU\VHDWVEHQFKHVDQGGLYDQVZHUH
OLWWHUHGZLWKVDWLQFXVKLRQV
7KHKDOOHQGHGLQDQRUQDWHGRRUEHIRUHZKLFKVWRRGQRJXDUG
:LWKRXWFHUHPRQ\7HFKRWOWKUXVWWKHGRRURSHQDQGXVKHUHGKLVIULHQGV
LQWRDEURDGFKDPEHUZKHUHVRPHWKLUW\GDUNVNLQQHGPHQDQGZRPHQ
ORXQJHGRQVDWLQFRYHUHGFRXFKHVVSUDQJXSZLWKH[FODPDWLRQVRI
DPD]HPHQW
7KHPHQDOOH[FHSWRQHZHUHRIWKHVDPHW\SHDV7HFKRWODQGWKH
ZRPHQZHUHHTXDOO\GDUNDQGVWUDQJHH\HGWKRXJKQRWXQEHDXWLIXOLQD
ZHLUGGDUNZD\7KH\ZRUHVDQGDOVJROGHQEUHDVWSODWHVDQGVFDQW\
VLONVNLUWVVXSSRUWHGE\JHPFUXVWHGJLUGOHVDQGWKHLUEODFNPDQHV
FXWVTXDUHDWWKHLUQDNHGVKRXOGHUVZHUHERXQGZLWKVLOYHUFLUFOHWV
2QDZLGHLYRU\VHDWRQDMDGHGDLVVDWDPDQDQGDZRPDQZKR
GLIIHUHGVXEWO\IURPWKHRWKHUV+HZDVDJLDQWZLWKDQHQRUPRXV
VZHHSRIEUHDVWDQGWKHVKRXOGHUVRIDEXOO8QOLNHWKHRWKHUVKH
ZDVEHDUGHGZLWKDWKLFNEOXHEODFNEHDUGZKLFKIHOODOPRVWWRKLV
EURDGJLUGOH+HZRUHDUREHRISXUSOHVLONZKLFKUHIOHFWHGFKDQJLQJ
VKHHQVRIFRORUZLWKKLVHYHU\PRYHPHQWDQGRQHZLGHVOHHYHGUDZQ
EDFNWRKLVHOERZUHYHDOHGDIRUHDUPPDVVLYHZLWKFRUGHGPXVFOHV
7KHEDQGZKLFKFRQILQHGKLVEOXHEODFNORFNVZDVVHWZLWKJOLWWHULQJ
MHZHOV
7KHZRPDQEHVLGHKLPVSUDQJWRKHUIHHWZLWKDVWDUWOHG
H[FODPDWLRQDVWKHVWUDQJHUVHQWHUHGDQGKHUH\HVSDVVLQJRYHU
&RQDQIL[HGWKHPVHOYHVZLWKEXUQLQJLQWHQVLW\RQ9DOHULD6KHZDV
WDOODQGOLWKHE\IDUWKHPRVWEHDXWLIXOZRPDQLQWKHURRP6KHZDV
FODGPRUHVFDQWLO\HYHQWKDQWKHRWKHUVIRULQVWHDGRIDVNLUWVKH
ZRUHPHUHO\DEURDGVWULSRIJLOWZRUNHGSXUSOHFORWKIDVWHQHGWRWKH
PLGGOHRIKHUJLUGOHZKLFKIHOOEHORZKHUNQHHV$QRWKHUVWULSDWWKH
EDFNRIKHUJLUGOHFRPSOHWHGWKDWSDUWRIKHUFRVWXPHZKLFKVKHZRUH
ZLWKDF\QLFDOLQGLIIHUHQFH+HUEUHDVWSODWHVDQGWKHFLUFOHWDERXW
KHUWHPSOHVZHUHDGRUQHGZLWKJHPV,QKHUH\HVDORQHRIDOOWKH
GDUNVNLQQHGSHRSOHWKHUHOXUNHGQREURRGLQJJOHDPRIPDGQHVV6KH
VSRNHQRZRUGDIWHUKHUILUVWH[FODPDWLRQVKHVWRRGWHQVHO\KHU
KDQGVFOHQFKHGVWDULQJDW9DOHULD
7KHPDQRQWKHLYRU\VHDWKDGQRWULVHQ
3ULQFH2OPHFVSRNH7HFKRWOERZLQJORZZLWKDUPVRXWVSUHDGDQG
WKHSDOPVRIKLVKDQGVWXUQHGXSZDUG,EULQJDOOLHVIURPWKHZRUOG
EH\RQGWKHIRUHVW,QWKH&KDPEHURI7H]FRWLWKH%XUQLQJ6NXOOVOHZ
&KLFPHFP\FRPSDQLRQ
7KH%XUQLQJ6NXOO,WZDVDVKXGGHULQJZKLVSHURIIHDUIURPWKH
SHRSOHRI7HFXKOWOL
$\H7KHQFDPH,DQGIRXQG&KLFPHFO\LQJZLWKKLVWKURDWFXW
%HIRUH,FRXOGIOHHWKH%XUQLQJ6NXOOFDPHXSRQPHDQGZKHQ,
ORRNHGXSRQLWP\EORRGEHFDPHDVLFHDQGWKHPDUURZRIP\ERQHV
PHOWHG,FRXOGQHLWKHUILJKWQRUUXQ,FRXOGRQO\DZDLWWKHVWURNH
7KHQFDPHWKLVZKLWHVNLQQHGZRPDQDQGVWUXFNKLPGRZQZLWKKHU
VZRUGDQGORLWZDVRQO\DGRJRI;RWDODQFZLWKZKLWHSDLQWXSRQ
KLVVNLQDQGWKHOLYLQJVNXOORIDQDQFLHQWZL]DUGXSRQKLVKHDG1RZ
WKDWVNXOOOLHVLQPDQ\SLHFHVDQGWKHGRJZKRZRUHLWLVDGHDG
PDQ
$QLQGHVFULEDEO\ILHUFHH[XOWDWLRQHGJHGWKHODVWVHQWHQFHDQG
ZDVHFKRHGLQWKHORZVDYDJHH[FODPDWLRQVIURPWKHFURZGLQJ
OLVWHQHUV
%XWZDLWH[FODLPHG7HFKRWO7KHUHLVPRUH:KLOH,WDONHGZLWK
WKHZRPDQIRXU;RWDODQFVFDPHXSRQXV2QH,VOHZWKHUHLVWKH
VWDELQP\WKLJKWRSURYHKRZGHVSHUDWHZDVWKHILJKW7ZRWKHZRPDQ
NLOOHG%XWZHZHUHKDUGSUHVVHGZKHQWKLVPDQFDPHLQWRWKHIUD\DQG
VSOLWWKHVNXOORIWKHIRXUWK$\H)LYHFULPVRQQDLOVWKHUHDUHWR
EHGULYHQLQWRWKHSLOODURIYHQJHDQFH
+HSRLQWHGWRDEODFNFROXPQRIHERQ\ZKLFKVWRRGEHKLQGWKHGDLV
+XQGUHGVRIUHGGRWVVFDUUHGLWVSROLVKHGVXUIDFHWKHEULJKW
VFDUOHWKHDGVRIKHDY\FRSSHUQDLOVGULYHQLQWRWKHEODFNZRRG
)LYHUHGQDLOVIRUILYH;RWDODQFDOLYHVH[XOWHG7HFKRWODQG
WKHKRUULEOHH[XOWDWLRQLQWKHIDFHVRIWKHOLVWHQHUVPDGHWKHP
LQKXPDQ
:KRDUHWKHVHSHRSOH"DVNHG2OPHFDQGKLVYRLFHZDVOLNHWKH
ORZGHHSUXPEOHRIDGLVWDQWEXOO1RQHRIWKHSHRSOHRI;XFKRWO
VSRNHORXGO\,WZDVDVLIWKH\KDGDEVRUEHGLQWRWKHLUVRXOVWKH
VLOHQFHRIWKHHPSW\KDOOVDQGGHVHUWHGFKDPEHUV
,DP&RQDQD&LPPHULDQDQVZHUHGWKHEDUEDULDQEULHIO\7KLV
ZRPDQLV9DOHULDRIWKH5HG%URWKHUKRRGDQ$TXLORQLDQSLUDWH:HDUH
GHVHUWHUVIURPDQDUP\RQWKH'DUIDUERUGHUIDUWRWKHQRUWKDQG
DUHWU\LQJWRUHDFKWKHFRDVW
7KHZRPDQRQWKHGDLVVSRNHORXGO\KHUZRUGVWULSSLQJLQKHU
KDVWH
<RXFDQQHYHUUHDFKWKHFRDVW7KHUHLVQRHVFDSHIURP;XFKRWO
<RXZLOOVSHQGWKHUHVWRI\RXUOLYHVLQWKLVFLW\
:KDWGR\RXPHDQJURZOHG&RQDQFODSSLQJKLVKDQGWRKLVKLOW
DQGVWHSSLQJDERXWVRDVWRIDFHERWKWKHGDLVDQGWKHUHVWRIWKH
URRP$UH\RXWHOOLQJXVZH
UHSULVRQHUV"
6KHGLGQRWPHDQWKDWLQWHUSRVHG2OPHF:HDUH\RXUIULHQGV
:HZRXOGQRWUHVWUDLQ\RXDJDLQVW\RXUZLOO%XW,IHDURWKHU
FLUFXPVWDQFHVZLOOPDNHLWLPSRVVLEOHIRU\RXWROHDYH;XFKRWO
+LVH\HVIOLFNHUHGWR9DOHULDDQGKHORZHUHGWKHPTXLFNO\
7KLVZRPDQLV7DVFHODKHVDLG6KHLVDSULQFHVVRI7HFXKOWOL
%XWOHWIRRGDQGGULQNEHEURXJKWRXUJXHVWV'RXEWOHVVWKH\DUH
KXQJU\DQGZHDU\IURPWKHLUORQJWUDYHOV
+HLQGLFDWHGDQLYRU\WDEOHDQGDIWHUDQH[FKDQJHRIJODQFHVWKH
DGYHQWXUHUVVHDWHGWKHPVHOYHV7KH&LPPHULDQZDVVXVSLFLRXV+LV
ILHUFHEOXHH\HVURYHGDERXWWKHFKDPEHUDQGKHNHSWKLVVZRUGFORVH
WRKLVKDQG%XWDQLQYLWDWLRQWRHDWDQGGULQNQHYHUIRXQGKLP
EDFNZDUG+LVH\HVNHSWZDQGHULQJWR7DVFHODEXWWKHSULQFHVVKDG
H\HVRQO\IRUKLVZKLWHVNLQQHGFRPSDQLRQ
7HFKRWOZKRKDGERXQGDVWULSRIVLONDERXWKLVZRXQGHGWKLJK
SODFHGKLPVHOIDWWKHWDEOHWRDWWHQGWRWKHZDQWVRIKLVIULHQGV
VHHPLQJWRFRQVLGHULWDSULYLOHJHDQGKRQRUWRVHHDIWHUWKHLU
QHHGV+HLQVSHFWHGWKHIRRGDQGGULQNWKHRWKHUVEURXJKWLQJROG
YHVVHOVDQGGLVKHVDQGWDVWHGHDFKEHIRUHKHSODFHGLWEHIRUHKLV
JXHVWV:KLOHWKH\DWH2OPHFVDWLQVLOHQFHRQKLVLYRU\VHDW
ZDWFKLQJWKHPIURPXQGHUKLVEURDGEODFNEURZV7DVFHODVDWEHVLGH
KLPFKLQFXSSHGLQKHUKDQGVDQGKHUHOERZVUHVWLQJRQKHUNQHHV
+HUGDUNHQLJPDWLFH\HVEXUQLQJZLWKDP\VWHULRXVOLJKWQHYHUOHIW
9DOHULD
VVXSSOHILJXUH%HKLQGKHUVHDWDVXOOHQKDQGVRPHJLUOZDYHG
DQRVWULFKSOXPHIDQZLWKDVORZUK\WKP
7KHIRRGZDVIUXLWRIDQH[RWLFNLQGXQIDPLOLDUWRWKHZDQGHUHUV
EXWYHU\SDODWDEOHDQGWKHGULQNZDVDOLJKWFULPVRQZLQHWKDW
FDUULHGDKHDG\WDQJ
<RXKDYHFRPHIURPDIDUVDLG2OPHFDWODVW,KDYHUHDGWKH
ERRNVRIRXUIDWKHUV$TXLORQLDOLHVEH\RQHWKHODQGVRIWKH6W\JLDQV
DQGWKH6KHPLWHVEH\RQG$UJRVDQG=LQJDUDDQG&LPPHULDOLHVEH\RQG
$TXLORQLD
:HKDYHHDFKDURYLQJIRRWDQVZHUHG&RQDQFDUHOHVVO\
+RZ\RXZRQWKURXJKWKHIRUHVWLVDZRQGHUWRPHTXRWK2OPHF
,QE\JRQHGD\VDWKRXVDQGILJKWLQJPHQVFDUFHO\ZHUHDEOHWRFDUYHD
URDGWKURXJKLWVSHULOV
:HHQFRXQWHUHGDEHQFKOHJJHGPRQVWURVLW\DERXWWKHVL]HRID
PDVWRGRQVDLG&RQDQFDVXDOO\KROGLQJRXWKLVZLQHJREOHWZKLFK
7HFKXWOILOOHGZLWKHYLGHQWSOHDVXUH%XWZKHQZH
GNLOOHGLWZHKDG
QRIXUWKHUWURXEOH
7KHZLQHYHVVHOVOLSSHGIURP7HFKRWO
VKDQGWRFUDVKRQWKHIORRU
+LVGXVN\VNLQZHQWDVK\2OPHFVWDUWHGWRKLVIHHWDQLPDJHRI
VWXQQHGDPD]HPHQWDQGDORZJDVSRIDZHRUWHUURUEUHDWKHGXSIURP
WKHRWKHUV6RPHVOLSSHGWRWKHLUNQHHVDVLIWKHLUOHJVZRXOGQRW
VXSSRUWWKHP2QO\7DVFHODVHHPHGQRWWRKDYHKHDUG&RQDQJODUHG
DERXWKLPEHZLOGHUHGO\
:KDW
VWKHPDWWHU":KDWDUH\RXJDSLQJDERXW"
<RX\RXVOHZWKHGUDJRQJRG"
*RG",NLOOHGDGUDJRQ:K\QRW",WZDVWU\LQJWRJREEOHXVXS
%XWGUDJRQVDUHLPPRUWDOH[FODLPHG2OPHF7KH\VOD\HDFK
RWKHUEXWQRPDQHYHUNLOOHGDGUDJRQ7KHWKRXVDQGILJKWLQJPHQRI
RXUDQFHVWRUVZKRIRXJKWWKHLUZD\WR;XFKRWOFRXOGQRWSUHYDLO
DJDLQVWWKHP7KHLUVZRUGVEURNHOLNHWZLJVDJDLQVWWKHLUVFDOHV
,I\RXUDQFHVWRUVKDGWKRXJKWWRGLSWKHLUVSHDUVLQWKH
SRLVRQRXVMXLFHRI'HUNHWD
V$SSOHVTXRWK&RQDQZLWKKLVPRXWK
IXOODQGMDEWKHPLQWKHH\HVRUPRXWKRUVRPHZKHUHOLNHWKDW
WKH\
GKDYHVHHQWKDWGUDJRQVDUHQRPRUHLPPRUWDOWKDQDQ\RWKHU
FKXQNRIEHHI7KHFDUFDVVOLHVDWWKHHGJHRIWKHWUHHVMXVWZLWKLQ
WKHIRUHVW,I\RXGRQ
WEHOLHYHPHJRDQGORRNIRU\RXUVHOI
2OPHFVKRRNKLVKHDGQRWLQGLVEHOLHIEXWLQZRQGHU
,WZDVEHFDXVHRIWKHGUDJRQVWKDWRXUDQFHVWRUVWRRNUHIXJHLQ
;XFKRWOVDLGKH7KH\GDUHGQRWSDVVWKURXJKWKHSODLQDQGSOXQJH
LQWRWKHIRUHVWEH\RQG6FRUHVRIWKHPZHUHVHL]HGDQGGHYRXUHGE\
WKHPRQVWHUVEHIRUHWKH\FRXOGUHDFKWKHFLW\
7KHQ\RXUDQFHVWRUVGLGQ
WEXLOG;XFKRWO"DVNHG9DOHULD
,WZDVDQFLHQWZKHQWKH\ILUVWFDPHLQWRWKHODQG+RZORQJLW
KDGVWRRGKHUHQRWHYHQLWVGHJHQHUDWHLQKDELWDQWVNQHZ
<RXUSHRSOHFDPHIURP/DNH=XDG"TXHVWLRQHG&RQDQ
$\H0RUHWKDQKDOIDFHQWXU\DJRDWULEHRIWKH7OD]LWODQV
UHEHOOHGDJDLQVWWKH6W\JLDQNLQJDQGEHLQJGHIHDWHGLQEDWWOH
IOHGVRXWKZDUG)RUPDQ\ZHHNVWKH\ZDQGHUHGRYHUJUDVVODQGVGHVHUW
DQGKLOOVDQGDWODVWWKH\FDPHLQWRWKHJUHDWIRUHVWDWKRXVDQG
ILJKWLQJPHQZLWKWKHLUZRPHQDQGFKLOGUHQ
,WZDVLQWKHIRUHVWWKDWWKHGUDJRQVIHOOXSRQWKHPDQGWRUH
PDQ\WRSLHFHVVRWKHSHRSOHIOHGLQDIUHQ]\RIIHDUEHIRUHWKHP
DQGDWODVWFDPHLQWRWKHSODLQDQGVDZWKHFLW\RI;XFKRWOLQWKH
PLGVWRILW
7KH\FDPSHGEHIRUHWKHFLW\QRWGDULQJWROHDYHWKHSODLQIRU
WKHQLJKWZDVPDGHKLGHRXVZLWKWKHQRLVHRIWKHEDWWOLQJPRQVWHUV
WKURXJKWKHIRUHVW7KH\PDGHZDULQFHVVDQWO\XSRQRQHDQRWKHU<HW
WKH\FDPHQRWLQWRWKHSODLQ
7KHSHRSOHRIWKHFLW\VKXWWKHLUJDWHVDQGVKRWDUURZVDWRXU
SHRSOHIURPWKHZDOOV7KH7OD]LWODQVZHUHLPSULVRQHGRQWKHSODLQ
DVLIWKHULQJRIWKHIRUHVWKDGEHHQDJUHDWZDOOIRUWRYHQWXUH
LQWRWKHZRRGVZRXOGKDYHEHHQPDGQHVV
7KDWQLJKWWKHUHFDPHVHFUHWO\WRWKHLUFDPSDVODYHIURPWKH
FLW\RQHRIWKHLURZQEORRGZKRZLWKDEDQGRIH[SORULQJVROGLHUV
KDGZDQGHUHGLQWRWKHIRUHVWORQJEHIRUHZKHQKHZDVD\RXQJPDQ
7KHGUDJRQVKDGGHYRXUHGDOOKLVFRPSDQLRQVEXWKHKDGEHHQWDNHQ
LQWRWKHFLW\WRGZHOOLQVHUYLWXGH+LVQDPHZDV7RONHPHF$IODPH
OLJKWHGWKHGDUNH\HVDWPHQWLRQRIWKHQDPHDQGVRPHRIWKHSHRSOH
PXWWHUHGREVFHQHO\DQGVSDW+HSURPLVHGWRRSHQWKHJDWHVWRWKH
ZDUULRUV+HDVNHGRQO\WKDWDOOFDSWLYHVWDNHQEHGHOLYHUHGLQWRKLV
KDQGV
$WGDZQKHRSHQHGWKHJDWHV7KHZDUULRUVVZDUPHGLQDQGWKH
KDOOVRI;XFKRWOUDQUHG2QO\DIHZKXQGUHGIRONGZHOWWKHUH
GHFD\LQJUHPQDQWVRIDRQFHJUHDWUDFH7RONHPHFVDLGWKH\FDPHIURP
WKHHDVWORQJDJRIURP2OG.RVDODZKHQWKHDQFHVWRUVRIWKRVHZKR
QRZGZHOOLQ.RVDODFDPHXSIURPWKHVRXWKDQGGURYHIRUWKWKH
RULJLQDOLQKDELWDQWVRIWKHODQG7KH\ZDQGHUHGIDUZHVWZDUGDQG
ILQDOO\IRXQGWKLVIRUHVWJLUGOHGSODLQLQKDELWHGWKHQE\DWULEHRI
EODFNSHRSOH
7KHVHWKH\HQVODYHGDQGVHWWREXLOGLQJDFLW\)URPWKHKLOOVWR
WKHHDVWWKH\EURXJKWMDGHDQGPDUEOHDQGODSLVOD]XOLDQGJROG
VLOYHUDQGFRSSHU+HUGVRIHOHSKDQWVSURYLGHGWKHPZLWKLYRU\:KHQ
WKHLUFLW\ZDVFRPSOHWHGWKH\VOHZDOOWKHEODFNVODYHV$QGWKHLU
PDJLFLDQVPDGHDWHUULEOHPDJLFWRJXDUGWKHFLW\IRUE\WKHLU
QHFURPDQWLFDUWVWKH\UHFUHDWHGWKHGUDJRQVZKLFKKDGRQFHGZHOWLQ
WKLVORVWODQGDQGZKRVHPRQVWURXVERQHVWKH\IRXQGLQWKHIRUHVW
7KRVHERQHVWKH\FORWKHGLQIOHVKDQGOLIHDQGWKHOLYLQJEHDVWV
ZDONHGWKHHDUWKDVWKH\ZDONHGLWZKHQWLPHZDV\RXQJ%XWWKH
ZL]DUGVZRYHDVSHOOWKDWNHSWWKHPLQWKHIRUHVWDQGWKH\FDPHQRW
LQWRWKHSODLQ
6RIRUPDQ\FHQWXULHVWKHSHRSOHRI;XFKRWOGZHOWLQWKHLUFLW\
FXOWLYDWLQJWKHIHUWLOHSODLQXQWLOWKHLUZLVHPHQOHDUQHGKRZWR
JURZIUXLWZLWKLQWKHFLW\IUXLWZKLFKLVQRWSODQWHGLQVRLOEXW
REWDLQVLWVQRXULVKPHQWRXWRIWKHDLUDQGWKHQWKH\OHWWKH
LUULJDWLRQGLWFKHVUXQGU\DQGGZHOWPRUHDQGPRUHLQOX[XULRXV
VORWKXQWLOGHFD\VHL]HGWKHP7KH\ZHUHDG\LQJUDFHZKHQRXU
DQFHVWRUVEURNHWKURXJKWKHIRUHVWDQGFDPHLQWRWKHSODLQ7KHLU
ZL]DUGVKDGGLHGDQGWKHSHRSOHKDGIRUJRWWKHLUDQFLHQWQHFURPDQF\
7KH\FRXOGILJKWQHLWKHUE\VRUFHU\QRUWKHVZRUG
:HOORXUIDWKHUVVOHZWKHSHRSOHRI;XFKRWODOOH[FHSWD
KXQGUHGZKLFKZHUHJLYHQOLYLQJLQWRWKHKDQGVRI7RONHPHFZKRKDG
EHHQWKHLUVODYHDQGIRUPDQ\GD\VDQGQLJKWVWKHKDOOVUHHFKRHGWR
WKHLUVFUHDPVXQGHUWKHDJRQ\RIKLVWRUWXUHV
6RWKH7OD]LWODQVGZHOWKHUHIRUDZKLOHLQSHDFHUXOHGE\WKH
EURWKHUV7HFXKOWOLDQG;RWDODQFDQGE\7RONHPHF7RONHPHFWRRND
JLUORIWKHWULEHWRZLIHDQGEHFDXVHKHKDGRSHQHGWKHJDWHVDQG
EHFDXVHKHNQHZPDQ\RIWKHDUWVRIWKH;XFKRWODQVKHVKDUHGWKH
UXOHRIWKHWULEHZLWKWKHEURWKHUVZKRKDGOHGWKHUHEHOOLRQDQGWKH
IOLJKW
)RUDIHZ\HDUVWKHQWKH\GZHOWDWSHDFHZLWKLQWKHFLW\GRLQJ
OLWWOHEXWHDWLQJGULQNLQJDQGPDNLQJORYHDQGUDLVLQJFKLOGUHQ
7KHUHZDVQRQHFHVVLW\WRWLOOWKHSODLQIRU7RONHPHFWDXJKWWKHP
KRZWRFXOWLYDWHWKHDLUGHYRXULQJIUXLWV%HVLGHVWKHVOD\LQJRI
WKH;XFKRWODQVEURNHWKHVSHOOWKDWKHOGWKHGUDJRQVLQWKHIRUHVW
DQGWKH\FDPHQLJKWO\DQGEHOORZHGDERXWWKHJDWHVRIWKHFLW\7KH
SODLQUDQUHGZLWKWKHEORRGRIWKHLUHWHUQDOZDUIDUHDQGLWZDV
WKHQWKDW+HELWKLVWRQJXHLQWKHPLGVWRIWKHVHQWHQFHWKHQ
SUHVHQWO\FRQWLQXHGEXW9DOHULDDQG&RQDQIHOWWKDWKHKDGFKHFNHG
DQDGPLVVLRQKHKDGFRQVLGHUHGXQZLVH
)LYH\HDUVWKH\GZHOWLQSHDFH7KHQ2OPHF
VH\HVUHVWHG
EULHIO\RQWKHVLOHQWZRPDQDWKLVVLGH;RWDODQFWRRNDZRPDQWR
ZLIHDZRPDQZKRPERWK7HFXKOWOLDQGROG7RONHPHFGHVLUHG,QKLV
PDGQHVV7HFXKOWOLVWROHKHUIURPKHUKXVEDQG$\HVKHZHQW
ZLOOLQJO\HQRXJK7RONHPHFWRVSLWH;RWDODQFDLGHG7HFXKOWOL
;RWDODQFGHPDQGHGWKDWVKHEHJLYHQEDFNWRKLPDQGWKHFRXQFLORI
WKHWULEHGHFLGHGWKDWWKHPDWWHUVKRXOGEHOHIWWRWKHZRPDQ6KH
FKRVHWRUHPDLQZLWK7HFXKOWOL,QZUDWK;RWDODQFVRXJKWWRWDNHKHU
EDFNE\IRUFHDQGWKHUHWDLQHUVRIWKHEURWKHUVFDPHWREORZVLQWKH
*UHDW+DOO
7KHUHZDVPXFKELWWHUQHVV%ORRGZDVVKHGRQERWKVLGHV7KH
TXDUUHOEHFDPHDIHXGWKHIHXGDQRSHQZDU)URPWKHZHOWHUWKUHH
IDFWLRQVHPHUJHG7HFXKOWOL;RWDODQFDQG7RONHPHF$OUHDG\LQ
WKHGD\VRISHDFHWKH\KDGGLYLGHGWKHFLW\EHWZHHQWKHP7HFXKOWOL
GZHOWLQWKHZHVWHUQTXDUWHURIWKHFLW\;RWDODQFLQWKHHDVWHUQ
DQG7RONHPHFZLWKKLVIDPLO\E\WKHVRXWKHUQJDWH
$QJHUDQGUHVHQWPHQWDQGMHDORXV\EORVVRPHGLQWREORRGVKHGDQG
UDSHDQGPXUGHU2QFHWKHVZRUGZDVGUDZQWKHUHZDVQRWXUQLQJEDFN
IRUEORRGFDOOHGIRUEORRGDQGYHQJHDQFHIROORZHGVZLIWRQWKHKHHOV
RIDWURFLW\7HFXKOWOLIRXJKWZLWK;RWDODQFDQG7RONHPHFDLGHGILUVW
RQHDQGWKHQWKHRWKHUEHWUD\LQJHDFKIDFWLRQDVLWILWWHGKLV
SXUSRVHV7HFXKOWOLDQGKLVSHRSOHZLWKGUHZLQWRWKHTXDUWHURIWKH
ZHVWHUQJDWHZKHUHZHQRZVLW;XFKRWOLVEXLOWLQWKHVKDSHRIDQ
RYDO7HFXKOWOLZKLFKWRRNLWVQDPHIURPLWVSULQFHRFFXSLHVWKH
ZHVWHUQHQGRIWKHRYDO7KHSHRSOHEORFNHGXSDOOGRRUVFRQQHFWLQJ
WKHTXDUWHUZLWKWKHUHVWRIWKHFLW\H[FHSWRQHRQHDFKIORRU
ZKLFKFRXOGEHGHIHQGHGHDVLO\7KH\ZHQWLQWRWKHSLWVEHORZWKH
FLW\DQGEXLOWDZDOOFXWWLQJRIIWKHZHVWHUQHQGRIWKHFDWDFRPEV
ZKHUHOLHWKHERGLHVRIWKHDQFLHQW;XFKRWODQVDQGRIWKRVH
7OD]LWODQVVODLQLQWKHIHXG7KH\GZHOWDVLQDEHVLHJHGFDVWOH
PDNLQJVRUWLHVDQGIRUUD\VRQWKHLUHQHPLHV
7KHSHRSOHRI;RWDODQFOLNHZLVHIRUWLILHGWKHHDVWHUQTXDUWHURI
WKHFLW\DQG7RONHPHFGLGOLNHZLVHZLWKWKHTXDUWHUE\WKHVRXWKHUQ
JDWH7KHFHQWUDOSDUWRIWKHFLW\ZDVOHIWEDUHDQGXQLQKDELWHG
7KRVHHPSW\KDOOVDQGFKDPEHUVEHFDPHDEDWWOHJURXQGDQGDUHJLRQRI
EURRGLQJWHUURU
7RONHPHFZDUUHGRQERWKFODQV+HZDVDILHQGLQWKHIRUPRID
KXPDQZRUVHWKDQ;RWDODQF+HNQHZPDQ\VHFUHWVRIWKHFLW\KHQHYHU
WROGWKHRWKHUV)URPWKHFU\SWVRIWKHFDWDFRPEVKHSOXQGHUHGWKH
GHDGRIWKHLUJULVO\VHFUHWVVHFUHWVRIDQFLHQWNLQJVDQGZL]DUGV
ORQJIRUJRWWHQE\WKHGHJHQHUDWH;XFKRWODQVRXUDQFHVWRUVVOHZ%XW
DOOKLVPDJLFGLGQRWDLGKLPWKHQLJKWZHRI7HFXKOWOLVWRUPHGKLV
FDVWOHDQGEXWFKHUHGDOOKLVSHRSOH7RONHPHFZHWRUWXUHGIRUPDQ\
GD\V
+LVYRLFHVDQNWRDFDUHVVLQJVOXUDQGDIDUDZD\ORRNJUHZLQKLV
H\HVDVLIKHORRNHGEDFNRYHUWKH\HDUVWRDVFHQHZKLFKFDXVHGKLP
LQWHQVHSOHDVXUH
$\HZHNHSWWKHOLIHLQKLPXQWLOKHVFUHDPHGIRUGHDWKDVIRUD
EULGH$WODVWZHWRRNKLPOLYLQJIURPWKHWRUWXUHFKDPEHUDQGFDVW
KLPLQWRDGXQJHRQIRUWKHUDWVWRJQDZDVKHGLHG)URPWKDW
GXQJHRQVRPHKRZKHPDQDJHGWRHVFDSHDQGGUDJJHGKLPVHOILQWRWKH
FDWDFRPEV7KHUHZLWKRXWGRXEWKHGLHGIRUWKHRQO\ZD\RXWRIWKH
FDWDFRPEVEHQHDWK7HFXKOWOLLVWKURXJK7HFXKOWOLDQGKHQHYHU
HPHUJHGE\WKDWZD\+LVERQHVZHUHQHYHUIRXQGDQGWKHVXSHUVWLWLRXV
DPRQJRXUSHRSOHVZHDUWKDWKLVJKRVWKDXQWVWKHFU\SWVWRWKLVGD\
ZDLOLQJDPRQJWKHERQHVRIWKHGHDG7ZHOYH\HDUVDJRZHEXWFKHUHG
WKHSHRSOHRI7RONHPHFEXWWKHIHXGUDJHGRQEHWZHHQ7HFXKOWOLDQG
;RWDODQFDVLWZLOOUDJHXQWLOWKHODVWPDQWKHODVWZRPDQLVGHDG
,WZDVILIW\\HDUVDJRWKDW7HFXKOWOLVWROHWKHZLIHRI;RWDODQF
+DOIDFHQWXU\WKHIHXGKDVHQGXUHG,ZDVERUQLQLW$OOLQWKLV
FKDPEHUH[FHSW7DVFHODZHUHERUQLQLW:HH[SHFWWRGLHLQLW
:HDUHDG\LQJUDFHHYHQDVZHUHWKRVH;XFKRWODQVRXUDQFHVWRUV
VOHZ:KHQWKHIHXGEHJDQWKHUHZHUHKXQGUHGVLQHDFKIDFWLRQ1RZZH
RI7HFXKOWOLQXPEHURQO\WKHVH\RXVHHEHIRUH\RXDQGWKHPHQZKR
JXDUGWKHIRXUGRRUVIRUW\LQDOO+RZPDQ\;RWDODQFDVWKHUHDUHZH
GRQRWNQRZEXW,GRXEWLIWKH\DUHPXFKPRUHQXPHURXVWKDQZH)RU
ILIWHHQ\HDUVQRFKLOGUHQKDYHEHHQERUQWRXVDQGZHKDYHVHHQQRQH
DPRQJWKH;RWDODQFDV
:HDUHG\LQJEXWEHIRUHZHGLHZHZLOOVOD\DVPDQ\RIWKHPHQ
RI;RWDODQFDVWKHJRGVSHUPLW
$QGZLWKKLVZHLUGH\HVEOD]LQJ2OPHFVSRNHORQJRIWKDWJULVO\
IHXGIRXJKWRXWLQVLOHQWFKDPEHUVDQGGLPKDOOVXQGHUWKHEOD]HRI
WKHJUHHQILUHMHZHOVRQIORRUVVPROGHULQJZLWKWKHIODPHVRIKHOO
DQGVSODVKHGZLWKGHHSHUFULPVRQIURPVHYHUHGYHLQV,QWKDWORQJ
EXWFKHU\DZKROHJHQHUDWLRQKDGSHULVKHG;RWDODQFZDVGHDGORQJ
DJRVODLQLQDJULPEDWWOHRQDQLYRU\VWDLU7HFXKOWOLZDVGHDG
IOD\HGDOLYHE\WKHPDGGHQHG;RWDODQFDVZKRKDGFDSWXUHGKLP
:LWKRXWHPRWLRQ2OPHFWROGRIKLGHRXVEDWWOHVIRXJKWLQEODFN
FRUULGRUVRIDPEXVKHVRQWZLVWLQJVWDLUVDQGUHGEXWFKHULHV:LWKD
UHGGHUPRUHDE\VPDOJOHDPLQKLVGHHSGDUNH\HVKHWROGRIPHQDQG
ZRPHQIOD\HGDOLYHPXWLODWHGDQGGLVPHPEHUHGRIFDSWLYHVKRZOLQJ
XQGHUWRUWXUHVVRJKDVWO\WKDWHYHQWKHEDUEDURXV&LPPHULDQJUXQWHG
1RZRQGHU7HFKRWOKDGWUHPEOHGZLWKWKHWHUURURIFDSWXUH<HWKHKDG
JRQHIRUWKWRVOD\LIKHFRXOGGULYHQE\KDWWKDWZDVVWURQJHUWKDQ
KLVIHDU2OPHFVSRNHIXUWKHURIGDUNDQGP\VWHULRXVPDWWHUVRI
EODFNPDJLFDQGZL]DUGU\FRQMXUHGRXWRIWKHEODFNQLJKWRIWKH
FDWDFRPEVRIZHLUGFUHDWXUHVLQYRNHGRXWRIGDUNQHVVIRUKRUULEOH
DOOLHV,QWKHVHWKLQJVWKH;RWDODQFDVKDGWKHDGYDQWDJHIRULWZDV
LQWKHHDVWHUQFDWDFRPEVZKHUHOD\WKHERQHVRIWKHJUHDWHVWZL]DUGV
RIWKHDQFLHQW;XFKRWODQVZLWKWKHLULPPHPRULDOVHFUHWV
9DOHULDOLVWHQHGZLWKPRUELGIDVFLQDWLRQ7KHIHXGKDGEHFRPHD
WHUULEOHHOHPHQWDOSRZHUGULYLQJWKHSHRSOHRI;XFKRWOLQH[RUDEO\RQ
WRGRRPDQGH[WLQFWLRQ,WILOOHGWKHLUZKROHOLYHV7KH\ZHUHERUQ
LQLWDQGWKH\H[SHFWHGWRGLHLQLW7KH\QHYHUOHIWWKHLU
EDUULFDGHGFDVWOHH[FHSWWRVWHDOIRUWKLQWRWKH+DOOVRI6LOHQFH
WKDWOD\EHWZHHQWKHRSSRVLQJIRUWUHVVHVWRVOD\DQGEHVODLQ
6RPHWLPHVWKHUDLGHUVUHWXUQHGZLWKIUDQWLFFDSWLYHVRUZLWKJULP
WRNHQVRIYLFWRU\LQILJKW6RPHWLPHVWKH\GLGQRWUHWXUQDWDOORU
UHWXUQHGRQO\DVVHYHUHGOLPEVFDVWGRZQEHIRUHWKHEROWHGEURQ]H
GRRUV,WZDVDJKDVWO\XQUHDOQLJKWPDUHH[LVWHQFHWKHVHSHRSOH
OLYHGVKXWRIIIURPWKHUHVWRIWKHZRUOGFDXJKWWRJHWKHUOLNH
UDELGUDWVLQWKHVDPHWUDSEXWFKHULQJRQHDQRWKHUWKURXJKWKH
\HDUVFURXFKLQJDQGFUHHSLQJWKURXJKWKHVXQOHVVFRUULGRUVWRPDLP
DQGWRUWXUHDQGPXUGHU
:KLOH2OPHFWDONHG9DOHULDIHOWWKHEOD]LQJH\HVRI7DVFHODIL[HG
XSRQKHU7KHSULQFHVVVHHPHGQRWWRKHDUZKDW2OPHFZDVVD\LQJ+HU
H[SUHVVLRQDVKHQDUUDWHGYLFWRULHVRUGHIHDWVGLGQRWPLUURUWKH
ZLOGUDJHRUILHQGLVKH[XOWDWLRQWKDWDOWHUQDWHGRQWKHIDFHVRIWKH
RWKHU7HFXKOWOL7KHIHXGWKDWZDVDQREVHVVLRQWRKHUFODQVPHQ
VHHPHGPHDQLQJOHVVWRKHU9DOHULDIRXQGKHULQGLIIHUHQWFDOORXVQHVV
PRUHUHSXJQDQWWKDQ2OPHF
VQDNHGIHURFLW\
$QGZHFDQQHYHUOHDYHWKHFLW\VDLG2OPHF)RUILIW\\HDUVRQ
RQHKDVOHIWLWH[FHSWWKRVH$JDLQKHFKHFNHGKLPVHOI
(YHQZLWKRXWWKHSHULORIWKHGUDJRQVKHFRQWLQXHGZHZKR
ZHUHERUQDQGUDLVHGLQWKHFLW\ZRXOGQRWGDUHOHDYHLW:HKDYH
QHYHUVHWIRRWRXWVLGHWKHZDOOV:HDUHQRWDFFXVWRPHGWRWKHRSHQ
VN\DQGWKHQDNHGVXQ1RZHZHUHERUQLQ;XFKRWODQGLQ;XFKRWOZH
VKDOOGLH
:HOOVDLG&RQDQZLWK\RXUOHDYHZH
OOWDNHRXUFKDQFHVZLWK
WKHGUDJRQV7KLVIHXGLVQRQHRIRXUEXVLQHVV,I\RX
OOVKRZXVWR
WKHZHVWJDWHZH
OOEHRQRXUZD\
7DVFHOD
VKDQGVFOHQFKHGDQGVKHVWDUWHGWRVSHDNEXW2OPHF
LQWHUUXSWHGKHU,WLVQHDUO\QLJKWIDOO,I\RXZDQGHUIRUWKLQWR
WKHSODLQE\QLJKW\RXZLOOFHUWDLQO\IDOOSUH\WRWKHGUDJRQV
:HFURVVHGLWODVWQLJKWDQGVOHSWLQWKHRSHQZLWKRXWVHHLQJ
DQ\UHWXUQHG&RQDQ
7DVFHODVPLOHGPLUWKOHVVO\<RXGDUHQRWOHDYH;XFKRWO
&RQDQJODUHGDWKHUZLWKLQVWLQFWLYHDQWDJRQLVPVKHZDVQRW
ORRNLQJDWKLPEXWDWWKHZRPDQRSSRVLWHKLP
,WKLQNWKH\GDUHVWDWHG2OPHF%XWORRN\RX&RQDQDQG
9DOHULDWKHJRGVPXVWKDYHVHQW\RXWRXVWRFDVWYLFWRU\LQWRWKH
ODSVRIWKH7HFXKOWOL<RXDUHSURIHVVLRQDOILJKWHUVZK\QRWILJKW
IRUXV":HKDYHZHDOWKLQDEXQGDQFHSUHFLRXVMHZHOVDUHDVFRPPRQ
LQ;XFKRWODVFREEOHVWRQHVDUHLQWKHFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOG6RPHWKH
;XFKRWODQVEURXJKWZLWKWKHPIURP.RVDOD6RPHOLNHWKHILUHVWRQHV
WKH\IRXQGLQWKHKLOOVWRWKHHDVW$LGXVWRZLSHRXWWKH
;RWDODQFDVDQGZHZLOOJLYH\RXDOOWKHMHZHOV\RXFDQFDUU\
$QGZLOO\RXKHOSXVGHVWUR\WKHGUDJRQV"DVNHG9DOHULD:LWK
ERZVDQGSRLVRQHGDUURZVWKLUW\PHQFRXOGVOD\DOOWKHGUDJRQVLQWKH
IRUHVW
$\HUHSOLHG2OPHFSURPSWO\:HKDYHIRUJRWWHQWKHXVHRIWKH
ERZLQ\HDUVRIKDQGWRKDQGILJKWLQJEXWZHFDQOHDUQDJDLQ
:KDWGR\RXVD\"9DOHULDLQTXLUHGRI&RQDQ
:H
UHERWKSHQQLOHVVYDJDERQGVKHJULQQHGKDUGLO\,
GDVVRRQ
NLOO;RWDODQFDVDVDQ\ERG\
7KHQ\RXDJUHH"H[FODLPHG2OPHFZKLOH7HFKRWOIDLUO\KXJJHG
KLPVHOIZLWKGHOLJKW
$\H$QGQRZVXSSRVH\RXVKRZXVFKDPEHUVZKHUHZHFDQVOHHSVR
ZHFDQEHIUHVKWRPRUURZIRUWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHVOD\LQJ
2OPHFQRGGHGDQGZDYHGDKDQGDQG7HFKRWODQGDZRPDQOHGWKH
DGYHQWXUHUVLQWRDFRUULGRUZKLFKOHGWKURXJKDGRRURIIWRWKHOHIW
RIWKHMDGHGDLV$JODQFHEDFNVKRZHG9DOHULD2OPHFVLWWLQJRQKLV
WKURQHFKLQRQNQRWWHGILVWVWDULQJDIWHUWKHP+LVH\HVEXUQHG
ZLWKDZHLUGIODPH7DVFHODOHDQHGEDFNLQKHUVHDWZKLVSHULQJWR
WKHVXOOHQIDFHGPDLG<DVDODZKROHDQHGRYHUKHUVKRXOGHUKHUHDU
WRWKHSULQFHVV
VPRYLQJOLSV
7KHKDOOZD\ZDVQRWVREURDGDVPRVWWKH\KDGWUDYHUVHGEXWLW
ZDVORQJ3UHVHQWO\WKHZRPDQKDOWHGRSHQHGDGRRUDQGGUHZDVLGH
IRU9DOHULDWRHQWHU
:DLWDPLQXWHJURZOHG&RQDQ:KHUHGR,VOHHS"
7HFKRWOSRLQWHGWRDFKDPEHUDFURVVWKHKDOOZD\EXWRQHGRRU
IDUWKHUGRZQ&RQDQKHVLWDWHGDQGVHHPHGLQFOLQHGWRUDLVHDQ
REMHFWLRQEXW9DOHULDVPLOHGVSLWHIXOO\DWKLPDQGVKXWWKHGRRULQ
KLVIDFH+HPXWWHUHGVRHPWKLQJXQFRPSOLPHQWDU\DERXWZRPHQLQ
JHQHUDODQGVWURGHRIIGRZQWKHFRUULGRUDIWHU7HFKRWO
,QWKHRUQDWHFKDPEHUZKHUHKHZDVWRVOHHSKHJODQFHGXSDWWKH
VORWOLNHVN\OLJKWV6RPHZHUHZLGHHQRXJKWRDGPLWWKHERG\RID
VOHQGHUPDQVXSSRVLQJWKHJODVVZHUHEURNHQ
:K\GRQ
WWKH;RWDODQFDVFRPHRYHUWKHURRIVDQGVKDWWHUWKRVH
VN\OLJKWV"KHDVNHG
7KH\FDQQRWEHEURNHQDQVZHUHG7HFKRWO%HVLGHVWKHURRIV
ZRXOGEHKDUGWRFODPEHURYHU7KH\DUHPRVWO\VSLUHVDQGGRPHVDQG
VWHHSULGJHV
+HYROXQWHHUHGPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHFDVWOHRI7HFXKOWOL
/LNHWKHUHVWRIWKHFLW\LWFRQWDLQHGIRXUVWRULHVRUWLHUVRI
FKDPEHUVZLWKWRZHUVMXWWLQJXSIURPWKHURRI(DFKWLHUZDVQDPHG
LQGHHGWKHSHRSOHIR;XFKRWOKDGDQDPHIRUHDFKFKDPEHUKDOODQG
VWDLULQWKHFLW\DVSHRSOHRIPRUHQRUPDOFLWLHVGHVLJQDWHVWUHHWV
DQGTXDUWHUV,Q7HFXKOWOLWKHIORRUVZHUHQDPHG7KH(DJOH
V7LHU
7KH$SH
V7LHU7KH7LJHU
V7LHUDQG7KH6HUSHQW
V7LHULQWKHRUGHU
DVHQXPHUDWHG7KH(DJOH
V7LHUEHLQJWKHKLJKHVWRUIRXUWKIORRU
:KRLV7DVFHOD"DVNHG&RQDQ2OPHF
VZLIH"
7HFKRWOVKXGGHUHGDQGJODQFHGIXUWLYHO\DERXWKLPEHIRUH
DQVZHULQJ
1R6KHLV7DVFHOD6KHZDVWKHZLIHRI;RWDODQFWKHZRPDQ
7HFXKOWOLVWROHWRVWDUWWKHIHXG
:KDWDUH\RXWDONLQJDERXW"GHPDQGHG&RQDQ7KDWZRPDQLV
EHDXWLIXODQG\RXQJ$UH\RXWU\LQJWRWHOOPHWKDWVKHZDVDZLIH
ILIW\\HDUVDJR"
$\H,VZHDULW6KHZDVDIXOOJURZQZRPDQZKHQWKH7OD]LWODQV
MRXUQH\HGIURP/DNH=XDG,WZDVEHFDXVHWKHNLQJRI6W\JLDGHVLUHG
KHUIRUDFRQFXELQHWKDW;RWDODQFDQGKLVEURWKHUUHEHOOHGDQGIOHG
LQWRWKHZLOGHUQHVV6KHLVDZLWFKZKRSRVVHVVHVWKHVHFUHWRI
SHUSHWXDO\RXWK
:KDW
VWKDW"DVNHG&RQDQ
7HFKRWOVKXGGHUHGDJDLQ
$VNPHQRW,GDUHQRWVSHDN,WLVWRRJULVO\HYHQIRU
;XFKRWO
$QGWRXFKLQJKLVILQJHUWRKLVOLSVKHJOLGHGIURPWKHFKDPEHU


6FHQWRI%ODFN/RWXV

9DOHULDXQEXFNOHGKHUVZRUGEHOWDQGODLGLWZLWKWKHVKHDWKHG
ZHDSRQRQWKHFRXFKZKHUHVKHPHDQWWRVOHHS6KHQRWHGWKDWWKH
GRRUVZHUHVXSSOLHGZLWKEROWVDQGDVNHGZKHUHWKH\OHG
7KRVHOHDGWRDGMRLQLQJFKDPEHUVDQVZHUHGWKHZRPDQLQGLFDWLQJ
WKHGRRUVRQULJKWDQGOHIW7KDWRQH"SRLQWLQJWRDFRSSHU
ERXQGGRRURSSRVLWHWKDWZKLFKRSHQHGLQWRWKHFRUULGRUOHDGVWR
DFRUULGRUZKLFKUXQVWRDVWDLUWKDWGHVFHQGVLQWRWKHFDWDFRPEV'R
QRWIHDUQDXJKWFDQKDUP\RXKHUH
:KRVSRNHRIIHDU"VQDSSHG9DOHULD,MXVWOLNHWRNQRZZKDW
VRUWRIKDUERU,
PGURSSLQJDQFKRULQ1R,GRQ
WZDQW\RXWRVOHHS
DWWKHIRRWRIP\FRXFK,
PQRWDFFXVWRPHGWREHLQJZDLWHGRQQRW
E\ZRPHQDQ\ZD\<RXKDYHP\OHDYHWRJR
$ORQHLQWKHURRPWKHSLUDWHVKRWWKHEROWVRQDOOWKHGRRUV
NLFNHGRIIKHUERRWVDQGVWUHWFKHGOX[XULRXVO\RXWRQWKHFRXFK6KH
LPDJLQHG&RQDQVLPLODUO\VLWXDWHGDFURVVWKHFRUULGRUEXWKHU
IHPLQLQHYDQLW\SURPSWHGKHUWRYLVXDOL]HKLPDVVFRZOLQJDQG
PXWWHULQJZLWKFKDJULQDVKHFDVWKLPVHOIRQKLVVROLWDU\FRXFKDQG
VKHJULQQHGZLWKJOHHIXOPDOLFHDVVKHSUHSDUHGKHUVHOIIRUVOXPEHU
2XWVLGHQLJKWKDGIDOOHQ,QWKHKDOOVRI;XFKRWOWKHJUHHQILUH
MHZHOVEOD]HGOLNHWKHH\HVRISUHKLVWRULFFDWV6RPHZKHUHDPRQJWKH
GDUNWRZHUVDQLJKWZLQGPRDQHGOLNHDUHVWOHVVVSLULW7KURXJKWKH
GLPSDVVDJHVVWHDOWK\ILJXUHVEHJDQVWHDOLQJOLNHGLVHPERGLHG
VKDGRZV
9DOHULDDZRNHVXGGHQO\RQKHUFRXFK,QWKHGXVN\HPHUDOGJORZRI
WKHILUHJHPVVKHVDZDVKDGRZ\ILJXUHEHQGLQJRYHUKHU)RUD
EHPXVHGLQVWDQWWKHDSSDULWLRQVHHPHGSDUWRIWKHGUHDPVKHKDGEHHQ
GUHDPLQJ6KHKDGVHHPHGWROLHRQWKHFRXFKLQWKHFKDPEHUDVVKH
ZDVDFWXDOO\O\LQJZKLOHRYHUKHUSXOVHGDQGWKUREEHGDJLJDQWLF
EODFNEORVVRPVRHQRUPRXVWKDWLWKLGWKHFHLOLQJ,WVH[RWLFSHUIXPH
SHUYDGHGKHUEHLQJLQGXFLQJDGHOLFLRXVVHQVXRXVODQJXRUWKDWZDV
VRPHWKLQJPRUHDQGOHVVWKDQVOHHS6KHZDVVLQNLQJLQWRVFHQWHG
ELOORZVRILQVHQVLEOHEOLVVZKHQVRPHWKLQJWRXFKHGKHUIDFH6R
VXSHUVHQVLWLYHZHUHKHUGUXJJHGVHQVHVWKDWWKHOLJKWWRXFKZDVOLNH
DGLVORFDWLQJLPSDFWMROWLQJKHUUXGHO\LQWRIXOOZDNHIXOQHVV7KHQ
LWZDVWKDWVKHVDZQRWDJDUJDQWXDQEORVVRPEXWDGDUNVNLQQHG
ZRPDQVWDQGLQJDERYHKHU
:LWKWKHUHDOL]DWLRQFDPHDQJHUDQGLQVWDQWDFWLRQ7KHZRPDQ
WXUQHGOLWKHO\EXWEHIRUHVKHFRXOGUXQ9DOHULDZDVRQKHUIHHWDQG
KDGFDXJKWKHUDUP6KHIRXJKWOLNHDZLOGFDWIRUDQLQVWDQWDQG
WKHQVXEVLGHGDVVKHIHOWKHUVHOIFUXVKHGE\WKHVXSHULRUVWUHQJWKRI
KHUFDSWRU7KHSULDWHZUHQFKHGWKHZRPDQDURXQGWRIDFHKHUFDXJKW
KHUFKLQZLWKKHUIUHHKDQGDQGIRUFHGKHUFDSWLYHWRPHHWKHUJD]H
,WZDVWKHVXOOHQ<DVDOD7DVFHOD
VPDLG
:KDWWKHGHYLOZHUH\RXGRLQJEHQGLQJRYHUPH":KDW
VWKDWLQ
\RXUKDQG"
7KHZRPDQPDGHQRUHSO\EXWVRXJKWWRFDVWDZD\WKHREMHFW
9DOHULDWZLVWHGKHUDUPDURXQGLQIURQWRIKHUDQGWKHWKLQJIHOOWR
WKHIORRUDJUHDWEODFNH[RWLFEORVVRPRQDMDGHJUHHQVWHPODUJH
DVDZRPDQ
VKHDGWREHVXUHEXWWLQ\EHVLGHWKHH[DJJHUDWHGYLVLRQ
VKHKDGVHHQ
7KHEODFNORWXVVDLG9DOHULDEHWZHHQKHUWHHWK7KHEORVVRP
ZKRVHVFHQWEULQJVGHHSVOHHS<RXZHUHWU\LQJWRGUXJPH,I\RX
KDGQ
WDFFLGHQWDOO\WRXFKHGP\IDFHZLWKWKHSHWDOV\RX
GKDYH
ZK\GLG\RXGRLW":KDW
V\RXUJDPH"
<DVDODPDLQWDLQHGDVXON\VLOHQFHDQGZLWKDQRDWK9DOHULD
ZKLUOHGKHUDURXQGIRUFHGKHUWRKHUNQHHVDQGWZLVWHGKHUDUPXS
EHKLQGKHUEDFN
7HOOPHRU,
OOWHDU\RXUDUPRXWRILWVVRFNHW
<DVDODVTXLUPHGLQDQJXLVKDVKHUDUPZDVIRUFHGH[FUXFLDWLQJO\XS
EHWZHHQKHUVKRXOGHUEODGHVEXWDYLROHQWVKDNLQJRIKHUKHDGZDV
WKHRQO\DQVZHUVKHPDGH
6OXW9DOHULDFDVWKHUIURPKHUWRVSUDZORQWKHIORRU7KH
SLUDWHJODUHGDWWKHSURVWUDWHILJXUHZLWKEOD]LQJH\HV)HDUDQGWKH
PHPRU\RI7DVFHOD
VEXUQLQJH\HVVWLUUHGLQKHUURXVLQJDOOKHU
WLJHULVKLQVWLQFWVRIVHOISUHVHUYDWLRQ7KHVHSHRSOHZHUHGHFDGHQW
DQ\VRUWRISHUYHUVLW\PLJKWEHH[SHFWHGWREHHQFRXQWHUHGDPRQJ
WKHP%XW9DOHULDVHQVHGKHUHVRPHWKLQJWKDWPRYHGEHKLQGWKHVFHQHV
VRPHVHFUHWWHUURUIRXOHUWKDQFRPPRQGHJHQHUDF\)HDUDQGUHYXOVLRQ
RIWKLVZHLUGFLW\VZHSWKHU7KHVHSHRSOHZHUHQHLWKHUVDQHQRU
QRUPDOVKHEHJDQWRGRXEWLIWKH\ZHUHHYHQKXPDQ0DGQHVVVPROGHUHG
LQWKHH\HVRIWKHPDOODOOH[FHSWWKHFUXHOFU\SWLFH\HVRI
7DVFHODZKLFKKHOGVHFUHWVDQGP\VWHULHVPRUHDE\VPDOWKDQPDGQHVV
6KHOLIWHGKHUKHDGDQGOLVWHQHGLQWHQWO\7KHKDOOVRI;XFKRWO
ZHUHDVVLOHQWDVLILWZHUHLQUHDOLW\DGHDGFLW\7KHJUHHQMHZHOV
EDWKHGWKHFKDPEHULQDQLJKWPDUHJORZLQZKLFKWKHH\HVRIWKH
ZRPDQRQWKHIORRUJOLWWHUHGHHULO\XSDWKHU$WKULOORISDQLF
WKUREEHGWKURXJK9DOHULDGULYLQJWKHODVWYHVWLJHRIPHUF\IURPKHU
ILHUFHVRXO
:K\GLG\RXWU\WRGUXJPH"VKHPXWWHUHGJUDVSLQJWKHZRPDQ
V
EODFNKDLUDQGIRUFLQJKHUKHDGEDFNWRJODUHLQWRKHUVXOOHQORQJ
ODVKHGH\HV'LG7DVFHODVHQG\RX"
1RDQVZHU9DOHULDFXUVHGYHQRPRXVO\DQGVODSSHGWKHZRPDQILUVW
RQRQHFKHHNDQGWKHQWKHRWKHU7KHEORZVUHVRXQGHGWKURXJKWKH
URRPEXW<DVDODPDGHQRRXWFU\
:K\GRQ
W\RXVFUHDP"GHPDQGHG9DOHULDVDYDJHO\'R\RXIHDU
VRPHRQHZLOOKHDU\RX":KRPGR\RXIHDU"7DVFHOD"2OPHF"&RQDQ"
<DVDODPDGHQRUHSO\6KHFURXFKHGZDWFKLQJKHUFDSWRUZLWKH\HV
EDOHIXODVWKRVHRIDEDVLOLVN6WXEERUQVLOHQFHDOZD\VIDQVDQJHU
9DOHULDWXUQHGDQGWRUHDKDQGIXORIFRUGVIURPDQHDUE\KDQJLQJ
<RXVXON\VOXWVKHVDLGEHWZHHQKHUWHHWK,
PJRLQJWRVWULS
\RXVWDUNQDNHGDQGWLH\RXDFURVVWKDWFRXFKDQGZKLS\RXXQWLO\RX
WHOOPHZKDW\RXZHUHGRLQJKHUHDQGZKRVHQW\RX
<DVDODPDGHQRYHUEDOSURWHVWQRUGLGVKHRIIHUDQ\UHVLVWDQFH
DV9DOHULDFDUULHGRXWWKHILUVWSDUWRIKHUWKHUHDWZLWKDIXU\WKDW
KHUFDSWLYH
VREVWLQDF\RQO\VKDUSHQHG7KHQIRUDVSDFHWKHUHZDVQR
VRXQGLQWKHFKDPEHUH[FHSWWKHZKLVWOHDQGFUDFNOHRIKDUGZRYHQ
VLONHQFRUGVRQQDNHGIOHVK<DVDODFRXOGQRWPRYHKHUIDVWERXQG
KDQGVRUIHHW+HUERG\ZULWKHGDQGTXLYHUHGXQGHUWKHFKDVWLVHPHQW
KHUKHDGVZD\HGIURPVLGHWRVLGHLQUK\WKPZLWKWKHEORZV+HUWHHWK
ZHUHVXQNLQWRKHUORZHUOLSDQGDWULFNOHRIEORRGEHJDQDVWKH
SXQLVKPHQWFRQWLQXHG%XWVKHGLGQRWFU\RXW
7KHSOLDQWFRUGVPDGHQRJUHDWVRXQGDVWKH\HQFRXQWHUHGWKH
TXLYHULQJERG\RIWKHFDSWLYHRQO\DVKDUSFUDFNOLQJVQDSEXWHDFK
FRUGOHIWDUHGVWUHDNDFURVV<DVDOD
VGDUNIOHVK9DOHULDLQIOLFWHG
WKHSXQLVKPHQWZLWKDOOWKHVWUHQJWKRIKHUZDUKDUGHQHGDUPZLWK
DOOWKHPHUFLOHVVQHVVDFTXLUHGGXULQJDOLIHZKHUHSDLQDQGWRUPHQW
ZHUHGDLO\KDSSHQLQJVDQGZLWKDOOWKHF\QLFDOLQJHQXLW\ZKLFKRQO\
DZRPDQGLVSOD\VWRZDUGDZRPDQ<DVDODVXIIHUHGPRUHSK\VLFDOO\DQG
PHQWDOO\WKDQVKHZRXOGKDYHVXIIHUHGXQGHUDODVKZLHOGHGE\DPDQ
KRZHYHUVWURQJ
,WZDVWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKLVIHPLQLQHF\QLFLVPZKLFKDWODVW
WDPHG<DVDOD
$ORZZKLPSHUHVFDSHGIURPKHUOLSVDQG9DOHULDSDXVHGDUP
OLIWHGDQGUDNHGEDFNDGDPS\HOORZORFN:HOODUH\RXJRLQJWR
WDON"VKHGHPDQGHG,FDQNHHSWKLVXSDOOQLJKWLIQHFHVVDU\
0HUF\ZKLVSHUHGWKHZRPDQ,ZLOOWHOO
9DOHULDFXWWKHFRUGVIURPKHUZULVWVDQGDQNOHVDQGSXOOHGKHU
WRKHUIHHW<DVDODVDQNGRZQRQWKHFRXFKKDOIUHFOLQLQJRQRQH
EDUHKLSVXSSRUWLQJKHUVHOIRQKHUDUPDQGZULWKLQJDWWKHFRQWDFW
RIKHUVPDUWLQJIOHVKZLWKWKHFRXFK6KHZDVWUHPEOLQJLQHYHU\
OLPE
:LQHVKHEHJJHGGU\OLSSHGLQGLFDWLQJZLWKDTXLYHULQJKDQGD
JROGYHVVHORQDQLYRU\WDEOH/HWPHGULQN,DPZHDNZLWKSDLQ
7KHQ,ZLOOWHOO\RXDOO
9DOHULDSLFNHGXSWKHYHVVHODQG<DVDODURVHXQVWHDGLO\WR
UHFHLYHLW6KHWRRNLWUDLVHGLWWRZDUGKHUOLSVWKHQGDVKHGWKH
FRQWHQWVIXOOLQWRWKH$TXLORQLDQ
VIDFH9DOHULDUHHOHGEDFNZDUG
VKDNLQJDQGFODZLQJWKHVWLQJLQJOLTXLGRXWRIKHUH\HV7KURXJKD
VPDUWLQJPLVWVKHVDZ<DVDODGDUWDFURVVWKHURRPIOLQJEDFNDEROW
WKURZRSHQWKHFRSSHUERXQGGRRUDQGUXQGRZQWKHKDOO7KHSLUDWHZDV
DIWHUKHULQVWDQWO\VZRUGRXWDQGPXUGHULQKHUKHDUW
%XW<DVDODKDGWKHVWDUWDQGVKHUDQZLWKWKHQHUYRXVDJLOLW\RI
DZRPDQZKRKDVMXVWEHHQZKLSSHGWRWKHSRLQWRIK\VWHULFDOIUHQ]\
6KHURXQGHGDFRUQHULQWKHFRUULGRU\DUGVDKHDGRI9DOHULDDQG
ZKHQWKHSLUDWHWXUQHGLWVKHVDZRQO\DQHPSW\KDOODQGDWWKH
RWKHUHQGDGRRUWKDWJDSHGEODFNO\$GDPSPROG\VFHQWUHHNHGXS
IURPLWDQG9DOHULDVKLYHUHG7KDWPXVWEHWKHGRRUWKDWKHGWRWKH
FDWDFRPEV<DVDODKDGWDNHQUHIXJHDPRQJWKHGHDG
9DOHULDDGYDQFHGWRWKHGRRUDQGORRNHGGRZQDIOLJKWRIVWRQH
VWHSVWKDWYDQLVKHGTXLFNO\LQWRXWWHUEODFNQHVV(YLGHQWO\LWZDVD
VKDIWWKDWOHGVWUDLJKWWRWKHSLWVEHORZWKHFLW\ZLWKRXWRSHQLQJ
XSRQDQ\RIWKHORZHUIORRUV6KHVKLYHUHGVOLJKWO\DWWKHWKRXJKWRI
WKHWKRXVDQGVRIFRUSVHVO\LQJLQWKHLUVWRQHF\SWVGRZQWKHUH
ZUDSSHGLQWKHLUPROGHULQJFORWKV6KHKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIJURSLQJ
KHUZD\GRZQWKRVHVWRQHVWHSV<DVDODGRXEWOHVVNQHZHYHU\WXUQDQG
WZLVWRIWKHVXEWHUUDQHDQWXQQHOV
6KHZDVWXUQLQJEDFNEDIIOHGDQGIXULRXVZKHQDVREELQJFU\
ZHOOHGXSIURPWKHEODFNQHVV,WVHHPHGWRFRPHIURPDJUHDWGHSWK
EXWKXPDQZRUGVZHUHIDLQWO\GLVWLQJXLVKDEOHDQGWKHYRLFHZDVWKDW
RIDZRPDQ2KKHOS+HOSLQ6HW
VQDPH$KKK,WWUDLOHGDZD\
DQG9DOHULDWKRXJKWVKHFDXJKWWKHHFKRRIDJKRVWO\WLWWHULQJ
9DOHULDIHOWKHUVNLQFUDZO:KDWKDGKDSSHQHGWR<DVDODGRZQ
WKHUHLQWKHWKLFNEODFNQHVV"7KHUHZDVQRGRXEWWKDWLWKDGEHHQVKH
ZKRKDGFULHGRXW%XWZKDWSHULOFRXOGKDYHEHIDOOHQKHU":DVD
;RWDODQFDOXUNLQJGRZQWKHUH"2OPHFKDGDVVXUHGWKHPWKDWWKH
FDWDFRPEVEHORZ7HFXKOWOLZHUHZDOOHGRIIIURPWKHUHVWWRRVHFXUHO\
IRUWKHLUHQHPLHVWREUHDNWKURXJK%HVLGHVWKDWWLWWHULQJKDGQRW
VRXQGHGOLNHDKXPDQEHLQJDWDOO
9DOHULDKXUULHGEDFNGRZQWKHFRUULGRUQRWVWRSSLQJWRFORVHWKH
GRRUWKDWRSHQHGRQWKHVWDLU5HJDLQLQJKHUFKDPEHUVKHFORVHGWKH
GRRUDQGVKRWWKHEROWEHKLQGKHU6KHSXOOHGRQKHUERRWVDQG
EXFNOHGKHUVZRUGEHOWDERXWKHU6KHZDVGHWHUPLQHGWRPDNHKHUZD\
WR&RQDQ
VURRPDQGXUJHKLPLIKHVWLOOOLYHGWRMRLQKHULQDQ
DWWDPSWWRILJKWWKHLUZD\RXWRIWKDWFLW\RIGHYLOV
%XWHYHQDVVKHUHDFKHGWKHGRRUWKDWRSHQHGLQWRWKHFRUULGRUD
ORQJGUDZQVFUHDPRIDJRQ\UDQJWKURXJKWKHKDOOVIROORZHGE\WKH
VWDPSRIUXQQLQJIHHWDQGWKHORXGFODQJRURIVZRUGV


7ZHQW\5HG1DLOV

7ZRZDUULRUVORXQJHGLQWKHJXDUGURRPRQWKHIORRUNQRZQDVWKH
7LHURIWKH(DJOH7KHLUDWWLWXGHZDVFDVXDOWKRXJKKDELWXDOO\
DOHUW$QDWWDFNRQWKHJUHDWEURQ]HGRRUIURPZLWKRXWZDVDOZD\VD
SRVVLELOLW\EXWIRUPDQ\\HDUVQRVXFKDVVDXOWKDGEHHQDWWHPSWHGRQ
HLWKHUVLGH
7KHVWUDQJHUVDUHVWURQJDOOLHVVDLGRQH2OPHFZLOOPRYH
DJDLQVWWKHHQHP\WRPRUURZ,EHOLHYH
+HVSRNHDVDVROGLHULQDZDUPLJKWKDYHVSRNHQ,QWKHPLQLDWXUH
ZRUOGRI;XFKRWOHDFKKDQGIXORIIHXGLVWVZDVDQDUP\DQGWKHHPSW\
KDOOVEHWZHHQWKHFDVWOHVZDVWKHFRXQWU\RYHUZKLFKWKH\FDPSDLJQHG
7KHRWKHUPHGLWDWHGIRUDVSDFH
6XSSRVHZLWKWKHLUDLGZHGHVWUR\;RWDODQFKHVDLG:KDWWKHQ
;DWPHF"
:K\UHWXUQHG;DWPHFZHZLOOGULYHUHGQDLOVIRUWKHPDOO7KH
FDSWLYHVZHZLOOEXUQDQGIOD\DQGTXDUWHU
%XWDIWHUZDUG"SXUVXHGWKHRWKHU$IWHUZHKDYHVODLQWKHPDOO"
:LOOLWQRWVHHPVWUDQJHWRKDYHQRIRHWRILJKW"$OOP\OLIH,KDYH
IRXJKWDQGKDWHGWKH;RWDODQFDV:LWKWKHIHXGHQGHGZKDWLVOHIW"
;DWPHFVKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUV+LVWKRXJKWVKDGQHYHUJRQHEH\RQG
WKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKHLUIRHV7KH\FRXOGQRWJREH\RQGWKDW
6XGGHQO\ERWKPHQVWLIIHQHGDWDQRLVHRXWVLGHWKHGRRU
7RWKHGRRU;DWPHFKLVVHGWKHODVWVSHDNHU,VKDOOORRN
WKURXJKWKH(\H
;DWPHFVZRUGLQKDQGOHDQHGDJDLQVWWKHEURQ]HGRRUVWUDLQLQJ
KLVHDUWRKHDUWKURXJKWKHPHWDO+LVPDWHORRNHGLQWRWKHPLUURU
+HVWDUWHGFRQYXOVLYHO\0HQZHUHFOXVWHUHGWKLFNO\RXWVLGHWKHGRRU
JULPGDUNIDFHGPHQZLWKVZRUGVJULSSHGLQWKHLUWHHWKBDQGWKHLU
ILQJHUVWKUXVWLQWRWKHLUHDUVB2QHZKRZRUHDIHDWKHUHGKHDGGUHVV
KDGDVHWRISLSHVZKFKKHVHWWRKLVOLSVDQGHYHQDVWKH7HFXKOWOL
VWDUWHGWRVKRXWDZDUQLQJWKHSLSHVEHJDQWRVNLUO
7KHFU\GLHGLQWKHJXDUG
VWKURDWDVWKHWKLQZHLUGSLSLQJ
SHQHWUDWHGWKHPHWDOGRRUDQGVPRWHRQKLVHDUV;DWPHFOHDQHGIUR]HQ
DJDLQVWWKHGRRUDVLISDUDO\]HGLQWKDWSRVLWLRQ+LVIDFHZDVWKDW
RIDZRRGHQLPDJHKLVH[SUHVVLRQRQHRIKRUULILHGOLVWHQLQJ7KH
RWKHUJXDUGIDUWKHUUHPRYHGIURPWKHVRXUFHRIWKHVRXQG\HWVHQVHG
WKHKRUURURIZKDWZDVWDNLQJSODFHWKHJULVO\WKUHDWWKDWOD\LQ
WKDWGHPRQLDFILILQJ+HIHOWWKHZHLUGVWUDLQVSOXFNLQJOLNHXQVHHQ
ILQJHUVDWWKHWLVVXHVRIKLVEUDLQILOOLQJKLPZLWKDOLHQHPRWLRQV
DQGLPSXOVHVRIPDGQHVV%XWZLWKDVRXOWHDULQJHIIRUWKHEURNHWKH
VSHOODQGVKULHNHGDZDUQLQJLQDYRLFHKHGLGQRWUHFRJQL]HDVKLV
RZQ
%XWHYHQDVKHFULHGRXWWKHPXVLFFKDQJHGWRDQXQEHDUDEOH
VKULOOLQJWKDWZDVOLNHDNQLIHLQWKHHDUGUXPV;DWPHFVFUHDPHGLQ
VXGGHQDJRQ\DQGDOOWKHVDQLW\ZHQWRXWRIKLVIDFHOLNHDIODPH
EORZQRXWLQDZLQG/LNHDPDGPDQKHULSSHGORRVHWKHFKDLQWRUH
RSHQWKHGRRUDQGUXVKHGRXWLQWRWKHKDOOVZRUGOLIWHGEHIRUHKLV
PDWHFRXOGVWRSKLP$GR]HQEODGHVVWUXFNKLPGRZQDQGRYHUKLV
PDQJOHGERG\WKH;RWDODQFDVVXUJHGLQWRWKHJXDUGURRPZLWKDORQJ
GUDZQEORRGPDG\HOOWKDWVHQWWKHXQZRQWHGHFKRHVUHYHUEHUDWLQJ
+LVEUDLQUHHOLQJIURPWKHVKRFNRILWDOOWKHUHPDLQLQJJXDUG
OHDSHGWRPHHWWKHPZLWKJRULQJVSHDU7KHKRUURURIWKHVRUFHU\KH
KDGMXVWZLWQHVVHGZDVVXEPHUJHGLQWKHVWXQQLQJUHDOL]DWLRQWKDWWKH
HQHP\ZHUHLQ7HFXKOWOL$QGDVKLVVSHDUKHDGULSSHGWKURXJKDGDUN
VNLQQHGEHOO\KHNQHZQRPRUHIRUDVZLQJLQJVZRUGFUXVKHGKLV
VNXOOHYHQDVZLOGH\HGZDUULRUVFDPHSRXULQJLQIURPWKHFKDPEHUV
EHKLQGWKHJXDUGURRP
,WZDVWKH\HOOLQJRIPHQDQGWKHFODQJLQJRIVWHHOWKDWEURXJKW
&RQDQERXQGLQJIURPKLVFRXFKZLGHDZDNHDQGEURDGVZRUGLQKDQG,Q
DQLQVWDQWKHKDGUHDFKHGWKHGRRUDQGIOXQJLWRSHQDQGZDVJODULQJ
RXWLQWRWKHFRUULGRUMXVWDV7HFKRWOUXVKHGXSLWH\HVEOD]LQJ
PDGO\
7KH;RWDODQFDVKHVFUHDPHGLQDYRLFHKDUGO\KXPDQB7KH\DUH
ZLWKLQWKHGRRUB
&RQDQUDQGRZQWKHFRUULGRUHYHQDV9DOHULDHPHUJHGIURPKHU
FKDPEHU
:KDWWKHGHYLOLVLW"VKHFDOOHG
7HFKRWOVD\VWKH;RWDODQFDVDUHLQKHDQVZHUHGKXUULHGO\7KDW
UDFNHWVRXQGVOLNHLW
:LWKWKH7HFXKOWOLRQWKHLUKHHOVWKH\EXUVWLQWRWKHWKURQHURRP
DQGZHUHFRQIURQWHGE\DVFHQHEH\RQGWKHPRVWIUDQWLFGUHDPRIEORRG
DQGIXU\7ZHQW\PHQDQGZRPHQWKHLUEODFNKDLUVWUHDPLQJDQGWKH
ZKLWHVNXOOVJOHDPLQJRQWKHLUEUHDVWVZHUHORFNHGLQFRPEDWZLWK
WKHSHRSOHRI7HFXKOWOL7KHZRPHQRQERWKVLGHVIRXJKWDVPDGO\DV
WKHPHQDQGDOUHDG\WKHURRPDQGWKHKDOOEH\RQGZHUHVWUHZQZLWK
FRUSVHV
2OPHFQDNHGEXWIRUDEUHHFKFORXWZDVILJKWLQJEHIRUHKLV
WKURQHDQGDVWKHDGYHQWXUHUVHQWHUHG7DVFHODUDQIURPDQLQQHU
FKDPEHUZLWKDVZRUGLQKHUKDQG
;DWPHFDQGKLVPDWHZHUHGHDGVRWKHUHZDVQRQHWRWHOOWKH
7HFXKOWOLKRZWKHLUIRHVKDGIRXQGWKHLUZD\LQWRWKHLUFLWDGHO1RU
ZDVWKHUHDQ\WRVD\ZKDWKDGSURPSWHGWKDWPDGDWWHPSW%XWWKH
ORVVHVRIWKH;RWDODQFDVKDGEHHQJUHDWHUWKHLUSRVLWLRQPRUH
GHVSHUDWHWKDQWKH7HFXKOWOLKDGNQRZQ7KHPDLPLQJRIWKHLUVFDO\
DOO\WKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKH%XUQLQJ6NXOODQGWKHQHZVJDVSHGE\D
G\LQJPDQWKDWP\VWHULRXVZKLWHVNLQDOOLHVKDGMRLQHGWKHLU
HQHPLHVKDGGULYHQWKHPWRWKHIUHQ]\RIGHVSHUDWLRQDQGWKHZLOG
GHWHUPLQDWLRQWRGLHGHDOLQJGHDWKWRWKHLUDQFLHQWIRHV
7KH7HFXKOWOLUHFRYHULQJIURPWKHILUVWVWXQQLQJVKRFNRIWKH
VXUSULVHWKDWKDGVZHSWWKHPEDFNLQWRWKHWKURQHURRPDQGOLWWHUHG
WKHIORRUZLWKWKHLUFRUSVHVIRXJKWEDFNZLWKDQHTXDOO\GHVSHUDWH
IXU\ZKLOHWKHGRRUJXDUGVIURPWKHORZHUIORRUVFDPHUDFLQJWRKXUO
WKHPVHOYHVLQWRWKHIUD\,WZDVWKHGHDWKILJKWRIUDELGZROYHV
EOLQGSDQWLQJPHUFLOHVV%DFNDQGIRUWKLWVXUJHGIURPGRRUWR
GDLVEODGHVZKLFNHULQJDQGVWULNLQJLQWRIOHVKEORRGVSXUWLQJIHHW
VWDPSLQJWKHFULPVRQIORRUZKHUHUHGGHUSRROVZHUHIRUPLQJ,YRU\
WDEOHVFUDVKHGRYHUVHDWVZHUHVSOLQWHUHGYHOYHWKDQJLQJVWRUQGRZQ
ZHUHVWDLQHGUHG,WZDVWKHEORRG\FOLPD[RIDEORRG\KDOIFHQWXU\
DQGHYHU\PDQWKHUHVHQVHGLW
%XWWKHFRQFOXVLRQZDVLQHYLWDEOH7KH7HFXKOWOLRXWQXPEHUHGWKH
LQYDGHUVDOPRVWWZRWRRQHDQGWKH\ZHUHKHDUWHQHGE\WKDWIDFWDQG
E\WKHHQWUDQFHLQWRWKHPHOHHRIWKHLUOLJKWVNLQQHGDOOLHV
7KHVHFUDVKHGLQWRWKHIUD\ZLWKWKHGHYDVWDWLQJHIIHFWRID
KXUULFDQHSORZLQJWKURXJKDJURYHRIVDSOLQJV,QVKHHUVWUHQJWKQR
WKUHH7OD]LWODQVZHUHDPDWFKIRU&RQDQDQGLQVSLWHRIKLVZHLJKW
KHZDVTXLFNHURQKLVIHHWWKDQDQ\RIWKHP+HPRYHGWKURXJKWKH
ZKLUOLQJHGG\LQJPDVVZLWKWKHVXUHW\DQGGHVWUXFWLYHQHVVRIDJUD\
ZROIDPLGVWDSDFNRIDOOH\FXUVDQGKHVWURGHRYHUDZDNHRI
FUXPSOHGILJXUHV
9DOHULDIRXJKWEHVLGHKLPKHUOLSVVPLOLQJDQGKHUH\HVEOD]LQJ
6KHZDVVWURQJHUWKDQWKHDYHUDJHPDQDQGIDUTXLFNHUDQGPRUH
IHURFLRXV+HUVZRUGZDVOLNHDOLYLQJWKLQJLQKHUKDQG:KHUH&RQDQ
EHDWGRZQRSSRVLWLRQE\WKHVKHHUZHLJKWDQGSRZHURIKLVEORZV
EUHDNLQJVSHDUVVSOLWWLQJVNXOOVDQGFOHDYLQJERVRPVWRWKH
EUHDVWERQH9DOHULDEURXJKWLQWRDFWLRQDILQHVVHRIVZRUGSOD\WKDW
GD]]OHGDQGEHZLOGHUHGKHUDQWDJRQLVWVEHIRUHLWVOHZWKHP$JDLQDQG
DJDLQDZDUULRUKHDYLQJKLJKKLVKHDY\EODGHIRXQGKHUSRLQWLQKLV
MXJXODUEHIRUHKHFRXOGVWULNH&RQDQWRZHULQJDERYHWKHILHOG
VWURGHWKURXJKWKHZHOWHUVPLWLQJULJKWDQGOHIWEXW9DOHULDPRYHG
OLNHDQLOOXVLYHSKDQWRPFRQVWDQWO\VKLIWLQJDQGWKUXVWLQJDQG
VODVKLQJDVVKHVKLIWHG6ZRUGVPLVVHGKHUDJDLQDQGDJDLQDVWKH
ZLHOGHUVIODLOHGWKHHPSW\DLUDQGGLHGZLWKKHUSRLQWLQWKHLU
KHDUWVRUWKURDWVDQGKHUPRFNLQJODXJKWHULQWKHLUHDUV
1HLWKHUVH[QRUFRQGLWLRQZDVFRQVLGHUHGE\WKHPDGGHQHG
FRPEDWDQWV7KHILYHZRPHQRIWKH;RWDODQFDVZHUHGRZQZLWKWKLU
WKURDWVFXWEHIRUH&RQDQDQG9DOHULDHQWHUHGWKHIUD\DQGZKHQDPDQ
RUZRPDQZHQWGRZQXQGHUWKHVWDPSLQJIHHWWKHUHZDVDOZD\VDNQLIH
UHDG\IRUWKHKHOSOHVVWKURDWRUDVDQGDOHGIRRWHDJHUWRFUXVKWKH
SURVWUDWHVNXOO
)URPZDOOWRZDOOIURPGRRUWRGRRUUROOHGWKHZDYHVRIFRPEDW
VSLOOLQJRYHULQWRDGMRLQLQJFKDPEHUV$QGSUHVHQWO\RQO\7HFXKOWOL
DQGWKHLUZKLWHVNLQQHGDOOLHVVWRRGXSULJKWLQWKHJUHDWWKURQH
URRP7KHVXUYLYRUVVWDUHGEOHDNO\DQGEODQNO\DWHDFKRWKHUOLNH
VXUYLYRUVDIWHU-XGJHPHQW'D\RUWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIWKHZRUOG2Q
OHJVZLGHEUDFHGKDQGVJULSSLQJQRWFKHGDQGGULSSLQJVZRUGVEORRG
WULFNOLQJGRZQWKHLUDUPVWKH\VWDUHGDWRQHDQRWKHUDFURVVWKH
PDQJOHGFRUSVHVRIIULHQGVDQGIRHV7KH\KDGQREUHDWKOHIWWR
VKRXWEXWDEHVWLDOPDGKRZOLQJURVHIURPWKHLUOLSV,WZDVQRWD
KXPDQFU\RIWULXPSK,WZDVWKHKRZOLQJRIDUDELGZROISDFN
VWDONLQJDPRQJWKHERGLHVRILWVYLFWLPV
&RQDQFDXJKW9DOHULD
VDUPDQGWXUQHGKHUDERXW
<RX
YHJRWDVWDELQWKHFDOIRI\RXUOHJKHJURZOHG
6KHJODQFHGGRZQIRUWKHILUVWWLPHDZDUHRIDVWLQJLQJLQWKH
PXVFOHVRIKHUOHJ6RPHG\LQJPDQRQWKHIORRUKDGIOHVKHGKLV
GDJJHUZLWKKLVODVWHIIRUW
<RXORRNOLNHDEXWFKHU\RXUVHOIVKHODXJKHG
+HVKRRNDUHGVKRZHUIURPKLVKDQGV
1RWPLQH2KDVFUDWFKKHUHDQGWKHUH1RWKLQJWRERWKHUDERXW
%XWWKDWFDOIRXJKWWREHEDQGDJHG
2OPHFFDPHWKURXJKWKHOLWWHUORRNLQJOLNHDJKRXOZLWKKLVQDNHG
PDVVLYHVKRXOGHUVVSODVKHGZLWKEORRGDQGKLVEODFNEHDUGGDEEOHGLQ
FULPVRQ+LVH\HVZHUHUHGOLNHWKHUHIOHFWLRQRIIODPHRQEODFN
ZDWHU
:HKDYHZRQKHFURDNHGGD]HGO\7KHIHXGLVHQGHG7KHGRJVRI
;RWDODQFOLHGHDG2KIRUDFDSWLYHWRIOD\DOLYH<HWLWLVJRRGWR
ORRNXSRQWKHLUGHDGIDFHV7ZHQW\GHDGGRJV7ZHQW\UHGQDLOVIRU
WKHEODFNFROXPQ
<RX
GEHVWVHHWR\RXUZRXQGHGJUXQWHG&RQDQWXUQLQJDZD\IURP
KLP+HUHJLUOOHWPHVHHWKDWOHJ
:DLWDPLQXWHVKHVKRRNKLPRIILPSDWLHQWO\7KHILUHRI
ILJKWLQJVWLOOEXUQHGEULJKWO\LQKHUVRXO+RZGRZHNQRZWKHVHDUH
DOORIWKHP"7KHVHPLJKWKDYHFRPHRQDUDLGRIWKHLURZQ
7KH\ZRXOGQRWVSOLWWKHFODQRQDIRUD\OLNHWKLVVDLG2OPHF
VKDNLQJKLVKHDGDQGUHJDLQLQJVRPHRIKLVRUGLQDU\LQWHOOLJHQFH
:LWKRXWKLVSXUSOHUREHWKHPDQVHHPHGOHVVOLNHDSULQFHWKDQVRPH
UHSHOOHQWEHDVWRISUH\,ZLOOVWDNHP\KHDGXSRQLWWKDWZHKDYH
VODLQWKHPDOO7KHUHZHUHOHVVRIWKHPWKDQ,GUHDPHGDQGWKH\PXVW
KDYHEHHQGHVSHUDWH%XWKRZFDPHWKH\LQ7HFXKOWOL"
7DVFHODFDPHIRUZDUGZLSLQJKHUVZRUGRQKHUQDNHGWKLJKDQG
KROGLQJLQKHURWKHUKDQGDQREMHFWVKHKDGWDNHQIURPWKHERG\RI
WKHIHDWKHUHGOHDGHURIWKH;RWDODQFDV
7KHSLSHVRIPDGQHVVVKHVDLG$ZDUULRUWHOOVPHWKDW;DWPHF
RSHQHGWKHGRRUWRWKH;RWDODQFDVDQGZDVFXWGRZQDVWKH\VWRUPHG
LQWRWKHJXDUGURRP7KLVZDUULRUFDPHWRWKHJXDUGURRPIURPWKHLQQHU
KDOOMXVWLQWLPHWRVHHLWKDSSHQDQGWRKHDUWKHODVWRIDZHLUG
VWUDLQRIPXVLFZKLFKIUR]HKLVYHU\VRXO7RONHPHFXVHGWRWDONRI
WKHVHSLSHVZKLFKWKH;XFKRWODQVVZRUHZHUHKLGGHQVRPHZKHUHLQWKH
FDWDFRPEVZLWKWKHERQHVRIWKHDQFLHQWZL]DUGZKRXVHGWKHPLQKLV
OLIHWLPH6RPHKRZWKHGRJVRI;RWDODQFIRXQGWKHPDQGOHDUQHGWKHLU
VHFUHW
6RPHERG\RXJKWWRJRWR;RWDODQFDQGVHHLIDQ\UHPDLQDOLYH
VDLG&RQDQ,
OOJRLIVRPHERG\ZLOOJXLGHPH
2OPHFJODQFHGDWWKHUHPQDQWVRIKLVSHRSOH7KHUHZHUHRQO\
WZHQW\OHIWDOLYHDQGRIWKHVHVHYHUDOOD\JURDQLQJRQWKHIORRU
7DVFHODZDVWKHRQO\RQHRIWKH7HFXKOWOLZKRKDGHVFDSHGZLWKRXWD
ZRXQG7KHSULQFHVVZDVXQWRXFKHGWKRXJKVKHKDGIRXJKWDVVDYDJHO\
DVDQ\
:KRZLOOJRZLWK&RQDQWR;RWDODQF"DVNHG2OPHF
7HFKRWOOLPSHGIRUZDUG7KHZRXQGLQKLVWKLJKKDGVWDUWHG
EOHHGLQJDIUHVKDQGKHKDGDQRWKHUJDVKDFURVVKLVULEV
,ZLOOJR
1R\RXZRQ
WYHWRHG&RQDQ$QG\RX
UHQRWJRLQJHLWKHU
9DOHULD,QDOLWWOHZKLOHWKDWOHJZLOOEHJHWWLQJVWLII
,ZLOOJRYROXQWHHUHGDZDUULRUZKRZDVNQRWWLQJDEDQGDJH
DERXWDVODVKHGIRUHDUP
9HU\ZHOO<DQDWK*RZLWKWKH&LPPHULDQ$QG\RXWRR7RSDO
2OPHFLQGLFDWHGDQRWKHUPDQZKRVHLQMXULHVZHUHVOLJKW%XWILUVW
DLGWROLIWWKHEDGO\ZRXQGHGRQWKHVHFRXFKHVZKHUHZHPD\EDQGDJH
WKHLUKXUWV
7KLVZDVGRQHTXLFNO\$VWKH\VWRRSHGWRSLFNXSDZRPDQZKRKDG
EHHQVWXQQHGE\DZDUFOXE2OPHF
VEHDUGEUXVKHG7RSDO
VHDU&RQDQ
WKRXJKWWKHSULQFHPXWWHUHGVRPHWKLQJWRWKHZDUULRUEXWKHFRXOG
QRWEHVXUH$IHZPRPHQWVODWHUKHZDVOHDGLQJKLVFRPSDQLRQVGRZQ
WKHKDOO
&RQDQJODQFHGEDFNDVKHZHQWRXWWKHGRRUDWWKDWVKDPEOHVZKHUH
WKHGHDGOD\RQWKHVPROGHULQJIORRUEORRGVWDLQHGGDUNOLPEV
NQRWWHGLQDWWLWXGHVRIILHUFHPXVFXODUHIIRUWGDUNIDFHVIUR]HQLQ
PDVNVRIKDWHJODVV\H\HVJODULQJXSDWWKHJUHHQILUHMHZHOVZKLFK
EDWKHGWKHJKDVWO\VFHQHLQDGXVN\HPHUDOGZLWFKOLJKW$PRQJWKH
GHDGWKHOLYLQJPRYHGDLPOHVVO\OLNHSHRSOHPRYLQJLQDWUDQFH
&RQDQKHDUG2OPHFFDOODZRPDQDQGGLUHFWKHUWREDQGDJH9DOHULD
V
OHJ7KHSLUDWHIROORZHGWKHZRPDQLQWRDQDGMRLQLQJFKDPEHUDOUHDG\
EHJLQQLQJWROLPSVOLJKWO\
:DULO\WKHWZR7HFXKOWOLOHG&RQDQDORQJWKHKDOOEH\RQGWKH
EURQ]HGRRUDQGWKURXJKFKDPEHUDIWHUFKDPEHUVKLPPHULQJLQWKH
JUHHQILUH7KH\VDZQRRQHKHDUGQRVRXQG$IWHUWKH\FURVVHGWKH
*UHDW+DOOZKLFKELVHFWHGWKHFLW\IURPQRUWKWRVRXWKWKHLUFDXWLRQ
ZDVLQFUHDVHGE\WKHUHDOL]DWLRQRIWKHLUQHDUQHVVWRHQHP\
WHUULWRU\%XWFKDPEHUVDQGKDOOVOD\HPSW\WRWKHLUZDU\JD]HDQG
WKH\FDPHDWODVWDORQJDEURDGGLPKDOOZD\DQGKDOWHGEHIRUHD
EURQ]HGRRUVLPLODUWRWKH(DJOH'RRURI7HFXKOWOL*LQJHUO\WKH\
WULHGLWDQGLWRSHQHGDWVLOHQWO\XQGHUWKHLUILQJHUV$ZHGWKH\
VWDUWHGLQWRWKHJUHHQOLWFKDPEHUVEH\RQG)RUILIW\\HDUVQR
7HFXKOWOLKDGHQWHUHGWKRVHKDOOVVDYHDVDSULVRQHUJRLQJWRD
KLGHRXVGRRP7RJRWR;RWDODQFKDGEHHQWKHXOWLPDWHKRUURUWKDW
FRXOGEHIDOODPDQRIWKHZHVWHUQFDVWOH7KHWHUURURILWKDG
VWDONHGWKURXJKWKHLUGUHDPVVLQFHHDUOLHVWFKLOGKRRG7R<DQDWKDQG
7RSROWKDWEURQ]HGRRUZDVOLNHWKHSRUWDORIKHOO
7KH\FULQJHGEDFNXQUHDVRQLQJKRUURULQWKHLUH\HVDQG&RQDQ
SXVKHGSDVWWKHPDQGVWURGHLQWR;RWDODQF
7LPLGO\WKH\IROORZHGKLP$VHDFKPDQVHWIRRWRYHUWKHWKUHVKROG
KHVWDUHGDQGJODUHGZLOGO\DERXWKLP%XWRQO\WKHLUTXLFNKXUULHG
EUHDWKLQJGLVWXUEHGWKHVLOHQFH
7KH\KDGFRPHLQWRDVTXDUHJXDUGURRPOLNHWKDWEHKLQGWKH(DJOH
'RRURI7HFXKOWOLDQGVLPLODUO\DKDOOUDQDZD\IURPLWWRDEURDG
FKDPEHUWKDWZDVDFRXQWHUSDUWRI2OPHF
VWKURQHURRP
&RQDQJODQFHGGRZQWKHKDOOZLWKLWVUXJVDQGGLYDQVDQGKDQJLQJV
DQGVWRRGOLVWHQLQJLQWHQWO\+HKHDUGQRQRLVHDQGWKHURRPVKDGDQ
HPSW\IHHO+HGLGQRWEHOLHYHWKHUHZHUHDQ\;RWDODQFDVOHIWDOLYH
LQ;XFKRWO
&RPHRQKHPXWWHUHGDQGVWDUWHGGRZQWKHKDOO
+HKDGQRWJRQHIDUZKHQKHZDVDZDUHWKDWRQO\<DQDWKZDV
IROORZLQJKLP+HZKHHOHGEDFNWRVHH7RSDOVWDQGLQJLQDQDWWLWXGH
RIKRUURURQHDUPRXWDVLIWRIHQGRIIVRPHWKUHDWHQLQJSHULOKLV
GLVWHQGHGH\HVIL[HGZLWKK\SQRWLFLQWHQVLW\RQVRPHWKLQJSURWUXGLQJ
IURPEHKLQGDGLYDQ
:KDWWKHGHYLO"7KHQ&RQDQVDZZKDW7RSDOZDVVWDULQJDWDQGKH
IHOWDIDLQWWZLWFKLQJRIWKHVNLQEHWZHHQKLVJLDQWVKRXOGHUV$
PRQVWURXVKHDGSURWUXGHGIURPEHKLQGWKHGLYDQDUHSWLOLDQKHDG
EURDGDVWKHKHDGRIDFURFRGLOHZLWKGRZQFXUYLQJIDQJVWKDW
SURMHFWHGRYHUWKHORZHUMDZ%XWWKHUHZDVDQXQQDWXUDOOLPSQHVV
DERXWWKHWKLQJDQGWKHKLGHRXVH\HVZHUHJOD]HG
&RQDQSHHUHGEHKLQGWKHFRXFK,WZDVDJUHDWVHUSHQWZKLFKOD\
WKHUHOLPSLQGHDWKEXWVXFKDVHUSHQWDVKHKDGQHYHUVHHQLQKLV
ZDQGHULQJV7KHUHHNDQGFKLOORIWKHGHHSEODFNHDUWKZHUHDERXWLW
DQGLWVFRORUZDVDQLQGHWHUPLQDEOHKXHZKLFKFKDQJHGZLWKHDFKQHZ
DQJOHIURPZKLFKKHVXUYH\HGLW$JUHDWZRXQGLQWKHQHFNVKRZHG
ZKDWKDGFDXVHGLWVGHDWK
,WLVWKH&UDZOHUZKLVSHUHG<DQDWK
,W
VWKHWKLQJ,VODVKHGRQWKHVWDLUJUXQWHG&RQDQ$IWHULW
WUDLOHGXVWRWKH(DJOH'RRULWGUDJJHGLWVHOIKHUHWRGLH+RZ
FRXOGWKH;RWDODQFDVFRQWUROVXFKDEUXWH"
7KH7HFXKOWOLVKLYHUHGDQGVKRRNWKHLUKHDGV
7KH\EURXJKWLWXSIURPWKHEODFNWXQQHOVEHORZWKHFDWDFRPEV
7KH\GLVFRYHUHGVHFUHWVXQNQRZQWR7HFXKOWOL
:HOOLW
VGHDGDQGLIWKH\
GKDGDQ\PRUHRIWKHPWKH\
GKDYH
EURXJKWWKHPDORQJZKHQWKH\FDPHWR7HFXKOWOL&RPHRQ
7KH\FURZGHGFORVHDWKLVKHHOVDVKHVWURGHGRZQWKHKDOODQG
WKUXVWRQWKHVLOYHUZRUNHGGRRUDWWKHRWKHUHQG
,IZHGRQ
WILQGDQ\ERG\RQWKLVIORRUKHVDLGZH
OOGHVFHQG
LQWRWKHORZHUIORRUV:H
OOH[SORUH;RWDODQFIURPWKHURRIWRWKH
FDWDFRPEV,I;RWDODQFLVOLNH7HFXKOWOLDOOWKHURRPVDQGKDOOVLQ
WKLVWLHUZLOOEHOLJKWHGZKDWWKHGHYLO
7KH\KDGFRPHLQWRWKHEURDGWKURQHFKDPEHUVRVLPLODUWRWKDW
RQHLQ7HFXKOWOL7KHUHZHUHWKHVDPHMDGHGDLVDQGLYRU\VHDWWKH
VDPHGLYDQVUXJVDQGKDQJLQJVRQWKHZDOOV1REODFNUHGVFDUUHG
FROXPQVWRRGEHKLQGWKHWKURQHGDLVEXWHYLGHQFHVRIWKHJULPIHXG
ZHUHQRWODFNLQJ
5DQJHGDORQJWKHZDOOEHKLQGWKHGDLVZHUHURZVRIJODVVFRYHUHG
VKHOYHV$QGRQWKRVHVKHOYHVKXQGUHGVRIKXPDQKHDGVSHUIHFWO\
SUHVHUYHGVWDUHGDWWKHVWDUWOHGZDWFKHUVZLWKHPRWLRQOHVVH\HVDV
WKH\KDGVWDUHGIRURQO\WKHJRGVNQHZKRZPDQ\PRQWKVDQG\HDUV
7RSDOPXWWHUHGDFXUVHEXW<DQDWKVWRRGVLOHQWWKHPDGOLJKW
JURZLQJLQKLVZLGHH\HV&RQDQIURZQHGNQRZLQJWKDW7OD]LWODQ
VDQLW\ZDVKXQJRQDKDLUWULJJHU
6XGGHQO\<DQDWKSRLQWHGWRWKHJKDVWO\UHOLFVZLWKDWZLWFKLQJ
ILQJHU
7KHUHLVP\EURWKHU
VKHDGKHPXUPXUHG$QGWKHUHLVP\
IDWKHU
V\RXQJHUEURWKHU$QGWKHUHEH\RQGWKHPLVP\VLVWHU
VHOGHVW
VRQ
6XGGHQO\KHEHJDQWRZHHSGU\H\HGZLWKKDUVKORXGVREVWKDW
VKRRNKLVIUDPH+HGLGQRWWDNHKLVH\HVIURPWKHKHDGV+LVVREV
JUHZVKULOOHUFKDQJHGWRIULJKWIXOKLJKSLWFKHGODXJKWHUDQGWKDW
LQWXUQEHFDPHDQXQEHDUDEOHVFUHDPLQJ<DQDWKZDVVWDUNPDG
&RQDQODLGDKDQGRQKLVVKRXOGHUDQGDVLIWKHWRXFKKDG
UHOHDVHGDOOWKHIUHQ]\LQKLVVRXO<DQDWKVFUHDPHGDQGZKLUOHG
VWULNLQJDWWKH&LPPHULDQZLWKKLVVZRUG&RQDQSDUULHGWKHEORZDQG
7RSDOWULHGWRFDWFK<DQDWK
VDUP%XWWKHPDGPDQDYRLGHGKLPDQG
ZLWKIURWKIO\LQJIURPKLVOLSVKHGURYHKLVVZRUGGHHSLQWR7RSDO
V
ERG\7RSDOVDQNGRZQZLWKDJURDQDQG<DQDWKZKLUOHGIRUDQLQVWDQW
OLNHDFUD]\GHUYLVKWKHQKHUDQDWWKHVKHOYHVDQGEHJDQKDFNLQJDW
WKHJODVVZLWKKLVVZRUGVFUHHFKLQJEODVSKHPRXVO\
&RQDQVSUDQJDWKLPIURPEHKLQGWU\LQJWRFDWFKKLPXQDZDUHDQG
GLVDUPKLPEXWWKHPDGPDQZKHHOHGDQGOXQJHGDWKLPVFUHDPLQJOLNH
DORVWVRXO5HDOL]LQJWKDWWKHZDUULRUZDVKRSHOHVVO\LQVDQHWKH
&LPPHULDQVLGHVWHSSHGDQGDVWKHPDQLDFZHQWSDVWKHVZXQJDFXW
WKDWVHYHUHGWKHVKRXOGHUERQHDQGEUHDVWDQGGURSSHGWKHPDQGHDG
EHVLGHKLVG\LQJYLFWLP
&RQDQEHQWRYHU7RSDOVHHLQJWKDWWKHPDQZDVDWKLVODVWJDVS
,WZDVXVHOHVVWRVHHNWRVWDQFKWKHEORRGJXVKLQJIURPWKHKRUULEOH
ZRXQG
<RX
UHGRQHIRU7RSDOJUXQWHG&RQDQ$Q\ZRUG\RXZDQWWR
VHQGWR\RXUSHRSOH"
%HQGFORVHUJDVSHG7RSDODQG&RQDQFRPSOLHGDQGDQLQVWDQW
ODWHUFDXJKWWKHPDQ
VZULVWDV7RSDOVWUXFNDWKLVEUHDVWZLWKD
GDJJHU
&URPVZRUH&RQDQ$UH\RXPDGWRR"
2OPHFRUGHUHGLWJDVSHGWKHG\LQJPDQ,NQRZQRWZK\$VZH
OLIWHGWKHZRXQGHGXSRQWKHFRXFKHVKHZKLVSHUHGWRPHELGGLQJPHWR
VOD\\RXDVZHUHWXUQHGWR7HFXKOWOL$QGZLWKWKHQDPHRIKLVFODQ
RQKLVOLSV7RSDOGLHG
&RQDQVFRZOHGGRZQDWKLPLQSX]]OHPHQW7KLVZKROHDIIDLUKDGDQ
DVSHFWRIOXQDF\:DV2OPHFPDGWRR":HUHDOOWKH7HFXKOWOLPDGGHU
WKDQKHKDGUHDOL]HG":LWKDVKUXJRIKLVVKRXOGHUVKHVWURGHGRZQ
WKHKDOODQGRXWRIWKHEURQ]HGRRUOHDYLQJWKHGHDG7HFXKOWOLO\LQJ
EHIRUHWKHVWDULQJGHDGH\HVRIWKHLUNLQVPHQ
VKHDGV
&RQDQQHHGHGQRJXLGHEDFNWKURXJKWKHODEU\LQWKWKH\KDG
WUDYHUVHG+LVSULPLWLYHLQVWLQFWRIGLUHFWLRQOHGKLPXQHUULQJO\
DORQJWKHURXWHWKH\KDGFRPH+HWUDYHUVHGLWDVZDULO\DVKHKDG
EHIRUHKLVVZRUGLQKLVKDQGDQGKLVH\HVILHUFHO\VHDUFKLQJHDFK
VKDGRZHGQRRNDQGFRUQHUIRULWZDVKLVIRUPHUDOOLHVKHIHDUHGQRZ
QRWWKHJKRVWVRIWKHVODLQ;RWDODQFDV
+HKDGFURVVHGWKH*UHDW+DOODQGHQWHUHGWKHFKDPEHUVEH\RQGZKHQ
KHKHDUGVRPHWKLQJPRYLQJDKHDGRIKLPVRPHWKLQJZKLFKJDVSHGDQG
SDQWHGDQGPRYHGZLWKDVWUDQJHIORXQGHULQJVFUDPEOLQJQRLVH$
PRPHQWODWHU&RQDQVDZDPDQFUDZOLQJRYHUWKHIODPLQJIORRUWRZDUG
KLPDPDQZKRVHSURJUHVVOHIWDEURDGEORRG\VPHDURQWKH
VPROGHULQJVXUIDFH,WZDV7HFKRWODQGKLVH\HVZHUHDOUHDG\JOD]LQJ
IURPDGHHSJDVKLQKLVEUHDVWEORRGJXVKHGVWHDGLO\EHWZHHQWKH
ILQJHUVRIKLVFOXWFKLQJKDQG:LWKWKHRWKHUKHFODZHGDQGKLWFKHG
KLPVHOIDORQJ
&RQDQKHFULHGFKRNLQJO\&RQDQ2OPHFKDVWDNHQWKH\HOORZ
KDLUHGZRPDQ
6RWKDW
VZK\KHWROG7RSDOWRNLOOPHPXUPXUHG&RQDQGURSSLQJ
WRKLVNQHHEHVLGHWKHPDQZKRKLVH[SHULHQFHGH\HWROGKLPZDV
G\LQJ2OPHFLVQ
WDVPDGDV,WKRXJKW
7HFKRWO
VJURSLQJILQJHUVSOXFNHGDW&RQDQ
VDUP,QWKHFROG
ORYHOHVVDQGDOWRJHWKHUKLGHRXVOLIHRIWKH7HFXKOWOLKLV
DGPLUDWLRQDQGDIIHFWLRQIRUWKHLQYDGHUVIURPWKHRXWHUZRUOGIRUPHG
DZDUPKXPDQRDVLVFRQVWLWXWHGDWLHWKDWFRQQHFWHGKLPZLWKDPRUH
QDWXUDOKXPDQLW\WKDWZDVWRWDOO\ODFNLQJLQKLVIHOORZVZKRVHRQO\
HPRWLRQVZHUHKDWHOXVWDQGWKHXUJHRIVDGLVWLFFUXHOW\
,VRXJKWWRRSSRVHKLPJXUJOHG7HFKRWOEORRGEXEEOLQJIURWKLO\
WRKLVOLSV%XWKHVWUXFNPHGRZQ+HWKRXJKWKHKDGVODLQPHEXW
,FUDZOHGDZD\$K6HWKRZIDU,KDYHFUDZOHGLQP\RZQEORRG
%HZDUH&RQDQ2OPHFPD\KDYHVHWDQDPEXVKIRU\RXUUHWXUQ6OD\
2OPHF+HLVDEHDVW7DNH9DOHULDDQGIOHH)HDUQRWWRWUDYHUVHWKH
IRUHVW2OPHFDQG7DVFHODOLHGDERXWWKHGUDJRQV7KH\VOHZHDFK
RWKHU\HDUVDJRDOOVDYHWKHVWURQJHVW)RUDGR]HQ\HDUVWKHUHKDV
EHHQRQO\RQHGUDJRQ,I\RXKDYHVODLQKLPWKHUHLVQDXJKWLQWKH
IRUHVWWRKDUP\RX+HZDVWKHJRG2OPHFZRUVKLSSHGDQG2OPHFIHG
KXPDQVDFULILFHVWRKLPWKHYHU\ROGDQGWKHYHU\\RXQJERXQGDQG
KXUOHGIURPWKHZDOO+DVWHQ2OPHFKDVWDNHQ9DOHULDWRWKH&KDPEHU
RIWKH
+LVKHDGVOXPSHGGRZQDQGKHZDVGHDGEHIRUHLWFDPHWRUHVWRQ
WKHIORRU
&RQDQVSUDQJXSKLVH\HVOLNHOLYHFRDOV6RWKDWZDV2OPHF
V
JDPHKDYLQJILUVWXVHGWKHVWUDQJHUVWRGHVWUR\KLVIRHV+HVKRXOG
KDYHNQRZQWKDWVRPHWKLQJRIWKHVRUWZRXOGEHJRLQJRQLQWKDW
EODFNEHDUGHGGHJHQHUDWH
VPLQG
7KH&LPPHULDQVWDUWHGWRZDUG7HFXKOWOLZLWKUHFNOHVVVSHHG
5DSLGO\KHUHFNRQHGWKHQXPEHUVRIKLVIRUPHUDOOLHV2QO\WZHQW\
RQHFRXQWLQJ2OPHFKDGVXUYLYHGWKDWILHQGLVKEDWWOHLQWKHWKURQH
URRP7KUHHKDGGLHGVLQFHZKLFKOHIWVHYHQWHHQHQHPLHVZLWKZKLFK
WRUHFNRQ,QKLVUDJH&RQDQIHOWFDSDEOHRIDFFRXQWLQJIRUWKHZKROH
FODQVLQJOHKDQGHG
%XWWKHLQQDWHFUDIWRIWKHZLOGHUQHVVURVHWRJXLGHKLVEHUVHUN
UDJH+HUHPHPEHUHG7HFKRWO
VZDUQLQJRIDQDPEXVK,WZDVTXLWH
SUREDEOHWKDWWKHSULQFHZRXOGPDNHVXFKSURYLVLRQVRQWKHFKDQFH
WKDW7RSDOPLJKWKDYHIDLOHGWRFDUU\RXWKLVRUGHU2OPHFZRXOGEH
H[SHFWLQJKLPWRUHWXUQE\WKHVDPHURXWHKHKDGIROORZHGLQJRLQJWR
;RWDODQF
&RQDQJODQFHGXSDWDVN\OLJKWXQGHUZKLFKKHZDVSDVVLQJDQG
FDXJKWWKHEOXUUHGJOLPPHURIVWDUV7KH\KDGQRW\HWEHJXQWRSDOH
IRUGDZQ7KHHYHQWVRIWKHQLJKWKDGEHHQFURZGHGLQWRD
FRPSDUDWLYHO\VKRUWVSDFHRIWLPH
+HWXUQHGDVLGHIURPKLVGLUHFWFRXUVHDQGGHVFHQGHGDZLQGLQJ
VWDLUFDVHWRWKHIORRUEHORZ+HGLGQRWNQRZZKHUHWKHGRRUZDVWR
EHIRXQGWKDWOHWLQWRWKHFDVWOHRQWKDWOHYHOEXWKHNQHZKHFRXOG
ILQGLW+RZKHZDVWRIRUFHWKHORFNVKHGLGQRWNQRZKHEHOLHYHG
WKDWWKHGRRUVRI7HFXKOWOLZRXOGDOOEHORFNHGDQGEROWHGLIIRUQR
RWKHUUHDVRQWKDQWKHKDELWVRIKDOIDFHQWXU\%XWWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJ
HOVHEXWWRDWWHPSWLW
6ZRUGLQKDQGKHKXUULHGQRLVHOHVVO\RQWKURXJKDPD]HRIJUHHQ
OLWRUVKDGRZ\URRPVDQGKDOOV+HNQHZKHPXVWEHQHDU7HFXKOWOL
ZKHQDVRXQGEURXJKWKLPXSVKRUW+HUHFRJQL]HGLWIRUZKDWLWZDV
DKXPDQEHLQJWU\LQJWRFU\RXWWKURXJKDVWLIOLQJJDJ,WFDPH
IURPVRPHZKHUHDKHDGRIKLPDQGWRWKHOHIW,QWKRVHGHDWKO\VWLOO
FKDPEHUVDVPDOOVRXQGFDUULHGDORQJZD\
&RQDQWXUQHGDVLGHDQGZHQWVHHNLQJDIWHUWKHVRXQGZKLFK
FRQWLQXHGWREHUHSHDWHG3UHVHQWO\KHZDVJODULQJWKURXJKDGRRUZD\
XSRQDZHLUGVFHQH,QWKHURRPLQWRZKLFKKHZDVORRNLQJDORZUDFN
OLNHIUDPHRILURQOD\RQWKHIORRUDQGDJLDQWILJXUHZDVERXQG
SURVWUDWHXSRQLW+LVKHDGUHVWHGRQDEHGRILURQVSLNHVZKLFK
ZHUHDOUHDG\FULPVRQSRLQWHGZLWKEORRGZKHUHWKH\KDGSLHUFHGKLV
VFDOS$SHFXOLDUKDUQHVVOLNHFRQWULYDQFHZDVIDVWHQHGDERXWKLV
KHDGWKRXJKLQVXFKDPDQQHUWKDWWKHOHDWKHUEDQGGLGQRWSURWHFW
KLVVFDOSIURPWKHVSLNHV7KLVKDUQHVVZDVFRQQHFWHGE\DVOHQGHU
FKDLQWRWKHPHFKDQLVPWKDWXSKHOGDKXJHLURQEDOOZKLFKZDV
VXVSHQGHGDERYHWKHFDSWLYH
VKDLU\EUHDVW$VORQJDVWKHPDQFRXOG
IRUFHKLPVHOIWRUHPDLQPRWLRQOHVVWKHLURQEDOOKXQJLQLWVSODFH
%XWZKHQWKHSDLQRIWKHLURQSRLQWVFDXVHGKLPWROLIWKLVKHDGWKH
EDOOOXUFKHGGRZQZDUGDIHZLQFKHV3UHVHQWO\KLVDFKLQJQHFNPXVFOHV
ZRXOGQRORQJHUVXSSRUWKLVKHDGLQLWVXQQDWXUDOSRVLWLRQDQGLW
ZRXOGIDOOEDFNRQWKHVSLNHVDJDLQ,WZDVREYLRXVWKDWHYHQWXDOO\
WKHEDOOZRXOGFUXVKKLPWRDSXOSVORZO\DQGLQH[RUDEO\7KHYLFWLP
ZDVJDJJHGDQGDERYHWKHJDJKLVJUHDWEODFNR[H\HVUROOHGZLOGO\
WRZDUGWKHPDQLQWKHGRRUZD\ZKRVWRRGLQVLOHQWDPD]HPHQW7KHPDQ
RQWKHUDFNZDV2OPHFSULQFHRI7HFXKOWOL


7KH(\HVRI7DVFHOD

:K\GLG\RXEULQJPHLQWRWKLVFKDPEHUWREDQGDJHP\OHJ"
GHPDQGHG9DOHULD&RXOGQ
W\RXKDYHGRQHLWMXVWDVZHOOLQWKH
WKURQHURRP"
6KHVDWRQDFRXFKZLWKKHUZRXQGHGOHJH[WHQGHGXSRQLWDQGWKH
7HFXKOWOLZRPDQKDGMXVWERXQGLWZLWKVLONEDQGDJHV9DOHULD
VUHG
VWDLQHGVZRUGOD\RQWKHFRXFKEHVLGHKHU
6KHIURZQHGDVVKHVSRNH7KHZRPDQKDGGRQHKHUWDVNVLOHQWO\DQG
HIILFLHQWO\EXW9DOHULDOLNHGQHLWKHUWKHOLQJHULQJFDUHVVLQJWRXFK
RIKHUVOLPILQJHUVQRUWKHH[SUHVVLRQLQKHUH\HV
7KH\KDYHWDNHQWKHUHVWRIWKHZRXQGHGLQWRWKHRWKHUFKDPEHUV
DQVZHUHGWKHZRPDQLQWKHVRIWVSHHFKRIWKH7HFXKOWOLZRPHQZKLFK
VRPHKRZGLGQRWVXJJHVWHLWKHUVRIWQHVVRUJHQWOHQHVVLQWKH
VSHDNHUV$OLWWOHZKLOHEHIRUH9DOHULDKDGVHHQWKLVVDPHZRPDQ
VWDED;RWDODQFDZRPDQWKURXJKWKHEUHDVWDQGVWDPSWKHH\HEDOOVRXW
RIDZRXQGHG;RWDODQFDPDQ
7KH\ZLOOEHFDUU\LQJWKHFRUSVHVRIWKHGHDGGRZQLQWRWKH
FDWDFRPEVVKHDGGHGOHVWWKHJKRVWVHVFDSHLQWRWKHFKDPEHUVDQG
GZHOOWKHUH
'R\RXEHOLHYHLQJKRVWV"DVNHG9DOHULD
,NQRZWKHJKRVWRI7RONHPHFGZHOOVLQWKHFDWDFRPEVVKH
DQVZHUHGZLWKDVKLYHU2QFH,VDZLWDV,FURXFKHGLQDFU\SW
DPRQJWKHERQHVRIDGHDGTXHHQ,WSDVVHGE\LQWKHIRUPRIDQ
DQFLHQWPDQZLWKIORZLQJZKLWHEHDUGDQGORFNVDQGOXPLQRXVH\HV
WKDWEOD]HGLQWKHGDUNQHVV,WZDV7RONHPHF,VDZKLPOLYLQJZKHQ,
ZDVDFKLOGDQGKHZDVEHLQJWRUWXUHG
+HUYRLFHVDQNWRDIHDUIXOZKLVSHU2OPHFODXJKVEXW,BNQRZB
7RONHPHF
VJKRVWGZHOOVLQWKHFDWDFRPEV7KH\VD\LWLVUDWVZKFK
JQDZWKHIOHVKIURPWKHERQHVRIWKHQHZO\GHDGEXWJKRVWVHDW
IOHVK:KRNQRZVEXWWKDW
6KHJODQFHGXSTXLFNO\DVDVKDGRZIHOODFURVVWKHFRXFK9DOHULD
ORRNHGXSWRVHH2OPHFJD]LQJGRZQDWKHU7KHSULQFHKDGFOHDQVHG
KLVKDQGVWRUVRDQGEHDUGRIWKHEORRGWKDWKDGVSODVKHGWKHPEXW
KHKDGQRWGRQQHGKLVUREHDQGKLVJUHDWGDUNVNLQQHGKDLUOHVVERG\
DQGOLPEVUHQHZHGWKHLPSUHVVLRQRIVWUHQJWKEHVWLDOLQLWVQDWXUH
+LVGHHSEODFNH\HVEXUQHGZLWKDPRUHHOHPHQWDOOLJKWDQGWKHUHZDV
WKHVXJJHVWLRQRIDWZLWFKLQJLQWKHILQJHUVWKDWWXJJHGDWKLVWKLFN
EOXHEODFNEHDUG
+HVWDUHGIL[HGO\DWWKHZRPDQDQGVKHURVHDQGJOLGHGIURPWKH
FKDPEHU$VVKHSDVVHGWKURXJKWKHGRRUVKHFDVWDORRNRYHUKHU
VKRXOGHUDW9DOHULDDJODQFHIXOORIF\QLFDOGHULVLRQDQGREVFHQH
PRFNHU\
6KHKDVGRQHDFOXPV\MREFULWLFL]HGWKHSULQFHFRPLQJWRWKH
GLYDQDQGEHQGLQJRYHUWKHEDQGDJH/HWPHVHH
:LWKDTXLFNQHVVDPD]LQJLQRQHRIKLVEXONKHVQDWFKHGKHUVZRUG
DQGWKUHZLWDFURVVWKHFKDPEHU+LVQH[WPRYHZDVWRFDWFKKHULQ
KLVJLDQWDUPV
4XLFNDQGXQH[SHFWHGDVWKHPRYHZDVVKHDOPRVWPDWFKHGLWIRU
HYHQDVKHJUDEEHGKHUKHUGLUNZDVLQKHUKDQGDQGVKHVWDEEHG
PXUGHURXVO\DWKLVWKURDW0RUHE\OXFNWKDQVNLOOKHFDXJKWKHU
ZULVWDQGWKHQEHJDQDVDYDJHZUHVWOLQJPDWFK6KHIRXJKWKLPZLWK
ILVWVIHHWNQHHVWHHWKDQGQDLOVZLWKDOOWKHVWUHQJWKRIKHU
PDJQLILFHQWERG\DQGDOOWKHNQRZOHGJHRIKDQGWRKDQGILJKWLQJVKH
KDGDFTXLUHGLQKHU\HDUVRIURYLQJDQGILJKWLQJRQVHDDQGODQG,W
DYDLOHGKHUQRWKLQJDJDLQVWKLVEUXWHVWUHQJWK6KHORVWKHUGLUNLQ
WKHILUVWPRPHQWRIFRQWDFWDQGWKHUHDIWHUIRXQGKHUVHOISRZHUOHVV
WRLQIOLFWDQ\DSSUHFLDEOHSDLQRQKHUJLDQWDWWDFNHU
7KHEOD]HLQKLVZHLUGEODFNH\HVGLGQRWDOWHUDQGWKHLU
H[SUHVVLRQILOOHGKHUZLWKIXU\IDQQHGE\WKHVDUGRQLFVPLOHWKDW
VHHPHGFDUYHGXSRQKLVEHDUGHGOLSV7KRVHH\HVDQGWKDWVPLOH
FRQWDLQHGDOOWKHFUXHOF\QLFLVPWKDWVHHWKHVEHORZWKHVXUIDFHRID
VRSKLVWLFDWHGDQGGHJHQHUDWHUDFHDQGIRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQKHUOLIH
9DOHULDH[SHULHQFHGIHDURIDPDQ,WZDVOLNHVWUXJJOLQJDJDLQVW
VRPHKXJHHOHPHQWDOIRUFHKLVLURQDUPVWKZDUWHGKHUHIIRUWVZLWKDQ
HDVHWKDWVHQWSDQLFUDFLQJWKURXJKKHUOLPEV+HVHHPHGLPSHUYLRXV
WRDQ\SDLQVKHFRXOGLQIOLFW2QO\RQFHZKHQVKHVDQNKHUZKLWH
WHHWKVDYDJHO\LQWRKLVZULVWVRWKDWWKHEORRGVWDUWHGGLGKH
UHDFW$QGWKDWZDVWREXIIHWKHUEUXWDOO\XSRQWKHVLGHRIWKHKHDG
ZLWKKLVRSHQKDQGVRWKDWVWDUVIODVKHGEHIRUHKHUH\HVDQGKHU
KHDGUROOHGRQKHUVKRXOGHUV
+HUVKLUWKDGEHHQWRUQRSHQLQWKHVWUXJJOHDQGZLWKF\QLFDO
FUXHOW\KHUDVSHGKLVWKLFNEHDUGDFURVVKHUEDUHEUHDVWVEULQJLQJ
WKHEORRGWRVXIIXVHWKHIDLUVNLQDQGIHWFKLQJDFU\RISDLQDQG
RXWUDJHGIXU\IURPKHU+HUFRQYXOVLYHUHVLVWDQFHZDVXVHOHVVVKH
ZDVFUXVKHGGRZQRQDFRXFKGLVDUPHGDQGSDQWLQJKHUH\HVEOD]LQJ
XSDWKLPOLNHWKHH\HVRIDWUDSSHGWLJUHVV
$PRPHQWODWHUKHZDVKXUU\LQJIURPWKHFKDPEHUFDUU\LQJKHULQ
KLVDUPV6KHPDGHQRUHVLVWDQFHEXWWKHVPROGHULQJRIKHUH\HV
VKRZHGWKDWVKHZDVXQFRQTXHUHGLQVSLULWDWOHDVW6KHKDGQRW
FULHGRXW6KHNQHZWKDW&RQDQZDVQRWZLWKLQFDOODQGLWGLGQRW
RFFXUWRKHUWKDWDQ\LQ7HFXKOWOLZRXOGRSSRVHWKHLUSULQFH%XWVKH
QRWLFHGWKDW2OPHFZHQWVWHDOWKLO\ZLWKKLVKHDGRQRQHVLGHDVLI
OLVWHQLQJIRUVRXQGVRISXUVXLWDQGKHGLGQRWUHWXUQWRWKHWKURQH
FKDPEHU+HFDUULHGKHUWKURXJKDGRRUWKDWVWRRGRSSRVLWHWKDW
WKURXJKZKLFKKHKDGHQWHUHGFURVVHGDQRWKHUURRPDQGEHJDQVWHDOLQJ
GRZQDKDOO$VVKHEHFDPHFRQYLQFHGWKDWKHIHDUHGVRPHRSSRVLWLRQ
WRWKHDEGXFWLRQVKHWKUHZEDFNKHUKHDGDQGVFUHDPHGDWWKHWRSRI
KHUOXVW\YRLFH
6KHZDVUHZDUGHGE\DVODSWKDWKDOIVWXQQHGKHUDQG2OPHF
TXLFNHQHGKLVSDFHWRDVKDPEOLQJUXQ
%XWKHUFU\KDGEHHQHFKRHGDQGWZLVWLQJKHUKHDGDERXW9DOHULD
WKURXJKWKHWHDUVDQGVWDUVWKDWSDUWO\EOLQGHGKHUVDZ7HFKRWO
OLPSLQJDIWHUWKHP
2OPHFWXUQHGZLWKDVQDUOVKLIWLQJWKHZRPDQWRDQXQFRPIRUWDEOH
DQGFHUWDLQO\XQGLJQLILHGSRVLWLRQXQGHURQHKXJHDUPZKHUHKHKHOG
KHUZULWKLQJDQGNLFNLQJYDLQO\OLNHDFKLOG
2OPHFSURWHVWHG7HFKRWO<RXFDQQRWEHVXFKDGRJDVWRGR
WKLVWKLQJ6KHLV&RQDQ
VZRPDQ6KHKHOSHGXVVOD\WKH;RWDODQFDV
DQG
:LWKRXWDZRUG2OPHFEDOOHGKLVIUHHKDQGLQWRDKXJHILVWDQG
VWUHWFKHGWKHZRXQGHGZDUULRUVHQVHOHVVDWKLVIHHW6WRRSLQJDQG
KLQGHUHGQRWDWDOOE\WKHVWUXJJOHVDQGLPSUHFDWLRQVRIKLVFDSWLYH
KHGUHZ7HFKRWO
VVZRUGIURPLWVVKHDWKDQGVWDEEHGWKHZDUULRULQ
WKHEUHDVW7KHQFDVWLQJDVLGHWKHZHDSRQKHIOHGRQDORQJWKH
FRUULGRU+HGLGQRWVHHDZRPDQ
VGDUNIDFHSHHUFDXWLRXVO\DIWHU
KLPIURPEHKLQGDKDQJLQJ,WYDQLVKHGDQGSUHVHQO\7HFKRWOJURDQHG
DQGVWLUUHGURVHGD]HGO\DQGVWDJJHUHGGUXQNHQO\DZD\FDOOLQJ
&RQDQ
VQDPH
2OPHFKXUULHGRQGRZQWKHFRUULGRUDQGGHVFHQGHGDZLQGLQJLYRU\
VWDLUFDVH+HFURVVHGVHYHUDOFRUULGRUVDQGKDOWHGDWODVWLQDEURDG
FKDPEHUZKRVHGRRUVZHUHYHLOHGZLWKKHDY\WDSHVWULHVZLWKRQH
H[FHSWLRQDKHDY\EURQ]HGRRUVLPLODUWRWKH'RRURIWKH(DJOHRQ
WKHXSSHUIORRU
+HZDVPRYHGWRUXPEOHSRLQWLQJWRLW7KDWLVRQHRIWKHRXWHU
GRRUVRI7HFXKOWOL)RUWKHILUVWWLPHLQILIW\\HDUVLWLV
XQJXDUGHG:HQHHGQRWJXDUGLWQRZIRU;RWDODQFLVQRPRUH
7KDQNVWR&RQDQDQGPH\RXEORRG\URJXHVQHHUHG9DOHULD
WUHPEOLQJZLWKIXU\DQGWKHVKDPHRISK\VLFDOFRHUFLRQ<RX
WUHFKHURXVGRJ&RQDQZLOOFXW\RXUWKURDWIRUWKLV
2OPHFGLGQRWERWKHUWRYRLFHKLVEHOLHIWKDW&RQDQ
VRZQJXOOHW
KDGDOUHDG\EHHQVHYHUHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLVZKLVSHUHGFRPPDQG+HZDV
WRRXWWHUO\F\QLFDOWREHDWDOOLQWHUHVWHGLQKHUWKRXJKWVRU
RSLQLRQV+LVIODPHOLWH\HVGHYRXUHGKHUGZHOOLQJEXUQLQJO\RQWKH
JHQHURXVH[SDQVHVRIFOHDUZKLWHIOHVKH[SRVHGZKHUHKHUVKLUWDQG
EUHHFKHVKDGEHHQWRUQLQWKHVWUXJJOH
)RUJHW&RQDQKHVDLGWKLFNO\2OPHFLVORUGRI;XFKRWO
;RWDODQFLVQRPRUH7KHUHZLOOEHQRPRUHILJKWLQJ:HVKDOOVSHQG
RXUOLYHVLQGULQNLQJDQGORYHPDNLQJ)LUVWOHWXVGULQN
+HVHDWHGKLPVHOIRQDQLYRU\WDEOHDQGSXOOHGKHUGRZQRQKLV
NQHHVOLNHDGDUNVNLQQHGVDW\UZLWKDZKLWHQ\PSKLQKLVDUPV
,JQRULQJKHUXQQ\PSKOLNHSURIDQLW\KHKHOGKHUKHOSOHVVZLWKRQH
JUHDWDUPDERXWKHUZDLVWZKLOHWKHRWKHUUHDFKHGDFURVVWKHWDEOH
DQGVHFXUHGDYHVVHORIZLQH
'ULQNKHFRPPDQGHGIRUFLQJLWWRKHUOLSVDVVKHZULWKHUHG
KHUKHDGDZD\
7KHOLTXRUVORSSHGRYHUVWLQJLQJKHUOLSVVSODVKLQJGRZQRQKHU
QDNHGEUHDVWV
<RXUJXHVWGRHVQRWOLNH\RXUZLQH2OPHFVSRNHDFRRO
VDUGRQLFYRLFH
2OPHFVWLIIHQHGIHDUJUHZLQKLVIODPLQJH\HV6ORZO\KHVZXQJ
KLVJUHDWKHDGDERXWDQGVWDUHGDW7DVFHODZKRSDVHGQHJOLJHQWO\LQ
WKHFXUWDLQHGGRRUZD\RQHKDQGRQKHUVPRRWKKLS9DOHULDWZLVWHG
KHUVHOIDERXWLQKLVLURQJULSDQGZKHQVKHPHWWKHEXUQLQJH\HVRI
7DVFHODDFKLOOWLQJOHGDORQJKHUVXSSOHVSLQH1HZH[SHULHQFHVZHUH
IORRGLQJ9DOHULD
VSURXGVRXOWKDWQLJKW5HFHQWO\VKHKDGOHDUQHGWR
IHDUDPDQQRZVKHNQHZZKDWLWZDVWRIHDUDZRPDQ
2OPHFVDWPRWLRQOHVVDJUD\SDOORUJURZLQJXQGHUKLVVZDUWK\
VNLQ7DVFHODEURXJKWKHURWKHUKDQGIURPEHKLQGKHUDQGGLVSOD\HGD
VPDOOJROGYHVVHO
,IHDUHGVKHZRXOGQRWOLNH\RXUZLQH2OPHFSXUUHGWKH
SULQFHVVVR,EURXJKWVRPHRIPLQHVRPH,EURXJKWZLWKPHORQJDJR
IURPWKHVKRUHVRI/DNH=XDGGR\RXXQGHUVWDQG2OPHF"
%HDGVRIVZHDWVWRRGRXWVXGGHQO\RQ2OPHF
VEURZ+LVPXVFOHV
UHOD[HGDQG9DOHULDEURNHDZD\DQGSXWWKHWDEOHEHWZHHQWKHP%XW
WKRXJKUHDVRQWROGKHUWRGDUWIURPWKHURRPVRPHIDVFLQDWLRQVKH
FRXOGQRWXQGHUVWDQGKHOGKHUULJLGZDWFKLQJWKHVFHQH
7DVFHODFDPHWRZDUGWKHVHDWHGSULQFHZLWKDVZD\LQJXQGXODWLQJ
ZDONWKDWZDVPRFNHU\LQLWVHOI+HUYRLFHZDVVRIWVOXUULQJO\
FDUHVVLQJEXWKHH\HVJOHDPHG+HUVOLPILQJHUVVWURNHGKLVEHDUG
OLJKWO\
<RXDUHVHOILVK2OPHFVKHFURRQHGVPLOLQJ<RXZRXOGNHHS
RXUKDQGVRPHJXHVWWR\RXUVHOIWKRXJK\RXNQHZ,ZLVKHGWRHQWHUWDLQ
KHU<RXDUHPXFKDWIDXOW2OPHF
7KHPDVNGURSSHGIRUDQLQVWDQWKHH\HVIODVKHGKHUIDFHZDV
FRQWRUWHGDQGZLWKDQDSSDOOLQJVKRZRIVWUHQJWKKHUKDQGORFNHG
FRQYXOVLYHO\LQKLVEHDUGDQGWRUHRXWDJUHDWKDQGIXO7KLVHYLGHQFH
RIXQQDWXUDOVWUHQJWKZDVQRPRUHWHUULI\LQJWKDQWKHPRPHQWDU\
EDULQJRIWKHKHOOLVKIXU\WKDWUDJHGXQGHUKHUEODQGH[WHULRU
2OPHFOXUFKHGXSZLWKDURDUDQGVWRRGVZD\LQJOLNHDEHDUKLV
PLJKW\KDQGVFOHQFKLQJDQGXQFOHQFKLQJ
6OXW+LVERRPLQJYRLFHILOOHGWKHURRP:LWFK6KHGHYLO
7HFXKOWOLVKRXOGKDYHVODLQ\RXILIW\\HDUVDJR%HJRQH,KDYH
HQGXUHGWRRPXFKIURP\RX7KLVZKLWHVNLQQHGZHQFKLVPLQH*HW
KHQFHEHIRUH,VOD\\RX
7KHSULQFHVVODXJKHGDQGGDVKHGWKHEORRGVWDLQHGVWUDQGVLQWRKLV
IDFH+HUODXJKWHUZDVOHVVPHUFLIXOWKDQWKHULQJRIIOLQWRQVWHHO
2QFH\RXVSRNHRWKHUZLVH2OPHFVKHWDXQWHG2QFHLQ\RXU
\RXWK\RXVSRNHZRUGVRIORYH$\H\RXZHUHP\ORYHURQFH\HDUV
DJRDQGEHFDXVH\RXORYHGPH\RXVOHSWLQP\DUPVEHQHDWKWKH
HQFKDQWHGORWXVDQGWKHUHE\SXWLQWRP\KDQGVWKHFKDLQVWKDW
HQVODYHG\RX<RXNQRZ\RXFDQQRWZLWKVWDQGPH<RXNQRZ,KDYHEXW
WRJD]HLQWR\RXUH\HVZLWKWKHP\VWLFSRZHUDSULHVWRI6W\JLD
WDXJKWPHORQJDJRDQG\RXDUHSRZHUOHVV<RXUHPHPEHUWKHQLJKW
EHQHDWKWKHEODFNORWXVWKDWZDYHGDERYHXVVWLUUHGE\QRZRUOGO\
EUHH]H\RXVFHQWDJDLQWKHXQHDUWKO\SHUIXPHVWKDWVWROHDQGURVH
OLNHDFORXGDERXW\RXWRHQVODYH\RX<RXFDQQRWILJKWDJDLQVWPH
<RXDUHP\VODYHDV\RXZHUHWKDWQLJKWDV\RXVKDOOEHVRORQJDV
\RXOLYH2OPHFRI;XFKRWO
+HUYRLFHKDGVXQNWRDPXUPXUOLNHWKHULSSOLQJRIDVWUHDP
UXQQLQJWKURXJKVWDUOLWGDUNQHVV6KHOHDQHGFORVHWRWKHSULQFHDQG
VSUHDGKHUORQJWDSHULQJILQJHUVXSRQKLVJLDQWEUHDVW+LVH\HV
JODUHGKLVJUHDWKDQGVIHOOOLPSO\WRKLVVLGHV
:LWKDVPLOHRIFUXHOPDOLFH7DVFHODOLIWGWKHYHVVHODQGSODFHG
LWWRKLVOLSV
'ULQN
0HFKDQLFDOO\WKHSULQFHREH\HG$QGLQVWDQWO\WKHJOD]HSDVVHG
IURPKLVH\HVDQGWKH\ZHUHIORRGHGZLWKIXU\FRPSUHKHQVLRQDQGDQ
DZIXOIHDU+LVPRXWKJDSHGEXWQRVRXQGLVVXHG)RUDQLQVWDQWKH
UHHOHGRQEXFNOLQJNQHHVDQGWKHQIHOOLQDVRGGHQKHDSRQWKH
IORRU
+LVIDOOMROWHG9DOHULDRXWRIKHUSDUDO\VLV6KHWXUQHGDQG
VSUDQJWRZDUGWKHGRRUEXWZLWKDPRYHPHQWWKDWZRXOGKDYHVKDPHGD
OHDSLQJSDQWKHU7DVFHODZDVEHIRUHKHU9DOHULDVWUXFNDWKHUZLWK
KHUFOHQFKHGILVWDQGDOOWKHSRZHURIKHUVXSSOHERG\EHKLQGWKH
EORZ,WZRXOGKDYHVWUHWFKHGDPDQVHQVHOHVVRQWKHIORRU%XWZLWK
DOLWKHWZLVWRIKHUWRUVR7DVFHODDYRLGHGWKHEORZDQGFDXJKWWKH
SLUDWH
VZULVW7KHQH[WLQVWDQW9DOHULD
VOHIWKDQGZDVLPSULVRQHG
DQGKROGLQJKHUZULVWVWRJHWKHUZLWKRQHKDQG7DVDFHODFDOPO\ERXQG
WKHPZLWKDFRUGVKHGUHZIURPKHUJLUGOH9DOHULDWKRXJKWVKHKDG
WDVWHGWKHXOWLPDWHLQKXPLOLDWLRQDOUHDG\WKDWQLJKWEXWKHUVKDPH
DWEHLQJPDQKDQGOHGE\2OPHFZDVQRWKLQJWRWKHVHQVDWLRQVWKDWQRZ
VKRRNKHUVXSSOHIUDPH9DOHULDKDGDOZD\VEHHQLQFOLQHGWRGHVSLVH
WKHRWKHUPHPEHUVRIKHUVH[DQGLWZDVRYHUZKHOPLQJWRHQFRXQWHU
DQRWKHUZRPDQZKRFRXOGKDQGOHKHUOLNHDFKLOG6KHVFDUFHO\
UHVLVWHGDWDOOZKHQ7DVFHODIRUFHGKHULQWRDFKDLUDQGGUDZLQJKHU
ERXQGZULVWVGRZQEHWZHHQKHUNQHHVIDVWHQHGWKHPWRWKHFKDLU
&DVXDOO\VWHSSLQJRYHU2OPHF7DVFHODZDONHGWRWKHEURQ]HGRRU
DQGVKRWWKHEROWDQGWKUHZLWRSHQUHYHDOLQJDKDOOZD\ZLWKRXW
2SHQLQJXSRQWKLVKDOOVKHUHPDUNHGVSHDNLQJWRKHUIHPLQLQH
FDSWLYHIRUWKHILUVWWLPHWKHUHLVDFKDPEHUZKLFKLQROGWLPHV
ZDVXVHGDVDWRUWXUHURRP:KHQZHUHWLUHGLQWR7HFXKOWOLZH
EURXJKWPRVWRIWKHDSSDUDWXVZLWKXVEXWWKHUHZDVRQHSLHFHWRR
KHDY\WRPRYH,WLVVWLOOLQZRUNLQJRUGHU,WKLQNLWZLOOEHTXLWH
FRQYHQLHQWQRZ
$QXQGHUVWDQGLQJIODPHRIWHUURUURVHLQ2OPHF
VH\HV7DVFHOD
VWURGHEDFNWRKLPEHQWDQGJULSSHGKLPE\WKHKDLU
+HLVRQO\SDUDO\]HGWHPSRUDULO\VKHUHPDUNHGFRQYHUVDWLRQDOO\
+HFDQKHDUWKLQNDQGIHHOD\HKHFDQIHHOYHU\ZHOOLQGHHG
:LWKZKLFKVLQLVWHUREVHUYDWLRQVKHVWDUWHGWRZDUGWKHGRRU
GUDJJLQJWKHJLDQWEXONZLWKDQHDVHWKDWPDGHWKHSLUDWH
VH\HV
GLODWH6KHSDVVHGLQWRWKHKDOODQGPRYHGGRZQLWZLWKRXW
KHVLWDWLRQSUHVHQWO\GLVDSSHDULQJZLWKKHUFDSWLYHLQWRDFKDPEHU
WKDWRSHQHGLQWRLWDQGZKHQFHVKRUWO\WKHUHDIWHULVVXHGWKHFODQN
RILURQ
9DOHULDVZRUHVRIWO\DQGWXJJHGYDLQO\ZLWKKHUOHJVEUDFHG
DJDLQVWWKHFKDLU7KHFRUGVWKDWFRQILQHGKHUZHUHDSSDUHQWO\
XQEUHDNDEOH
7DVFHODSUHVHQWO\UHWXUQHGDORQHEHKLQGKHUDPXIIOHGJURDQLQJ
LVVXHGIURPWKHFKDPEHU6KHFORVHGWKHGRRUEXWGLGQRWEROWLW
7DVFHODZDVEH\RQGWKHJULSRIKDELWDVVKHZDVEH\RQGWKHWRXFKRI
RWKHUKXPDQLQVWLQFWVDQGHPRWLRQV
9DOHULDVDWGXPEO\ZDWFKLQJWKHZRPDQLQZKRVHVOLPKDQGVWKH
SLUDWHUHDOL]HGKHUGHVWLQ\QRZUHVWHG
7DVFHODJUDVSHGKHU\HOORZORFNVDQGIRUFHGEDFNKHUKHDGORRNLQJ
LPSHUVRQDEO\GRZQLQWRKHUIDFH%XWWKHJOLWWHULQKHUGDUNH\HVZDV
QRWLPSHUVRQDEOH
,KDYHFKRVHQ\RXIRUDJUHDWKRQRUVKHVDLG<RXVKDOO
UHVWRUHWKH\RXWKRI7DVFHOD2K\RXVWDUHDWWKDW0\DSSHDUDQFHLV
WKDWRI\RXWKEXWWKURXJKP\YHLQVFUHHSVWKHVOXJJLVKFKLOORI
DSSURDFKLQJDJHDV,KDYHIHOWLWDWKRXVDQGWLPHVEHIRUH,DPROG
VRROG,GRQRWUHPHPEHUP\FKLOGKRRG%XW,ZDVDJLUORQFHDQGD
SULHVWRI6W\JLDORYHGPHDQGJDYHPHWKHVHFUHWRILPPRUWDOLW\DQG
\RXWKHYHUODVWLQJ+HGLHGWKHQVRPHVDLGE\SRLVRQ%XW,GZHOW
LQP\SDODFHE\WKHVKRUHVRI/DNH=XDGDQGWKHSDVVLQJ\HDUVWRXFKHG
PHQRW6RDWODVWDNLQJRI6W\JLDGHVLUHGPHDQGP\SHRSOH
UHEHOOHGDQGEURXJKWPHWRWKLVODQG2OPHFFDOOHGPHDSULQFHVV,
DPQRWRIUR\DOEORRG,DPJUHDWHUWKDQDSULQFHVV,DP7DVFHOD
ZKRVH\RXWK\RXURZQJORULRXV\RXWKVKDOOUHVWRUH
9DOHULD
VWRQJXHFORYHWRWKHURRIRIKHUPRXWK6KHVHQVHGKHUHD
P\VWHU\GDUNHUWKDQWKHGHJHQHUDF\VKHKDGDQWLFLSDWHG
7KHWDOOHUZRPDQXQERXQGWKH$TXLORQLDQ
VZULVWVDQGSXOOHGKHUWR
KHUIHHW,WZDVQRWIHDURIWKHGRPLQDQWVWUHQJWKWKDWOXUNHGLQWKH
SULQFHVV
OLPEVWKDWPDGH9DOHULDDKHOSOHVVTXLYHULQJFDSWLYHLQ
KHUKDQGV,WZDVWKHEXUQLQJK\SQRWLFWHUULEOHH\HVRI7DVFHOD


+H&RPHVIURPWKH'DUN

:HOO,
PD.XVKLWH
&RQDQJODUHGGRZQDWWKHPDQRQWKHLURQUDFN
:KDWWKHGHYLODUH\RXGRLQJRQWKDWWKLQJ"
,QFRKHUHQWVRXQGVLVVXHGIURPEHKLQGWKHJDJDQG&RQDQEHQWDQG
WRUHLWDZD\HYRNLQJDEHOORZRIIHDUIURPWKHFDSWLYHIRUKLV
DFWLRQFDXVHGWKHLURQEDOOWROXUFKGRZQXQWLOLWQHDUO\WRXFKHGWKH
EURDGEUHDVW
%HFDUHIXOIRU6HW
VVDNHEHJJHG2OPHF
:KDWIRU"GHPDQGHG&RQDQ'R\RXWKLQN,FDUHZKDWKDSSHQVWR
\RX",RQO\ZLVK,KDGWLPHWRVWD\KHUHDQGZDWFKWKDWFKXQNRILURQ
JULQG\RXUJXWVRXW%XW,
PLQDKXUU\:KHUH
V9DOHULD"
/RRVHPHXUJHG2OPHF,ZLOOWHOO\RXDOO
7HOOPHILUVW
1HYHU7KHSULQFH
VKHDY\MDZVVHWVWXEERUQO\
$OOULJKW&RQDQVHDWHGKLPVHOIRQDQHDUE\EHQFK,
OOILQG
KHUP\VHOIDIWHU\RX
YHEHHQUHGXFHGWRDMHOO\,EHOLHYH,FDQ
VSHHGXSWKDWSURFHVVE\WZLVWLQJP\VZRUGSRLQWDURXQGLQ\RXUHDU
KHDGGHGH[WHQGLQJWKHZHDSRQH[SHULPHQWDOO\
:DLW:RUGVFDPHLQDUXVKIURPWKHFDSWLYH
VDVK\OLSV
7DVFHODWRRNKHUIURPPH,
YHQHYHUEHHQDQ\WKLQJEXWDSXSSHWLQ
7DVFHOD
VKDQGV
7DVFHOD"VQRUWHG&RQDQDQGVSDW:K\WKHILOWK\
1RQRSDQWHG2OPHF,W
VZRUVHWKDQ\RXWKLQN7DVFHODLVROG
FHQWXULHVROG6KHUHQHZVKHUOLIHDQGKHU\RXWKE\WKHVDFULILFH
RIEHDXWLIXO\RXQJZRPHQ7KDW
VRQHWKLQJWKDWKDVUHGXFHGWKHFODQ
WRLWVSUHVHQWVWDWH6KHZLOOGUDZWKHHVVHQFHRI9DOHULD
VOLIH
LQWRKHURZQERG\DQGEORRPZLWKIUHVKYLJRUDQGEHDXW\
$UHWKHGRRUVORFNHG"DVNHG&RQDQWKXPELQJKLVVZRUGHGJH
$\H%XW,NQRZDZD\WRJHWLQWR7HFXKOWOL2QO\7DVFHODDQG,
NQRZDQGVKHWKLQNVPHKHOSOHVVDQG\RXVODLQ)UHHPHDQG,VZHDU,
ZLOOKHOS\RXUHVFXH9DOHULD:LWKRXWP\KHOS\RXFDQQRWZLQLQWR
7HFXKOWOLIRUHYHQLI\RXWRUWXUHGPHLQWRUHYHDOLQJWKHVHFUHW\RX
FRXOGQ
WZRUNLW/HWPHJRDQGZHZLOOVWHDORQ7DVFHODDQGNLOO
KHUEHIRUHVKHFDQZRUNPDJLFEHIRUHVKHFDQIL[KHUH\HVRQXV$
NQLIHWKURZQIURPEHKLQGZLOOGRWKHZRUN,VKRXOGKDYHNLOOHGKHU
WKXVORQJDJREXW,IHDUHGWKDWZLWKRXWKHUWRDLGXVWKH;RWDODQFDV
ZRXOGRYHUFRPHXV6KHQHHGHGP\KHOSWRRWKDW
VWKHRQO\UHDVRQ
VKHOHWPHOLYHWKLVORQJ1RZQHLWKHUQHHGVWKHRWKHUDQGRQHPXVW
GLH,VZHDUWKDWZKHQZHKDYHVODLQWKHZLWFK\RXDQG9DOHULDVKDOO
JRIUHHZLWKRXWKDUP0\SHRSOHZLOOREH\PHZKHQ7DVFHODLVGHDG
&RQDQVWRRSHGDQGFXWWKHURSHVWKDWKHOGWKHSULQFHDQG2OPHF
VOLGFDXWLRXVO\IURPXQGHUWKHJUHDWEDOODQGURVHVKDNLQJKLVKHDG
OLNHDEXOODQGPXWWHULQJLPSUHFDWLRQVDVKHILQJHUHGKLVODFHUDWHG
VFDOS6WDQGLQJVKRXOGHUWRVKRXOGHUWKHWZRPHQSUHVHQWHGD
IRUPLGDEOHSLFWXUHRISULPLWLYHSRZHU2OPHFZDVDVWDOODV&RQDQ
DQGKHDYLHUEXWWKHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJUHSHOOHQWDERXWWKH7OD]LWODQ
VRPHWKLQJDE\VPDODQGPRQVWURXVWKDWFRQWUDVWHGXQIDYRUDEO\ZLWKWKH
FOHDQFXWFRPSDFWKDUGQHVVRIWKH&LPPHULDQ&RQDQKDGGLVFDUGHGWKH
UHPQDQWVRIKLVWDWWHUHGEORRGVRDNHGVKLUWDQGVWRRGZLWKKLV
UHPDUNDEOHPXVFXODUGHYHORSPHQWLPSUHVVLYHO\UHYHDOHG+LVJUHDW
VKRXOGHUVZHUHDVEURDGDVWKRVHRI2OPHFDQGPRUHFOHDQO\RXWOLQHG
DQGKLVKXJHEUHDVWDUFKHGZLWKDPRUHLPSUHVVLYHVZHHSWRDKDUG
ZDLVWWKDWODFNHGWKHSDXQFK\WKLFNQHVVRI2OPHF
VPLGVHFWLRQ+H
PLJKWKDYHEHHQDQLPDJHRISULPDOVWUHQJWKFXWRXWRIEURQ]H2OPHF
ZDVGDUNHUEXWQRWIURPWKHEXUQLQJRIWKHVXQ,I&RQDQZDVD
ILJXUHRXWRIWKHGDZQRIWLPH2OPHFZDVDVKDPEOLQJVRPEHUVKDSH
IURPWKHGDUNQHVVRIWLPH
VSUHGDZQ
/HDGRQGHPDQGHG&RQDQ$QGNHHSDKHDGRIPH,GRQ
WWUXVW
\RXDQ\IDUWKHUWKDQ,FDQWKURZDEXOOE\WKHWDLO
2OPHFWXUQHGDQGVWDONHGRQDKHDGRIKLPRQHKDQGWZLWFKLQJ
VOLJKWO\DVLWSOXFNHGDWKLVPDWWHGEHDUG
2OPHFGLGQRWOHDG&RQDQEDFNWRWKHEURQ]HGRRUZKLFKWKHSULQFH
QDWXUDOO\VXSSRVHG7DVFHODKDGORFNHGEXWWRDFHUWDLQFKDPEHURQ
WKHERUGHURI7HFXKOWOL
7KLVVHFUHWKDVEHHQJXDUGHGIRUKDOIDFHQWXU\KHVDLG1RW
HYHQRXURZQFODQNQHZRILWDQGWKH;RWDODQFDVQHYHUOHDUQHG
7HFXKOWOLKLPVHOIEXLOWWKLVVHFUHWHQWUDQFHDIWHUZDUGVVOD\LQJWKH
VODYHVZKRGLGWKHZRUNIRUKHIHDUHGWKDWKHPLJKWILQGKLPVHOI
ORFNHGRXWRIKLVRZQNLQJGRPVRPHGD\EHFDXVHRIWKHVSLWHRI
7DVFHODZKRVHSDVVLRQIRUKLPVRRQFKDQJHGWRKDWH%XWVKH
GLVFRYHUHGWKHVHFUHWDQGEDUUHGWKHKLGGHQGRRUDJDLQVWWKLPRQH
GD\DVKHIOHGEDFNIURPDQXQVXFFHVVIXOUDLGDQGWKH;RWDODQFDV
WRRNKLPDQGIOD\HGKLP%XWRQFHVS\LQJXSRQKHU,VDZKHUHQWHU
7HFXKOWOLE\WKLVURXWHDQGVROHDUQHGWKHVHFUHW
+HSUHVVHGXSRQDJROGRUQDPHQWLQWKHZDOODQGDSDQHOVZXQJ
LQZDUGGLVFORVLQJDQLYRU\VWDLUOHDGLQJXSZDUG
7KLVVWDLULVEXLOWZLWKLQWKHZDOOVDLG2OPHF,WOHDGVXSWR
DWRZHUXSRQWKHURRIDQGWKHQFHRWKHUVWDLUVZLQGGRZQWRWKH
YDULRXVFKDPEHUV+DVWHQ
$IWHU\RXFRPUDGHUHWRUWHG&RQDQVDWLULFDOO\VZD\LQJKLV
EURDGVZRUGDVKHVSRNHDQG2OPHFVKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGVWHSSHG
RQWRWKHVWDLUFDVH&RQDQLQVWDQWO\IROORZHGKLPDQGWKHGRRUVKXW
EHKLQGWKHP)DUDERYHDFOXVWHURIILUHMHZHOVPDGHWKHVWDLUFDVHD
ZHOORIGXVN\GUDJRQOLJKW
7KH\PRXQWHGXQWLO&RQDQHVWLPDWHGWKDWWKH\ZHUHDERYHWKHOHYHO
RIWKHIRXUWKIORRUDQGWKHQFDPHRXWLQWRDF\OLQGULFDOWRZHULQ
WKHGRPHGURRIRIZKLFKZDVVHWWKHEXQFKRIILUHMHZHOVWKDWOLJKWHG
WKHVWDLU7KURXJKJROGEDUUHGZLQGRZVVHWZLWKXQEUHDNDEOHFU\VWDO
SDQHVWKHILUVWZLQGRZVKHKDGVHHQLQ;XFKRWO&RQDQJRWDJOLPSVH
RIKLJKULGJHVGRPHVDQGPRUHWRZHUVORRPLQJGDUNO\DJDLQVWWKH
VWDUV+HZDVORRNLQJDFURVVWKHURRIVRI;XFKRWO
2OPHFGLGQRWORRNWKURXJKWKHZLQGRZV+HKXUULHGGRZQRQHRIWKH
VHYHUDOVWDLUVWKDWZRXQGGRZQIURPWKHWRZHUDQGZKHQWKH\KDG
GHVFHQGHGDIHZIHHWWKLVVWDLUFKDQJHGLQWRDQDUURZFRUULGRUWKDW
ZRXQGWRUWXRXVO\RQIRUVRPHGLVWDQFH,WFHDVHGDWDVWHHSIOLJKWRI
VWHSVOHDGLQJGRZQZDUG7KHUH2OPHFSDXVHG
8SIURPEHORZPXIIOHGEXWXQPLVWDNDEOHZHOOHGDZRPDQ
VVFUHDP
HGJHGZLWKIULJKWIXU\DQGVKDPH$QG&RQDQUHFRJQL]HG9DOHULD
V
YRLFH
,QWKHVZLIWUDJHURXVHGE\WKDWFU\DQGWKHDPD]HPHQWRI
ZRQGHULQJZKDWSHULOFRXOGZULQJVXFKDVKULHNIURP9DOHULD
V
UHFNOHVVOLSV&RQDQIRUJRW2OPHF+HSXVKHGSDVWWKHSULQFHDQG
VWDUWHGGRZQWKHVWDLU$ZDNHQLQJLQVWLQFWEURXJKWKLPDERXWDJDLQ
MXVWDV2OPHFVWUUXFNZLWKKLVJUHDWPDOOHWOLNHILVW7KHEORZ
ILUHFHDQGVLOHQWZDVDLPHGDWWKHEDVHRI&RQDQ
VEUDLQ%XWWKH
&LPPHULDQZKHHOHGLQWLPHWRUHFHLYHWKHEXIIHWRQWKHVLGHRIKLV
QHFNLQVWHDG7KHLPSDFWZRXOGKDYHVQDSSHGWKHYHUWHEUDHRIDOHVVHU
PDQ$VLWZDV&RQDQVZD\HGEDFNZDUGEXWHYHQDVKHUHHOHGKH
GURSSHGKLVVZRUGXVHOHVVDWVXFKFORVHTXDUWHUVDQGJUDVSHG
2OPHF
VH[WHQGHGDUPGUDJJLQJWKHSULQFHZLWKKLPDVKHIHOO
+HDGORQJWKH\ZHQWGRZQWKHVWHSVWRJHWKHULQDUHYROYLQJZKLUORI
OLPEVDQGKHDGVDQGERGLHV$QGDVWKH\ZHQW&RQDQ
VLURQILQJHUV
IRXQGDQGORFNHGLQ2OPHF
VEXOOWKURDW
7KHEDUEDULDQ
VQHFNDQGVKRXOGHUIHOWQXPEIURPWKHVOHGJHOLNH
LPSDFWRI2OPHF
VKXJHILVWZKLFKKDGFDUULHGDOOWKHVWUHQJWKRI
WKHPDVVLYHIRUHDUPWKLFNWULFHSVDQGJUHDWVKRXOGHU%XWWKLVGLG
QRWDIIHFWKLVIHURFLW\WRDQ\DSSUHFLDEOHH[WHQW/LNHDEXOOGRJKH
KXQJRQJULPO\UROOHGXQWLODWODVWWKH\VWUXFNDQLYRU\SDQHOGRRU
DWWKHERWWRPZLWKVXFKDQGLPSDFWWKDWWKH\VSOLQWHUHGLWLWVIXOO
OHQJWKDQGFUDVKHGWKURXJKLWVUXLQV%XW2OPHFZDVDOUHDG\GHDGIRU
WKRVHLURQILQJHUVKDGFUXVKHGRXWKLVOLIHDQGEURNHQKLVQHFNDV
WKH\IHOO
&RQDQURVHVKDNLQJWKHVSOLQWHUVIURPKLVJUHDWVKRXOGHUV
EOLQNLQJEORRGDQGGXVWRXWRIKLVH\HV
+HZDVLQWKHJUHDWWKURQHURRP7KHUHZHUHILIWHHQSHRSOHLQWKDW
URRPEHVLGHVKLPVHOI7KHILUVWSHUVRQKHVDZZDV9DOHULD$FXULRXV
EODFNDOWDUVWRRGEHIRUHWKHWKURQHGDLV5DQJHGDERXWLWVHYHQ
EODFNFDQGOHVLQJROGHQFDQGOHVWLFNVVHQWXSRR]LQJVSLUDOVRIWKLFN
JUHHQVPRNHGLVWXUELQJO\VFHQWHG7KHVHVSLUDOVXQLWHGLQDFORXG
QHDUWKHFHLOLQJIRUPLQJDVPRN\DUFKDERYHWKHDOWDU2QWKDWDOWDU
OD\9DOHULDVWDUNQDNHGKHUZKLWHIOHVKJOHDPLQJLQVKRFNLQJ
FRQWUDVWWRWKHJOLVWHQLQJHERQVWRQH6KHZDVQRWERXQG6KHOD\DW
IXOOOHQJWKKHUDUPVVWUHWFKHGRXWDERYHKHUKHDGWRWKHLUIXOOHVW
H[WHQW$WWKHKHDGRIWKHDOWDUNQHOWD\RXQJPDQKROGLQJKHU
ZULVWVILUPO\$\RXQJZRPDQNQHOWDWWKHRWKHUHQGRIWKHDOWDU
JUDVSLQJKHUDQNOHV%HWZHHQWKHPVKHFRXOGQHLWKHUULVHQRUPRYH
(OHYHQPHQDQGZRPHQRI7HFXKOWOLNQHOWGXPEO\LQDVHPLFLUFOH
ZDWFKLQJWKHVFHQHZLWKKRWOXVWIXOH\HV
2QWKHLYRU\WKURQHVHDW7DVFHODOROOHG%URQ]HERZOVRILQFHQVH
UROOHGWKHLUVSLUDOVDERXWKHUWKHZLVSVRIVPRNHFXUOHGDERXWKHU
QDNHGOLPEVOLNHFDUHVVLQJILQJHUV6KHFRXOGQRWVLWVWLOOVKH
VTXLUPHGDQGVKLIWHGDERXWZLWKVHQVXRXVDEDQGRQDVLIILQGLQJ
SOHDVXUHLQWKHFRQWDFWRIWKHVPRRWKLYRU\ZLWKKHUVOHHNIOHVK
7KHFUDVKRIWKHGRRUDVLWEURNHEHQHDWKWKHLPSDFWRIWKH
KXUWOLQJERGLHVFDXVHGQRFKDQJHLQWKHVFHQH7KHNQHHOLQJPHQDQG
ZRPHQPHUHO\JODQFHGLQFXULRXVO\DWWKHFRUSVHRIWKHLUSULQFHDQGDW
WKHPDQZKRURVHIURPWKHUXLQVRIWKHGRRUWKHQVZXQJWKHLUH\HV
JUHHGLO\EDFNWRWKHZULWKLQJZKLWHVKDSHRQWKHEODFNDOWDU7DVFHOD
ORRNHGLQVROHQWO\DWKLPDQGVSUDZOHGEDFNRQKHUVHDWODXJKLQJ
PRFNLQJO\
6OXW&RQDQVDZUHG+LVKDQGVFOHQFKHGLQWRLURQKDPPHUVDVKH
VWDUWHGIRUKHU:LWKKLVILUVWVWHSVRPHWKLQJFODQJHGORXGO\DQG
VWHHOELWVDYDJHO\LQWRKLVOHJ+HVWXPEOHGDQGDOPRVWIHOOFKHFNHG
LQKLVKHDGORQJVWULGH7KHMDZVRIDQLURQWUDSKDGFORVHGRQKLV
OHJZLWKWHHWKWKDWVDQNGHHSDQGKHOG2QO\WKHULGJHGPXVFOHVRI
KLVFDOIVDYHGWKHERQHIURPEHLQJVSOLQWHUHG7KHDFFXUVHGWKLQJKDG
VSUXQJRXWRIWKHVPROGHULQJIORRUZLWKRXWZDUQLQJ+HVDZWKHVORWV
QRZLQWKHIORRUZKHUHWKHMDZVKDGODLQSHUIHFWO\FDPRXIODJHG
)RROODXJKHG7DVFHOD'LG\RXWKLQN,ZRXOGQRWJXDUGDJDLQVW
\RXUSRVVLEOHUHWXUQ"(YHU\GRRULQWKLVFKDPEHULVJXDUGHGE\VXFK
WUDSV6WDQGWKHUHDQGZDWFKQRZZKLOH,IXOILOOWKHGHVWLQ\RI\RXU
KDQGVRPHIULHQG7KHQ,ZLOOGHFLGH\RXURZQ
&RQDQ
VKDQGLQVWLQFWLYHO\VRXJKWKLVEHOWRQO\WRHQFRXQWHUDQ
HPSW\VFDEEDUG+LVVZRUGZDVRQWKHVWDLUEHKLQGKLP+LVSRQLDUG
ZDVO\LQJEDFNLQWKHIRUHVWZKHUHWKHGUDJRQKDGWRUQLWIURPKLV
MDZ7KHVWHHOWHHWKLQKLVOHJZHUHOLNHEXUQLQJFRDOVEXWWKHSDLQ
ZDVQRWDVVDYDJHDVWKHIXU\WKDWVHHWKHGLQKLVVRXO+HZDV
WUDSSHGOLNHDZROI,IKHKDGKDGKLVVZRUGKHZRXOGKDYHKHZQRII
KLVOHJDQGFUDZOHGDFURVVWKHIORRUWRVOD\7DVFHOD9DOHULD
VH\HV
UROOHGWRZDUGKLPZLWKPXWHDSSHDODQGKLVRZQKHOSOHVVQHVVVHQWUHG
ZDYHVRIPDGQHVVVXUJLQJWKURXJKKLVEUDLQ
'URSSLQJRQWKHNQHHRIKLVIUHHOHJKHVWURYHWRJHWKLVILQJHUV
EHWZHHQWKHMDZVRIWKHWUDSWRWHDUWKHPDSDUWE\VKHHUVWUHQJWK
%ORRGVWDUWHGIURPEHQHDWKKLVILQJHUQDLOVEXWWKHMDZVILWWHGFORVH
DERXWKLVOHJLQDFLUFOHZKRVHVHJPHQWVMRLQWHGSHUIHFWO\
FRQWUDFWHGXQWLOWKHUHZDVQRVSDFHEHWZHHQKLVPDQJOHGIOHVKDQGWKH
IDQJHGLURQ7KHVLWHRI9DOHULD
VQDNHGERG\DGGHGIODPHWRWKHILUH
RIKLVUDJH
7DVFHODLJQRUHGKLP5LVLQJODQJXLGO\IURPKHUVHDWVKHVZHSWWKH
UDQNVRIKHUVXEMHFWVZLWKDVHDUFKLQJJODQFHDQGDVNHG:KHUHDUH
;DPHF=ODQDWKDQG7DFKLF"
7KH\GLGQRWUHWXUQIURPWKHFDWDFRPEVSULQFHVVDQVZHUHGD
PDQ/LNHWKHUHVWRIXVWKH\ERUHERGLHVRIWKHVODLQLQWRWKH
FU\SWVEXWWKH\KDYHQRWUHWXUQHG3HUKDSVWKHJKRVWRI7RONHPHF
WRRNWKHP
%HVLOHQWIRROVKHRUGHUHGKDUVKO\7KHJKRVWLVDP\WK
6KHFDPHGRZQIURPKHUGDLVSOD\LQJZLWKDWKLQJROGKLOWHG
GDJJHU+HUH\HVEXUQHGOLNHQRWKLQJRQWKHKLWKHUVLGHRIKHOO6KH
SDXVHGEHVLGHWKHDOWDUDQGVSRNHLQWKHWHQVHVWLOOQHVV
<RXUOLIHVKDOOPDNHPH\RXQJZKLWHZRPDQVKHVDLG,VKDOO
OHDQXSRQ\RXUERVRPDQGSODFHP\OLSVRYHU\RXUVDQGVORZO\DK
VORZO\VLQNWKLVEODGHWKURXJK\RXUKHDUWVRWKDW\RXUOLIH
IOHHLQJ\RXUVWLIIHQLQJERG\VKDOOHQWHUPLQHPDNLQJPHEORRPDJDLQ
ZLWK\RXWKDQGZLWKOLIHHYHUODVWLQJ
6ORZO\OLNHDVHUSHQWDUFKLQJWRZDUGLWVYLFWLPVKHEHQWGRZQ
WKURXJKWKHZULWKLQJVPRNHFORVHUDQGFORVHURYHUWKHQRZPRWLRQOHVV
ZRPDQZKRVWDUHGXSLQWRKHUJORZLQJGDUNH\HVH\HVWKDWJUHZ
ODUJHUDQGGHHSHUEOD]LQJOLNHEODFNPRRQVLQWKHVZLUOLQJVPRNH
7KHNQHHOLQJSHRSOHJULSSHGWKHLUKDQGVDQGKHOGWKHLUEUHDWK
WHQVHIRUWKHEORRG\FOLPD[DQGWKHRQO\VRXQGZDV&RQDQ
VILHUFH
SDQWLQJDVKHVWURYHWRWHDUKLVOHJIURPWKHWUDS
$OOH\HVZHUHJOXHGRQWKHDOWDUDQGWKHZKLWHILJXUHWKHUHWKH
FUDVKRIDWKXQGHUEROWFRXOGKDUGO\KDYHEURNHQWKHVSHOO\HWLWZDV
RQO\DORZFU\WKDWVKDWWHUHGWKHIL[LW\RIWKHVFHQHDQGERXJKWDOO
ZKLUOLQJDERXWDORZFU\\HWRQHWRPDNHWKHKDLUVWDQGXS
VWLIIO\RQWKHVFDOS7KH\ORRNHGDQGWKH\VDZ
)UDPHGLQWKHGRRUWRWKHOHIWRIWKHGDLVVWRRGDQLJKWPDUH
ILJXUH,WZDVDPDQZLWKDWDQJOHRIZKLWHKDLUDQGDPDWWHGZKLWH
EHDUGWKDWIHOORYHUKLVEUHDVW5DJVRQO\SDUWO\FRYHUHGKLVJDXQW
IUDPHUHYHDOLQJKDOIQDNHGOLPEVVWUDQJHO\XQQDWXUDOLQDSSHDUDQFH
7KHVNLQZDVQRWOLNHWKDWRIDQRUPDOKXPDQ7KHUHZDVDVXJJHVWLRQ
RIBVFDOLQHVVBDERXWLWDVLIWKHRZQHUKDGGZHOWORQJXQGHU
FRQGLWLRQVDOPRVWDQWLWKHWLFDOWRWKRVHFRQGLWLRQVXQGHUZKLFKKXPDQ
OLIHRUGLQDULO\WKULYHV$QGWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJDWDOOKXPDQDERXWWKH
H\HVWKDWEOD]HGIURPWKHWDQJOHRIZKLWHKDLU7KH\ZHUHJUHDW
JOHDPLQJGLVNVWKDWVWDUWHGXQZLQNLQJO\OXPLQRXVZKLWLVKDQG
ZLWKRXWDKLQWRIQRUPDOHPRWLRQRUVDQLW\7KHPRXWKJDSHGEXWQR
FRKHUHQWZRUGVLVVXHGRQO\DKLJKSLWFKHGWLWWHULQJ
7RONHPHFZKLVSHUHG7DVFHODOLYLGZKLOHWKHRWKHUVFURXFKHGLQ
VSHHFKOHVVKRUURU1RP\WKWKHQQRJKRVW6HW<RXKDYHGZHOWIRU
WZHOYH\HDUVLQGDUNQHVV7ZHOYH\HDUVDPRQJWKHERQHVRIWKHGHDG
:KDWJULVO\IRRGGLG\RXILQG":KDWPDGWUDYHVW\RIOLIHGLG\RX
OLYHLQWKHVWDUNEODFNQHVVRIWKDWHWHUQDOQLJKW",VHHQRZZK\
;DPHFDQG=ODQDWKDQG7DFKLFGLGQRWUHWXUQIURPWKHFDWDFRPEVDQG
QHYHUZLOOUHWXUQ%XWZK\KDYH\RXZDLWHGVRORQJWRVWULNH":HUH
\RXVHHNLQJVRPHWKLQJLQWKHSLWV"6RPHVHFUHWZHDSRQ\RXNQHZZDV
KLGGHQWKHUH"$QGKDYH\RXIRXQGLWDWODVW"
7KDWKLGHRXVWLWWHULQJZDV7RONHPHF
VRQO\UHSO\DVKHERXQGHG
LQWRWKHURRPZLWKDORQJOHDSWKDWFDUULHGKLPRYHUWKHVHFUHWWUDS
EHIRUHWKHGRRUE\FKDQFHRUE\VRPHIDLQWUHFROOHFWLRQRIWKH
ZD\VRI;XFKRWO+HZDVQRWPDGDVDPDQLVDPG+HKDGGZHOWDSDUW
IURPKXPDQLW\VRORQJWKDWKHZDVQRORQJHUKXPDQ2QO\DQXQEURNHQ
WKUHDGRIPHPRU\HPERGLHGLQKDWHDQGWKHXUJHIRUYHQJHDQFHKDG
FRQQHFWHGKLPZLWKWKHKXPDQLW\IURPZKLFKKHKDGEHHQFXWRIIDQG
KHOGKLPOXUNLQJQHDUWKHSHRSOHKHKDWHG2QO\WKDWWKLQVWULQJKDG
NHSWKLPIURPUDFLQJDQGSUDQFLQJRIIIRUHYHULQWRWKHEODFN
FRUULGRUVDQGUHDOPVRIWKHVXEWHUUDQHDQZRUOGKHKDGGLVFRYHUHG
ORQJDJR
<RXVRXJKWVRPHWKLQJKLGGHQZKLVSHUHG7DVFHODFULQJLQJEDFN
$QG\RXKDYHIRXQGLW<RXUHPHPEHUWKHIHXG$IWHUDOOWKHVH\HDUV
RIEODFNQHVV\RXUHPHPEHU
)RULQWKHOHDQKDQGRI7RONHPHFQRZZDYHGDFXULRXVMDGHKXHG
ZDQGRQWKHHQGRIZKLFKJORZHGDNQRERIFULPVRQVKDSHGOLNHD
SRPHJUDQDWH6KHVSUDQJDVLGHDVKHWKUXVWLWRXWOLNHDVSHDUDQGD
EHDPRIFULPVRQILUHODQFHGIURPWKHSRPHJUDQDWH,WPLVVHG7DVFHOD
EXWWKHZRPDQKROGLQJ9DOHULD
VDQNOHVZDVLQWKHZD\,WVPRWH
EHWZHHQKHUVKRXOGHUV7KHUHZDVDVKDUSFUDFNOLQJVRXQGDQGWKHUD\
RIILUHIODVKHGIURPKHUERVRPDQGVWUXFNWKHEODFNDOWDUZLWKD
VQDSSLQJRIEOXHVSDUNV7KHZRPDQWRSSOHGVLGHZLVHVKULYHOLQJDQG
ZLWKHULQJOLNHDPXPP\HYHQDVVKHIHOO
9DOHULDUROOHGIURPWKHDOWDURQWKHRWKHUVLGHDQGVWDUWHGIRU
WKHRSSRVLWHZDOORQDOOIRXUV)RUKHOOKDGEXUVWORRVHLQWKH
WKURQHURRPRIGHDG2OPHF
7KHPDQZKRKDGKHOG9DOHULD
VKDQGVZDVWKHQH[WWRGLH+H
WXUQHGWRUXQEXWEHIRUHKHKDGWDNHQKDOIDGR]HQVWHSV7RONHPHF
ZLWKDQDJLOLW\DSSDOOLQJLQVXFKDIUDPHERXQGHGDURXQGWRD
SRVLWLRQWKDWSODFHGWKHPDQEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKHDOWDU$JDLQWKHUHG
ILUHEHDPIODVKHGDQGWKH7HFXKOWOLUROOHGOLIHOHVVWRWKHIORRUDV
WKHEHDPFRPSOHWHGLWVFRXUVHZLWKDEXUVWRIEOXHVSDUNVDJDLQVWWKH
DOWDU
7KHQEHJDQWKHVODXJKWHU6FUHDPLQJLQVDQHO\WKHSHRSOHUXVKHG
DERXWWKHFKDPEHUFDURPLQJIURPRQHDQRWKHUVWXPEOLQJDQGIDOOLQJ
$QGDPRQJWKHP7RONHPHFFDSHUHGDQGSUDQFHGGHDOLQJGHDWK7KH\
FRXOGQRWHVFDSHE\WKHGRRUVIRUDSSDUHQWO\WKHPHWDORIWKH
SRUWDOVVHUYHGOLNHWKHPHWDOYHLQHGVWRQHDOWDUWRFRPSOHWHWKH
FLUFXLWIRUZKDWHYHUKHOOLVKSRZHUIODVKHGOLNHWKXQGHUEROWVIURPWKH
ZLWFKZDQGWKHDQFLHQWZDYHGLQKLVKDQG:KHQKHFDXJKWDPDQRUD
ZRPDQEHWZHHQKLPDQGDGRRURUWKHDOWDUWKDWRQHGLHGLQVWDQWO\
+HFKRVHQRVSHFLDOYLFWLP+HWRRNWKHPDVWKH\FDPHZLWKKLVUDJV
IODSSLQJDERXWKLVZLOGO\J\UDWLQJOLPEVDQGWKHJXVW\HFKRHVRIKLV
WLWWHULQJVZHHSLQJWKHURRPDERYHWKHVFUHDPV$QGERGLHVIHOOOLNH
IDOOLQJOHDYHVDERXWWKHDOWDUDQGDWWKHGRRUV2QHZDUULRULQ
GHVSHUDWLRQUXVKHGDWKLPOLIWLQJDGDJJHURQO\WRIDOOEHIRUHKH
FRXOGVWULNH%XWWKHUHVWZHUHOLNHFUD]HGFDWWOHZLWKQRWKRXJKW
IRUUHVLVWDQFHDQGQRFKDQFHRIHVFDSH
7KHODVW7HFXKOWOLH[FHSW7DVFHODKDGIDOOHQZKHQWKHSULQFHVV
UHDFKHGWKH&LPPHULDQDQGWKHJLUOZKRKDGWDNHQUHIXJHEHVLGHKLP
7DVFHODEHQWDQGWRXFKHGWKHIORRUSUHVVLQJDGHVLJQXSRQLW
,QVWDQWO\WKHLURQMDZVUHOHDVHGWKHEOHHGLQJOLPEDQGVDQNEDFNLQWR
WKHIORRU
6OD\KLPLI\RXFDQVKHSDQWHGDQGSUHVVHGDKHDY\NQLIHLQWR
KLVKDQG,KDYHQRPDJLFWRZLWKVWDQGKLP
:LWKDJUXQWKHVSUDQJEHIRUHWKHZRPDQQRWKHHGLQJKLVODFHUDWHG
OHJLQWKHKHDWRIWKHILJKWLQJOXVW7RONHPHFZDVFRPLQJWRZDUGKLP
KLVZHLUGH\HVDEOD]HEXWKHKHVLWDWHGDWWKHJOHDPRIWKHNQLIHLQ
&RQDQ
VKDQG7KHQEHJDQDJULPJDPHDV7RONHPHFVRXJKWWRFLUFOH
DERXW&RQDQDQGJHWWKHEDUEDULDQEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKHDOWDURUD
PHWDOGRRUZKLOH&RQDQVRXJKWWRDYRLGWKLVDQGGULYHKRPHKLV
NQLIH7KHZRPHQZDWFKHGWHQVHO\KROGLQJWKHLUEUHDWK
7KHUHZDVQRVRXQGH[FHSWWKHUXVWOHDQGVFUDSHRITXLFNVKLIWLQJ
IHHW7RONHPHFSUDQFHGDQGFDSHUHGQRPRUH+HUHDOL]HGWKDWJULPPHU
JDPHFRQIURQWHGKLPWKDQWKHSHRSOHZKRKDGGLHGVFUHDPLQJDQG
IOHHLQJ,QWKHHOHPHQWDOEOD]HRIWKHEDUEDULDQ
VH\HVKHUHDGDQ
LQWHQWGHDGO\DVKLVRZQ%DFNDQGIRUWKWKH\ZHDYHGDQGZKHQRQH
PRYHGWKHRWKHUPRYHGDVLILQYLVLEOHWKUHDGVERXQGWKHPWRJHWKHU
%XWDOOWKHWLPH&RQDQZDVJHWWLQJFORVHUDQGFORVHUWRKLVHQHP\
$OUHDG\WKHFRLOHGPXVFOHVRIKLVWKLJKVZHUHEHJLQQLQJWRIOH[IRUD
VSULQJZKHQ9DOHULDFULHGRXW)RUDIOHHWLQJLQVWDQWDEURQ]HGRRU
ZDVLQOLQHZLWK&RQDQ
VPRYLQJERG\7KHUHGOLQHOHDSHGVHDULQJ
&RQDQ
VIODQNDVKHWZLVWHGDVLGHDQGHYHQDVKHVKLIWHGKHKXUOHG
WKHNQLIH2OG7RONHPHFZHQWGRZQWUXO\VODLQDWODVWWKHKLOW
YLEUDWLQJRQKLVEUHDVW
7DVFHODVSUDQJQRWWRZDUG&RQDQEXWWRZDUGWKHZDQGZKHUHLW
VKLPPHUHGOLNHDOLYHWKLQJRQWKHIORRU%XWDVVKHOHDSHGVRGLG
9DOHULDZLWKDGDJJHUVQDWFKHGIURPDGHDGPDQDQGWKHEODGH
GULYHQZLWKDOOWKHSRZHURIWKHSLUDWH
VPXVFOHVLPSDOHGWKH
SULQFHVVRI7HFXKOWOLVRWKDWWKHSRLQWVWRRGRXWEHWZHHQKHU
EUHDVWV7DVFHODVFUHDPHGRQFHDQGIHOOGHDGDQG9DOHULDVSXUQHGWKH
ERG\ZLWKKHUKHHODVLWIHOO
,KDGWRGRWKDWPXFKIRUP\RZQVHOIUHVSHFWSDQWHG9DOHULD
IDFLQJ&RQDQDFURVVWKHOLPSFRUSVH
:HOOWKLVFOHDQVXSWKHIHXGKHJUXQWHG,W
VEHHQDKHOORI
DQLJKW:KHUHGLGWKHVHSHRSOHNHHSWKHLUIRRG",
PKXQJU\
<RXQHHGDEDQGDJHRQWKDWOHJ9DOHULDULSSHGDOHQJWKRIVLON
IURPDKDQJLQJDQGNQRWWHGLWDERXWKHUZDLVWWKHQWRUHRIIVRPH
VPDOOHUVWULSVZKLFKVKHERXQGHIILFLHQWO\DERXWWKHEDUEDULDQ
V
ODFHUDWHGOLPE
,FDQZDONRQLWKHDVVXUHGKHU/HW
VEHJRQH,W
VGDZQ
RXWVLGHWKLVLQIHUQDOFLW\,
YHKDGHQRXJKRI;XFKRWO,W
VZHOOWKH
EUHHGH[WHUPLQDWHGLWVHOI,GRQ
WZDQWDQ\RIWKHLUDFFXUVHGMHZHOV
7KH\PLJKWEHKDXQWHG
7KHUHLVHQRXJKFOHDQORRWLQWKHZRUOGIRU\RXDQGPHVKH
VDLGVWUDLJKWHQLQJWRVWDQGWDOODQGVSOHQGLGEHIRUHKLP
7KHROGEOD]HFDPHEDFNLQKLVH\HVDQGWKLVWLPHVKHGLGQRW
UHVLVWDVKHFDXJKWKHUILHUFHO\LQKLVDUPV
,W
VDORQJZD\WRWKHFRDVWVKHVDLGSUHVHQWO\ZLWKGUDZLQJ
KHUOLSVIURPKLV
:KDWPDWWHU"KHODXJKHG7KHUH
VQRWKLQJZHFDQ
WFRQTXHU
:H
OOKDYHRXUIHHWRQDVKLS
VGHFNEHIRUHWKH6W\JLDQVRSHQWKHLU
SRUWVIRUWKHWUDGLQJVHDVRQ$QGWKHQZH
OOVKRZWKHZRUOGZKDW
SOXQGHULQJPHDQV




-(:(/62)*:$+/85


&RQDQ
VDPRXUZLWK9DOHULDGRHVQRWODVWORQJSHUKDSVWKHIDFW
WKDWHDFKRIWKHPLQVLVWVRQEHLQJWKHERVVKDVVRPHWKLQJWRGRZLWK
WKHIDFW$WDQ\UDWHWKH\SDUW9DOHULDWRUHWXUQWRWKHVHD&RQDQ
WRWU\KLVOXFNLQWKHEODFNNLQJGRPV+HDULQJRIWKHSULFHOHVV
7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDIRUWXQHLQDQFLHQWMHZHOVKLGGHQVRPHZKHUHLQ
.HVKDQKHVHOOVKLVVHUYLFHVWRWKHLUDVFLEOHNLQJRI.HVKDQWR
WUDLQKLVDUPLHVIRUZDUDJDLQVWWKHQHLJKERULQJNLQJGRPRI3XQW


3DWKVRI,QWULJXH

7KHFOLIIVURVHVKHHUIURPWKHMXQJOHWRZHULQJUDPSDUWVRIVWRQH
WKDWJOLQWHGMDGHEOXHDQGGXOOFULPVRQLQWKHULVLQJVXQDQGFXUYHG
DZD\DQGDZD\WRHDVWDQGZHVWDERYHWKHZDYLQJHPHUDOGRFHDQRI
IURQGVDQGOHDYHV,WORRNHGLQVXUPRXQWDEOHWKDWJLDQWSDOLVDGHZLWK
LWVVKHHUFXUWDLQVRIVROLGURFNLQZKLFKELWVRITXDUW]ZLQNHG
GD]]OLQJO\LQWKHVXQOLJKW%XWWKHPDQZKRZDVZRUNLQJKLVWHGLRXV
ZD\XSZDUGZDVDOUHDG\KDOIZD\WRWKHWRS
+HFDPHIURPDUDFHRIKLOOPHQDFFXVWRPHGWRVFDOLQJIRUELGGLQJ
FUDJVDQGKHZDVDPDQRIXQXVXDOVWUHQJWKDQGDJLOLW\+LVRQO\
JDUPHQWZDVDSDLURIVKRUWUHGVLONEUHHNVDQGKLVVDQGDOVZHUH
VOXQJWRKLVEDFNRXWRIKLVZD\DVZHUHKLVVZRUGDQGGDJJHU
7KHPDQZDVSRZHUIXOO\EXLOWVXSSOHDVDSDQWKHU+LVVNLQZDV
EURQ]HGE\WKHVXQKLVVTXDUHFXWEODFNPDQHFRQILQHGE\DVLOYHU
EDQGDERXWKLVWHPSOHV+LVLURQPXVFOHVTXLFNH\HVDQGVXUHIHHW
VHUYHGKLPZHOOKHUHIRULWZDVDFOLPEWRWHVWWKHVHTXDOLWLHVWR
WKHXWPRVW$KXQGUHGDQGILIW\IHHWEHORZKLPZDYHGWKHMXQJOH$Q
HTXDOGLVWDQFHDERYHKLPWKHULPRIWKHFOLIIVZDVHWFKHGDJDLQVWWKH
PRUQLQJVN\
+HODERUHGOLNHRQHGULYHQE\WKHQHFHVVLW\RIKDVWH\HWKHZDV
IRUFHGWRPRYHDWDVQDLO
VSDFHFOLQJLQJOLNHDIO\RQDZDOO+LV
JURSLQJKDQGVDQGIHHWIRXQGQLFKHVDQGNQREVSUHFDULRXVKROGVDW
EHVWDQGVRPHWLPHVKHYLUWXDOO\KXQJE\KLVILQJHUQDLOV<HWXSZDUG
KHZHQWFODZLQJVTXLUPLQJILJKWLQJIRUHYHU\IRRW$WWLPHVKH
SDXVHGWRUHVWKLVDFKLQJPXVFOHVDQGVKDNLQJWKHVZHDWRXWRIKLV
H\HVWZLVWHGKLVKHDGWRVWDUHVHDUFKLQJO\RXWRYHUWKHMXQJOH
FRPELQJWKHJUHHQH[SDQVHIRUDQ\WUDFHRIKXPDQOLIHRUPRWLRQ
1RZWKHVXPPLWZDVQRWIDUDERYHKLPDQGKHREVHUYHGRQO\DIHZ
IHHWDERYHKLVKHDGDEUHDNLQWKHVKHHUVWRQHRIWKHFOLII$Q
LQVWDQWODWHUKHKDGUHDFKHGLWDVPDOOFDYHUQMXVWEHORZWKH
HGJHRIWKHULP$VKLVKHDGURVHDERYHWKHOLSRILWVIORRUKH
JUXQWHG+HFOXQJWKHUHKLVHOERZVKRRNHGRYHUWKHOLS7KHFDYHZDV
VRWLQ\WKDWLWZDVOLWWOHPRUHWKDQDQLFKHFXWLQWKHVWRQHEXWLW
KHOGDQRFFXSDQW$VKULYOHGEURZQPXPP\FURVVOHJJHGDUPVIROGHG
RQWKHZLWKHUHGEUHDVWXSRQZKLFKWKHVKUXQNHQKHDGZDVVXQNVDWLQ
WKHOLWWOHFDYHUQ7KHOLPEVZHUHERXQGLQSODFHZLWKUDZKLGHWKRQJV
ZKLFKKDGEHFRPHPHUHURWWHGZLVSV,IWKHIRUPKDGHYHUEHHQ
FORWKHGWKHUDYDJHVRIWLPHKDGORQJDJRUHGXFHGWKHJDUPHQWVWR
GXVW%XWWKUXVWEHWZHHQWKHFURVVHGDUPVDQGWKHVKUXQNHQEUHDVW
WKHUHZDVDUROORISDUFKPHQW\HOORZHGZLWKDJHWRWKHFRORURIROG
LYRU\
7KHFOLPEHUVWUHWFKHGIRUWKDORQJDUPDQGZUHQFKHGDZD\WKLV
F\OLQGHU:LWKRXWLQYHVWLJDWLRQKHWKUXVWLWLQWRKLVJLUGOHDQG
KDXOHGKLPVHOIXSXQWLOKHZDVVWDQGLQJLQWKHRSHQLQJRIWKHQLFKH
$VSULQJXSZDUGDQGKHFDXJKWWKHULPRIWKHFOLIIVDQGSXOOHG
KLPVHOIXSDQGRYHUDOPRVWZLWKWKHVDPHPRWLRQ
7KHUHKHKDOWHGSDQWLQJDQGVWDUHGGRZQZDUG
,WZDVOLNHORRNLQJLQWRWKHLQWHULRURIDYDVWERZOULPPHGE\D
FLUFXODUVWRQHZDOO7KHIORRURIWKHERZOZDVFRYHUHGZLWKWUHHVDQG
GHQVHUYHJHWDWLRQWKRXJKQRZKHUHGLGWKHJURZWKGXSOLFDWHWKHMXQJOH
GHQVHQHVVRIWKHRXWHUIRUHVW7KHFOLIIVPDUFKHGDURXQGLWZLWKRXWD
EUHDNDQGRIXQLIRUPKHLJKW,WZDVDIUHDNRIQDWXUHQRWWREH
SDUDOOHOHGSHUKDSVLQWKHZKROHZRUOGDYDVWQDWXUDODPSKLWKHDWHU
DFLUFXODUELWRIIRUHVWHGSODLQWKUHHRUIRXUPLOHVLQGLDPHWHU
FXWRIIIURPWKHUHVWRIWKHZRUOGDQGFRQILQHGZLWKLQWKHULQJRI
WKRVHSDOLVDGHGFOLIIV
%XWWKHPDQRQWKHFOLIIVGLGQRWGHYRWHKLVWKRXJKWVWRPDUYHOLQJ
DWWKHWRSRJUDSKLFDOSKHQRPHQRQ:LWKWHQVHHDJHUQHVVKHVHDUFKHGWKH
WUHHWRSVEHORZKLPDQGH[KDOHGDJXVW\VLJKZKHQKHFDXJKWWKH
JOLQWRIPDUEOHGRPHVDPLGVWWKHWZLQNOLQJJUHHQ,WZDVQRP\WK
WKHQEHORZKLPOD\WKHIDEXORXVDQGGHVHUWHGSDODFHRI$ONPHHQRQ
&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQODWHRIWKH%DUDFKD,VOHVRIWKH%ODFN
&RDVWDQGRIPDQ\RWKHUFOLPHVZKHUHOLIHUDQZLOGKDGFRPHWRWKH
NLQJGRPRI.HVKDQIROORZLQJWKHOXUHRIDIDEOHGWUHDVXUHWKDW
RXWVKRQHWKHKRDUGRIWKH7XUDQLDQNLQJV
.HVKDQZDVDEDUEDULFNLQJGRPO\LQJLQWKHHDVWHUQKLQWHUODQGVRI
.XVKZKHUHWKHEURDGJUDVVODQGVPHUJHZLWKWKHIRUHVWVWKDWUROOXS
IURPWKHVRXWK7KHSHRSOHZHUHDPL[HGUDFHDGXVN\QRELOLW\UXOLQJ
DSRSXODWLRQWKDWZDVODUJHO\SXUH1HJUR7KHUXOHUVSULQFHVDQG
KLJKSULHVWVFODLPHGGHVFHQWIURPDZKLWHUDFHZKLFKLQD
P\WKLFDODJHKDGUXOHGDNLQJGRPZKRVHFDSLWDOFLW\ZDV$ONPHHQRQ
&RQIOLFWLQJOHJHQGVVRXJKWWRH[SODLQWKHUHDVRQIRUWKDWUDFH
V
HYHQWXDOGRZQIDOODQGWKHDEDQGRQPHQWRIWKHFLW\E\WKHVXUYLYRUV
(TXDOO\QHEXORXVZHUHWKHWDOHVRIWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUWKHWUHDVXUH
RI$ONPHHQRQ%XWWKHVHPLVW\OHJHQGVKDGEHHQHQRXJKWREULQJ&RQDQ
WR.HVKDQRYHUYDVWGLVWDQFHVRISODLQULYHUODFHGMXQJOHDQG
PRXQWDLQV
+HKDGIRXQG.HVKDQZKLFKLQLWVHOIZDVFRQVLGHUHGP\WKLFDOE\
PDQ\QRUWKHUQDQGZHVWHUQQDWLRQVDQGKHKDGKHDUGHQRXJKWRFRQILUP
WKHUXPRUVRIWKHWUHDVXUHWKDWPHQFDOOHGWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU%XW
LWVKLGLQJSODFHKHFRXOGQRWOHDUQDQGKHZDVFRQIURQWHGZLWKWKH
QHFHVVLW\RIH[SODLQLQJKLVSUHVHQFHLQ.HVKDQ8QDWWDFKHGVWUDQJHUV
ZHUHQRWZHOFRPHWKHUH
%XWKHZDVQRWQRQSOXVVHG:LWKFRRODVVXUDQFHKHPDGHKLVRIIHU
WRWKHVWDWHO\SOXPHGVXVSLFLRXVJUDQGHHVRIWKHEDUEDULFDOO\
PDJQLILFHQWFRXUW+HZDVDSURIHVVLRQDOILJKWLQJPDQ,QVHDUFKRI
HPSOR\PHQWKHVDLGKHKDGFRPHWR.HVKDQ)RUDSULFHKHZRXOG
WUDLQWKHDUPLHVRI.HVKDQDQGOHDGWKHPDJDLQVW3XQWWKHLU
KHUHGLWDU\HQHP\ZKRVHUHFHQWVXFFHVVHVLQWKHILHOGKDGDURXVHGWKH
IXU\RI.HVKDQ
VLUDVFLEOHNLQJ
7KHSURSRVLWLRQZDVQRWVRDXGDFLRXVDVLWPLJKWVHHP&RQDQ
V
IDPHKDGSUHFHGHGKLPHYHQLQWRGLVWDQW.HVKDQKLVH[SORLWVDVD
FKLHIRIWKHEODFNFRUVDLUVWKRVHZROYHVRIWKHVRXWKHUQFRDVWVKDG
PDGHKLVQDPHNQRZQDGPLUHGDQGIHDUHGWKURXJKRXWWKHEODFN
NLQJGRPV+HGLGQRWUHIXVHWHVWVGHYLVHGE\WKHGXVN\ORUGV
6NLUPLVKHVDORQJWKHERUGHUVZHUHLQFHVVDQWDIIRUGLQJWKH&LPPHULDQ
SOHQW\RIRSSRUWXQLWLHVWRGHPRQVWUDWHKLVDELOLW\DWKDQGWRKDQG
ILJKWLQJ+LVUHFNOHVVIHURFLW\LPSUHVVHGWKHORUGVRI.HVKDQ
DOUHDG\DZDUHRIKLVUHSXWDWLRQDVDOHDGHURIPHQDQGWKHSURVSHFWV
VHHPHGIDYRUDEOH$OO&RQDQVHFUHWO\GHVLUHGZDVHPSOR\PHQWWRJLYH
KLPOHJLWLPDWHH[FXVHIRUUHPDLQLQJLQ.HVKDQORQJHQRXJKWRORFDWH
WKHKLGLQJSODFHRIWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU7KHQWKHUHFDPHDQ
LQWHUUXSWLRQ7KXWPHNULFDPHWR.HVKDQDWWKHKHDGRIDQHPEDVV\IURP
=HPEDEZHL
7KXWPHNULZDVD6W\JLDQDQDGYHQWXUHUDQGDURJXHZKRVHZLWVKDG
UHFRPPHQGHGKLPWRWKHWZLQNLQJVRIWKHJUHDWK\EULGWUDGLQJNLQJGRP
ZKLFKOD\PDQ\GD\V
PDUFKWRWKHHDVW+HDQGWKH&LPPHULDQNQHZ
HDFKRWKHURIROGDQGZLWKRXWORYH7KXWPHNULOLNHZLVHKDGD
SURSRVLWLRQWRPDNHWRWKHNLQJRI.HVKDQDQGLWDOVRFRQFHUQHGWKH
FRQTXHVWRI3XQWZKLFKNLQJGRPLQFLGHQWDOO\O\LQJHDVWRI
.HVKDQKDGUHFHQWO\H[SHOOHGWKH=HPEDEZDQWUDGHUVDQGEXUQHGWKHLU
IRUWUHVVHV
+LVRIIHURXWZHLJKHGHYHQWKHSUHVWLJHRI&RQDQ+HSOHGJHG
KLPVHOIWRLQYDGH3XQWIURPWKHHDVWZLWKDKRVWRIEODFNVSHDUPHQ
6KHPLWLVKDUFKHUVDQGPHUFHQDU\VZRUGVPHQDQGWRDLGWKHNLQJRI
.HVKDQWRDQQH[WKHKRVWLOHNLQJGRP7KHEHQHYROHQWNLQJVRI
=HPEDEZHLGHVLUHGRQO\DPRQRSRO\RIWKHWUDGHRI.HVKDQDQGKHU
WULEXWDULHVDQGDVDSOHGJHRIJRRGIDLWKVRPHRIWKH7HHWKRI
*ZDKOXU7KHVHZRXOGEHSXWWRQREDVHXVDJH7KXWPHNULKDVWHQHGWR
H[SODLQWRWKHVXVSLFLRXVFKLHIWDLQVWKH\ZRXOGEHSODFHGLQWKH
WHPSOHRI=HPEDEZHLEHVLGHWKHVTXDWJROGLGROVRI'DJRQDQG'HUNHWR
VDFUHGJXHVWVLQWKHKRO\VKULQHRIWKHNLQJGRPWRVHDOWKHFRYHQDQW
EHWZHHQ.HVKDQDQG=HPEDEZHL7KLVVWDWHPHQWEURXJKWDVDYDJHJULQWR
&RQDQ
VKDUGOLSV
7KH&LPPHULDQPDGHQRDWWHPSWWRPDWFKZLWVDQGLQWULJXHZLWK
7KXWPHNULDQGKLV6KHPLWLVKSDUWQHU=DUJKHED+HNQHZWKDWLI
7KXWPHNULZRQKLVSRLQWKHZRXOGLQVLVWRQWKHLQVWDQWEDQLVKPHQWRI
KLVULYDO7KHUHZDVEXWRQHWKLQJIRU&RQDQWRGRILQGWKHMHZHOV
EHIRUHWKHNLQJRI.HVKDQPDGHXSKLVPLQGDQGIOHHZLWKWKHP%XW
E\WKLVWLPHKHZDVFHUWDLQWKDWWKH\ZHUHQRWKLGGHQLQ.HVKLDWKH
UR\DOFLW\ZKLFKZDVDVZDUPRIWKDWFKHGKXWVFURZGLQJDERXWDPXG
ZDOOWKDWHQFORVHGDSDODFHRIVWRQHDQGPXGDQGEDPERR
:KLOHKHIXPHGZLWKQHUYRXVLPSDWLHQFHWKHKLJKSULHVW*RUXOJD
DQQRXQFHGWKDWEHIRUHDQ\GHFLVLRQFRXOGEHUHDFKHGWKHZLOORIWKH
JRGVPXVWEHDVFHUWDLQHGFRQFHUQLQJWKHSURSRVHGDOOLDQFHZLWK
=HPEDEZHLDQGWKHSOHGJHRIREMHFWVORQJKHOGKRO\DQGLQYLRODWH7KH
RUDFOHRI$ONPHHQRQPXVWEHFRQVXOWHG
7KLVZDVDQDZHVRPHWKLQJDQGLWFDXVHGWRQJXHVWRZDJH[FLWHGO\
LQSDODFHDQGEHHKLYHKXW1RWIRUDFHQWXU\KDGWKHSULHVWVYLVLWHG
WKHVLOHQWFLW\7KHRUDFOHPHQVDLGZDVWKH3ULQFHVV<HOD\DWKH
ODVWUXOHURI$ONPHHQRQZKRKDGGLHGLQWKHIXOOEORRPRIKHU\RXWK
DQGEHDXW\DQGZKRVHERG\KDGPLUDFXORXVO\UHPDLQHGXQEOHPLVKHG
WKURXJKRXWWKHDJHV2IROGSULHVWVKDGPDGHWKHLUZD\LQWRWKH
KDXQWHGFLW\DQGVKHKDGWDXJKWWKHPZLVGRP7KHODVWSULHVWWRVHHN
WKHRUDFOHKDGEHHQDZLFNHGPDQZKRKDGVRXJKWWRVWHDOIRUKLPVHOI
WKHFXULRXVO\FXWMHZHOVWKDWPHQFDOOHGWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU%XW
VRPHGRRPKDGFRPHXSRQKLPLQWKHGHVHUWHGSDODFHIURPZKLFKKLV
DFRO\WHVIOHHLQJKDGWROGWDOHVRIKRUURUWKDWKDGIRUDKXQGUHG
\HDUVIULJKWHQHGWKHSULHVWVIURPWKHFLW\DQGWKHRUDFOH
%XW*RUXOJDWKHSUHVHQWKLJKSULHVWDVRQHFRQILGHQWLQKLV
NQRZOHGJHRIKLVRZQLQWHJULW\DQQRXQFHGWKDWKHZRXOGJRZLWKD
KDQGIXORIIROORZHUVWRUHYLYHWKHDQFLHQWFXVWRP$QGLQWKH
H[FLWHPHQWWRQJXHVEX]]HGLQGLVFUHHWO\DQG&RQDQFDXJKWWKHFOXHIRU
ZKLFKKHKDGVRXJKWIRUZHHNVWKHRYHUKHDUGZKLVSHURIDOHVVHU
SULHVWWKDWVHQWWKH&LPPHULDQVWHDOLQJRXWRI.HVKLDWKHQLJKW
EHIRUHWKHGDZQZKHQWKHSULHVWVZHUHWRVWDUW
5LGLQJDVKDUGDVKHGDUHGIRUDQLJKWDQGDGD\DQGDQLJKWKH
FDPHLQWKHHDUO\GDZQWRWKHFOLIIVRI$ONPHHQRQZKLFKVWRRGLQWKH
VRXWKZHVWHUQFRUQHURIWKHNLQJGRPDPLGVWXQLQKDELWHGMXQJOHZKLFK
ZDVWDERRWRWKHFRPPRQPHQ1RQHEXWWKHSULHVWVGDUHGDSSURDFKWKH
KDXQWHGYDOHZLWKLQDGLVWDQFHRIPDQ\PDLOHV$QGQRWHYHQDSULHVW
KDGHQWHUHG$ONPHHQRQIRUDKXQGUHG\HDUV
1RPDQKDGHYHUFOLPEHGWKHVHFOLIIVOHJHQGVVDLGDQGQRQHEXW
WKHSULHVWVNQHZWKHVHFUHWHQWUDQFHLQWRWKHYDOOH\&RQDQGLGQRW
ZDVWHWLPHORRNLQJIRULW6WHHSVWKDWEDONHGWKHVHEODFNSHRSOH
KRUVHPHQDQGGZHOOHUVRISODLQDQGOHYHOIRUHVWZHUHQRWLPSRVVLEOH
IRUDPDQERUQLQWKHUXJJHGKLOOVRI&LPPHULD
1RZRQWKHVXPPLWRIWKHFOLIIVKHORRNHGGRZQLQWRWKHFLUFXODU
YDOOH\DQGZRQGHUHGZKDWSODJXHZDURUVXSHUVWLWLRQKDGGULYHQWKH
PHPEHUVRIWKDWDQFLHQWZKLWHUDFHIRUWKIURPWKHLUVWURQJKROGWR
PLQJOHZLWKDQGEHDEVRUEHGE\WKHEODFNWULEHVWKDWKHPPHGWKHPLQ
7KLVYDOOH\KDGEHHQWKHLUFLWDGHO7KHUHWKHSDODFHVWRRGDQG
WKHUHRQO\WKHUR\DOIDPLO\DQGWKHLUFRXUWGZHOW7KHUHDOFLW\
VWRRGRXWVLGHWKHFOLIIV7KRVHZDYLQJPDVVHVRIJUHHQMXQJOH
YHJHWDWLRQKLGLWVUXLQV%XWWKHGRPHVWKDWJOLVWHQHGLQWKHOHDYHV
EHORZKLPZHUHWKHXQEURNHQSLQQDFOHVRIWKHUR\DOSDODFHRI
$ONPHHQRQZKLFKKDGGHILHGWKHFRUURGLQJDJHV
6ZLQJLQJDOHJRYHUWKHULPKHZHQWGRZQVZLIWO\7KHLQQHUVLGH
RIWKHFOLIIVZDVPRUHEURNHQQRWTXLWHVRVKHHU,QOHVVWKDQKDOI
WKHWLPHLWKDGWDNHQKLPWRDVFHQWWKHRXWHUVLGHKHGURSSHGWRWKH
VZDUGHGYDOOH\IORRU
:LWKRQHKDQGRQKLVVZRUGKHORRNHGDOHUWO\DERXWKLP7KHUHZDV
QRUHDVRQWRVXSSRVHPHQOLHGZKHQWKH\VDLGWKDW$ONPHHQRQZDVHPSW\
DQGGHVHUWHGKDXQWHGRQO\E\WKHJKRVWVRIWKHGHDGSDVW%XWLWZDV
&RQDQ
VQDWXUHWREHVXVSLFLRXVDQGZDU\7KHVLOHQFHZDVSULPRGLDO
QRWHYHQDOHDITXLYHUHGRQDEUDQFK:KHQKHEHQWWRSHHUXQGHUWKH
WUHHVKHVDZQRWKLQJEXWWKHPDUFKLQJURZVRIWUXQNVUHFHGLQJDQG
UHFHGLQJLQWRWKHEOXHJORRPRIWKHGHHSZRRGV
1HYHUWKHOHVVKHZHQWZDULO\VZRUGLQKDQGKLVUHVWOHVVH\HV
FRPELQJWKHVKDGRZVIURPVLGHWRVLGHKLVVSULQJ\WUHDGPDNLQJQR
VRXQGRQWKHVZDUG$OODERXWKLPKHVDZVLJQVRIDQDQFLHQW
FLYLOL]DWLRQPDUEOHIRXQWDLQVYRLFHOHVVDQGFUXPEOLQJVWRRGLQ
FLUFOHVRIVOHQGHUWUHHVZKRVHSDWWHUQVZHUHWRRV\PPHWULFDOWRKDYH
EHHQDFKDQFHRIQDWXUH)RUHVWJURZWKDQGXQGHUEUXVKKDGLQYDGHGWKH
HYHQO\SODQQHGJURYHVEXWWKHLURXWOLQHVZHUHVWLOOYLVLEOH%URDG
SDYHPHQWVUDQDZD\XQGHUWKHWUHHVEURNHQDQGZLWKJUDVVJURZLQJ
WKURXJKWKHZLGHFUDFNV+HJOLPSVHGZDOOVZLWKRUQDPHQWDOFRSLQJV
ODWWLFHVRIFDUYHQVWRQHWKDWPLJKWRQFHKDYHVHUYHGDVWKHZDOOVRI
SOHDVXUHSDYLOLRQV
$KHDGRIKLPWKURXJKWKHWUHHVWKHGRPHVJOHDPHGDQGWKHEXONRI
WKHVWUXFWXUHVXSSRUWLQJWKHPEHFDPHPRUHDSSDUHQWDVKHDGYDQFHG
3UHVHQWO\SXVKLQJWKURXJKDVFUHHQRIYLQHWDQJOHGEUDQFKHVKHFDPH
LQWRDFRPSDUDWLYHO\RSHQVSDFHZKHUHWKHWUHHVVWUDJJOHG
XQHQFXPEHUHGE\XQGHUJURZWKDQGVDZEHIRUHKLPWKHZLGHSLOODUHG
SRUWLFRRIWKHSDODFH
$VKHPRXQWHGWKHEURDGPDUEOHVWHSVKHQRWHGWKDWWKHEXLOGLQJ
ZDVLQIDUEHWWHUVWDWHRISUHVHUYDWLRQWKDQWKHOHVVHUVWUXFWXUHVKH
KDGJOLPSVHG7KHWKLFNZDOOVDQGPDVVLYHSLOODUVVHHPHGWRRSRZHUIXO
WRFUXPEOHEHIRUHWKHDVVDXOWRIWLPHDQGWKHHOHPHQWV7KHVDPH
HQFKDQWHGTXLHWEURRGHGRYHUDOO7KHFDWOLNHSDGRIKLVVDQGDOHG
IHHWVHHPHGVWDUWLQJO\ORXGLQWKHVWLOOQHVV
6RPHZKHUHLQWKLVSDODFHOD\WKHHIILJ\RULPDJHZKLFKKDGLQ
WLPHVSDVWVHUYHGDVRUDFOHIRUWKHSULHVWVRI.HVKDQ$QGVRPHZKHUH
LQWKHSDODFHXQOHVVWKDWLQGLVFUHHWSULHVWKDGEDEEOHGDOLHZDV
KLGGHQWKHWUHDVXUHRIWKHIRUJRWWHQNLQJVRI$ONPHHQRQ
&RQDQSDVVHGLQWRDEURDGORIW\KDOOOLQHGZLWKWDOOFROXPQV
EHWZHHQZKLFKDUFKHVJDSHGWKHLUGRRUVORQJURWWHGDZD\+H
WUDYHUVHGWKLVLQDWZLOLJKWGLPQHVVDQGDWWKHRWKHUHQGSDVVHG
WKURXJKJUHDWGRXEOHYDOYHGEURQ]HGRRUVZKLFKVWRRGSDUWO\RSHQDV
WKH\PLJKWKDYHVWRRGIRUFHQWXULHV+HHPHUJHGLQWRDYDVWGRPHG
FKDPEHUZKLFKPXVWKDYHVHUYHGDVDXGLHQFHKDOOIRUWKHNLQJVRI
$ONPHHQRQ
,WZDVRFWDJRQDOLQVKDSHDQGWKHJUHDWGRPHXSLQZKLFKWKH
ORIW\FHLOLQJFXUYHGREYLRXVO\ZDVFXQQLQJO\SLHUFHGIRUWKHFKDPEHU
ZDVPXFKEHWWHUOLJKWHGWKDQWKHKDOOZKLFKOHGWRLW$WWKHIDUWKHU
VLGHRIWKHJUHDWURRPWKHUHURVHDGDLVZLWKEURDGODSLVOD]XOL
VWHSVOHDGLQJXSWRLWDQGRQWKDWGDLVWKHUHVWRRGDPDVVLYHFKDLU
ZLWKRUQDWHDUPVDQGDKLJKEDFNZKLFKRQFHGRXEWOHVVVXSSRUWHGD
FORWKRIJROGFDQRS\&RQDQJUXQWHGH[SORVLYHO\DQGKLVH\HVOLW7KH
JROGHQWKURQHRI$ONPHHQRQQDPHGLQLPPHPRULDOOHJHQGU\+HZHLJKHG
LWZLWKDSUDFWLVHGH\H,WUHSUHVHQWHGDIRUWXQHLQLWVHOILIKH
ZHUHEXWDEOHWREHDULWDZD\,WVULFKQHVVILUHGKLVLPDJLQDWLRQ
FRQFHUQLQJWKHWUHDVXUHLWVHOIDQGPDGHKLPEXUQZLWKHDJHUQHVV+LV
ILQJHUVLWFKHGWRSOXQJHDPRQJWKHJHPVKHKDGKHDUGGHVFULEHGE\
VWRU\WHOOHUVLQWKHPDUNHWVTXDUHVRI.HVKLDZKRUHSHDWHGWDOHV
KDQGHGGRZQIURPPRXWKWRPRXWKWKURXJKWKHFHQWXULHVMHZHOVQRW
WREHGXSOLFDWHGLQWKHZRUOGUXELHVHPHUDOGVGLDPRQGV
EORRGVWRQHVRSDOVVDSSKLUHVWKHORRWRIWKHDQFLHQWZRUOG
+HKDGH[SHFWHGWRILQGWKHRUDFOHHIILJ\VHDWHGRQWKHWKURQH
EXWVLQFHLWZDVQRWLWZDVSUREDEO\SODFHGLQVRPHRWKHUSDUWRI
WKHSDODFHLILQGHHGVXFKDWKLQJUHDOO\H[LVWHG%XWVLQFHKHKDG
WXUQHGKLVIDFHWRZDUG.HVKDQVRPDQ\P\WKVKDGSURYHGWREH
UHDOLWLHVWKDWKHGLGQRWGRXEWWKDWWKHZRXOGILQGVRPHNLQGRI
LPDJHRUJRG
%HKLQGWKHWKURQHWKHUHZDVDQDUURZDUFKHGGRRUZD\ZKLFK
GRXEWOHVVKDGEHHQPDVNHGE\KDQJLQJVLQWKHGD\VRI$ONPHHQRQ
V
OLIH+HJODQFHGWKURXJKLWDQGVDZWKDWLWOHWLQWRDQDOFRYH
HPSW\DQGZLWKDQDUURZFRUULGRUOHDGLQJRIIIURPLWDWULJKW
DQJOHV7XUQLQJDZD\IURPLWKHVSLHGDQRWKHUDUFKWRWKHOHIWRI
WKHGDLVDQGLWXQOLNHWKHRWKHUVZDVIXUQLVKHGZLWKDGRRU1RU
ZDVLWDQ\FRPPRQGRRU7KHSRUWDOZDVRIWKHVDPHULFKPHWDODVWKH
WKURQHDQGFDUYHGZLWKPDQ\FXULRXVDUDEHVTXHV
$WKLVWRXFKLWVZXQJRSHQVRUHDGLO\WKDWLWVKLQJHVPLJKW
UHFHQWO\KDYHEHHQRLOHG,QVLGHKHKDOWHGVWDULQJ
+HZDVLQDVTXDUHFKDPEHURIQRJUHDWGLPHQVLRQVZKRVHPDUEOH
ZDOOVURVHWRDQRUQDWHFHLOLQJLQODLGZLWKJROG*ROGIULH]HVUDQ
DERXWWKHEDVHDQGWKHWRSRIWKHZDOOVDQGWKHUHZDVQRGRRURWKHU
WKDQWKHRQHWKRXJKZKLFKKHKDGHQWHUHG%XWKHQRWHGWKHVHGHWDLOV
PHFKDQLFDOO\+LVZKROHDWWHQWLRQZDVFHQWHUHGRQWKHVKDSHZKLFKOD\
RQDQLYRU\GDLVEHIRUHKLP
+HKDGH[SHFWHGDQLPDJHSUREDEO\FDUYHGZLWKWKHVNLOORID
IRUJRWWHQDUW%XWQRDUWFRXOGPLPLFWKHSHUIHFWLRQRIWKHILJXUH
WKDWOD\EHIRUHKLP
,WZDVQRHIILJ\RIVWRQHRUPHWDORULYRU\,WZDVWKHDFWXDO
ERG\RIDZRPDQDQGE\ZKDWGDUNDUWWKHDQFLHQWVKDGSUHVHUYHGWKDW
IRUPXQEOHPLVKHGIRUVRPDQ\DJHV&RQDQFRXOGQRWHYHQJXHVV7KH
YHU\JDUPHQWVVKHZRUHZHUHLQWDFWDQG&RQDQVFRZOHGDWWKDWD
YDXJHXQHDVLQHVVVWLUULQJDWWKHEDFNRIKLVPLQG7KHDUWVWKDW
SUHVHUYHGWKHERG\VKRXOGQRWKDYHDIIHFWHGWKHJDUPHQWV<HWWKHUH
WKH\ZHUHJROGEUHDVWSODWHVVHWZLWKFRQFHQWULFFLUFOHVRIVPDOO
JHPVJLOGHGVDQGDOVDQGDVKRUWVLONHQVNLUWXSKHOGE\DMHZHOHG
JLUGOH1HLWKHUFORWKQRUPHWDOVKRZHGDQ\VLJQVRIGHFD\
<HOD\DZDVFROGO\EHDXWLIXOHYHQLQGHDWK+HUERG\ZDVOLNH
DODEDVWHUVOHQGHU\HWYROXSWXRXVDJUHDWFULPVRQMHZHOJOHDPHG
DJDLQVWWKHGDUNO\SLOHGIRDPRIKHUKDLU
&RQDQVWRRGIURZQLQJGRZQDWKHUDQGWKHQWDSSHGWKHGDLVZLWK
KLVVZRUG3RVVLELOLWLHVRIDKROORZFRQWDLQLQJWKHWUHDVXUHRFFXUUHG
WRKLPEXWWKHGDLVUDQJVROLG+HWXUQHGDQGSDFHGWKHFKDPEHULQ
VRPHLQGHFLVLRQ:KHUHVKRXOGKHVHDUFKILUVWLQWKHOLPLWHGWLPHDW
KLVGLVSRVDO"7KHSULHVWKHKDGRYHUKHDUGEDEEOLQJWRDFRXUWHVDQKDG
VDLGWKHWUHDVXUHZDVKLGGHQLQWKHSDODFH%XWWKDWLQFOXGHGDVSDFH
RIFRQVLGHUDEOHYDVWQHVV+HZRQGHUHGLIKHVKRXOGKLGHKLPVHOIXQWLO
WKHSULHVWVKDGFRPHDQGJRQHDQGWKHQUHQHZWKHVHDUFK%XWWKHUH
ZDVDVWURQJFKDQFHWKDWWKH\PLJKWWDNHWKHMHZHOVZLWKWKHPZKHQ
WKH\UHWXUQHGWR.HVKLD)RUKHZDVFRQYLQFHGWKDW7KXWPHNULKDG
FRUUXSWHG*RUXOJD
&RQDQFRXOGSUHGLFW7KXWPHNUL
VSODQVIURPKLVNQRZOHGJHRIWKH
PDQ+HNQHZWKDWLWKDGEHHQ7KXWPHNULZKRKDGSURSRVHGWKHFRQTXHVW
RI3XQWWRWKHNLQJVRI=HPEDEZHLZKLFKFRQTXHVWZDVEXWRQHPRYH
WRZDUGWKHLUUHDOJRDOWKHFDSWXUHRIWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU7KRVH
ZDU\NLQJVZRXOGGHPDQGSURRIWKDWWKHWUHDVXUHUHDOO\H[LVWHGEHIRUH
WKH\PDGHDQ\PRYH7KHMHZHOV7KXWPHNULDVNHGDVDSOHGJHZRXOG
IXUQLVKWKDWSURRI
:LWKSRVLWLYHHYLGHQFHRIWKHWUHDVXUH
VUHDOLW\WKHNLQJVRI
=LPEDEZHLZRXOGPRYH3XQWZRXOGEHLQYDGHGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\IURPWKH
HDVWDQGWKHZHVWEXWWKH=HPEDEZDQVZRXOGVHHWRLWWKDWWKH
.HVKDQLGLGPRVWRIWKHILJKWLQJDQGWKHQZKHQERWK3XQWDQG.HVKDQ
ZHUHH[KDXVWHGIURPWKHVWUXJJOHWKH=HPEDEZDQVZRXOGFUXVKERWK
UDFHVORRW.HVKDQDQGWDNHWKHWUHDVXUHE\IRUFHLIWKH\KDGWR
GHVWUR\HYHU\EXLOGLQJDQGWRUWXUHHYHU\OLYLQJKXPDQLQWKHNLQJGRP
%XWWKHUHZDVDOZD\VDQRWKHUSRVVLELOLW\LI7KXWPHNULFRXOGJHW
KLVKDQGVRQWKHKRDUGLWZRXOGEHFKDUDFWHULVWLFRIWKHPDQWR
FKHDWKLVHPSOR\HUVVWHDOWKHMHZHOVIRUKLPVHOIDQGGHFDPSOHDYLQJ
WKH=HPEDEZDQHPLVVDULHVKROGLQJWKHVDFN
&RQDQEHOLHYHGWKDWWKLVFRQVXOWLQJRIWKHRUDFOHZDVEXWDUXVH
WRSHUVXDGHWKHNLQJRI.HVKDQWRDFFHGHWR7KXWPHNUL
VZLVKHVIRU
KHQHYHUIRUDPRPHQWGRXEWHGWKDW*RUXOJDZDVDVVXEWOHDQGGHYLRXV
DVDOOWKHUHVWPL[HGXSLQWKLVJUDQGVZLQGOH&RQDQKDGQRW
DSSURDFKHGWKHKLJKSULHVWKLPVHOIEHFDXVHLQWKHJDPHRIEULEHU\KH
ZRXOGKDYHQRFKDQFHDJDLQVW7KXWPHNULDQGWRDWWHPSWLWZRXOGEHWR
SOD\GLUHFWO\LQWRWKH6W\JLDQ
VKDQGV*RUXOJDFRXOGGHQRXQFHWKH
&LPPHULDQWRWKHSHRSOHHVWDEOLVKDUHSXWDWLRQIRULQWHJULW\DQG
ULG7KXWPHNULRIKLVULYDODWRQHVWURNH+HZRQGHUHGKRZ7KXWPHNUL
KDGFRUUXSWHGWKHKLJKSULHVWDQGMXVWZKDWFRXOGEHRIIHUHGDVD
EULEHWRDPDQZKRKDGWKHJUHDWHVWWUHDVXUHLQWKHZRUOGXQGHUKLV
ILQJHUV
$WDQ\UDWHKHZDVVXUHWKDWWKHRUDFOHZRXOGEHPDGHWRVD\WKDW
WKHJRGVZLOOHGLWWKDW.HVKDQZKRXOGIROORZ7KXWPHNUL
VZLVKHVDQG
KHZDVVXUHWRRWKDWLWZRXOGGURSDIHZSRLQWHGUHPDUNVFRQFHUQLQJ
KLPVHOI$IWHUWKDW.HVKLDZRXOGEHWRRKRWIRUWKH&LPPHULDQQRU
KDG&RQDQKDGDQ\LQWHQWLRQRIUHWXUQLQJZKHQKHURGHZD\LQWKH
QLJKW
7KHRUDFOHFKDPEHUKHOGQRFOXHIRUKLP+HZHQWIRUWKLQWRWKH
JUHDWWKURQHURRPDQGODLGKLVKDQGVRQWKHWKURQH,WZDVKHDY\EXW
KHFRXOGWLOWLWXS7KHIORRUEHQHDWKDWKLFNPDUEOHGDLVZDV
VROLG$JDLQKHVRXJKWWKHDOFRYH+LVPLQGFOXQJWRDVHFUHWFU\SW
QHDUWKHRUDFOH3DLQVWDNLQJO\KHEHJDQWRWDSDORQJWKHZDOOVDQG
SUHVHQWO\KLVWDSVUDQJKROORZDWDVSRWRSSRVLWHWKHPRXWKRIWKH
QDUURZFRUULGRU/RRNLQJPRUHFORVHO\KHVDZWKDWWKHFUDFNEHWZHHQ
WKHPDUEOHSDQHODWWKDWSRLQWDQGWKHQH[WZDVZLGHUWKDQXVXDO+H
LQVHUWHGDGDJJHUSRLQWDQGSULHG
6LOHQWO\WKHSDQHOVZXQJRSHQUHYHDOLQJDQLFKHLQWKHZDOOEXW
QRWKLQJHOVH+HVZRUHIHHOLQJO\7KHDSHUWXUHZDVHPSW\DQGLWGLG
QRWORRNDVLILWKDGHYHUVHUYHGDVDFU\SWIRUWUHDVXUH/HDQLQJ
LQWRWKHQLFKHKHVDZDV\VWHPRIWLQ\KROHVLQWKHZDOODERXWRQD
OHYHOZLWKDPDQ
VPRXWK+HSHHUHGWKURXJKDQGJUXQWHG
XQGHUVWDQGLQJO\7KDWZDVWKHZDOOWKDWIRUPHGWKHSDUWLWLRQEHWZHHQ
WKHDOFRYHDQGWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHU7KRVHKROHVKDGQRWEHHQYLVLEOH
LQWKHFKDPEHU&RQDQJULQQHG7KLVH[SODLQHGWKHP\VWHU\RIWKH
RUDFOHEXWLWZDVDELWFUXGHUWKDQKHKDGH[SHFWHG*RUXOJDZRXOG
SODQWHLWKHUKLPVHOIRUVRPHWUXVWHGPLQLRQLQWKDWQLFKHWRWDON
WKURXJKWKHKROHVWKHFUHGXORXVDFRO\WHVEODFNPHQDOOZRXOG
DFFHSWLWDVWKHYHULWDEOHYRLFHRI<HOD\D
5HPHPEHULQJVRPHWKLQJWKH&LPPHULDQGUHZIRUWKWKHUROORI
SDUFKPHQWKHKDGWDNHQIURPWKHPXPP\DQGXQUROOHGLWFDUHIXOO\DV
LWVHHPHGUHDG\WRIDOOWRSLHFHVZLWKDJH+HVFRZOHGRYHUWKHGLP
FKDUDFWHUVZLWKZKLFKLWZDVFRYHUHG,QKLVURDPLQJDERXWWKHZRUOG
WKHJLDQWDGYHQWXUHUKDGSLFNHGXSDZLGHVPDWWHULQJRINQRZOHGJH
SDUWLFXODUO\LQFOXGLQJWKHVSHDNLQJDQGUHDGLQJRIPDQ\DOLHQ
WRQJXHV0DQ\DVKHOWHUHGVFKRODUZRXOGKDYHEHHQDVWRQLVKHGDWWKH
&LPPHULDQ
VOLQJXLVWLFDELOLWLHVIRUKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGPDQ\
DGYHQWXUHVZKHUHNQRZOHGJHRIDVWUDQJHODQJXDJHKDGPHDQWWKH
GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQOLIHDQGGHDWK
7KHFKDUDFWHUVZHUHSX]]OLQJDWRQFHIDPLOLDUDQGXQLQWHOOLJLEOH
DQGSUHVHQWO\KHGLVFRYHUHGWKHUHDVRQ7KH\ZHUHWKHFKDUDFWHUVRI
DUFKDLF3HOLVKWLFZKLFKSRVVHVVHGPDQ\SRLQWVRIGLIIHUHQFHIURPWKH
PRGHUQVFULSWZLWKZKLFKKHZDVIDPLOLDUDQGZKLFKWKUHHFHQWXULHV
DJRKDGEHHQPRGLILHGE\FRQTXHVWE\DQRPDGWULEH7KLVROGHU
SXUHUVFULSWEDIIOHGKLP+HPDGHRXWDUHFXUUHQWSKUDVHKRZHYHU
ZKLFKKHUHFRJQL]HGDVDSURSHUQDPH%LW<DNLQ+HJDWKHUHGWKDWLW
ZDVWKHQDPHRIWKHZULWHU
6FRZOLQJKLVOLSVXQFRQVFLRXVO\PRYLQJDVKHVWUXJJOHGZLWKWKH
WDVNKHEOXQGHUHGWKURXJKWKHPDQXVFULSWILQGLQJPXFKRILW
XQWUDQVODWDEOHDQGPRVWRIWKHUHVWRILWREVFXUH
+HJDWKHUHGWKDWWKHZULWHUWKHP\VWHULRXV%LW<DNLQKDGFRPH
IURPDIDUZLWKKLVVHUYDQWVDQGHQWHUHGWKHYDOOH\RI$ONPHHQRQ
0XFKWKDWIROORZHGZDVPHDQLQJOHVVLQWHUVSHUVHGDVLWZDVZLWK
XQIDPLOLDUSKUDVHVDQGFKDUDFWHUV6XFKDVKHFRXOGWUDQVODWHVHHPHG
WRLQGLFDWHWKHSDVVLQJRIDYHU\ORQJSHULRGRIWLPH7KHQDPHRI
<HOD\DZDVUHSHDWHGIUHTXHQWO\DQGWRZDUGWKHODVWSDUWRIWKH
PDQXVFULSWLWEHFDPHDSSDUHQWWKDW%LW<DNLQNQHZWKDWGHDWKZDVXSRQ
KLP:LWKDVOLJKWVWDUW&RQDQUHDOL]HGWKDWWKHPXPP\LQWKHFDYHUQ
PXVWEHWKHUHPDLQVRIWKHZULWHURIWKHPDQXVFULSWWKHP\VWHULRXV
3HOLVKWL%LW<DNLQ7KHPDQKDGGLHGDVKHKDGSURSKHVLHGDQGKLV
VHUYDQWVREYLRXVO\KDGSODFHGKLPLQWKDWRSHQFU\SWKLJKXSRQ
WKHFOLIIVDFFRUGLQJWRKLVLQVWUXFWLRQVEHIRUHKLVGHDWK
,WZDVVWUDQJHWKDW%LW<DNLQZDVQRWPHQWLRQHGLQDQ\RIWKH
OHJHQGVRI$ONPHHQRQ2EYLRXVO\KHKDGFRPHWRWKHYDOOH\DIWHULW
KDGEHHQGHVHUWHGE\WKHRULJLQDOLQKDELWDQWVWKHPDQXVFULSW
LQGLFDWHGDVPXFKEXWLWVHHPHGSHFXOLDUWKDWWKHSULHVWVZKRFDPH
LQWKHROGGD\VWRFRQVXOWWKHRUDFOHKDGQRWVHHQWKHPDQRUKLV
VHUYDQWV&RQDQIHOWVXUHWKDWWKHPXPP\DQGWKLVSDUFKPHQWZDVPRUH
WKDQDKXQGUHG\HDUVROG%LW<DNLQKDGGZHOWLQWKHYDOOH\ZKHQWKH
SULHVWVFDPHRIROGWRERZEHIRUHGHDG<HOD\D<HWFRQFHUQLQJKLPWKH
OHJHQGVZHUHVLOHQWWHOOLQJRQO\RIDGHVHUWHGFLW\KDXQWHGRQO\E\
WKHGHDG
:K\KDGWKHPDQGZHOWLQWKLVGHVRODWHVSRWDQGWRZKDWXQNQRZQ
GHVWLQDWLRQKDGKLVVHUYDQWVGHSDUWHGDIWHUGLVSRVLQJRIWKHLU
PDVWHU
VFRUSVH"
&RQDQVKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGWKUXVWWKHSDUFKPHQWEDFNLQWR
KLVJLUGOHKHVWDUWHGYLROHQWO\WKHVNLQRQWKHEDFNVRIKLV
KDQGVWLQJOLQJ6WDUWLQJO\VKRFNLQJO\LQWKHVOXPEHURXVVWLOOQHVV
WKHUHKDGERRPHGWKHGHHSVWULGHQWFODQJRURIDJUHDWJRQJ
+HZKHHOHGFURXFKLQJOLNHDJUHDWFDWVZRUGLQKDQGJODULQJ
GRZQWKHQDUURZFRUULGRUIURPZKLFKWKHVRXQGKDGVHHPHGWRFRPH+DG
WKHSULHVWVRI.HVKLDDUULYHG"7KLVZDVLPSUREDEOHKHNQHZWKH\
ZRXOGQRWKDYHKDGWLPHWRUHDFKWKHYDOOH\%XWWKDWJRQJZDV
LQGLVSXWDEOHHYLGHQFHRIKXPDQSUHVHQFH
&RQDQZDVEDVLFDOO\DGLUHFWDFWLRQLVW6XFKVXEWOHW\DVKH
SRVVHVVHGKDGEHHQDFTXLUHGWKURXJKFRQWDFWZLWKWKHPRUHGHYLRXV
UDFHV:KHQWDNHQRIIJXDUGE\VRPHXQH[SHFWHGRFFXUUHQFHKH
UHYHUWHGLQVWLQFWLYHO\WRW\SH6RQRZLQVWHDGRIKLGLQJRUVOLSSLQJ
DZD\LQWKHRSSRVLWHGLUHFWLRQDVWKHDYHUDJHPDQPLJKWKDYHGRQHKH
UDQVWUDLJKWGRZQWKHFRUULGRULQWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHVRXQG+LV
VDQGDOVPDGHQRPRUHVRXQGWKDQWKHSDGVRIDSDQWKHUZRXOGKDYH
PDGHKLVH\HVZHUHVOLWVKLVOLSVXQFRQVFLRXVO\DVQDUO3DQLFKDG
PRPHQWDULO\WRXFKHGKLVVRXODWWKHVKRFNRIWKDWXQH[SHFWHG
UHYHUEHUDWLRQDQGWKHUHGUDJHRIWKHSULPLWLYHWKDWLVZDNHQHGE\
WKUHDWRISHULODOZD\VOXUNHGFORVHWRWKHVXUIDFHRIWKH&LPPHULDQ
+HHPHUJHGSUHVHQWO\IURPWKHZLQGLQJFRUULGRULQWRDVPDOORSHQ
FRXUW6RPHWKLQJJOLQWLQJLQWKHVXQFDXJKWKLVH\H,WZDVWKHJRQJ
DJUHDWJROGGLVNKDQJLQJIURPDJROGDUPH[WHQGLQJIURPWKH
FUXPEOLQJZDOO$EUDVVPDOOHWOD\QHDUEXWWKHUHZDVQRVRXQGRU
VLJKWRIKXPDQLW\7KHVXUURXQGLQJDUFKHVJDSHGHPSWLO\&RQDQ
FURXFKHGLQVLGHWKHGRRUZD\IRUZKDWVHHPHGDORQJWLPH7KHUHZDVQR
VRXQGRUPRYHPHQWWKURXJKRXWWKHJUHDWSDODFH+LVSDWLHQFHH[KDXVWHG
DWODVWKHJOLGHGDURXQGWKHFXUYHRIWKHFRXUWSHHULQJLQWRWKH
DUFKHVUHDG\WROHDSHLWKHUZD\OLNHDIODVKRIOLJKWRUWRVWULNH
ULJKWRUOHIWDVDFREUDVWULNHV
+HUHDFKHGWKHJRQJVWDUWHGLQWRWKHDUFKQHDUHVWLW+HVDZRQO\
DGLPFKDPEHUOLWWHUHGZLWKWKHGHEULVRIGHFD\%HQHDWKWKHJRQJ
WKHSROLVKHGPDUEOHIODJVVKRZHGQRIRRWSULQWEXWWKHUHZDVDVFHQW
LQWKHDLUDIDLQWO\IHWLGRGRUKHFRXOGQRWFODVVLI\KLV
QRVWULOVGLODWHGOLNHWKRVHRIDZLOGEHDVWDVKHVRXJKWLQYDLQWR
LGHQWLI\LW
+HWXUQHGWRZDUGWKHDUFKZLWKDSSDOOLQJVXGGHQQHVVWKH
VHHPLQJO\VROLGIODJVVSOLQWHUHGDQGJDYHZD\XQGHUKLVIHHW(YHQDV
KHIHOOKHVSUHDGZLGHKLVDUPVDQGFDXJKWWKHHGJHVRIWKHDSHUWXUH
WKDWJDSHGEHQHDWKKLP7KHHGJHVFUXPEOHGRIIXQGHUKLVFOXWFKLQJ
ILQJHUV'RZQLQWRXWWHUEODFNQHVVKHVKRWLQWREODFNLF\ZDWHUWKDW
JULSSHGKLPDQGZKLUOHGKLPDZD\ZLWKEUHDWKOHVVVSHHG


$*RGGHVV$ZDNHQV

7KH&LPPHULDQDWILUVWPDGHQRDWWHPSWWRILJKWWKHFXUUHQWWKDW
ZDVVZHHSLQJKLPWKURXJKOLJKWOHVVQLJKW+HNHSWKLPVHOIDIORDW
JULSSLQJEHWZHHQKLVWHHWKWKHVZRUGZKLFKKHKDGQRWUHOLQTXLVKHG
HYHQLQKLVIDOODQGGLGQRWVHHNWRJXHVVWRZKDWGRRPKHZDVEHLQJ
ERUQH%XWVXGGHQO\DEHDPRIOLJKWODQFHGWKHGDUNQHVVDKHDGRIKLP
+HVDZWKHVXUJLQJVHHWKLQJEODFNVXUIDFHRIWKHZDWHULQWXUPRLO
DVLIGLVWXUEHGE\VRPHPRQVWHURIWKHGHHSDQGKHVDZWKHVKHHU
VWRQHZDOOVRIWKHFKDQQHOFXUYHGXSWRDYDXOWRYHUKHDG2QHDFK
VLGHUDQDQDUURZOHGJHMXVWEHORZWKHDUFKLQJURRIEXWWKH\ZHUH
IDURXWRIKLVUHDFK$WRQHSRLQWWKLVURRIKDGEHHQEURNHQ
SUREDEO\IDOOHQLQDQGWKHOLJKWZDVVWUHDPLQJWKURXJKWKHDSHUWXUH
%H\RQGWKDWVKDIWRIOLJKWZDVXWWHUEODFNQHVVDQGSDQLFDVVDLOHG
WKH&LPPHULDQDVKHVDZKHZRXOGEHVZHSWRQSDVWWKDWVSRWRIOLJKW
DQGLQWRWKHXQNQRZQEODFNQHVVDJDLQ
7KHQKHVDZVRPHWKLQJHOVHEURQ]HODGGHUVH[WHQGLQJIURPWKH
OHGJHVWRWKHZDWHU
VVXUIDFHDWUHJXODULQWHUYDOVDQGWKHUHZDVRQH
MXVWDKHDGRIKLP,QVWDQWO\KHVWUXFNRXWIRULWILJKWLQJWKH
FXUUHQWWKDWZRXOGKDYHKHOGKLPWRWKHPLGGOHRIWKHVWUHDP,W
GUDJJHGDWKLPDVZLWKWDQJLEOHDQLPDWHVOLP\KDQGVEXWKH
EXIIHWHGWKHUXVKLQJVXUJHZLWKWKHVWUHQJWKRIGHVSHUDWLRQDQGGUHZ
FORVHUDQGFORVHULQVKRUHILJKWLQJIXULRXVO\IRUHYHU\LQFK1RZKH
ZDVHYHQZLWKWKHODGGHHUDQGZLWKDILHUFHJDVSLQJSOXQJHKH
JULSSHGWKHERWWRPUXQJDQGKXQJRQEUHDWKOHVV
$IHZVHFRQGVODWHUKHVWUXJJOHGXSRXWRIWKHVHHWKLQJZDWHU
WUXVWLQJKLVZHLJKWGXELRXVO\WRWKHFRUURGHGUXQJV7KH\VDJJHGDQG
EHQWEXWWKH\KHOGDQGKHFODPEHUHGXSRQWRWKHQDUURZOHGJHZKLFK
UDQDORQJWKHZDOOVFDUFHO\DPDQ
VOHQJWKEHORZWKHFXUYLQJURRI
7KHWDOO&LPPHULDQZDVIRUFHGWREHQGKLVKHDGDVKHVWRRGXS$
KHDY\EURQ]HGRRUVKRZHGLQWKHVWRQHDWDSRLQWHYHQZLWKWKHKHDG
RIWKHODGGHUEXWLWGLGQRWJLYHWR&RQDQ
VHIIRUWV+HWUDQVIHUUHG
KLVVZRUGIURPKLVWHHWKWRLWVVFDEEDUGVSLWWLQJEORRGIRUWKH
HGJHKDGFXWKLVOLSVLQWKDWILHUFHILJKWZLWKWKHULYHUDQG
WXUQHGKLVDWWHQWLRQWRWKHEURNHQURRI
+HFRXOGUHDFKKLVDUPVXSWKURXJKWKHFUHYLFHDQGJULSWKHHGJH
DQGFDUHIXOWHVWLQJWROGKLPLWZRXOGEHDUKLVZHLJKW$QLQVWDQW
ODWHUKHKDGGUDZQKLPVHOIXSWKURXJKWKHKROHDQGIRXQGKLPVHOILQ
DZLGHFKDPEHULQDVWDWHRIH[WUHPHGLVUHSDLU0RVWRIWKHURRIKDG
IDOOHQLQDVZHOODVDJUHDWVHFWLRQRIWKHIORRUZKLFKZDVODLG
RYHUWKHYDXOWRIDVXEWHUUDQHDQULYHU%URNHQDUFKHVRSHQHGLQWR
RWKHUFKDPEHUVDQGFRUULGRUVDQG&RQDQEHOLHYHGKHZDVVWLOOLQWKH
JUHDWSDODFH+HZRQGHUHGXQHDVLO\KRZPDQ\FKDPEHUVLQWKDWSDODFH
KDGXQGHUJURXQGZDWHUGLUHFWO\XQGHUWKHPDQGZKHQWKHDQFLHQWIODJV
RUWLOHVPLJKWJLYHZD\DJDLQDQGSUHFLSLWDWHKLPEDFNLQWRWKH
FXUUHQWIURPZKLFKKHKDGMXVWFUDZOHG
$QGKHZRQGHUHGMXVWKRZPXFKRIDQDFFLGHQWWKDWIDOOKDGEHHQ
+DGWKRVHURWWHQIODJVVLPSO\FKDQFHGWRJLYHZD\EHQHDWKKLVZHLJKW
RUZDVWKHUHDPRUHVLQLVWHUH[SODQDWLRQ"2QHWKLQJDWOHDVWZDV
REYLRXVKHZDVQRWWKHRQO\OLYLQJWKLQJLQWKDWSDODFH7KDWJRQJ
KDGQRWVRXQGHGRILWVRZQDFFRUGZKHWKHUWKHQRLVHKDGEHHQPHDQW
WROXUHKLPWRKLVGHDWKRUQRW7KHVLOHQFHRIWKHSDODFHEHFDPH
VXGGHQO\VLQLVWHUIUDXJKWZLWKFUDZOLQJPHQDFH
&RXOGLWEHVRPHRQHRQWKHVDPHPLVVLRQDVKLPVHOI"$VXGGHQ
WKRXJKWRFFXUUHGWRKLPDWWKHPHPRU\RIWKHP\VWHULRXV%LW<DNLQ
:DVLWQRWSRVVLEOHWKDWWKLVPDQKDGIRXQGWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXULQ
KLVORQJUHVLGHQFHLQ$ONPHHQRQWKDWKLVVHUYDQWVKDGWDNHQWKHP
ZLWKWKHPZKHQWKH\GHSDUWHG"7KHSRVVLELOLW\WKDWKHPLJKWEH
IROORZLQJDZLOOR
WKHZLVSLQIXULDWHGWKH&LPPHULDQ
&KRRVLQJDFRUULGRUZKLFKKHEHOLHYHGOHGEDFNWRZDUGWKHSDUWRI
WKHSDODFHKHKDGILUVWHQWHUHGKHKXUULHGDORQJLWVWHSSLQJ
JLQJHUO\DVKHWKRXJKWRIWKDWEODFNULYHUWKDWVHHWKHGDQGIRDPHG
VRPHZKHUHEHORZKLVIHHW
+LVVSHFXODWLRQVUHFXUUHQWO\UHYROYHGDERXWWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUDQG
LWVFU\SWLFRFFXSDQW6RPHZKHUHLQWKDWYLFLQLW\PXVWEHWKHFOXHWR
WKHP\VWHU\RIWKHWUHDVXUHLILQGHHGLWVWLOOUHPDLQHGLQLWV
LPPHPRULDOKLGLQJSODFH
7KHJUHDWSDODFHOD\VLOHQWDVHYHUGLVWXUEHGRQO\E\WKHVZLIW
SDVVLQJRIKLVVDQGDOHGIHHW7KHFKDPEHUVDQGKDOOVKHWUDYHUVHG
ZHUHFUXPEOLQJLQWRUXLQEXWDVKHDGYDQFHGWKHUDYDJHVRIGHFD\
EHFDPHOHVVDSSDUHQW+HZRQGHUHGEULHIO\IRUZKDWSXUSRVHWKH
ODGGHUVKDGEHHQVXVSHQGHGIURPWKHOHGJHVRYHUWKHVXEWHUUDQHDQ
ULYHUEXWGLVPLVVHGWKHPDWWHUZLWKDVKUXJ+HZDVOLWWOH
LQWHUHVWHGLQVSHFXODWLQJRYHUXQUHPXQHUDWLYHSUREOHPVRIDQWLTXLW\
+HZDVQRWVXUHMXVWZKHUHWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUOD\IURPZKHUHKH
ZDVEXWSUHVHQWO\KHHPHUJHGLQWRDFRUULGRUZKLFKOHGEDFNLQWRWKH
JUHDWWKURQHURRPXQGHURQHRIWKHDUFKHV+HKDGUHDFKHGDGHFLVLRQ
LWZDVXVHOHVVIRUKLPWRZDQGHUDLPOHVVO\DERXWWKHSDODFHVHHNLQJ
WKHKRDUG+HZRXOGFRQFHDOKLPVHOIVRPHZKHUHKHUHZDLWXQWLOWKH
.HVKDQLSULHVWVFDPHDQGWKHQDIWHUWKH\KDGJRQHWKURXJKWKHIDUFH
RIFRQVXOWLQJWKHRUDFOHKHZRXOGIROORZWKHPWRWKHKLGLQJSODFHRI
WKHJHPVWRZKLFKKHZDVFHUWDLQWKH\ZRXOGJR3HUKDSVWKH\ZRXOG
WDNHRQO\DIHZRIWKHMHZHOVZLWKWKHP+HZRXOGFRQWHQWKLPVHOI
ZLWKWKHUHVW
'UDZQE\DPRUELGIDVFLQDWLRQKHUHHQWHUHGWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHU
DQGVWDUHGGRZQDJDLQDWWKHPRWLRQOHVVILJXUHRIWKHSULQFHVVZKR
ZDVZRUVKLSSHGDVDJRGGHVVHQWUDQFHGE\KHUIULJLGEHDXW\:KDW
FU\SWLFVHFUHWZDVORFNHGLQWKDWPDUYHORXVO\PROGHGIRUP"
+HVWDUWHGYLROHQWO\7KHEUHDWKVXFNHGWKURXJKKLVWHHWKWKH
VKRUWKDLUVSULFNOHGDWWKHEDFNRIKLVVFDOS7KHERG\VWLOOOD\DV
KHKDGILUVWVHHQLWVLOHQWPRWLRQOHVVLQEUHDVWSODWHVRIMHZHOHG
JROGJLOGHGVDQGDOVDQGVLONHQVNLUW%XWQRZWKHUHZDVDVXEWOH
GLIIHUHQFH7KHOLVVRPOLPEVZHUHQRWULJLGDSHDFKEORRPWRXFKHG
WKHFKHHNVWKHOLSVZHUHUHG
:LWKDSDQLFN\FXUVH&RQDQULSSHGRXWKLVVZRUG
B&URP6KH
VDOLYHB
$WKLVZRUGVWKHORQJGDUNODVKHVOLIWHGWKHH\HVRSHQHGDQG
JD]HGXSDWKLPLQVFUXWDEO\GDUNOXVWURXVP\VWLFDO+HJODUHGLQ
IUR]HQVSHHFKOHVVQHVV
6KHVDWXSZLWKDVXSSOHHDVHVWLOOKROGLQJKLVHQVRUFHOOHG
VWDUH
+HOLFNHGKLVGU\OLSVDQGIRXQGYRLFH
<RXDUHDUH\RX<HOD\D"KHVWDPPHUHG
,DP<HOD\D7KHYRLFHZDVULFKDQGPXVLFDODQGKHVWDUHGZLWK
QHZZRQGHU'RQRWIHDU,ZLOOQRWKDUP\RXLI\RXGRP\ELGGLQJ
+RZFDQDGHDGZRPDQFRPHWROLIHDIWHUDOOWKHVHFHQWXULHV"KH
GHPDQGHGDVLIVNHSWLFDORIZKDWKLVVHQVHVWROGKLP$FXULRXV
JOHDPZDVEHJLQQLQJWRVPROGHULQKLVH\HV
6KHOLIWHGKHUDUPVLQDP\VWLFDOJHVWXUH
,DPDJRGGHVV$WKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRWKHUHGHVFHQGHGXSRQPHWKH
FXUVHRIWKHJUHDWHUJRGVWKHJRGVRIGDUNQHVVEH\RQGWKHERUGHUVRI
OLJKW7KHPRUWDOLQPHGLHGWKHJRGGHVVLQPHFRXOGQHYHUGLH+HUH
,KDYHODLQIRUVRPDQ\FHQWXULHVWRDZDNHQHDFKQLJKWDWVXQVHWDQG
KROGP\FRXUWDVRI\RUHZLWKVSHFWHUVGUDZQIURPWKHVKDGRZVRIWKH
SDVW0DQLI\RXZRXOGQRWYLHZWKDWZKLFKZLOOEODVW\RXUVRXOIRU
HYHUJHKHQFHTXLFNO\,FRPPDQG\RX*R7KHYRLFHEHFDPH
LPSHULRXVDQGKHUVOHQGHUDUPOLIWHGDQGSRLQWHG
&RQDQKLVH\HVEXUQLQJVOLWVVORZO\VKHDWKHGKLVVZRUGEXWKH
GLGQRWREH\KHURUGHU+HVWHSSHGFORVHUDVLILPSHOOHGE\D
SRZHUIXOIDVFLQDWLRQZLWKRXWWKHVOLJKWHVWZDUQLQJKHJUDEEHGKHU
XSLQDEHDUOLNHJUDVS6KHVFUHDPHGDYHU\XQJRGGHVVOLNHVFUHDP
DQGWKHUHZDVDVRXQGRIULSSLQJVLONDVZLWKRQHUXWKOHVVZUHQFKKH
WRUHRIIKHUVNLUW
*RGGHVV+D+LVEDUNZDVIXOORIDQJU\FRQWHPSW+HLJQRUHGWKH
IUDQWLFZULWKLQJVRIKLVFDSWLYH,WKRXJKWLWZDVVWUDQJHWKDWD
SULQFHVVRI$ONPHHQRQZRXOGVSHDNZLWKD&RULQWKLDQDFFHQW$VVRRQ
DV,
GJDWKHUHGP\ZLWV,NQHZ,
GVHHQ\RXVRPHZKHUH<RX
UH
0XULHOD=DUJKHED
V&RULQWKLDQGDQFLQJJLUO7KLVFUHVFHQWVKDSHG
ELUWKPDUNRQ\RXUKLSSURYHVLW,VDZLWRQFHZKHQ=DUJKHEDZDV
ZKLSSLQJ\RX*RGGHVV%DK+HVPDFNHGWKHEHWUD\LQJKLS
FRQWHPSWXRXVO\DQGUHVRXQGLQJO\ZLWKKLVRSHQKDQGDQGWKHJLUO
\HOSHGSLWHRXVO\
$OOKHULPSHULRXVQHVVKDGJRQHRXWRIKHU6KHZDVQRORQJHUD
P\VWLFDOILJXUHRIDQWLTXLW\EXWDWHUULILHGDQGKXPLOLDWHGGDQFLQJ
JLUOVXFKDVFDQEHERXJKWDWDOPRVWDQ\6KHPLWLVKPDUNHWSODFH6KH
OLIWHGXSKHUYRLFHDQGZHSWXQDVKDPHGO\+HUFDSWRUJODUHGGRZQDW
KHUZLWKDQJU\WULXPSK
*RGGHVV+D6R\RXZHUHRQHRIWKHYHLOHGZRPHQ=DUJKHEDEURXJKW
WR.HVKLDZLWKKLP'LG\RXWKLQN\RXFRXOGIRROPH\RXOLWWOH
LGLRW"$\HDUDJR,VDZ\RXLQ$NELWDQDZLWKWKDWVZLQH=DUJKHED
DQG,GRQ
WIRUJHWIDFHVRUZRPHQ
VILJXUHV,WKLQN,
OO
6TXLUPLQJDERXWLQKLVJUDVSVKHWKUHZKHUVOHQGHUDUPVDERXWKLV
PDVVLYHQHFNLQDQDEDQGRQRIWHUURUWHDUVFRXUVHGGRZQKHUFKHHNV
DQGKHUVREVTXLYHUHGZLWKDQRWHRIK\VWHULD
2KSOHDVHGRQ
WKXUWPH'RQ
W,KDGWRGRLW=DUJKHEDEURXJKW
PHKHUHWRDFWDVWKHRUDFOH
:K\\RXVDFULOHJLRXVOLWWOHKXVV\UXPEOHG&RQDQ'R\RXQRW
IHDUWKHJRGV"&URP,VWKHUHQRKRQHVW\DQ\ZKHUH"
2KSOHDVHVKHEHJJHGTXLYHULQJZLWKDEMHFWIULJKW,
FRXOGQ
WGLVREH\=DUJKHED2KZKDWVKDOO,GR",VKDOOEHFXUVHGE\
WKHVHKHDWKHQJRGV
:KDWGR\RXWKLQNWKHSULHVWVZLOOGRWR\RXLIWKH\ILQGRXW
\RX
UHDQLPSRVWHU"KHGHPDQGHG
$WWKHWKRXJKWKHUOHJVUHIXVHGWRVXSSRUWKHUDQGVKHFROODSVHG
LQDVKXGGHULQJKHDSFODVSLQJ&RQDQ
VNQHHVDQGPLQJOLQJLQFRKHUHQW
SOHDVIRUPHUF\DQGSURWHFWLRQZLWKSLWHRXVSURWHVWDWLRQVRIKHU
LQQRFHQFHRIDQ\PDOLJQLQWHQWLRQ,WZDVDYLYLGFKDQJHIURPKHU
SRVHDVWKHDQFLHQWSULQFHVVEXWQRWVXUSULVLQJ7KHIHDUWKDWKDG
QHUYHGKHUWKHQZDVQRZKHUXQGRLQJ
:KHUHLV=DUJKHED"KHGHPDQGHG6WRS\DPPHULQJGDPQLWDQG
DQVZHUPH
2XWVLGHWKHSDODFHVKHZKLPSHUHGZDWFKLQJIRUWKHSULHVWV
+RZPDQ\PHQZLWKKLP"
1RQH:HFDPHDORQH
+D,WZDVPXFKOLNHWKHVDWLVILHGJUXQWRIDKXQWLQJOLRQ<RX
PXVWKDYHOHIW.HVKLDDIHZKRXUVDIWHU,GLG'LG\RXFOLPEWKH
FOLIIV"
6KHVKRRNKHUKHDGWRRFKRNHGZLWKWHDUVWRVSHDNFRKHUHQWO\
:LWKDQLPSDWLHQWLPSUHFDWLRQKHVHL]HGKHUVOLPVKRXOGHUVDQGVKRRN
KHUXQWLOVKHJDVSHGIRUEUHDWK
:LOO\RXTXLWWKDWEOXEEHULQJDQGDQVZHUPH"+RZGLG\RXJHWLQWR
WKHYDOOH\"
=DUJKHEDNQHZWKHVHFUHWZD\VKHJDVSHG7KHSULHVW*ZDUXQJD
WROGKLPDQG7KXWPHNUL2QWKHVRXWKVLGHRIWKHYDOOH\WKHUHLVD
EURDGSRROO\LQJDWWKHIRRWRIWKHFOLIIV7KHUHLVDFDYHPRXWK
XQGHUWKHVXUIDFHRIWKHZDWHUWKDWLVQRWYLVLEOHWRWKHFDVXDO
JODQFH:HGXFNHGXQGHUWKHZDWHUDQGHQWHUHGLW7KHFDYHVORSHVXS
RXWRIWKHZDWHUVZLIWO\DQGOHDGVWKURXJKWKHFOLIIV7KHRSHQLQJRQ
WKHVLGHRIWKHYDOOH\LVPDVNHGE\KHDY\WKLFNHWV
,FOLPEHGWKHFOLIIVRQWKHHDVWVLGHKHPXWWHUHG:HOOZKDW
WKHQ"
:HFDPHWRWKHSDODFHDQG=DUJKHEDKLGPHDPRQJWKHWUHHVZKLOH
KHZHQWWRORRNIRUWKHFKDPEHURIWKHRUDFOH,GRQRWWKLQNKH
IXOO\WUXVWHG*ZDUXQJD:KLOHKHZDVJRQH,WKRXJKW,KHDUGDJRQJ
VRXQGEXW,ZDVQRWVXUH3UHVHQWO\=DUJKHEDFDPHDQGWRRNPHLQWR
WKHSDODFHDQGEURXJKWPHWRWKLVFKDPEHUZKHUHWKHJRGGHVV<HOD\D
OD\XSRQWKHGDLV+HVWULSSHGWKHERG\DQGFORWKHGPHLQWKH
JDUPHQWVDQGRUQDPHQWV7KHQKHZHQWIRUWKWRKLGHWKHERG\DQGZDWFK
IRUWKHSULHVWV,KDYHEHHQDIUDLG:KHQ\RXHQWHUHG,ZDQWHGWR
OHDSXSDQGEHJ\RXWRWDNHPHDZD\IURPWKLVSODFHEXW,IHDUHG
=DUJKHED:KHQ\RXGLVFRYHUHG,ZDVDOLYH,WKRXJKW,FRXOGIULJKWHQ
\RXDZD\
:KDWZHUH\RXWRVD\DVWKHRUDFOH"KHDVNHG
,ZDVWRELGWKHSULHVWVWRWDNHWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDQGJLYH
VRPHRIWKHPWR7KXWPHNULDVDSOHGJHDVKHGHVLUHGDQGSODFHWKH
UHVWLQWKHSDODFHDW.HVKLD,ZDVWRWHOOWKHPWKDWDQDZIXOGRRP
WKUHDWHQHG.HVKDQLIWKH\GLGQRWDJUHHWR7KXWPHNUL
VSURSRVDOV
$QGRK\HV,ZDVWRWHOOWKHPWKDW\RXZHUHWREHVNLQQHGDOLYH
LPPHGLDWHO\
7KXWPHNULZDQWHGWKHWUHDVXUHZKHUHKHRUWKH=HPEDEZDQV
FRXOGOD\KDQGRQLWHDVLO\PXWWHUHG&RQDQGLVUHJDUGLQJWKHUHPDUN
FRQFHUQLQJKLPVHOI,
OOFDUYHKLVOLYHU\HW*RUXOJDLVDSDUW\
WRWKLVVZLQGOHRIFRXUVH"
1R+HEHOLHYHVLQKLVJRGVDQGLVLQFRUUXSWLEOH+HNQRZV
QRWKLQJDERXWWKLV+HZLOOREH\WKHRUDFOH,WZDVDOO7KXWPHNUL
V
SODQ.QRZLQJWKH.HVKDQLZRXOGFRQVXOWWKHRUDFOHKHKDG=DUJKHED
EULQJPHZLWKWKHHPEDVV\IURP=HPEDEZHLFORVHO\YHLOHGDQG
VHFOXGHG
:HOO,
PGDPQHGPXWWHUHG&RQDQ$SULHVWZKRKRQHVWO\
EHOLHYHVLQKLVRUDFOHDQGFDQQRWEHEULEHG&URP,ZRQGHULILW
ZDV=DUJKHEDZKREDQJHGWKDWJRQJ'LGKHNQRZ,ZDVKHUH"&RXOGKH
KDYHNQRZQDERXWWKDWURWWHQIODJJLQJ":KHUHLVKHQRZJLUO"
+LGLQJLQDWKLFNHWRIORWXVWUHHVQHDUWKHDQFLHQWDYHQXHWKDW
OHDGVIURPWKHVRXWKZDOORIWKHFOLIIVWRWKHSDODFHVKHDQVZHUHG
7KHQVKHUHQHZHGKHULPSRUWXQLWLHV2K&RQDQKDYHSLW\RQPH,DP
DIUDLGRIWKLVHYLODQFLHQWSODFH,NQRZ,KDYHKHDUGVWHDOWK\
IRRWIDOOVSDGGLQJDERXWPHRK&RQDQWDNHPHDZD\ZLWK\RX
=DUJKHEDZLOONLOOPHZKHQ,KDYHVHUYHGKLVSXUSRVHKHUH,NQRZ
LW7KHSULHVWVWRRZLOONLOOPHLIWKH\GLVFRYHUP\GHFHLW
+HLVDGHYLOKHERXJKWPHIURPDVODYHWUDGHUZKRVWROHPH
RXWRIDFDUDYDQERXQGWKURXJKVRXWKHUQ.RWKDQGKDVPDGHPHWKH
WRRORIKLVLQWULJXHVHYHUVLQFH7DNHPHDZD\IURPKLP<RXFDQQRW
EHDVFUXHODVKH'RQ
WOHDYHPHWREHVODLQKHUH3OHDVH3OHDVH
6KHZDVRQKHUNQHHVFOXWFKLQJDW&RQDQK\VWHULFDOO\KHU
EHDXWLIXOWHDUVWDLQHGIDFHXSWXUQHGWRKLPKHUGDUNVLONHQKDLU
IORZLQJLQGLVRUGHURYHUKHUZKLWHVKRXOGHUV&RQDQSLFNHGKHUXSDQG
VHWKHURQKLVNQHH
/LVWHQWRPH,
OOSURWHFW\RXIURP=DUJKHED7KHSULHVWVVKDOO
QRWNQRZRI\RXUSHUILG\%XW\RX
YHJRWWRGRDV,WHOO\RX
6KHIDOWHUHGSURPLVHVRIH[SOLFLWREHGLHQFHFODVSLQJKLVFRUGHG
QHFNDVLIVHHNLQJVHFXULW\IURPWKHFRQWDFW
*RRG:KHQWKHSULHVWVFRPH\RX
OODFWWKHSDUWRI<HOD\DDV
=DUJKHEDSODQQHGLW
OOEHGDUNDQGLQWKHWRUFKOLJKWWKH\
OO
QHYHUNQRZWKHGLIIHUHQFH%XW\RX
OOVD\WKLVWRWKHP
,WLVWKH
ZLOORIWKHJRGVWKDWWKH6W\JLDQDQGKLV6KHPLWLVKGRJVEHGULYHQ
IURP.HVKDQ7KH\DUHWKLHYHVDQGWUDWLRUVZKRSORWWRUREWKHJRGV
/HWWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUEHSODFHGLQWKHFDUHRIWKHJHQHUDO&RQDQ
/HWKLPOHDGWKHDUPLHVRI.HVKDQ+HLVEHORYHGRIWKHJRGV

6KHVKLYHUHGZLWKDQH[SUHVVLRQRIGHVSHUDWLRQEXWDFTXLHVFHG
%XW=DUJKHED"VKHFULHG+H
OONLOOPH
'RQ
WZRUU\DERXW=DUJKHEDKHJUXQWHG,
OOWDNHFDUHRIWKDW
GRJ<RXGRDV,VD\+HUHSXWXS\RXUKDLUDJDLQ,W
VIDOOHQDOO
RYHU\RXUVKRXOGHUV$QGWKHJHP
VIDOOHQRXWRILW
+HUHSODFHGWKHJUHDWJORZLQJJHPKLPVHOIQRGGLQJDSSURYDO
,W
VZRUWKDURRPIXORIVODYHVLWVHOIDORQH+HUHSXW\RXU
VNLUWEDFNRQ,W
VWRUQGRZQWKHVLGHEXWWKHSULHVWVZLOOQHYHU
QRWLFHLW:LSH\RXUIDFH$JRGGHVVGRHVQ
WFU\OLNHDZKLSSHG
VFKRROJLUO%\&URP\RXBGRBORRNOLNH<HOD\DIDFHKDLUILJXUH
DQGDOO,I\RXDFWWKHJRGGHVVZLWKWKHSULHVWVDVZHOODV\RXGLG
ZLWKPH\RX
OOIRROWKHPHDVLO\
,
OOWU\VKHVKLYHUHG
*RRG,
PJRLQJWRILQG=DUJKHED
$WWKDWVKHEHFDPHSDQLFN\DJDLQ
1R'RQ
WOHDYHPHDORQH7KLVSODFHLVKDXQWHG
7KHUH
VQRWKLQJKHUHWRKDUP\RXKHDVVXUHGKHULPSDWLHQWO\
1RWKLQJEXW=DUJKHEDDQG,
PJRLQJWRORRNDIWHUKLP,
OOEHEDFN
VKRUWO\,
OOEHZDWFKLQJIURPFORVHE\LQFDVHDQ\WKLQJJRHVZURQJ
GXULQJWKHFHUHPRQ\EXWLI\RXSOD\\RXUSDUWSURSHUO\QRWKLQJZLOO
JRZURQJ
$QGWXUQLQJKHKDVWHQHGRXWRIWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUEHKLQGKLP
0XULHODVTXHDNHGZUHWFKHGO\DWKLVJRLQJ
7ZLOLJKWKDGIDOOHQ7KHJUHDWURRPVDQGKDOOVZHUHVKDGRZ\DQG
LQGLVWLQFWFRSSHUIULH]HVJOLQWHGGXOO\WKURXJKWKHGXVN&RQDQ
VWURGHOLNHDVLOHQWSKDQWRPWKURXJKWKHJUHDWKDOOVZLWKD
VHQVDWLRQRIEHLQJVWDUHGDWIURPWKHVKDGRZHGUHFHVVHVE\LQYLVLEOH
JKRVWVRIWKHSDVW1RZRQGHUWKHJLUOZDVQHUYRXVDPLGVXFK
VXUURXQGLQJV
+HJOLGHGGRZQWKHPDUEOHVWHSVOLNHDVOLQNLQJSDQWKHUVZRUGLQ
KDQG6LOHQFHUHLJQHGRYHUWKHYDOOH\DQGDERYHWKHULPRIWKH
FOLIIVVWDUVZHUHEOLQNLQJRXW,IWKHSULHVWVRI.HVKLDKDGHQWHUHG
WKHYDOOH\WKHUHZDVQRWDVRXQGQRWDPRYHPHQWLQWKHJUHHQHU\WR
EHWUD\WKHP+HPDGHRXWWKHDQFLHQWEURNHQSDYHGDYHQXHZDQGHULQJ
DZD\WRWKHVRXWKORVWDPLGFOXVWHULQJPDVVHVRIIURQGVDQGWKLFN
OHDYHGEXVKHV+HIROORZHGLWZDULO\KXJJLQJWKHHGJHRIWKHSDYLQJ
ZKHUHWKHVKUXEVPDVVHGWKHLUVKDGRZVWKLFNO\XQWLOKHVDZDKHDGRI
KLPGLPO\LQWKHGXVNWKHFOXPSRIORWXVWUHHVWKHVWUDQJHJURZWK
SHFXOLDUWRWKHEODFNODQGVRI.XVK7KHUHDFFRUGLQJWRWKHJLUO
=DUJKHEDVKRXOGEHOXUNLQJ&RQDQEHFDPHVWHDOWKSHUVRQLILHG$
YHOYHWIRRWHGVKDGRZKHPHOWHGLQWRWKHWKLFNHWV
+HDSSURDFKHGWKHORWXVJURYHE\DFLUFXLWRXVPRYHPHQWDQG
VFDUFHO\WKHUXVWOHRIDOHDISURFODLPHGKLVSDVVLQJ$WWKHHGJHRI
WKHWUHHVKHKDOWHGVXGGHQO\FURXFKHGOLNHDVXVSLFLRXVSDQWKHU
DPRQJWKHGHHSVKUXEV$KHDGRIKLPDPRQJWKHGHQVHOHDYHVVKRZHGD
SDOOLGRYDOGLPLQWKHXQFHUWDLQOLJKW,WPLJKWKDYHEHHQRQHRI
WKHJUHDWZKLWHEORVVRPVZKLFKVKRQHWKLFNO\DPRQJWKHEUDQFKHV%XW
&RQDQNQHZWKDWLWZDVDPDQ
VIDFH$QGLWZDVWXUQHGWRZDUGKLP+H
VKUDQNTXLFNO\GHHSHULQWRWKHVKDGRZV+DG=DUJKHEDVHHQKLP"7KH
PDQZDVORRNLQJGLUHFWO\WRZDUGKLP6HFRQGVSDVVHG7KHGLPIDFHKDG
QRWPRYHG&RQDQFRXOGPDNHRXWWKHGDUNWXIWEHORZWKDWZDVWKH
VKRUWEODFNEHDUG
$QGVXGGHQO\&RQDQZDVDZDUHRIVRPHWKLQJXQQDWXUDO=DUJKHEDKH
NQHZZDVQRWDWDOOPDQ6WDQGLQJHUHFWKHKHDGZRXOGVFDUFHO\WRS
WKH&LPPHULDQVVKRXOGHUV\HWWKDWIDFHZDVRQDOHYHOZLWK&RQDQ
V
RZQ:DVWKHPDQVWDQGLQJRQVRPHWKLQJ"&RQDQEHQWDQGSHHUHGWRZDUG
WKHJURXQGEHORZWKHVSRWZKHUHWKHIDFHVKRZHGEXWKLVYLVLRQZDV
EORFNHGE\XQGHUJURZWKDQGWKHWKLFNEROHVRIWKHWUHHV%XWKHVDZ
VRPHWKLQJHOVHDQGKHVWLIIHQHG7KURXJKDVORWLQWKHXQGHUEUXVKKH
JOLPSVHGWKHVWHPRIWKHWUHHXQGHUZKLFKDSSDUHQWO\=DUJKHEDZDV
VWDQGLQJ7KHIDFHZDVGLUHFWO\LQOLQHZLWKWKDWWUHH+HVKRXOG
KDYHVHHQEHORZWKDWIDFHQRWWKHWUHHWUXQNEXW=DUJKHED
VERG\
EXWWKHUHZDVQRERG\WKHUH
6XGGHQO\WHQVHUWKDQDWLJHUZKRVWDONVKLVSUH\&RQDQJOLGHG
GHHSHULQWRWKHWKLFNHWDQGDPRPHQWODWHUGUHZDVLGHDOHDI\EUDQFK
DQGJODUHGDWWKHIDFHWKDWKDGQRWPRYHG1RUZRXOGLWHYHUPRYH
DJDLQRILWVRZQYROLWLRQ+HORRNHGRQ=DUJKHED
VVHYHUHGKHDG
VXVSHQGHGIURPWKHEUDQFKRIWKHWUHHE\LWVRZQORQJEODFNKDLU
7KH5HWXUQRIWKH2UDFOH

&RQDQZKHHOHGVXSSOHO\VZHHSLQJWKHVKDGRZVZLWKDILHUFHO\
TXHVWLQJVWDUH7KHUHZDVQRVLJQRIWKHPXUGHUHGPDQ
VERG\RQO\
\RQGHUWKHWDOOOXVKJUDVVZDVWUDPSOHGDQGEURNHQGRZQDQGWKHVZDUG
ZDVGDEEOHGGDUNO\DQGZHWO\&RQDQVWRRGVFDUFHO\EUHDWKLQJDVKH
VWUDLQHGKLVHDUVLQWRWKHVLOHQFH7KHWUHHVDQGEXVKHVZLWKWKHLU
JUHDWSDOOLGEORVVRPVVWRRGGDUNVWLOODQGVLQLVWHUHWFKHGDJDLQVW
WKHGHHSHQLQJGXVN
3ULPLWLYHIHDUVZKLVSHUHGDWWKHEDFNRI&RQDQ
VPLQG:DVWKLV
WKHZRUNRIWKHSULHVWVRI.HVKDQ",IVRZKHUHZHUHWKH\":DVLW
=DUJKHEDDIWHUDOOZKRKDGVWUXFNWKHJRQJ"$JDLQWKHUHURVHWKH
PHPRU\RI%LW<DNLQDQGKLVP\VWHULRXVVHUYDQWV%LW<DNLQZDVGHDG
VKULYHOHGWRDKXONRIZULQNOHGOHDWKHUDQGERXQGLQKLVKROORZHG
FU\SWWRJUHHWWKHULVLQJVXQIRUHYHU%XWWKHVHUYDQWVRI%LW<DNLQ
ZHUHXQDFFRXQWHGIRUB7KHUHZDVQRSURRIWKH\KDGHYHUOHIWWKH
YDOOH\B
&RQDQWKRXJKWRIWKHJLUO0XULHODDORQHDQGXQJXDUGHGLQWKDW
JUHDWVKDGRZ\SDODFH+HZKHHOHGDQGUDQEDFNGRZQWKHVKDGRZHG
DYHQXHDQGKHUDQDVDVXVSLFLRXVSDQWKHUUXQVSRLVHGHYHQLQIXOO
VWULGHWRZKLUOULJKWRUOHIWDQGVWULNHGHDWKEORZV
7KHSDODFHORRPHGWKURXJKWKHWUHHVDQGKHVDZVRPHWKLQJHOVH
WKHJORZRIILUHUHIOHFWLQJUHGO\IURPWKHSROLVKHGPDUEOH+HPHOWHG
LQWRWKHEXVKHVWKDWOLQHGWKHEURNHQVWUHHWJOLGHGWKURXJKWKH
GHQVHJURZWKDQGUHDFKHGWKHHGJHRIWKHRSHQVSDFHEHIRUHWKH
SRUWLFR9RLFHVUHDFKHGKLPWRUFKHVEREEHGDQGWKHLUIODUHVKRQHRQ
JORVV\HERQVKRXOGHUV7KHSULHVWVRI.HVKDQKDGFRPH
7KH\KDGQRWDGYDQFHGXSWKHZLGHRYHUJURZQDYHQXHDV=DUJKHED
KDGH[SHFWHGWKHPWRGR2EYLRXVO\WKHUHZDVPRUHWKDQRQHVHFUHWZD\
LQWRWKHYDOOH\RI$ONPHHQRQ
7KH\ZHUHILOLQJXSWKHEURDGPDUEOHVWHSVKROGLQJWKHLUWRUFKHV
KLJK+HVDZ*RUXOJDDWWKHKHDGRIWKHSDUDGHDSURILOHFKLVHOHG
RXWRIFRSSHUHWFKHGLQWKHWRUFKJODUH7KHUHVWZHUHDFRO\WHV
JLDQWEODFNPHQIURPZKRVHVNLQVWKHWRUFKHVVWUXFNKLJKOLJKWV$W
WKHHQGRIWKHSURFHVVLRQWKHUHVWDONHGDKXJH1HJURZLWKDQ
XQXVXDOO\ZLFNHGFDVWRIFRXQWHQDQFHDWWKHVLJKWRIZKRP&RQDQ
VFRZOHG7KDWZDV*ZDUXQJDZKRP0XULHODKDGQDPHGDVWKHPDQZKRKDG
UHYHDOHGWKHVHFUHWRIWKHSRROHQWUDQFHWR=DUJKHED&RQDQZRQGHUHG
KRZGHHSO\WKHPDQZDVLQWKHLQWULJXHVRIWKH6W\JLDQ
+HKXUULHGWRZDUGWKHSRUWLFRFLUFOLQJWKHRSHQVSDFHWRNHHSLQ
WKHIULQJLQJVKDGRZV7KH\OHIWQRRQHWRJXDUGWKHHQWUDQFH7KH
WRUFKHVVWUHDPHGVWHDGLO\GRZQWKHORQJGDUNKDOO%HIRUHWKH\
UHDFKHGWKHGRXEOHYDOYHGGRRUDWWKHRWKHUHQG&RQDQKDGPRXQWHG
WKHRXWHUVWHSVDQGZDVLQWKHKDOOEHKLQGWKHP6OLQNLQJVZLIWO\
DORQJWKHFROXPQOLQHGZDOOKHUHDFKHGWKHJUHDWGRRUDVWKH\
FURVVHGWKHKXJHWKURQHURRPWKHLUWRUFKHVGULYLQJEDFNWKHVKDGRZV
7KH\GLGQRWORRNEDFN,QVLQJOHILOHWKHLURVWULFKSOXPHVQRGGLQJ
WKHLUOHRSDUGVNLQWXQLFVFRQWUDVWLQJFXULRXVO\ZLWKWKHPDUEOHDQG
DUDEHVTXHGPHWDORIWKHDQFLHQWSDODFHWKH\PRYHGDFURVVWKHZLGH
URRPDQGKDOWHGPRPHQWDULO\DWWKHJROGHQGRRUWRWKHOHIWRIWKH
WKURQHGDLV
*RUOXJD
VYRLFHERRPHGHHULO\DQGKROORZO\LQWKHJUHDWHPSW\
VSDFHIUDPHGLQVRQRURXVSKUDVHVXQLQWHOOLJLEOHWRWKHOXUNLQJ
OLVWHQHUWKHQWKHKLJKSULHVWWKUXVWRSHQWKHJROGHQGRRUDQG
HQWHUHGERZLQJUHSHDWHGO\IURPWKHZDLVWDQGEHKLQGKLPWKHWRUFKHV
VDQNDQGURVHVKRZHULQJIODNHVRIIODPHDVWKHZRUVKLSSHUVLPLWDWHG
WKHLUPDVWHU7KHJROGGRRUFORVHGEHKLQGWKHPVKXWWLQJRXWVRXQG
DQGVLJKWDQG&RQDQGDUWHGDFURVVWKHWKURQHFKDPEHUDQGLQWRWKH
DOFRYHEHKLQGWKHWKURQH+HPDGHOHVVVRXQGWKDQDZLQGEORZLQJ
DFURVVWKHFKDPEHU
7LQ\EHDPVRIOLJKWVWUHDPHGWKURXJKWKHDSHUWXUHVLQWKHZDOODV
KHSULHGRSHQWKHVHFUHWSDQHO*OLGLQJLQWRWKHQLFKHKHSHHUHG
WKURXJK0XULHODVDWXSULJKWRQWKHGDLVKHUDUPVIROGHGKHUKHDG
OHDQLQJEDFNDJDLQVWWKHZDOOZLWKLQDIHZLQFKHVRIKLVH\HV7KH
GHOLFDWHSHUIXPHRIKHUIRDP\KDLUZDVLQKLVQRVWULOV+HFRXOGQRW
VHHKHUIDFHRIFRXUVHEXWKHUDWWLWXGHZDVDVLIVKHJD]HG
WUDQTXLOO\LQWRVRPHIDUJXOIRIVSDFHRYHUDQGEH\RQGWKHVKDYHQ
KHDGVRIWKHEODFNJLDQWVZKRNQHOWEHIRUHKHU&RQDQJULQQHGZLWK
DSSUHFLDWLRQ7KHOLWWOHVOXW
VDQDFWUHVVKHWROGKLPVHOI+H
NQHZVKHZDVVKULYHOLQJZLWKWHUURUEXWVKHVKRZHGQRVLJQ,QWKH
XQFHUWDLQIODUHRIWKHWRUFKHVVKHORRNHGH[DFWO\OLNHWKHJRGGHVVKH
KDGVHHQO\LQJRQWKDWVDPHGDLVLIRQHFRXOGLPDJLQHWKDWJRGGHVV
LPEXHGZLWKYLEUDQWOLIH
*RUXOJDZDVERRPLQJIRUWKVRPHNLQGRIDFKDQWLQDQDFFHQW
XQIDPLOLDUWR&RQDQDQGZKLFKZDVSUREDEO\VRPHLQYRFDWLRQLQWKH
DQFLHQWWRQJXHRI$ONPHHQRQKDQGHGGRZQIURPJHQHUDWLRQWR
JHQHUDWLRQRIKLJKSULHVWV,WVHHPHGLQWHUPLQDEOH&RQDQJUHZ
UHVWOHVV7KHORQJHUWKHWKLQJODVWHGWKHPRUHWHUULILFZRXOGEHWKH
VWUDLQRQ0XULHOD,IVKHVQDSSHGKHKLWFKHGKLVVZRUGDQGGDJJHU
IRUZDUG+HFRXOGQRWVHHWKHOLWWOHWUROORSWRUWXUHGDQGVODLQE\
EODFNPHQ
%XWWKHFKDQWGHHSORZSLWFKHGDQGLQGHVFULEDEO\RPLQRXV
FDPHWRDFRQFOXVLRQDWODVWDQGDVKRXWHGDFFODLPIURPWKHDFRO\WHV
PDUNHGLWVSHULRG/LIWLQJKLVKHDGDQGUDLVLQJKLVDUPVWRZDUGWKH
VLOHQWIRUPRQWKHGDLV*RUXOJDFULHGLQWKHGHHSULFKUHVRQDQFH
WKDWZDVWKHQDWXUDODWWULEXWHRIWKH.HVKDQLSULHVW2JUHDW
JRGGHVVGZHOOHUZLWKWKHJUHDWRQHRIGDUNQHVVOHWWK\KHDUWEH
PHOWHGWK\OLSVRSHQHGIRUWKHHDUVRIWK\VODYHZKRVHKHDGLVLQ
WKHGXVWEHQHDWKWK\IHHW6SHDNJUHDWJRGGHVVRIWKHKRO\YDOOH\
7KRXNQRZHVWWKHSDWKVEHIRUHXVWKHGDUNQHVVWKDWYH[HVXVLVDV
WKHOLJKWRIWKHPLGGD\VXQWRWKHH6KHGWKHUDGLDQFHRIWK\ZLVGRP
RQWKHSDWKVRIWK\VHUYDQWV7HOOXV2PRXWKSLHFHRIWKHJRGVZKDW
LVWKHLUZLOOFRQFHUQLQJ7KXWPHNULWKH6W\JLDQ"
7KHKLJKSLOHGEXUQLVKHGPDVVRIKDLUWKDWFDXJKWWKHWRUFKOLJKW
LQGXOOEURQ]HJOHDPVTXLYHUHGVOLJKWO\$JXVW\VLJKURVHIURPWKH
EODFNVKDOILQDZHKDOILQIHDU0XULHOD
VYRLFHFDPHSODLQO\WR
&RQDQ
VHDUVLQWKHEUHDWKOHVVVLOHQFHDQGLWVHHPHGFROGGHWDFKHG
LPSUHVRQDOWKRXJKKHZLQFHGDWWKH&RULQWKLDQDFFHQW
,WLVWKHZLOORIWKHJRGVWKDWWKH6W\JLDQDQGKLV6KHPLWLVK
GRJVEHGULYHQIURP.HVKDQ6KHZDVUHSHDWLQJKLVH[DFWZRUGV7KH\
DUHWKLHYHVDQGWUDLWRUVZKRSORWWRUREWKHJRGV/HWWKH7HHWKRI
*ZDKOXUEHSODFHGLQWKHFDUHRIWKHJHQHUDO&RQDQ/HWKLPOHDGWKH
DUPLHVRI.HVKDQ+HLVEHORYHGRIWKHJRGV
7KHUHZDVDTXLYHULQKHUYRLFHDVVKHHQGHGDQG&RQDQEHJDQWR
VZHDWEHOLHYLQJVKHZDVRQWKHSRLQWRIDQK\VWHULFDOFROODSVH%XW
WKHEODFNVGLGQRWQRWLFHDQ\PRUHWKDQWKH\LGHQWLILHGWKH
&RULQWKLDQDFFHQWRIZKLFKWKH\NQHZQRWKLQJ7KH\VPRWHWKHLUSDOPV
VRIWO\WRJHWKHUDQGDPXUPXURIZRQGHUDQGDZHURVHIURPWKHP
*RUXOJD
VH\HVJOLWWHUHGIDQDWLFDOO\LQWKHWRUFKOLJKW
<HOD\DKDVVSRNHQKHFULHGLQDQH[DOWHGYRLFH,WLVWKHZLOO
RIWKHJRGV/RQJDJRLQWKHGD\VRIRXUDQFHVWRUVWKH\ZHUHPDGH
WDERRDQGKLGGHQDWWKHFRPPDQGRIWKHJRGVZKRZUHQFKHGWKHPIURP
WKHDZIXOMDZVRI*ZDKOXUWKHNLQJRIGDUNQHVVLQWKHELUWKRIWKH
ZRUOG$WWKHFRPPDQGRIWKHJRGVWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUZHUHKLGGHQ
DWWKHLUFRPPDQGWKH\VKDOOEHEURXJKWIRUWKDJDLQ2VWDUERUQ
JRGGHVVJLYHXV\RXUOHDYHWRJRWRWKHVHFUHWKLGLQJSODFHRIWKH
7HHWKWRVHFXUHWKHPIRUKLPZKRPWKHJRGVORYH
<RXKDYHP\OHDYHWRJRDQVZHUHGWKHIDOVHJRGGHVVZLWKDQ
LPSHULRXVJHVWXUHRIGLVPLVVDOWKDWVHW&RQDQJULQQLQJDJDLQDQGWKH
SULHVWVEDFNHGRXWRVWULFKSOXPHVDQGWRUFKHVULVLQJDQGIDOOLQJ
ZLWKWKHUK\WKPRIWKHLUJHQXIOH[LRQV
7KHJROGGRRUFORVHGDQGZLWKDPRDQWKHJRGGHVVIHOOEDFNOLPSO\
RQWKHGDLV&RQDQVKHZKLPSHUHGIDLQWO\&RQDQ
6KKKKHKLVVHGWKURXJKWKHDSHUWXUHVDQGWXUQLQJJOLGHGIURP
WKHQLFKHDQGFORVHGWKHSDQHO$JOLPSVHSDVWWKHMDPERIWKHFDUYHQ
GRRUVKRZHGKLPWKHWRUFKHVUHFHGLQJDFURVVWKHJUHDWWKURQHURRP
EXWKHZDVDWWKHVDPHWLPHDZDUHRIDUDGLDQFHWKDWGLGQRWHPDQDWH
IURPWKHWRUFKHV+HZDVVWDUWOHGEXWWKHVROXWLRQSUHVHQWHGLWVHOI
LQVWDQWO\$QHDUO\PRRQKDGULVHQDQGLWVOLJKWVODQWHGWKURXJKWKH
SLHUFHGGRPHZKLFKE\VRPHFXULRXVZRUNPDQVKLSLQWHQVLILHGWKHOLJKW
7KHVKLQLQJGRPHRI$ONPHHQRQZDVQRIDEOHWKHQ3HUKDSVLWV
LQWHULRUZDVRIWKHFXULRXVZKLWHO\IODPLQJFU\VWDOIRXQGRQO\LQWKH
KLOOVRIWKHEODFNFRXQWULHV7KHOLJKWIORRGHGWKHWKURQHURRPDQG
VHHSHGLQWRWKHFKDPEHUVLPPHGLDWHO\DGMRLQLQJ
%XWDV&RQDQPDGHWRZDUGWKHGRRUWKDWOHGLQWRWKHWKURQHURRP
KHZDVEURXJKWDURXQGVXGGHQO\E\DQRLVHWKDWVHHPHGWRHPDQDWHIURP
WKHSDVVDJHWKDWOHGRIIIURPWKHDOFRYH+HFURXFKHGDWWKHPRXWK
VWDULQJLQWRLWUHPHPEHULQJWKHFODQJRURIWKHJRQJWKDWKDGHFKRHG
IURPLWWROXUHKLPLQWRDVQDUH7KHOLJKWIURPWKHGRPHILOWHUHG
RQO\DOLWWOHZD\LQWRWKDWQDUURZFRUULGRUDQGVKRZHGKLPRQO\
HPSW\VSDFH<HWKHFRXOGKDYHVZRUQWKDWKHKDGKHDUGWKHIXUWLYH
SDGRIDIRRWVRPHZKHUHGRZQLW
:KLOHKHKHVLWDWHGKHZDVHOHFWULILHGE\DZRPDQ
VVWUDQJOHGFU\
IURPEHKLQGKLP%RXQGLQJWKURXJKWKHGRRUEHKLQGWKHWKURQHKHVDZ
DQXQH[SHFWHGVSHFWDFOHLQWKHFU\VWDOOLJKW
7KHWRUFKHVRIWKHSULHVWVKDGYDQLVKHGIURPWKHJUHDWKDOO
RXWVLGHEXWRQHSULHVWZDVVWLOOLQWKHSDODFH*ZDUXQJD+LV
ZLFNHGIHDWXUHVZHUHFRQYXOVHGZLWKIXU\DQGKHJUDVSHGWKH
WHUULILHG0XULHODE\WKHWKURDWFKRNLQJKHUHIIRUWVWRVFUHDPDQG
SOHDGVKDNLQJKHUEUXWDOO\
7UDLWUHVV%HWZHHQKLVWKLFNUHGOLSVKLVYRLFHKLVVHGOLNHD
FREUD:KDWJDPHDUH\RXSOD\LQJ"'LGQRW=DUJKHEDWHOO\RXZKDWWR
VD\"$\H7KXWPHNULWROGPH$UH\RXEHWUD\LQJ\RXUPDVWHURULVKH
EHWUD\LQJKLVIULHQGVWKURXJK\RX"6OXW,
OOWZLVWRII\RXUIDOVH
KHDGEXWILUVW,
OO
$ZLGHQLQJRIKLVFDSWLYH
VORYHO\H\HVDVVKHVWDUHGRYHUKLV
VKRXOGHUZDUQHGWKHKXJHEODFN+HUHOHDVHGKHUDQGZKHHOHGMXVWDV
&RQDQ
VVZRUGODVKHGGRZQ7KHLPSDFWRIWKHVWURNHNQRFNHGKLP
KHDGORQJEDFNZDUGWRWKHPDUEOHIORRUZKHUHKHOD\WZLWFKLQJEORRG
RR]LQJIURPDUDJJHGJDVKLQKLVVFDOS
&RQDQVWDUWHGWRZDUGKLPWRILQLVKWKHMREIRUKHNQHZWKDWWKH
EODFN
VVXGGHQPRYHPHQWKDGFDXVHGWKHEODGHWRVWULNHIODWEXW
0XULHODWKUHZKHUDUPVFRQYXOVLYHO\DERXWKLP
,
YHGRQHDV\RXRUGHUHGVKHJDVSHGK\VWHULFDOO\7DNHPH
DZD\2KSOHDVHWDNHPHDZD\
:HFDQ
WJR\HWKHJUXQWHG,ZDQWWRIROORZWKHSULHVWVDQG
VHHZKHUHWKH\JHWWKHMHZHOV7KHUHPD\EHPRUHORRWKLGGHQWKHUH
%XW\RXFDQJRZLWKPH:KHUH
VWKDWJHP\RXZRUHLQ\RXUKDLU"
,WPXVWKDYHIDOOHQRXWRQWKHGDLVVKHVWDPPHUHGIHHOLQJIRU
LW,ZDVVRIULJKWHQHGZKHQWKHSULHVWVOHIW,UDQRXWWRILQG
\RXDQGWKLVELJEUXWHKDGVWD\HGEHKLQGDQGKHJUDEEHGPH
:HOOJRJHWLWZKLOH,GLVSRVHRIWKLVFDUFDVVKHFRPPDQGHG
*RRQ7KDWJHPLVZRUWKDIRUWXQHLWVHOI
6KHKHVLWDWHGDVLIORWKWRUHWXUQWRWKDWFU\SWLFFKDPEHUWKHQ
DVKHJUDVSHG*ZDUXQJD
VJLUGOHDQGGUDJJHGKLPLQWRWKHDOFRYHVKH
WXUQHGDQGHQWHUHGWKHRUDFOHURRP
&RQDQGXPSHGWKHVHQVHOHVVEODFNRQWKHIORRUDQGOLIWHGKLV
VZRUG7KH&LPPHULDQKDGOLYHGWRRORQJLQWKHZLOGSODFHVRIWKH
ZRUOGWRKDYHDQ\LOOXVLRQVDERXWPHUF\7KHRQO\VDIHHQHP\ZDVD
KHDGOHVVHQHP\%XWEHIRUHKHFRXOGVWULNHDVWDUWOLQJVFUHDP
FKHFNHGWKHOLIWHGEODGH,WFDPHIURPWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHU
&RQDQ&RQDQB6KH
VFRPHEDFNB7KHVKULHNHQGHGLQDJXUJOH
DQGDVFUDSLQJVKXIIOH
:LWKDQRDWK&RQDQGDVKHGRXWRIWKHDOFRYHDFURVVWKHWKURQH
GDLVDQGLQWRWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUDOPRVWEHIRUHWKHVRXQGKDGFHDVHG
7KHUHKHKDOWHGJODULQJEHZLOGHUHGO\7RDOODSSHDUDQFHV0XULHODOD\
SODFLGO\RQWKHGDLVH\HVFORVHGDVLILQVOXPEHU
:KDWLQWKXQGHUDUH\RXGRLQJ"KHGHPDQGHGDFLGO\,VWKLVDQ\
WLPHWREHSOD\LQJMRNHV
+LVYRLFHWUDLOHGDZD\+LVJD]HUDQDORQJWKHLYRU\WKLJKPROGHG
LQWKHFORVHILWWLQJVLONVNLUW7KDWVNLUWVKRXOGJDSHIURPJLUGOH
WRKHP+HNQHZEHFDXVHLWKDGEHHQKLVRZQKDQGWKDWWRUHLWDVKH
UXWKOHVVO\VWULSSHGWKHJDUPHQWIURPWKHGDQFHU
VZULWKLQJERG\%XW
WKHVNLUWVKRZHGQRUHQW$VLQJOHVWULGHEURXJKWKLPWRWKHGDLVDQG
KHODLGKLVKDQGRQWKHLYRU\ERG\VQDWFKHGLWDZD\DVLILWKDG
HQFRXQWHUHGKRWLURQLQVWHDGRIWKHFROGLPPRELOLW\RIGHDWK
&URPKHPXWWHUHGKLVH\HVVXGGHQO\VOLWVRIEDOHILUH,W
V
QRW0XULHOD,W
V<HOD\D
+HXQGHUVWRRGQRZWKDWIUDQWLFVFUHDPWKDWKDGEXUVWIURP
0XULHOD
VOLSVZKHQVKHHQWHUHGWKHFKDPEHU7KHJRGGHVVKDG
UHWXUQHG7KHERG\KDGEHHQVWULSSHGE\=DUJKHEDWRIXUQLVKWKH
DFFRXWHUPHQWVIRUWKHSUHWHQGHU<HWQRZLWZDVFODGLQVLONDQG
MHZHOVDV&RQDQKDGILUVWVHHQLW$SHFXOLDUSULFNOLQJPDGHLWVHOI
PDQLIHVWDPRQJWKHVRUWKDLUVDWWKHEDVHRI&RQDQ
VVFDOS
0XULHODKHVKRXWHGVXGGHQO\B0XULHODB:KHUHWKHGHYLODUH
\RX"
7KHZDOOVWKUHZEDFNKLVYRLFHPRFNLQJO\7KHUHZDVQRHQWUDQFH
WKDWKHFRXOGVHHH[FHSWWKHJROGHQGRRUDQGQRQHFRXOGKDYHHQWHUHG
RUGHSDUWHGWKURXJKWKDWZLWKRXWKLVNQRZOHGJH7KLVPXFKZDV
LQGLVSXWDEOH<HOD\DKDGEHHQUHSODFHGRQWKHGDLVZLWKLQWKHIHZ
PLQXWHVWKDWKDGHODSVHGVLQFH0XULHODKDGILUVWOHIWWKHFKDPEHUWR
EHVHL]HGE\*ZDUXQJDKLVHDUVZHUHVWLOOWLQJOLQJZLWKWKHHFKRHV
RI0XULHOD
VVFUHDP\HWWKH&RULQWKLDQJLUOKDGYDQLVKHGDVLILQWR
WKLQDLU7KHUHZDVEXWRQHH[SODQDWLRQLIKHUHMHFWHGWKHGDUNHU
VSHFXODWLRQWKDWVXJJHVWHGWKHVXSHUQDWXUDOVRPHZKHUHLQWKH
FKDPEHUWKHUHZDVDVHFUHWGRRU$QGHYHQDVWKHWKRXJKWFURVVHGKLV
PLQGKHVDZLW
,QZKDWKDGVHHPHGDFXUWDLQRIVROLGPDUEOHDWKLQSHUSHQGLFXODU
FUDFNVKRZHGDQGLQWKHFUDFNKXQJDZLVSRIVLON,QDQLQVWDQWKH
ZDVEHQGLQJRYHULW7KDWVKUHGZDVIURP0XULHOD
VWRUQVNLUW7KH
LPSOLFDWLRQZDVXQPLVWDNDEOH,WKDGEHHQFDXJKWLQWKHFORVLQJGRRU
DQGWRUQRIIDVVKHZDVERUQHWKURXJKWKHRSHQLQJE\ZKDWHYHUJULP
EHLQJVZHUHKHUFDSWRUV7KHELWRIFORWKLQJKDGSUHYHQWHGWKHGRRU
IURPILWWLQJSHUIHFWO\LQWRLWVIUDPH
7KUXVWLQJKLVGDJJHUSRLQWLQWRWKHFUDFN&RQDQH[HUWHGOHYHUDJH
ZLWKDFRUGHGIRUHDUP7KHEODGHEHQWEXWLWZDVRIXQEUHDNDEOH
$NELWDQDQVWHHO7KHPDUEOHGRRURSHQHG&RQDQ
VVZRUGZDVOLIWHGDV
KHSHHUHGLQWRWKHDSHUWXUHEH\RQGEXWKHVDZQRVKDSHRIPHQDFH
/LJKWILOWHULQJLQWRWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUUHYHDOHGDVKRUWIOLJKWRI
VWHSVFXWRXWRIPDUEOH3XOOLQJWKHGRRUEDFNWRLWVIXOOHVWH[WHQW
KHGURYHKLVGDJJHULQWRDFUDFNLQWKHIORRUSURSLQJLWRSHQ7KHQ
KHZHQWGRZQWKHVWHSVZLWKRXWKHVLWDWLRQ+HVDZQRWKLQJKHDUG
QRWKLQJ$GR]HQVWHSVGRZQWKHVWDLUHQGHGLQDQDUURZFRUULGRU
ZKLFKUDQVWUDLJKWDZD\LQWRJORRP
+HKDOWHGVXGGHQO\SRVHGOLNHDVWDWXHDWWKHIRRWRIWKHVWDLU
VWDULQJDWWKHSDLQWLQJVZKLFKIUHVFRHGWKHZDOOVKDOIYLVLEOHLQ
WKHGLPOLJKWZKLFKILOWHUHGGRZQIURPDERYH7KHDUWZDV
XQPLVWDNDEO\3HOLVKWLKHKDGVHHQIUHVFRHVRILGHQWLFDO
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVRQWKHZDOOVRI$VJDOXQ%XWWKHVFHQHVGHSLFWHGKDG
QRFRQQHFWLRQZLWKDQ\WKLQJ3HOLVKWLH[FHSWIRURQHKXPDQILJXUH
IUHTXHQWO\UHFXUUHQWDOHDQZKLWHEHDUGHGROGPDQZKRVHUDFLDO
FKDUDFWHULVWLFVZHUHXQPLVWDNDEOH7KH\VHHPHGWRUHSUHVHQWYDULRXV
VHFWLRQVRIWKHSDODFHDERYH6HYHUDOVFHQHVVKRZHGDFKDPEHUKH
UHFRJQL]HGDVWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUZLWKWKHILJXUHRI<HOD\DVWUHWFKHG
XSRQWKHLYRU\GDLVDQGKXJHEODFNPHQNQHHOLQJEHIRUHLW$QGWKHUH
EHKLQGWKHZDOOLQWKHQLFKHOXUNHGWKHDQFLHQW3HOLVKWL$QGWKHUH
ZHUHRWKHUILJXUHVWRRILJXUHVWKDWPRYHGWKURXJKWKHGHVHUWHG
SDODFHGLGWKHELGGLQJRIWKH3HOLVKWLDQGGUDJJHGXQQDPDEOHWKLQJV
RXWRIWKHVXEWHUUDQHDQULYHU,QWKHIHZVHFRQGV&RQDQVWRRGIUR]HQ
KLWKHUWRXQLQWHOOLJLEOHSKUDVHVLQWKHSDUFKPHQWPDQXVFULSWEOD]HGLQ
KLVEUDLQZLWKFKLOOLQJFODULW\7KHORRVHELWVRIWKHSDWHUQFOLFNHG
LQWRSODFH7KHP\VWHU\RI%LW<DNLQZDVDP\VWHU\QRORQJHUQRUWKH
ULGGOHRI%LW<DNLQ
VVHUYDQWV
&RQDQWXUQHGDQGSHHUHGLQWRWKHGDUNQHVVDQLF\ILQJHUFUDZOLQJ
DORQJKLVVSLQH7KHQKHZHQWDORQJWKHFRUULGRUFDWIRRWHGDQG
ZLWKRXWKHVLWDWLRQPRYLQJGHHSHUDQGGHHSHULQWRWKHGDUNQHVVDVKH
GUHZIDUWKHUDZD\IURPWKHVWDLU7KHDLUKXQJKHDY\ZLWKWKHRGRUKH
KDGVFHQWHGLQWKHFRXUWRIWKHJRQJ
1RZLQXWWHUEODFNQHVVKHKHDUGDVRXQGDKHDGRIKLPWKH
VKXIIOHRIEDUHIHHWRUWKHVZLVKRIORRVHJDUPHQWVDJDLQVWVWRQH
KHFRXOGQRWWHOOZKLFK%XWDQLQVWDQWODWHUKLVRXWVWUHWFKHGKDQG
HQFRXQWHUHGDEDUULHUZKLFKKHLGHQWLILHGDVDPDVVLYHGRRURIFDUYHG
PHWDO+HSXVKHGDJDLQVWLWIUXLWOHVVO\DQGKLVVZRUGSRLQWVRXJKW
YDLQO\IRUDFUDFN,WILWWHGLQWRWKHVLOODQGMDPEVDVLIPROGHG
WKHUH+HH[HUWHGDOOKLVVWUHQJWKKLVIHHWVWUDLQLQJDJDLQVWWKH
IORRUWKHYHLQVNQRWWLQJLQKLVWHPSOHV,WZDVXVHOHVVDFKDUJHRI
HOHSKDQWVZRXOGVFDUFHO\KDYHVKDNHQWKDWWLWDQLFSRUWDO
$VKHOHDQHGWKHUHKHFDXJKWDVRXQGRQWKHRWKHUVLGHWKDWKLV
HDUVLQVWDQWO\LGHQWLILHGLWZDVWKHFUHDNRIUXVW\LURQOLNHD
OHYHUVFUDSLQJLQLWVVORW,QVWLQFWLYHO\DFWLRQIROORZHGUHFRJQLWLRQ
VRVSRQWDQHRXVO\WKDWVRXQGLPSXOVHDQGDFWLRQZHUHSUDFWLFDOO\
VLPXOWDQHRXV$QGDVKLVSURGLJLRXVERXQGFDUULHGKLPEDFNZDUGWKHUH
ZDVWKHUXVKRIDJUHDWEXONIURPDERYHDQGDWKXQGHURXVFUDVK
ILOOHGWKHWXQQHOZLWKGHDIHQLQJYLEUDWLRQV%LWVRIIO\LQJVSOLQWHUV
VWUXFNKLPDKXJHEORFNRIVWRQHKHNQHZIURPWKHVRXQGGURSSHG
RQWKHVSRWKHKDGMXVWTXLWWHG$QLQVWDQW
VVORZHUWKRXJKWRU
DFWLRQDQGLWZRXOGKDYHFUXVKHGKLPOLNHDQDQW
&RQDQIHOOEDFN6RPHZKHUHRQWKHRWKHUVLGHRIWKDWPHWDOGRRU
0XULHODZDVDFDSWLYHLIVKHVWLOOOLYHG%XWKHFRXOGQRWSDVVWKDW
GRRUDQGLIKHUHPDLQHGLQWKHWXQQHODQRWKHUEORFNPLJKWIDOODQG
KHPLJKWQRWEHVROXFN\,WZRXOGGRWKHJLUOQRJRRGIRUKLPWREH
FUXVKHGLQWRDSXUSOHSXOS+HFRXOGQRWFRQWLQXHKLVVHDUFKLQWKDW
GLUHFWLRQ+HPXVWJHWDERYHJURXQGDQGORRNIRUVRPHRWKHUDYHQXHRI
DSSURDFK
+HWXUQHGDQGKXUULHGWRZDUGWKHVWDLUVLJKLQJDVKHHPHUJHGLQWR
FRPSDUDWLYHUDGLDQFH$QGDVKHVHWIRRWRQWKHILUVWVWHSWKHOLJKW
ZDVEORWWHGRXWDQGDERYHKLPWKHPDUEOHGRRUUXVKHGVKXWZLWKD
UHVRXQGLQJUHYHUEHUDWLRQ
6RPHWKLQJOLNHSDQLFVHL]HGWKH&LPPHULDQWKHQWUDSSHGLQWKDW
EODFNWXQQHODQGKHZKHHOHGRQWKHVWDLUOLIWLQJKLVVZRUGDQG
JODULQJPXUGHURXVO\LQWRWKHGDUNQHVVEHKLQGKLPH[SHFWLQJDUXVKRI
JKRXOLVKDVVDLODQWV%XWWKHUHZDVQRVRXQGRUPRYHPHQWGRZQWKH
WXQQHO'LGWKHPHQEH\RQGWKHGRRULIWKH\BZHUHBPHQEHOLHYH
WKDWKHKDGEHHQGLVSRVHGRIE\WKHIDOORIWKHVWRQHIURPWKHURRI
ZKLFKKDGXQGRXEWHGO\EHHQUHOHDVHGE\VRPHVRUWRIPDFKLQHU\"
7KHQZK\KDGWKHGRRUEHHQVKXWDERYHKLP"$EDQGRQLQJVSHFXODWLRQ
&RQDQJURSHGKLVZD\XSWKHVWHSVKLVVNLQFUDZOLQJLQDQWLFLSDWLRQ
RIDNQLIHLQKLVEDFNDWHYHU\VWULGH\HDUQLQJWRGURZQKLVVHPL
SDQLFLQDEDUEDURXVEXUVWRIEORRGOHWWLQJ
+HWKUXVWDJDLQVWWKHGRRUDWWKHWRSDQGFXUVHGVRXOIXOO\WR
ILQGWKDWLWGLGQRWJLYHWRKLVHIIRUWV7KHQDVKHOLIWHGKLVVZRUG
ZLWKKLVULJKWKDQGWRKHZDWWKHPDUEOHKLVJURSLQJOHIW
HQFRXQWHUHGDPHWDOEROWWKDWHYLGHQWO\VOLSSHGLQWRSODFHDWWKH
FORVLQJRIWKHGRRU,QDQLQVWDQWKHKDGGUDZQWKLVEROWDQGWKHQ
WKHGRRUJDYHWRKLVVKRYH+HERXQGHGLQWRWKHFKDPEHUOLNHDVOLW
H\HGVQDUOLQJLQFDUQDWLRQRIIXU\IHURFLRXVO\GHVLURXVWRFRPHWR
JULSVZLWKZKDWHYHUHQHP\ZDVKRXQGLQJKLP
7KHGDJJHUZDVJRQHIURPWKHIORRU7KHFKDPEHUZDVHPSW\DQGVR
ZDVWKHGDLV<HOD\DKDGDJDLQYDQLVKHG
%\&URPPXWWHUHGWKH&LPPHULDQ,VVKHDOLYHDIWHUDOO"
+HVWURGHRXWLQWRWKHWKURQHURRPEDIIOHGDQGWKHQVWUXFNE\D
VXGGHQWKRXJKWVWHSSHGEHKLQGWKHWKURQHDQGSHHUHGLQWRWKHDOFRYH
7KHUHZDVEORRGRQWKHVPRRWKPDUEOHZKHUHKHKDGFDVWGRZQWKH
VHQVHOHVVERG\RI*ZDUXQJDWKDWZDVDOO7KHEODFNPDQKDG
YDQLVKHGDVFRPSOHWHO\DV<HOD\D


7KH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU

%DIIOHGZUDWKFRQIXVHGWKHEUDLQRI&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQ+HNQHZ
QRPRUHKRZWRJRDERXWVHDUFKLQJIRU0XULHODWKDQKHKDGNQRZQKRZ
WRJRDERXWVHDUFKLQJIRUWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXU2QO\RQHWKRXJKW
RFFXUUHGWRKLPWRIROORZWKHSULHVWV3HUKDSVDWWKHKLGLQJSODFH
RIWKHWUHDVXUHVRPHFOXHZRXOGEHUHYHDOHGWRKLP,WZDVDVOLP
FKDQFHEXWEHWWHUWKDQZDQGHULQJDERXWDLPOHVVO\
$VKHKXUULHGWKURXJKWKHJUHDWVKDGRZ\KDOOWKDWOHGWRWKH
SRUWLFRKHKDOIH[SHFWHGWKHOXUNLQJVKDGRZVWRFRPHWROLIHEHKLQG
KLPZLWKUHQGLQJIDQJVDQGWDORQV%XWRQO\WKHEHDWRIKLVRZQUDSLG
KHDUWDFFRPSDQLHGKLPLQWRWKHPRRQOLJKWWKDWGDSSOHGWKHVKLPPHULQJ
PDUEOH
$WWKHIRRWRIWKHZLGHVWHSVKHFDVWDERXWLQWKHEULJKW
PRRQOLJKWIRUVRPHVLJKWWRVKRZKLPWKHGLUHFWLRQKHPXVWJR$QGKH
IRXQGLWSHWDOVVFDWWHUHGRQWKHVZDUGWROGZKHUHDQDUPRU
JDUPHQWKDGEUXVKHGDJDLQVWDEORVVRPODGHQEUDQFK*UDVVKDGEHHQ
SUHVVHGGRZQXQGHUKHDY\IHHW&RQDQZKRKDGWUDFNHGZROYHVLQKLV
QDWLYHKLOOVIRXQGQRLQVXUPRXQWDEOHGLIILFXOW\LQIROORZLQJWKH
WUDLORIWKH.HVKDQLSULHVWV
,WOHGDZD\IURPWKHSDODFHWKURXJKPDVVHVRIH[RWLFVFHQWHG
VKUXEEHU\ZKHUHJUHDWSDOHEORVVRPVVSUHDGWKHLUVKLPPHULQJSHWDOV
WKURXJKYHUGDQWWDQJOHGEXVKHVWKDWVKRZHUHGEORRPVDWWKHWRXFK
XQWLOKHFDPHDWODVWWRDJUHDWPDVVRIURFNWKDWMXWWHGOLNHD
WLWDQ
VFDVWOHRXWIURPWKHFOLIIVDWDSRLQWFORVHVWWRWKHSDODFH
ZKLFKKRZHYHUZDVDOPRVWKLGGHQIURPYLHZE\YLQHLQWHUODFHGWUHHV
(YLGHQWO\WKDWEDEEOLQJSULHVWLQ.HVKLDKDGEHHQPLVWDNHQZKHQKH
VDLGWKH7HHWKZHUHKLGGHQLQWKHSDODFH7KLVWUDLOKDGOHGKLPDZD\
IURPWKHSODFHZKHUH0XULHODKDGGLVDSSHDUHGEXWDEHOLHIZDV
JURZLQJLQ&RQDQWKDWHDFKSDUWRIWKHYDOOH\ZDVFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKDW
SDODFHE\VXEWHUUDQHDQSDVVDJHV
&URXFKLQJLQWKHGHHSYHOYHWEODFNVKDGRZVRIWKHEXVKHVKH
VFUXWLQL]HGWKHJUHDWMXWRIURFNZKLFKVWRRGRXWLQEROGUHOLHILQ
WKHPRRQOLJKW,WZDVFRYHUHGZLWKVWUDQJHJURWHVTXHFDUYLQJV
GHSLFWLQJPHQDQGDQLPDOVDQGKDOIEHVWLDOFUHDWXUHVWKDWPLJKWKDYH
EHHQJRGVRUGHYLOV7KHVW\OHRIDUWGLIIHUHGVRVWULNLQJO\IURP
WKDWRIWKHUHVWRIWKHYDOOH\WKDW&RQDQZRQGHUHGLILWGLGQRW
UHSUHVHQWDGLIIHUHQWHUDDQGUDFHDQGZDVLWVHOIDUHOLFRIDQDJH
ORVWDQGIRUJRWWHQDWZKDWHYHULPPHDVXUDEO\GLVWDQWGDWHWKHSHRSOH
RI$ONPHHQRQKDGIRXQGDQGHQWHUHGWKHKDXQWHGYDOOH\
$JUHDWGRRUVWRRGRSHQLQWKHVKHHUFXUWDLQRIWKHFOLIIDQGD
JLJDQWLFGUDJRQ
VKHDGZDVFDUYHGDERXWLWVRWKDWWKHRSHQGRRUZDV
OLNHWKHGUDJRQ
VJDSLQJPRXWK7KHGRRULWVHOIZDVRIFDUYHQEURQ]H
DQGORRNHGWRZHLJKVHYHUDOWRQV7KHUHZDVQRORFNWKDWKHFRXOG
VHHEXWDVHULHVRIEROWVVKRZLQJDORQJWKHHGJHRIWKHPDVVLYH
SRUWDODVLWVWRRGRSHQWROGKLPWKDWWKHUHZDVVRPHV\VWHPRI
ORFNLQJDQGXQORFNLQJDV\VWHPGRXEWOHVVNQRZQRQO\WRWKHSULHVWV
RI.HVKDQ
7KHWUDLOVKRZHGWKDW*RUXOJDDQGKLVKHQFKHPHQKDGJRQHWKURXJK
WKDWGRRU%XW&RQDQKHVLWDWHG7RZDLWXQWLOWKH\HPHUJHGZRXOG
SUREDEO\PHDQWRVHHWKHGRRUORFNHGLQKLVIDFHDQGKHPLJKWQRWEH
DEOHWRVROYHWKHP\VWHU\RILWVXQORFNLQJ2QWKHRWKHUKDQGLIKH
IROORZHGWKHPLQWKH\PLJKWHPHUJHDQGORFNKLPLQWKHFDYHUQ
7KURZLQJFDXWLRQWRWKHZLQGVKHJOLGHGWKURXJKWKHJUHDWSRUWDO
6RPHZKHUHLQWKHFDYHUQZHUHWKHSULHVWVWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDQG
SHUKDSVDFOXHWRWKHIDWHRI0XULHOD3HUVRQDOULVNVKDGQHYHU\HW
GHWHUUHGKLPIURPDQ\SXUSRVH
0RRQOLJKWLOOXPLQHGIRUDIHZ\DUGVWKHZLGHWXQQHOLQZKLFKKH
IRXQGKLPVHOI6RPHZKHUHDKHDGRIKLPKHVDZDIDLQWJORZDQGKHDUG
WKHHFKRRIDZHLUGFKDQWLQJ7KHSULHVWVZHUHQRWVRIDUDKHDGRI
KLPDVKHKDGWKRXJKW7KHWXQQHOGHERXFKHGLQWRDZLGHURRPEHIRUH
WKHPRRQOLJKWSOD\HGRXWDQHPSW\FDYHUQRIQRJUHDWGLPHQVLRQVEXW
ZLWKDORIW\YDXOWHGURRIJORZLQJZLWKDSKRVSKRUHVFHQW
HQFUXVWDWLRQZKLFKDV&RQDQNQHZZDVDFRPPRQSKHQRPHQRQLQWKDW
SDUWRIWKHZRUOG,WPDGHDJKRVWO\KDOIOLJKWLQZKLFKKHZDVDEOH
WRVHHDEHVWLDOLPDJHVTXDWWLQJRQDVKULQHDQGWKHEODFNPRXWKVRI
VL[RUVHYHQWXQQHOVOHDGLQJRIIIURPWKHFKDPEHU'RZQWKHZLGHVWRI
WKHVHWKHRQHGLUHFWO\EHKLQGWKHVTXDWLPDJHZKLFKORRNHGWRZDUG
WKHRXWHURSHQLQJKHFDXJKWWKHJOHDPRIWRUFKHVZDYHULQJZKHUHDV
WKHSKRVSKRUHVFHQWJORZZDVIL[HGDQGKHDUGWKHFKDQWLQJLQFUHDVHLQ
YROXPH
'RZQLWKHZHQWUHFNOHVVO\DQGZDVSUHVHQWO\SHHULQJLQWRD
ODUJHUFDYHUQWKDQWKHRQHKHKDGMXVWOHIW7KHUHZDVQRSKRVSKRUXV
KHUHEXWWKHOLJKWRIWKHWRUFKHVIHOORQDODUJHUDOWDUDQGDPRUH
REVFHQHDQGUHSXOVLYHJRGVTXDWWLQJWRDGOLNHXSRQLW%HIRUHWKLV
UHSXJQDQWGHLW\*RUXOJDDQGKLVWHQDFRO\WHVNQHOWDQGEHDWWKHLU
KHDGVXSRQWKHJURXQGZKLOHFKDQWLQJPRQRWRQRXVO\&RQDQUHDOL]HG
ZK\WKHLUSURJUHVVKDGEHHQVRVORZ(YLGHQWO\DSSURDFKLQJWKHVHFUHW
FU\SWRIWKH7HHWKZDVDFRPSOLFDWHGDQGHODERUDWHULWXDO
+HZDVILGJHWLQJLQQHUYRXVLPSDWLHQFHEHIRUHWKHFKDQWLQJDQG
ERZLQJZHUHRYHUEXWSUHVHQWO\WKH\URVHDQGSDVVHGLQWRWKHWXQQHO
ZKLFKRSHQHGEHKLQGWKHLGRO7KHLUWRUFKHVEREEHGDZD\LQWRWKH
QLJKWHGYDXOWDQGKHIROORZHGVZLIWO\1RWPXFKGDQJHURIEHLQJ
GLVFRYHUHG+HJOLGHGDORQJWKHVKDGRZVOLNHDFUHDWXUHRIWKHQLJKW
DQGWKHEODFNSULHVWVZHUHFRPSOHWHO\HQJURVVHGLQWKHLUFHUHPRQLDO
PXPPHU\$SSDUHQWO\WKH\KDGQRWHYHQQRWLFHGWKHDEVHQFHRI
*ZDUXQJD
(PHUJLQJLQWRDFDYHUQRIKXJHSURSRUWLRQVDERXWZKRVHXSZDUG
FXUYLQJZDOOVJDOOHU\OLNHOHGJHVPDUFKHGLQWLHUVWKH\EHJDQWKHLU
ZRUVKLSDQHZEHIRUHDQDOWDUZKLFKZDVODUJHUDQGDJRGZKLFKZDV
PRUHGLVJXVWLQJWKDQDQ\HQFRXQWHUHGWKXVIDU
&RQDQFURXFKHGLQWKHEODFNPRXWKRIWKHWXQQHOVWDULQJDWWKH
ZDOOVUHIOHFWLQJWKHOXULGJORZRIWKHWRUFKHV+HVDZDFDUYHQVWRQH
VWDLUZLQGLQJXSIURPWLHUWRWLHURIWKHJDOOHULHVWKHURRIZDV
ORVWLQGDUNQHVV
+HVWDUWHGYLROHQWO\DQGWKHFKDQWLQJEURNHRIIDVWKHNQHHOLQJ
EODFNVIOXQJXSWKHLUKHDGV$QLQKXPDQYRLFHERRPHGRXWKLJKDERYH
WKHP7KH\IUR]HRQWKHLUNQHHVWKHLUIDFHVWXUQHGXSZDUGZLWKD
JKDVWO\EOXHKXHLQWKHVXGGHQJODUHRIDZHLUGOLJKWWKDWEXUVW
EOLQGLQJO\XSQHDUWKHORIW\URRIDQGWKHQEXUQHGZLWKDWKUREELQJ
JORZ7KDWJODUHOLJKWHGDJDOOHU\DQGDFU\ZHQWXSIURPWKHKLJK
SULHVWHFKRHGVKXGGHULQJO\E\KLVDFRO\WHV,QWKHIODVKWKHUHKDG
EHHQEULHIO\GLVFORVHGWRWKHPDVOLPZKLWHILJXUHVWDQGLQJXSULJKW
LQDVKHHQRIVLONDQGDJOLQWRIMHZHOFUXVWHGJROG7KHQWKHEOD]H
VPROGHUHGWRDWKUREELQJSXOVLQJOXPLQRVLW\LQZKLFKQRWKLQJZDV
GLVWLQFWDQGWKDWVOLPVKDSHZDVEXWDVKLPPHULQJEOXURILYRU\
B<HOD\DBVFUHDPHG*RUXOJDKLVEURZQIHDWXUHVDVKHQ:K\KDYH
\RXIROORZHGXV":KDWLV\RXUSOHDVXUH"
7KDWZHLUGXQKXPDQYRLFHUROOHGGRZQIURPWKHURRIUHHFKRLQJ
XQGHUWKDWDUFKLQJYDXOWWKDWPDJQLILHGDQGDOWHUHGLWEH\RQG
UHFRJQLWLRQ
:RHWRWKHXQEHOLHYHUV:RHWRWKHIDOVHFKLOGUHQRI.HVKLD'RRP
WRWKHPZKLFKGHQ\WKHLUGHLW\
$FU\RIKRUURUZHQWXSIURPWKHSULHVWV*RUXOJDORRNHGOLNHD
VKRFNHGYXOWXUHLQWKHJODUHRIWKHWRUFKHV
,GRQRWXQGHUVWDQGKHVWDPPHUHG:HDUHIDLWKIXO,QWKH
FKDPEHURIWKHRUDFOH\RXWROGXV
'RQRWKHHGZKDW\RXKHDUGLQWKHFKDPEHURIWKHRUDFOHUROOHG
WKDWWHUULEOHYRLFHPXOWLSOLHGXQWLOLWZDVDVWKRXJKDP\ULDG
YRLFHVWKXQGHUHGDQGPXWWHUHGWKHVDPHZDUQLQJ%HZDUHRIIDOVH
SURSKHWVDQGIDOVHJRGV$GHPRQLQP\JXLVHVSRNHWR\RXLQWKH
SDODFHJLYLQJIDOVHSURSKHF\1RZKDUNHQDQGREH\IRURQO\,DPWKH
WUXHJRGGHVVDQG,JLYH\RXRQHFKDQFHWRVDYH\RXUVHOYHVIURPGRRP
7DNHWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUIURPWKHFU\SWZKHUHWKH\ZHUHSODFHG
VRORQJDJR$ONPHHQRQLVQRORQJHUKRO\EHFDXVHLWKDVEHHQ
GHVHFUDWHGE\EODVSKHPHUV*LYHWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXULQWRWKHKDQGV
RI7KXWPHNULWKH6W\JLDQWRSODFHLQWKHVDQFWXDU\RI'DJRQDQG
'HUNHWR2QO\WKLVFDQVDYH.HVKDQIURPWKHGRRPWKHGHPRQVRIWKH
QLJKWKDYHSORWWHG7DNHWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDQGJRUHWXUQ
LQVWDQWO\WR.HVKLDWKHUHJLYHWKHMHZHOVWR7KXWPHNULDQGVHL]H
WKHIRUHLJQGHYLO&RQDQDQGIOD\KLPDOLYHLQWKHJUHDWVTXDUH
7KHUHZDVQRKHVLWDWLRQLQREH\LQJ&KDWWHULQJZLWKIHDUWKH
SULHVWVVFUDPEOHGXSDQGUDQIRUWKHGRRUWKDWRSHQHGEHKLQGWKH
EHVWLDOJRG*RUXOJDOHGWKHIOLJKW7KH\MDPPHGEULHIO\LQWKH
GRRUZD\\HOSLQJDVZLOGO\ZDYLQJWRUFKHVWRXFKHGVTXLUPLQJEODFN
ERGLHVWKH\SOXQJHGWKURXJKDQGWKHSDWWHURIWKHLUVSHHGLQJIHHW
GZLQGOHGGRZQWKHWXQQHO
&RQDQGLGQRWIROORZ+HZDVFRQVXPHGZLWKDIXULRXVGHVLUHWR
OHDUQWKHWUXWKRIWKLVIDQWDVWLFDIIDLU:DVWKDWLQGHHG<HOD\DDV
WKHFROGVZHDWRQWKHEDFNVRIKLVKDQGVWROGKLPRUZDVLWWKDW
OLWWOHKXVV\0XULHODWXUQHGWUDLWUHVVDIWHUDOO",ILWZDV
%HIRUHWKHODVWWRUFKKDGYDQLVKHGGRZQWKHEODFNWXQQHOKHZDV
ERXQGLQJYHQJHIXOO\XSWKHVWRQHVWDLU7KHEOXHJORZZDVG\LQJGRZQ
EXWKHFRXOGVWLOOPDNHRXWWKDWWKHLYRU\ILJXUHVWRRGPRWLRQOHVVRQ
WKHJDOOHU\+LVEORRGUDQFROGDVKHDSSURDFKHGLWEXWKHGLGQRW
KHVLWDWH+HFDPHRQZLWKKLVVZRUGOLIWHGDQGWRZHUHGOLNHDWKUHDW
RIGHDWKRYHUWKHLQVFUXWDEOHVKDSH
<HOD\DKHVQDUOHG'HDGDVVKH
VEHHQIRUDWKRXVDQG\HDUV
B+DB
)URPWKHGDUNPRXWKRIDWXQQHOEHKLQGKLPDGDUNIRUPOXQJHG%XW
WKHVXGGHQGHDGO\UXVKRIXQVKRGIHHWKDGUHDFKHGWKH&LPPHULDQ
V
TXLFNHDUV+HZKLUOHGOLNHDFDWDQGGRGJHGWKHEORZDLPHG
PXUGHURXVO\DWKLVEDFN$VWKHJOHDPLQJVWHHOLQWKHGDUNKDQG
KLVVHGSDVWKLPKHVWUXFNEDFNZLWKWKHIXU\RIDURXVHGS\WKRQDQG
WKHORQJVWUDLJKWEODGHLPSDOHGKLVDVVDLODQWDQGVWRRGRXWDIRRW
DQGDKDOIEHWZHHQKLVVKRXOGHUV
6R&RQDQWRUHKLVVZRUGIUHHDVWKHYLFWLPVDJJHGWRWKHIORRU
JDVSLQJDQGJXUJOLQJ7KHPDQZULWKHGEULHIO\DQGVWLIIHQHG,QWKH
G\LQJOLJKW&RQDQVDZDEODFNERG\DQGHERQFRXQWHQDQFHKLGHRXVLQ
WKHEOXHJODUH+HKDGNLOOHG*ZDUXQJD
&RQDQWXUQHGIURPWKHFRUSVHWRWKHJRGGHVV7KRQJVDERXWKHU
NQHHVDQGEUHDVWKHOGKHUXSULJKWDJDLQVWWKDVWRQHSLOODUDQGKHU
WKLFNKDLUIDVWHQWHGWRWKHFROXPQKHOGKHUKHDGXS$WDIHZ
\DUGV
GLVWDQFHWKHVHERQGVZHUHQRWYLVLEOHLQWKHXQFHUWDLQOLJKW
+HPXVWKDYHFRPHWRDIWHU,GHVFHQGHGLQWRWKHWXQQHOPXWWHUHG
&RQDQ+HPXVWKDYHVXVSHFWHG,ZDVGRZQWKHUH6RKHSXOOHGRXWWKH
GDJJHU&RQDQVWRRSHGDQGZUHQFKHGWKHLGHQWLFDOZHDSRQIURPWKH
VWLIIHQLQJILQJHUVJODQFHGDWLWDQGUHSODFHGLWLQKLVRZQJLUGOH
DQGVKXWWKHGRRU7KHQKHWRRN<HOD\DWREHIRROKLVEURWKHU
LGLRWV7KDWZDVKHVKRXWLQJDZKLOHDJR<RXFRXOGQ
WUHFRJQL]HKLV
YRLFHXQGHUWKLVHFKRLQJURRI$QGWKDWEXUVWLQJEOXHIODPH,
WKRXJKWLWORRNHGIDPLOLDU,W
VDWULFNRIWKH6W\JLDQSULHVWV
7KXWPHNULPXVWKDYHJLYHQVRPHRILWWR*ZDUXQJD
7KHPDQFRXOGHDVLO\KDYHUHDFKHGWKLVFDYHUQDKHDGRIKLV
FRPSDQLRQV(YLGHQWO\IDPLOLDUZLWKWKHSODQRIWKHFDYHUQVE\
KHDUVD\RUE\PDSVKDQGHGGRZQLQWKHSULHVWFUDIWKHKDGHQWHUHGWKH
FDYHDIWHUWKHRWKHUVFDUU\LQJWKHJRGGHVVIROORZHGDFLUFXLWRXV
URXWHWKURXJKWKHWXQQHOVDQGFKDPEHUVDQGHQVFRQFHGKLPVHOIDQGKLV
EXUGHQRQWKHEDOFRQ\ZKLOH*RUXOJDDQGWKHRWKHUDFRO\WHVZHUH
HQJDJHGLQWKHLUHQGOHVVULWXDOV
7KHEOXHJODUHKDGIDGHGEXWQRZ&RQDQZDVDZDUHRIDQRWKHUJORZ
HPDQDWLQJIURPWKHPRXWKRIRQHRIWKHFRUULGRUVWKDWRSHQHGRQWKH
OHGJH6RPHZKHUHGRZQWKDWFRUULGRUWKHUHZDVDQRWKHUILHOGRI
SKRVSKRUXVIRUKHUHFRJQL]HGWKHIDLQWVWHDG\UDGLDQFH7KHFRUULGRU
OHGLQWKHGLUHFWLRQWKHSULHVWVKDGWDNHQDQGKHGHFLGHGWRIROORZ
LWUDWKHUWKDQGHVFHQGLQWRWKHGDUNQHVVRIWKHJUHDWFDYHUQEHORZ
'RXEWOHVVLWFRQQHFWHGZLWKDQRWKHUJDOOHU\LQVRPHRWKHUFKDPEHU
ZKLFKPLJKWEHWKHGHVWLQDWLRQRIWKHSULHVWV+HKXUULHGGRZQLW
WKHLOOXPLQDWLRQJURZLQJVWURQJHUDVKHDGYDQFHGXQWLOKHFRXOGPDNH
RXWWKHIORRUDQGWKHZDOOVRIWKHWXQQHO$KHDGRIKLPDQGEHORZKH
FRXOGKHDUWKHSULHVWVFKDQWLQJDJDLQ
$EUXSWO\DGRRUZD\LQWKHOHIWKDQGZDOOZDVOLPQHGLQWKH
SKRVSKRURXVJORZDQGWRKLVHDUVFDPHWKHVRXQGRIVRIWK\VWHULFDO
VREELQJ+HZKHHOHGDQGJODUHGWKURXJKWKHGRRU
+HZDVORRNLQJDJDLQLQWRDFKDPEHUKHZQRXWRIVROLGURFNQRWD
QDWXUDOFDYHUQOLNHWKHRWKHUV7KHGRPHGURRIVKRQHZLWKWKH
SKRVSKRURXVOLJKWDQGWKHZDOOVZHUHDOPRVWFRYHUHGZLWKDUDEHVTXHV
RIEHDWHQJROG
1HDUWKHIDUWKHUZDOORQDJUDQLWHWKURQHVWDULQJIRUHYHUWRZDUG
WKHDUFKHGGRRUZD\VDWWKHPRQVWURXVDQGREVFHQH3WHRUWKHJRGRI
WKH3HOLVKWLZURXJKWLQEUDVVZLWKKLVH[DJJHUDWHGDWWULEXWHV
UHIOHFWLQJWKHJURVVQHVVRIKLVFXOW$QGLQKLVODSVSUDZOHGDOLPS
ZKLWHILJXUH
:HOO,
OOEHGDPQHGPXWWHUHG&RQDQ+HJODQFHGVXVSLFLRXVO\
DERXWWKHFKDPEHUVHHLQJQRRWKHUHQWUDQFHRUHYLGHQFHRI
RFFXSDWLRQDQGWKHQDGYDQFHGQRLVHOHVVO\DQGORRNHGGRZQDWWKHJLUO
ZKRVHVOLPVKRXOGHUVVKRRNZLWKVREVRIDEMHFWPLVHU\KHUIDFHVXQN
LQKHUDUPV)URPWKLFNEDQGVRIJROGRQWKHLGRO
VDUPVVOLPJROG
FKDLQVUDQWRVPDOOHUEDQGVRQKHUZULVWV+HODLGDKDQGRQKHU
QDNHGVKRXOGHUDQGVKHVWDUWHGFRQYXOVLYHO\VKULHNHGDQGWZLVWHG
KHUWHDUVWDLQHGIDFHWRZDUGKLP
B&RQDQB6KHPDGHDVSDVPRGLFHIIRUWWRJRLQWRWKHXVXDO
FOLQFKEXWWKHFKDLQVKLQGHUHGKHU+HFXWWKURXJKWKHVRIWJROGDV
FORVHWRKHUZULVWVDVKHFRXOGJUXQWLQJ<RX
OOKDYHWRZHDUWKHVH
EUDFHOHWVXQWLO,FDQILQGDFKLVHORUDILOH/HWJRRIPHGDPQLW
<RXDFWUHVVHVDUHWRRGDPQHGHPRWLRQDO:KDWKDSSHQHGWR\RX
DQ\ZD\"
:KHQ,ZHQWEDFNLQWRWKHRUDFOHFKDPEHUVKHZKLPSHUHG,VDZ
WKHJRGGHVVO\LQJRQWKHGDLVDV,
GILUVWVHHQKHU,FDOOHGRXWWR
\RXDQGVWDUWHGWRUXQWRWKHGRRUWKHQVRPHWKLQJJUDEEHGPHIURP
EHKLQG,WFODSSHGDKDQGRYHUP\PRXWKDQGFDUULHGPHWKURXJKD
SDQHOLQWKHZDOODQGGRZQVRPHVWHSVDQGDORQJDGDUNKDOO,
GLGQ
WVHHZKDWLWZDVWKDWKDGKROGRIPHXQWLOZHSDVVHGWKURXJKD
ELJPHWDOGRRUDQGFDPHLQWRDWXQQHOZKRVHURRIZDVDOLJKWOLNH
WKLVFKDPEHU
2K,QHDUO\IDLQWHGZKHQ,VDZ7KH\DUHQRWKXPDQV7KH\DUH
JUD\KDLU\GHYLOVWKDWZDONOLNHPHQDQGVSHDNDJLEEHULVKQRKXPDQ
FRXOGXQGHUVWDQG7KH\VWRRGWKHUHDQGVHHPHGWREHZDLWLQJDQGRQFH
,WKRXJKW,KHDUGVRPHERG\WU\LQJWKHGRRU7KHQRQHRIWKHBWKLQJVB
SXOOHGDPHWDOOHYHULQWKHZDOODQGVRPHWKLQJFUDVKHGRQWKHRWKHU
VLGHRIWKHGRRU
7KHQWKH\FDUULHGPHRQDQGRQWKURXJKZLQGLQJWXQQHOVDQGXS
VWRQHVWDLUZD\VLQWRWKLVFKDPEHUZKHUHWKH\FKDLQHGPHRQWKHNQHHV
RIWKLVDERPLQDEOHLGRODQGWKHQWKH\ZHQWDZD\2K&RQDQZKDWDUH
WKH\"
6HUYDQWVRI%LW<DNLQKHJUXQWHG,IRXQGDPDQXVFULSWWKDW
WROGPHDQXPEHURIWKLQJVDQGWKHQVWXPEOHGXSRQVRPHIUHVFRHVWKDW
WROGPHWKHUHVW%LW<DNLQZDVD3HOLVKWLZKRZDQGHUHGLQWRWKH
YDOOH\ZLWKKLVVHUYDQWVDIWHUWKHSHRSOHRI$ONPHHQRQKDGGHVHUWHG
LW+HIRXQGWKHERG\RI3ULQFHVV<HOD\DDQGGLVFRYHUHGWKDWWKH
SULHVWVUHWXUQHGIURPWLPHWRWLPHWRPDNHRIIHULQJVWRKHUIRUHYHQ
WKHQVKHZDVZRUVKLSSHGDVDJRGGHVV
+HPDGHDQRUDFOHRIKHUDQGKHZDVWKHYRLFHRIWKHRUDFOH
VSHDNLQJIURPDQLFKHKHFXWLQWKHZDOOEHKLQGWKHLYRU\GDLV7KH
SULHVWVQHYHUVXVSHFWHGQHYHUVDZKLPRUKLVVHUYDQWVIRUWKH\
DOZD\VKLGWKHPVHOYHVZKHQWKHPHQFDPH%LW<DNLQOLYHGDQGGLHG
KHUHZLWKRXWHYHUEHLQJGLVFRYHUHGE\WKHSULHVWV&URPNQRZVKRZ
ORQJKHGZHOWKHUHEXWLWPXVWKDYHEHHQIRUFHQWXULHV7KHZLVHPHQ
RIWKH3HOLVKWLNQRZKRZWRLQFUHDVHWKHVSDQRIWKHLUOLYHVIRU
KXQGUHGVRI\HDUV,
YHVHHQVRPHRIWKHPP\VHOI:K\KHOLYHGKHUH
DORQHDQGZK\KHSOD\HGWKHSDUWRIRUDFOHQRRUGLQDU\KXPDQFDQ
JXHVVEXW,EHOLHYHWKHRUDFOHSDUWZDVWRNHHSWKHFLW\LQYLRODWH
DQGVDFUHGVRKHFRXOGUHPDLQXQGLVWXUEHG+HDWHWKHIRRGWKH
SULHVWVEURXJKWDVDQRIIHULQJWR<HOD\DDQGKLVVHUYDQWVDWHRWKHU
WKLQJV,
YHDOZD\VNQRZQWKHUHZDVDVXEWHUUDQHDQULYHUIORZLQJ
DZD\IURPWKHODNHZKHUHWKHSHRSOHRIWKH3XQWLVKKLJKODQGVWKURZ
WKHLUGHDG7KDWULYHUUXQVXQGHUWKLVSDODFH7KH\KDYHODGGHUVKXQJ
RYHUWKHZDWHUZKHUHWKH\FDQKDQJDQGILVKIRUWKHFRUSVHVWKDWFRPH
IORDWLQJWKURXJK%LW<DNLQUHFRUGHGHYHU\WKLQJRQSDUFKPHQWDQG
SDLQWHGZDOOV
%XWKHGLHGDWODVWDQGKLVVHUYDQWVPXPPLILHGKLPDFFRUGLQJWR
LQVWUXFWLRQVKHJDYHWKHPEHIRUHKLVGHDWKDQGVWXFNKLPLQDFDYH
LQWKHFOLIIV7KHUHVWLVHDV\WRJXHVV+LVVHUYDQWVZKRZHUHHYHQ
PRUHQHDUO\LPPRUWDOWKDQKHNHSWRQGZHOOLQJKHUHEXWWKHQH[W
WLPHDKLJKSULHVWFDPHWRFRQVXOWWKHRUDFOHQRWKDYLQJDPDVWHUWR
UHVWUDLQWKHUPWKH\WRUHKLPWRSLHFHV6RVLQFHWKHQXQWLO
*RUXOJDQRERG\FDPHWRWDONWRWKHRUDFOH
,W
VREYLRXVWKH\
YHEHHQUHQHZLQJWKHJDUPHQWVDQGRUQDPHQWVRI
WKHJRGGHVVDVWKH\
GVHHQ%LW<DNLQGR'RXEWOHVVWKHUH
VDVHDOHG
FKDPEHUVRPHZKHUHZHUHWKHVLONVDUHNHSWIURPGHFD\7KH\FORWKHG
WKHJRGGHVVDQGEURXJKWKHUEDFNWRWKHRUDFOHURRPDIWHU=DUJKHED
KDGVWROHQKHU$QGRKE\WKHZD\WKH\WRRNRII=DUJKHED
VKHDG
DQGKXQJLWXSLQDWKLFNHW
6KHVKLYHUHG\HWDWWKHVDPHWLPHEUHDWKHGDVLJKRIUHOLHI
+H
OOQHYHUZKLSPHDJDLQ
1RWWKLVVLGHRI+HOODJUHHG&RQDQ%XWFRPHRQ*ZDUXQJD
UXLQHGP\FKDQFHVZLWKKLVVWROHQJRGGHVV,
PJRLQJWRIROORZWKH
SULHVWVDQGWDNHP\FKDQFHRIVWHDOLQJWKHORRWIURPWKHPDIWHUWKH\
JHWLW$QG\RXVWD\FORVHWRPH,FDQ
WVSHQGDOOP\WLPHORRNLQJ
IRU\RX
%XWWKHVHUYDQWVRI%LW<DNLQVKHZKLVSHUHGIHDUIXOO\
:H
OOKDYHWRWDNHRXUFKDQFHKHJUXQWHG,GRQ
WNQRZZKDW
V
LQWKHLUPLQGVEXWVRIDUWKH\KDYHQ
WVKRZQDQ\GLVSRVLWLRQWRFRPH
RXWDQGILJKWLQWKHRSHQ&RPHRQ
7DNLQJKHUZULVWKHOHGKHURXWRIWKHFKDPEHUDQGGRZQWKH
FRUULGRU$VWKH\DGYDQFHGWKH\KHDUGWKHFKDQWLQJRIWKHSULHVWV
DQGPLQJOLQJZLWKWKHVRXQGWKHORZVXOOHQUXVKLQJRIZDWHUV7KH
OLJKWJUHZVWURQJHUDERYHWKHPDVWKH\HPHUJHGRQDKLJKSLWFKHG
JDOOHU\RIDJUHDWFDYHUQDQGORRNHGGRZQRQDVFHQHZHLUGDQG
IDQWDVWLF
$ERYHWKHPJOHDPHGWKHSKRVSKRUHVFHQWURRIDKXQGUHGIHHWEHORZ
WKHPVWUHWFKHGWKHVPRRWKIORRURIWKHFDYHUQ2QWKHIDUVLGHWKLV
IORRUZDVFXWE\DGHHSQDUURZVWUHDPEULPPLQJLWVURFN\FKDQQHO
5XVKLQJRXWRILPSHQHWUDEOHJORRPLWVZLUOHGDFURVVWKHFDYHUQDQG
ZDVORVWDJDLQLQGDUNQHVV7KHYLVLEOHVXUIDFHUHIOHFWHGWKH
UDGLDQFHDERYHWKHGDUNVHHWKLQJZDWHUVJOLQWHGDVLIIOHFNHGZLWK
OLYLQJMHZHOVIURVW\EOXHOXULGUHGVKLPPHULQJJUHHQDQGHYHU
FKDQJLQJLULGHVFHQFH
&RQDQDQGKLVFRPSDQLRQVWRRGXSRQRQHRIWKHJDOOHU\OLNHOHGJHV
WKDWEDQGHGWKHFXUYHRIWKHORIW\ZDOODQGIURPWKLVOHGJHD
QDWXUDOEULGJHRIVWRQHVRDUHGLQDEUHDWKWDNLQJDUFKRYHUWKHYDVW
JXOIRIWKHFDYHUQWRMRLQDPXFKVPDOOHUOHGJHRQWKHRSSRVLWHVLGH
DFURVVWKHULYHU7HQIHHWEHORZLWDQRWKHUEURDGHUDUFKVSDQQHGWKH
FDYH$WHLWKHUHQGDFDUYHGVWDLUMRLQHGWKHH[WUHPLWLHVRIWKHVH
IO\LQJDUFKHV
&RQDQ
VJD]HIROORZLQJWKHFXUYHRIWKHDUFKWKDWVZHSWDZD\IURP
WKHOHGJHRQZKLFKWKH\VWRRGFDXJKWDJOLQWRIOLJKWWKDWZDVQRW
WKHOXULGSKRVSKRUXVRIWKHFDYHUQ2QWKDWVPDOOOHGJHRSSRVLWHWKHP
WKHUHZDVDQRSHQLQJLQWKHFDYHZDOOWKURXJKZKLFKVWDUVZHUH
JOLQWLQJ
%XWKLVIXOODWWHQWLRQZDVGUDZQWRWKHVFHQHEHQHDWKWKHP7KH
SULHVWVKDGUHDFKHGWKHLUGHVWLQDWLRQ7KHUHLQDVZHHSLQJDQJOHRI
WKHFDYHUQZDOOVWRRGDVWRQHDOWDUEXWWKHUHZDVQRLGROXSRQLW
:KHWKHUWKHUHZDVRQHEHKLQGLW&RQDQFRXQGQRWDVFHUWDLQEHFDXVH
VRPHWULFNRIWKHOLJKWRUWKHVZHHSRIWKHZDOOOHIWWKHVSDFH
EHKLQGWKHDOWDULQWRWDOGDUNQHVV
7KHSULHVWVKDGVWXFNWKHLUWRUFKHVLQWRKROHVLQWKHVWRQHIORRU
IRUPLQJDVHPLFLUFOHRIILUHLQIURQWRIWKHDOWDUDWDGLVWDQFHRI
VHYHUDO\DUGV7KHQWKHSULHVWVWKHPVHOYHVIRUPHGDVHPLFLUFOHLQVLGH
WKHFUHVFHQWRIWRUFKHVDQG*RUXOJDDIWHUOLIWLQJKLVDUPVDORIWLQ
LQYRFDWLRQEHQWWRWKHDOWDUDQGODLGKDQGVRQLW,WOLIWHGDQG
WLOWHGEDFNZDUGRQLWVKLQGHUHGJHOLNHWKHOLGRIDFKHVW
UHYHDOLQJDVPDOOFU\SW
([WHQGLQJDORQJDUPLQWRWKHUHFHVV*RUXOJDEURXJKWXSDVPDOO
EUDVVFKHVW/RZHULQJWKHDOWDUEDFNLQWRSODFHKHVHWWKHFKHVWRQ
LWDQGWKUHZEDFNWKHOLG7RWKHHDJHUZDWFKHUVRQWKHKLJKJDOOHU\
LWVHHPHGDVLIWKHDFWLRQKDGUHOHDVHGDEOD]HRIOLYLQJILUHZKLFK
WKUREEHGDQGTXLYHUHGDERXWWKHRSHQHGFKHVW&RQDQ
VKHDUWOHDSHG
DQGKLVKDQGFDXJKWDWKLVKLOW7KH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDWODVW7KH
WUHDVXUHWKDWZRXOGPDNHLWVSRVVHVVRUWKHULFKHVWPDQLQWKHZRUOG
+LVEUHDWKFDPHIDVWEHWZHHQKLVFOHQFKHGWHHWK
7KHQKHZDVVXGGHQO\DZDUHWKDWDQHZHOHPHQWKDGHQWHUHGLQWRWKH
OLJKWRIWKHWRUFKHVDQGRIWKHSKRVSKRUHVFHQWURRIUHQGHULQJERWK
YRLG'DUNQHVVVWROHDURXQGWKHDOWDUH[FHSWIRUWKDWJORZLQJVSRW
RIHYLOUDGLDQFHFDVWE\WKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUDQGWKDWJUHZDQG
JUHZ7KHEODFNVIUR]HLQWREDVDOWLFVWDWXHVWKHLUVKDGRZVVWUHDPLQJ
JURWHVTXHO\DQGJLJDQWLFDOO\RXWEHKLQGWKHP
7KHDOWDUZDVODYHGLQWKHJORZQRZDQGWKHDVWRXQGHGIHDWXUHVRI
*RUXOJDVWRRGRXWLQVKDUSUHOLHI7KHQWKHP\VWHULRXVVSDFHEHKLQG
WKHDOWDUVZDPLQWRWKHZLGHQLQJLOOXPLQDWLRQ$QGVORZO\ZLWKWKH
FUDZOLQJOLJKWILJXUHVEHFDPHYLVLEOHOLNHVKDSHVJURZLQJRXWRI
WKHQLJKWDQGVLOHQFH
$WILUVWWKH\VHHPHGOLNHJUD\VWRQHVWDWXHVWKRVHPRWLRQOHVV
VKDSHVKDLU\PDQOLNH\HWKLGHRXVO\KXPDQEXWWKHLUH\HVZHUH
DOLYHFROGVSDUNVRIJUD\LF\ILUH$QGDVWKHZHLUGJORZOLWWKHLU
EHVWLDOFRXQWHQDQFHV*RUXOJDVFUHDPHGDQGIHOOEDFNZDUGWKURZLQJXS
KLVORQJDUPVLQDJHVWXUHRIIUHQ]LHGKRUURU
%XWDORQJHUDUPVKRWDFURVVWKHDOWDUDQGDPLVVKDSHQKDQGORFNHG
RQKLVWKURDW6FUHDPLQJDQGILJKWLQJWKHKLJKSULHVWZDVGUDJJHG
EDFNDFURVVWKHDOWDUDKDPPHUOLNHILVWVPDVKHGGRZQDQG*RUXOJD
V
FULHVZHUHVWLOOHG/LPSDQGEURNHQKHVDJJHGFURVVWKHDOWDUKLV
EUDLQVRR]LQJIURPKLVFUXVKHGVNXOO$QGWKHQWKHVHUYDQWVRI%LW
<DNLQVXUJHGOLNHDEXUVWLQJIORRGIURP+HOORQWKHEODFNSULHVWVZKR
VWRRGOLNHKRUURUEODVWHGLPDJHV
7KHQWKHUHZDVVODXJKWHUJULPDQGDSSDOOLQJ
&RQDQVDZEODFNERGLHVWRVVHGOLNHFKDIILQWKHLQKXPDQKDQGVRI
WKHVOD\HUVDJDLQVWZKRVHKRUULEOHVWUHQJWKDQGDJLOLW\WKHGDJJHUV
DQGVZRUGVRIWKHSULHVWVZHUHLQHIIHFWLYH+HVDZPHQOLIWHGERGLO\
DQGWKHLUKHDGVFUDFNHGRSHQDJDLQVWWKHVWRQHDOWDU+HVDZD
IODPLQJWRUFKJUDVSHGLQDPRQVWURXVKDQGWKUXVWLQH[RUDEO\GRZQ
WKHJXOOHWRIDQDJRQL]HGZUHWFKZKRZULWKHGLQYDLQDJDLQVWWKHDUPV
WKDWSLQLRQHGKLP+HVDZDPDQWRUQLQWZRSLHFHVDVRQHPLJKWWHDU
DFKLFNHQDQGWKHEORRG\IUDJPHQWVKXUOHGFOHDUDFURVVWKHFDYHUQ
7KHPDVVDFUHZDVDVVKRUWDQGGHYDVWDWLQJDVWKHUXVKRIDKXUULFDQH
,QDEXUVWRIUHGDE\VPDOIHURFLW\LWZDVRYHUH[FHSWIRURQHZUHWFK
ZKRIOHGVFUHDPLQJEDFNWKHZD\WKHSULHVWVKDGFRPHSXUVXHGE\D
VZDUPRIEORRGGDEEOHGVKDSHVRIKRUURUZKLFKUHDFKHGRXWWKHLUUHG
VPHDUHGKDQGVIRUKLP)XJLWLYHDQGSXUVXHUVYDQLVKHGGRZQWKHEODFN
WXQQHODQGWKHVFUHDPVRIWKHKXPDQFDPHEDFNGZLQGOLQJDQGFRQIXVHG
E\WKHGLVWDQFH
0XULHODZDVRQKHUNQHHVFOXWFKLQJ&RQDQ
VOHJVKHUIDFHSUHVVHG
DJDLQVWKLVNQHHDQGKHUH\HVWLJKWO\VKXW6KHZDVDTXDNLQJ
TXLYHULQJPROGRIDEMHFWWHUURU%XW&RQDQZDVJDOYDQL]HG$TXLFN
JODQFHDFURVVDWWKHDSHUWXUHZKHUHWKHVWDUVVKRQHDJODQFHGRZQDW
WKHFKHVWWKDWVWLOOEOD]HGRSHQRQWKHEORRGVPHDUHGDOWDUDQGKH
VDZDQGVHL]HGWKHGHVSHUDWHJDPEOH
,
PJRLQJDIWHUWKDWFKHVWKHJUDWHG6WD\KHUH
2K0LWUDQR,QDQDJRQ\RIIULJKWVKHIHOOWRWKHIORRUDQG
FDXJKWDWKLVVDQGDOV'RQ
W'RQ
W'RQ
WOHDYHPH
/LHVWLOODQGNHHS\RXUPRXWKVKXWKHVQDSSHGGLVHQJDJLQJ
KLPVHOIIURPKHUIUDQWLFFODVS
+HGLVUHJDUGHGWKHWRUWXRXVVWDLU+HGURSSHGIURPOHGJHWROHGJH
ZLWKUHFNOHVVKDVWH7KHUHZDVQRVLJQRIWKHPRQVWHUVDVKLVIHHW
KLWWKHIORRU$IHZRIWKHWRUFKHVVWLOOIODUHGLQWKHLUVRFNHWV
WKHSKRVSKRUHVFHQWJORZWKUREEHGDQGTXLYHUHGDQGWKHULYHUIORZHG
ZLWKDQDOPRVWDUWLFXODWHPXWWHULQJVFLQWLOODQWZLWKXQGUHDPHG
UDGLDQFHV7KHJORZWKDWKDGKHUDOGHGWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIWKHVHUYDQWV
KDGYDQLVKHGZLWKWKHP2QO\WKHOLJKWRIWKHMHZHOVLQWKHEUDVV
FKHVWVKLPPHUHGDQGTXLYHUHG
+HVQDWFKHGWKHFKHVWQRWLQJLWVFRQWHQWVLQRQHOXVWIXOJODQFH
VWUDQJHFXULRXVO\VKDSHQVWRQHVWKDWEXUQHGZLWKDQLF\QRQ
WHUUHVWULDOILUH+HVODPPHGWKHOLGWKUXVWWKHFKHVWXQGHUKLVDUP
DQGUDQEDFNXSWKHVWHSV+HKDGQRGHVLUHWRHQFRXQWHUWKHKHOOLVK
VHUYDQWVRI%LW<DNLQ+LVJOLPSVHRIWKHPLQDFWLRQKDGGLVSHOOHG
DQ\LOXVLRQFRQFHUQLQJWKHLUILJKWLQJDELOLW\:K\WKH\KDGZDLWHGVR
ORQJEHIRUHVWULNLQJDWWKHLQYDGHUVKHZDVXQDEOHWRVD\:KDWKXPDQ
FRXOGJXHVVWKHPRWLYHVRUWKRXJKWVRIWKHVHPRQVWURVLWLHV"7KDWWKH\
ZHUHSRVVHVVHGRIFUDIWDQGLQWHOOLJHQFHHTXDOWRKXPDQLW\KDGEHHQ
GHPRQVWUDWHG$QGWKHUHRQWKHFDYHUQIORRUOD\FULPVRQSURRIRI
WKHLUEHVWLDOIHURFLW\
7KH&RULQWKLDQJLUOVWLOOFRZHUHGRQWKHJDOOHU\ZKHUHKHKDGOHIW
KHU+HFDXJKWKHUZULVWDQG\DQNHGKHUWRKHUIHHWJUXQWLQJ,
JXHVVLW
VWLPHWRJR
7RREHPXVHGZLWKWHUURUWREHIXOO\DZDUHRIZKDWZDVJRLQJRQ
WKHJLUOVXIIHUHGKHUVHOIWREHOHGDFURVVWKHGL]]\VSDQ,WZDVQRW
XQWLOWKH\ZHUHSRLVHGRYHUWKHUXVKLQJZDWHUWKDWVKHORRNHGGRZQ
YRLFHGDVWDUWOHG\HOSDQGZRXOGKDYHIDOOHQEXWIRU&RQDQ
VPDVVLYH
DUPDERXWKHU*URZOLQJDQREMXUJDWLRQLQKHUHDUKHVQDWFKHGKHUXS
XQGHUKLVIUHHDUPDQGVZHSWKHULQDIOXWWHURIOLPSO\ZDYLQJDUPV
DQGOHJVDFURVVWKHDUFKDQGLQWRWKHDSHUWXUHWKDWRSHQHGDWWKH
RWKHUHQG:LWKRXWERWKHULQJWRVHWKHURQKHUIHHWKHKXUULHG
WKURXJKWKHVKRUWWXQQHOLQWRZKLFKWKLVDSHUWXUHRSHQHG$QLQVWDQW
ODWHUWKH\HPHUJHGXSRQDQDUURZOHGJHRQWKHRXWHUVLGHRIWKH
FOLIIVWKDWFLUFOHGWKHYDOOH\/HVVWKDQDKXQGUHGIHHWEHORZWKHP
WKHMXQJOHZDYHGLQWKHVWDUOLJKW
/RRNLQJGRZQ&RQDQYHQWHGDJXVW\VLJKRIUHOLHI+HEHOLHYHGKH
FRXOGQHJRWLDWHWKHGHVFHQWHYHQWKRXJKEXUGHQHGZLWKWKHMHZHOVDQG
WKHJLUODOWKRXJKKHGRXEWHGLIHYHQKHXQEXUGHQHGFRXOGKDYH
DVFHQGHGDWWKDWVSRW+HVHWWKHFKHVWVWLOOVPHDUHGZLWK*RUXOJD
V
EORRGDQGFORWWHGZLWKKLVEUDLQVRQWKHOHGJHDQGZDVDERXWWR
UHPRYHKLVJLUGOHLQRUGHUWRWLHWKHER[WRKLVEDFNZKHQKHZDV
JDOYDQL]HGE\DVRXQGEHKLQGKLPDVRXQGVLQLVWHUDQGXQPLVWDNDEOH
6WD\KHUHKHVQDSSHGDWWKHEHZLOGHUHG&RULQWKLDQJLUO'RQ
W
PRYH$QGGUDZLQJKLVVZRUGKHJOLGHGLQWRWKHWXQQHOJODULQJEDFN
LQWRWKHFDYHUQ
+DOIZD\DFURVVWKHXSSHUVSDQKHVDZDJUD\GHIRUPHGVKDSH2QH
RIWKHVHUYDQWVRI%LW<DNLQZDVRQKLVWUDLO7KHUHZDVQRGRXEW
WKDWWKHEUXWHKDGVHHQWKHPDQGZDVIROORZLQJWKHP&RQDQGLGQRW
KHVLWDWH,WPLJKWEHHDVLHUWRGHIHQGWKHPRXWKRIWKHWXQQHOEXW
WKLVILJKWPXVWEHILQLVKHGTXLFNO\EHIRUHWKHRWKHUVHUYDQWVFRXOG
UHWXUQ
+HUDQRXWRQWKHVSDQVWUDLJKWWRZDUGWKHRQFRPLQJPRQVWHU,W
ZDVQRDSHQHLWKHUZDVLWDPDQ,WZDVVRPHVKDPEOLQJKRUURU
VSDZQHGLQWKHP\VWHULRXVQDPHOHVVMXQJOHVRIWKHVRXWKZKHUH
VWUDQJHOLIHWHHPHGLQWKHUHHNLQJURWZLWKRXWWKHGRPLQDQFHRIPDQ
DQGGUXPVWKXQGHUHGLQWHPSOHVWKDWKDGQHYHUNQRZQWKHWUHDGRID
KXPDQIRRW+RZWKHDQFLHQW3HOLVKWLKDGJDLQHGORUGVKLSRYHUWKHP
DQGZLWKLWHWHUQDOH[LOHIURPKXPDQLW\ZDVDIRXOULGGOHDERXW
ZKLFK&RQDQGLGQRWFDUHWRVSHFXODWHHYHQLIKHKDGKDG
RSSRUWXQLW\
0DQDQGPRQVWHUWKH\PHWDWWKHKLJKHVWDUFKRIWKHVSDQZKHUH
DKXQGUHGIHHWEHORZUXVKHGWKHIXULRXVEODFNZDWHU$VWKH
PRQVWURXVVKDSHZLWKLWOHSURXVJUD\ERG\DQGWKHIHDWXUHVRID
FDUYHQXQKXPDQLGROORRPHGRYHUKLP&RQDQVWUXFNDVDZRXQGHGWLJHU
VWULNHVZLWKHYHU\RXQFHRIWKHZDQGIXU\EHKLQGWKHEORZ7KDW
VWURNHZRXOGKDYHVKHDUHGDKXPDQERG\DVXQGHUEXWWKHERQHVRIWKH
VHUYDQWRI%LW<DNLQZHUHOLNHWHPSHUHGVWHHO<HWHYHQWHPSHUHG
VWHHOFRXOGQRWZKROO\KDYHZLWKVWRRGWKDWIXULRXVVWURNH5LEVDQG
VKRXOGHUERQHSDUWHGDQGEORRGVSRXWHGIURPWKHJUHDWJDVK
7KHUHZDVQRWLPHIRUDVHFRQGVWURNH%HIRUHWKH&LPPHULDQFRXOG
OLIWKLVEODGHDJDLQRUVSULQJFOHDUWKHVZHHSRIDJLDQWDUP
NQRFNHGKLPIURPWKHVSDQDVDIO\LVIOLFNHGIURPDZDOO$VKH
SOXQJHGGRZQZDUGWKHUXVKRIWKHULYHUZDVOLNHDNQHOOLQKLVHDUV
EXWKLVWZLVWLQJERG\IHOOKDOIZD\DFURVVWKHORZHUDUFK+HZDYHUHG
WKHUHSUHFDULRXVO\IRURQHEORRGFKLOOLQJLQVWDQWWKHQKLVFOXWFKLQJ
ILQJHUVKRRNHGRYHUWKHIDUWKHUHGJHDQGKHVFUDPEOHGWRVDIHW\KLV
VZRUGVWLOOLQKLVRWKHUKDQG
$VKHVSUDQJXSKHVDZWKHPRQVWHUVSXUWLQJEORRGKLGHRXVO\
UXVKWRZDUGWKHFOLIIHQGRIWKHEULGJHREYLRXVO\LQWHQGLQJWR
GHVFHQGWKHVWDLUWKDWFRQQHFWHGWKHDUFKHVDQGUHQHZWKHIHXG$W
WKHYHU\OHGJHWKHEUXWHSDXVHGLQPLGIOLJKWDQG&RQDQVDZLWWRR
0XULHODZLWKWKHMHZHOFKHVWXQGHUKHUDUPVWRRGVWDULQJZLOGLQJ
LQWKHPRXWKRIWKHWXQQHO
:LWKDWULXPSKDQWEHOORZWKHPRQVWHUVFRRSHGKHUXSXQGHURQHDUP
VQDWFKHGWKHMHZHOFKHVWZLWKWKHRWKHUKDQGDVVKHGURSSHGLWDQG
WXUQLQJOXPEHUHGEDFNDFURVVWKHEULGJH&RQDQFXUVHGZLWKSDVVLRQ
DQGUDQIRUWKHRWKHUVLGHDOVR+HGRXEWHGLIKHFRXOGFOLPEWKH
VWDLUWRWKHKLJKHUDUFKLQWLPHWRFDWFKWKHEUXWHEHIRUHLWFRXOG
SOXQJHLQWRWKHODE\ULQWKVRIWXQQHOVRQWKHRWKHUVLGH
%XWWKHPRQVWHUZDVVORZLQJOLNHFORFNZRUNUXQQLQJGRZQ%ORRG
JXVKHGIURPWKDWWHUULEOHJDVKLQKLVEUHDVWDQGKHOXUFKHG
GUXQNHQO\IURPVLGHWRVLGH6XGGHQO\KHVWXPEOHGUHHOHGDQGWRSSOHG
VLGHZLVHSLWFKHGKHDGORQJIURPWKHDUFKDQGKXUWOHGGRZQZDUG*LUO
DQGMHZHOFKHVWIHOOIURPKLVQHUYHOHVVKDQGVDQG0XULHOD
VVFUHDP
UDQJWHUULEO\DERYHWKHVQDUORIWKHZDWHUEHORZ
&RQDQZDVDOPRVWXQGHUWKHVSRWIURPZKLFKWKHFUHDWXUHKDG
IDOOHQ7KHPRQVWHUVWUXFNWKHORZHUDUFKJODQFLQJO\DQGVKRWRII
EXWWKHZULWKLQJILJXUHRIWKHJLUOVWUXFNDQGFOXQJDQGWKHFKHVW
KLWWKHHGJHRIWKHVSDQQHDUKHU2QHIDOOLQJREMHFWVWUXFNRQRQH
VLGHRI&RQDQDQGRQHRQWKHRWKHU(LWKHUZDVZLWKLQDUP
VOHQJWK
IRUWKHIUDFWLRQRIDVSOLWVHFRQGWKHFKHVWWHHWHUHGRQWKHHGJHRI
WKHEULGJHDQG0XULHODFOXQJE\RQHDUPKHUIDFHWXUQHGGHVSHUDWHO\
WRZDUG&RQDQKHUH\HVGLODWHGZLWKWKHIHDURIGHDWKDQGKHUOLSV
SDUWHGLQDKDXQWLQJFU\RIGHVSDLU
&RQDQGLGQRWKHVLWDWHQRUGLGKHHYHQJODQFHWRZDUGWKHFKHVW
WKDWKHOGWKHZHDOWKRIDQHSRFK:LWKDTXLFNQHVVWKDWZRXOGKDYH
VKDPHGWKHVSULQJRIDKXQJU\MDJXDUKHVZRRSHGJUDVSHGWKHJLUO
V
DUPMXVWDVKHUILQJHUVVOLSSHGIURPWKHVPRRWKVWRQHDQGVQDWFKHG
KHUXSRQWKHVSDQZLWKRQHH[SORVLYHKHDYH7KHFKHVWWRSSOHGRQ
RYHUDQGVWUXFNWKHZDWHUQLQHW\IHHWEHORZZKHUHWKHERG\RIWKH
VHUYDQWRI%LW<DNLQKDGDOUHDG\YDQLVKHG$VSODVKDMHWWLQJIODVK
RIIRDPPDUNHGZKHUHWKH7HHWKRI*ZDKOXUGLVDSSHDUHGIRUHYHUIURP
WKHVLJKWRIPDQ
&RQDQVFDUFHO\ZDVWHGDGRZQZDUGJODQFH+HGDUWHGDFURVVWKHVSDQ
DQGUDQXSWKHFOLIIVWDLUOLNHDFDWFDUU\LQJWKHOLPSJLUODVLI
VKHKDGEHHQDQLQIDQW$KLGHRXVXOXODWLRQFDXVHGKLPWRJODQFHRYHU
KLVVKRXOGHUDVKHUHDFKHGWKHKLJKHUDUFKWRVHHWKHRWKHUVHUYDQWV
VWUHDPLQJEDFNLQWRWKHFDYHUQEHORZEORRGGULSSLQJIURPWKHLUEDUHG
IDQJV7KH\UDFHGXSWKHVWDLUWKDWZRXQGXSIURPWLHUWRWLHU
URDULQJYHQJHIXOO\EXWKHVOXQJWKHJLUOXQFHUHPRQLRXVO\RYHUKLV
VKRXOGHUGDVKHGWKURXJKWKHWXQQHODQGZHQWGRZQWKHFOLIIVOLNHDQ
DSHKLPVHOIGURSSLQJDQGVSULQJLQJIURPKROGWRKROGZLWKEUHDNQHFN
UHFNOHVVQHVV:KHQWKHILHUFHFRXQWHQDQFHVORRNHGRYHUWKHOHGJHRI
WKHDSHUWXUHLWZDVWRVHHWKH&LPPHULDQDQGWKHJLUOGLVDSSHDULQJ
LQWRWKHIRUHVWWKDWVXUURXQGHGWKHFOLIIV
:HOOVDLG&RQDQVHWWLQJWKHJLUORQKHUIHHWZLWKLQWKH
VKHOWHULQJVFUHHQRIEUDQFKHVZHFDQWDNHRXUWLPHQRZ,GRQ
W
WKLQNWKRVHEUXWHVZLOOIROORZXVRXWVLGHWKHYDOOH\$Q\ZD\,
YH
JRWDKRUVHWLHGDWDZDWHUKROHFORVHE\LIWKHOLRQVKDYHQ
WHDWHQ
KLP&URP
VGHYLOV:KDWDUH\RXFU\LQJDERXWBQRZ"B
6KHFRYHUHGKHUWHDUVWDLQHGIDFHZLWKKHUKDQGVDQGKHUVOLP
VKRXOGHUVVKRRNZLWKVREV
,ORVWWKHMHZHOVIRU\RXVKHZDLOHGPLVHUDEO\,WZDVP\
IDXOW,I,
GREH\HG\RXDQGVWD\HGRXWRQWKHOHGJHWKDWEUXWH
ZRXOGQHYHUKDYHVHHQPH<RXVKRXOGKDYHFDXJKWWKHJHPVDQGOHWPH
GURZQ
<HV,VXSSRVH,VKRXOGKHDJUHHG%XWIRUJHWLW1HYHUZRUU\
DERXWZKDW
VSDVW$QGVWRSFU\LQJZLOO\RX"7KDW
VEHWWHU&RPH
RQ
<RXPHDQ\RX
UHJRLQJWRNHHSPH"7DNHPHZLWK\RX"VKHDVNHG
KRSHIXOO\
:KDWHOVHGR\RXVXSSRVH,
GGRZLWK\RX"+HUDQDQDSSURYLQJ
JODQFHRYHUKHUILJXUHDQGJULQQHGDWWKHWRUQVNLUWZKLFKUHYHDOHGD
JHQHURXVH[SDQVHRIWHPSWLQJLYRU\WLQWHGFXUYHV,FDQXVHDQ
DFWUHVVOLNH\RX7KHUH
VQRXVHJRLQJEDFNWR.HVKLD7KHUH
V
QRWKLQJLQ.HVKDQQRZWKDW,ZDQW:H
OOJRWR3XQW7KHSHRSOHRI
3XQWZRUVKLSDQLYRU\ZRPDQDQGWKH\ZDVKJROGRXWRIWKHULYHUVLQ
ZLFNHUEDVNHWV,
OOWHOOWKHPWKDW.HVKDQLVLQWULJXLQJZLWK
7KXWPHNULWRHQVODYHWKHPZKLFKLVWUXHDQGWKDWWKHJRGVKDYH
VHQWPHWRSURWHFWWKHPIRUDERXWDKRXVHIXORIJROG,I,FDQ
PDQDJHWRVPXJJOH\RXLQWRWKHLUWHPSOHWRH[FKDQJHSODFHVZLWKWKHLU
LYRU\JRGGHVVZH
OOVNLQWKHPRXWRIWKHLUMDZWHHWKEHIRUHZHJHW
WKURXJKZLWKWKHP



%(<21'7+(%/$&.5,9(5


+HDGLQJIRU3XQWZLWK0XULHOD&RQDQFDUULHVRXWKLVVFKHPHIRU
UHOLHYLQJWKRVHZRUVKLSSHUVRIDQLYRU\JRGGHVVRIVRPHRIWKHLU
DEXQGDQWJROG+HWKHQFRQWLQXHVWR=HPEDEZHL,QWKHFLW\RIWKH
WZLQNLQJVKHMRLQVDWUDGLQJFDUDYDQZKLFKKHVTXLUHVQRUWKZDUG
DORQJWKHGHVHUWERUGHUVERUGHUVSDWUROOHGE\KLVRQHWLPH=XDJLU
PDUDXGHUVEULQJLQJLWVDIHO\LQWR6KHP+HFRQWLQXHVQRUWKZDUGV
DFURVVWKH+\ERULDQNLQJGRPVWRKLVEOHDNKRPHODQG&RQDQLVQRZ
DURXQGIRUW\ZLWKIHZVLJQVRIKLV\HDUVVDYHDPRUHGHOLEHUDWH
DSSURDFKWRZHQFKLQJDQGWKHSXUVXLWRIWURXEOH%DFNLQ&LPPHULDKH
ILQGVWKHVRQVRIKLVFRQWHPSRUDULHVUDLVLQJIDPLOLHVLQWKHLUWXUQ
DQGWHPSHULQJWKHLUQRUWKHUQKDUGLKRRGZLWKOLWWOHOX[XULHVZKLFK
ILOWHUXSIURPWKHVRIWHU+\ERULDQODQGV(YHQVRQR+\ERULDQ
FRORQLVWKDVFURVVHGWKH&LPPHULDQERUGHUVVLQFHWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRI
9HQDULXPPRUHWKDQWZRGHFDGHVEHIRUH1RZKRZHYHUWKH$TXLORQLDQV
DUHVSUHDGLQJZHVWZDUGWKURXJKWKH%RVVRQLDQ0DUFKHVLQWRWKH
IULQJHVRIWKH3LFWLVKZLOGHUQHVV6RWKLWKHUVHHNLQJZRUNIRUKLV
VZRUGJRHV&RQDQ+HHQUROOVDVDVFRXWDW)RUW7XVFHODQWKHODVW
$TXLORQLDQRXWSRVWRQWKHHDVWEDQNRIWKH%ODFN5LYHUGHHSLQ
3LFWLVKWHUULWRU\+HUHDILHUFHWULEDOZDUZLWKWKH3LFWVLVLQ
SURJUHVV


&RQDQ/RVHV+LV$[

7KHVWLOOQHVVRIWKHIRUHVWWUDLOZDVVRSULPHYDOWKDWWKHWUHDG
RIDVRIWERRWHGIRRWZDVDVWDUWOLQJGLVWXUEDQFH$WOHDVWLWVHHPHG
VRWRWKHHDUVRIWKHZD\IDUHUWKRXJKKHZDVPRYLQJDORQJWKHSDWK
ZLWKWKHFDXWLRQWKDWPXVWEHSUDFWLVHGE\DQ\PDQZKRYHQWXUHV
EH\RQG7KXQGHU5LYHU+HZDVD\RXQJPDQRIPHGLXPKHLJKWZLWKDQ
RSHQFRXQWHQDQFHDQGDPRSRIWRXVOHGWDZQ\KDLUXQFRQILQHGE\FDSRU
KHOPHW+LVJDUEZDVFRPPRQHQRXJKIRUWKDWFRXQWU\DFRDUVH
WXQLFEHOWHGDWWKHZDLVWVKRUWOHDWKHUEUHHFKHVEHQHDWKDQGVRIW
EXFNVNLQERRWVWKDWFDPHVKRUWRIWKHNQHH$NQLIHKLOWMXWWHGIURP
RQHERRWWRS7KHEURDGOHDWKHUEHOWVXSSRUWHGDVKRUWKHDY\VZRUG
DQGDEXFNVNLQSRXFK7KHUHZDVQRSHUWXUEDWLRQLQWKHZLGHH\HVWKDW
VFDQQHGWKHJUHHQZDOOVZKLFKIULQJHGWKHWUDLO7KRXJKQRWWDOOKH
ZDVZHOOEXLOWDQGWKHDUPVWKDWWKHVKRUWZLGHVOHHYHVRIWKHWXQLF
OHIWEDUHZHUHWKLFNZLWKFRUGHGPXVFOH
+HWUDPSHGLPSHUWXUEDEO\DORQJDOWKRXJKWKHODVWVHWWOHU
VFDELQ
OD\PLOHVEHKLQGKLPDQGHDFKVWHSZDVFDUU\LQJKLPQHDUHUWKHJULP
SHULOWKDWKXQJOLNHDEURRGLQJVKDGRZRYHUWKHDQFLHQWIRUHVW
+HZDVQRWPDNLQJDVPXFKQRLVHDVLWVHHPHGWRKLPWKRXJKKH
ZHOONQHZWKDWWKHIDLQWWUHDGRIKLVERRWHGIHHWZRXOGEHOLNHD
WRFVLQRIDODUPWRWKHILHUFHHDUVWKDWPLJKWEHOXUNLQJLQWKH
WUHDFKHURXVJUHHQIDVWQHVV+LVFDUHOHVVDWWLWXGHZDVQRWJHQXLQH
KLVH\HVDQGHDUVZHUHNHHQO\DOHUWHVSHFLDOO\KLVHDUVIRUQRJD]H
FRXOGSHQHWUDWHWKHOHDI\WDQJOHIRUPRUHWKDQDIHZIHHWLQHLWKHU
GLUHFWLRQ
%XWLWZDVLQVWLQFWPRUHWKDQDQ\ZDUQLQJE\WKHH[WHUQDOVHQVHV
ZKLFKEURXJKWKLPXSVXGGHQO\KLVKDQGRQKLVKLOW+HVWRRGVWRFN
VWLOOLQWKHPLGGOHRIWKHWUDLOXQFRQVFLRXVO\KROGLQJKLVEUHDWK
ZRQGHULQJZKDWKHKDGKHDUGDQGZRQGHULQJLILQGHHGKHKDGKHDUG
DQ\WKLQJ7KHVLOHQFHVHHPHGDEVROXWH1RWDVTXLUUHOFKDWWHUHGRU
ELUGFKLUSHG7KHQKLVJD]HIL[HGLWVHOIRQDPDVVRIEXVKHVEHVLGH
WKHWUDLODIHZ\DUGVDKHDGRIKLP7KHUHZDVQREUHH]H\HWKHKDG
VHHQDEUDQFKTXLYHU7KHVKRUWKDLUVRQKLVVFDOSSULFNOHGDQGKH
VWRRGIRUDQLQVWDQWXQGHFLGHGFHUWDLQWKDWDPRYHLQHLWKHU
GLUHFWLRQZRXOGEULQJGHDWKVWUHDNLQJDWKLPIURPWKHEXVKHV
$KHDY\FKRSSLQJFUXQFKVRXQGHGEHKLQGWKHOHDYHV7KHEXVKHVZHUH
VKDNHQYLROHQWO\DQGVLPXOWDQHRXVO\ZLWKWKHVRXQGDQDUURZDUFKHG
HUUDWLFDOO\IURPDPRQJWKHPDQGYDQLVKHGDPRQJWKHWUHHVDORQJWKH
WUDLO7KHZD\IDUHUJOLPSVHGLWVIOLJKWDVKHVSUDQJIUDQWLFDOO\WR
FRYHU
&URXFKLQJEHKLQGDWKLFNVWHPKLVVZRUGTXLYHULQJLQKLVILQJHUV
KHVDZWKHEXVKHVSDUWDQGDWDOOILJXUHVWHSSHGOHLVXUHO\LQWRWKH
WUDLO7KHWUDYHOOHUVWDUHGLQVXUSULVH7KHVWUDQJHUZDVFODGOLNH
KLPVHOILQUHJDUGWRERRWVDQGEUHHNVWKRXJKWKHODWWHUZHUHRIVLON
LQVWHDGRIOHDWKHU%XWKHZRUHDVOHHYHOHVVKDXEHUNRIGDUNPHVK
PDLOLQSODFHRIDWXQLFDQGDKHOPHWSHUFKHGRQKLVEODFNPDQH
7KDWKHOPHWKHOGWKHRWKHU
VJD]HLWZDVZLWKRXWDFUHVWEXW
DGRUQHGE\VKRUWEXOO
VKRUQV1RFLYLOL]HGKDQGHYHUIRUJHGWKDW
KHDGSLHFH1RUZDVWKHIDFHEHORZLWWKDWRIDFLYLOL]HGPDQGDUN
VFDUUHGZLWKVPROGHULQJEOXHH\HVLWZDVDIDFHDVXQWDPHGDVWKH
SULPRUGLDOIRUHVWZKLFKIRUPHGLWVEDFNJURXQG7KHPDQKHOGDEURDG
VZRUGLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGWKHHGJHZDVVPHDUHGZLWKFULPVRQ
&RPHRQRXWKHFDOOHGLQDQDFFHQWXQIDPLOLDUWRWKHZD\IDUHU
$OO
VVDIHQRZ7KHUHZDVRQO\RQHRIWKHGRJV&RPHRQRXW
7KHRWKHUHPHUJHGGXELRXVO\DQGVWDUHGDWWKHVWUDQJHU+HIHOW
FXULRXVO\KHOSOHVVDQGIXWLOHDVKHJD]HGRQWKHSURSRUWLRQVRIWKH
IRUHVWPDQWKHPDVVLYHLURQFODGEUHDVWDQGWKHDUPWKDWERUHWKH
UHGGHQHGVZRUGEXUQHGGDUNE\WKHVXQDQGULGJHGDQGFRUGHGZLWK
PXVFOHV+HPRYHGZLWKWKHGDQJHURXVHDVHRIDSDQWKHUKHZDVWRR
ILHUFHO\VXSSOHWREHDSURGXFWRIFLYLOL]DWLRQHYHQRIWKDWIULQJH
RIFLYLOL]DWLRQZKLFKFRPSRVHGWKHRXWHUIURQWLHUV
7XUQLQJKHVWHSSHGEDFNWRWKHKXVKHVDQGSXOOHGWKHPDSDUW
6WLOOQRWFHUWDLQMXVWZKDWKDGKDSSHQHGWKHZD\IDUHUIURPWKHHDVW
DGYDQFHGDQGVWDUHGGRZQLQWRWKHEXVKHV$PDQOD\WKHUHDVKRUW
GDUNWKLFNO\PXVFOHGPDQQDNHGH[FHSWIRUDORLQFORWKDQHFNODFH
RIKXPDQWHHWKDQGDEUDVVDUPOHW$VKRUWVZRUGZDVWKUXVWLQWRWKH
JLUGOHRIWKHORLQFORWKDQGRQHKDQGVWLOOJULSSHGDKHDY\EODFN
ERZ7KHPDQKDGORQJEODFNKDLUWKDWZDVDERXWDOOWKHZD\IDUHU
FRXOGWHOODERXWKLVKHDGIRUKLVIHDWXUHVZHUHDPDVNRIEORRGDQG
EUDLQV+LVVNXOOKDGEHHQVSOLWWRWKHWHHWK
$3LFWE\WKHJRGVH[FODLPHGWKHZD\IDUHU
7KHEXUQLQJEOXHH\HVWXUQHGXSRQKLP
$UH\RXVXUSULVHG"
:K\WKH\WROGPHDW9HOLWULXPDQGDJDLQDWWKHVHWWOHUV
FDELQV
DORQJWKHURDGWKDWWKHVHGHYLOVVRPHWLPHVVQHDNHGDFURVVWKH
ERUGHUEXW,GLGQ
WH[SHFWWRPHHWRQHWKLVIDULQWKHLQWHULRU
<RX
UHRQO\IRXUPLOHVHDVWRI%ODFN5LYHUWKHVWUDQJHU
LQIRUPHGKLP7KH\
YHEHHQVKRWZLWKLQDPLOHRI9HOLWULXP1R
VHWWOHUEHWZHHQ7KXQGHU5LYHUDQG)RUW7XVFHODQLVUHDOO\VDIH,
SLFNHGXSWKLVGRJ
VWUDLOWKUHHPLOHVVRXWKRIWKHIRUWWKLV
PRUQLQJDQG,
YHEHHQIROORZLQJKLPHYHUVLQFH,FDPHXSEHKLQGKLP
MXVWDVKHZDVGUDZLQJDQDUURZRQ\RX$QRWKHULQVWDQWDQGWKHUH
G
KDYHEHHQDVWUDQJHULQ+HOO%XW,VSRLOHGKLVDLPIRUKLP
7KHZD\IDUHUZDVVWDULQJZLGHH\HGDWWKHODUJHUPDQGXPEIRXQGHG
E\WKHUHDOL]DWLRQWKDWWKHPDQKDGDFWXDOO\WUDFNHGGRZQRQHRIWKH
IRUHVWGHYLOVDQGVODLQKLPXQVXVSHFWHG7KDWLPSOLHGZRRGVPDQVKLSRI
DTXDOLW\XQGUHDPHGHYHQIRU&RQDMRKDUD
<RXDUHRQHRIWKHIRUW
VJDUULVRQ"KHDVNHG
,
PQRVROGLHU,GUDZWKHSD\DQGUDWLRQVRIDQRIILFHURIWKH
OLQHEXW,GRP\ZRUNLQWKHZRRGV9DODQQXVNQRZV,
PRIPRUHXVH
UDQJLQJDORQJWKHULYHUWKDQFRRSHGXSLQWKHIRUW
&DVXDOO\WKHVOD\HUVKRYHGWKHERG\GHHSHULQWRWKHWKLFNHWVZLWK
KLVIRRWSXOOHGWKHEXVKHVWRJHWKHUDQGWXUQHGDZD\GRZQWKHWUDLO
7KHRWKHUIROORZHGKLP
0\QDPHLV%DOWKXVKHRIIHUHG,ZDVDW9HOLWULXPODVWQLJKW
,KDYHQ
WGHFLGHGZKHWKHU,
OOWDNHXSDKLGHRIODQGRUHQWHUIRUW
VHUYLFH
7KHEHVWODQGQHDU7KXQGHU5LYHULVDOUHDG\WDNHQJUXQWHGWKH
VOD\HU3OHQW\RIJRRGODQGEHWZHHQ6FDOS&UHHN\RXFURVVHGLWD
IHZPLOHVEDFNDQGWKHIRUWEXWWKDW
VJHWWLQJWRRGHYLOLVKFORVH
WRWKHULYHU7KH3LFWVVWHDORYHUWREXUQDQGPXUGHUDVWKDWRQH
GLG7KH\GRQ
WDOZD\VFRPHVLQJO\6RPHGD\WKH\
OOWU\WRVZHHSWKH
VHWWOHUVRXWRI&RQDMRKDUD$QGWKH\PD\VXFFHHGSUREDEO\ZLOO
VXFFHHG7KLVFRORQL]DWLRQEXVLQHVVLVPDGDQ\ZD\7KHUH
VSOHQW\RI
JRRGODQGHDVWRIWKH%RVVRQLDQPDUFKHV,IWKH$TXLORQLDQVZRXOGFXW
XSVRPHRIWKHELJHVWDWHVRIWKHLUEDURQVDQGSODQWZKHDWZKHUHQRZ
RQO\GHHUDUHKXQWHGWKH\ZRXOGQ
WKDYHWRFURVVWKHERUGHUDQGWDNH
WKHODQGRIWKH3LFWVDZD\IURPWKHP
7KDW
VTXHHUWDONIURPDPDQLQWKHVHUYLFHRIWKHJRYHUQRURI
&RQDMRKDUDREMHFWHG%DOWKXV
,W
VQRWKLQJWRPHWKHRWKHUUHWRUWHG,
PDPHUFHQDU\,VHOO
P\VZRUGWRWKHKLJKHVWELGGHU,QHYHUSODQWHGZKHDWDQGQHYHUZLOO
VRORQJDVWKHUHDUHRWKHUKDUYHVWVWREHUHDSHGZLWKWKHVZRUG%XW
\RX+\ERULDQVKDYHH[SDQGHGDVIDUDV\RX
OOEHDOORZHGWRH[SDQG
<RX
YHFURVVHGWKHPDUFKHVEXUQHGDIHZYLOODJHVH[WHUPLQDWHGDIHZ
FODQVDQGSXVKHGEDFNWKHIURQWLHUWR%ODFN5LYHUEXW,GRXEWLI
\RX
OOHYHQEHDEOHWRKROGZKDW\RX
YHFRQTXHUHGDQG\RX
OOQHYHU
SXVKWKHIURQWLHUDQ\IXUWKHUZHVWZDUG<RXULGLRWLFNLQJGRHVQ
W
XQGHUVWDQGFRQGLWLRQVKHUH+HZRQ
WVHQG\RXHQRXJKUHLQIRUFHPHQWV
DQGWKHUHDUHQRWHQRXJKVHWWOHUVWRZLWKVWDQGWKHVKRFNRID
FRQFHUWHGDWWDFNIURPDFURVVWKHULYHU
%XWWKH3LFWVDUHGLYLGHGLQWRVPDOOFODQVSHUVLVWHG%DOWKXV
7KH\
OOQHYHUXQLWH:HFDQZKLSDQ\VLQJOHFODQ
2UDQ\WKUHHRUIRXUFODQVDGPLWWHGWKHVOD\HU%XWVRPHGD\D
PDQZLOOULVHDQGXQLWHWKLUW\RUIRUW\FODQVMXVWDVZDVGRQHDPRQJ
WKH&LPPHULDQVZKHQWKH*XQGHUPHQWULHGWRSXVKWKHERUGHU
QRUWKZDUG\HDUVDJR7KH\WULHGWRFRORQL]HWKHVRXWKHUQPDUFKHVRI
&LPPHULDGHVWUR\HGDIHZVPDOOFODQVEXLOWDIRUWWRZQ9HQDULXP
\RX
YHKHDUGWKHWDOH
6R,KDYHLQGHHGUHSOLHG%DOWKXVZLQFLQJ7KHPHPRU\RIWKDW
UHGGLVDVWHUZDVDEODFNEORWLQWKHFKURQLFOHVRIDSURXGDQG
ZDUOLNHSHRSOH0\XQFOHZDVDW9HQDULXPZKHQWKH&LPPHULDQVVZDUPHG
RYHUWKHZDOOV+HZDVRQHRIWKHIHZZKRHVFDSHGWKDWVODXJKWHU
,
YHKHDUGKLPWHOOWKHWDOHPDQ\DWLPH7KHEDUEDULDQVVZHSWRXW
RIWKHKLOOVLQDUDYHQLQJKRUGHZLWKRXWZDUQLQJDQGVWRUPHG
9HQDULXPZLWKVXFKIXU\QRQHFRXOGVWDQGEHIRUHWKHP0HQZRPHQDQG
FKLOGUHQZHUHEXWFKHUHG9HQDULXPZDVUHGXFHGWRDPDVVRIFKDUUHG
UXLQVDVLWLVWRWKLVGD\7KH$TXLORQLDQVZHUHGULYHQEDFNDFURVV
WKHPDUFKHVDQGKDYHQHYHUVLQFHWULHGWRFRORQL]HWKH&LPPHULDQ
FRXQWU\%XW\RXVSHDNRI9HQDULXPIDPLOLDUO\3HUKDSV\RXZHUH
WKHUH"
,ZDVJUXQWHGWKHRWKHU,ZDVRQHRIWKHKRUGHWKDWVZDUPHG
RYHUWKHZDOOV,KDGQ
W\HWVHHQILIWHHQVQRZVEXWDOUHDG\P\QDPH
ZDVUHSHDWHGDERXWWKHFRXQFLOILUHV
%DOWKXVLQYROXQWDULO\UHFRLOHGVWDULQJ,WVHHPHGLQFUHGLEOHWKDW
WKHPDQZDONLQJWUDQTXLOO\DWKLVVLGHVKRXOGKDYHEHHQRQHRIWKRVH
VFUHHFKLQJEORRGPDGGHYLOVWKDWSRXUHGRYHUWKHZDOOVRI9HQDULXP
RQWKDWORQJJRQHGD\WRPDNHKHUVWUHHWVUXQFULPVRQ
7KHQ\RXWRRDUHDEDUEDULDQKHH[FODLPHGLQYROXQWDULO\
7KHRWKHUQRGGHGZLWKRXWWDNLQJRIIHQVH
,DP&RQDQD&LPPHULDQ
,
YHKHDUGRI\RX)UHVKLQWHUHVWTXLFNHQHG%DOWKXV
JD]H1R
ZRQGHUWKH3LFWKDGIDOOHQYLFWLPWRKLVRZQVRUWRIVXEWOHW\7KH
&LPPHULDQVZHUHEDUEDULDQVDVIHURFLRXVDVWKH3LFWVDQGPXFKPRUH
LQWHOOLJHQW(YLGHQWO\&RQDQKDGVSHQWPXFKWLPHDPRQJFLYLOL]HGPHQ
WKRXJKWKDWFRQWDFWKDGREYLRXVO\QRWVRIWHQHGKLPQRUZHDNHQHGDQ\
RIKLVSULPLWLYHLQVWLQFWV%DOWKXV
DSSUHKHQVLRQWXUQHGWR
DGPLUDWLRQDVKHPDUNHGWKHHDV\FDWOLNHVWULGHWKHHIIRUWOHVV
VLOHQFHZLWKZKLFKWKH&LPPHULDQPRYHGDORQJWKHWUDLO7KHRLOHG
OLQNVRIKLVDUPRUGLGQRWFOLQNDQG%DOWKXVNQHZ&RQDQFRXOGJOLGH
WKURXJKWKHGHHSHVWWKLFNHWRUPRVWWDQJOHGFRSVHDVQRLVHOHVVO\DV
DQ\QDNHG3LFWWKDWHYHUOLYHG
<RX
UHQRWD*XQGHUPDQ",WZDVPRUHDVVHUWLRQWKDQTXHVWLRQ
%DOWKXVVKRRNKLVKHDG,
PIURPWKH7DXUDQ
,
YHVHHQJRRGZRRGVPHQIURPWKH7DXUDQ%XWWKH%RVVRQLDQVKDYH
VKHOWHUHG\RX$TXLORQLDQVIURPWKHRXWHUZLOGHUQHVVIRUWRRPDQ\
FHQWXULHV<RXQHHGKDUGHQLQJ
7KDWZDVWUXHWKH%RVVRQLDQPDUFKHVZLWKWKHLUIRUWLLHGYLOODJHV
ILOOHGZLWKGHWHUPLQHGERZPHQKDGORQJVHUYHG$TXLORQLDDVDEXIIHU
DJDLQVWWKHRXWO\LQJEDUEDULDQV1RZDPRQJWKHVHWWOHUVEH\RQG
7KXQGHU5LYHUKHUHZDVJURZLQJXSDEUHHGRIIRUHVWPHQFDSDEOHRI
PHHWLQJWKHEDUEDULDQVDWWKHLURZQJDPHEXWWKHLUQXPEHUVZHUH
VWLOOVFDQW\0RVWRIWKHIURQWLHUVPHQZHUHOLNH%DOWKXVPRUHRI
WKHVHWWOHUWKDQWKHZRRGVPDQW\SH
7KHVXQKDGQRWVHWEXWLWZDVQRORQJHULQVLJKWKLGGHQDVLW
ZDVEHKLQGWKHGHQVHIRUHVWZDOO7KHVKDGRZVZHUHOHQJWKHQLQJ
GHHSHQLQJEDFNLQWKHZRRGVDVWKHFRPSDQLRQVVWURGHRQGRZQWKH
WUDLO
,WZLOOEHGDUNEHIRUHZHUHDFKWKHIRUWFRPPHQWHG&RQDQ
FDVXDOO\WKHQ/LVWHQ
+HVWRSSHGVKRUWKDOIFURXFKLQJVZRUGUHDG\WUDQVIRUPHGLQWRD
VDYDJHILJXUHRIVXVSLFLRQDQGPHQDFHSRLVHGWRVSULQJDQGUHQG
%DOWKXVKDGKHDUGLWWRRDZLOGVFUHDPWKDWEURNHDWLWVKLJKHVW
QRWH,WZDVWKHFU\RIDPDQLQGLUHIHDURUDJRQ\
&RQDQZDVRIILQDQLQVWDQWUDFLQJGRZQWKHWUDLOHDFKVWULGH
ZLGHQLQJWKHGLVWDQFHEHWZHHQKLPDQGKLVVWUDLQLQJFRPSDQLRQ
%DOWKXVSXIIHGDFXUVH$PRQJWKHVHWWOHPHQWVRIWKH7DXUDQKHZDV
DFFRXQWHGDJRRGUXQQHUEXW&RQDQZDVOHDYLQJKLPEHKLQGZLWK
PDGGHQLQJHDVH7KHQ%DOWKXVIRUJRWKLVH[DVSHUDWLRQDVKLVHDUVZHUH
RXWUDJHGE\WKHPRVWIULJKWIXOFU\KHKDGHYHUKHDUG,WZDVQRW
KXPDQWKLVRQHLWZDVDGHPRQLDFDOFDWHUZDXOLQJRIKLGHRXVWULXPSK
WKDWVHHPHGWRH[XOWRYHUIDOOHQKXPDQLW\DQGILQGHFKRLQEODFN
JXOIVEH\RQGKXPDQNHQ
%DOWKXVIDOWHUHGLQKLVVWULGHDQGFODPP\VZHDWEHDGHGKLVIOHVK
%XW&RQDQGLGQRWKHVLWDWHKHGDUWHGDURXQGDEHQGLQWKHWUDLODQG
GLVDSSHDUHGDQG%DOWKXVSDQLFN\DWILQGLQJKLPVHOIDORQHZLWKWKDW
DZIXOVFUHDPVWLOOVKXGGHULQJWKURXJKWKHIRUHVWLQJULVO\HFKRHV
SXWRQDQH[WUDEXUVWRIVSHHGDQGSOXQJHGDIWHUKLP
7KH$TXLORQLDQVOLGWRDVWXPEOLQJKDOWDOPRVWFROOLGLQJZLWKWKH
&LPPHULDQZKRVWRRGLQWKHWUDLORYHUDFUXPSOHGERG\%XW&RQDQZDV
QRWORRNLQJDWWKHFRUSVHZKLFKOD\WKHUHLQWKHFULPVRQVRDNHGGXVW
+HZDVJODULQJLQWRWKHGHHSZRRGVRQHLWKHUVLGHRIWKHWUDLO
%DOWKXVPXWWHUHGDKRUULILHGRDWK,WZDVWKHERG\RIDPDQZKLFK
OD\WKHUHLQWKHWUDLODVKRUWIDWPDQFODGLQWKHJLOWZRUNHG
ERRWVDQGGHVSLWHWKHKHDWWKHHUPLQHWULPPHGWXQLFRIDZHDOWK\
PHUFKDQW+LVIDWSDOHIDFHZDVVHWLQDVWDUHRIIUR]HQKRUURUKLV
WKLFNWKURDWKDGEHHQVODVKHGIURPHDUWRHDUDVLIE\DUD]RUVKDUS
EODGH7KHVKRUWVZRUGVWLOOLQLWVVFDEEDUGVHHPHGWRLQGLFDWHWKDW
KHKDGEHHQVWUXFNGRZQZLWKRXWDFKDQFHWRILJKWIRUKLVOLIH
$3LFW"%DOWKXVZKLVSHUHGDVKHWXUQHGWRSHHULQWRWKH
GHHSHQLQJVKDGRZVRIWKHIRUHVW
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDGDQGVWUDLJKWHQHGWRVFRZOGRZQDWWKHGHDG
PDQ
$IRUHVWGHYLO7KLVLVWKHILIWKE\&URP
:KDWGR\RXPHDQ"
'LG\RXHYHUKHDURID3LFWLVKZL]DUGFDOOHG=RJDU6DJ"
%DOWKXVVKRRNKLVKHDGXQHDVLO\
+HGZHOOVLQ*ZDZHODWKHQHDUHVWYLOODJHDFURVVWKHULYHU7KUHH
PRQWKVDJRKHKLGEHVLGHWKLVURDGDQGVWROHDVWULQJRISDFNPXOHV
IURPDSDFNWUDLQERXQGIRUWKHIRUWGUXJJHGWKHLUGULYHUV
VRPHKRZ7KHPXOHVEHORQJHGWRWKLVPDQ&RQDQFDVXDOO\LQGLFDWHG
WKHFRUSVHZLWKKLVIRRW7LEHULDVDPHUFKDQWRI9HOLWULXP7KH\
ZHUHORDGHGZLWKDOHNHJVDQGROG=RJDUVWRSSHGWRJX]]OHEHIRUHKH
JRWDFURVVWKHULYHU$ZRRGVPDQQDPHG6RUDFWXVWUDLOHGKLPDQGOHG
9DODQQXVDQGWKUHHVROGLHUVWRZKHUHKHOD\GHDGGUXQNLQDWKLFNHW
$WWKHLPSRUWXQLWLHVRI7LEHULDV9DODQQXVWKUHZ=RJDU6DJLQWRD
FHOOZKLFKLVWKHZRUVWLQVXOW\RXFDQJLYHD3LFW+HPDQDJHGWR
NLOOKLVJXDUGDQGHVFDSHDQGVHQWEDFNZRUGWKDWKHPHDQWWRNLOO
7LEHULDVDQGWKHILYHPHQZKRFDSWXUHGKLPLQDZD\WKDWZRXOGPDNH
$TXLORQLDQVVKXGGHUIRUFHQWXULHVWRFRPH
:HOO6RUDFWXVDQGWKHVROGLHUVDUHGHDG6RUDFWXVZDVNLOOHGRQ
WKHULYHUWKHVROGLHUVLQWKHYHU\VKDGRZRIWKHIRUW$QGQRZ
7LEHULDVLVGHDG1R3LFWNLOOHGDQ\RIWKHP(DFKYLFWLPH[FHSW
7LEHULDVDV\RXVHHODFNHGKLVKHDGZKLFKQRGRXEWLVQRZ
RUQDPHQWLQJWKHDOWDURI=RJDU6DJ
VSDUWLFXODUJRG
+RZGR\RXNQRZWKH\ZHUHQ
WNLOOHGE\WKH3LFWV"GHPDQGHG
%DOWKXV
&RQDQSRLQWHGWRWKHFRUSVHRIWKHPHUFKDQW
<RXWKLQNWKDWZDVGRQHZLWKDNQLIHRUDVZRUG"/RRNFORVHUDQG
\RX
OOVHHWKDWRQO\DWDORQFRXOGKDYHPDGHDJDVKOLNHWKDW7KH
IOHVKLVULSSHGQRWFXW
3HUKDSVDSDQWKHUEHJDQ%DOWKXVZLWKRXWFRQYLFWLRQ
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDGLPSDWLHQWO\
$PDQIURPWKH7DXUDQFRXOGQ
WPLVWDNHWKHPDUNRIDSDQWKHU
V
FODZV1R,W
VDIRUHVWGHYLOVXPPRQHGE\=RJDU6DJWRFDUU\RXWKLV
UHYHQJH7LEHULDVZDVDIRROWRVWDUWIRU9HOLWULXPDORQHDQGVR
FORVHWRGXVN%XWHDFKRQHRIWKHYLFWLPVVHHPHGWREHVPLWWHQZLWK
PDGQHVVMXVWEHIRUHGRRPRYHUWRRNKLP/RRNKHUHWKHVLJQVDUHSODLQ
HQRXJK7LEHULDVFDPHULGLQJDORQJWKHWUDLORQKLVPXOHPD\EHZLWK
DEXQGOHRIFKRLFHRWWHUSHOWVEHKLQGKLVVDGGOHWRVHOOLQ
9HOLWULXPDQGWKHWKLQJVSUDQJRQKLPIURPEHKLQGWKDWEXVK6HH
ZKHUHWKHEUDQFKHVDUHFUXVKHGGRZQ
7LEHULDVJDYHRQHVFUHDPDQGWKHQKLVWKURDWZDVWRUQRSHQDQG
KHZDVVHOOLQJKLVRWWHUVNLQVLQ+HOO7KHPXOHUDQDZD\LQWRWKH
ZRRGV/LVWHQ(YHQQRZ\RXFDQKHDUKLPWKUDVKLQJDERXWXQGHUWKH
WUHHV7KHGHPRQGLGQ
WKDYHWLPHWRWDNH7LEHULDV
KHDGLWWRRN
IULJKWDVZHFDPHXS
$V\RXFDPHXSDPHQGHG%DOWKXV,WPXVWQRWEHDYHU\WHUULEOH
FUHDWXUHLILWIOHHVIURPRQHDUPHGPDQ%XWKRZGR\RXNQRZLWZDV
QRWD3LFWZLWKVRPHNLQGRIDKRRNWKDWULSVLQVWHDGRIVOLFLQJ"'LG
\RXVHHLW"
7LEHULDVZDVDQDUPHGPDQJUXQWHG&RQDQ,I=RJDU6DJFDQ
EULQJGHPRQVWRDLGKLPKHFDQWHOOWKHPZKLFKPHQWRNLOODQGZKLFK
WROHWDORQH1R,GLGQ
WVHHLW,RQO\VDZWKHEXVKHVVKDNHDVLW
OHIWWKHWUDLO%XWLI\RXZDQWIXUWKHUSURRIORRNKHUH
7KHVOD\HUKDGVWHSSHGLQWRWKHSRRORIEORRGLQZKLFKWKHGHDG
PDQVSUDZOHG8QGHUWKHEXVKHVDWWKHHGJHRIWKHSDWKWKHUHZDVD
IRRWSULQWPDGHLQEORRGRQWKHKDUGORDP
'LGDPDQPDNHWKDW"GHPDQGHG&RQDQ
%DOWKXVIHOWKLVVFDOSSULFNOH1HLWKHUPDQQRUDQ\EHDVWWKDWKH
KDGHYHUVHHQFRXOGKDYHOHIWWKDWVWUDQJHPRQVWURXVWKUHHWRHG
SULQWWKDWZDVFXULRXVO\FRPELQHGRIWKHELUGDQGWKHUHSWLOH\HWD
WUXHW\SHRIQHLWKHU+HVSUHDGKLVILQJHUVDERYHWKHSULQWFDUHIXO
QRWWRWRXFKLWDQGJUXQWHGH[SORVLYHO\+HFRXOGQRWVSDQWKHPDUN
:KDWLVLW"KHZKLVSHUHG,QHYHUVDZDEHDVWWKDWOHIWDVSRRU
OLNHWKDW
1RUDQ\RWKHUVDQHPDQDQVZHUHG&RQDQJULPO\,W
VDVZDPS
GHPRQWKH\
UHWKLFNDVEDWVLQWKHVZDPSVEH\RQG%ODFN5LYHU<RX
FDQKHDUWKHPKRZOLQJOLNHGDPQHGVRXOVZKHQWKHZLQGEORZVVWURQJ
IURPWKHVRXWKRQKRWQLJKWV
:KDWVKDOOZHGR"DVNHGWKH$TXLORQLDQSHHULQJXQHDVLO\LQWR
WKHGHHSEOXHVKDGRZV7KHIUR]HQIHDURQWKHGHDGFRXQWHQDQFH
KDXQWHGKLP+HZRQGHUHGZKDWKLGHRXVKHDGWKHZUHWFKKDGVHHQWKUXVW
JULQQLQJIURPDPRQJWKHOHDYHVWRFKLOOKLVEORRGZLWKWHUURU
1RXVHWRWU\WRIROORZDGHPRQJUXQWHG&RQDQGUDZLQJDVKRUW
ZRRGPDQ
VD[IURPKLVJLUGOH,WULHGWUDFNLQJKLPDIWHUKHNLOOHG
6RUDFWXV,ORVWKLVWUDLOZLWKLQDGR]HQVWHSV+HPLJKWKDYHJURZQ
KLPVHOIZLQJVDQGIORZQDZD\RUVXQNGRZQWKURXJKWKHHDUWKWR+HOO
,GRQ
WNQRZ,
PQRWJRLQJDIWHUWKHPXOHHLWKHU,W
OOHLWKHU
ZDQGHUEDFNWRWKHIRUWRUWRVRPHVHWWOHU
VFDELQ
$VKHVSRNH&RQDQZDVEXV\DWWKHHGJHRIWKHWUDLOZLWKKLVD[
:LWKDIHZVWURNHVKHFXWDSDLURIVDSOLQJVQLQHRUWHQIHHWORQJ
DQGGHQXGHGWKHPRIWKHLUEUDQFKHV7KHQKHFXWDOHQJWKIURPD
VHUSHQWOLNHYLQHWKDWFUDZOHGDPRQJWKHEXVKHVQHDUE\DQGPDNLQJ
RQHHQGIDVWWRRQHRIWKHSROHVDFRXSOHRIIHHWIURPWKHHQG
ZKLSSHGWKHYLQHRYHUWKHRWKHUVDSOLQJDQGLQWHUODFHGLWEDFNDQG
IRUWK,QDIHZPRPHQWVKHKDGDFUXGHEXWVWURQJOLWWHU
7KHGHPRQLVQ
WJRLQJWRJHW7LEHULDV
KHDGLI,FDQKHOSLWKH
JURZOHG:H
OOFDUU\WKHERG\LQWRWKHIRUW,WLVQ
WPRUHWKDQ
WKUHHPLOHV,QHYHUOLNHGWKHIDWIRROEXWZHFDQ
WKDYH3LFWLVK
GHYLOVPDNLQJVRFXUVHGIUHHZLWKZKLWHPHQ
VKHDGV
7KH3LFWVZHUHDZKLWHUDFHWKRXJKVZDUWK\EXWWKHERUGHUPHQ
QHYHUVSRNHRIWKHPDVVXFK
%DOWKXVWRRNWKHUHDUHQGRIWKHOLWWHURQWRZKLFK&RQDQ
XQFHUHPRQLRXVO\GXPSHGWKHXQIRUWXQDWHPHUFKDQWDQGWKH\PRYHGRQ
GRZQWKHWUDLODVVZLIWO\DVSRVVLEOH&RQDQPDGHQRPRUHQRLVHODGHQ
ZLWKWKHLUJULPEXUGHQWKDQKHKDGPDGHZKHQXQHQFXPEHUHG+HKDG
PDGHDORRSZLWKWKHPHUFKDQW
VEHOWDWWKHHQGRIWKHSROHVDQGZDV
FDUU\LQJKLVVKDUHRIWKHORDGZLWKRQHKDQGZKLOHWKHRWKHUJULSSHG
KLVQDNHGEURDGVZRUGDQGKLVUHVWOHVVJD]HURYHGWKHVLQLVWHUZDOOV
DERXWWKHP7KHVKDGRZVZHUHWKLFNHQLQJ$GDUNHQLQJEOXHPLVW
EOXUUHGWKHRXWOLQHVRIWKHIROLDJH7KHIRUHVWGHHSHQHGLQWKH
WZLOLJKWEHFDPHDEOXHKDXQWRIP\VWHU\VKHOWHULQJXQJXHVVHGWKLQJV
7KH\KDGFRYHUHGPRUHWKDQDPLOHDQGWKHPXVFOHVLQ%DOWKXV

VWXUG\DUPVZHUHEHJLQQLQJWRDFKHDOLWWOHZKHQDFU\UDQJ
VKXGGHULQJIURPWKHZRRGVZKRVHEOXHVKDGRZVZHUHGHHSHQLQJLQWR
SXUSOH
&RQDQVWDUWHGFRQYXOVLYHO\DQG%DOWKXVDOPRVWOHWJRWKHSROHV
$ZRPDQFULHGWKH\RXQJHUPDQ*UHDW0LWUDDZRPDQFULHGRXW
WKHQ
$VHWWOHU
VZLIHVWUD\LQJLQWKHZRRGVVQDUOHG&RQDQVHWWLQJ
GRZQKLVHQGRIWKHOLIWHU/RRNLQJIRUDFRZSUREDEO\DQGVWD\
KHUH
+HGLYHGOLNHDKXQWLQJZROILQWRWKHOHDI\ZDOO%DOWKXV
KDLU
EULVWOHG
6WD\KHUHDORQHZLWKWKLVFRUSVHDQGDGHYLOKLGLQJLQWKH
ZRRGV"KH\HOSHG,
PFRPLQJZLWK\RX
$QGVXLWLQJDFWLRQWRZRUGVKHSOXQJHGDIWHUWKH&LPPHULDQ&RQDQ
JODQFHGEDFNDWKLPEXWPDGHQRREMHFWLRQWKRXJKKHGLGQRW
PRGHUDWHKLVSDFHWRDFFRPPRGDWHWKHVKRUWHUOHJVRIKLVFRPSDQLRQ
%DOWKXVZDVWHGKLVZLQGLQVZHDULQJDVWKH&LPPHULDQGUHZDZD\IURP
KLPDJDLQOLNHDSKDQWRPEHWZHHQWKHWUHHVDQGWKHQ&RQDQEXUVW
LQWRDGLPJODGHDQGKDOWHGFURXFKLQJOLSVVQDUOLQJVZRUGOLIWHG
:KDWDUHZHVWRSSLQJIRU"SDQWHG%DOWKXVGDVKLQJWKHVZHDWRXW
RIKLVH\HVDQGJULSSLQJKLVVKRUWVZRUG
7KDWVFUHDPFDPHIURPWKLVJODGHRUQHDUE\DQVZHUHG&RQDQ,
GRQ
WPLVWDNHWKHORFDWLRQRIVRXQGVHYHQLQWKHZRRGV%XWZKHUH
$EUXSWO\WKHVRXQGUDQJRXWDJDLQBEHKLQGWKHPBLQWKH
GLUHFWLRQRIWKHWUDLOWKH\KDGMXVWTXLWWHG,WURVHSLHUFLQJO\DQG
SLWLIXOO\WKHFU\RIDZRPDQLQIUDQWLFWHUURUDQGWKHQ
VKRFNLQJO\LWFKDQJHGWRD\HOORIPRFNLQJODXJKWHUWKDWPLJKWKDYH
EXUVWIURPWKHOLSVRIDILHQGRIORZHU+HOO
:KDWLQ0LWUD
VQDPH%DOWKXV
IDFHZDVDSDOHEOXULQWKH
JORRP
:LWKDVFRUFKLQJRDWK&RQDQZKHHOHGDQGGDVKHGEDFNWKHZD\KHKDG
FRPHDQGWKH$TXLORQLDQVWXPEOHGEHZLOGHUHGO\DIWHUKLP+H
EOXQGHUHGLQWRWKH&LPPHULDQDVWKHODWWHUVWRSSHGGHDGDQG
UHERXQGHGIURPKLVEUDZQ\VKRXOGHUVDVWKRXJKIURPDQLURQVWDWXH
*DVSLQJIURPWKHLPSDFWKHKHDUG&RQDQ
VEUHDWKKLVVWKURXJKKLV
WHHWK7KH&LPPHULDQVHHPHGIUR]HQLQKLVWUDFNV
/RRNLQJRYHUKLVVKRXOGHU%DOWKXVIHOWKLVKDLUVWDQGXSVWLIIO\
6RPHWKLQJZDVPRYLQJWKURXJKWKHGHHSEXVKHVWKDWIULQJHGWKHWUDLO
VRPHWKLQJWKDWQHLWKHUZDONHGQRUIOHZEXWVHHPHGWRJOLGHOLNHD
VHUSHQW%XWLWZDVQRWDVHUSHQW,WVRXWOLQHVZHUHLQGLVWLQFWEXW
LWZDVWDOOHUWKDQDPDQDQGQRWYHU\EXON\,WJDYHRIIDJOLPPHU
RIZHLUGOLJKWOLNHDIDLQWEOXHIODPH,QGHHGWKHHHU\ILUHZDV
WKHRQO\WDQJLEOHWKLQJDERXWLW,WPLJKWKDYHEHHQDQHPERGLHG
IODPHPRYLQJZLWKUHDVRQDQGSXUSRVHWKURXJKWKHEODFNHQLQJZRRGV
&RQDQVQDUOHGDVDYDJHFXUVHDQGKXUOHGKLVD[ZLWKIHURFLRXV
ZLOO%XWWKHWKLQJJOLGHGRQZLWKRXWDOWHULQJLWVFRXUVH,QGHHGLW
ZDVRQO\DIHZLQVWDQWV
IOHHWLQJJOLPSVHWKH\KDGRILWDWDOO
VKDGRZ\WKLQJRIPLVW\IODPHIORDWLQJWKURXJKWKHWKLFNHWV7KHQLW
ZDVJRQHDQGWKHIRUHVWFURXFKHGLQEUHDWKOHVVVWLOOQHVV
:LWKDVQDUO&RQDQSOXQJHGWKURXJKWKHLQWHUYHQLQJIROLDJHDQG
LQWRWKHWUDLO+LVSURIDQLW\DV%DOWKXVIORXQGHUHGDIWHUKLPZDV
OXULGDQGLPSDVVLRQHG7KH&LPPHULDQZDVVWDQGLQJRYHUWKHOLWWHURQ
ZKLFKOD\WKHERG\RI7LEHULDV$QGWKDWERG\QRORQJHUSRVVHVVHGD
KHDG
7ULFNHGXVZLWKLWVGDPQDEOHFDWHUZDXOLQJUDYHG&RQDQVZLQJLQJ
KLVJUHDWVZRUGDERXWKLVKHDGLQKLVZUDWK,PLJKWKDYHNQRZQ,
PLJKWKDYHJXHVVHGDWULFN1RZWKHUH
OOEHILYHKHDGVWRGHFRUDWH
=RJDU
VDOWDU
%XWZKDWWKLQJLVLWWKDWFDQFU\OLNHDZRPDQDQGODXJKOLNHD
GHYLODQGVKLQHVOLNHZLWFKILUHDVLWJOLGHVWKURXJKWKHWUHHV"
JDVSHG%DOWKXVPRSSLQJWKHVZHDWIURPKLVSDOHIDFH
$VZDPSGHYLOUHVSRQGHG&RQDQPRURVHO\*UDEWKRVHSROHV
:H
OOWDNHLQWKHERG\DQ\ZD\$WOHDVWRXUORDG
VDELWOLJKWHU
:LWKZKLFKJULPSKLORVRSK\KHJULSSHGWKHOHDWKHU\ORRSDQG
VWDONHGGRZQWKHWUDLO


7KH:L]DUGRI*ZDZHOD

)RUW7XVFHODQVWRRGRQWKHHDVWHUQEDQNRI%ODFN5LYHUWKHWLGHV
RIZKLFKZDVKHGWKHIRRWRIWKHVWRFNDGH7KHODWWHUZDVRIORJVDV
ZHUHDOOWKHEXLOGLQJVZLWKLQLQFOXGLQJWKHGRQMRQWRGLJQLI\LWE\
WKDWDSSHOODWLRQLQZKLFKZHUHWKHJRYHUQRU
VTXDUWHUVRYHUORRNLQJ
WKHVWRFNDGHDQGWKHVXOOHQULYHU%H\RQGWKDWULYHUOD\DKXJH
IRUHVWZKLFKDSSURDFKHGMXQJOHOLNHGHQVLW\DORQJWKHVSRQJ\VKRUHV
0HQSDFHGWKHUXQZD\VDORQJWKHORJSDUDSHWGD\DQGQLJKWZDWFKLQJ
WKDWGHQVHJUHHQZDOO6HOGRPDPHQDFLQJILJXUHDSSHDUHGEXWWKH
VHQWULHVNQHZWKDWWKH\WRRZHUHZDWFKHGILHUFHO\KXQJULO\ZLWK
WKHPHUFLOHVVQHVVRIDQFLHQWKDWH7KHIRUHVWEH\RQGWKHULYHUPLJKW
VHHPGHVRODWHDQGYDFDQWRIOLIHWRWKHLJQRUDQWH\HEXWOLIHWHHPHG
WKHUHQRWDORQHRIELUGDQGEHDVWDQGUHSWLOHEXWDOVRRIPHQWKH
ILHUFHVWRIDOOWKHKXQWLQJEHDVWV
7KHUHDWWKHIRUWFLYLOL]DWLRQHQGHG)RUW7XVFHODQZDVWKHODVW
RXWSRVWRIDFLYLOL]HGZRUOGLWUHSUHVHQWHGWKHZHVWHUQPRVWWKUXVW
RIWKHGRPLQDQW+\ERULDQUDFHV%H\RQGWKHULYHUWKHSULPLWLYHVWLOO
UHLJQHGLQVKDGRZ\IRUHVWVEUXVKWKDWFKHGKXWVZKHUHKXQJWKH
JULQQLQJVNXOOVRIPHQDQGPXGZDOOHGHQFORVXUHVZKHUHILUHV
IOLFNHUHGDQGGUXPVUXPEOHGDQGVSHDUVZHUHZKHWWHGLQWKHKDQGVRI
GDUNVLOHQWPHQZLWKWDQJOHGEODFNKDLUDQGWKHH\HVRIVHUSHQWV
7KRVHH\HVRIWHQJODUHGWKURXJKEXVKHVDWWKHIRUWDFURVVWKHULYHU
2QFHGDUNVNLQQHGPHQKDGEXLOWWKHLUKXWVZKHUHWKDWIRUWVWRRG
\HVDQGWKHLUKXWVKDGULVHQZKHUHQRZVWRRGWKHILHOGVDQGORJ
FDELQVRIIDLUKDLUHGVHWWOHUVEDFNEH\RQG9HOLWULXPWKDWUDZ
WXUEXOHQWIURQWLHUWRZQRQWKHEDQNVRI7KXQGHU5LYHUWRWKHVKRUHV
RIWKDWRWKHUULYHUWKDWERXQGVWKH%RVVRQLDQPDUFKHV7UDGHUVKDG
FRPHDQGSULHVWVRI0LWUDZKRZDONHGZLWKEDUHIHHWDQGHPSW\KDQGV
DQGGLHGKRUULEO\PRVWRIWKHPEXWVROGLHUVKDGIROORZHGPHQZLWK
D[HVLQWKHLUKDQGVDQGZRPHQDQGFKLOGUHQLQR[GUDZQZDLQV%DFNWR
7KXQGHU5LYHUDQGVWLOOEDFNEH\RQG%ODFN5LYHUWKHDERULJLQHVKDG
EHHQSXVKHGZLWKVODXJKWHUDQGPDVVDFUH%XWWKHGDUNVNLQQHGSHRSOH
GLGQRWIRUJHWWKDWRQFH&RQDMRKDUDKDGEHHQWKHLUV
7KHJXDUGLQVLGHWKHHDVWHUQJDWHEDZOHGDFKDOOHQJH7KURXJKD
EDUUHGDSHUWXUHWRUFKOLJKWIOLFNHUHGJOLQWLQJRQDVWHHOKHDGSLHFH
DQGVXVSLFLRXVH\HVEHQHDWKLW
2SHQWKHJDWHVQRUWHG&RQDQ<RXVHHLW
V,GRQ
W\RX"
0LOLWDU\GLVFLSOLQHSXWKLVWHHWKRQHGJH
7KHJDWHVZXQJLQZDUGDQG&RQDQDQGKLVFRPSDQLRQSDVVHGWKURXJK
%DOWKXVQRWHGWKDWWKHJDWHZDVIODQNHGE\DWRZHURQHDFKVLGHWKH
VXPPLWVRIZKLFKURVHDERYHWKHVWRFNDGH+HVDZORRSKROHVIRU
DUURZV
7KHJXDUGVPHQJUXQWHGDVWKH\VDZWKHEXUGHQERUQHEHWZHHQWKH
PHQ7KHLUSLNHVMDQJOHGDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHUDVWKH\WKUXVWVKXWWKH
JDWHFKLQRQVKRXOGHUDQG&RQDQDVNHGWHVWLO\+DYH\RXQHYHUVHHQ
DKHDGOHVVERG\EHIRUH"
7KHIDFHVRIWKHVROGLHUVZHUHSDOOLGLQWKHWRUFKOLJKW
7KDW
V7LEHULDVEOXUWHGRQH,UHFRJQL]HWKDWIXUWULPPHG
WXQLF9DOHULXVKHUHRZHVPHILYHOXQDV,WROGKLP7LEHULDVKDG
KHDUGWKHORRQFDOOZKHQKHURGHWKURXJKWKHJDWHRQKLVPXOHZLWK
KLVJODVV\VWDUH,ZDJHUHGKH
GFRPHEDFNZLWKRXWKLVKHDG
&RQDQJUXQWHGHQLJPDWLFDOO\PRWLRQHG%DOWKXVWRHDVHWKHOLWWHU
WRWKHJURXQGDQGWKHQVWURGHRIIWRZDUGWKHJRYHUQRU
VTXDUWHUV
ZLWKWKH$TXLORQLDQDWKLVKHHOV7KHWRXVOHKHDGHG\RXWKVWDUHG
DERXWKLPHDJHUO\DQGFXULRXVO\QRWLQJWKHURZVRIEDUUDFNVDORQJ
WKHZDOOVWKHVWDEOHVWKHWLQ\PHUFKDQWV
VWDOOVWKHWRZHULQJ
EORFNKRXVHDQGWKHRWKHUEXLOGLQJVZLWKWKHRSHQVTXDUHLQWKH
PLGGOHZKHUHWKHVROGLHUVGULOOHGDQGZKHUHQRZILUHVGDQFHGDQG
PHQRIIGXW\ORXQJHG7KHVHZHUHQRZKXUU\LQJWRMRLQWKHPRUELG
FURZGJDWKHUHGDERXWWKHOLWWHUDWWKHJDWH7KHUDQJ\ILJXUHVRI
$TXLORQLDQSLNHPHQDQGIRUHVWUXQQHUVPLQJOHGZLWKWKHVKRUWHU
VWRFNLHUIRUPVRI%RVVRQLDQDUFKHUV
+HZDVQRWJUHDWO\VXUSULVHGWKDWWKHJRYHUQRUUHFHLYHGWKHP
KLPVHOI$XWRFUDWLFVRFLHW\ZLWKLWVULJLGFDVWHODZVOD\HDVWRIWKH
PDUFKHV9DODQQXVZDVVWLOOD\RXQJPDQZHOONQLWZLWKDILQHO\
FKLVHOHGFRXQWHQDQFHDOUHDG\FDUYHGLQWRVREHUFDVWE\WRLODQG
UHVSRQVLELOLW\
<RXOHIWWKHIRUWEHIRUHGD\EUHDN,ZDVWROGKHVDLGWR&RQDQ
,KDGEHJXQWRIHDUWKDWWKH3LFWVKDGFDXJKW\RXDWODVW
:KHQWKH\VPRNHP\KHDGWKHZKROHULYHUZLOONQRZJUXQWHG
&RQDQ7KH\
OOKHDU3LFWLVKZRPHQZDLOLQJWKHLUGHDGDVIDUDV
9HOLWULXP,ZDVRQDORQHVFRXW,FRXOGQ
WVOHHS,NHSWKHDULQJ
GUXPVWDONLQJDFURVVWKHULYHU
7KH\WDONHDFKQLJKWUHPLQGHGWKHJRYHUQRUKLVILQHH\HV
VKDGRZHGDVKHVWDUHGFORVHO\DW&RQDQ+HKDGOHDUQHGWKHXQZLVGRP
RIGLVFRXQWLQJZLOGPHQ
VLQVWLQFWV
7KHUHZDVDGLIIHUHQFHODVWQLJKWJURZOHG&RQDQ7KHUHKDV
EHHQHYHUVLQFH=RJDU6DJJRWEDFNDFURVVWKHULYHU
:HVKRXOGHLWKHUKDYHJLYHQKLPSUHVHQWVDQGVHQWKLPKRPHRU
HOVHKDQJHGKLPVLJKHGWKHJRYHUQRU<RXDGYLVHGWKDWEXW
%XWLW
VKDUGIRU\RX+\ERULDQVWROHDUQWKHZD\VRIWKH
RXWODQGVVDLG&RQDQ:HOOLWFDQ
WEHKHOSHGQRZEXWWKHUH
OOEH
QRSHDFHRQWKHERUGHUVRORQJDV=RJDUOLYHVDQGUHPHPEHUVWKHFHOO
KHVZHDWHGLQ,ZDVIROORZLQJDZDUULRUZKRVOLSSHGRYHUWRSXWD
IHZZKLWHQRWFKHVRQKLVERZ$IWHU,VSOLWKLVKHDG,IHOOLQZLWK
WKLVODGZKRVHQDPHLV%DOWKXVDQGZKR
VFRPHIURPWKH7DXUDQWRKHOS
KROGWKHIURQWLHU
9DODQQXVDSSURYLQJO\H\HGWKH\RXQJPDQ
VIUDQNFRXQWHQDQFHDQG
VWURQJO\NQLWIUDPH
,DPJODGWRZHOFRPH\RX\RXQJVLU,ZLVKPRUHRI\RXUSHRSOH
ZRXOGFRPH:HQHHGPHQXVHGWRIRUHVWOLIH0DQ\RIRXUVROGLHUVDQG
VRPHRIRXUVHWWOHUVDUHIURPWKHHDVWHUQSURYLQFHVDQGNQRZQRWKLQJ
RIZRRGFUDIWRUHYHQRIDJULFXOWXUDOOLIH
1RWPDQ\RIWKDWEUHHGWKLVVLGHRI9HOLWULXPJUXQWHG&RQDQ
7KDWWRZQ
VIXOORIWKHPWKRXJK%XWOLVWHQ9DODQQXVZHIRXQG
7LEHULDVGHDGRQWKHWUDLO$QGLQDIHZZRUGVKHUHODWHGWKHJULVO\
DIIDLU
9DODQQXVSDOHG,GLGQRWNQRZKHKDGOHIWWKHIRUW+HPXVWKDYH
EHHQPDG
+HZDVDQVZHUHG&RQDQ/LNHWKHRWKHUIRXUHDFKRQHZKHQKLV
WLPHFDPHZHQWPDGDQGUXVKHGLQWRWKHZRRGVWRPHHWKLVGHDWKOLNH
DKDUHUXQQLQJGRZQWKHWKURDWRIDS\WKRQB6RPHWKLQJBFDOOHGWR
WKHPIURPWKHGHHSVRIWKHIRUHVWVRPHWKLQJWKHPHQFDOODORRQIRU
ODFNRIDEHWWHUQDPHEXWRQO\WKHGRRPHGRQHVFRXOGKHDULW=RJDU
6DJKDVPDGHDPDJLFWKDW$TXLORQLDQFLYLOL]DWLRQFDQ
WRYHUFRPH
7RWKLVWKUXVW9DODQQXVPDGHQRUHSO\KHZLSHGKLVEURZZLWKD
VKDN\KDQG
'RWKHVROGLHUVNQRZRIWKLV"
:HOHIWWKHERG\E\WKHHDVWHUQJDWH
<RXVKRXOGKDYHFRQFHDOHGWKHIDFWKLGGHQWKHFRUSVHVRPHZKHUH
LQWKHZRRGV7KHVROGLHUVDUHQHUYRXVHQRXJKDOUHDG\
7KH\
GKDYHIRXQGLWRXWVRPHZD\,I,
GKLGGHQWKHERG\LW
ZRXOGKDYHEHHQUHWXUQHGWRWKHIRUWDVWKHFRUSVHRI6RUDFWXVZDV
WLHGXSRXWVLGHWKHJDWHIRUWKHPHQWRILQGLQWKHPRUQLQJ
9DODQQXVVKXGGHUHG7XUQLQJKHZDONHGWRDFDVHPHQWDQGVWDUHG
VLOHQWO\RXWRYHUWKHULYHUEODFNDQGVKLQ\XQGHUWKHJOLQWRIWKH
VWDUV%H\RQGWKHULYHUWKHMXQJOHURVHOLNHDQHERQ\ZDOO7KH
GLVWDQWVFUHHFKRIDSDQWKHUEURNHWKHVWLOOQHVV7KHQLJKWSUHVVHG
LQEOXUULQJWKHVRXQGVRIWKHVROGLHUVRXWVLGHWKHEORFNKRXVH
GLPPLQJWKHILUHV$ZLQGZKLVSHUHGWKURXJKWKHEODFNEUDQFKHV
ULSSOLQJWKHGXVN\ZDWHU2QLWVZLQJVFDPHDORZUK\WKPLFSXOVLQJ
VLQLVWHUDVWKHSDGRIDOHRSDUG
VIRRW
$IWHUDOOVDLG9DODQQXVDVLIVSHDNLQJKLVWKRXJKWVDORXG
ZKDWGRZHNQRZZKDWGRHVDQ\RQHNQRZRIWKHWKLQJVWKDW
MXQJOHPD\KLGH":HKDYHGLPUXPRUVRIJUHDWVZDPSVDQGULYHUVDQGD
IRUHVWWKDWVWUHWFKHVRQDQGRQRYHUHYHUODVWLQJSODLQVDQGKLOOVWR
HQGDWODVWRQWKHVKRUHVRIWKHZHVWHUQRFHDQ%XWZKDWWKLQJVOLH
EHWZHHQWKLVULYHUDQGWKDWRFHDQZHGDUHQRWHYHQJXHVV1RZKLWH
PDQKDVHYHUSOXQJHGGHHSLQWRWKDWIDVWQHVVDQGUHWXUQHGDOLYHWR
WHOOXVZKDWEHIRXQG:HDUHZLVHLQRXUFLYLOL]HGNQRZOHGJHEXW
RXUNQRZOHGJHH[WHQGVMXVWVRIDUWRWKHZHVWHUQEDQNRIWKDW
DQFLHQWULYHU:KRNQRZVZKDWVKDSHVHDUWKO\DQGXQHDUWKO\PD\OXUN
EH\RQGWKHGLPFLUFOHRIOLJKWRXUNQRZOHGJHKDVFDVW"
:KRNQRZVZKDWJRGVDUHZRUVKLSSHGXQGHUWKHVKDGRZVRIWKDW
KHDWKHQIRUHVWRUZKDWGHYLOVFUDZORXWRIWKHEODFNRR]HRIWKH
VZDPSV":KRFDQEHVXUHWKDWDOOWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIWKDWEODFN
FRXQWU\DUHQDWXUDO"=RJDU6DJDVDJHRIWKHHDVWHUQFLWLHVZRXOG
VQHHUDWKLVSULPLWLYHPDJLFPDNLQJDVWKHPXPPHU\RIDIDNLU\HWKH
KDVGULYHQPDGDQGNLOOHGILYHPHQLQDPDQQHUQRPDQFDQH[SODLQ,
ZRQGHULIKHKLPVHOILVZKROO\KXPDQ
,I,FDQJHWZLWKLQD[WKURZLQJGLVWDQFHRIKLP,
OOVHWWOHWKDW
TXHVWLRQJURZOHG&RQDQKHOSLQJKLPVHOIWRWKHJRYHUQRU
VZLQHDQG
SXVKLQJDJODVVWRZDUG%DOWKXVZKRWRRNLWKHVLWDWLQJO\DQGZLWKDQ
XQFHUWDLQJODQFHWRZDUG9DODQQXV
7KHJRYHUQRUWXUQHGWRZDUG&RQDQDQGVWDUHGDWKLPWKRXJKWIXOO\
7KHVROGLHUVZKRGRQRWEHOLHYHLQJKRVWVRUGHYLOVKHVDLG
DUHDOPRVWLQDSDQLFRIIHDU<RXZKREHOLHYHLQJKRVWVJKRXOV
JREOLQVDQGDOOPDQQHURIXQFDQQ\WKLQJVGRQRWVHHPWRIHDUDQ\RI
WKHWKLQJVLQZKLFK\RXEHOLHYH
7KHUH
VQRWKLQJLQWKHXQLYHUVHFROGVWHHOZRQ
WFXWDQVZHUHG
&RQDQ,WKUHZP\D[DWWKHGHPRQDQGKHWRRNQRKXUWEXW,PLJKW
KDYHPLVVHGLQWKHGXVNRUDEUDQFKGHIOHFWHGLWVIOLJKW,
PQRW
JRLQJRXWRIP\ZD\ORRNLQJIRUGHYLOVEXW,ZRXOGQ
WVWHSRXWRIP\
SDWKWROHWRQHJRE\
9DODQQXVOLIWHGKLVKHDGDQGPHW&RQDQ
VJD]HVTXDUHO\
&RQDQPRUHGHSHQGVRQ\RXWKDQ\RXUHDOL]H<RXNQRZWKH
ZHDNQHVVRIWKLVSURYLQFHDVOHQGHUZHGJHWKUXVWLQWRWKHXQWDPHG
ZLOGHUQHVV<RXNQRZWKDWWKHOLYHVRIDOOWKHSHRSOHZHVWRIWKH
PDUFKHVGHSHQGRQWKLVIRUW:HUHLWWRIDOOUHGD[HVZRXOGEH
VSOLQWHULQJWKHJDWHVRI9HOLWULXPEHIRUHDKRUVHPDQFRXOGFURVVWKH
PDUFKHV+LV0DMHVW\RUKLV0DMHVW\
VDGYLVHUVKDYHLJQRUHGP\SOHD
WKDWPRUHWURRSVEHVHQWWRKROGWKHIURQWLHU7KH\NQRZQRWKLQJRI
ERUGHUFRQGLWLRQVDQGDUHDYHUVHWRH[SHQGLQJDQ\PRUHPRQH\LQWKLV
GLUHFWLRQ7KHIDWHRIWKHIURQWLHUGHSHQGVXSRQWKHPHQZKRQRZKROG
LW
<RXNQRZWKDWPRVWRIWKHDUP\ZKLFKFRQTXHUHG&RQDMRKDUDKDV
EHHQZLWKGUDZQ<RXNQRZWKHIRUFHOHIWLVLQDGHTXDWHHVSHFLDOO\
VLQFHWKDWGHYLO=RJDU6DJPDQDJHGWRSRLVRQRXUZDWHUVXSSO\DQG
IRUW\PHQGLHGLQRQHGD\0DQ\RIWKHRWKHUVDUHVLFNRUKDYHEHHQ
ELWWHQE\VHUSHQWVRUPDXOHGE\ZLOGEHDVWVZKLFKVHHPWRVZDUPLQ
LQFUHDVLQJQXPEHUVLQWKHYLFLQLW\RIWKHIRUW7KHVROGLHUVEHOLHYH
=RJDU
VERDVWWKDWKHFRXOGVXPPRQWKHIRUHVWEHDVWVWRVOD\KLV
HQHPLHV
,KDYHWKUHHKXQGUHGSLNHPHQIRXUKXQGUHG%RVVRQLDQDUFKHUVDQG
SHUKDSVILIW\PHQZKROLNH\RXUVHOIDUHVNLOOHGLQZRRGFUDIW7KH\
DUHZRUWKWHQWLPHVWKHLUQXPEHURIVROGLHUVEXWWKHUHDUHVRIHZRI
WKHP)UDQNO\&RQDQP\VLWXDWLRQLVEHFRPLQJSUHFDULRXV7KH
VROGLHUVZKLVSHURIGHVHUWLRQWKH\DUHORZVSLULWHGEHOLHYLQJ=RJDU
6DJKDVORRVHGGHYLOVRQXV7KH\IHDUWKHEODFNSODJXHZLWKZKLFKKH
WKUHDWHQHGXVWKHWHUULEOHEODFNGHDWKRIWKHVZDPSODQGV:KHQ,
VHHDVLFNVROGLHU,VZHDWZLWKIHDURIVHHLQJKLPWXUQEODFNDQG
VKULYHODQGGLHEHIRUHP\H\HV
&RQDQLIWKHSODJXHLVORRVHGXSRQXVWKHVROGLHUVZLOOGHVHUW
LQDERG\7KHERUGHUZLOOEHOHIWXQJXDUGHGDQGQRWKLQJZLOOFKHFN
WKHVZHHSRIWKHGDUNVNLQQHGKRUGHVWRWKHYHU\JDWHVRI9HOLWULXP
PD\EHEH\RQG,IZHFDQQRWKROGWKHIRUWKRZFDQWKH\KROGWKH
WRZQ"
&RQDQ=RJDU6DJPXVWGLHLIZHDUHWRKROG&RQDMRKDUD<RXKDYH
SHQHWUDWHGWKHXQNQRZQGHHSHUWKDQDQ\RWKHUPDQLQWKHIRUW\RX
NQRZZKHUH*ZDZHODVWDQGVDQGVRPHWKLQJRIWKHIRUHVWWUDLOVDFURVV
WKHULYHU:LOO\RXWDNHDEDQGRIPHQWRQLJKWDQGHQGHDYRUWRNLOO
RUFDSWXUHKLP"2K,NQRZLW
VPDG7KHUHLVQ
WPRUHWKDQRQHFKDQFH
LQDWKRXVDQGWKDWDQ\RI\RXZLOOFRPHEDFNDOLYH%XWLIZHGRQ
W
JHWKLPLW
VGHDWKIRUXVDOO<RXFDQWDNHDVPDQ\PHQDV\RX
ZLVK
$GR]HQPHQDUHEHWWHUIRUDMREOLNHWKDWWKDQDUHJLPHQW
DQVZHUHG&RQDQ)LYHKXQGUHGPHQFRXOGQ
WILJKWWKHLUZD\WR*ZDZHOD
DQGEDFNEXWDGR]HQPLJKWVOLSLQDQGRXWDJDLQ/HWPHSLFNP\
PHQ,GRQ
WZDQWDQ\VROGLHUV
/HWPHJRHDJHUO\H[FODLPHG%DOWKXV,
YHKXQWHGGHHUDOOP\
OLIHRQWKH7DXUDQ
$OOULJKW9DODQQXVZH
OOHDWDWWKHVWDOOZKHUHWKHIRUHVWHUV
JDWKHUDQG,
OOSLFNP\PHQ:H
OOVWDUWZLWKLQDQKRXUGURSGRZQ
WKHULYHULQDERDWWRDSRLQWEHORZWKHYLOODJHDQGWKHQVWHDOXSRQ
LWWKURXJKWKHZRRGV,IZHOLYHZHVKRXOGEHEDFNE\GD\EUHDN


7KH&UDZOHUVLQWKH'DUN

7KHULYHUZDVDYDJXHWUDFHEHWZHHQZDOOVRIHERQ\7KHSDGGOHV
WKDWSURSHOOHGWKHORQJERDWFUHHSLQJDORQJLQWKHGHQVHVKDGRZRI
WKHHDVWHUQEDQNGLSSHGVRIWO\LQWRWKHZDWHUPDNLQJQRPRUHQRLVH
WKDQWKHEHDNRIDKHURQ7KHEURDGVKRXOGHUVRIWKHPDQLQIURQWRI
%DOWKXVZHUHDEOXHLQWKHGHQVHJORRP+HNQHZWKDWQRWHYHQWKH
NHHQH\HVRIWKHPDQZKRNQHOWLQWKHSURZZRXOGGLVFHUQDQ\WKLQJ
PRUHWKDQDIHZIHHWDKHDGRIWKHP&RQDQZDVIHHOLQJKLVZD\E\
LQVWLQFWDQGDQLQWHQVLYHIDPLOLDULW\ZLWKWKHULYHU
1RRQHVSRNH%DOWKXVKDGKDGDJRRGORRNDWKLVFRPSDQLRQVLQWKH
IRUWEHIRUHWKH\VOLSSHGRXWRIWKHVWRFNDGHDQGGRZQWKHEDQNLQWR
WKHZDLWLQJFDQRH7KH\ZHUHRIDQHZEUHHGJURZLQJXSLQWKHZRUOG
RQWKHUDZHGJHRIWKHIURQWLHUPHQZKRPJULPQHFHVVLW\KDGWDXJKW
ZRRGFUDIW$TXLORQLDQVRIWKHZHVWHUQSURYLQFHVWRDPDQWKH\KDG
PDQ\SRLQWVLQFRPPRQ7KH\GUHVVHGDOLNHLQEXFNVNLQERRWV
OHDWKHUQEUHHNVDQGGHHUVNLQVKLUWVZLWKEURDGJLUGOHVWKDWKHOG
D[HVDQGVKRUWVZRUGVDQGWKH\ZHUHDOOJDXQWDQGVFDUUHGDQGKDUG
H\HGVLQHZ\DQGWDFLWXUQ
7KH\ZHUHZLOGPHQRIDVRUW\HWWKHUHZDVVWLOODZLGHJXOI
EHWZHHQWKHPDQGWKH&LPPHULDQ7KH\ZHUHVRQVRIFLYLOL]DWLRQ
UHYHUWHGWRDVHPLEDUEDULVP+HZDVDEDUEDULDQRIDWKRXVDQG
JHQHUDWLRQVRIEDUEDULDQV7KH\KDGDFTXLUHGVWHDOWKDQGFUDIWEXW
KHKDGEHHQERUQWRWKHVHWKLQJV+HH[FHOOHGWKHPHYHQLQOLWKH
HFRQRP\RIPRWLRQ7KH\ZHUHZROYHVEXWKHZDVDWLJHU
%DOWKXVDGPLUHGWKHPDQGWKHLUOHDGHUDQGIHOWDSXOVHRISULGH
WKDWKHZDVDGPLWWHGLQWRWKHLUFRPSDQ\+HZDVSURXGWKDWKLVSDGGOH
PDGHQRPRUHQRLVHWKDQGLGWKHLUV,QWKDWUHVSHFWDWOHDVWKHZDV
WKHLUHTXDOWKRXJKZRRGFUDIWOHDUQHGLQKXQWVRQWKH7DXUDQFRXOG
QHYHUHTXDOWKDWJURXQGLQWRWKHVRXOVRIPHQRQWKHVDYDJHERUGHU
%HORZWKHIRUWWKHULYHUPDGHDZLGHEHQG7KHOLJKWVRIWKH
RXWSRVWZHUHTXLFNO\ORVWEXWWKHFDQRHKHOGRQLWVZD\IRUQHDUO\D
PLOHDYRLGLQJVQDJVDQGIORDWLQJORJVZLWKDOPRVWXQFDQQ\SUHFLVLRQ
7KHQDORZJUXQWIURPWKHLUOHDGHUDQGWKH\VZXQJLWVKHDGDERXW
DQGJOLGHGWRZDUGWKHRSSRVLWHVKRUH(PHUJLQJIURPWKHEODFNVKDGRZV
RIWKHEUXVKWKDWIULQJHGWKHEDQNDQGFRPLQJLQWRWKHRSHQRIWKH
PLGVWUHDPFUHDWHGDSHFXOLDULOOXVLRQRIUDVKH[SRVXUH%XWWKHVWDUV
JDYHOLWWOHOLJKWDQG%DOWKXVNQHZWKDWXQOHVVRQHZHUHZDWFKLQJIRU
LWLWZRXOGEHDOOEXWLPSRVVLEOHIRUWKHNHHQHVWH\HWRPDNHRXW
WKHVKDGRZ\VKDSHRIWKHFDQRHFURVVLQJWKHULYHU
7KH\VZXQJLQXQGHUWKHRYHUKDQJLQJEXVKHVRIWKHZHVWHUQVKRUH
DQG%DOWKXVJURSHGIRUDQGIRXQGDSURMHFWLQJURRWZKLFKKHJUDVSHG
1RZRUGZDVVSRNHQ$OOLQVWUXFWLRQVKDGEHHQJLYHQEHIRUHWKH
VFRXWLQJSDUW\OHIWWKHIRUW$VVLOHQWO\DVDJUHDWSDQWKHU&RQDQ
VOLGRYHUWKHVLGHDQGYDQLVKHGLQWKHEXVKHV(TXDOO\QRLVHOHVV
QLQHPHQIROORZHGKLP7R%DOWKXVJUDVSLQJWKHURRWZLWKKLVSDGGOH
DFURVVKLVNQHHLWVHHPHGLQFUHGLEOHWKDWWHQPHQVKRXOGWKXVIDGH
LQWRWKHWDQJOHGIRUHVWZLWKRXWDVRXQG
+HVHWWOHGKLPVHOIWRZDLW1RZRUGSDVVHGEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKH
RWKHUPDQZKRKDGEHHQOHIWZLWKKLP6RPHZKHUHDPLOHRUVRWRWKH
QRUWKZHVW=RJDU6DJ
VYLOODJHVWRRGJLUGOHGZLWKWKLFNZRRGV
%DOWKXVXQGHUVWRRGKLVRUGHUVKHDQGKLVFRPSDQLRQZHUHWRZDLWIRU
WKHUHWXUQRIWKHUDLGLQJSDUW\,I&RQDQDQGKLVPHQKDGQRW
UHWXUQHGE\WKHILUVWWLQJHRIGDZQWKH\ZHUHWRUDFHEDFNXSWKH
ULYHUWRWKHIRUWDQGUHSRUWWKDWWKHIRUHVWKDGDJDLQWDNHQLWV
LPPHPRULDOWROORIWKHLQYDGLQJUDFH7KHVLOHQFHZDVRSSUHVVLYH1R
VRXQGFDPHIURPWKHEODFNZRRGVLQYLVLEOHEH\RQGWKHHERQ\PDVVHV
WKDWZHUHWKHRYHUKDQJLQJEXVKHV%DOWKXVQRORQJHUKHDUGWKHGUXPV
7KH\KDGEHHQVLOHQWIRUKRXUV+HNHSWEOLQNLQJXQFRQVFLRXVO\
WU\LQJWRVHHWKURXJKWKHGHHSJORRP7KHGDQNQLJKWVPHOOVRIWKH
ULYHUDQGWKHGDPSIRUHVWRSSUHVVHGKLP6RPHZKHUHQHDUE\WKHUH
ZDVDVRXQGDVLIDELJILVKKDGIORSSHGDQGVSODVKHGWKHZDWHU
%DOWKXVWKRXJKWLWPXVWKDYHOHDSHGVRFORVHWRWKHFDQRHWKDWLWKDG
VWUXFNWKHVLGHIRUDVOLJKWTXLYHUYLEUDWHGWKHFUDIW7KHERDW
V
VWHUQEHJDQWRVZLQJVOLJKWO\DZD\IURPWKHVKRUH7KHPDQEHKLQG
KLPPXVWKDYHOHWJRRIWKHSURMHFWLRQKHZDVJULSSLQJ%DOWKXV
WZLVWHGKLVKHDGWRKLVVDZDUQLQJDQGFRXOGMXVWPDNHRXWWKH
ILJXUHRIKLVFRPSDQLRQDVOLJKWO\EODFNHUEXONLQWKHEODFNQHVV
7KHPDQGLGQRWUHSO\:RQGHULQJLIKHKDGIDOOHQDVOHHS%DOWKXV
UHDFKHGRXWDQGJUDVSHGKLVVKRXOGHU7RKLVDPD]HPHQWWKHPDQ
FUXPSOHGXQGHUKLVWRXFKDQGVOXPSHGGRZQLQWKHFDQRH7ZLVWLQJKLV
ERG\KDOIDERXW%DOWKXVJURSHGIRUKLPKLVKHDUWVKRRWLQJLQWRKLV
WKURDW+LVIXPEOLQJILQJHUVVOLGRYHUWKHPDQ
VWKURDWRQO\WKH
\RXWK
VFRQYXOVLYHFOHQFKLQJRIKLVMDZVFKRNHGEDFNWKHFU\WKDW
URVHWRKLVOLSV+LVILQJHUHQFRXQWHUHGDJDSLQJRR]LQJZRXQG
KLVFRPSDQLRQ
VWKURDWKDGEHHQFXWIURPHDUWRHDU
,QWKDWLQVWDQWRIKRUURUDQGSDQLF%DOWKXVVWDUWHGXSDQGWKHQ
DPXVFXODUDUPRXWRIWKHGDUNQHVVORFNHGILHUFHO\DERXWKLVWKURDW
VWUDQJOLQJKLV\HOO7KHFDQRHURFNHGZLOGO\%DOWKXV
NQLIHZDVLQ
KLVKDQGWKRXJKKHGLGQRWUHPHPEHUMHUNLQJLWRXWRIKLVERRWDQG
KHVWDEEHGILHUFHO\DQGEOLQGO\+HIHOWWKHEODGHVLQNGHHSDQGD
ILHQGLVK\HOOUDQJLQKLVHDUD\HOOWKDWZDVKRUULEO\DQVZHUHG7KH
GDUNQHVVVHHPHGWRFRPHWROLIHDERXWKLP$EHVWLDOFODPRUURVHRQ
DOOVLGHVDQGRWKHUDUPVJUDSSOHGKLP%RUQHXQGHUDPDVVRI
KXUWOLQJERGLHVWKHFDQRHUROOHGVLGHZLVHEXWEHIRUHKHZHQWXQGHU
ZLWKLWVRPHWKLQJFUDFNHGDJDLQVW%DOWKXV
KHDGDQGWKHQLJKWZDV
EULHIO\LOOXPLQDWHGE\DEOLQGLQJEXUVWRIILUHEHIRUHLWJDYHZD\WR
DEODFNQHVVZKHUHQRWHYHQVWDUVVKRQH


7KH%HDVWVRI=RJDU6DJ

)LUHVGD]]OHG%DOWKXVDJDLQDVKHVORZO\UHFRYHUHGKLVVHQVHV+H
EOLQNHGVKRRNKLVKHDG7KHLUJODUHKXUWKLVH\HV$FRQIXVHGPHGOH\
RIVRXQGURVHDERXWKLPJURZLQJPRUHGLVWLQFWDVKLVVHQVHVFOHDUHG
+HOLIWHGKLVKHDGDQGVWDUHGVWXSLGO\DERXWKLP%ODFNILJXUHV
KHPPHGKLPLQHWFKHGDJDLQVWFULPVRQWRQJXHVRIIODPH
0HPRU\DQGXQGHUVWDQGLQJFDPHLQDUXVK+HZDVERXQGXSULJKWWRD
SRVWLQDQRSHQVSDFHULQJHGE\ILHUFHDQGWHUULEOHILJXUHV%H\RQG
WKDWULQJILUHVEXUQHGWHQGHGE\QDNHGGDUNVNLQQHGZRPHQ%H\RQG
WKHILUHVKHVDZKXWVRIPXGDQGZDWWOHWKDWFKHGZLWKEUXVK%H\RQG
WKHKXWVWKHUHZDVDVWRFNDGHZLWKDEURDGJDWH%XWKHVDZWKHVH
WKLQJVRQO\LQFLGHQWDOO\(YHQWKHFU\SWLFGDUNZRPHQZLWKWKHLU
FXULRXVFRLIIXUHVZHUHQRWHGE\KLPRQO\DEVHQWO\+LVIXOODWWHQWLRQ
ZDVIL[HGLQDZIXOIDVFLQDWLRQRQWKHPHQZKRVWRRGJODULQJDWKLP
6KRUWPHQEURDGVKRXOGHUHGGHHSFKHVWHGOHDQKLSSHGWKH\ZHUH
QDNHGH[FHSWIRUVFDQW\ORLQFORXWV7KHILUHOLJKWEURXJKWRXWWKH
SOD\RIWKHLUVZHOOLQJPXVFOHVLQEROGUHOLHI7KHLUGDUNIDFHVZHUH
LPPRELOHEXWWKHLUQDUURZH\HVJOLWWHUHGZLWKWKHILUHWKDWEXUQVLQ
WKHH\HVRIDVWDONLQJWLJHU7KHLUWDQJOHGPDQHVZHUHERXQGEDFN
ZLWKEDQGVRIFRSSHU6ZRUGVDQGD[HVZHUHLQWKHLUKDQGV&UXGH
EDQGDJHVEDQGHGWKHOLPEVRIVRPHDQGVPHDUVRIEORRGZHUHGULHGRQ
WKHLUGDUNVNLQV7KHUHKDGEHHQILJKWLQJUHFHQWDQGGHDGO\
+LVH\HVZDYHUHGDZD\IURPWKHVWHDG\JODUHRIKLVFDSWRUVDQGKH
UHSUHVVHGDFU\RIKRUURU$IHZIHHWDZD\WKHUHURVHDORZKLGHRXV
S\UDPLGLWZDVEXLOWRIJRU\KXPDQKHDGV'HDGH\HVJODUHGJODVVLO\
XSWKHEODFNVN\1XPEO\KHUHFRJQL]HGWKHFRXQWHQDQFHVZKLFKZHUH
WXUQHGWRZDUGKLP7KH\ZHUHWKHKHDGVRIWKHPHQZKRKDGIROORZHG
&RQDQLQWRWKHIRUHVW+HFRXOGQRWWHOOLIWKH&LPPHULDQ
VKHDGZHUH
DPRQJWKHP2QO\DIHZIDFHVZHUHYLVLEOHWRKLP,WORRNHGWRKLPDV
LIWKHUHPXVWEHWHQRUHOHYHQKHDGVDWOHDVW$GHDGO\VLFNQHVV
DVVDLOHGKLP+HIRXJKWDGHVLUHWRUHWFK%H\RQGWKHKHDGVOD\WKH
ERGLHVRIKDOIDGR]HQ3LFWVDQGKHZDVDZDUHRIDILHUFHH[XOWDWLRQ
DWWKHVLJKW7KHIRUHVWUXQQHUVKDGWDNHQWROODWOHDVW
7ZLVWLQJKLVKHDGDZD\IURPWKHJKDVWO\VSHFWDFOHKHEHFDPHDZDUH
WKDWDQRWKHUSRVWVWRRGQHDUKLPDVWDNHSDLQWHGEODFNDVZDVWKH
RQHWRZKLFKKHZDVERXQG$PDQVDJJHGLQKLVERQGVWKHUHQDNHG
H[FHSWIRUKLVOHDWKHUQEUHHNVZKRP%DOWKXVUHFRJQL]HGDVRQHRI
&RQDQ
VZRRGVPHQ%ORRGWULFNOHGIURPKLVPRXWKRR]HGVOXJJLVKO\
IURPDJDVKLQKLVVLGH/LIWLQJKLVKHDGDVKHOLFNHGKLVOLYLG
OLSVKHPXWWHUHGPDNLQJKLPVHOIKHDUGZLWKGLIILFXOW\DERYHWKH
ILHQGLVKFODPRURIWKH3LFWV6RWKH\JRW\RXWRR
6QHDNHGXSLQWKHZDWHUDQGFXWWKHRWKHUIHOORZ
VWKURDW
JURDQHG%DOWKXV:HQHYHUKHDUGWKHPWLOOWKH\ZHUHRQXV0LWUD
KRZFDQDQ\WKLQJPRYHVRVLOHQWO\"
7KH\
UHGHYLOVPXPEOHGWKHIURQWLHUVPDQ7KH\PXVWKDYHEHHQ
ZDWFKLQJXVIURPWKHWLPHZHOHIWPLGVWUHDP:HZDONHGLQWRDWUDS
$UURZVIURPDOOVLGHVZHUHULSSLQJLQWRXVEHIRUHZHNQHZLW0RVWRI
XVGURSSHGDWWKHILUVWILUH7KUHHRUIRXUEURNHWKURXJKWKHEXVKHV
DQGFDPHWRKDQGJULSV%XWWKHUHZHUHWRRPDQ\&RQDQPLJKWKDYH
JRWWHQDZD\,KDYHQ
WVHHQKLVKHDG%HHQEHWWHUIRU\RXDQGPHLI
WKH\
GNLOOHGXVRXWULJKW,FDQ
WEODPH&RQDQ2UGLQDULO\ZH
GKDYH
JRWWHQWRWKHYLOODJHZLWKRXWEHLQJGLVFRYHUHG7KH\GRQ
WNHHSVSLHV
RQWKHULYHUEDQNDVIDUGRZQDVZHODQGHG:HPXVWKDYHVWXPEOHG
LQWRDELJSDUW\FRPLQJXSWKHULYHUIURPWKHVRXWK6RPHGHYLOPHQW
LVXS7RRPDQ\3LFWVKHUH7KHVHDUHQ
WDOO*ZDZHOLPHQIURPWKH
ZHVWHUQWULEHVKHUHDQGIURPXSDQGGRZQWKHULYHU
%DOWKXVVWDUHGDWWKHIHURFLRXVVKDSHV/LWWOHDVKHNQHZRI
3LFWLVKZD\VKHZDVDZDUHWKDWWKHQXPEHURIPHQFOXVWHUHGDERXW
WKHPZDVRXWRISURSRUWLRQWRWKHVL]HRIWKHYLOODJH7KHUHZHUHQRW
HQRXJKKXWVWRKDYHDFFRPPRGDWHGWKHPDOO7KHQKHQRWLFHGWKDWWKHUH
ZDVDGLIIHUHQFHLQWKHEDUEDULFWULEDOGHVLJQVSDLQWHGRQWKHLU
IDFHVDQGEUHDVWV
6RPHNLQGRIGHYLOPHQWPXWWHUHGWKHIRUHVWUXQQHU7KH\PLJKW
KDYHJDWKHUHGKHUHWRZDWFK=RJDU
VPDJLFPDNLQJ+H
OOPDNHVRPH
UDUHPDJLFZLWKRXUFDUFDVVHV:HOODERUGHUPDQGRHVQ
WH[SHFWWR
GLHLQEHG%XW,ZLVKZH
GJRQHRXWDORQJZLWKWKHUHVW
7KHZROILVKKRZOLQJRIWKH3LFWVURVHLQYROXPHDQGH[XOWDWLRQ
DQGIURPDPRYHPHQWLQWKHLUUDQNVDQHDJHUVXUJLQJDQGFURZGLQJ
%DOWKXVGHGXFHGWKDWVRPHRQHRILPSRUWDQFHZDVFRPLQJ7ZLVWLQJKLV
KHDGDERXWKHVDZWKDWWKHVWDNHVZHUHVHWEHIRUHDORQJEXLOGLQJ
ODUJHUWKDQWKHRWKHUKXWVGHFRUDWHGE\KXPDQVNXOOVGDQJOLQJIURP
WKHHDYHV7KURXJKWKHGRRURIWKDWVWUXFWXUHQRZGDQFHGDIDQWDVWLF
ILJXUH
=RJDUPXWWHUHGWKHZRRGVPDQKLVEORRG\FRXQWHQDQFHVHWLQ
ZROILVKOLQHVDVKHXQFRQVFLRXVO\VWUDLQHGDWKLVFRUGV%DOWKXVVDZ
DOHDQILJXUHRIPLGGOHKHLJKWDOPRVWKLGGHQLQRVWULFKSOXPHVVHW
RQDKDUQHVVRIOHDWKHUDQGFRSSHU)URPDPLGVWWKHSOXPHVSHHUHGD
KLGHRXVDQGPDOHYROHQWIDFH7KHSOXPHVSX]]OHG%DOWKXV+HNQHZ
WKHLUVRXUFHOD\KDOIWKHZLGWKRIDZRUOGWRWKHVRXWK7KH\
IOXWWHUHGDQGUXVWOHGHYLOO\DVWKHVKDPDQOHDSHGDQGFDYRUWHG
:LWKIDQWDVWLFERXQGVDQGSUDQFLQJVKHHQWHUHGWKHULQJDQG
ZKLUOHGEHIRUHKLVERXQGDQGVLOHQWFDSWLYHV:LWKDQRWKHUPDQLW
ZRXOGKDYHVHHPHGULGLFXORXVDIRROLVKVDYDJHSUDQFLQJ
PHDQLQJOHVVO\LQDZKLUORIIHDWKHUV%XWWKDWIHURFLRXVIDFHJODULQJ
RXWIURPWKHELOORZLQJPDVVJDYHWKHVFHQHDJULPVLJQLILFDQFH1R
PDQZLWKDIDFHOLNHWKDWFRXOGVHHPULGLFXORXVRUOLNHDQ\WKLQJ
H[FHSWWKHGHYLOKHZDV
6XGGHQO\KHIUR]HWRVWDWXHVTXHVWLOOQHVVWKHSOXPHVULSSOHGRQFH
DQGVDQNDERXWKLP7KHKRZOLQJZDUULRUVIHOOVLOHQW=RJDU6DJVWRRG
HUHFWDQGPRWLRQOHVVDQGKHVHHPHGWRLQFUHDVHLQKHLJKWWRJURZ
DQGH[SDQG%DOWKXVH[SHULHQFHGWKHLOOXVLRQWKDWWKH3LFWZDV
WRZHULQJDERYHKLPVWDULQJFRQWHPSWXRXVO\GRZQIURPDJUHDWKHLJKW
WKRXJKKHNQHZWKHVKDPDQZDVQRWDVWDOODVKLPVHOI+HVKRRNRII
WKHLOOXVLRQZLWKGLIILFXOW\
7KHVKDPDQZDVWDONLQJQRZDKDUVKJXWWXUDOLQWRQDWLRQWKDW\HW
FDUULHGWKHKLVVRIDFREUD+HWKUXVWKLVKHDGRQKLVORQJQHFN
WRZDUGWKHZRXQGHGPDQRQWKHVWDNHKLVH\HVVKRQHUHGDVEORRGLQ
WKHILUHOLJKW7KHIURQWLHUVPDQVSDWIXOOLQKLVIDFH
:LWKDILHQGLVKKRZO=RJDUERXQGHGFRQYXOVLYHO\LQWRWKHDLUDQG
WKHZDUULRUVJDYHWRQJXHWRD\HOOWKDWVKXGGHUHGXSWRWKHVWDUV
7KH\UXVKHGWRZDUGWKHPDQRQWKHVWDNHEXWWKHVKDPDQEHDWWKHP
EDFN$VQDUOHGFRPPDQGVHQWPHQUXQQLQJWRWKHJDWH7KH\KXUOHGLW
RSHQWXUQHGDQGUDFHGEDFNWRWKHFLUFOH7KHULQJRIPHQVSOLW
GLYLGHGZLWKGHVSHUDWHKDVWHWRULJKWDQGOHIW%DOWKXVVDZWKHZRPHQ
DQGQDNHGFKLOGUHQVFXUU\LQJWRWKHKXWV7KH\SHHNHGRXWRIGRRUV
DQGZLQGRZV$EURDGODQHZDVOHIWWRWKHRSHQJDWHEH\RQGZKLFK
ORRPHGWKHEODFNIRUHVWFURZGLQJVXOOHQO\LQXSRQWKHFOHDULQJ
XQOLJKWHGE\WKHILUHV
$WHQVHVLOHQFHUHLJQHGDV=RJDU6DJWXUQHGWRZDUGWKHIRUHVW
UDLVHGRQKLVWLSWRHVDQGVHQWDZHLUGLQKXPDQFDOOVKXGGHULQJRXW
LQWRWKHQLJKW6RPHZKHUHIDURXWLQWKHEODFNIRUHVWDGHHSHUFU\
DQVZHUHGKLP%DOWKXVVKXGHGHUHG)URPWKHWLPEUHRIWKDWFU\KHNQHZ
LWQHYHUFDPHIURPDKXPDQWKURDW+HUHPHPEHUHGZKDW9DODQQXVKDG
VDLGWKDW=RJDUERDVWHGWKDWKHFRXOGVXPPRQZLOGEHDVWVWRGRKLV
ELGGLQJ7KHZRRGVPDQZDVOLYLGEHQHDWKKLVPDVNRIEORRG+HOLFNHG
KLVOLSVVSDVPRGLFDOO\
7KHYLOODJHKHOGLWVEUHDWK=RJDU6DJVWRRGVWLOODVDVWDWXH
KLVSOXPHVWUHPEOLQJIDLQWO\DERXWKLP%XWVXGGHQO\WKHJDWHZDVQR
ORQJHUHPSW\
$VKXGGHULQJJDVSVZHSWRYHUWKHYLOODJHDQGPHQFURZGHGKDVWLO\
EDFNMDPPLQJRQHDQRWKHUEHWZHHQWKHKXWV%DOWKXVIHOWWKHVKRUW
KDLUVWLURQKLVVFDOS7KHFUHDWXUHWKDWVWRRGLQWKHJDWHZDVOLNH
WKHHPERGLPHQWRIQLJKWPDUHOHJHQG,WVFRORUZDVRIDFXULRXVSDOH
TXDOLW\ZKLFKPDGHLWVHHPJKRVWO\DQGXQUHDOLQWKHGLPOLJKW%XW
WKHUHZDVQRWKLQJXQUHDODERXWWKHORZKXQJVDYDJHKHDGDQGWKH
JUHDWFXUYHGIDQJVWKDWJOLVWHQHGLQWKHILUHOLJKW2QQRLVHOHVV
SDGGHGIHHWLWDSSURDFKHGOLNHDSKDQWRPRXWRIWKHSDVW,WZDVD
VXUYLYDORIDQROGHUJULPPHUDJHWKHRJUHRIPDQ\DQDQFLHQWOHJHQG
DVDEHUWRRWKWLJHU1R+\ERULDQKXQWHUKDGORRNHGXSRQRQHRI
WKRVHSULPRUGLDOEUXWHVIRUFHQWXULHV,PPHPRULDOP\WKVOHQWWKH
FUHDWXUHVDVXSHUQDWXUDOTXDOLW\LQGXFHGE\WKHLUJKRVWO\FRORUDQG
WKHLUILHQGLVKIHURFLW\
7KHEHDVWWKDWJOLGHGWRZDUGWKHPHQRQWKHVWDNHVZDVORQJHUDQG
KHDYLHUWKDQDFRPPRQVWULSHGWLJHUDOPRVWDVEXON\DVDEHDU,WV
VKRXOGHUVDQGIRUHOHJVZHUHVRPDVVLYHDQGPLJKWLO\PXVFOHGDVWR
JLYHLWDFXULRXVO\WRSKHDY\ORRNWKRXJKLWVKLQGTXDUWHUVZHUHPRUH
SRZHUIXOWKDQWKDWRIDOLRQ,WVMDZVZHUHPDVVLYHEXWLWVKHDGZDV
EUXWLVKO\VKDSHG,WVEUDLQFDSDFLW\ZDVVPDOO,WKDGURRPIRUQR
LQVWLQFWVH[FHSWWKRVHRIGHVWUXFWLRQ,WZDVDIUHDNRIFDUQLYRURXV
GHYHORSPHQWHYROXWLRQUXQDPXFNLQDKRUURURIIDQJVDQGWDORQV
7KLVZDVWKHPRQVWURVLW\=RJDU6DJKDGVXPPRQHGRXWRIWKHIRUHVW
%DOWKXVQRORQJHUGRXEWHGWKHDFWXDOLW\RIWKHVKDPDQ
VPDJLF2QO\
WKHEODFNDUWVFRXOGHVWDEOLVKDGRPLQDWLRQRYHUWKDWWLQ\EUDLQHG
PLJKW\WKHZHGPRQVWHU/LNHDZKLVSHUDWWKHEDFNRIKLV
FRQVFLRXVQHVVURVHWKHYDJXHPHPRU\RIWKHQDPHRIDQDQFLHQWJRGRI
GDUNQHVVDQGSULPRUGLDOIHDUWRZKRPRQFHERWKPHQDQGEHDVWVERZHG
DQGZKRVHFKLOGUHQPHQZKLVSHUHGVWLOOOXUNHGLQGDUNFRUQHUV
RIWKHZRUOG1HZKRUURUWLQJHGWKHJODUHKHIL[HGRQ=RJDU6DJ
7KHPRQVWHUPRYHGSDVWWKHKHDSRIERGLHVDQGWKHSLOHRIJRU\
KHDGVZLWKRXWDSSHDULQJWRQRWLFHWKHP+HZDVQRVFDYHQJHU+H
KXQWHGRQO\WKHOLYLQJLQDOLIHGHGLFDWHGVROHO\WRVODXJKWHU$Q
DZIXOKXQJHUEXUQHGJUHHQO\LQWKHZLGHXQZLQNLQJH\HVWKHKXQJHU
QRWDORQHRIEHOO\HPSWLQHVVEXWWKHOXVWRIGHDWKGHDOLQJ+LV
JDSLQJMDZVVODYHUHG7KHVKDPDQVWHSSHGEDFNKLVKDQGZDYHGWRZDUG
WKHZRRGVPDQ
7KHJUHDWFDWVDQNLQWRDFURXFKDQG%DOWKXVQXPEO\UHPHPEHUHG
WDOHVRILWVDSSDOOLQJIHURFLW\RIKRZLWZRXOGVSULQJXSRQDQ
HOHSKDQWDQGGULYHLWVVZRUGOLNHIDQJVVRGHHSO\LQWRWKHWLWDQ
V
VNXOOWKDWWKH\FRXOGQHYHUEHZLWKGUDZQEXWZRXOGNHHSLWQDLOHGWR
LWVYLFWLPWRGLHE\VWDUYDWLRQ7KHVKDPDQFULHGRXWVKULOO\DQG
ZLWKDQHDUVKDWWHULQJURDUWKHPRQVWHUVSUDQJ
%DOWKXVKDGQHYHUGUHDPHGRIVXFKDVSULQJVXFKDKXUWOLQJRI
LQFDUQDWHGGHVWUXFWLRQHPERGLHGLQWKDWJLDQWEXONRILURQWKHZVDQG
ULSSLQJWDORQV)XOORQWKHZRRGVPDQ
VEUHDVWLWVWUXFNDQGWKH
VWDNHVSOLQWHUHGDQGVQDSSHGDWWKHEDVHFUDVKLQJWRWKHHDUWKXQGHU
WKHLPSDFW7KHQWKHVDEHUWRRWKZDVJOLGLQJWRZDUGWKHJDWHKDOI
GUDJJLQJKDOIFDUU\LQJDKLGHRXVFULPVRQKXONWKDWRQO\IDLQWO\
UHVHPEOHGDPDQ%DOWKXVJODUHGDOPRVWSDUDO\]HGKLVEUDLQUHIXVLQJ
WRFUHGLWZKDWKLVH\HVKDGVHHQ
,QWKDWOHDSWKHJUHDWEHDVWKDGQRWRQO\EURNHQRIIWKHVWDNHLW
KDGULSSHGWKHPDQJOHGERG\RILWVYLFWLPIURPWKHSRVWWRZKLFKLW
ZDVERXQG7KHKXJHWDORQVLQWKDWLQVWDQWRIFRQWDFWKDG
GLVHPERZHOHGDQGSDUWLDOO\GLVPHPEHUHGWKHPDQDQGWKHJLDQWIDQJV
KDGWRUQDZD\WKHZKROHWRSRIKLVKHDGVKHDULQJWKURXJKWKHVNXOO
DVHDVLO\DVWKURXJKIOHVK6WRXWUDZKLGHWKRQJVKDGJLYHQZD\OLNH
SDSHUZKHUHWKHWKRQJVKDGKHOGIOHVKDQGERQHVKDGQRW%DOWKXV
UHWFKHGVXGGHQO\+HKDGKXQWHGEHDUVDQGSDQWKHUVEXWKHKDGQHYHU
GUHDPHGWKHEHDVWOLYHGZKLFKFRXOGPDNHVXFKDUHGUXLQRIDKXPDQ
IUDPHLQWKHIOLFNHURIDQLQVWDQW
7KHVDEHUWRRWKYDQLVKHGWKURXJKWKHJDWHDQGDIHZPRPHQWVODWHU
DGHHSURDUVRXQGHGWKURXJKWKHIRUHVWUHFHGLQJLQWKHGLVWDQFH%XW
WKH3LFWVVWLOOVKUDQNEDFNDJDLQVWWKHKXWVDQGWKHVKDPDQVWLOO
VWRRGIDFLQJWKHJDWHWKDWZDVOLNHDEODFNRSHQLQJWROHWLQWKH
QLJKW
&ROGVZHDWEXUVWVXGGHQO\RXWRQ%DOWKXV
VNLQ:KDWQHZKRUURU
ZRXOGFRPHWKURXJKWKDWJDWHWRPDNHFDUULRQPHDWRIBKLVBERG\"6LFN
SDQLFDVVDLOHGKLPDQGKHVWUDLQHGIXWLOHO\DWKLVWKRQJV7KHQLJKW
SUHVVHGLQYHU\EODFNDQGKRUULEOHRXWVLGHWKHILUHOLJKW7KHILUHV
WKHPVHOYHVJORZHGOXULGDVWKHILUHVRI+HOO+HIHOWWKHH\HVRIWKH
3LFWVXSRQKLPKXQGUHGVRIKXQJU\FUXHOH\HVWKDWUHIOHFWHGWKH
OXVWRIVRXOVXWWHUO\ZLWKRXWKXPDQLW\DVKHNQHZLW7KH\QRORQJHU
VHHPHGPHQWKH\ZHUHGHYLOVRIWKLVEODFNMXQJOHDVLQKXPDQDVWKH
FUHDWXUHVWRZKLFKWKHILHQGLQWKHQRGGLQJSOXPHVVFUHDPHGWKURXJK
WKHGDUNQHVV
=RJDUVHQWDQRWKHUFDOOVKXGGHULQJWKURXJKWKHQLJKWDQGLWZDV
XWWHUO\XQOLNHWKHILUVWFU\7KHUHZDVDKLGHRXVVLELODQFHLQLW
%DOWKXVWXUQHGFROGDWWKHLPSOLFDWLRQ,IDVHUSHQWFRXOGKLVVWKDW
ORXGLWZRXOGPDNHMXVWVXFKDVRXQG
7KLVWLPHWKHUHZDVQRDQVZHURQO\DSHULRGRIEUHDWKOHVV
VLOHQFHLQZKLFKWKHSRXQGRI%DOWKXV
KHDUWVWUDQJOHGKLPDQGWKHQ
WKHUHVRXQGHGDVZLVKLQJRXWVLGHWKHJDWHDGU\UXVWOLQJWKDWVHQW
FKLOOVGRZQ%DOWKXV
VSLQH$JDLQWKHILUHOLWJDWHKHOGDKLGHRXV
RFFXSDQW
$JDLQ%DOWKXVUHFRJQL]HGWKHPRQVWHUIURPDQFLHQWOHJHQGV+HVDZ
DQGNQHZWKHDQFLHQWDQGHYLOVHUSHQWZKLFKVZD\HGWKHUHLWVZHGJH
VKDSHGKHDGKXJHDVWKDWRIDKRUVHDVKLJKDVDWDOOPDQ
VKHDG
DQGLWVSDOHO\JOHDPLQJEDUUHOULSSOLQJRXWEHKLQGLW$IRUNHG
WRQJXHGDUWHGLQDQGRXWDQGWKHILUHOLJKWJOLWWHUHGRQEDUHGIDQJV
%DOWKXVEHFDPHLQFDSDEOHRIHPRWLRQ7KHKRUURURIKLVIDWH
SDUDO\]HGKLP7KDWZDVWKHUHSWLOHWKDWWKHDQFLHQWVFDOOHG*KRVW
6QDNHWKHSDOHDERPLQDEOHWHUURUWKDWRIROGJOLGHGLQWRKXWVE\
QLJKWWRGHYRXUZKROHIDPLOLHV/LNHWKHS\WKRQLWFUXVKHGLWV
YLFWLPEXWXQOLNHRWKHUFRQVWULFWRUVLWVIDQJVERUHYHQRPWKDW
FDUULHGPDGQHVVDQGGHDWK,WWRRKDGORQJEHHQFRQVLGHUHGH[WLQFW
%XW9DODQQXVKDGVSRNHQWUXO\1RZKLWHPDQNQHZZKDWVKDSHVKDXQWHG
WKHJUHDWIRUHVWVEH\RQG%ODFN5LYHU
,WFDPHRQVLOHQWO\ULSSOLQJRYHUWKHJURXQGLWVKLGHRXVKHDGRQ
WKHVDPHOHYHOLWVQHFNFXUYLQJEDFNVOLJKWO\IRUWKHVWURNH
%DOWKXVJD]HGZLWKDJOD]HGK\SQRWL]HGVWDUHLQWRWKDWORDWKVRPH
JXOOHWGRZQZKLFKKHZRXOGVRRQEHHQJXOIHGDQGKHZDVDZDUHRIQR
VHQVDWLRQH[FHSWDYDJXHQDXVHD
$QGWKHQVRPHWKLQJWKDWJOLQWHGLQWKHILUHOLJKWVWUHDNHGIURPWKH
VKDGRZVRIWKHKXWVDQGWKHJUHDWUHSWLOHZKLSSHGDERXWDQGZHQW
LQWRLQVWDQWFRQYXOVLRQV$VLQDGUHDP%DOWKXVVDZDVKRUWWKURZLQJ
VSHDUWUDQVIL[LQJWKHPLJKW\QHFNMXVWEHORZWKHJDSLQJMDZVWKH
VKDIWSURWUXGHGIURPRQHVLGHWKHVWHHOKHDGIURPWKHRWKHU
.QRWWLQJDQGORRSLQJKLGHRXVO\WKHPDGGHQHGUHSWLOHUROOHGLQWR
WKHFLUFOHRIPHQZKRVWRYHEDFNIURPKLP7KHVSHDUKDGQRWVHYHUHG
LWVVSLQHEXWPHUHO\WUDQVIL[HGLWVJUHDWQHFNPXVFOHV,WV
IXULRXVO\ODVKLQJWDLOPRZHGGRZQDGR]HQPHQDQGLWVMDZVVQDSSHG
FRQYXOVLYHO\VSODVKLQJRWKHUVZLWKYHQRPWKDWEXUQHGOLNHOLTXLG
ILUH+RZOLQJFXUVLQJVFUHDPLQJIUDQWLFWKH\VFDWWHUHGEHIRUHLW
NQRFNLQJHDFKRWKHUGRZQLQWKHLUIOLJKWWUDPSOLQJWKHIDOOHQ
EXUVWLQJWKURXJKWKHKXWV7KHJLDQWVQDNHUROOHGLQWRDILUH
VFDWWHULQJVSDUNVDQGEUDQGVDQGWKHSDLQODVKHGLWWRPRUHIUHQ]LHG
HIIRUWV$KXWZDOOEXFNOHGXQGHUWKHUDPOLNHLPSDFWRILWVIODLOLQJ
WDLOGLVJRUJLQJKRZOLQJSHRSOH
0HQVWDPSHGHGWKURXJKWKHILUHVNQRFNLQJWKHORJVULJKWDQGOHIW
7KHIODPHVVSUDQJXSWKHQVDQN$UHGGLVKGLPJORZZDVDOOWKDW
OLJKWHGWKDWQLJKWPDUHVFHQHZKHUHWKHJLDQWUHSWLOHZKLSSHGDQG
UROOHGDQGPHQFODZHGDQGVKULHNHGLQIUDQWLFIOLJKW
%DOWKXVIHOWVRPHWKLQJMHUNDWKLVZULVWVDQGWKHQPLUDFXORXVO\
KHZDVIUHHDQGDVWURQJKDQGGUDJJHGKLPEHKLQGWKHSRVW'D]HGO\
KHVDZ&RQDQIHOWWKHIRUHVWPDQ
VLURQJULSRQKLVDUP
7KHUHZDVEORRGRQWKH&LPPHULDQ
VPDLOGULHGEORRGRQWKHVZRUG
LQKLVULJKWKDQGKHORRPHGGLPDQGJLJDQWLFLQWKHVKDGRZ\OLJKW
&RPHRQ%HIRUHWKH\JHWRYHUWKHLUSDQLF
%DOWKXVIHOWWKHKDIWRIDQD[VKRYHGLQWRKLVKDQG=RJDU6DJKDG
GLVDSSHDUHG&RQDQGUDJJHG%DOWKXVDIWHUKLPXQWLOWKH\RXWK
VQXPE
EUDLQDZRNHDQGKLVOHJVEHJDQWRPRYHRIWKHLURZQDFFRUG7KHQ
&RQDQUHOHDVHGKLPDQGUDQLQWRWKHEXLOGLQJZKHUHWKHVNXOOVKXQJ
%DOWKXVIROORZHGKLP+HJRWDJOLPSVHRIDJULPVWRQHDOWDUIDLQWO\
OLJKWHGE\WKHJORZRXWVLGHILYHKXPDQKHDGVJULQQHGRQWKDWDOWDU
DQGWKHUHZDVDJULVO\IDPLOLDULW\DERXWWKHIHDWXUHVRIWKH
IUHVKHVWLWZDVWKHKHDGRIWKHPHUFKDQW7LEHULDV%HKLQGWKHDOWDU
ZDVDQLGROGLPLQGLVWLQFWEHVWLDO\HWYDJXHO\PDQOLNHLQ
RXWOLQH7KHQIUHVKKRUURUFKRNHG%DOWKXVDVWKHVKDSHKHDYHGXS
VXGGHQO\ZLWKDUDWWOHRIFKDLQVOLIWLQJORQJPLVVKDSHQDUPVLQWKH
JORRP
&RQDQ
VVZRUGIODLOHGGRZQFUXQFKLQJWKURXJKIOHVKDQGERQHDQG
WKHQWKH&LPPHULDQZDVGUDJJLQJ%DOWKXVDURXQGWKHDOWDUSDVWD
KXGGOHGVKDJJ\EXONRQWKHIORRUWRDGRRUDWWKHEDFNRIWKHORQJ
KXW7KURXJKWKLVWKH\EXUVWRXWLQWRWKHHQFORVXUHDJDLQ%XWDIHZ
\DUGVEH\RQGWKHPORRPHGWKHVWRFNDGH
,WZDVGDUNEHKLQGWKHDOWDUKXW7KHPDGVWDPSHGHRIWKH3LFWV
KDGQRWFDUULHGWKHPLQWKDWGLUHFWLRQ$WWKHZDOO&RQDQKDOWHG
JULSSHG%DOWKXVDQGKHDYHGKLPDWDUP
VOHQJWKLQWRWKHDLUDVKH
PLJKWKDYHOLIWHGDFKLOG%DOWKXVJUDVSHGWKHSRLQWVRIWKHXSULJKW
ORJVVHWLQWKHVXQGULHGPXGDQGVFUDPEOHGXSRQWKHPLJQRULQJWKH
KDYRFGRQHKLVVNLQ+HORZHUHGDKDQGWRWKH&LPPHULDQZKHQDURXQG
DFRUQHURIWKHDOWDUKXWVSUDQJDIOHHLQJ3LFW+HKDOWHGVKRUW
JOLPSVLQJWKHPDQRQWKHZDOOLQWKHIDLQWJORZRIWKHILUHV&RQDQ
KXUOHGKLVD[ZLWKGHDGO\DLPEXWWKHZDUULRU
VPRXWKZDVDOUHDG\
RSHQIRUD\HOORIZDUQLQJDQGLWUDQJORXGDERYHWKHGLQFXWVKRUW
DVKHGURSSHGZLWKDVKDWWHUHGVNXOO
%OLQGLQJWHUURUKDGQRWVXEPHUJHGDOOLQJUDLQHGLQVWLQFWV$VWKDW
ZLOG\HOOURVHDERYHWKHFODPRUWKHUHZDVDQLQVWDQW
VOXOODQG
WKHQDKXQGUHGWKURDWVED\HGIHURFLRXVDQVZHUDQGZDUULRUVFDPH
OHDSLQJWRUHSHOWKHDWWDFNSUHVDJHGE\WKHZDUQLQJ
&RQDQOHDSHGKLJKFDXJKWQRW%DOWKXV
KDQGEXWKLVDUPQHDUWKH
VKRXOGHUDQGVZXQJKLPVHOIXS%DOWKXVVHWKLVWHHWKDJDLQVWWKH
VWUDLQDQGWKHQWKH&LPPHULDQZDVRQWKHZDOOEHVLGHKLPDQGWKH
IXJLWLYHVGURSSHGGRZQRQWKHRWKHUVLGH


7KH&KLOGUHQRI-KHEEDO6DJ

:KLFKZD\LVWKHULYHU"%DOWKXVZDVFRQIXVHG
:HGRQ
WGDUHWU\IRUWKHULYHUQRZJUXQWHG&RQDQ7KHZRRGV
EHWZHHQWKHYLOODJHDQGWKHULYHUDUHVZDUPLQJZLWKZDUULRUV&RPH
RQ:H
OOKHDGLQWKHODVWGLUHFWLRQWKH\
OOH[SHFWXVWRJR
ZHVW
/RRNLQJEDFNDVWKH\HQWHUHGWKHWKLFNJURZWK%DOWKXVEHKHOGWKH
ZDOOGRWWHGZLWKEODFNKHDGVDVWKHVDYDJHVSHHUHGRYHU7KH3LFWV
ZHUHEHZLOGHUHG7KH\KDGQRWJDLQHGWKHZDOOLQWLPHWRVHHWKH
IXJLWLYHVWDNHFRYHU7KH\KDGUXVKHGWRWKHZDOOH[SHFWLQJWRUHSHO
DQDWWDFNLQIRUFH7KH\KDGVHHQWKHERG\RIWKHGHDGZDUULRU%XW
QRHQHP\ZDVLQVLJKW
%DOWKXVUHDOL]HGWKDWWKH\GLGQRW\HWNQRZWKHLUSULVRQHUKDG
HVFDSHG)URPRWKHUVRXQGVKHEHOLHYHGWKDWWKHZDUULRUVGLUHFWHGE\
WKHVKULOOYRLFHRI=RJDU6DJZHUHGHVWUR\LQJWKHZRXQGHGVHUSHQW
ZLWKDUURZV7KHPRQVWHUZDVRXWRIWKHVKDPDQ
VFRQWURO$PRPHQW
ODWHUWKHTXDOLW\RIWKH\HOOVZDVDOWHUHG6FUHHFKHVRIUDJHURVHLQ
WKHQLJKW
&RQDQODXJKHGJULPO\+HZDVOHDGLQJ%DOWKXVDORQJDQDUURZWUDLO
WKDWUDQZHVWXQGHUWKHEODFNEUDQFKHVVWHSSLQJDVVZLIWO\DQG
VXUHO\DVLIKHWURGDZHOOOLJKWHGWKRURXJKIDUH%DOWKXVVWXPEOHG
DIWHUKLPJXLGLQJKLPVHOIE\IHHOLQJWKHGHQVHZDOORQHLWKHUKDQG
7KH\
OOEHDIWHUXVQRZ=RJDU
VGLVFRYHUHG\RX
UHJRQHDQGKH
NQRZVP\KHDGZDVQ
WLQWKHSLOHEHIRUHWKHDOWDUKXW7KHGRJ,I
,
GKDGDQRWKHUVSHDU,
GKDYHWKURZQLWWKURXJKKLPEHIRUH,VWUXFN
WKHVQDNH.HHSWRWKHWUDLO7KH\FDQ
WWUDFNXVE\WRUFKOLJKWDQG
WKHUHDUHDVFRUHRISDWKVOHDGLQJIURPWKHYLOODJH7KH\
OOIROORZ
WKRVHOHDGLQJWRWKHULYHUILUVWWKURZDFRUGRQRIZDUULRUVIRU
PLOHVDORQJWKHEDQNH[SHFWLQJXVWRWU\WREUHDNWKURXJK:HZRQ
W
WDNHWRWKHZRRGVXQWLOZHKDYHWR:HFDQPDNHEHWWHUWLPHRQWKLV
WUDLO1RZEXFNOHGRZQWRLWDQGUXQZDV\RXQHYHUUDQEHIRUH
7KH\JRWRYHUWKHLUSDQLFFXUVHGTXLFNSDQWHG%DOWKXV
FRPSO\LQJZLWKDIUHVKEXUVWRIVSHHG
7KH\
UHQRWDIUDLGRIDQ\WKLQJYHU\ORQJJUXQWHG&RQDQ
)RUDVSDFHQRWKLQJZDVVDLGEHWZHHQWKHP7KHIXJLWLYHVGHYRWHG
DOOWKHLUDWWHQWLRQWRFRYHULQJGLVWDQFH7KH\ZHUHSOXQJLQJGHHSHU
DQGGHHSHULQWRWKHZLOGHUQHVVDQGJHWWLQJIDUWKHUDZD\IURP
FLYLOL]DWLRQDWHYHU\VWHSEXW%DOWKXVGLGQRWTXHVWLRQ&RQDQV
ZLVGRP7KH&LPPHULDQSUHVHQWO\WRRNWLPHWRJUXQW:KHQZH
UHIDU
HQRXJKDZD\IURPWKHYLOODJHZH
OOVZLQJEDFNWRWKHULYHULQDELJ
FLUFOH1RRWKHUYLOODJHZLWKLQPLOHVRI*ZDZHOD$OOWKH3LFWVDUH
JDWKHUHGLQWKDWYLFLQLW\:H
OOFLUFOHZLGHDURXQGWKHP7KH\FDQ
W
WUDFNXVXQWLOGD\OLJKW7KH\
OOSLFNXSRXUSDWKWKHQEXWEHIRUH
GDZQZH
OOOHDYHWKHWUDLODQGWDNHWRWKHZRRGV
7KH\SOXQJHGRQ7KH\HOOVGLHGRXWEHKLQGWKHP%DOWKXV
EUHDWK
ZDVZKLVWOLQJWKURXJKKLVWHHWK+HIHOWDSDLQLQKLVVLGHDQG
UXQQLQJEHFDPHWRUWXUH+HEOXQGHUHGDJDLQVWWKHEXVKHVRQHDFKVLGH
RIWKHWUDLO&RQDQSXOOHGXSVXGGHQO\WXUQHGDQGVWDUHGEDFNGRZQ
WKHGLPSDWK
6RPHZKHUHWKHPRRQZDVULVLQJDGLPZKLWHJORZDPLGVWDWDQJOHRI
EUDQFKHV
6KDOOZHWDNHWRWKHZRRGV"SDQWHG%DOWKXV
*LYHPH\RXUD[PXUPXUHG&RQDQVRIWO\6RPHWKLQJLVFORVH
EHKLQGXV
7KHQZH
GEHWWHUOHDYHWKHWUDLOH[FODLPHG%DOWKXV&RQDQVKRRN
KLVKHDGDQGGUHZKLVFRPSDQLRQLQWRDGHQVHWKLFNHW7KHPRRQURVH
KLJKHUPDNLQJDGLPOLJKWLQWKHSDWK
:HFDQ
WILJKWWKHZKROHWULEHZKLVSHUHG%DOWKXV
1RKXPDQEHLQJFRXOGKDYHIRXQGRXUWUDLOVRTXLFNO\RUIROORZHG
XVVRVZLIWO\PXWWHUHG&RQDQ.HHSVLOHQW
7KHUHIROORZHGDWHQVHVLOHQFHLQZKLFK%DOWKXVIHOWWKDWKLV
KHDUWFRXOGEHKHDUGSRXQGLQJIRUPLOHVDZD\7KHQDEUXSWO\ZLWKRXW
DVRXQGWRDQQRXQFHLWVFRPLQJDVDYDJHKHDGDSSHDUHGLQWKHGLP
SDWK%DOWKXV
KHDUWMXPSHGLQWRKLVWKURDWDWILUVWJODQFHKH
IHDUHGWRORRNXSRQWKHDZIXOKHDGRIWKHVDEHUWRRWK%XWWKLVKHDG
ZDVVPDOOHUPRUHQDUURZLWZDVDOHRSDUGZKLFKVWRRGWKHUH
VQDUOLQJVLOHQWO\DQGJODULQJGRZQWKHWUDLO:KDWZLQGWKHUHZDVZDV
EORZLQJWRZDUGWKHKLGLQJPHQFRQFHDOLQJWKHLUVFHQW7KHEHDVW
ORZHUHGKLVKHDGDQGVQXIIHGWKHWUDLOWKHQPRYHGIRUZDUG
XQFHUWDLQO\$FKLOOSOD\HGGRZQ%DOWKXV
VSLQH7KHEUXWHZDV
XQGRXEWHGO\WUDLOLQJWKHP
$QGLWZDVVXVSLFLRXV,WOLIWHGLWVKHDGLWVH\HVJORZLQJOLNH
EDOOVRIILUHDQGJURZOHGORZLQLWVWKURDW$QGDWWKDWLQVWDQW
&RQDQKXUOHGWKHD[
$OOWKHZHLJKWRIDUPDQGVKRXOGHUZDVEHKLQGWKHWKURZDQGWKH
D[ZDVDVWUHDNRIVLOYHULQWKHGLPPRRQ$OPRVWEHIRUHKHUHDOL]HG
ZKDWKDGKDSSHQHG%DOWKXVVDZWKHOHRSDUGUROOLQJRQWKHJURXQGLQ
LWVGHDWKWKURHVWKHKDQGOHRIWKHD[VWDQGLQJXSIURPLWVKHDG7KH
KHDGRIWKHZHDSRQKDGVSOLWLWVQDUURZVNXOO
&RQDQERXQGHGIURPWKHEXVKHVZUHQFKHGKLVD[IUHHDQGGUDJJHG
WKHOLPSERG\LQDPRQJWKHWUHHVFRQFHDOLQJLWIURPWKHFDVXDO
JODQFH
1RZOHW
VJRDQGJRIDVWKHJUXQWHGOHDGLQJWKHZD\
VRXWKZDUGDZD\IURPWKHWUDLO7KHUH
OOEHZDUULRUVFRPLQJDIWHU
WKDWFDW$VVRRQDVKHJRWKLVZLWVEDFN=RJDUVHQWKLPDIWHUXV
7KH3LFWVZRXOGIROORZKLPEXWKH
GOHDYHWKHPIDUEHKLQG+H
G
FLUFOHWKHYLOODJHXQWLOKHKLWRXUWUDLODQGWKHQFRPHDIWHUXVOLNH
DVWUHDN7KH\FRXOGQ
WNHHSXSZLWKKLPEXWWKH\
OOKDYHDQLGHDDV
WRRXUJHQHUDOGLUHFWLRQ7KH\
GIROORZOLVWHQLQJIRUKLVFU\:HOO
WKH\ZRQ
WKHDUWKDWEXWWKH\
OOILQGWKHEORRGRQWKHWUDLODQG
ORRNDURXQGDQGILQGWKHERG\LQWKHEUXVK7KH\
OOSLFNXSRXUVSRRU
WKHUHLIWKH\FDQ:DONZLWKFDUH
+HDYRLGHGFOLQJLQJEULDUVDQGORZKDQJLQJEUDQFKHVHIIRUWOHVVO\
JOLGLQJEHWZHHQWUHHVZLWKRXWWRXFKLQJWKHVWHPVDQGDOZD\VSODQWLQJ
KLVIHHWLQWKHSODFHVFDOFXODWHGWRVKRZOHDVWHYLGHQFHRIKLV
SDVVLQJEXWZLWK%DOWKXVLWZDVVORZHUPRUHODERULRXVZRUN
1RVRXQGFDPHIURPEHKLQGWKHP7KH\KDGFRYHUHGPRUHWKDQDPLOH
ZKHQ%DOWKXVVDLG'RHV=RJDU6DJFDWFKOHRSDUGFXEVDQGWUDLQWKHP
IRUEORRGKRXQGV"
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDG7KDWZDVDOHRSDUGKHFDOOHGRXWRIWKH
ZRRGV
%XW%DOWKXVSHUVLVWHGLIKHFDQRUGHUWKHEHDVWVWRGRKLV
ELGGLQJZK\GRHVQ
WKHURXVHWKHPDOODQGKDYHWKHPDIWHUXV"7KH
IRUHVWLVIXOORIOHRSDUGVZK\VHQGRQO\RQHDIWHUXV"
&RQDQGLGQRWUHSO\IRUDVSDFHDQGZKHQKHGLGLWZDVZLWKD
FXULRXVUHWLFHQFH
+HFDQ
WFRPPDQGDOOWKHDQLPDOV2QO\VXFKDVUHPHPEHU-KHEEDO
6DJ
-KHEEDO6DJ"%DOWKXVUHSHDWHGWKHDQFLHQWQDPHKHVLWDQWO\+H
KDGQHYHUKHDUGLWVSRNHQPRUHWKDQWKUHHRUIRXUWLPHVLQKLVZKROH
OLIH
2QFHDOOOLYLQJWKLQJVZRUVKLSSHGKLP7KDWZDVORQJDJRZKHQ
EHDVWVDQGPHQVSRNHRQHODQJXDJH0HQKDYHIRUJRWWHQKLPHYHQWKH
EHDVWVIRUJHW2QO\DIHZUHPHPEHU7KHPHQZKRUHPHPEHU-KHEEDO6DJ
DQGWKHEHDVWVZKRUHPHPEHUDUHEURWKHUVDQGVSHDNWKHVDPHWRQJXH
%DOWKXVGLGQRWUHSO\KHKDGVWUDLQHGDWD3LFWLVKVWDNHDQGVHHQ
WKHQLJKWHGMXQJOHJLYHXSLWVIDQJHGKRUURUVDWDVKDPDQ
VFDOO
&LYLOL]HGPHQODXJKVDLG&RQDQ%XWQRWRQHFDQWHOOPHKRZ
=RJDU6DJFDQFDOOS\WKRQVDQGWLJHUVDQGOHRSDUGVRXWRIWKH
ZLOGHUQHVVDQGPDNHWKHPGRKLVELGGLQJ7KH\ZRXOGVD\LWLVDOLH
LIWKH\GDUHG7KDW
VWKHZD\ZLWKFLYLOL]HGPHQ:KHQWKH\FDQ
W
H[SODLQVRPHWKLQJE\WKHLUKDOIEDNHGVFLHQFHWKH\UHIXVHWREHOLHYH
LW
7KHSHRSOHRQWKH7DXUDQZHUHFORVHUWRWKHSULPLWLYHWKDQPRVW
$TXLORQLDQVVXSHUVWLWLRQVSHUVLVWHGZKRVHVRXUFHVZHUHORVWLQ
DQWLTXLW\$QG%DOWKXVKDGVHHQWKDWZKLFKVWLOOSULFNOHGKLVIOHVK
+HFRXOGQRWUHIXWHWKHPRQVWURXVWKLQJZKLFK&RQDQ
VZRUGVLPSOLHG
,
YHKHDUGWKDWWKHUH
VDQDQFLHQWJURYHVDFUHGWR-KHEEDO6DJ
VRPHZKHUHLQWKLVIRUHVWVDLG&RQDQ,GRQ
WNQRZ,
YHQHYHUVHHQ
LW%XWPRUHEHDVWVUHPHPEHULQWKLVFRXQWU\WKDQDQ\,
YHHYHU
VHHQ
7KHQRWKHUVZLOOEHRQRXUWUDLO"
7KH\DUHQRZZDV&RQDQ
VGLVTXLHWLQJDQVZHU=RJDUZRXOGQHYHU
OHDYHRXUWUDFNLQJWRRQHEHDVWDORQH
:KDWDUHZHWRGRWKHQ"DVNHG%DOWKXVXQHDVLO\JUDVSLQJKLVD[
DVKHVWDUHGDWWKHJORRP\DUFKHVDERYHKLP+LVIOHVKFUDZOHGZLWK
WKHPRPHQWDU\H[SHFWDWLRQRIULSSLQJWDORQVDQGIDQJVOHDSLQJIURP
WKHVKDGRZV
:DLW
&RQDQWXUQHGVTXDWWHGDQGZLWKKLVNQLIHEHJDQVFUDWFKLQJD
FXULRXVV\PEROLQWKHPROG6WRRSLQJWRORRNDWLWRYHUKLVVKRXOGHU
%DOWKXVIHOWDFUDZOLQJRIWKHIOHVKDORQJKLVVSLQHKHNQHZQRW
ZK\+HIHOWQRZLQGDJDLQVWKLVIDFHEXWWKHUHZDVDUXVWOLQJRI
OHDYHVDERYHWKHPDQGDZHLUGPRDQLQJVZHSWJKRVWLO\WKURXJKWKH
EUDQFKHV&RQDQJODQFHGXSLQVFUXWDEO\WKHQURVHDQGVWRRGVWDULQJ
VRPEHUO\GRZQDWWKHV\PEROKHKDGGUDZQ
:KDWLVLW"ZKLVSHUHG%DOWKXV,WORRNHGDUFKDLFDQGPHDQLQJOHVV
WRKLP+HVXSSRVHGWKDWLWZDVKLVLJQRUDQFHRIDUWLVWU\ZKLFK
SUHYHQWHGKLVLGHQWLI\LQJLWDVRQHRIWKHFRQYHQWLRQDOGHVLJQVRI
VRPHSUHYDLOLQJFXOWXUH%XWKDGKHEHHQWKHPRVWHUXGLWHDUWLVWLQ
WKHZRUOGKHZRXOGKDYHEHHQQRQHDUHUWKHVROXWLRQ
,VDZLWFDUYHGLQWKHURFNRIDFDYHQRKXPDQKDGYLVLWHGIRUD
PLOOLRQ\HDUVPXWWHUHG&RQDQLQWKHXQLQKDELWHGPRXQWDLQVEH\RQG
WKH6HDRI9LOD\HWKDOIDZRUOGDZD\IURPWKLVVSRW/DWHU,VDZD
EODFNZLWFKILQGHURI.XVKVFUDWFKLWLQWKHVDQGRIDQDPHOHVV
ULYHU+HWROGPHSDUWRILWVPHDQLQJLW
VVDFUHGWR-KHEEDO6DJ
DQGWKHFUHDWXUHVZKLFKZRUVKLSKLP:DWFK
7KH\GUHZEDFNDPRQJWKHGHQVHIROLDJHVRPH\DUGVDZD\DQGZDLWHG
LQWHQVHVLOHQFH7RWKHHDVWGUXPVPXWWHUHGDQGVRPHZKHUHWRQRUWK
DQGZHVWRWKHUGUXPVDQVZHUHG%DOWKXVVKLYHUHGWKRXJKKHNQHZORQJ
PLOHVRIEODFNIRUHVWVHSDUDWHGKLPIURPWKHJULPEHDWHUVRIWKRVH
GUXPVZKRVHGXOOSXOVLQJZDVDVLQLVWHURYHUWXUHWKDWVHWWKHGDUN
VWDJHIRUEORRG\GUDPD
%DOWKXVIRXQGKLPVHOIKROGLQJKLVEUHDWK7KHQZLWKDVOLJKW
VKDNLQJRIWKHOHDYHVWKHEXVKHVSDUWHGDQGDPDJQLILFHQWSDQWKHU
FDPHLQWRYLHZ7KHPRRQOLJKWGDSSOLQJWKURXJKWKHOHDYHVVKRQHRQ
LWVJORVV\FRDWULSSOLQJZLWKWKHSOD\RIWKHJUHDWPXVFOHVEHQHDWK
LW
:LWKLWVKHDGORZLWJOLGHGWRZDUGWKHP,WZDVVPHOOLQJRXWWKHLU
WUDLO7KHQLWKDOWHGDVLIIUR]HQLWVPX]]OHDOPRVWWRXFKLQJWKH
V\PEROFXWLQWKHPROG)RUDORQJVSDFHLWFURXFKHGPRWLRQOHVVLW
IODWWHQHGLWVORQJERG\DQGODLGLWVKHDGRQWKHJURXQGEHIRUHWKH
PDUN$QG%DOWKXVIHOWWKHVKRUWKDLUVVWLURQKLVVFDOS)RUWKH
DWWLWXGHRIWKHJUHDWFDUQLYRUHZDVRQHRIDZHDQGDGRUDWLRQ
7KHQWKHSDQWKHUURVHDQGEDFNHGDZD\FDUHIXOO\EHOO\DOPRVWWR
WKHJURXQG:LWKKLVKLQGTXDUWHUVDPRQJWKHEXVKHVKHZKHHOHGDVLI
LQVXGGHQSDQLFDQGZDVJRQHOLNHDIODVKRIGDSSOHGOLJKW
%DOWKXVPRSSHGKLVEURZZLWKDWUHPEOLQJKDQGDQGJODQFHGDW
&RQDQ
7KHEDUEDULDQ
VH\HVZHUHVPROGHULQJZLWKILUHVWKDWQHYHUOLWWKH
H\HVRIPHQEUHGWRWKHLGHDVRIFLYLOL]DWLRQ,QWKDWLQVWDQWKHZDV
DOOZLOGDQGKDGIRUJRWWHQWKHPDQDWKLVVLGH,QKLVEXUQLQJJD]H
%DOWKXVJOLPSVHGDQGYDJXHO\UHFRJQL]HGSULVWLQHLPDJHVDQGKDOI
HPERGLHGPHPRULHVVKDGRZVIURP/LIH
VGDZQIRUJRWWHQDQGUHSXGLDWHG
E\VRSKLVWLFDWHGUDFHVDQFLHQWSULPHYDOIDQWDVPVXQQDPHGDQG
QDPHOHVV
7KHQWKHGHHSHUILUHVZHUHPDVNHGDQG&RQDQZDVVLOHQWO\OHDGLQJ
WKHZD\GHHSHULQWRWKHIRUHVW
:H
YHQRPRUHWRIHDUIURPWKHEHDVWVKHVDLGDIWHUDZKLOH
EXWZH
YHOHIWDVLJQIRUPHQWRUHDG7KH\ZRQ
WIROORZRXUWUDLO
YHU\HDVLO\DQGXQWLOWKH\ILQGWKDWV\PEROWKH\ZRQ
WNQRZIRUVXUH
ZH
YHWXUQHGVRXWK(YHQWKHQLWZRQ
WEHHDV\WRVPHOOXVRXW
ZLWKRXWWKHEHDVWVWRDLGWKHP%XWWKHZRRGVVRXWKRIWKHWUDLOZLOO
EHIXOORIZDUULRUVORRNLQJIRUXV,IZHNHHSPRYLQJDIWHUGD\OLJKW
ZH
OOEHVXUHWRUXQLQWRVRPHRIWKHP$VVRRQDVZHILQGDJRRG
SODFHZH
OOKLGHDQGZDLWXQWLODQRWKHUQLJKWWRVZLQJEDFNDQGPDNH
WKHULYHU:H
YHJRWWRZDUQ9DODQQXVEXWLWZRQ
WKHOSKLPDQ\LI
ZHJHWRXUVHOYHVNLOOHG
:DUQ9DODQQXV"
+HOOWKHZRRGVDORQJWKHULYHUDUHVZDUPLQJZLWK3LFWV7KDW
V
ZK\WKH\JRWXV=RJDU
VEUHZLQJZDUPDJLFQRPHUHUDLGWKLVWLPH
+H
VGRQHVRPHWKLQJQR3LFWKDVGRQHLQP\PHPRU\XQLWHGDVPDQ\
DVILIWHHQRUVL[WHHQFODQV+LVPDJLFGLGLWWKH\
OOIROORZD
ZL]DUGIDUWKHUWKDQWKH\ZLOODZDUFKLHI<RXVDZWKHPRELQWKH
YLOODJHDQGWKHUHZHUHKXQGUHGVKLGLQJDORQJWKHULYHUEDQNWKDW\RX
GLGQ
WVHH0RUHFRPLQJIURPWKHIDUWKHUYLOODJHV+H
OOKDYHDW
OHDVWWKUHHWKRXVDQGILJKWLQJPHQ,OD\LQWKHEXVKHVDQGKHDUG
WKHLUWDONDVWKH\ZHQWSDVW7KH\PHDQWRDWWDFNWKHIRUWZKHQ,
GRQ
WNQRZEXW=RJDUGRHVQ
WGDUHGHOD\ORQJ+H
VJDWKHUHGWKHPDQG
ZKLSSHGWKHPLQWRDIUHQ]\,IKHGRHVQ
WOHDGWKHPLQWREDWWOH
TXLFNO\WKH\
OOIDOOWRTXDUUHOLQJZLWKRQHDQRWKHU7KH\
UHOLNH
EORRGPDGWLJHUV
,GRQ
WNQRZZKHWKHUWKH\FDQWDNHWKHIRUWRUQRW$Q\ZD\ZH
YH
JRWWRJHWEDFNDFURVVWKHULYHUDQGJLYHWKHZDUQLQJ7KHVHWWOHUV
RQWKH9HOLWULXPURDGPXVWHLWKHUJHWLQWRWKHIRUWRUEDFNWR
9HOLWULXP:KLOHWKH3LFWVDUHEHVLHJLQJWKHIRUWZDUSDUWLHVZLOO
UDQJHWKHURDGIDUWRWKHHDVWPLJKWHYHQFURVV7KXQGHU5LYHUDQG
UDLGWKHWKLFNO\VHWWOHGFRXQWU\EHKLQG9HOLWULXP
$VKHWDONHGKHZDVOHDGLQJWKHZD\GHHSHUDQGGHHSHULQWRWKH
DQFLHQWZLOGHUQHVV3UHVHQWO\KHJUXQWHGZLWKVDWLVIDFWLRQ7KH\KDG
UHDFKHGDVSRWZKHUHWKHXQGHUEUXVKZDVPRUHVFDWWHUHGDQGDQ
RXWFURSSLQJRIVWRQHZDVYLVLEOHZDQGHULQJRIIVRXWKZDUG%DOWKXV
IHOWPRUHVHFXUHDVWKH\IROORZHGLW1RWHYHQD3LFWFRXOGWUDLO
WKHPRYHUQDNHGURFN
+RZGLG\RXJHWDZD\"KHDVNHGSUHVHQWO\
&RQDQWDSSHGKLVPDLOVKLUWDQGKHOPHW
,IPRUHERUGHUHUVZRXOGZHDUKDUQHVVWKHUH
GEHIHZHUVNXOOV
KDQJLQJRQWKHDOWDUKXWV%XWPRVWPHQPDNHQRLVHLIWKH\ZHDU
DUPRU7KH\ZHUHZDLWLQJRQHDFKVLGHRIWKHSDWKZLWKRXWPRYLQJ
$QGZKHQD3LFWVWDQGVPRWLRQOHVVWKHYHU\EHDVWVRIWKHIRUHVWSDVV
KLPZLWKRXWVHHLQJKLP7KH\
GVHHQXVFURVVLQJWKHULYHUDQGJRWLQ
WKHLUSODFHV,IWKH\
GJRQHLQWRDPEXVKDIWHUZHOHIWWKHEDQN,
G
KDYHKDGVRPHKLQWRILW%XWWKH\ZHUHZDLWLQJDQGQRWHYHQDOHDI
WUHPEOHG7KHGHYLOKLPVHOIFRXOGQ
WKDYHVXVSHFWHGDQ\WKLQJ7KH
ILUVWVXVSLFLRQ,KDGZDVZKHQ,KHDUGDVKDIWUDVSDJDLQVWDERZDV
LWZDVSXOOHGEDFN,GURSSHGDQG\HOOHGIRUWKHPHQEHKLQGPHWR
GURSEXWWKH\ZHUHWRRVORZWDNHQE\VXUSULVHOLNHWKDW
0RVWRIWKHPIHOODWWKHILUVWYROOH\WKDWUDNHGXVIURPERWK
VLGHV6RPHRIWKHDUURZVFURVVHGWKHWUDLODQGVWUXFN3LFWVRQWKH
RWKHUVLGH,KHDUGWKHPKRZO+HJULQQHGZLWKYLFLRXVVDWLVIDFWLRQ
6XFKRIXVDVZHUHOHIWSOXQJHGLQWRWKHZRRGVDQGFORVHGZLWKWKHP
:KHQ,VDZWKHRWKHUVZHUHDOOGRZQRUWDNHQ,EURNHWKURXJKDQG
RXWIRRWHGWKHSDLQWHGGHYLOVWKURXJKWKHGDUNQHVV7KH\ZHUHDOO
DURXQGPH,UDQDQGFUDZOHGDQGVQHDNHGDQGVRPHWLPHV,OD\RQP\
EHOO\XQGHUWKHEXVKHVZKLOHWKH\SDVVHGPHRQDOOVLGHV
,WULHGIRUWKHVKRUHDQGIRXQGLWOLQHGZLWKWKHPZDLWLQJIRU
MXVWVXFKDPRYH%XWL
GKDYHFXWP\ZD\WKURXJKDQGWDNHQDFKDQFH
RQVZLPPLQJRQO\,KHDUGWKHGUXPVSRXQGLQJLQWKHYLOODJHDQGNQHZ
WKH\
GWDNHQVRPHERG\DOLYH
7KH\ZHUHDOOVRHQJURVVHGLQ=RJDU
VPDJLFWKDW,ZDVDEOHWR
FOLPEWKHZDOOEHKLQGWKHDOWDUKXW7KHUHZDVDZDUULRUVXSSRVHGWR
EHZDWFKLQJDWWKDWSRLQWEXWKHZDVVTXDWWLQJEHKLQGWKHKXWDQG
SHHULQJDURXQGWKHFRUQHUDWWKHFHUHPRQ\,FDPHXSEHKLQGKLPDQG
EURNHKLVQHFNZLWKP\KDQGVEHIRUHKHNQHZZKDWZDVKDSSHQLQJ,W
ZDVKLVVSHDU,WKUHZLQWRWKHVQDNHDQGWKDW
VKLVD[\RX
UH
FDUU\LQJ
%XWZKDWZDVWKDWWKDWWKLQJ\RXNLOOHGLQWKHDOWDUKXW"
DVNHG%DOWKXVZLWKDVKLYHUDWWKHPHPRU\RIWKHGLPVHHQKRUURU
2QHRI=RJDU
VJRGV2QHRI-KHEEDO
VFKLOGUHQWKDWGLGQ
W
UHPHPEHUDQGKDGWREHNHSWFKDLQHGWRWKHDOWDU$EXOODSH7KH
3LFWVWKLQNWKH\
UHVDFUHGWRWKH+DLU\2QHZKROLYHVRQWKHPRRQ
WKHJRULOODJRGRI*XOODK
,W
VJHWWLQJOLJKW+HUH
VDJRRGSODFHWRKLGHXQWLOZHVHHKRZ
FORVHWKH\
UHRQRXUWUDLO3UREDEO\KDYHWRZDLWXQWLOQLJKWWR
EUHDNEDFNWRWKHULYHU
$ORZKLOOSLWFKHGXSZDUGJLUGOHGDQGFRYHUHGZLWKWKLFNWUHHV
DQGEXVKHV1HDUWKHFUHVW&RQDQVOLGLQWRDWDQJOHRIMXWWLQJURFNV
FURZQHGE\GHQVHEXVKHV/\LQJDPRQJWKHPWKH\FRXOGVHHWKHMXQJOH
EHORZZLWKRXWEHLQJVHHQ,WZDVDJRRGSODFHWRKLGHRUGHIHQG
%DOWKXVGLGQRWEHOLHYHWKDWHYHQD3LFWFRXOGKDYHWUDLOHGWKHPRYHU
WKHURFN\JURXQGIRUWKHSDVWIRXURUILYHPLOHVEXWKHZDVDIUDLG
RIWKHEHDVWVWKDWREH\HG=RJDU6DJ+LVIDLWKLQWKHFXULRXVV\PERO
ZDYHUHGDOLWWOHQRZ%XW&RQDQKDGGLVPLVVHGWKHSRVVLELOLW\RI
EHDVWVWUDFNLQJWKHP
$JKRVWO\ZKLWHQHVVVSUHDGWKURXJKWKHGHQVHEUDQFKHVWKHSDWFKHV
RIVN\YLVLEOHDOWHUHGLQKXHJUHZIURPSLQNWREOXH%DOWKXVIHOW
WKHJQDZLQJRIKXQJHUWKRXJKKHKDGVODNHGKLVWKLUVWDWDVWUHDP
WKH\KDGVNLUWHG7KHUHZDVFRPSOHWHVLOHQFHH[FHSWIRUDQ
RFFDVLRQDOFKLUSRIDELUG7KHGUXPVZHUHQRORQJHUWREHKHDUG
%DOWKXV
WKRXJKWVUHYHUWHGWRWKHJULPVFHQHEHIRUHWKHDOWDUKXW
7KRVHZHUHRVWULFKSOXPHV=RJDU6DJZRUHKHVDLG,
YHVHHQ
WKHPRQWKHKHOPHWVRINQLJKWVZKRURGHIURPWKH(DVWWRYLVLWWKH
EDURQVRIWKHPDUFKHV7KHUHDUHQRRVWULFKHVLQWKLVIRUHVWDUH
WKHUH"
7KH\FDPHIURP.XVKDQVZHUHG&RQDQ:HVWRIKHUHPDQ\
PDUFKHVOLHVWKHVHDVKRUH6KLSVIURP=LQJDUDRFFDVLRQDOO\FRPHDQG
WUDGHZHDSRQVDQGRUQDPHQWVDQGZLQHWRWKHFRDVWDOWULEHVIRUVNLQV
DQGFRSSHURUHDQGJROGGXVW6RPHWLPHVWKH\WUDGHRVWULFKSOXPHV
WKH\JRWIURPWKH6W\JLDQVZKRLQWXUQJRWWKHPIURPWKHEODFN
WULEHVRI.XVKZKLFKOLHVVRXWKRI6W\JLD7KH3LFWLVKVKDPDQVSODFH
JUHDWVWRUHE\WKHP%XWWKHUH
VPXFKULVNLQVXFKWUDGH7KH3LFWV
DUHWRROLNHO\WRWU\WRVHL]HWKHVKLS$QGWKHFRDVWLVGDQJHURXV
WRVKLSV,
YHVDLOHGDORQJLWZKHQ,ZDVZLWKWKHSLUDWHVRIWKH
%DUDFKDQ,VOHVZKLFKOLHVRXWKZHVWRI=LQJDUD
%DOWKXVORRNHGDWKLVFRPSDQLRQZLWKDGPLUDWLRQ
,NQHZ\RXKDGQ
WVSHQW\RXUOLIHRQWKLVIURQWLHU<RX
YH
PHQWLRQHGVHYHUDOIDUSODFHV<RX
YHWUDYHOHGZLGHO\"
,
YHURDPHGIDUIDUWKHUWKDQDQ\RWKHUPDQRIP\UDFHHYHU
ZDQGHUHG,
YHVHHQDOOWKHJUHDWFLWLHVRIWKH+\ERULDQVWKH
6KHPLWHVWKH6W\JLDQVDQGWKH+\UNDQLDQV,
YHURDPHGLQWKH
XQNQRZQFRXQWULHVVRXWKRIWKHEODFNNLQJGRPVRI.XVKDQGHDVWRI
WKH6HDRI9LOD\HW,
YHEHHQDPHUFHQDU\FDSWDLQDFRUVDLUD
BNR]DNBDSHQQLOHVVYDJDERQGDJHQHUDOKHOO,
YHEHHQ
HYHU\WKLQJH[FHSWDNLQJRIDFLYLOL]HGFRXQWU\DQG,PD\EHWKDW
EHIRUH,GLH7KHIDQF\SOHDVHGKLPDQGKHJULQQHGKDUGO\7KHQKH
VKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGVWUHWFKHGKLVPLJKW\ILJXUHRQWKHURFNV
7KLVLVDVJRRGDOLIHDVDQ\,GRQ
WNQRZKRZORQJ,
OOVWD\RQ
WKHIURQWLHUDZHHNDPRQWKD\HDU,KDYHDURYLQJIRRW%XWLW
V
DVZHOORQWKHERUGHUDVDQ\ZKHUH
%DOWKXVVHWKLPVHOIWRZDWFKWKHIRUHVWEHORZWKHP0RPHQWDULO\KH
H[SHFWHGWRVHHILHUFHSDLQWHGIDFHVWKUXVWWKURXJKWKHOHDYHV%XW
DVWKHKRXUVSDVVHGQRVWHDOWK\IRRWIDOOGLVWXUEHGWKHEURRGLQJ
TXLHW%DOWKXVEHOLHYHGWKH3LFWVKDGPLVVHGWKHLUWUDLODQGJLYHQXS
WKHFKDVH&RQDQJUHZUHVWOHVV
:HVKRXOGKDYHVLJKWHGSDUWLHVVFRXULQJWKHZRRGVIRUXV,I
WKH\
YHTXLWWKHFKDVHLW
VEHFDXVHWKH\
UHDIWHUELJJHUJDPH7KH\
PD\EHJDWKHULQJWRFURVVWKHULYHUDQGVWRUPWKHIRUW
:RXOGWKH\FRPHWKLVIDUVRXWKLIWKH\ORVWWKHWUDLO"
7KH\
YHORVWWKHWUDLODOOULJKWRWKHUZLVHWKH\
GKDYHEHHQRQ
RXUQHFNVEHIRUHQRZ8QGHURUGLQDU\FLUFXPVWDQFHVWKH\
GVFRXUWKH
ZRRGVIRUPLOHVLQHYHU\GLUHFWLRQ6RPHRIWKHPVKRXOGKDYHSDVVHG
ZLWKRXWVLJKWRIWKLVKLOO7KH\PXVWEHSUHSDULQJWRFURVVWKH
ULYHU:H
YHJRWWRWDNHDFKDQFHDQGPDNHIRUWKHULYHU
&UHHSLQJGRZQWKHURFNV%DOWKXVIHOWKLVIOHVKFUDZOEHWZHHQKLV
VKRXOGHUVDVKHPRPHQWDULO\H[SHFWHGDZLWKHULQJEODVWRIDUURZVIURP
WKHJUHHQPDVVHVDERYHWKHP+HIHDUHGWKDWWKH3LFWVKDGGLVFRYHUHG
WKHPDQGZHUHO\LQJDERXWLQDPEXVK%XW&RQDQZDVFRQYLQFHGQR
HQHPLHVZHUHQHDUDQGWKH&LPPHULDQZDVULJKW
:H
UHPLOHVWRWKHVRXWKRIWKHYLOODJHJUXQWHG&RQDQ:H
OO
KLWVWUDLJKWWKURXJKIRUWKHULYHU,GRQ
WNQRZKRZIDUGRZQWKH
ULYHUWKH\
YHVSUHDG:H
OOKRSHWRKLWLWEHORZWKHP
:LWKKDVWHWKDWVHHPHGUHFNOHVVWR%DOWKXVWKH\KXUULHGHDVWZDUG
7KHZRRGVVHHPHGHPSW\RIOLIH&RQDQEHOLHYHGWKDWDOOWKH3LFWV
ZHUHJDWKHUHGLQWKHYLFLQLW\RI*ZDZHODLILQGHHGWKH\KDGQRW
DOUHDG\FURVVHGWKHULYHU+HGLGQRWEHOLHYHWKH\ZRXOGFURVVLQWKH
GD\WLPHKRZHYHU
6RPHZRRGVPDQZRXOGEHVXUHWRVHHWKHPDQGJLYHWKHDODUP
7KH\
OOFURVVDERYHDQGEHORZWKHIRUWRXWRIVLJKWRIWKHVHQWULHV
7KHQRWKHUVZLOOJHWLQFDQRHVDQGPDNHVWUDLJKWDFURVVIRUWKHULYHU
ZDOO$VVRRQDVWKH\DWWDFNWKRVHKLGGHQLQWKHZRRGVRQWKHHDVW
VKRUHZLOODVVDLOWKHIRUWIURPWKHRWKHUVLGHV7KH\
YHWULHGWKDW
EHIRUHDQGJRWWKHJXWVVKRWDQGKDFNHGRXWRIWKHP%XWWKLVWLPH
WKH\
YHJRWHQRXJKPHQWRPDNHDUHDORQVODXJKWRILW
7KH\SXVKHGRQZLWKRXWSDXVLQJWKRXJK%DOWKXVJD]HGORQJLQJO\DW
WKHVTXLUUHOVIOLWWLQJDPRQJWKHEUDQFKHVZKLFKKHFRXOGKDYH
EURXJKWGRZQZLWKDFDVWRIKLVD[:LWKDVLJKKHGUHZXSKLVEURDG
EHOW7KHHYHUODVWLQJVLOHQFHDQGJORRPRIWKHSULPLWLYHIRUHVWZDV
EHJLQQLQJWRGHSUHVVKLP+HIRXQGKLPVHOIWKLQNLQJRIWKHRSHQ
JURYHVDQGVXQGDSSOHGPHDGRZVRIWKH7DXUDQRIWKHEOXIIFKHHURI
KLVIDWKHU
VVWHHSWKDWFKHGGLDPRQGSDQHGKRXVHRIWKHIDWFRZV
EURZVLQJWKURXJKWKHGHHSOXVKJUDVVDQGWKHKHDUW\IHOORZVKLSRI
WKHEUDZQ\EDUHDUPHGSORZPHQDQGKHUGVPHQ
+HIHOWORQHO\LQVSLWHRIKLVFRPSDQLRQ&RQDQZDVDVPXFKD
SDUWRIWKLVZLOGHUQHVVDV%DOWKXVZDVDOLHQWRLW7KH&LPPHULDQ
PLJKWKDYHVSHQW\HDUVDPRQJWKHJUHDWFLWLHVRIWKHZRUOGKHPLJKW
KDYHZDONHGZLWKWKHUXOHUVRIFLYLOL]DWLRQKHPLJKWHYHQDFKLHYH
KLVZLOGZKLPVRPHGD\DQGUXOHDVNLQJRIDFLYLOL]HGQDWLRQ
VWUDQJHUWKLQJVKDGKDSSHQHG%XWKHZDVQROHVVDEDUEDULDQ+HZDV
FRQFHUQHGRQO\ZLWKWKHQDNHGIXQGDPHQWDOVRIOLIH7KHZDUP
LQWLPDFLHVRIVPDOONLQGO\WKLQJVWKHVHQWLPHQWVDQGGHOLFLRXV
WULYLDOLWLHVWKDWPDNHXSVRPXFKRIFLYLOL]HGPHQ
VOLYHVZHUH
PHDQLQJOHVVWRKLP$ZROIZDVQROHVVDZROIEHFDXVHDZKLPRI
FKDQFHFDXVHGKLPWRUXQZLWKWKHZDWFKGRJV%ORRGVKHGDQGYLROHQFH
DQGVDYDJHU\ZHUHWKHQDWXUDOHOHPHQWVRIWKHOLIH&RQDQNQHZKH
FRXOGQRWDQGZRXOGQHYHUXQGHUVWDQGWKHOLWWOHWKLQJVWKDWDUHVR
GHDUWRFLYLOL]HGPHQDQGZRPHQ
7KHVKDGRZVZHUHOHQJWKHQLQJZKHQWKH\UHDFKHGWKHULYHUDQG
SHHUHGWKURXJKWKHPDVNLQJEXVKHV7KH\FRXOGVHHXSDQGGRZQWKH
ULYHUIRUDERXWDPLOHHDFKZD\7KHVXOOHQVWUHDPOD\EDUHDQG
HPSW\&RQDQVFRZOHGDFURVVDWWKHRWKHUVKRUH
:H
YHJRWWRWDNHDQRWKHUFKDQFHKHUH:H
YHJRWWRVZLPWKH
ULYHU:HGRQ
WNQRZZKHWKHUWKH\
YHFURVVHGRUQRW7KHZRRGVRYHU
WKHUHPD\EHDOLYHZLWKWKHP:H
YHJRWWRULVNLW:H
UHDERXWVL[
PLOHVVRXWKRI*ZDZHOD
+HZKHHOHGDQGGXFNHGDVDERZVWULQJWZDQJHG6RPHWKLQJOLNHD
ZKLWHIODVKRIOLJKWVWUHDNHGWKURXJKWKHEXVKHV%DOWKXVNQHZLWZDV
DQDUURZ7KHQZLWKDWLJHULVKERXQG&RQDQZDVWKURXJKWKHEXVKHV
%DOWKXVFDXJKWWKHJOHDPRIVWHHODVKHZKLUOHGKLVVZRUGDQGKHDUG
DGHDWKVFUHDP7KHQH[WLQVWDQWKHKDGEURNHQWKURXJKWKHEXVKHV
DIWHUWKH&LPPHULDQ
$3LFWZLWKDVKDWWHUHGVNXOOOD\IDFHGRZQRQWKHJURXQGKLV
ILQJHUVVSDVPRGLFDOO\FODZLQJDWWKHJUDVV+DOIDGR]HQRWKHUVZHUH
VZDUPLQJDERXW&RQDQVZRUGVDQGD[HVOLIWHG7KH\KDGFDVWDZD\
WKHLUERZVXVHOHVVDWVXFKGHDGO\FORVHTXDUWHUV7KHLUORZHUMDZV
ZHUHSDLQWHGZKLWHFRQWUDVWLQJYLYLGO\ZLWKWKHLUGDUNIDFHVDQG
WKHGHVLJQVRQWKHLUPXVFXODUEUHDVWVGLIIHUHGIURPDQ\%DOWKXVKDG
HYHUVHHQ
2QHRIWKHPKXUOHGKLVD[DW%DOWKXVDQGUXVKHGDIWHULWZLWK
OLIWHGNQLIH%DOWKXVGXFNHGDQGWKHQFDXJKWWKHZULVWWKDWGURYHWKH
NQLIHOLFNLQJDWKLVWKURDW7KH\ZHQWWRWKHJURXQGWRJHWKHU
UROOLQJRYHUDQGRYHU7KH3LFWZDVOLNHDZLOGEHDVWKLVPXVFOHV
KDUGDVVWHHOVWULQJV
%DOWKXVZDVVWULYLQJWRPDLQWDLQKLVKROGRQWKHZLOGPDQ
VZULVW
DQGEULQJKLVRZQD[LQWRSOD\EXWVRIDVWDQGIXULRXVZDVWKH
VWUXJJOHWKDWHDFKDWWHPSWWRVWULNHZDVEORFNHG7KH3LFWZDV
ZUHQFKLQJIXULRXVO\WRIUHHKLVNQLIHKDQGZDVFOXWFKLQJDW%DOWKXV

D[DQGGULYLQJKLVNQHHVDWWKH\RXWK
VJURLQ6XGGHQO\KHDWWHPSWHG
WRVKLIWKLVNQLIHWRKLVIUHHKDQGDQGLQWKDWLQVWDQW%DOWKXV
VWUXJJOLQJXSRQRQHNQHHVSOLWWKHSDLQWHGKHDGZLWKDGHVSHUDWH
EORZRIKLVD[
+HVSUDQJXSDQGJODUHGZLOGO\DERXWIRUKLVFRPSDQLRQH[SHFWLQJ
WRVHHKLPRYHUZKHOPHGE\QXPEHUV7KHQKHUHDOL]HGWKHIXOOVWUHQJWK
DQGIHURFLW\RIWKH&LPPHULDQ&RQDQEHVWURGHWZRRIKLVDWWDFNHUV
VKRUQKDOIDVXQGHUE\WKDWWHUULEOHEURDGVZRUG$V%DOWKXVORRNHGKH
VDZWKH&LPPHULDQEHDWGRZQDWKUXVWLQJVKRUWVZRUGDYRLGWKHVWURNH
RIDQD[ZLWKDFDWOLNHVLGHZLVHVSULQJZKLFKEURXJKWKLPZLWKLQ
DUP
VOHQJWKRIDVTXDWVDYDJHVWRRSLQJIRUDERZ%HIRUHWKH3LFW
FRXOGVWUDLJKWHQWKHUHGVZRUGIODLOHGGRZQDQGFORYHKLPIURP
VKRXOGHUWRPLGEUHDVWERQHZKHUHWKHEODGHVWXFN7KHUHPDLQLQJ
ZDUULRUVUXVKHGLQRQHIURPHLWKHUVLGH%DOWKXVKXUOHGKLVD[ZLWK
DQDFFXUDF\WKDWUHGXFHGWKHDWWDFNHUVWRRQHDQG&RQDQDEDQGRQLQJ
KLVHIIRUWVWRIUHHKLVVZRUGZKHHOHGDQGPHWWKHUHPDLQLQJ3LFW
ZLWKKLVEDUHKDQGV7KHVWRFN\ZDUULRUDKHDGVKRUWHUWKDQKLVWDOO
HQHP\OHDSHGLQVWULNLQJZLWKKLVD[DWWKHVDPHWLPHVWDEELQJ
PXUGHURXVO\ZLWKKLVNQLIH7KHNQLIHEURNHRQWKH&LPPHULDQ
VPDLO
DQGWKHD[FKHFNHGLQPLGDLUDV&RQDQ
VILQJHUVORFNHGOLNHLURQRQ
WKHGHVFHQGLQJDUP$ERQHVQDSSHGORXGO\DQG%DOWKXVVDZWKH3LFW
ZLQFHDQGIDOWHU7KHQH[WLQVWDQWKHZDVVZHSWRIIKLVIHHWOLIWHG
KLJKDERYHWKH&LPPHULDQ
VKHDGKHZULWKHGLQPLGDLUIRUDQ
LQVWDQWNLFNLQJDQGWKUDVKLQJDQGWKHQZDVGDVKHGKHDGORQJWRWKH
HDUWKZLWKVXFKIRUFHWKDWKHUHERXQGHGDQGWKHQOD\VWLOOKLVOLPS
SRVWXUHWHOOLQJRIVSOLQWHUHGOLPEVDQGDEURNHQVSLQH
&RPHRQ&RQDQZUHQFKHGKLVVZRUGIUHHDQGVQDWFKHGXSDQD[
*UDEDERZDQGDKDQGIXORIDUURZVDQGKXUU\:H
YHJRWWRWUXVWWR
RXUKHHOVDJDLQ7KDW\HOOZDVKHDUG7KH\
OOEHKHUHLQQRWLPH,I
ZHWULHGWRVZLPQRZWKH\
GIHDWKHUXVZLWKDUURZVEHIRUHZHUHDFKHG
PLGVWUHDP


5HG$[HVRIWKH%RUGHU

&RQDQGLGQRWSOXQJHGHHSO\LQWRWKHIRUHVW$IHZKXQGUHG\DUGV
IURPWKHULYHUKHDOWHUHGKLVVODQWLQJFRXUVHDQGUDQSDUDOOHOZLWK
LW%DOWKXVUHFRJQL]HGDJULPGHWHUPLQDWLRQQRWWREHKXQWHGDZD\
IURPWKHULYHUZKLFKWKH\PXVWFURVVLIWKH\ZHUHWRZDUQWKHPHQLQ
WKHIRUW%HKLQGWKHPURVHPRUHORXGO\WKH\HOOVRIWKHIRUHVWPHQ
%DOWKXVEHOLHYHGWKH3LFWVKDGUHDFKHGWKHJODGHZKHUHWKHERGLHVRI
WKHVODLQPHQOD\7KHQIXUWKHU\HOOVVHHPHGWRLQGLFDWHWKDWWKH
VDYDJHVZHUHVWUHDPLQJLQWRWKHZRRGVLQSXUVXLW7KH\KDGOHIWD
WUDLODQ\3LFWFRXOGIROORZ
&RQDQLQFUHDVHGKLVVSHHGDQG%DOWKXVJULPO\VHWKLVWHHWKDQG
NHSWRQKLVKHHOVWKRXJKKHIHOWKHPLJKWFROODSVHDQ\WLPH,W
VHHPHGFHQWXULHVVLQFHKHKDGHDWHQODVW+HNHSWJRLQJPRUHE\DQ
HIIRUWRIZLOOWKDQDQ\WKLQJHOVH+LVEORRGZDVSRXQGLQJVR
IXULRXVO\LQKLVHDUGUXPVWKDWKHZDVQRWDZDUHZKHQWKH\HOOVGLHG
RXWEHKLQGWKHP
&RQDQKDOWHGVXGGHQO\%DOWKXVOHDQHGDJDLQVWDWUHHDQGSDQWHG
7KH\
YHTXLWJUXQWHGWKH&LPPHULDQVFRZOLQJ
6QHDNLQJXSRQXVJDVSHG%DOWKXV
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDG
$VKRUWFKDVHOLNHWKLVWKH\
G\HOOHYHU\VWHSRIWKHZD\1R
7KH\
YHJRQHEDFN,WKRXJKW,KHDUGVRPHERG\\HOOLQJEHKLQGWKHPD
IHZVHFRQGVEHIRUHWKHQRLVHEHJDQWRJHWGLPPHU7KH\
YHEHHQ
UHFDOOHG$QGWKDW
VJRRGIRUXVEXWGDPQHGEDGIRUWKHPHQLQWKH
IRUW,WPHDQVWKHZDUULRUVDUHEHLQJVXPPRQHGRXWRIWKHZRRGVIRU
WKHDWWDFN7KRVHPHQZHUDQLQWRZHUHZDUQRUVIURPDWULEHGRZQWKH
ULYHU7KH\ZHUHXQGRXEWHGO\KHDGHGIRU*ZDZHODWRMRLQLQWKH
DVVDXOWRQWKHIRUW'DPQLWZH
UHIDWKHUDZD\WKDQHYHUQRZ:H
YH
JRWWRJHWDFURVVWKHULYHU
7XUQLQJHDVWKHKXUULHGWKURXJKWKHWKLFNHWVZLWKQRDWWHPSWDW
FRQFHDOPHQW%DOWKXVIROORZHGKLPIRUWKHILUVWWLPHIHHOLQJWKH
VWLQJRIODFHUDWLRQVRQKLVEUHDVWDQGVKRXOGHUZKHUHWKH3LFW
V
VDYDJHWHHWKKDGVFRUHGKLP+HZDVSXVKLQJWKURXJKWKHWKLFNEXVKHV
WKDWKLQJHGWKHEDQNZKHQ&RQDQSXOOHGKLPEDFN7KHQKHKHDUGD
UK\WKPLFVSODVKLQJDQGSHHULQJWKURXJKWKHOHDYHVVDZDGXJRXW
FDQRHFRPLQJXSWKHULYHULWVVLQJOHRFFXSDQWSDGGOLQJKDUGDJDLQVW
WKHFXUUHQW+HZDVDVWURQJO\EXLOW3LFWZLWKDZKLWHKHURQIHDWKHU
WKUXVWLQDFRSSHUEDQGWKDWFRQILQHGKLVVTXDUHFXWPDQH
7KDW
VD*ZDZHODPDQPXWWHUHG&RQDQ(PLVVDU\IURP=RJDU
:KLWHSOXPHVKRZVWKDW+H
VFDUULHGDSHDFHWDONWRWKHWULEHVGRZQ
WKHULYHUDQGQRZKH
VWU\LQJWRJHWEDFNDQGWDNHDKDQGLQWKH
VODXJKWHU
7KHORQHDPEDVVDGRUZDVQRZDOPRVWHYHQZLWKWKHLUKLGLQJSODFH
DQGVXGGHQO\%DOWKXVDOPRVWMXPSHGRXWRIKLVVNLQ$WKLVYHU\HDU
KDGVRXQGHGWKHKDUVKJXWWXUDOVRID3LFW7KHQKHUHDOL]HGWKDW
&RQDQKDGFDOOHGWRWKHSDGGOHULQKLVRZQWRQJXH7KHPDQVWDUWHG
VFDQQHGWKHEXVKHVDQGFDOOHGEDFNVRPHWKLQJWKHQFDVWDVWDUWOHG
JODQFHDFURVVWKHULYHUEHQWORZDQGVHQWWKHFDQRHVKRRWLQJLQ
WRZDUGWKHZHVWHUQEDQN1RWXQGHUVWDQGLQJ%DOWKXVVDZ&RQDQWDNH
IURPKLVKDQGWKHERZKHKDGSLFNHGXSLQWKHJODGHDQGQRWFKDQ
DUURZ
7KH3LFWKDGUXQKLVFDQRHLQFORVHWRWKHVKRUHDQGVWDULQJXS
LQWRWKHEXVKHVFDOOHGRXWVRPHWKLQJ+LVDQVZHUFDPHLQWKHWZDQJ
RIWKHERZVWULQJWKHVWUHDNLQJIOLJKWRIWKHDUURZWKDWVDQNWRWKH
IHDWKHUVLQKLVEURDGEUHDVW:LWKDFKRNLQJJDVSKHVOXPSHGVLGHZLVH
DQGUROOHGLQWRWKHVKDOORZZDWHU,QDQLQVWDQW&RQDQZDVGRZQWKH
EDQNDQGZDGLQJLQWRWKHZDWHUWRJUDVSWKHGULIWLQJFDQRH%DOWKXV
VWXPEOHGDIWHUKLPDQGVRPHZKDWGD]HGO\FUDZOHGLQWRWKHFDQRH&RQDQ
VFUDPEOHGLQVHL]HGWKHSDGGOHDQGVHQWWKHFUDIWVKRRWLQJWRZDUG
WKHHDVWHUQVKRUH%DOWKXVQRWHGZLWKHQYLRXVDGPLUDWLRQWKHSOD\RI
WKHJUHDWPXVFOHVEHQHDWKWKHVXQEXUQWVNLQ7KH&LPPHULDQVHHPHGDQ
LURQPDQZKRQHYHUNQHZIDWLJXH
:KDWGLG\RXVD\WRWKH3LFW"DVNHG%DOWKXV
7ROGKLPWRSXOOLQWRVKRUHVDLGWKHUHZDVDZKLWHIRUHVWUXQQHU
RQWKHEDQNZKRZDVWU\LQJWRJHWDVKRWDWKLP
7KDWGRHVQ
WVHHPIDLU%DOWKXVREMHFWHG+HWKRXJKWDIULHQG
ZDVVSHDNLQJWRKLP<RXPLPLFNHGD3LFWSHUIHFWO\
:HQHHGHGKLVERDWJUXQWHG&RQDQQRWSDXVLQJLQKLVH[HUWLRQV
2QO\ZD\WROXUHKLPWRWKHEDQN:KLFKLVZRUVHWREHWUD\D3LFW
ZKR
GHQMR\VNLQQLQJXVERWKDOLYHRUEHWUD\WKHPHQDFURVVWKH
ULYHUZKRVHOLYHVGHSHQGRQRXUJHWWLQJRYHU"
%DOWKXVPXOOHGRYHUWKLVGHOLFDWHHWKLFDOTXHVWLRQIRUDPRPHQW
WKHQVKUXJJHGKLVVKRXOGHUVDQGDVNHG+RZIDUDUHZHIURPWKH
IRUW"
&RQDQSRLQWHGWRDFUHHNZKLFKIORZHGLQWR%ODFN5LYHUIURPWKH
HDVWDIHZKXQGUHG\DUGVEHORZWKHP
7KDW
V6RXWK&UHHNLW
VWHQPLOHVIURPLWVPRXWKWRWKHIRUW
,W
VWKHVRXWKHUQERXQGDU\RI&RQDMRKDUD0DUVKHVPLOHVZLGHVRXWKRI
LW1RGDQJHURIDUDLGIURPDFURVVWKHP1LQHPLOHVDERYHWKHIRUW
1RUWK&UHHNIRUPVWKHRWKHUERXQGDU\0DUVKHVEH\RQGWKDWWRR
7KDW
VZK\DQDWWDFNPXVWFRPHIURPWKHZHVWDFURVV%ODFN5LYHU
&RQDMRKDUD
VMXVWOLNHDVSHDUZLWKDSRLQWQLQHWHHQPLOHVZLGH
WKUXVWLQWRWKH3LFWLVKZLOGHUQHVV
:K\GRQ
WZHNHHSWRWKHFDQRHDQGPDNHWKHWULSE\ZDWHU"
%HFDXVHFRQVLGHULQJWKHFXUUHQWZH
YHJRWWREUDFHDQGWKH
EHQGVLQWKHULYHUZHFDQJRIDVWHUDIRRW%HVLGHVUHPHPEHU*ZDZHOD
LVVRXWKRIWKHIRUWLIWKH3LFWVDUHFURVVLQJWKHULYHUZH
GUXQ
ULJKWLQWRWKHP
'XVNZDVJDWKHULQJDVWKH\VWHSSHGXSRQWKHHDVWHUQEDQN:LWKRXW
SDXVH&RQDQSXVKHGRQQRUWKZDUGDWDSDFHWKDWPDGH%DOWKXV
VWXUG\
OHJVDFKH
9DODQQXVZDQWHGDIRUWEXLOWDWWKHPRXWKVRI1RUWKDQG6RXWK
&UHHNVJUXQWHGWKH&LPPHULDQ7KHQWKHULYHUFRXOGEHSDWUROOHG
FRQVWDQWO\%XWWKH*RYHUQPHQWZRXOGQ
WGRLW
6RIWEHOOLHGIRROVVLWWLQJRQYHOYHWFXVKLRQVZLWKQDNHGJLUOV
RIIHULQJWKHPLFHGZLQHRQWKHLUNQHHV,NQRZWKHEUHHG7KH\
FDQ
WVHHDQ\IDUWKHUWKDQWKHLUSDODFHZDOO'LSORPDF\KHOO
7KH\
GILJKW3LFWVZLWKWKHRULHVRIWHUULWRULDOH[SDQVLRQ9DODQQXV
DQGPHQOLNHKLPKDYHWRREH\WKHRUGHUVRIDVHWRIGDPQHGIRROV
7KH\
OOQHYHUJUDEDQ\PRUH3LFWLVKODQGDQ\PRUHWKDQWKH\
OOHYHU
UHEXLOG9HQDULXP7KHWLPHPD\FRPHZKHQWKH\
OOVHHWKHEDUEDULDQV
VZDUPLQJRYHUWKHZDOOVRIWKHHDVWHUQFLWLHV
$ZHHNEHIRUH%DOWKXVZRXOGKDYHODXJKHGDWDQ\VXFKSUHSRVWHURXV
VXJJHVWLRQ1RZKHPDGHQRUHSO\+HKDGVHHQWKHXQFRQTXHUDEOH
IHURFLW\RIWKHPHQZKRGZHOWEH\RQGWKHIURQWLHUV
+HVKLYHUHGFDVWLQJJODQFHVDWWKHVXOOHQULYHUMXVWYLVLEOH
WKURXJKWKHEXVKHVDWWKHDUFKHVRIWKHWUHHVZKLFKFURZGHGFORVHWR
LWVEDQNV+HNHSWUHPHPEHULQJWKDWWKH3LFWVPLJKWKDYHFURVVHGWKH
ULYHUDQGEHO\LQJLQDPEXVKEHWZHHQWKHPDQGWKHIRUW,WZDVIDVW
JURZLQJGDUN
$VOLJKWVRXQGDKHDGRIWKHPMXPSHGKLVKHDUWLQWRKLVWKURDWDQG
&RQDQ
VVZRUGJOHDPHGLQWKHDLU+HORZHUHGLWZKHQDGRJDJUHDW
JDXQWVFDUUHGEHDVWVOXQNRXWRIWKHEXVKHVDQGVWRRGVWDULQJDW
WKHP
7KDWGRJEHORQJHGWRDVHWWOHUZKRWULHGWREXLOGKLVFDELQRQ
WKHEDQNRIWKHULYHUDIHZPLOHVVRXWKRIWKHIRUWJUXQWFG&RQDQ
7KH3LFWVVOLSSHGRYHUDQGNLOOHGKLPRIFRXUVHDQGEXUQHGKLV
FDELQ:HIRXQGKLPGHDGDPRQJWKHHPEHUVDQGWKHGRJO\LQJ
VHQVHOHVVDPRQJWKUHH3LFWVKH
GNLOOHG+HZDVDOPRVWFXWWRSLHFHV
:HWRRNKLPWRWKHIRUWDQGGUHVVHGKLVZRXQGVEXWDIWHUKH
UHFRYHUHGKHWRRNWRWKHZRRGVDQGWXUQHGZLOG:KDWQRZ6ODVKHU
DUH\RXKXQWLQJWKHPHQZKRNLOOHG\RXUPDVWHU"
7KHPDVVLYHKHDGVZXQJIURPVLGHWRVLGHDQGWKHH\HVJORZHG
JUHHQO\+HGLGQRWJURZORUEDUN6LOHQWO\DVDSKDQWRPKHVOLGLQ
EHKLQGWKHP
/HWKLPFRPHPXWWHUHG&RQDQ+HFDQVPHOOWKHGHYLOVEHIRUHZH
FDQVHHWKHP
%DOWKXVVPLOHGDQGODLGKLVKDQGFDUHVVLQJO\RQWKHGRJ
VKHDG
7KHOLSVLQYROXQWDULO\ZULWKHGEDFNWRGLVSOD\WKHJOHDPLQJIDQJV
WKHQWKHJUHDWEHDVWEHQWKLVKHDGVKHHSLVKO\DQGKLVWDOOPRYHG
ZLWKMHUN\XQFHUWDLQW\DVLIWKHRZQHUKDGDOPRVWIRUJRWWHQWKH
HPRWLRQVRIIULHQGOLQHVV%DOWKXVPHQWDOO\FRPSDUHGWKHJUHDWJDXQW
KDUGERG\ZLWKWKHIDWVOHHNKRXQGVWXPEOLQJYRFLIHURXVO\RYHURQH
DQRWKHULQKLVIDWKHU
VNHQQHO\DUG+HVLJKHG7KHIURQWLHUZDVQR
OHVVKDUGIRUEHDVWVWKDQIRUPHQ7KLVGRJKDGDOPRVWIRUJRWWHQWKH
PHDQLQJRINLQGQHVVDQGIULHQGOLQHVV
6ODVKHUJOLGHGDKHDGDQG&RQDQOHWKLPWDNHWKHOHDG7KHODVW
WLQJHRIGXVNIDGHGLQWRVWDUNGDUNQHVV7KHPLOHVIHOODZD\XQGHU
WKHLUVWHDG\IHHW6ODVKHUVHHPHGYRLFHOHVV6XGGHQO\KHKDOWHG
WHQVHHDUVOLIWHG$QLQVWDQWODWHUWKHPHQKHDUGLWDGHPRQLDF
\HOOLQJXSWKHULYHUDKHDGRIWKHPIDLQWDVDZKLVSHU
&RQDQVZRUHOLNHDPDGPDQ
7KH\
YHDWWDFNHGWKHIRUW:H
UHWRRODWH&RPHRQ
+HLQFUHDVHGKLVSDFHWUXVWLQJWRWKHGRJWRVPHOORXWDPEXVKHV
DKHDG,QDIORRGRIWHQVHH[FLWHPHQW%DOWKXVIRUJRWKLVKXQJHUDQG
ZHDULQHVV7KH\HOOVJUHZORXGHUDVWKH\DGYDQFHGDQGDERYHWKH
GHYLOLVKVFUHDPLQJWKH\FRXOGKHDUWKHGHHSVKRXWVRIWKHVROGLHUV
-XVWDV%DOWKXVEHJDQWRIHDUWKH\ZRXOGUXQLQWRWKHVDYDJHVZKR
VHHPHGWREHKRZOLQJMXVWDKHDGRIWKHP&RQDQVZXQJDZD\IURPWKH
ULYHULQDZLGHVHPLFLUFOHWKDWFDUULHGWKHPWRDORZULVHIURPZKLFK
WKH\FRXOGORRNRYHUWKHIRUHVW7KH\VDZWKHIRUWOLJKWHGZLWK
WRUFKHVWKUXVWRYHUWKHSDUDSHWVRQORQJSROHV7KHVHFDVWD
IOLFNHULQJXQFHUWDLQOLJKWRYHUWKHFOHDULQJDQGLQWKDWOLJKWWKH\
VDZWKURQJVRIQDNHGSDLQWHGILJXUHVDORQJWKHIULQJHRIWKH
FOHDULQJ7KHULYHUVZDUPHGZLWKFDQRHV7KH3LFWVKDGWKHIRUW
FRPSOHWHO\VXUURXQGHG
$QLQFHVVDQWKDLORIDUURZVUDLQHGDJDLQVWWKHVWRFNDGHIURPWKH
ZRRGVDQGWKHULYHU7KHGHHSWZDQJLQJRIWKHERZVWULQJVURVHDERYH
WKHKRZOLQJ<HOOLQJOLNHZROYHVVHYHUDOKXQGUHGQDNHGZDUULRUVZLWK
D[HVLQWKHLUKDQGVUDQIURPXQGHUWKHWUHHVDQGUDFHGWRZDUGWKH
HDVWHUQJDWH7KH\ZHUHZLWKLQDKXQGUHGDQGILIW\\DUGVRIWKHLU
REMHFWLYHZKHQDZLWKHULQJEODVWRIDUURZVIURPWKHZDOOOLWWHUHGWKH
JURXQGZLWKFRUSVHVDQGVHQWWKHVXUYLYRUVIOHHLQJEDFNWRWKHWUHHV
7KHPHQLQWKHFDQRHVUXVKHGWKHLUERDWVWRZDUGWKHULYHUZDOODQG
ZHUHPHWE\DQRWKHUVKRZHURIFORWK\DUGVKDIWVDQGDYROOH\IURPWKH
VPDOOEDOOLVWDHPRXQWHGRQWRZHUVRQWKDWVLGHRIWKHVWRFNDGH
6WRQHVDQGORJVZKLUOHGWKURXJKWKHDLUDQGVSOLQWHUHGDQGVDQNKDOI
DGR]HQFDQRHVNLOOLQJWKHLURFFXSDQWVDQGWKHRWKHUERDWVGUHZ
EDFNRXWRIUDQJH$GHHSURDURIWULXPSKURVHIURPWKHZDOOVRIWKH
IRUWDQVZHUHGE\EHVWLDOKRZOLQJIURPDOOTXDUWHUV
6KDOOZHWU\WREUHDNWKURXJK"DVNHG%DOWKXVWUHPEOLQJZLWK
HDJHUQHVV
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDG+HVWRRGZLWKKLVDUPVIROGHGKLVKHDG
VOLJKWO\EHQWDVRPEHUDQGEURRGLQJILJXUH
7KHIRUW
VGRRPHG7KH3LFWVDUHEORRGPDGDQGZRQ
WVWRSXQWLO
WKH\
UHDOONLOOHG$QGWKHUHDUHWRRPDQ\RIWKHPIRUWKHPHQLQWKH
IRUWWRNLOO:HFRXOGQ
WEUHDNWKURXJKDQGLIZHGLGZHFRXOGGR
QRWKLQJEXWGLHZLWK9DODQQXV
7KHUH
VQRWKLQJZHFDQGREXWVDYHRXURZQKLGHVWKHQ"
<HV:H
YHJRWWRZDUQWKHVHWWOHUV'R\RXNQRZZK\WKH3LFWV
DUHQRWWU\LQJWREXUQWKHIRUWZLWKILUHDUURZV"%HFDXVHWKH\GRQ
W
ZDQWDIODPHWKDWPLJKWZDUQWKHSHRSOHWRWKHHDVW7KH\SODQWR
VWDPSRXWWKHIRUWDQGWKHQVZHHSHDVWEHIRUHDQ\RQHNQRZVRILWV
IDOO7KH\PD\FURVV7KXQGHU5LYHUDQGWDNH9HOLWULXPEHIRUHWKH
SHRSOHNQRZZKDW
VKDSSHQHG$WOHDVWWKH\
OOGHVWUR\HYHU\OLYLQJ
WKLQJEHWZHHQWKHIRUWDQG7KXQGHU5LYHU
:H
YHIDLOHGWRZDUQWKHIRUWDQG,VHHQRZLWZRXOGKDYHGRQH
QRJRRGLIZHKDGVXFFHHGHG7KHIRUW
VWRRSRRUO\PDQQHG$IHZPRUH
FKDUJHVDQGWKH3LFWVZLOOEHRYHUWKHZDOOVDQGEUHDNLQJGRZQWKH
JDWHV%XWZHFDQVWDUWWKHVHWWOHUVWRZDUG9HOLWULXP&RPHRQ:H
UH
RXWVLGHWKHFLUFOHWKH3LFWVKDYHWKURZQDURXQGWKHIRUW:H
OONHHS
FOHDURILW
7KH\VZXQJRXWLQDZLGHDUFKHDULQJWKHULVLQJDQGIDOOLQJRI
WKHYROXPHRIWKH\HOOVPDUNLQJHDFKFKDUJHDQGUHSXOVH7KHPHQLQ
WKHIRUWZHUHKROGLQJWKHLURZQEXWWKHVKULHNVRIWKH3LFWVGLGQRW
GLPLQLVKLQVDYDJHU\7KH\YLEUDWHGZLWKDWLPEUHWKDWKHOGDVVXUDQFH
RIXOWLPDWHYLFWRU\
%HIRUH%DOWKXVUHDOL]HGWKH\ZHUHFORVHWRLWWKH\EURNHLQWRWKH
URDGOHDGLQJHDVW
1RZUXQJUXQWHG&RQDQ%DOWKXVVHWKLVWHHWK,WZDVQLQHWHHQ
PLOHVWR9HOLWULXPDJRRGILYHWR6FDOS&UHHNEH\RQGZKLFKEHJDQWKH
VHWWOHPHQWV,WVHHPHGWRWKH$TXLORQLDQWKDWWKH\KDGEHHQILJKWLQJ
DQGUXQQLQJIRUFHQWXULHV%XWWKHQHUYRXVH[FLWHPHQWWKDWULRWHG
WKURXJKKLVEORRGVWLPXODWHGKLPWRKHUFXOHDQHIIRUWV
6ODVKHUUDQDKHDGRIWKHPKLVKHDGWRWKHJURXQGVQDUOLQJORZ
WKHILUVWVRXQGWKH\KDGKHDUGIURPKLP
3LFWVDKHDGRIXVVQDUOHG&RQDQGURSSLQJWRRQHNQHHDQG
VFDQQLQJWKHJURXQGLQWKHVWDUOLJKW+HVKRRNKLVKHDGEDIIOHG,
FDQ
WWHOOKRZPDQ\3UREDEO\RQO\DVPDOOSDUW\6RPHWKDWFRXOGQ
W
ZDLWWRWDNHWKHIRUW7KH\
YHJRQHDKHDGWREXWFKHUWKHVHWWOHUVLQ
WKHLUEHGV&RPHRQ
$KHDGRIWKHPSUHVHQWO\WKH\VDZDVPDOOEOD]HWKURXJKWKHWUHHV
DQGKHDUGDZLOGDQGIHURFLRXVFKDQWLQJ7KHWUDLOEHQWWKHUHDQG
OHDYLQJLWWKH\FXWDFURVVWKHEHQGWKURXJKWKHWKLFNHWV$IHZ
PRPHQWVODWHUWKH\ZHUHORRNLQJRQDKLGHRXVVLJKW$QR[ZDLQVWRRG
LQWKHURDGSLOHGZLWKPHDJHUKRXVHKROGIXUQLVKLQJVLWZDVEXUQLQJ
WKHR[HQOD\QHDUZLWKWKHLUWKURDWVFXW$PDQDQGDZRPDQOD\LQ
WKHURDGVWULSSHGDQGPXWLODWHG)LYH3LFWVZHUHGDQFLQJDERXWWKHP
ZLWKIDQWDVWLFOHDSVDQGERXQGVZDYLQJEORRG\D[HVRQHRIWKHP
EUDQGLVKHGWKHZRPDQ
VUHGVPHDUHGJRZQ
$WWKHVLJKWDUHGKD]HVZDPEHIRUH%DOWKXV/LIWLQJKLVERZKH
OLQHGWKHSUDQFLQJILJXUHEODFNDJDLQVWWKHILUHDQGORRVHG7KH
VOD\HUOHDSHGFRQYXOVLYHO\DQGIHOOGHDGZLWKWKHDUURZWKURXJKKLV
KHDUW7KHQWKHWZRZKLWHPHQDQGWKHGRJZHUHXSRQWKHVWDUWOHG
VXUYLYRUV&RQDQZDVDQLPDWHGPHUHO\E\KLVILJKWLQJVSLULWDQGDQ
ROGROGUDFLDOKDWHEXW%DOWKXVZDVDILUHZLWKZUDWK
+HPHWWKHILUVW3LFWWRRSSRVHKLPZLWKDIHURFLRXVVZLSHWKDW
VSOLWWKHSDLQWHGVNXOODQGVSUDQJRYHUKLVIDLOLQJERG\WRJUDSSOH
ZLWKWKHRWKHUV%XW&RQDQKDGDOUHDG\NLOOHGRQHRIWKHWZRKHKDG
FKRVHQDQGWKHOHDSRIWKH$TXLORQLDQZDVDVHFRQGODWH7KHZDUULRU
ZDVGRZQZLWKWKHORQJVZRUGWKURXJKKLPHYHQDV%DOWKXV
D[ZDV
OLIWHG7XUQLQJWRZDUGWKHUHPDLQLQJ3LFW%DOWKXVVDZ6ODVKHUULVH
IURPKLVYLFWLPKLVJUHDWMDZVGULSSLQJEORRG
%DOWKXVVDLGQRWKLQJDVKHORRNHGGRZQDWWKHSLWLIXOIRUPVLQWKH
URDGEHVLGHWKHEXUQLQJZDLQ%RWKZHUH\RXQJWKHZRPDQOLWWOHPRUH
WKDQDJLUO%\VRPHZKLPRIFKDQFHWKH3LFWVKDGOHIWKHUIDFH
XQPDUUHGDQGHYHQLQWKHDJRQLHVRIDQDZIXOGHDWKLWZDVEHDXWLIXO
%XWKHUVRIW\RXQJERG\KDGEHHQKLGHRXVO\VODVKHGZLWKPDQ\NQLYHV
DPLVWFORXGHG%DOWKXV
H\HVDQGKHVZDOORZHGFKRNLQJO\7KH
WUDJHG\PRPHQWDULO\RYHUFDPHKLP+HIHOWOLNHIDOOLQJXSRQWKH
JURXQGDQGZHHSLQJDQGELWLQJWKHHDUWK
6RPH\RXQJFRXSOHMXVWKLWWLQJRXWRQWKHLURZQ&RQDQZDV
VD\LQJDVKHZLSHGKLVVZRUGXQHPRWLRQDOO\2QWKHLUZD\WRWKHIRUW
ZKHQWKH3LFWVPHWWKHP0D\EHWKHER\ZDVJRLQJWRHQWHUWKH
VHUYLFHPD\EHWDNHXSODQGRQWKHULYHU:HOOWKDW
VZKDWZLOO
KDSSHQWRHYHU\PDQZRPDQDQGFKLOGWKLVVLGHRI7KXQGHU5LYHULI
ZHGRQ
WJHWWKHPLQWR9HOLWULXPLQDKXUU\
%DOWKXV
NQHHVWUHPEOHGDVKHIROORZHG&RQDQ%XWWKHUHZDVQR
KLQWRIZHDNQHVVLQWKHORQJHDV\VWULGHRIWKH&LPPHULDQ7KHUHZDV
DNLQVKLSEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKHJUHDWJDXQWEUXWHWKDWJOLGHGEHVLGH
KLP6ODVKHUQRORQJHUJURZOHGZLWKKLVKHDGWRWKHWUDLO7KHZD\
ZDVFOHDUEHIRUHWKHP7KH\HOOLQJRQWKHULYHUFDPHIDLQWO\WRWKHP
EXW%DOWKXVEHOLHYHGWKHIRUWZDVVWLOOKROGLQJ&RQDQKDOWHG
VXGGHQO\ZLWKDQRDWK
+HVKRZHG%DOWKXVDWUDLOWKDWOHGQRUWKIURPWKHURDG,WZDVDQ
ROGWUDLOSDUWO\JURZQZLWKQHZ\RXQJJURZWKDQGWKLVJURZWKKDG
UHFHQWO\EHHQEURNHQGRZQ%DOWKXVUHDOL]HGWKLVIDFWPRUHE\IHHO
WKDQVLJKWWKRXJK&RQDQVHHPHGWRVHHOLNHDFDWLQWKHGDUN7KH
&LPPHULDQVKRZHGKLPZKHUHEURDGZDJRQWUDFNVWXUQHGRIIWKHPDLQ
WUDLOGHHSO\LQGHQWHGLQWKHIRUHVWPROG
6HWWOHUVJRLQJWRWKHOLFNVDIWHUVDOWKHJUXQWHG7KH\
UHDW
WKHHGJHVRIWKHPDUVKDERXWQLQHPLOHVIURPKHUH%ODVWLW7KH\
OO
EHFXWRIIDQGEXWFKHUHGWRDPDQ/LVWHQ2QHPDQFDQZDUQWKH
SHRSOHRQWKHURDG*RDKHDGDQGZDNHWKHPXSDQGKHUGWKHPLQWR
9HOLWULXP,
OOJRDQGJHWWKHPHQJDWKHULQJWKHVDOW7KH\
OOEH
FDPSHGE\WKHOLFNV:HZRQ
WFRPHEDFNWRWKHURDG:H
OOKHDG
VWUDLJKWWKURXJKWKHZRRGV
:LWKQRIXUWKHUFRPPHQW&RQDQWXUQHGRIIWKHWUDLODQGKXUULHG
GRZQWKHGLPSDWKDQG%DOWKXVDIWHUVWDULQJDIWHUKLPIRUDIHZ
PRPHQWVVHWRXWDORQJWKHURDG7KHGRJKDGUHPDLQHGZLWKKLPDQG
JOLGHGVRIWO\DWKLVKHHOV:KHQ%DOWKXVKDGJRQHDIHZURGVKHKHDUG
WKHDQLPDOJURZO:KLUOLQJKHJODUHGEDFNWKHZD\KHKDGFRPHDQG
ZDVVWDUWOHGWRVHHDYDJXHJKRVWO\JORZYDQLVKLQJLQWRWKHIRUHVWLQ
WKHGLUHFWLRQ&RQDQKDGWDNHQ6ODVKHUUXPEOHGGHHSLQKLVWKURDW
KLVKDFNOHVVWLIIDQGKLVH\HVEDOOVRIJUHHQILUH%DOWKXV
UHPHPEHUHGWKHJULPDSSDULWLRQWKDWKDGWDNHQWKHKHDGRIWKH
PHUFKDQW7LEHULDVQRWIDUIURPWKDWVSRWDQGKHKHVLWDWHG7KHWKLQJ
PXVWEHIROORZLQJ&RQDQ%XWWKHJLDQW&LPPHULDQKDGUHSHDWHGO\
GHPRQVWUDWHGKLVDELOLW\WRWDNHFDUHRIKLPVHOIDQG%DOWKXVIHOW
KLVGXW\OD\WRZDUGWKHKHOSOHVVVHWWOHUVZKRVOXPEHUHGLQWKHSDWK
RIWKHUHGKXUULFDQH7KHKRUURURIWKHILHU\SKDQWRPZDV
RYHUVKDGRZHGE\WKHKRUURURIWKRVHOLPSYLRODWHGERGLHVEHVLGHWKH
EXUQLQJR[ZDLQ
+HKXUULHGGRZQWKHURDGFURVVHG6FDOS&UHHNDQGFDPHLQVLJKWRI
WKHILUVWVHWWOHU
VFDELQDORQJORZVWUXFWXUHRID[KHZQORJV
,QDQLQVWDQWKHZDVSRXQGLQJRQWKHGRRU$VOHHS\YRLFHLQTXLUHG
KLVSOHDVXUH
*HWXS7KH3LFWVDUHRYHUWKHULYHU
7KDWEURXJKWLQVWDQWUHVSRQVH$ORZFU\HFKRHGKLVZRUGVDQGWKHQ
WKHGRRUZDVWKURZQRSHQE\DZRPDQLQDVFDQW\VKLIW+HUKDLUKXQJ
RYHUKHUEDUHVKRXOGHUVLQGLVRUGHUVKHKHOGDFDQGOHLQRQHKDQG
DQGDQD[LQWKHRWKHU+HUIDFHZDVFRORUOHVVKHUH\HVZLGHZLWK
WHUURU
&RPHLQVKHEHJJHG:H
OOKROGWKHFDELQ
1R:HPXVWPDNHIRU9HOLWULXP7KHIRUWFDQ
WKROGWKHPEDFN,W
PD\KDYHIDOOHQDOUHDG\'RQ
WVWRSWRGUHVV*HW\RXUFKLOGUHQDQG
FRPHRQ
%XWP\PDQ
VJRQHZLWKWKHRWKHUVDIWHUVDOWVKHZDLOHG
ZULQJLQJKHUKDQGV%HKLQGKHUSHHUHGWKUHHWRXVOHG\RXQJVWHUV
EOLQNLQJDQGEHZLOGHUHG
&RQDQ
VJRQHDIWHUWKHP+H
OOIHWFKWKHPWKURXJKVDIH:HPXVW
KXUU\XSWKHURDGWRZDUQWKHRWKHUFDELQV
5HOLHIIORRGHGKHUFRXQWHQDQFH
0LWUDEHWKDQNHGVKHFULHG,IWKH&LPPHULDQ
VJRQHDIWHU
WKHPWKH\
UHVDIHLIPRUWDOPDQFDQVDYHWKHP
,QDZKLUOZLQGRIDFWLYLW\VKHVQDWFKHGXSWKHVPDOOHVWFKLOGDQG
KHUGHGWKHRWKHUVWKURXJKWKHGRRUDKHDGRIKHU%DOWKXVWRRNWKH
FDQGOHDQGJURXQGLWRXWXQGHUKLVKHHO+HOLVWHQHGDQLQVWDQW1R
VRXQGFDPHXSWKHGDUNURDG
+DYH\RXJRWDKRUVH"
,QWKHVWDEOHVKHJURDQHG2KKXUU\
+HSXVKHGKHUDVLGHDVVKHIXPEOHGZLWKVKDNLQJKDQGVDWWKHEDUV
+HOHGWKHKRUVHRXWDQGOLIWHGWKHFKLOGUHQRQLWVEDFNWHOOLQJ
WKHPWRKROGWRLWVPDQHDQGWRRQHDQRWKHU7KH\VWDUHGDWKLP
VHULRXVO\PDNLQJQRRXWFU\7KHZRPDQWRRNWKHKRUVH
VKDOWHUDQG
VHWRXWXSWKHURDG6KHVWLOOJULSSHGKHUD[DQG%DOWKXVNQHZWKDW
LIFRUQHUHGVKHZRXOGILJKWZLWKWKHGHVSHUDWHFRXUDJHRIDVKH
SDQWKHU
+HKHOGEHKLQGOLVWHQLQJ+HZDVRSSUHVVHGE\WKHEHOLHIWKDWWKH
IRUWKDGEHHQVWRUPHGDQGWDNHQWKDWWKHGDUNVNLQQHGKRUGHVZHUH
DOUHDG\VWUHDPLQJXSWKHURDGWRZDUG9HOLWULXPGUXQNHQRQVODXJKWHU
DQGPDGIRUEORRG7KH\ZRXOGFRPHZLWKWKHVSHHGRIVWDUYLQJZROYHV
3UHVHQWO\WKH\VDZDQRWKHUFDELQORRPLQJDKHDG7KHZRPDQVWDUWHG
WRVKULHNDZDUQLQJEXW%DOWKXVVWRSSHGKHU+HKXUULHGWRWKHGRRU
DQGNQRFNHG$ZRPDQ
VYRLFHDQVZHUHGKLP+HUHSHDWHGKLVZDUQLQJ
DQGVRRQWKHFDELQGLVJRUJHGLWVRFFXSDQWVDQROGZRPDQWZR\RXQJ
ZRPHQDQGIRXUFKLOGUHQ/LNHWKHRWKHUZRPDQ
VKXVEDQGWKHLUPHQ
KDGJRQHWRWKHVDOWOLFNVWKHGD\EHIRUHXQVXVSHFWLQJRIDQ\
GDQJHU2QHRIWKH\RXQJZRPHQVHHPHGGD]HGWKHRWKHUSURQHWR
K\VWHULD%XWWKHROGZRPDQDVWHUQROGYHWHUDQRIWKHIURQWLHU
TXLHWHGWKHPKDUVKO\VKHKHOSHG%DOWKXVJHWRXWWKHWZRKRUVHVWKDW
ZHUHVWDEOHGLQDSHQEHKLQGWKHFDELQDQGSXWWKHFKLOGUHQRQWKHP
%DOWKXVXUJHGWKDWVKHKHUVHOIPRXQWZLWKWKHPEXWVKHVKRRNKHU
KHDGDQGPDGHRQHRIWKH\RXQJHUZRPHQULGH
6KH
VZLWKFKLOGJUXQWHGWKHROGZRPDQ,FDQZDONDQG
ILJKWWRRLILWFRPHVWRWKDW
$VWKH\VHWRXWRQHRIWKH\RXQJZRPHQVDLG$\RXQJFRXSOH
SDVVHGDORQJWKHURDGDERXWGXVNZHDGYLVHGWKHPWRVSHQGWKHQLJKW
DWRXUFDELQEXWWKH\ZHUHDQ[LRXVWRPDNHWKHIRUWWRQLJKW'LG
GLG
7KH\PHWWKH3LFWVDQVZHUHG%DOWKXVEULHIO\DQGWKHZRPDQ
VREEHGLQKRUURU
7KH\ZHUHVFDUFHO\RXWRIVLJKWRIWKHFDELQZKHQVRPHGLVWDQFH
EHKLQGWKHPTXDYHUHGDORQJKLJKSLWFKHG\HOO
$ZROIH[FODLPHGRQHRIWKHZRPHQ
$SDLQWHGZROIZLWKDQD[LQKLVKDQGPXWWHUHG%DOWKXV*R
5RXVHWKHRWKHUVHWWOHUVDORQJWKHURDGDQGWDNHWKHPZLWK\RX,
OO
VFRXWDORQJEHKLQG
:LWKRXWDZRUGWKHROGZRPDQKHUGHGKHUFKDUJHVDKHDGRIKHU$V
WKH\IDGHGLQWRWKHGDUNQHVV%DOWKXVFRXOGVHHWKHSDOHRYDOVWKDW
ZHUHWKHIDFHVRIWKHFKLOGUHQWZLVWHGEDFNRYHUWKHLUVKRXOGHUVWR
VWDUHWRZDUGKLP+HUHPHPEHUHGKLVRZQSHRSOHRQWKH7DXUDQDQGD
PRPHQW
VJLGG\VLFNQHVVVZDPRYHUKLP:LWKPRPHQWDU\ZHDNQHVVKH
JURDQHGDQGVDQNGRZQLQWKHURDGKLVPXVFXODUDUPIHOORYHU
6ODVKHU
VPDVVLYHQHFNDQGKHIHOWWKHGRJ
VZDUPPRLVWWRQJXHWRXFK
KLVIDFH
+HOLIWHGKLVKHDGDQGJULQQHGZLWKDSDLQIXOHIIRUW
&RPHRQER\KHPXPEOHGULVLQJ:H
YHJRWZRUNWRGR
$UHGJORZVXGGHQO\EHFDPHHYLGHQWWKURXJKWKHWUHHV7KH3LFWV
KDGILUHGWKHODVWKXW+HJULQQHG+RZ=RJDU6DJZRXOGIURWKLIKH
NQHZKLVZDUULRUVKDGOHWWKHLUGHVWUXFWLYHQDWXUHVJHWWKHEHWWHURI
WKHP7KHILUHZRXOGZDUQWKHSHRSOHIDUWKHUXSWKHURDG7KH\ZRXOG
EHDZDNHDQGDOHUWZKHQWKHIXJLWLYHVUHDFKHGWKHP%XWKLVIDFHJUHZ
JULP7KHZRPHQZHUHWUDYHOLQJVORZO\RQIRRWDQGRQWKHRYHUORDGHG
KRUVHV7KHVZLIWIRRWHG3LFWVZRXOGUXQWKHPGRZQZLWKLQDPLOH
XQOHVVKHWRRNKLVSRVLWLRQEHKLQGDWDQJOHRIIDOOHQORJVEHVLGH
WKHWUDLO7KHURDGZHVWRIKLPZDVOLJKWHGE\WKHEXUQLQJFDELQDQG
ZKHQWKH3LFWVFDPHKHVDZWKHPILUVWEODFNIXUWLYHILJXUHVHWFKHG
DJDLQVWWKHGLVWDQWJODUH
'UDZLQJDVKDIWWRWKHKHDGKHORRVHGDQGRQHRIWKHILJXUHV
FUXPSOHG7KHUHVWPHOWHGLQWRWKHZRRGVRQHLWKHUVLGHRIWKHURDG
6ODVKHUZKLPSHUHGZLWKWKHNLOOLQJOXVWEHVLGHKLP6XGGHQO\DILJXUH
DSSHDUHGRQWKHIULQJHRIWKHWUDLOXQGHUWKHWUHHVDQGEHJDQ
JOLGLQJWRZDUGWKHIDOOHQWLPEHUV%DOWKXV
ERZVWULQJWZDQJHGDQG
WKH3LFW\HOSHGVWDJJHUHGDQGIHOOLQWRWKHVKDGRZVZLWKWKHDUURZ
WKURXJKKLVWKLJK6ODVKHUFOHDUHGWKHWLPEHUVZLWKDERXQGDQG
OHDSHGLQWRWKHEXVKHV7KH\ZHUHYLROHQWO\VKDNHQDQGWKHQWKHGRJ
VOXQNEDFNWR%DOWKXV
VLGHKLVMDZVFULPVRQ
1RPRUHDSSHDUHGLQWKHWUDLO%DOWKXVEHJDQWRIHDUWKH\ZHUH
VWHDOLQJSDVWKLVSRVLWLRQWKURXJKWKHZRRGVDQGZKHQKHKHDUGD
IDLQWVRXQGWRKLVOHIWKHORRVHGEOLQGO\+HFXUVHGDVKHKHDUGWKH
VKDIWVSOLQWHUDJDLQVWDWUHHEXW6ODVKHUJOLGHGDZD\DVVLOHQWO\DV
DSKDQWRPDQGSUHVHQWO\%DOWKXVKHDUGDWKUDVKLQJDQGDJXUJOLQJ
WKHQ6ODVKHUFDPHOLNHDJKRVWWKURXJKWKHEXVKHVVQXJJOLQJKLV
JUHDWFULPVRQVWDLQHGKHDGDJDLQVW%DOWKXV
DUP%ORRGRR]HGIURPD
JDVKLQKLVVKRXOGHUEXWWKHVRXQGVLQWKHZRRGKDGFHDVHGIRUHYHU
7KHPHQOXUNLQJRQWKHHGJHVRIWKHURDGHYLGHQWO\VHQVHGWKHIDWH
RIWKHLUFRPSDQLRQDQGGHFLGHGWKDWDQRSHQFKDUJHZDVSUHIHUDEOHWR
EHLQJGUDJJHGGRZQLQWKHGDUNE\DGHYLOEHDVWWKH\FRXOGQHLWKHU
VHHQRUKHDU3HUKDSVWKH\UHDOL]HGWKDWRQO\RQHPDQOD\EHKLQGWKH
ORJV7KH\FDPHZLWKDVXGGHQUXVKEUHDNLQJFRYHUIURPERWKVLGHVRI
WKHWUDLO7KUHHGURSSHGZLWKDUURZVWKURXJKWKHPDQGWKH
UHPDLQLQJSDLUKHVLWDWHG2QHWXUQHGDQGUDQEDFNGRZQWKHURDGEXW
WKHRWKHUOXQJHGRYHUWKHEUHDVWZRUNKLVH\HVDQGWHHWKJOHDPLQJLQ
WKHGLPOLJKWKLVD[OLIWHG%DOWKXV
IRRWVOLSSHGDVKHVSUDQJXS
EXWWKHVOLSVDYHGKLVOLIH7KHGHVFHQGLQJD[VKDYHGDORFNRIKDLU
IURPKLVKHDGDQGWKH3LFWUROOHGGRZQWKHORJVIURPWKHIRUFHRI
KLVZDVWHGEORZ%HIRUHKHFRXOGUHJDLQKLVIHHW6ODVKHUWRUHKLV
WKURDWRXW
7KHQIROORZHGDWHQVHSHULRGRIZDLWLQJLQZKLFKWLPH%DOWKXV
ZRQGHUHGLIWKHPDQZKRKDGIOHGKDGEHHQWKHRQO\VXUYLYRURIWKH
SDUW\2EYLRXVO\LWKDGEHHQDVPDOOEDQGWKDWKDGHLWKHUOHIWWKH
ILJKWLQJDWWKHIRUWRUZDVVFRXWLQJDKHDGRIWKHPDLQERG\(DFK
PRPHQWWKDWSDVVHGLQFUHDVHGWKHFKDQFHVIRUVDIHW\RIWKHZRPHQDQG
FKLOGUHQKXUU\LQJWRZDUG9HOLWKXP
7KHQZLWKRXWZDUQLQJDVKRZHURIDUURZVZKLVWOHGRYHUKLVUHWUHDW
$ZLOGKRZOLQJURVHIURPWKHZRRGVDORQJWKHWUDLO(LWKHUWKH
VXUYLYRUKDGJRQHDIWHUDLGRUDQRWKHUSDUW\KDGMRLQHGWKHILUVW
7KHEXUQLQJFDELQVWLOOVPROGHUHGOHQGLQJDOLWWOHOLJKW7KHQWKH\
ZHUHDIWHUKLPJOLGLQJWKURXJKWKHWUHHVEHVLGHWKHWUDLO+HVKRW
WKUHHDUURZVDQGWKUHZWKHERZDZD\$VLIVHQVLQJKLVSOLJKWWKH\
FDPHRQQRW\HOOLQJQRZEXWLQGHDGO\VLOHQFHH[FHSWIRUDVZLIW
SDGRIPDQ\IHHW
+HILHUFHO\KXJJHGWKHKHDGRIWKHJUHDWGRJJURZOLQJDWKLVVLGH
PXWWHUHG$OOULJKWER\JLYH
HPKHOODQGVSUDQJWRKLVIHHW
GUDZLQJKLVD[7KHQWKHGDUNILJXUHVIORRGHGRYHUWKHEUHDVWZRUNV
DQGFORVHGLQDVWRUPRIIODLOLQJD[HVVWDEELQJNQLYHVDQGULSSLQJ
IDQJV


7KH'HYLOLQWKH)LUH

:KHQ&RQDQWXUQHGIURPWKH9HOLWULXPURDGKHH[SHFWHGDUXQRI
VRPHQLQHPLOHVDQGVHWKLPVHOIWRWKHWDVN%XWKHKDGQRWJRQHIRXU
ZKHQKHKHDUGWKHVRXQGVRIDSDUW\RIPHQDKHDGRIKLP)URPWKH
QRLVHWKH\ZHUHPDNLQJLQWKHLUSURJUHVVKHNQHZWKH\ZHUHQRW3LFWV
+HKDLOHGWKHP
:KR
VWKHUH"FKDOOHQJHGDKDUVKYRLFH6WDQGZKHUH\RXDUH
XQWLOZHNQRZ\RXRU\RX
OOJHWDQDUURZWKURXJK\RX
<RXFRXOGQ
WKLWDQHOHSKDQWLQWKLVGDUNQHVVDQVZHUHG&RQDQ
LPSDWLHQWO\&RPHRQIRROLW
V,&RQDQ7KH3LFWVDUHRYHUWKH
ULYHU
:HVXVSHFWHGDVPXFKDQVZHUHGWKHOHDGHURIWKHPHQDVWKH\
VWURGHIRUZDUGWDOOUDQJ\PHQVWHUQIDFHGZLWKERZVLQWKHLU
KDQGV2QHRIRXUSDUW\ZRXQGHGDQDQWHORSHDQGWUDFNHGLWQHDUO\WR
%ODFN5LYHU+HKHDUGWKHP\HOOLQJGRZQWKHULYHUDQGUDQEDFNWRRXU
FDPS:HOHIWWKHVDOWDQGWKHZDJRQVWXUQHGWKHR[HQORRVHDQG
FDPHDVVZLIWO\DVZHFRXOG,IWKH3LFWVDUHEHVLHJLQJWKHIRUW
ZDUSDUWLHVZLOOEHUDQJLQJXSWKHURDGWRZDUGRXUFDELQV
<RXUIDPLOLHVDUHVDIHJUXQWHG&RQDQ0\FRPSDQLRQZHQWDKHDG
WRWDNHWKHPWR9HOLWULXP,IZHJREDFNWRWKHPDLQURDGZHPD\UXQ
LQWRWKHZKROHKRUGH:H
OOVWULNHVRXWKHDVWWKURXJKWKHWLPEHU*R
DKHDG,
OOVFRXWEHKLQG
$IHZPRPHQWVODWHUWKHZKROHEDQGZDVKXUU\LQJVRXWKHDVWZDUG
&RQDQIROORZHGPRUHVORZO\NHHSLQJMXVWZLWKLQHDUVKRW+HFXUVHG
WKHQRLVHWKH\ZHUHPDNLQJWKDWPDQ\3LFWVRU&LPPHULDQVZRXOGKDYH
PRYHGWKURXJKWKHZRRGVZLWKQRPRUHQRLVHWKDQWKHZLQGPDNHVDVLW
EORZVWKURXJKWKHEODFNEUDQFKHV+HKDGMXVWFURVVHGDVPDOOJODGH
ZKHQKHZKHHOHGDQVZHULQJWKHFRQYLFWLRQRIKLVSULPLWLYHLQVWLQFWV
WKDWKHZDVEHLQJIROORZHG6WDQGLQJPRWLRQOHVVDPRQJWKHEXVKHVKH
KHDUGWKHVRXQGVRIWKHUHWUHDWLQJVHWWOHUVIDGHDZD\7KHQDYRLFH
FDOOHGIDLQWO\EDFNDORQJWKHZD\KHKDGFRPH&RQDQ&RQDQ:DLW
IRUPH&RQDQ
%DOWKXVKHVZRUHEHZLOGHUHGO\&DXWLRXVO\KHFDOOHG+HUH,
DP
:DLWIRUPH&RQDQWKHYRLFHFDPHPRUHGLVWLQFWO\
&RQDQPRYHGRXWRIWKHVKDGRZVVFRZOLQJ:KDWWKHGHYLODUH\RX
GRLQJKHUH"B&URPB
+HKDOIFURXFKHGWKHIOHVKSULFNOLQJDORQJKLVVSLQH,WZDVQRW
%DOWKXVZKRZDVHPHUJLQJIURPWKHRWKHUVLGHRIWKHJODGH$ZHLUG
JORZEXUQHGWKURXJKWKHWUHHV,WPRYHGWRZDUGKLPVKLPPHULQJ
ZHLUGO\DJUHHQZLWFKILUHWKDWPRYHGZLWKSXUSRVHDQGLQWHQW
,WKDOWHGVRPHIHHWDZD\DQG&RQDQJODUHGDWLWWU\LQJWR
GLVWLQJXLVKLWVILUHPLVWHGRXWOLQHV7KHTXLYHULQJIODPHKDGDVROLG
FRUHWKHIODPHZDVEXWDJUHHQJDUPHQWWKDWPDVNHGVRPHDQLPDWHDQG
HYLOHQWLW\EXWWKH&LPPHULDQZDVXQDEOHWRPDNHRXWLWVVKDSHRU
OLNHQHVV7KHQVKRFNLQJO\DYRLFHVSRNHWRKLPIURPDPLGVWWKH
ILHU\FROXPQ
:K\GR\RXVWDQGOLNHDVKHHSZDLWLQJIRUWKHEXWFKHU&RQDQ"
7KHYRLFHZDVKXPDQEXWFDUULHGVWUDQJHYLEUDWLRQVWKDWZHUHQRW
KXPDQ
6KHHS"&RQDQ
VZUDWKJRWWKHEHVWRIKLVPRPHQWDU\DZH'R\RX
WKLQN,
PDIUDLGRIDGDPQHG3LFWLVKVZDPSGHYLO"$IULHQGFDOOHG
PH
,FDOOHGLQKLVYRLFHDQVZHUHGWKHRWKHU7KHPHQ\RXIROORZ
EHORQJWRP\EURWKHU,ZRXOGQRWUREKLVNQLIHRIWKHLUEORRG%XW
\RXDUHPLQH2IRRO\RXKDYHFRPHIURPWKHIDUJUD\KLOOVRI
&LPPHULDWRPHHW\RXUGRRPLQWKHIRUHVWVRI&RQDMRKDUD
<RX
YHKDG\RXUFKDQFHDWPHEHIRUHQRZVQRUWHG&RQDQ:K\
GLGQ
W\RXNLOOPHWKHQLI\RXFRXOG"
0\EURWKHUKDGQRWSDLQWHGDVNXOOEODFNIRU\RXDQGKXUOHGLW
LQWRWKHILUHWKDWEXUQVIRUHYHURQ*XOODK
VEODFNDOWDU+HKDGQRW
ZKLVSHUHG\RXUQDPHWRWKHEODFNJKRVWVWKDWKDXQWWKHXSODQGVRIWKH
'DUN/DQG%XWDEDWKDVIORZQRYHUWKH0RXQWDLQVRIWKH'HDGDQG
GUDZQ\RXULPDJHLQEORRGRQWKHZKLWHWLJHU
VKLGHWKDWKDQJVEHIRUH
WKHORQJKXWZKHUHVOHHSWKH)RXU%URWKHUVRIWKH1LJKW7KHJUHDW
VHUSHQWVFRLODERXWWKHLUIHHWDQGWKHVWDUVEXUQOLNHILUHIOLHVLQ
WKHLUKDLU
:K\KDYHWKHJRGVRIGDUNQHVVGRRPHGPHWRGHDWK"JURZOHG&RQDQ
6RPHWKLQJDKDQGIRRWRUWDORQKHFRXOGQRWWHOOZKLFK
WKUXVWRXWIURPWKHILUHDQGPDUNHGVZLIWO\RQWKHPROG$V\PERO
EOD]HGWKHUHPDUNHGZLWKILUHDQGIDGHGEXWQRWEHIRUHKH
UHFRJQL]HGLW
<RXGDUHGPDNHWKHVLJQZKLFKRQO\DSULHVWRI-KHEEDO6DJGDUH
PDNH7KXQGHUUXPEOHGWKURXJKWKHEODFN0RXQWDLQRIWKH'HDGDQGWKH
DOWDUKXWRI*XOODKZDVWKURZQGRZQE\DZLQGIURPWKH*XOIRI
*KRVWV7KHORRQZKLFKLVPHVVHQJHUWRWKH)RXU%URWKHUVRIWKH1LJKW
IOHZVZLIWO\DQGZKLVSHUHG\RXUQDPHLQP\HDU<RXUUDFHLVUXQ<RX
DUHDGHDGPDQDOUHDG\<RXUKHDGZLOOKDQJLQWKHDOWDUKXWRIP\
EURWKHU<RXUERG\ZLOOEHHDWHQE\WKHEODFNZLQJHGVKDUSEHDNHG
&KLOGUHQRI-KLO
:KRWKHGHYLOLV\RXUEURWKHU"GHPDQGHG&RQDQ+LVVZRUGZDV
QDNHGLQKLVKDQGDQGKHZDVVXEWO\ORRVHQLQJWKHD[LQKLVEHOW
=RJDU6DJDFKLOGRI-KHEEDO6DJZKRVWLOOYLVLWVKLVVDFUHG
JURYHVDWWLPHV$ZRPDQRI*ZDZHODVOHSWLQDJURYHKRO\WR-KHEEDO
6DJ+HUEDEHZDV=RJDU6DJ,WRRDPDVRQRI-KHEEDO6DJRXWRID
ILUHEHLQJIURPDIDUUHDOP=RJDU6DJVXPPRQHGPHRXWRIWKH0LVW\
/DQGV:LWKLQFDQWDWLRQVDQGVRUFHU\DQGKLVRZQEORRGKH
PDWHULDOL]HGPHLQWKHIOHVKRIKLVRZQSODQHW:HDUHRQHWLHG
WRJHWKHUE\LQYLVLEOHWKUHDGV+LVWKRXJKWVDUHP\WKRXJKWVLIKHLV
VWUXFN,DPEUXLVHG,I,DPFXWKHEOHHGV%XW,KDYHWDONHG
HQRXJK6RRQ\RXUJKRVWZLOOWDONZLWKWKHJKRVWVRIWKH'DUN/DQG
DQGWKH\ZLOOWHOO\RXRIWKHROGJRGVZKLFKDUHQRWGHDGEXWVOHHS
LQWKHRXWHUDE\VVHVDQGIURPWLPHWRWLPHDZDNH
,
GOLNHWRVHHZKDW\RXORRNOLNHPXWWHUHG&RQDQZRUNLQJKLV
D[IUHH\RXZKROHDYHDWUDFNOLNHDELUGZKREXUQOLNHDIODPH
DQG\HWVSHDNZLWKDKXPDQYRLFH
<RXVKDOOVHHDQVZHUHGWKHYRLFHIURPWKHIODPHVHHDQG
FDUU\WKHNQRZOHGJHZLWK\RXLQWRWKH'DUN/DQG
7KHIODPHVOHDSHGDQGVDQNGZLQGOLQJDQGGLPPLQJ$IDFHEHJDQWR
WDNHVKDGRZ\IRUP$WILUVW&RQDQWKRXJKWLWZDV=RJDU6DJKLPVHOI
ZKRVWRRGZUDSSHGLQJUHHQILUH%XWWKHIDFHZDVKLJKHUWKDQKLV
RZQDQGWKHUHZDVDGHPRQLDFDVSHFWDERXWLW&RQDQKDGQRWHG
YDULRXVDEQRUPDOLWLHVDERXW=RJDU6DJ
VIHDWXUHVDQREOLTXHQHVVRI
WKHH\HVDVKDUSQHVVRIWKHHDUVDZROILVKWKLQQHVVRIWKHOLSV
WKHVHSHFXOLDULWLHVZHUHH[DJJHUDWHGLQWKHDSSDULWLRQZKLFKVZD\HG
EHIRUHKLP7KHH\HVZHUHUHGDVFRDOVRIOLYLQJILUH
0RUHGHWDLOVFDPHLQWRYLHZDVOHQGHUWRUVRFRYHUHGZLWKVQDN\
VFDOHVZKLFKZDV\HWPDQOLNHLQVKDSHZLWKPDQOLNHDUPVIURPWKH
ZDLVWXSZDUGEHORZORQJFUDQHOLNHOHJVHQGHGLQVSOD\WKUHHWRHG
IHHWOLNHWKRVHRIKXJHELUG$ORQJWKHPRQVWURXVOLPEVWKHEOXHILUH
IOXWWHUHGDQGUDQ+HVDZLWDVWKURXJKDJOLVWHQLQJPLVW
7KHQVXGGHQO\LWZDVWRZHULQJRYHUKLPWKRXJKKHKDGQRWVHHQLW
PRYHWRZDUGKLP$ORQJDUPZKLFKIRUWKHILUVWWLPHKHQRWLFHGZDV
DUPHGZLWKFXUYLQJVLFNOHOLNHWDORQVVZXQJKLJKDQGVZHSWGRZQDW
KLVQHFN:LWKDILHUFHFU\KHEURNHWKHVSHOODQGERXQGHGDVLGH
KXUOLQJKLVD[7KHGHPRQDYRLGHGWKHFDVWZLWKDQXQEHOLHYDEO\TXLFN
PRYHPHQWRILWVQDUURZKHDGDQGZDVRQKLPDJDLQZLWKDKLVVLQJUXVK
RIOHDSLQJIODPHV
%XWIHDUKDGIRXJKWIRULWZKHQLWVOHZLWVRWKHUYLFWLPVDQG
&RQDQZDVQRWDIUDLG+HNQHZWKDWDQ\EHLQJFORWKHGLQPDWHULDO
IOHVKFDQEHVODLQE\PDWHULDOZHDSRQVKRZHYHUJULVO\LWVIRUPPD\
EH
2QHIODLOLQJWDORQDUPHGOLPENQRFNHGKLVKHOPHWIURPKLVKHDG$
OLWWOHORZHUDQGLWZRXOGKDYHGHFDSLWDWHGKLP%XWILHUFHMR\VXUJHG
WKURXJKKLPDVKLVVDYDJHO\GULYHQVZRUGVDQNGHHSLQWKHPRQVWHU
V
JURLQ+HERXQGHGEDFNZDUGIURPDIODLOLQJVWURNHWHDULQJKLVVZRUG
IUHHDVKHOHDSHG7KHWDORQVUDNHGKLVEUHDVWULSSLQJWKURXJKPDLO
OLQNVDVLIWKH\KDGEHHQFORWK%XWKLVUHWXUQVSULQJZDVOLNHWKDW
RIDVWDUYLQJZROI+HZDVLQVLGHWKHODVKLQJDUPVDQGGULYLQJKLV
VZRUGGHHSLQWKHPRQVWHU
VEHOO\IHOWWKHDUPVORFNDERXWKLPDQG
WKHWDORQVULSSLQJWKHPDLOIURPKLVEDFNDVWKH\VRXJKWKLVYLWDOV
KHZDVODSSHGDQGGD]]OHGE\EOXHIODPHWKDWZDVFKLOODVLFH
WKHQKHKDGWRUQILHUFHO\DZD\IURPWKHZHDNHQLQJDUPVDQGKLVVZRUG
FXWWKHDLULQDWUHPHQGRXVVZLSH
7KHGHPRQVWDJJHUHGDQGIHOOVSUDZOLQJVLGHZLVHLWVKHDGKDQJLQJ
RQO\E\DVKUHGRIIOHVK7KHILUHVWKDWYHLOHGLWOHDSHGILHUFHO\
XSZDUGQRZUHGDVJXVKLQJEORRGKLGLQJWKHILJXUHIURPYLHZ$
VFHQWRIEXUQLQJIOHVKILOOHG&RQDQ
VQRVWULOV6KDNLQJWKHEORRGDQG
VZHDWIURPKLVH\HVKHZKHHOHGDQGUDQVWDJJHULQJWKURXJKWKHZRRGV
%ORRGWULFNOHGGRZQKLVOLPEV6RPHZKHUHPLOHVWRWKHVRXWKKHVDZ
WKHIDLQWJORZRIIODPHVWKDWPLJKWPDUNDEXUQLQJFDELQ%HKLQGKLP
WRZDUGWKHURDGURVHDGLVWDQWKRZOLQJWKDWVSXUUHGKLPWRJUHDWHU
HIIRUWV


&RQDMRKDUD1R0RUH

7KHUHKDGEHHQILJKWLQJRQ7KXQGHU5LYHUILHUFHILJKWLQJEHIRUH
WKHZDOOVRI9HOLWULXPD[DQGWRUFKKDGEHHQSOLHGXSDQGGRZQWKH
EDQNDQGPDQ\DVHWWOHU
VFDELQOD\LQDVKHVEHIRUHWKHSDLQWHG
KRUGHZDVUROOHGEDFN
$VWUDQJHTXLHWIROORZHGWKHVWRUPLQZKLFKSHRSOHJDWKHUHGDQG
WDONHGLQKXVKHGYRLFHVDQGPHQZLWKUHGVWDLQHGEDQGDJHVGUDQN
WKHLUDOHVLOHQWO\LQWKHWDYHUQVDORQJWKHULYHUEDQN
7KHUHWR&RQDQWKH&LPPHULDQPRRGLO\TXDIILQJIURPDJUHDWZLQH
JODVVFDPHDJDXQWIRUHVWHUZLWKDEDQGDJHDERXWKLVKHDGDQGKLV
DUPLQDVOLQJ+HZDVWKHRQHVXUYLYRURI)RUW7XVFHODQ
<RXZHQWZLWKWKHVROGLHUVWRWKHUXLQVRIWKHIRUW"
&RQDQQRGGHG
,ZDVQ
WDEOHPXUPXUHGWKHRWKHU7KHUHZDVQRILJKWLQJ"
7KH3LFWVKDGIDOOHQEDFNDFURVV%ODFN5LYHU6RPHWKLQJPXVWKDYH
EURNHQWKHLUQHUYHWKRXJKRQO\WKHGHYLOZKRPDGHWKHPNQRZVZKDW
7KHZRRGVPDQJODQFHGDWKLVEDQGDJHGDUPDQGVLJKHG
7KH\VD\WKHUHZHUHQRERGLHVZRUWKGLVSRVLQJRI
&RQDQVKRRNKLVKHDG$VKHV7KH3LFWVKDGSLOHGWKHPLQWKHIRUW
DQGVHWILUHWRWKHIRUWEHIRUHWKH\FURVVHGWKHULYHU7KHLURZQ
GHDGDQGWKHPHQRI9DODQQXV
9DODQQXVZDVNLOOHGDPRQJWKHODVWLQWKHKDQGWRKDQG
ILJKWLQJZKHQWKH\EURNHWKHEDUULHUV7KH\WULHGWRWDNHKLPDOLYH
EXWKHPDGHWKHPNLOOKLP7KH\WRRNWHQRIWKHUHVWRIXVSULVRQHUV
ZKHQZHZHUHVRZHDNIURPILJKWLQJZHFRXOGILJKWQRPRUH7KH\
EXWFKHUHGQLQHRIXVWKHQDQGWKHUH,WZDVZKHQ=RJDU6DJGLHGWKDW
,JRWP\FKDQFHWREUHDNIUHHDQGUXQIRULW
=RJDU6DJ
VGHDG"HMDFXODWHG&RQDQ
$\H,VDZKLPGLH7KDW
VZK\WKH3LFWVGLGQ
WSUHVVWKHILJKW
DJDLQVW9HOLWULXPDVILHUFHO\DVWKH\GLGDJDLQVWWKHIRUW,WZDV
VWUDQJH+HWRRNQRZRXQGVLQEDWWOH+HZDVGDQFLQJDPRQJWKHVODLQ
ZDYLQJDQD[ZLWKZKLFKKH
GMXVWEUDLQHGWKHODVWRIP\FRPUDGHV+H
FDPHDWPHKRZOLQJOLNHDZROIDQGWKHQKHVWDJJHUHGDQGGURSSHG
WKHD[DQGEHJDQWRUHHOLQDFLUFOHVFUHDPLQJDV,QHYHUKHDUGD
PDQRUEHDVWVFUHDPEHIRUH+HIHOOEHWZHHQPHDQGWKHILUHWKH\
G
EXLOWWRURDVWPHJDJLQJDQGIURWKLQJDWWKHPRXWKDQGDOODWRQFH
KHZHQWULJLGDQGWKH3LFWVVKRXWHGWKDWKHZDVGHDG,WZDVGXULQJ
WKHFRQIXVLRQWKDW,VOLSSHGP\FRUGVDQGUDQIRUWKHZRRGV
,VDZKLPO\LQJLQWKHILUHOLJKW1RZHDSRQKDGWRXFKHGKLP<HW
WKHUHZHUHUHGPDUNVOLNHWKHZRXQGVRIDVZRUGLQWKHJURLQEHOO\
DQGQHFNWKHODVWDVLIKLVKHDGKDGEHHQDOPRVWVHYHUHGIURPKLV
ERG\:KDWGR\RXPDNHRIWKDW"
&RQDQPDGHQRUHSO\DQGWKHIRUHVWHUDZDUHRIWKHUHWLFHQFHRI
EDUEDULDQVRQFHUWDLQPDWWHUVFRQWLQXHG+HOLYHGE\PDJLFDQG
VRPHKRZKHGLHGE\PDJLF,WZDVWKHP\VWHU\RIKLVGHDWKWKDWWRRN
WKHKHDUWRXWRIWKH3LFWV1RWDPDQZKRVDZLWZDVLQWKHILJKWLQJ
EHIRUH9HOLWULXP7KH\KXUULHGEDFNDFURVV%ODFN5LYHU7KRVHWKDW
VWUXFN7KXQGHU5LYHUZHUHZDUULRUVZKRKDGFRPHRQEHIRUH=RJDU6DJ
GLHG7KH\ZHUHQRWHQRXJKWRWDNHWKHFLW\E\WKHPVHOYHV
,FDPHDORQJWKHURDGEHKLQGWKHLUPDLQIRUFHDQG,NQRZQRQH
IROORZHGPHIURPWKHIRUW,VQHDNHGWKURXJKWKHLUOLQHVDQGJRWLQWR
WKHWRZQ<RXEURXJKWWKHVHWWOHUVWKURXJKDOOULJKWEXWWKHLUZRPHQ
DQGFKLOGUHQJRWLQWR9HOLWULXPMXVWDKHDGRIWKRVHSDLQWHGGHYLOV
,IWKH\RXWK%DOWKXVDQGROG6ODVKHUKDGQ
WKHOGWKHPXSDZKLOH
WKH\
GKDYHEXWFKHUHGHYHU\ZRPDQDQGFKLOGLQ&RQDMRKDUD,SDVVHG
WKHSODFHZKHUH%DOWKXVDQGWKHGRJPDGHWKHLUODVWVWDQG7KH\ZHUH
O\LQJDPLGDKHDSRIGHDG3LFWV,FRXQWHGVHYHQEUDLQHGE\KLV
D[RUGLVHPERZHOHGE\WKHGRJ
VIDQJVDQGWKHUHZHUHRWKHUVLQWKH
URDGZLWKDUURZVVWLFNLQJLQWKHP*RGVZKDWDILJKWWKDWPXVWKDYH
EHHQ
+HZDVDPDQVDLG&RQDQ,GULQNWRKLVVKDGHDQGWRWKH
VKDGHRIWKHGRJZKRNQHZQRIHDU+HTXDIIHGSDUWRIWKHZLQH
WKHQHPSWLHGWKHUHVWXSRQWKHIORRUZLWKDFXULRXVKHDWKHQJHVWXUH
DQGVPDVKHGWKHJREOHW7KHKHDGVRIWHQ3LFWVVKDOOSD\IRUKLV
DQGVHYHQKHDGVIRUWKHGRJZKRZDVDEHWWHUZDUULRUWKDQPDQ\D
PDQ
$QGWKHIRUHVWHUVWDULQJLQWRWKHPRRG\VPROGHULQJEOXHH\HV
NQHZWKHEDUEDULFRDWKZRXOGEHNHSW
7KH\
OOQRWUHEXLOGWKHIRUW"
1R&RQDMRKDUDLVORVWWR$TXLORQLD7KHIURQWLHUKDVEHHQSXVKHG
EDFN7KXQGHU5LYHUZLOOEHWKHQHZERUGHU
7KHZRRGVPDQVLJKHGDQGVWDUHGDWKLVFDOORXVHGKDQGZRUQIURP
FRQWDFWZLWKD[KDIWDQGVZRUGKLOW&RQDQUHDFKHGKLVORQJDUPIRU
WKHZLQHMXJ7KHIRUHVWHUVWDUHGDWKLPFRPSDULQJKLPZLWKWKHPHQ
DERXWWKHPWKHPHQZKRKDGGLHGDORQJWKHORVWULYHUFRPSDULQJKLP
ZLWKWKRVHRWKHUZLOGPHQRYHUWKDWULYHU&RQDQGLGQRWVHHPDZDUH
RIKLVJD]H
%DUEDULVPLVWKHQDWXUDOVWDWHRIPDQNLQGWKHERUGHUHUVDLG
VWLOOVWDULQJVRPEHUO\DWWKH&LPPHULDQ&LYLOL]DWLRQLVXQQDWXUDO
,WLVDZKLPRIFLUFXPVWDQFH$QGEDUEDULVPPXVWDOZD\VXOWLPDWHO\
WULXPSK